Pod Insights Real Survival Stories Two Kilometres Underground: Inches of Breathing Room About this episode One of the world’s top cave photographers travels to Russian-occupied Georgia to capture images of a true natural wonder - a cave so deep it takes four days to reach the bottom. But when water cascades into the underground system, Robbie Shone will face a series of challenges beyond his worst nightmares. Soon he will find himself with literal inches of space in which to keep breathing…
A Noiser production, written by Duncan Barrett.
For ad-free listening, bonus material and early access to new episodes, join Noiser+. Click the subscription banner at the top of the feed to get started. Or go to noiser.com/subscriptions
If you have an amazing survival story of your own that you’d like to put forward for the show, let us know. Drop us an email at [email protected]
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:00 Speaker 00 Visible puts the ultimate wireless hack in the palm of your hand. With unlimited 5G wireless data and hotspot, designed to keep you connected. Powered by Verizon's 5G network. And, no contract holding you back. Plans start at $25 a month. Or get the premium Visible Plus Pro Plan and save $10 on your first month when you use promo code HACK. Make the switch at visible.com. Terms apply. See visible.com for details.
0:30 Speaker 01 For decades, a shadowy organization called the Illuminati has kept lemon on top and lime in the shadows. Look around: lemon-forward sodas, even lemon-forward songs. We ran the tracks, slowed them down, reversed them, and squeezed out the truth.
0:50 Speaker 01 That's lemon propaganda right there. But now, 7-Up is fighting back with their new Lime Lemon Soda. Join the 7-Uprising: Flip the Sip.
1:04 John Hopkins? It's Sunday, September 16, 2018, in the Arabica Massif, a mountain range in Russian-occupied Georgia.
1:13 John Hopkins? These towering limestone formations are blanketed in lush woodland. Their snow-tipped peaks loom over the serene waters of the Black Sea, which fans out into the distance.
1:28 John Hopkins? But Arabica's greatest natural feature is below the surface:
1:34 John Hopkins? Varyovkina.
1:38 John Hopkins? Officially, the deepest cave in the world.
1:44 John Hopkins? From its opening in the mountains, Varyovkina drops straight down, startling 2.2 kilometers, or more than 7,200 feet.
1:55 John Hopkins? It's a vast, vertical chasm, right through the heart of the mountain range.
2:02 John Hopkins? Deep down is a kingdom of slender passageways, echoey caverns, and immense darkness.
2:11 John Hopkins? And it's in this world that 38-year-old British photographer Robbie Shone has spent the past two weeks. He's here documenting the work of a Russian caving team.
2:24 John Hopkins? He's captured images of the stunning green pools of water at the bottom, the jutting rock formations, the glistening limestone walls. He's even visited Varyovkina's terminal sump, the deepest point in the deepest cave.
2:44 John Hopkins? Right now though, on Sunday morning, Robbie's tucking into his breakfast. He and the Russian cavers are huddled under a blue tarpaulin, chowing down in the light of their head torches.
2:57 John Hopkins? Over the past week, Robbie's grown used to Varyovkina's Camp 3, located on a horizontal plateau 1,900 metres below the surface.
3:07 John Hopkins? By caving standards, it's pretty luxurious, with a high ceiling and soft brown sand blanketing the ground.
3:15 John Hopkins? The cavers have made themselves at home here, hanging their kit up to dry on washing lines strung over their heads. Robbie's photographic equipment, cameras, lights, tripods, and more, is spread out all around the cave. The atmosphere is laid back, relaxed.
3:35 John Hopkins? Until the radio fizzes into life.
3:42 John Hopkins? It's a warning for Camp 3. From a pair of cavers up in Camp 2, 700 odd metres above them, there is a flood pulse on its way down through the cave system. Thousands of gallons of water hurtling towards them with the force of a freight train.
4:01 John Hopkins? Robbie hears the rumble getting closer and closer. The walls of the cave begin to shake. He rushes to the entrance of Camp 3 and looks up into Varyovkina's main vertical column, which stretches above.
4:17 Speaker 03 First of all, we felt the wind. I'll never forget, we felt the wind a couple of seconds earlier. And then we saw this wall of white brown water just bursting out of the hole above us. And it plummeted right past us. Very quickly, it filled the space of like 10 metre wide shaft. And the water just disappeared into the pit beneath us and found its way down to the water table.
4:43 John Hopkins? The sheer force of the waterfall is overwhelming. Robbie stands watching it, his mouth wide open. The furious brown liquid is roaring into a pit just below them, where the water table lies. A saturated layer, from which there's nowhere for the water to escape. If it doesn't stop flowing, the level will rise and rise, and he and his colleagues are going to be trapped. Not just underground, but underwater.
5:13 Speaker 03 Drowning is my biggest fear. So I was terrified. The only way to stay alive was to get higher. And the only way to get higher was to get on that rope in the waterfall and start climbing.
5:30 John Hopkins? Ever wondered what you would do when disaster strikes? If your life depended on your next decision, could you make the right choice?
5:39 John Hopkins? Welcome to Real Survival Stories. These are the astonishing tales of ordinary people thrown into extraordinary situations. People suddenly forced to fight for their lives.
5:54 John Hopkins? In this episode, we meet Robbie Shon. The 38-year-old is one of the world's top cave photographers. And in September 2018, he travels to Georgia to capture images of a true natural wonder. A cave so deep, it takes four days to reach the bottom. But when water cascades into the underground system, Robbie will face a series of challenges beyond his worst nightmares. Soon, he will find himself with literally inches of space in which to keep breathing.
6:28 Speaker 03 We needed to have our mouth and our nose up in the roof in order to breathe. I think there was maybe six inches of airspace and the rest was brown, foamy water.
6:38 John Hopkins? I'm John Hopkins. From the Noiser Podcast Network, this is Real Survival Stories.
7:10 John Hopkins? It's 11 years earlier, September 2007.
7:17 John Hopkins? Robbie Shone is at a farmhouse in rural China, near the ancient town of Tianxing. He's laid out his kit on the battered wooden table in front of him. Camera, SD cards, batteries, prepping for a big adventure the next morning.
7:35 John Hopkins? Robbie's in China to photograph an unusual geological phenomenon, the Miao Kang Shaft, an unbroken 500-meter drop.
7:46 John Hopkins? If your rope snaps, that's a 10-second fall before you hit anything. He's hoping to get some spectacular images of the stunning striated rock disappearing into the blackness below. But Robbie and his team aren't the only ones exploring Miao Kang. A Russian group are also in town, led by a man called Pavel Demidov. Robbie's never worked with Russians before.
8:12 Speaker 03 They have a reputation for being very strong and very tough. So we were a little bit wary. And I'll never forget the moment we met the leader, Pavel, Pavel Demidov.
8:26 John Hopkins? Suddenly, the door to the farmhouse is flung open.
8:30 John Hopkins? And in walks Pavel.
8:34 John Hopkins? He is almost a decade older than Robbie. He's tall, strong, muscular. His hair is cut short, almost shaved off completely, with the image of a snow leopard carved into it. In short, he fits the intimidating stereotype to a T.
8:54 John Hopkins? But tonight, Pavel has come bearing gifts.
9:01 Speaker 03 In each hand, he held a bottle. And he said, "My name is Pavel, and I drink vodka and champagne." And from then onwards, we realised that actually, we had nothing to fear. These guys were just like us, you know.
9:17 John Hopkins? For Robbie and Pavel, it's the start of a beautiful friendship, one that will last far beyond a trip to China.
9:25 Speaker 03 I kept in touch with Pavel over the years. And in 2017, he got in touch with me and said that a deep cave that the team had been working on in Georgia had just broken the world depth record, Bury of Kena. And he would love for me to come and photograph it. This is a great opportunity. It might be my only opportunity. So I said, "Yes, let's do it."
9:50 John Hopkins? By now, Robbie is an established caver himself and one of the top cave photographers in the world.
9:58 John Hopkins? He first got the bug at Sheffield Hallam University when a rock climber friend took him down a cave in the Yorkshire Dales. His eyes were opened to a whole new subterranean landscape, as beautiful as it was strange. Gorgeous moss-covered rock formations, underground waterfalls, otherworldly stalactites.
10:21 Speaker 03 I'll never forget the experience. It was like love at first sight. This alien world was something that fascinated me. I'd never seen anything like it before. And I'd totally forgotten about the daylight, the sunshine on the surface. I was now in the cave. I was now experiencing this underworld for the very first time. And I was hooked. And from then onwards, I wanted to go caving all the time.
10:45 John Hopkins? Officially, Robbie was supposed to be studying fine art, but his real passion was for photography.
10:52 John Hopkins? Unfortunately, photographing caves is a pretty niche speciality, and none of his tutors were able to help him with it.
11:00 Speaker 03 There was nobody at university that could teach me cave photography. It was all new to them, and I wasn't on the photography course. So I would go downstairs to the photography floor and borrow old film cameras from the university. And then I would take them into the caves in the Peak District, practising lighting, because that's basically the main skill of cave photography, is lighting. How do you light these spaces to make the caves look beautiful?
11:28 John Hopkins? Eventually, through a process of trial and error, he learnt the tricks of the trade.
11:35 John Hopkins? And while he was honing his photography skills, he was developing as a climber as well. Before long, he'd qualified as a rope-access technician, spending his long summer holidays working for a local firm that supplied climbers for jobs requiring rope skills.
11:53 Speaker 03 You can go and work on places like the Dartford Crossing over the River Thames and like clean it or paint it. It was great. It was great money. It was working with cavers and climbers, so the conversation was brilliant. It was exactly what I wanted. But most importantly is you could dip out from the industry and go on an expedition somewhere to like Malaysia or China on a caving expedition. I could practise my cave photography in the big, big caves of the world. And then I could come back, make a phone call on like the Thursday, and I could be back on the job on the Monday.
12:29 John Hopkins? After graduating, Robbie continued this work as a rope technician, all the while building his photography portfolio, visiting the eerie ice caves of Mount Etna in Sicily, capturing the stunning crystals of New Mexico's Lechuguilla, and lighting up the precipitous interior of China's Miao Kang, meeting Pavel Demidov in the process. So by 2017, when Pavel asks him to come and capture Veriovquina, Robbie is well established as one of the foremost cave photographers in the world.
13:05 John Hopkins? His images have graced the pages of National Geographic magazine, and he's appeared on TV numerous times. Plus, so far in his almost two-decade career, he's avoided any serious danger.
13:18 Speaker 03 I've been caving for eighteen, nineteen years, and I never really had any kind of incident in the cave. I had a lot of experience by this point. I was ready to tackle, you know, camping in a cave for over two weeks. That was not going to be a problem.
13:37 John Hopkins? In September 2018, Robbie leaves his partner Gina behind in their home in Austria and sets off for Veriavkina. He'll be a part of a team of ten, eight Russians and two Englishmen.
13:50 John Hopkins? Robbie has secured funding from the National Geographic Society for him and his assistant Jeff Wade to document Pavel's latest expedition.
14:00 John Hopkins? But before they head underground, there's work to do at surface level.
14:06 John Hopkins? They meet up with the team at a camp in the Arabica Mountains, just ten minutes' walk from the cave entrance. It's a picturesque spot, looming peaks close in all around, green and white. You can even glimpse the gleaming shores of the Black Sea in the distance.
14:24 John Hopkins? But they aren't here to enjoy the view.
14:28 Speaker 03 We spent about three days on the surface beforehand, packing all of the gear. Because, as you can imagine, two and a half weeks underground, we needed to carry a lot of food, and it all had to be waterproofed. We had to take down the sleeping bags with gas cylinders for the stoves.
14:47 John Hopkins? At the surface camp, surrounded by piles of small, plastic-wrapped packages, Robbie asks Pavel about the kind of conditions they can expect to find underground.
14:58 John Hopkins? Veriavkina is damp and prone to flooding during periods of heavy rainfall. On previous visits, Pavel has found plates and cutlery stuck to the walls and even the ceilings after a sudden deluge has come and gone.
15:14 John Hopkins? But he isn't worried. Even the lowest levels of the cave only ever fill up in winter. It's mid-September. They should be fine.
15:24 John Hopkins? Robbie, however, isn't so sure.
15:30 Speaker 03 This nagged me. This was on my mind and I remember speaking to Gina, my partner, before I left, I was like, I've just got a bad feeling. Them to say that, like, we know it floods to the ceiling. Gina, she works in climate change, she's a researcher. So she knows that our weather is changing, our climate is changing. We can get these freak weather storms on a regular basis, any times of the year. We live with this conversation all the time. So I was going to Verkhina with that at the back of my mind, anyway.
16:00 John Hopkins? Even for an experienced caver, Verkhina is no walk in the underground park. As the team finally sets off, laden with supplies and equipment, the challenge ahead becomes stark.
16:14 John Hopkins? The Entrance Series, the stretch of narrow tunnels leading down from the surface, is particularly hard going. An eight-hour slog through rocky spaces too cramped to stand up in.
16:27 Speaker 03 It's very tight, the walls are quite restrictive. It's not for the faint-hearted. And of course, we had all these bags of equipment. I had bags of photography equipment, bags of batteries, you know, to last the two and a half weeks. So all this had to get through these narrow spaces.
16:47 Speaker 00 Visible puts the ultimate wireless hack in the palm of your hand. With unlimited 5G wireless data and hotspot, designed to keep you connected, powered by Verizon's 5G network. And no contract holding you back. Plans start at $25 a month, or get the premium Visible Plus Pro Plan and save $10 on your first month when you use promo code HACK. Make the switch at visible.com. Terms apply. See visible.com for details.
17:17 Speaker 01 The Lemonati has spent decades keeping lemon on top and lime in the shadows. Their lemon agenda has infiltrated everything, even our music. That hit song named after the color of lemons? Not a coincidence. Big Lemon has been pulling strings in the industry for years. Think about it. But now, 7-Up is fighting back with their new Lime Lemon Soda. Now lime comes first. 7-Up, flip the sip.
17:52 John Hopkins? Meter by meter, the team make their way through the dark, dank tunnels. Robbie hugs his photographic equipment close, negotiating the twists and turns of the entrance series.
18:06 John Hopkins? At times, the cavers are forced to crawl on their bellies, squeezing through gaps barely large enough for the human frame.
18:16 John Hopkins? Thoughts of becoming stuck have to be pushed to one side.
18:21 John Hopkins? And eventually, after the best part of a day, the team emerge into an open chamber.
18:27 John Hopkins? They stretch their stiffened limbs, taking in the magnificent scene around them.
18:34 Speaker 03 Once you've tackled the entrance series, and you've got through that, and you're now beneath the surface at minus 400, then you're away. You pop out at the head of a giant pitch, which is like 160 meters of open space, all the way down to Camp One, at about minus 600.
18:57 John Hopkins? From slowly scrambling through a claustrophobic maze, now it's time for a speedier, vertical drop.
19:08 John Hopkins? Robbie shimmies into the dark abyss. He slides carefully down the ropes until his feet hit the ground.
19:18 John Hopkins? Soon, the entire team has arrived at Camp One. It's here that they'll spend their first night in Verkhovkina.
19:28 John Hopkins? After an energy-sapping day, it's time for dinner. Pavel, it turns out, is not just team leader, but head of the catering department as well.
19:38 John Hopkins? He opens a bag and pulls out meals for the entire crew. Freeze-dried at his home back in Moscow. The provisions are compact, light to carry. All Pavel has to do is add hot water, and voila, a hot dinner. But the Russians haven't just brought food with them.
20:00 Speaker 03 Pavel and the team took down with them 100% alcohol.
20:05 Speaker 03 And they would, they would wait until everybody is safely at a camp before they would open the alcohol and they would dilute it to that magic 40% proof. And they would mix it with like berries or lemons, they would take lots of fresh lemons down to flavour the vodka. And Pavel insisted that we all drank three shots of vodka before we went to bed.
20:33 John Hopkins? The temperature at Camp One is just three or four degrees above freezing. So the shots of vodka are a welcome warmer.
20:42 John Hopkins? It's not long before Robbie drifts off to sleep.
20:49 John Hopkins? Well rested the following morning, the team rise and set off again. They still have a long journey ahead of them.
20:56 Speaker 03 The rest of the cave is quite, quite straightforward relatively. But it still takes three days after that to get to the very bottom.
21:09 John Hopkins? The route down to Camp Three, over a mile beneath the entrance, is not to be sniffed at.
21:16 John Hopkins? As recently as 2024, a less experienced climber tragically died traversing this stretch of Varyovkina. But for Robbie and his companions, this kind of rope work feels almost second nature.
21:31 John Hopkins? And there's something meditative about the slow, steady rate of descent.
21:40 Speaker 03 You're so involved, you're so captivated by the challenges of caving, that you just forget about everything, all the worries in your day-to-day life, paying the bills, blah, blah, blah, all that goes out of your head and you're just concentrating on being in the cave and living that experience.
21:59 John Hopkins? Still, when the group makes it to Camp Three, it's a welcome relief. From a long, vertical tunnel, there's a horizontal ledge off to the side, which opens out into a high-ceilinged, sand-strewn plateau. The perfect spot for the team to make camp, rest up, and prepare themselves to explore the lowest levels.
22:22 John Hopkins? Perhaps the most dazzling sight down here is the terminal sump, a beautiful oval pool at the very deepest point of the cave network.
22:34 John Hopkins? While two of the Russians swim in the bright green water, lighting it up with their torches, Robbie snaps an image of Pavel ascending from the depths, one foot planted on a wall of jet-black limestone. Pavel's eyes are on the rope above him. There is a look of steely determination on his face.
22:58 John Hopkins? He looks every inch the action hero.
23:06 John Hopkins? Now, in his mid-forties, Pavel is no longer the brash young man Robbie met in China a decade earlier. He's matured into a brave and thoughtful team leader.
23:18 Speaker 03 And it was brilliant. We started taking photographs and we spent a week at the bottom camp, working our way through the lowest sections, documenting the team and had a great time. It was brilliant. And I'd totally forgotten that we were, you know, two kilometres underground.
23:36 John Hopkins? While Robbie and the others explore the wonders of Verkhovkina's lowest level, 2,000 metres above them, the weather has taken a turn for the worse.
23:47 Speaker 03 There had been continuous rain for about a week after we left. And then on the penultimate day, the day before the flood, there was a hailstorm with hailstones the size of your thumbnail. So all that water that falls could find its way down into the tunnel to us because there is one main canyon leading down to the lowest point in Verkhovkina.
24:22 John Hopkins? A flood pulse occurs when a large quantity of water gradually builds up on the surface and then suddenly forces its way underground. A wild, white-water torrent, moving with the force of a runaway train.
24:38 John Hopkins? For experienced cavers, they're a familiar hazard. As long as you don't get in the way of the deluge, they don't usually present too much of a problem. Within a few hours, sometimes even a few minutes, the flood will cease and the passageways will become navigable again.
24:55 John Hopkins? So when Robbie and his colleagues in Camp 3 learn that a pulse is on its way down to them, there isn't an instant need to be concerned. In fact, thanks to the cave's rudimentary communication network, they have about half an hour's warning to get well out of the way.
25:12 Speaker 03 They had a communication system in operation from the surface down to the lowest camp. Two cavers from the team had left the day before, up the ropes, back up to Camp 2, where they were making their way out of the cave, they had to get back to Moscow for work. A huge flood pulse passed their camp. They got on the radio and they radioed down to us and they said, "Look, you know, a giant flood pulse is just past us. We suggest you don't leave camp. Wait, wait until it hits you and then you can monitor the situation."
25:45 John Hopkins? It'll take a while for the flood pulse to reach them. It has a way to travel down from Camp 2. The team's best guess: 20 to 25 minutes.
25:56 John Hopkins? They return to their breakfast and wait patiently, listening out for the sound of rushing water.
26:04 John Hopkins? Sure enough, bang on cue, they hear it coming. A deep bellow, gradually growing louder.
26:14 Speaker 03 We heard the sound of what I always describe as a freight train, like in the underground, slowly coming toward you. You can hear it and it's like, "What's that?" It's like a rumbling sound, and then you realise what it is.
26:28 John Hopkins? Robbie sets down his food and runs to the ledge overlooking the central canyon.
26:34 John Hopkins? It's here that the torrent of water will fall past them as it drops down to Veriavka's lowest reaches. He peers up at the hole in the ceiling where the climbing ropes disappear into the shaft above. It's their only way out of here.
26:51 Speaker 03 First of all, we felt the wind. I'll never forget, we felt the wind a couple of seconds earlier and then we saw this wall of white brown water just bursting out of the hole above us and it plummeted right past us. Very quickly, it filled the space of like 10 meter wide shaft and the water just disappeared into beneath us and found its way down to the water table.
27:21 Speaker 04 Starting or growing your own business can be intimidating and lonely at times. Your to-do list may feel endless with new tasks and lists can easily begin to overrun your life. So finding the right tool that not only helps you out but simplifies everything as a built-in business partner can be a game changer. For millions of businesses, that tool is Shopify. Shopify is the commerce platform behind millions of businesses around the world and 10% of all e-commerce in the US. From household names like Jimm Shark, Rare Beauty, and Heinz, to brands just getting started. Shopify has hundreds of ready-to-use templates that can help you build a beautiful online store that matches your brand's style.
28:02 Speaker 04 And you can tackle all the important tasks in one place, from inventory to payments to analytics and more. No need to save multiple websites or try to figure out what platform is hosting the tool that you need. And if people haven't heard about your brand, you can get the word out like you have a marketing team behind you with easy-to-run email and social media campaigns to reach customers wherever they're scrolling or strolling. Start your business today with the industry's best business partner, Shopify, and start hearing... Sign up for your $1 per month trial today at Shopify.com/real. Go to Shopify.com/real. That's Shopify.com/real.
28:46 Speaker 00 Visible puts the ultimate wireless hack in the palm of your hand. With unlimited 5G wireless data and hotspot, designed to keep you connected. Powered by Verizon's 5G network. And, no contract holding you back. Plans start at $25 a month. Or get the premium Visible Plus Pro Plan and save $10 on your first month when you use promo code HACK. Make the switch at visible.com. Terms apply. See visible.com for details.
29:16 John Hopkins? The water table in Veriavkina is about 60 meters, or 200 feet, below Camp 3. Once the flood reaches that level, there's only one place for the water to travel, and that's back up. But it's still a decent distance beneath them. No need to panic, and the pulse should pass soon enough. For the next few hours, the cavers continue to wait, quietly monitoring the situation. Pavel and another member of his team, called Andre, go to check on a nearby siphon, a flooded section of cave.
29:52 John Hopkins? The Russians noted how high the water was in this particular spot before, so they should be able to get a good idea of how much the level is rising.
30:04 Speaker 03 So they nipped down to have a look at this. And whilst they were gone, another team member, Peter, he went over to a small hole that we'd been spitting our toothpaste out into. And he looked down and, because I think he thought he could hear a gurgling noise or something. There was nothing, and he came back.
30:25 John Hopkins? Meanwhile, Robbie's doing his best to get on with his own work, capturing photographs of the people and the action.
30:33 John Hopkins? His gear is strewn out all over the rocky, sandy floor. Even now, no one is overly worried about the flood pulse. The mood is alert, but calm.
30:45 John Hopkins? But then, a few minutes later, Peter returns to check on that little hole in the ground again. And this time, what he sees is alarming.
31:00 Speaker 03 I'll never forget the look on his face because he turned around and he looked at me first. And he was white and I rushed over to see what he'd seen. And to my horror, within a few inches beneath the surface of this hole was brown water, jostling and rising, there was foam, and it was coming up so quickly.
31:20 John Hopkins? In an instant, the stakes have been raised. The water table isn't just creeping higher, it's racing upwards and seeping into Camp Three.
31:32 John Hopkins? Robbie turns to his assistant, who is staring wide-eyed at the bubbling murky floodwater.
31:40 Speaker 03 I looked at Jeff and said, "Look, you know, we need to leave right now." I looked at all of my photography gear that was just strewn out all over the campsite floor. Quickly realised that I had no time to pack it away. I needed to race out of this cave, I needed to go up these ropes fast.
31:57 John Hopkins? That's £10,000 worth of equipment he's leaving behind. An indication of the severity of the situation.
32:04 John Hopkins? Robbie does take a moment to salvage the photographs he's already taken, including the haunting shot of Pavel ascending from the terminal sump.
32:14 John Hopkins? He grabs the memory card out of his camera, seals it into a Ziploc bag, and tucks it away inside his pocket. Then he bursts into action.
32:24 Speaker 03 I needed to get dressed, I needed to get my oversuit on, the dry suit, the harness, the helmet and lights. Go, go, go.
32:33 John Hopkins? With their Russian counterparts scrambling behind them, Robbie and Jeff flee the campsite, making their way to the ledge that overhangs the main canyon.
32:43 John Hopkins? Looking down, Robbie can clearly see the water beneath, rising up to meet them.
32:49 Speaker 03 To my horror again, the pit was now a lake. The waterfall was cascading into this brown lake, only a metre beneath the traverse line, which had previously been like a 10-metre drop.
33:02 John Hopkins? Time is running out. From here, the only way is up.
33:08 John Hopkins? But the route to Camp Two means climbing through the waterfall. A raging barrage of ice-cold froth tumbling downwards with colossal force.
33:21 Speaker 03 I didn't think about it. It was survival instinct, I put it down to. The only way to stay alive was to get higher. And the only way to get high was to get on that rope in the waterfall and start climbing. I jumped on the rope, swung into the waterfall and just started climbing the rope as fast as I could. But the force of the water squashed my head into my shoulders, a bit like a tortoise going into its shell. I had to tense up all the muscles in my neck.
33:45 John Hopkins? As Robbie climbs, his body is pounded by the thundering flood pulse. Every sinew strains against the onslaught. He is ascending, hand over hand, forcing his way up, fighting the water for every inch. You can't even see where he's going.
34:03 Speaker 03 I couldn't look up because it would have ripped my helmet off my head if I'd looked up and that would have been my helmet and light lost. Game over.
34:15 John Hopkins? Fortunately, the lip of Robbie's helmet creates a little space for him to suck in air as he climbs.
34:23 John Hopkins? His eyes fixed straight ahead of him, he makes it up to the top of the pitch, the point where he has to unclip himself from one rope and clip onto the next, freeing the bottom rope for Jeff to follow after him.
34:36 John Hopkins? It's the sort of manoeuvre that's second nature to an experienced climber. But he's never had to do it in circumstances like these.
34:45 John Hopkins? Robbie shouts down to Jeff, "Rope free", but it's unclear if his friend can hear him at all.
34:52 John Hopkins? All Robbie can do is keep moving upwards. He's climbing for his life now.
34:59 Speaker 03 I was racing up the ropes as fast as I could. Because I was fearing the worst, I thought that the water table was rising faster than I was climbing. And eventually it was just going to swallow me up.
35:11 John Hopkins? Finally Robbie is almost out of the waterfall's direct path. After over a hundred metres of climbing, it's just a few more inches up. His ropes rise up and away from the water. With an exhausted final heave, he clambers onto a dry ledge.
35:30 John Hopkins? The water continues to crash down right next to him. But for the moment at least, he can breathe easily again. He can hear Jeff following close behind now.
35:41 Speaker 03 Jeff caught me up. He was shouting, "Slow down, slow down." And we just stood on this ledge for maybe, well, it felt like eternity, but it was probably only about a minute.
35:51 John Hopkins? The two Englishmen have made it out of the waterfall. But there's no sign of their Russian companions. Four of the team were still in Camp Three when Robbie and Jeff fled.
36:02 John Hopkins? But Pavel and Andre were even deeper underground, inspecting one of Varyovkin's lowest siphons. Right now, it's unclear whether any of them are still alive.
36:14 John Hopkins? It's a stomach-churning weight as Robbie and Jeff peer into the chasm below.
36:22 John Hopkins? And then, at last, Robbie spots them, emerging from the depths, soaked through and utterly spent. One by one, the Russians clamber up onto the ledge. One, two, three, four. That's everyone accounted for, apart from Andre and their leader Pavel.
36:45 John Hopkins? It's hard not to fear the worst.
36:49 Speaker 03 When we'd left the lowest camp, Pavel and Andre were still away. You know, where they were, we had no idea. There was no way they could have survived. It was like madness. It's madness to imagine that they'd survived that.
37:03 John Hopkins? A mordorian silence falls over the group. Heads are bowed. But then, looking out over the edge, Robbie sees the faint glimmer of a headlamp.
37:16 John Hopkins? Andre emerges from the waterfall. Before, last but not least, sweating, panting and grunting, Pavel emerges as well.
37:28 John Hopkins? He's got quite a story to share. As team leader Pavel was the last out of Camp 3. And he barely escaped with his life.
37:37 Speaker 03 The water completely filled the chamber, the tent was all gone. Everything was destroyed. He was in the roof, maybe a foot of airspace. And he tried to get over to the rope, I remember him telling me. And he got spat out by the whirlpool and he grazed his face. And he had another go and he eventually got to the rope with only seconds remaining. And he climbed up.
38:02 John Hopkins? Against the odds, all eight members of the team have escaped Camp 3.
38:09 John Hopkins? But they haven't survived this subterranean flood yet. There's still some way to go. And there is a new problem.
38:20 John Hopkins? The route ahead, a narrow horizontal tunnel is blocked by something even more impassable than the waterfall.
38:29 Speaker 03 The way ahead of us was completely submerged. It was a horizontal passage that was completely full of water. And there was no way we could go any higher.
38:37 John Hopkins? The climbers will just have to wait it out. Eventually, the flow of water will dry up. When it does, there should be just enough airspace to shuffle through the passage. But it's impossible to know how long they'll have to wait. And in the meantime, the waterfall continues to cascade downwards.
38:58 John Hopkins? If the water level beneath carries on rising before they can escape, there will only be one outcome.
39:06 John Hopkins? With no other options, they make camp for the night on their ledge and wait.
39:13 Speaker 03 Those 16 hours were hell. The waiting, I convinced myself that I was going to die. We were trapped.
39:22 John Hopkins? The mood is leaden, but the Russians remain stoical and clamber into the tent for the night.
39:30 John Hopkins? Pavel invites Robbie and Jeff to join them, but right now Robbie can't bear to sit still.
39:36 John Hopkins? Instead, he paces up and down the ledge, just metres from the precipice.
39:42 Speaker 03 I feel like out of the whole team, it hit me the most. I reacted the worst, for sure. I dealt with it the worst out of the lot of us. And there was no vodka, so we couldn't even get drunk and then die, you know? We were always reminded of our situation by the thundering force of the waterfall, the water which was passing through the rock next to us. You know, we were safe, we were dry where we were, but the noise! And you could almost feel the walls vibrating. I was following the rope all the way down to the bottom, to where my light beam ended, and just waiting to see brown, foaming water appear. And that was the scariest moment, waiting to see that.
40:27 Speaker 03 That was the worst point, because when I was climbing the ropes from the bottom camp up to this point, I was just full of adrenaline, full of, "I've got to get higher, I've got to get higher", I wasn't thinking much. But now I was thinking. I had time to think about Gina, I had time to think about my parents, I had time to think about my life. At this point, you know, I didn't know how long I was going to be thinking about my life, but I was thinking about all those things, those people that I weren't going to see ever again, those moments. And drowning is my biggest fear, so I was terrified.
41:09 Speaker 01 The Lemonade has spent decades keeping lemon on top and lime in the shadows. Their lemon agenda has infiltrated everything, even our music. That hit song named after the colour of lemons? Not a coincidence. Big Lemon has been pulling strings in the industry for years. Think about it. But now, 7-Up is fighting back with their new Lime Lemon Soda. Now lime comes first. 7-Up, flip the sip.
41:39 Speaker 00 Visible puts the ultimate wireless hack in the palm of your hand. With unlimited 5G wireless data and hotspot, designed to keep you connected. Powered by Verizon's 5G network. And, no contract holding you back. Plans start at $25 a month. Or get the premium Visible Plus Pro Plan and save $10 on your first month when you use promo code HACK. Make the switch at visible.com. Terms apply. See visible.com for details.
42:09 John Hopkins? It's been the longest night of Robbie's life. But as he, once again, paces along the rocky ledge, he notices something. The rush of water. It's beginning to die down.
42:24 Speaker 03 The noise slowly dropped and the water table hadn't appeared. Okay. Maybe we are gonna survive this. Maybe, maybe it is gonna be okay. After all, I'm not thinking about my life ending and, and all these horrible thoughts anymore. That was a point where we all thought, okay. It's gonna get better now. We're gonna find a way out. It's gonna be okay.
42:50 John Hopkins? With the waterfall dried up, the team can finally continue to cap too. But, despite the renewed optimism, they're now facing a test possibly beyond anything they've yet encountered. They must traverse a 60-meter horizontal passage, which is still almost entirely filled with water.
43:12 Speaker 03 To get through it, you have to get on your hands and knees. That's how big it is. It's not very high. You need to be on your hands and knees to go through it.
43:20 John Hopkins? After a couple more hours, the team feels the tunnel has dried up enough for them to pass through. But only just. A tiny gap of air has appeared between the water and the ceiling of the passage.
43:36 John Hopkins? Robbie centers himself. Deep breath. Keep calm. Here we go.
43:44 John Hopkins? As he begins to crawl through the tunnel on his hands and knees, he's almost completely submerged in opaque, foamy water. There's only about six inches of air.
43:56 Speaker 03 It was just passable for us, providing we tilted our heads sideways and we could breathe by following the roof. We needed to have our mouth and our nose up in the roof in order to breathe the airspace.
44:09 John Hopkins? It's a grueling gauntlet. But slowly, steadily, a line of men creep their way forwards, chins always angled upwards.
44:20 John Hopkins? Finally, after sixty brutal meters, Robbie emerges from the end of the tunnel.
44:27 John Hopkins? They're out.
44:32 John Hopkins? Safely at Camp Two, the team settles down to a much-needed meal. But it's too soon for anyone to count their chickens.
44:41 John Hopkins? Just as everyone starts to relax, they're given a startling reminder of the hazards all around.
44:47 John Hopkins? Team leader Pavel is cooking the dinner as usual, when there is a strange, cracking noise bouncing off the cavernous walls. A small boulder has begun to loosen from the ceiling of the cave. Then, quite suddenly, it dislodges, striking Pavel on its way down.
45:07 John Hopkins? A crunch, a streak of blood and a cry of pain. Everybody rushes to their leader. Thankfully, he's all right.
45:16 John Hopkins? It's a second close shave for the Russian. An inch closer, and the rock would have directly hit his head.
45:25 Speaker 03 He wasn't badly hurt. He had like a cut to his face, but he was okay. But I remember turning to Jeff, who was sat next to me, and I just quietly said to him, "Death is still in this cave. He's after one of us."
45:41 John Hopkins? Over the next two days Robbie and the others continue their climb back to the surface. Back up the central column, along the treacherous entrance series. Ropes, readjustments, rests, restarts.
45:56 John Hopkins? Until finally, Robbie senses a change in the air.
46:01 Speaker 03 I could smell vegetation at this point. I knew that we'd made it out of the cave. I remember getting to the top of the ropes and I stopped and sat there in my harness. And uncontrollably I just burst into tears, like I was hit by this wave of emotion. Because I recognize the fact that I'd done it, we'd all survived.
46:21 John Hopkins? It's night time when the weary group of men finally set foot on the surface.
46:27 John Hopkins? Then, one by one, they walk the short distance from the cave entrance to the nearby campsite.
46:35 Speaker 03 I could see the lights at camp and I remember seeing a blood-red moon sinking over the Black Sea. And it was just above the horizon and I was stood watching it slowly descend into the ocean. And then the stars were out and just slowly went down to camp in a daze.
47:00 John Hopkins? At the campsite, the cavers toast their survival in the traditional Russian way.
47:11 Speaker 03 There was some bottles of vodka, tequila. We start laughing and joking as the alcohol sets in. I remember I called Gina. I walked up a hill to get some signal. And she said to me afterward, she said, "You know, you were very matter-of-fact on the phone. You were very calm and precise and you were telling me what had happened and that you'd survived and it was all okay." But she said, she later said that when I called her again back at the coast, like three days later, it was like that near-death experience had sunk in and apparently I was a nervous wreck on the phone. I was emotional, I cried again. So it didn't hit me immediately, but it hit me a few days later.
47:54 John Hopkins? As Robbie readjusts to life back home with his partner in Austria, it soon becomes clear that his experiences in Veriavkina have left a lasting impact. He is tormented by visions of drowning deep underground.
48:10 Speaker 03 I probably should have seen help. I spent three months, nearly three months, getting drunk every night because I couldn't go to sleep being conscious. I couldn't go to sleep being sober, being aware of my existence because I would lie in bed thinking of water catching me up and lapping by my legs and then within a minute or two it would up by my neck and then it would swallow me whole and I was going to drown. I had this feeling that, no, I wasn't alive. I'd actually died down in the bottom of the cave and all of our bodies were just at the bottom. And I was now in ghost form. I was now a ghost.
48:55 John Hopkins? Slowly, Robbie begins to recover his mental health. He's able to sleep better, to process what happened.
49:03 John Hopkins? But he says his brush with death will never fully leave him.
49:08 Speaker 03 I'm OK now, but mentally it's altered me for sure. For better, for worse, I don't know. I think it's made me a lot more aware of the fragility of being alive and how death can take us at any moment. I now look at my caving projects slightly differently. I don't focus on the difficult, challenging, more dangerous projects like, you know, the bottom of Veriavkina, for example. To be honest, I have no desire to ever go back to the bottom of Veriavkina or the next deepest cave. You know, in my lifetime, I'm sure there'll be another cave that breaks the world depth record.
49:52 Speaker 03 I'm not on that trip. That's for somebody else, right?
49:59 John Hopkins? Despite his newfound caution, Robbie still has unfinished business with Veriavkina. His job on the 2018 expedition was to document the cave with his photographs. But the only photos he brought back with him were those of the lowest levels, including his magnificent image of Pavel ascending from the terminal sump.
50:21 John Hopkins? He'd been planning to photograph the rest of the cave on the way back up, before he was forced to leave all his equipment behind in Camp 3.
50:31 John Hopkins? A year after barely escaping with his life, Robbie is back there to finish the job, along with Jeff and Pavel.
50:41 Speaker 03 We didn't go down to the bottom. That was something I made quite clear to Pavel. I didn't want to go to the bottom. And we didn't need to go to the bottom. We'd got all the pictures. So we went down to, I think, 1,000 metres or something like that, and then photographed the rest of the cave from there back to the surface.
50:59 John Hopkins? Robbie and Pavel's bond is stronger than ever after their ordeal in the world's deepest cave. And together, they've shared their story at public events.
51:09 Speaker 03 I love that. I love standing in front of an audience now. I didn't know how I would react to that. It's something I never did. I was a little bit scared, a little bit intimidated about being onstage. It turns out that it's actually good fun.
51:27 John Hopkins? Unlike Robbie, Pavel shows no signs of slowing down. He even returns to Camp 3 of Veriavkina. It's a sobering sight. Clothes, sleeping bags, and photographic equipment strewn all around. Many of the items are embedded in the ceiling.
51:47 John Hopkins? Later, Pavel shows Robbie what he found in the cave.
51:51 Speaker 03 And I was presented with a load of gear that they'd salvaged. They'd been down a few weeks earlier and managed to salvage my Primaloft jacket that I'd left, some radios, a walkie-talkie. The walkie-talkie still works. I still use it.
52:10 John Hopkins? Over the next two years Pavel supervises a number of safety improvements at Veriavkina. But all the measures in the world can't guarantee a cave's welfare. Even one as experienced and level-headed as Pavel Demidov. In August 2020 Robbie's friend is exploring a new cave in the Arabika Masiv, not far from Veriavkina.
52:34 Speaker 03 He was only, I don't know, 200, 300 metres underground when he was crushed by a big rockfall and his teammate had to move the rocks out of the way in order for him to get past, to reach the surface and call the... not the rescue, the recovery, I guess. Because he realised that Pavel had died in the rockfall.
53:00 John Hopkins? With the help of the international caving community, Robbie and Gina raise over £5,000 to pay for Pavel's body to be recovered.
53:10 John Hopkins? At the head of their fundraising page sits the image of Pavel ascending from the pool of Veriavkina's deepest point. A look of heroic determination on his face.
53:24 Speaker 03 Pavel was, in my opinion, the greatest cave explorer of our generation. He was an incredible leader. He was incredibly tough and strong, but he was also incredibly kind and generous and supportive. It's a big loss. It's a big loss to cave exploration.
53:45 John Hopkins? Robbie and Gina meanwhile have embarked on adventures of a different kind as parents to four-year-old Maddie. And in a way, it's all thanks to Veriavkina.
53:58 Speaker 03 It did change my life. I remember when we got back home, I told Gina that I was ready to start a family. My life is very different now. Maddie is in it. That's a direct result of Veriavkina, I think. I mean, I think about it often, I must admit. Psychologically, the Veriavkina experience changed me, for sure. I'm more aware of my existence. Maybe it was a good thing it happened.
54:34 John Hopkins? En el próximo episodio, nos encontramos con Mark Lyons.
54:39 John Hopkins? En noviembre de 2015, el apetito ciclista ha entrado en La Ruta de los Conquistadores, una épica carrera de bicicleta montaña a través del corazón de Costa Rica. Es un desafío desagradable, considerado por muchos como la competición más difícil de su tipo.
54:55 John Hopkins? Y Mark pronto aprenderá por qué tiene una reputación tan temerosa.
55:00 John Hopkins? Cuando se cae y cae durante una cruz de río, el padre de dos se va a deslizar hacia el fondo por millas, profundo en el bosque.
55:15 John Hopkins? Eso es la próxima vez, en Real Historias de Vida. Escucha la historia de Mark hoy sin esperar una semana al suscribirse a Noiza Plus.
55:23 Speaker 00 Visible pone el hack无线 ultimate en el dedo de tu mano. Con datos de datos wireless unlimited 5G y hotspot diseñados para mantenerte conectado, impulsado por la red 5G de Verizon. Y sin contrato te mantenga en contacto. Los planes empiezan a 25 dólares al mes, o obtén el Premium Visible Plus Pro Plan y gasta 10 dólares en tu primer mes cuando utiliza el código promocional Hack. Haz el cambio en visible.com. Términos aplicables. Visible.com para detalles.
55:53 Speaker 01 El Lemonade ha pasado décadas manteniendo a Lemon en la cima y Lime en las sombras. Su agenda de limón ha infiltrado todo, incluso nuestra música. ¿Esa canción se llama después del color de los limones? No es una coincidencia. Big Lemon ha estado sacando cordones en la industria durante años. Piénsalo. Pero ahora 7Up está luchando de nuevo con su nueva soda Lime Lemon. Ahora Lime viene primero. 7Up, flipa la cepa.
Previous Skidding off the Freeway: Trapped out of Sight Next Swept Downstream: Mountain Biker in Costa Rica Page updated November 3, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated