Pod Insights Real Survival Stories Aid Worker Kidnapped: Daring Bolt for Freedom (Part 2 of 2) About this episode We return to Jeff Frazier as he prepares for an audacious prison break. In the dead of night, with the guards distracted, he’ll make his move. Can he overcome the many obstacles in his path and escape into the jungle? Or will he be caught… and if so, what punishment awaits?
A Noiser production, written by Joe Viner.
For ad-free listening, bonus material and early access to new episodes, join Noiser+. Click the Noiser+ banner to get started. Or, if you’re on Spotify or Android, go to noiser.com/subscriptions
If you have an amazing survival story of your own that you’d like to put forward for the show, let us know. Drop us an email at [email protected]
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:00 Speaker 00 Host Thanksgiving with industry-leading quality standards from Whole Foods Market. There are no antibiotics in their meat department, ever, so carve up turkey and spiral-cut ham with peace of mind. Shop organic sides like stuffing mix and cranberry sauce from 365 Brand. And guess what? All their delectable pies are made with no high-fructose corn syrup. Gourmet Thanksgiving flavors with the quality you want, only at Whole Foods Market.
0:30 Speaker 01 With Truvia Sweeteners, it's simple to make sweetness part of your routine. From sweetening your creamy morning matcha to freshly baked blueberry scones, Truvia Sweeteners make it easy to enjoy the flavors you love with less sugar per serving. From everyday drinks to homemade favorites, they're made to fit right in. Because with Truvia, every moment tastes better. Find Truvia at your favorite local grocery retailer and bring better sweetness home.
0:59 John Hopkins? It's May 2023, the dead of night in a deprived suburb to the south of Port-au-Prince, Haiti.
1:08 John Hopkins? Two people, a man and a woman, creep along the shadowy verge of a dirt road.
1:15 John Hopkins? Behind them, up a hill to the east, is a 15-foot metal fence topped with razor wire. To the west, sits a dense shanty town, a sea of concrete and corrugated iron. Beyond that, at the crest of a slope gently rising above the houses, lies a clump of thick jungle, darkly silhouetted against the moonlit sky. That's where the man and woman are headed. If they can get there, they'll be safe, at least for tonight. But if they're spotted before they reach the tree line, they'll either be captured or shot.
1:53 John Hopkins? They walk slowly, their heads lowered, carefully avoiding stepping on sticks or broken glass, anything that could draw attention to them.
2:03 John Hopkins? The woman is Haitian, small and wiry.
2:07 John Hopkins? But the man is tall, well over six feet, with broad shoulders and long arms.
2:14 John Hopkins? His head is wrapped in a swaddle of black fabric, but a few wisps of scraggly, dark facial hair escape the makeshift mask. His name is Jeff Frazier. He's an American, and in this dangerous neighborhood, foreigners are easy targets.
2:34 John Hopkins? But however unsafe it is out here, it's better than where they've come from.
2:40 John Hopkins? For the past 28 days, Jeff and the woman, whose name is Stephanie, have been living in captivity, locked in a filthy cell, suffering abuse at the hands of the gang who kidnapped them. The hostages have been trying to negotiate a ransom for their release, to no avail. Finally, after putting up with all they could bear, Jeff and Stephanie found another way out: the window. And now, they are well on their way to freedom. They just need to reach those trees.
3:15 John Hopkins? But suddenly, something stops them in their tracks.
3:19 Speaker 03 We look up ahead and we see two gang guards with weapons. They're maybe 100, 150 meters up.
3:29 John Hopkins? The guards stand chatting by the side of the road, their AK-47s slung casually across their chests.
3:38 John Hopkins? Jeff's stomach clenches. He can practically hear Stephanie's heart beating by his side. The escaped prisoners hold their breath and start slowly backing away.
3:51 John Hopkins? Too late. They've been seen. The guards unsling their rifles and prowl forwards to investigate.
3:59 Speaker 03 They start running toward us. We could reasonably run, but would certainly risk being shot at. Remember, this is the place where they shoot all day long. And they're going to assume we're a rival gang if we're running away.
4:13 John Hopkins? Jeff and Stephanie have just seconds to make a decision. Do they give themselves up and face the inevitable consequences? Or do they take their chances and run?
4:32 John Hopkins? Ever wondered what you would do when disaster strikes? If your life depended on your next decision, could you make the right choice? Welcome to Real Survival Stories. These are the astonishing tales of ordinary people thrown into extraordinary situations. People suddenly forced to fight for their lives.
4:53 John Hopkins? In this episode, we return to Haiti and to kidnapped humanitarian worker Jeff Frazier. For nearly a month, Jeff has been kept in squalid conditions by a local gang. During that time, he and his fellow hostages have discussed the possibility of escape in the abstract, a last resort if all other options disappear.
5:14 Speaker 03 And I would often shoot those conversations down because they were all just dangerous thought patterns to be in. You can really go down a rabbit hole of claustrophobia being in that room.
5:31 John Hopkins? But when Jeff's ransom delivery fails to secure his release, escape seems to be his only option. And one night, he and his fellow hostage Stephanie make their bid for freedom, knowing that one misstep, one moment of misfortune, could get them both killed.
5:51 John Hopkins? I'm John Hopkins. From the Noiser Network, this is Real Survival Stories.
6:20 John Hopkins? It's May 2023. It's just before midnight, and 45-year-old Jeff Frazier is loitering by the window of his cell.
6:31 John Hopkins? He glances over his shoulder at Stephanie. She's standing on an upturned bucket by the door, one eye pressed to a pinhole in the wood, watching the activity of the guards outside.
6:43 John Hopkins? After a pause, Stephanie flashes the signal: "All clear."
6:49 John Hopkins? Jeff lifts the red cloth curtain and wraps a length of nylon rope around two of the bars that cover the small window.
6:58 John Hopkins? Next, he takes a wooden curtain rail and places it flush against the bars, tying it in place with the loose ends of the rope. Then he begins twisting the curtain rail round and round, tightening the knot like a tourniquet, until the parallel bars start to bend under the pressure.
7:19 John Hopkins? It's been four weeks since Jeff was kidnapped: a drawn-out ordeal of failed negotiations, psychological torment, and physical abuse.
7:29 John Hopkins? Over the course of that time, Jeff has witnessed the release of several of his fellow hostages. Now he and Stephanie are the only ones left. In the long hours they've spent alone together, a close bond has formed between the two captives: a friendship that has become a vital source of solidarity and comfort.
7:50 Speaker 03 It's just Stephanie and I, you know, that are in there, the two of us. And so we pass the time by telling stories of each other's homes and talk about better times. And those bonds are absolutely essential to survival.
8:07 John Hopkins? Jeff's negotiations with the gang haven't gone well. After first trying to barter on his own behalf, he subsequently agreed to hand over talks to a team of professional kidnap and ransom specialists assembled by his wife Mary. Two days ago, one of the guards came to tell him that an agreement had been reached. He was going home. Earlier today, as scheduled, the ransom exchange took place. A courier from Jeff's team met the gang and handed over thirteen thousand dollars in cash. But the gang didn't uphold their end of the bargain. They took the money, but refused to let Jeff go.
8:46 John Hopkins? It's the final straw. If the kidnappers weren't played by the rules, then neither will he.
8:53 Speaker 03 When they came up with that accord on day twenty-eight, I really believed I was getting out. But we also prepared the escape, just in case. Either way, I was getting out on the twenty-eighth, right? But that was a poor ultimatum to give myself emotionally, because those two things should not be connected, but they were. I was gonna be out on twenty-eighth, whether I went out the window or went out the door. You know, I was going out.
9:25 Speaker 00 Host Thanksgiving with industry-leading quality standards from Whole Foods Market. There are no antibiotics in their meat department, ever, so carve up turkey and spiral-cut ham with peace of mind. Shop organic sides like stuffing mix and cranberry sauce from 365 brand. And guess what? All their delectable pies are made with no high-fructose corn syrup. Gourmet Thanksgiving flavors with the quality you want, only at Whole Foods Market.
9:57 John Hopkins? Sweat forms on Jeff's brow as he bends the window bars. Slowly, he is creating an opening wide enough for his bulky frame.
10:09 John Hopkins? He peeks out of the window.
10:12 John Hopkins? He can see beyond the high wall of the compound. There's a hill sloping up to a patch of jungle about half a mile away. If he and Stephanie can reach those trees under cover of darkness, there'll be a way.
10:27 Speaker 03 I thought we had a really strong chance of being successful. We would walk out at like 3:00 in the morning when it's quiet. We're hoping for darkness. Rain would have been even better because Haitians hate the rain, so they're not out and about. But in the middle of the night, we shouldn't run into many people. I estimated we were about a half a mile from the tree line. And with military experience and I've been in the woods a lot, once I get to the tree line, you're not going to find me.
10:53 John Hopkins? From there, Jeff and Stephanie will continue west through the trees, eventually making their way out of gang-controlled territory to freedom.
11:03 John Hopkins? They've decided that tonight's the night to attempt their escape. The guards, flush with cash after the delivery of Jeff's ransom, are throwing themselves a party.
11:15 John Hopkins? Pungent smoke and thumping music drift through from their living quarters. They should be occupied for most of the night. With any luck, they won't even notice the empty cell until morning. Still, the prisoners have to be discreet.
11:31 John Hopkins? Jeff gets another all-clear signal from Stephanie. He resumes his clandestine handiwork.
11:40 John Hopkins? In tiny quarter-inch increments, he widens the gap between the bars.
11:49 John Hopkins? He beckons Stephanie over to the window. They look out across the dark, deserted compound.
11:57 Speaker 03 The plan was to essentially kind of hide in plain sight with, we had some disguises. I had some black fabric from some clothes that were left behind that I made a mask to cover my face.
12:11 John Hopkins? It's not a bad disguise, given their limited resources. But Jeff will still be highly conspicuous out there beyond the compound walls. And when their captors realize he's escaped, the area will be crawling with gang members searching for a tall, broad-shouldered American and his female Haitian accomplice.
12:32 John Hopkins? They just need to make sure they're far away by the time that happens.
12:39 John Hopkins? At 3 a.m., Jeff finally squeezes himself through the gap in the bars.
12:47 Speaker 03 I went first out the window and hung out outside just for a minute or two because the sounds are very different outside than they are inside. I remember listening, trying to see what I could hear, listening for anything. I was especially afraid of dogs kind of outing us. There's always dogs around and if they see me, they're gonna start barking at me and then it's over.
13:17 John Hopkins? Jeff pulls his lower half through the window and drops to the ground with a muffled thud.
13:24 John Hopkins? The air is muggy and still, no trace of a tropical breeze.
13:30 John Hopkins? A symphony of insects resonates through the leafy canopy.
13:35 John Hopkins? When Jeff helps Stephanie down from the window, it's clear she's starting to panic. Her breath comes in short, shallow gasps.
13:43 Speaker 03 So I remember when she first came out, she started freaking out. She was essentially hyperventilating. Had to calm her down. We walked around the side of the building where we had a little bit more cover, just to let her kind of settle down.
14:01 John Hopkins? Gradually, Stephanie's breathing returns to normal, but she's understandably agitated. Jeff's military training has left him well-equipped to deal with high-stress environments and situations.
14:15 John Hopkins? He looks his companion dead in the eye, wordlessly communicating the need to stay calm and collected. They can't let their nerves get the better of them.
14:26 John Hopkins? Jeff turns and looks across the courtyard to the exit.
14:30 Speaker 03 Our window faced west, and it looked right at a man door in the 15-foot-high wall. So that's where we were headed. We needed to walk out that man door.
14:43 John Hopkins? After a brief consultation, it's agreed that Jeff will go first, and Stephanie will follow close behind.
14:50 Speaker 03 She was very nervous, and I didn't want her making any choices in that scenario. So I said, "Do you just follow behind me maybe 10 steps, and we'll go?"
15:02 John Hopkins? While Stephanie hangs back, Jeff prowls forward in a low crouch, his eyes darting to and fro.
15:10 John Hopkins? This walk to the main exit might be a straight shot, but it takes them out into the middle of the yard, directly in the line of sight of the front porch, where the guards often sit.
15:22 John Hopkins? Jeff creeps onwards, glancing back periodically towards the front of the building. All clear.
15:31 John Hopkins? Eventually, he makes it to the door in the corrugated metal wall. Carefully, cautiously, he pushes against the weathered steel.
15:42 John Hopkins? It opens.
15:44 John Hopkins? He steps outside and looks around for guards, but again, there's no one.
15:50 John Hopkins? He presses his back flat against the wall and waits by the side of the door for Stephanie. He peeks around the corner, but there's no sign of her.
16:00 John Hopkins? Jeff's pulse quickens.
16:04 John Hopkins? What's taking her so long? Could she have gotten cold feet or been spotted by the guards?
16:11 John Hopkins? A minute goes by, then two.
16:15 John Hopkins? Then, after an eternity, Stephanie appears through the door.
16:22 John Hopkins? Jeff reaches out and pulls her into the shadows.
16:27 John Hopkins? The first stage of their plan is complete. Now they need to start moving towards the trees. But as Jeff and Stephanie appraise their surroundings, they notice something is seriously wrong.
16:42 Speaker 03 One of the tenets of a successful escape was that we would do it under darkness because we have disguises on, but they're not very good disguises. And so we need to be dark out. But unfortunately, once I get outside that 15-foot wall, there's no more trees. You know, there's a ton of trees in the compound, but not outside the compound. And now it's so bright. It's like there's two full moons outside. It is so bright.
17:13 John Hopkins? And the moonlight is not the only setback. As Jeff looks over towards the trees to the west, he realizes that he has made a potentially disastrous miscalculation.
17:25 Speaker 03 One of the big assumptions that we made was that the wood line was only about 500 meters away, maybe less. And we made that assumption based on the limited view outside of that western window. But once I got outside the compound, I could see that it was actually quite a bit further away. In fact, it was probably about a mile and a half away.
17:50 John Hopkins? Worse still, they can now see that they're separated from the trees by a dense tract of housing, a chaotic jumble of concrete shacks, tarpaulin roofs, and corrugated metal fencing. To reach safety, they will have to navigate this maze.
18:07 Speaker 03 The way these kind of shanty towns are built, their unpredictable patterns, you really have to know what you're doing to know how to find the sidewalks, so to speak. They meander through these labyrinths in a confusing way. You know, sometimes 12 inches wide to get through them. But locals know how to pass through, but I sure don't. And so that's a pretty devastating realization that we're not nearly as close to safety as we thought.
18:40 John Hopkins? Jeff and Stephanie exchange looks. They can't magic up another plan. They don't have a choice. In order to get to those trees, they're going to have to go through the houses.
18:52 John Hopkins? Both escapees strain their ears, listening out for patrolling guards over the staccato pounding of their hearts.
19:00 John Hopkins? When they're confident the coast is clear, they set off walking along a dirt track that winds down towards the buildings.
19:08 John Hopkins? As part of his humanitarian work, Jeff has spent plenty of time in terribly poor areas like this, and he tries to use his observations about local behaviour to their advantage.
19:20 Speaker 03 Our plan is to walk really slowly. Haitians walk real slowly, especially in hilly environments because they're not fed well. So they have very low energy. So our idea was to do that.
19:33 John Hopkins? The escaped prisoners gradually make their way downhill, hope and adrenaline growing with each yard they put between themselves and the compound. So far, so good.
19:47 John Hopkins? Then after a few minutes, Jeff hears voices from somewhere close by. Looking round, he sees two men carrying bundles of sticks, walking down the track towards them.
19:59 Speaker 03 We passed a couple of guys that were coming down the hill having chopped wood in the mountains that day, and they're just now making it home from their long hike. But they don't seem to notice us. They continue talking as they walk right by us.
20:16 John Hopkins? Jeff exhales.
20:19 John Hopkins? They're not far from the houses now, just a couple of hundred metres. They round a bend in the track so that they're walking parallel to the buildings, separated by a stretch of scrubland. Every step is a step in the right direction. And then, they see something.
20:39 Speaker 03 We continue kind of limping along. We're fine, there's nobody around. But then we look up ahead and we see two gang guards with weapons. They're maybe 100, 150 meters up.
20:56 John Hopkins? The escaped prisoners freeze. The guards are stood in the middle of the road, assault rifles slung across their chests. Jeff and Stephanie hold their breath and start inching quietly back up the track. But they don't get far. The guards look up and immediately clock the pair.
21:21 Speaker 03 They start running toward us. It's essentially too late. I think we could reasonably run, but would certainly risk being shot at. This is, remember, this is the place where they shoot all day long. And they're going to assume we're a rival gang if we're running away.
21:37 John Hopkins? Jeff and Stephanie admit defeat. They put their hands up. Game over. Except when the guards come close, Jeff notices a couple of interesting things. These guys are young, certainly not high-ranking members of the gang, which means they're potentially open to bribes. Stephanie is way ahead of him. She starts speaking to the men in Creole.
22:07 Speaker 03 Stephanie brilliantly starts to try to convince them to help us get to freedom and that we'll pay them a ransom if they get us to safety. There are pretty reasonable routes out in the dark. They could smuggle us out. The numbers that we're talking are astonishingly high numbers. You know, $1,000 US to one of these guys is several years of pay.
22:35 John Hopkins? Jeff watches their faces as Stephanie talks. He can see that the young gang members are interested.
22:43 Speaker 03 And they're listening. They're considering, you know, helping us. And they said, okay. They tell us to call our friends to meet them. We're like, we don't have phones. They said, follow us. We follow them deep into the labyrinth.
23:06 John Hopkins? This is cause for a small amount of optimism. It seems Stephanie may have just bartered their way to freedom.
23:14 John Hopkins? They follow the two gang members into the shanty town. It's just as mazy and complex as Jeff had expected. It would have taken them hours to navigate these tight, twisting alleys.
23:27 John Hopkins? Eventually, they arrive at a cinder block shack with a slanting metal roof. Jeff and Stephanie are led into a windowless, concrete room.
23:38 Speaker 03 They stick us in this room and lock us in. And said, "Hey, we'll be back with a phone." And about thirty minutes later, they do come back with that phone. And they let Stephanie talk. She calls her boss, who is oftentimes helpful. And he agrees, "Hey, give me thirty minutes. Let me put it together, put together a couple of grand, and we'll find a place to meet you."
24:06 John Hopkins? By now, it must be approaching dawn.
24:10 John Hopkins? Jeff and Stephanie pace around the room, hopeful that her boss will come through for them. But thirty minutes pass, then an hour. Their hope dwindles. Jeff sits on the floor by the wall and closes his eyes. A depressingly familiar pattern emerges.
24:31 Speaker 03 It's probably like seven or eight AM. We start to see more senior people come into our dark room. They unlock the door, peek their head in, and they start telling us lies about how they're gonna help us and take us to the airport, and they're just trying to figure it out. But we know better.
24:53 John Hopkins? It's obvious that these people have no intention of helping. They're clearly affiliates of the gang who kidnapped them, and they will shortly return them to the hands of their captors and whatever punishment awaits.
25:06 John Hopkins? Sure enough, at about ten AM, the men escort Jeff and Stephanie from the room and into the back of an SUV.
25:15 John Hopkins? As they pile into the vehicle, there is still a final glimmer of hope that maybe they really have stumbled across some good Samaritans.
25:23 John Hopkins? But that glimmer is swiftly extinguished when the SUV starts driving up the hill, back towards the compound.
25:36 Speaker 04 Starting or growing your own business can be intimidating and lonely at times. Your to-do list may feel endless with new tasks and lists can easily begin to overrun your life. So finding the right tool that not only helps you out, but simplifies everything as a built-in business partner can be a game changer. For millions of businesses, that tool is Shopify. Shopify is the commerce platform behind millions of businesses around the world and 10% of all e-commerce in the US. From household names like Jimm Shark, Rare Beauty, and Heinz, to brands just getting started. Shopify has hundreds of ready-to-use templates that can help you build a beautiful online store that matches your brand's style.
26:17 Speaker 04 And you can tackle all the important tasks in one place, from inventory, to payments, to analytics, and more. No need to save multiple websites or try to figure out what platform is hosting the tool that you need. And if people haven't heard about your brand, you can get the word out like you have a marketing team behind you with easy-to-run email and social media campaigns to reach customers wherever they're scrolling or strolling. Start your business today with the industry's best business partner, Shopify, and start hearing... Sign up for your $1 per month trial today at Shopify.com/real. Go to Shopify.com/real. That's Shopify.com/real.
27:01 Speaker 00 Host Thanksgiving with industry-leading quality standards from Whole Foods Market. There are no antibiotics in their meat department, ever, so carve up turkey and spiral-cut ham with peace of mind. Shop organic sides like stuffing mix and cranberry sauce from 365 Brand. And guess what? All their delectable pies are made with no high-fructose corn syrup. Gourmet Thanksgiving flavors with the quality you want, only at Whole Foods Market.
27:32 John Hopkins? It's mid-morning. The SUV trundles upwards, nearing the compound. Sitting slumped on the backseat, Jeff's body jostles from side to side as the vehicle bumps over the dirt track.
27:47 Speaker 03 I remember when they were driving us back to the compound, just devastated because I had a pretty good idea of what was gonna happen to us. Aside from I'm captive again, but also the violence that was likely to occur.
28:08 John Hopkins? After arriving back at the compound, Jeff and Stephanie are marched across the yard.
28:15 John Hopkins? Jeff glances around at the faces of the onlooking guards. There is a strange atmosphere in the air.
28:22 Speaker 03 I think I was surprised at first when we pulled in because it was fairly quiet. The higher ups weren't there yet and the lower guards all kind of had their tail between their legs because they were afraid for their own lives. If we had successfully escaped, they would probably have all been killed.
28:46 John Hopkins? The guards watch as Jeff and Stephanie are led back into the main building, where they are taken to a different cell, one whose windows haven't been tampered with.
28:58 John Hopkins? There are four other prisoners inside this room. Two of them are Jeff's security guards, DJ and Reggie, who were kidnapped alongside him some 29 days ago.
29:11 John Hopkins? They don't look pleased to see him.
29:13 Speaker 03 And they were just very upset with us because they believed we had put them in danger also. When we came up missing, when the guys realized that we were missing, everyone was freaking out and they were all forced to lay on their faces and were being threatened with death. You better tell us where they went. And they assumed they were complicit. Stephanie and I essentially had no friends at that point.
29:45 John Hopkins? The cruel irony is that, following his failed escape attempt, Jeff is further from freedom now than he ever was before.
29:54 John Hopkins? He slumps to his knees and drops his head into his hands, his filthy, overgrown hair tumbling around his fingers. At this stage, who knows what comes next?
30:06 John Hopkins? Will the gang refuse to negotiate further? Will they hold him hostage for another month? Six months? A year?
30:15 John Hopkins? Clearly, there will be repercussions for his escape attempt. The treatment he was receiving before was relative luxury compared with what's to come.
30:24 Speaker 03 The rest of that day was just full of beatings and torture and terror. Those are rough times, just dealing with the utter despair of realizing that
30:37 Speaker 03 on day 28, I was really thinking I was getting out, right? And then now, on day 29, 30, 31, all these days, I know that I'm nowhere near getting out, right? And now, now my time has gotten far worse because now, anytime somebody has an opportunity to harass me or give me a hard time or hit me with some stick, they'll do it.
31:04 John Hopkins? In the days after his recapture, Jeff loses his mattress privileges and is forced to sleep on the floor.
31:13 John Hopkins? One of his cellmates gives him a shoe to use as a pillow, and Jeff spends every night curled up on the cold concrete.
31:22 John Hopkins? As well as the beatings, the gang also tightens the rations, providing the prisoners with even less sustenance than before.
31:29 Speaker 03 We didn't have food, but they also withheld water from us, and that's far worse. If you get truly thirsty, like that messes with you real good. We did get bleach water at some point, and we were all drinking it. You're not supposed to, and you shouldn't. It only makes you more thirsty, but we didn't have much choice.
31:53 John Hopkins? The days grind interminably on. Since his recapture, the guards haven't brought Jeff his cellphone, so he hasn't been able to speak to Mary or anyone from his team on the outside.
32:07 John Hopkins? But over the next few days, his fellow hostages make progress with their own negotiations. One by one, Jeff watches his cellmates secure their freedom.
32:19 Speaker 03 They started letting people go. DJ got out and Reggie got out. By day thirty-four, it's just Stephanie and I. And then she gets out on day thirty-five, which I was, of course, thrilled for her.
32:38 John Hopkins? For the first time since this ordeal began, Jeff is alone.
32:46 Speaker 03 That got bad fast. Having no one to talk to all day long, except for these guards who just come in and harass you, and no food, little water, that whole thing, crush. I was imploding quickly. It is devastating to be alone. It's hard to explain the level of emotional destruction that comes from being alone, but it's significant.
33:11 John Hopkins? Jeff's despair threatens to become all-consuming. Utterly exhausted, physically and mentally, it's increasingly difficult to see the light at the end of the tunnel. But he tries to suppress the demons, to keep thinking as rationally as he can.
33:28 Speaker 03 I'm an eternal optimist. The most rational thing is that I will get out. That is the most likely thing.
33:37 Speaker 03 And so you have to be super-disciplined at pointing your brain to that, because that is optimism. There's reason to hope, but it's just so difficult, in the meantime, to get through it.
33:57 John Hopkins? Three days after Stephanie's release, a guard brings Jeff his cellphone. He's getting a call from Billy, the negotiator recruited by his team on the outside. Billy tells him that discussions with the kidnappers are ongoing.
34:13 John Hopkins? Currently, they're trying to organize a second ransom exchange. But to avoid a repeat of the last time, they have a new plan.
34:22 Speaker 03 My team has unbeknownst to me has been working hard since the failed ransom attempt to re-establish trust with the gang and demand a live exchange. So they are willing to pay again a smaller amount, but it has to be a live exchange. And so, meaning I have to be present at the time they hand money and they'll do a one-for-one, right? None of this, take the money, go up the hill and decide if you're gonna bring Jeff, right? We're only gonna get the money if we see Jeff and you let him go.
34:58 John Hopkins? Surprisingly, the gang agrees to these demands. Later that day, another man steps into his cell and tells Jeff they have an accord. That is, an agreement for his release.
35:12 John Hopkins? It's hard to trust the gang's promises, but this seems like a major moment, like a light has been turned back on.
35:19 Speaker 03 And I'm of course thrilled because I assumed I was gonna be there for weeks, you know, given the whole escape thing and that we're essentially gonna start over. So I'm thrilled that they've gotten an accord.
35:34 John Hopkins? There are still details to hammer out, including where the exchange will happen. And this proves a major sticking point.
35:43 Speaker 03 So you can imagine the tensions around location preference for a live exchange. My team wants it to happen in an area that's safe for them and the gang wants it to happen in an area that's safe for them. And so they spend days arguing about this.
36:00 John Hopkins? Jeff is stuck in excruciating limbo.
36:05 John Hopkins? Negotiations could collapse at any moment. He spends the hours praying and sleeping and willing his team to agree to a compromise.
36:15 John Hopkins? Jeff has now learned that US federal law enforcement has become involved in securing his release. Members of the FBI have flown out to Haiti and are helping to coordinate the ransom drop. Jeff relayed this information to the gang, hoping it would spook them into letting him go.
36:34 John Hopkins? To some extent, it worked. His kidnappers are clearly keen to get the ransom money and wash their hands of this troublesome American. But talk of the FBI has also made them extremely skittish.
36:48 John Hopkins? Eventually, after 48 hours of arguing over a location for the exchange, things suddenly go south. One of the more senior kidnappers, a gang member who Jeff has dubbed Chef Two, barges into the cell apoplectic with rage.
37:07 Speaker 03 Chef Two comes running in and is hitting me and screaming at my team while he's on the phone and saying, "There's no accord. You know, we have no agreement. You're gonna die here." You know, just total breakdown of the whole process. I was so confident I was getting out that I had cleaned the room and was ready to go, and to realize I was going to have to stay for quite a bit longer was just crushing, absolutely crushing.
37:45 John Hopkins? It's the morning of day 43. Jeff lies on the floor of his cell, staring at the ceiling. There's a foul, chemical taste in his mouth and a burning sensation in his stomach, the result of drinking water disinfected with bleach. It's all his captors ever gave him.
38:07 John Hopkins? The door opens and one of the kidnappers enters the cell.
38:12 John Hopkins? Jeff barely even registers his presence. After forty-three days of captivity, all the beatings, all the false dawns, it's hard to fight anymore.
38:23 John Hopkins? But the guard hasn't come to torment him. Instead, he says that a location has finally been agreed. They're doing the ransom exchange later today.
38:34 John Hopkins? Jeff looks up at the guard.
38:37 John Hopkins? Immediately, he notices something different about him. The man has removed his face mask. It suggests he no longer needs to hide his identity from him.
38:49 John Hopkins? The kidnapper exits and leaves Jeff alone to his thoughts.
38:56 John Hopkins? Could it be that this time, they're actually letting him go?
39:02 Speaker 03 I started walking my laps and talking to myself, just saying, "Don't believe it. You know, it's a trick. They're just trying to mess with your brain." And it was working. Just had to remind myself over and over again not to get my hopes up because, you know, getting crushed again just seemed too much to bear.
39:22 John Hopkins? But then, a couple of hours later...
39:25 Speaker 03 They bring me the phone and it's a guy from my team who says, "No, no, it's real. We do have an accord. We have an agreed location. We are gonna agree to their location." It's still live exchange, but we found a guy who's willing to go in there, to the gang territory and do the live exchange.
39:45 John Hopkins? This is the chance. The exchange is on, but it has to go perfectly.
39:56 John Hopkins? At three o'clock that afternoon, a guard comes into the cell and hands Jeff his shoes, phone, credit card, and passport. Then he's led outside and into the back of a waiting SUV. Jeff is flanked on the backseat by armed gang members, their rifles stashed between their legs.
40:17 John Hopkins? There's still so much uncertainty. Could this be a setup?
40:22 John Hopkins? The SUV heads down the very same road that Jeff was snatched from forty-three days ago. They've been told to look out for a courier on a motorbike, wearing a red t-shirt.
40:34 John Hopkins? Jeff peers through the dirt-flecked windscreen. The street is busy. It's hard to make out individuals among the swarming traffic.
40:43 John Hopkins? But eventually, they spot him. The vehicle pulls over, and one of the kidnappers, nicknamed Chef Bad Cop, gets out to go and count the money.
40:54 John Hopkins? Jeff watches with mounting unease as Bad Cop turns away from the courier and marches back to the SUV, shaking his head.
41:04 Speaker 03 I watch Chef Bad Cop count the money, and it's not enough.
41:13 Speaker 03 And I'm just crushed, because I know that that's not good for me. And so they drive me back up to the compound, and I'm whining and complaining in the back. I'm trying to negotiate, like, because the amount that he said it was short was like $100 US. It's like, dude, give me a break. This is chump change. Like, just let me go. And he's not having it. Tells me to shut up.
41:36 John Hopkins? As the SUV rolls back through the gates of the compound, Jeff can hardly see straight.
41:43 John Hopkins? This just seems impossible, that his freedom could hang on a measly $100.
41:51 John Hopkins? The SUV rolls to a stop, and the kidnappers get out, leaving their agitated prisoner on the backseat. Clearly, this is just a power play by the gang, a last-second show of strength. How will Jeff's team respond? They could call the gang's bluff and pull out of the deal entirely, leaving him once again facing captivity.
42:13 John Hopkins? Bowing to their demands could show weakness. But can they really expect Jeff to endure this any longer?
42:21 John Hopkins? Eventually, the kidnappers return, and Jeff waits to hear his fate.
42:28 Speaker 03 They come back, they say, hey, we got the phone call, they have the rest of the money. And I couldn't believe it. Like, that seems so great. My team actually got the money and was okay with them playing games because clearly this is a game.
42:44 John Hopkins? They drive back to the same location. Jeff watches in a daze as Bad Cop once again gets out of the car and approaches the courier on the motorbike, who hands over the bag full of cash.
42:58 John Hopkins? And this time...
43:00 Speaker 03 He doesn't even count it. Bad Cop waves me out and says I can go. I quickly get onto the motorcycle and we ride out of there.
43:10 John Hopkins? Jeff grips the seat, two-handed, and holds on tight as the courier motors them away.
43:17 John Hopkins? His long hair thrashes wildly in the wind as tears start rolling down his face.
43:24 Speaker 03 I remember weeping on this guy's back. And I remember trying to hide my face because who I am in that area is very noticeable, right? And everyone around me is looking at me like a fishbowl. So I'm trying to hide my face as I'm openly weeping.
43:43 John Hopkins? They leave Matisson and approach Port-au-Prince city center.
43:49 John Hopkins? The motorcycle stops and Jeff is handed over to a truck driver. As the clunky vehicle weaves through the traffic, a fleet of motorbikes suddenly closes in around them.
44:02 John Hopkins? Jeff feels a jolt of panic.
44:05 Speaker 03 Of course, this is triggering for me because the last time I was surrounded by motorcycles was not good. And I look over at my driver and I'm about to attack the driver, right? I'm not thinking clearly, but this obviously looks bad. He's like, no, no, no, these are cops that just surrounded us. Calm down. And luckily, those cops escort us through town to the Marriott Hotel. They pull into the Marriott Hotel, the gate closes behind us and I was free.
44:44 Speaker 00 Hosts Thanksgiving with industry-leading quality standards from Whole Foods Market. There are no antibiotics in their meat department, ever, so carve up turkey and spiral-cut ham with peace of mind. Shop organic sides like stuffing mix and cranberry sauce from 365 brand. And guess what? All their delectable pies are made with no high-fructose corn syrup. Gourmet Thanksgiving flavors with the quality you want, only at Whole Foods Market.
45:13 Speaker 05 Holiday shopping for the big and tall guy? DXL has the sizes, the fit, and the brands he loves, with prices you'll love too. Choose from sizes XL to 8XL, waist 38 to 60, and over 75 brands, all in one place. Hard to shop for? Only if you shop in the wrong places. DXL, big and tall. Consider him handled. Shop DXL.com or visit one of 250 stores nationwide. DXL, wear what you want.
45:45 John Hopkins? It's May 24, 2023, at the Marriott Hotel in Port-au-Prince.
45:53 John Hopkins? Inside his hotel bathroom, Jeff steps out of the shower and goes over to the mirror.
45:59 John Hopkins? He wipes away the steam and looks at his reflection for the first time in 43 days.
46:05 Speaker 03 Looking at myself in the mirror for the first time was astonishing. I had grown a very long beard. My hair was all crazy, and I was very pale. And I had lost about 50 pounds and hadn't seen myself in that kind of, you know, state. I was covered in bug bites and bruises. Just looked terrible.
46:31 John Hopkins? When he first arrived at the hotel, Jeff was met by a team of FBI agents, who escorted him into the back of an ambulance.
46:38 John Hopkins? That was the moment when Jeff was hit by an overwhelming wave of relief.
46:43 Speaker 03 Once I saw that ambulance and then the FBI and my subconscious kind of decided I was actually safe, I absolutely fell apart. And my legs gave way, I could barely stand and, you know, I could barely speak through my tears.
47:02 John Hopkins? After the medics determined that he didn't need to go to hospital, Jeff checked into his hotel room. An FBI agent arranged for room service to send up some food: a cheeseburger, pizza and ice cream, the remnants of which now lie scattered around the room.
47:20 John Hopkins? After eating and showering, Jeff finally feels ready to call his wife.
47:26 John Hopkins? Through floods of tears, he tells Mary that he's safe and coming home.
47:35 John Hopkins? The next day Jeff is escorted to the airport and put on a plane back to America. Two and a half hours later, he goes through arrivals and steps through the sliding glass doors into the dazzling Florida sunshine. He scans the cars in the guest pickup lot, and soon he sees the one he's looking for.
47:55 Speaker 03 As soon as I spotted the car parked there, I started running to her. But it was strange because my legs were still not working right, and so I had this strange kind of gangly, floppy walk-run, which scared the heck out of her. But she gets out of the car and I got to hold her for the first time.
48:17 Speaker 03 I just remember it being so healing. I just didn't expect the power of that embrace.
48:26 Speaker 03 And how long I had imagined that reunion. It was spectacular. It was every bit as wonderful as I hoped.
48:44 John Hopkins? Today Jeff remains as committed as ever to his humanitarian mission in Haiti, even though for safety reasons, he currently cannot go back there himself. But if anything, he says his time in captivity has made him even more determined to do what he can to help the Haitian people.
49:04 John Hopkins? More than a year on from his ordeal, Jeff can still clearly picture the faces of the civilians he passed as the motorbike drove him out of gang-controlled territory. The faces of those who can't simply negotiate their way to a better life.
49:19 Speaker 03 Those are the true captives. And as I looked at them, realizing I was going home, but they're still there and they're still at the mercy of these vicious gangs to this day. And I remember thinking that I was hopefully riding to freedom, but they're not going to be. And there's definitely that survivor's guilt with me to this day.
49:48 Speaker 03 Bad things happen to people, right? Whether it be the loss of a loved one, or loss of a job, or a friend. It's hard to take that pain away, but it is possible to make that pain meaningful. And I think in this situation, as well as past situations that I've survived, is I have to make those situations meaningful. The people of Haiti, these are good people who want to do good things and want lives of freedom like the ones that we enjoy. I know the terror that faces them every day. So that's what drives me in this work today.
50:40 John Hopkins? In the next episode, we dive down into the eerie and enigmatic depths of Loch Ness.
50:47 John Hopkins? In the summer of 1977, diver and PhD student Hugh Williams is exploring a famous lake on the lookout for a submerged World War II Wellington bomber.
50:59 John Hopkins? But during his investigation, the 24-year-old suddenly becomes trapped deep underwater.
51:07 John Hopkins? Something grabs Hugh from below, and whatever it is, it isn't letting go.
51:14 John Hopkins? With time ticking away and his air supply disappearing, Hugh will have to make a series of pivotal choices, knowing that one wrong move could spell the end.
51:26 John Hopkins? That's next time on Real Survival Stories. Listen today without waiting a week by subscribing to Noiser Plus.
51:35 Speaker 00 Hosts Thanksgiving with industry-leading quality standards from Whole Foods Market. There are no antibiotics in their meat department, ever, so carve up turkey and spiral cut ham with peace of mind. Shop organic sides like stuffing mix and cranberry sauce from 365 Brand. And guess what? All their delectable highs are made with no high fructose corn syrup. Gourmet Thanksgiving flavors with the quality you want, only at Whole Foods Market.
52:05 Speaker 01 With Truvia Sweeteners, it's simple to make sweetness part of your routine. From sweetening your creamy morning matcha to freshly baked blueberry scones, Truvia Sweeteners make it easy to enjoy the flavors you love with less sugar per serving. From everyday drinks to homemade favorites, they're made to fit right in. Because with Truvia, every moment tastes better. Find Truvia at your favorite local grocery retailer and bring better sweetness home.
Previous Aid Worker Kidnapped: Held Hostage in Haiti (Part 1 of 2) Next Race Against Time: Deep in Loch Ness Page updated November 5, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated