Pod Insights The Real Estate Espresso Podcast Small Bay Industrial About this episode Today's show is a talk that I gave last month at the Ottawa Real Estate Investors Organization on Small Bay Industrial. This is a segment that our firm is active in and one that we see as having structural shortages in many major markets across North America.------------------**Real Estate Espresso Podcast:** Spotify: [The Real Estate Espresso Podcast](https://open.spotify.com/show/3GvtwRmTq4r3es8cbw8jW0?si=c75ea506a6694ef1) iTunes: [The Real Estate Espresso Podcast](https://podcasts.apple.com/ca/podcast/the-real-estate-espresso-podcast/id1340482613) Website: [www.victorjm.com](http://www.victorjm.com) LinkedIn: [Victor Menasce](http://www.linkedin.com/in/vmenasce) YouTube: [The Real Estate Espresso Podcast](http://www.youtube.com/@victorjmenasce6734) Facebook: [www.facebook.com/realestateespresso](http://www.facebook.com/realestateespresso) Email: [[email protected] ](mailto:[email protected] ) **Y Street Capital:** Website: [www.ystreetcapital.com](http://www.ystreetcapital.com) Facebook: [www.facebook.com/YStreetCapital](https://www.facebook.com/YStreetCapital) Instagram: [@ystreetcapital](http://www.instagram.com/ystreetcapital)
Transcript 0:01 Speaker 00 Welcome to the Real Estate Espresso Podcast, your morning shot of what's new in the world of real estate investing. I'm your host Victor Manash. This is the weekend edition. We've got a very special show for you today. On today's show, I'm coming to you live from the Ottawa Real Estate Investors Organization where I'm giving a talk on Small Bay Industrial. Enjoy today's talk on Small Bay Industrial.
0:30 Speaker 00 Well, good evening and welcome to Oreo. I'm Victor Manash, President here at Oreo, and we're going to be talking tonight about Small Bay Industrial. But first, let me give you just a little bit of background on myself and my team. I'm the host of the Real Estate Espresso Podcast, daily show seven days a week. If you're not already a listener, I'll put up your hands if you already subscribe to the show. Awesome. Well, thanks for listening. And for those who are not part of the show, it's a daily show seven days a week, just coming up on episode 2700. So I've been doing this a little while. And over here on the right-hand side is a photograph of partners in our team at Y Street Capital. We're a
1:12 Speaker 00 development firm based here in Ottawa, split between Ottawa and the US. Probably the majority of the work that we do is US-based. We do a little bit here in Canada. This is a rendering of a project that we're looking to pull out of the ground later this year in Westboro. And this is an image of, actually just from this morning, of a project up at Mont Tremblant. This is a workforce housing project at Mont Tremblant that the community's been looking for for a long time. We're going to talk about Small Bay Industrial today. And in fact, this is an article from the Ottawa Business Journal. It's actually kind of funny that the picture on the headline of the article is actually a large bay product that was just built in Canada, even though the article is talking about Small Bay, they got the
1:56 Speaker 00 picture wrong. But the point is the same, that Small Bay Industrial is continuing to be a segment that's in hot demand. So let's start by actually defining what it is. Who uses it? Who are the customers for this product? It's your traditional small commercial trades, the plumbers, electricians, landscaping companies, mechanical contractors, siding contractors, all of those sorts of folks. There's even some auto repair, parts fulfillment. These are the typical things that you find in a small bay industrial. We're starting to see some unconventional uses. A new one lately is actually pickleball courts. You often see these being used as small offices for retail, for folks that don't want to pay
2:40 Speaker 00 the exorbitant cost of pure retail space. There are now CrossFit gyms that are coming into this. And then high-value storage, which is kind of an interesting segment. I'll get to that in a moment. If you're looking at small bay industrial, well, let's start by just talking a little bit about what the typical format is. There's typically what looks a little bit like a retail storefront with a commercial door and maybe a window. And then at the back, there'll be a roll-up door to an open space. Some of the older product are single-story buildings. Generally, these are single-story buildings, but ceiling height matters. The newer product is typically going to have a 20-foot ceiling height. Some of the older product that isn't that might be 10, 12-foot ceiling height.
3:25 Speaker 00 In my opinion, is functionally obsolete. You're not going to get as much use out of that shorter ceiling height. And you'd say, "Well, why is that?" It doesn't matter. I mean, people are only six feet tall. Why do you need that much ceiling height? And it has to do with storage. It has to do with the possibility of building a mezzanine level above the front office so that you can get additional functionality. A lot of folks are looking for that. And if you're going to be storing product, getting that additional height matters. When you look at the way these buildings are built, they're typically built slab-on-grate. So you're going to build a foundation down to the footings, and then there's going to be a concrete slab. These buildings have no basement. And so typically, if you look at the cost of industrial...
4:07 Speaker 00 Any kind of industrial product, anywhere between 25 to 30% of the cost of the build is actually going to go into the concrete slab. If you're building something that's got significant height, that's got to carry loads, of course, the concrete slab is going to be thicker and that's going to cost more. But generally speaking, the concrete slab is the number one cost associated with these buildings. If we start to think about comparing small bay and large bay, even in large bay, large bay height matters a lot. Used to be that 27 foot was the standard, then 35 feet became the standard. Now, a lot of brand new buildings are being built with a 40 foot standard. In fact, today, many of the buildings have the rack and stack system associated with
4:52 Speaker 00 carrying pallets that sometimes go up five, six, seven levels. And the rack itself forms part of the structure of the building. They don't support the ceiling on columns anymore. They support, they support the ceiling on the racking that would also support the product. So the way these buildings get put, get put together today is significantly changed over the last few years. And if you've ever walked into one of these facilities and seen a forklift pulling down a pallet that's 35 feet in the air and it's swaying in the wind, it is a precarious looking thing. It's amazing that there aren't any injuries, but that's how they do it. This is where they're really maximizing the, the density per square foot by getting additional height.
5:37 Speaker 00 Because again, it's that concrete slab that is the number one cost. So building additional wall height, additional height in the racks actually doesn't cost you that much. You get a more efficient product with greater ceiling height. So as you're evaluating, if you're looking at large bay, recognize that a 20 foot ceiling height, a 27 foot ceiling height, and a 40 foot ceiling height are not the same product. They would be valued very differently. And when people in this space start quoting Rent per square foot metrics, you need to normalize it based on the ceiling height. You can't just look at rent per square foot. Increasingly, a lot of the small bay product is being used for last mile logistics. Not everything that is delivered through e-commerce gets delivered through the Amazon channel. These are typically inside the urban center. It's a small warehouse.
6:22 Speaker 00 You've got to have excellent access to highways and freeways, and it's got to be low cost. If the goal is to minimize the time to placing an order to fulfillment, those last mile logistics, the location really, really matters. And they don't necessarily need a massive warehouse. They just need proximity at a low cost. Another use for this product is what I call the man cave. The picture here shows a couple of cars with a, with an entertainment area, an informal space for business meetings. And for those who are into collecting cars, they usually collect one too many and the wife says, "Get it out of here. We don't have room." And they will go either purchase or rent a space in a small bay industrial and create
7:05 Speaker 00 an entertainment area and a storage area for their vehicles. It is really a thing now. We see it in Vegas, we see it in Phoenix, we see it in a lot of major cities now where folks that do own exotic vehicles are looking for a place to store their vehicles and have a place to show them off. Sometimes they're kitting out these places to be really well, well finished. In fact, my son, who does some of this kind of work in Calgary, one of his clients owns a Ferrari. The Ferrari is in the garage on a turntable, so you can look at the car from all angles. And my son spray painted the subwoofer for the entertainment area to match the same Ferrari red, so that all, everything tied together.
7:47 Speaker 00 So this is a, a segment that really is getting some attention. If you're playing, if you're looking to play in small bay industrial, you don't necessarily have to start with actually building a building. You could go with a phased approach. That might consist of a covered land play consisting of industrial outdoor storage as phase one, and then later down the road, maybe adding... The vertical construction component to add the actual buildings. There's demand for this product nationwide. The picture I'm showing you here is from down on Bank Street in Ottawa. We just completed construction of one in Winter Haven, Florida. That's in the lease up process right now. And we're about to get started on another one in Bradenton, Florida,
8:31 Speaker 00 which is just right next to Sarasota. In that particular area, this particular site, it's an interesting site because it started out as a charter school. It's a 35 acre site. And the deal is we're going to be skinning down that site and restricting the charter school down to 11 acres. And the remaining acreage is actually going to be, you know, built out for industrial purposes. And we looked at a whole bunch of different products that could go on this acreage, including multifamily apartments and a luxury RV park and all kinds of different things. And of all of the different uses, believe it or not, the highest and best use was actually industrial outdoor storage. That gave us the best yield on a dollar per square foot basis
9:14 Speaker 00 with the minimum investment and fastest time to revenue. And as it turns out, in this particular area of Florida, there's a shortage of industrial land. So the rents that we can get on a per square foot basis are actually off the charts compared to what they might be on a national average basis. Okay, let's go back to Ottawa and look at the Ottawa context. Ottawa, like many cities, has a shortage of land that is zoned industrial. The rents that they're getting are incredibly high. Right now averaging $16.90 per square foot on a triple net basis. That is way above national averages. That's a very high number. We're starting to see large bay moving outside the city just because there isn't that much space
9:57 Speaker 00 within the city boundary that's zoned industrial. For example, Ford Motor Company built a distribution warehouse for parts just outside Castleman. That's a, it's a big facility. I think it's a couple of hundred thousand square feet. It's quite large. And then if you're looking to do something within the city, there are four zonings that would be candidates for this type of product. There's what's called light industrial, there's general industrial, there's business park and rural industrial, those four. I'm going to share with you some metrics. These are more, I'll say, North America-wide numbers. This is not a very scientific survey. It's just my observation of what I'm seeing across a breadth of different markets.
10:37 Speaker 00 We typically see large bay industrial renting anywhere between four to eight dollars per square foot on a triple net basis. Some of the newer product is a little bit higher, especially if it's got the ceiling height. Industrial outdoor storage is renting these days for about three dollars and sixty cents gross per square foot per year. And it's a little more in some areas, a little less in others, but that seems to be about the range. But then you're not building a ton of buildings for industrial outdoor storage. You're, you're building a product that is really suited for that particular customer base. It's fenced yards, it's security, it's electricity, it's, you know, proper drainage, all of those sorts of things. But it's not a very high-cost product to deliver. There's a new category called warehouse on wheels. I'll talk about that in a moment.
11:23 Speaker 00 In fact, just interviewed someone on the podcast who is the owner of a company that specializes in this. If you look at office, for those that are looking to use small bay industrial, office is renting twenty-five to thirty dollars a square foot on a triple net basis. Small bay industrial is going to be much less expensive. So a lot of folks are looking at small bay for that purpose. And then, of course, retail is anywhere in the thirty to fifty-five dollars per square foot on a triple net basis. Small bay by comparison, historically, has been around eight dollars per square foot, so it's been much less expensive. It's more than large bay, but it is less than office and retail. Today, with the shortage in small bay that we're seeing across most markets in North America,
12:07 Speaker 00 we're starting to see rents pushing up around that fourteen dollar per square foot on a triple net basis. So it's still at a discount compared with office and retail, but it's starting to be at a little bit of a premium compared with large bay. So it's an interesting segment. It's filling a gap in the marketplace. For those that are looking to flex space, there is the warehouse on wheels. In fact, this is an opportunity for things that don't have to be necessarily climate-controlled to expand storage capacity. Of course, you know, a trailer on your property doesn't impact your property taxes. These are typically a 30-day commitment, so you rent these on a 30-day basis. You load them up, or you back them up to the loading dock, get the contents in and out
12:50 Speaker 00 with a forklift truck, so it's relatively easy to manage the contents of these trailers. And it's actually better than a shipping container because it's at the height of the loading dock, whereas a shipping container on the ground is much more difficult to get the contents in and out if you're going to have to do that manually versus what you might be doing with a forklift truck. So, most flex space, in fact, some major auto manufacturers, you will look at one of their industrial facilities and you'll see dozens, if not hundreds, of trailers up against the rear fence, and they're holding parts, they're holding inventory and doing it in a very low-cost way without having necessarily to build buildings.
13:31 Speaker 00 This is a segment that's not well-publicized, but is one that, from a practical standpoint, the folks that are actually in this business are using it effectively to keep their costs down. Let me share with you a real development example. This is a 21-acre site that we are developing in Brigham City, Utah. This is just north of Salt Lake City. And I'll take you here to the map to orient you a little bit. We have a number of projects that we're doing in this particular area. We have one that, well, in the whole Pacific Northwest, we have projects up in Boise, in Pocatello, in Logan, in Ogden, in a suburb of Salt Lake called Tooele. We're in Grand Junction, and of course, we have our mega project in Colorado Springs.
14:16 Speaker 00 So, in the immediate Salt Lake area, we have the project in Logan, we have the one in Brigham City, we have the one in Tooele, and then another one in Grantsville. So, we have a few within that radius of Salt Lake City. And Salt Lake is a fast-growing area. It's an area that's interesting from a number of standpoints, starting to see data centers opening up there, although there is pushback from the community, in particular, from the electric utilities, who don't want to necessarily be forced to upgrade their infrastructure for data centers at the expense of the population. But there is definitely a lot of growth in this particular area. One of the key things is something called the inland port.
14:57 Speaker 00 If you might remember back during the pandemic, there was a lot of congestion in the port of Long Beach and the port of LA. And those ports are pretty big, you know, Long Beach is like over 3,000 acres and you would think that's a pretty big port. And it is, but it's just not big enough. I think they can hold like, I don't know, 85 ships at one time or something like that. It's a huge port. The problem is that when the port gets congested, if you need to get the container that's at the bottom of a stack of six, you gotta, you gotta find the space to put the other five containers so you can get the one on the bottom. It just takes a long time. It's very slow. So with the, this innovation called the inland port, the, the port is actually no longer in the Los Angeles area.
15:42 Speaker 00 Under the new process, what happens is a container comes off the ship, it goes immediately on a railcar and it gets shipped to Utah. And that's where the port is, where there's 16,000 acres. And then from there it gets sorted and then distributed to various parts of the country, wherever its final destination may be. So the inland port is an area that's driving a lot of investment, a lot of jobs coming into the immediate area. That's one of many reasons that we happen to be invested in this particular area. Our property in Brigham City also is benefiting from some of this infrastructure investment. So let's dive into the particular property itself. You can see a little bit of a site plan here.
16:22 Speaker 00 You've got a Marriott Hotel in the middle at the bottom there. That's going to be a Town Place Suites Hotel. At the top, there's 104 townhouses. And then on the left-hand side, on the west side there, you see about 60,000 square feet of flex multi-tenant industrial. And so that's, we're building this product in Brigham City on one of our own properties. This is an area where we've seen massive rent growth, huge income growth between 21 and 2022. There was almost 30% year-over-year rent growth nationwide. It's starting to slow and level out a bit. You're not going to see those types of increases forever on an annualized basis.
17:03 Speaker 00 Between 2023 and 2024, the rent growth averaged around 12%. And then so far, in the first quarter of this year, we've seen 2.5% rent growth. If I look at that, and that's US average. If I look at it in the Ottawa context, we saw about 10% rent growth in 2022. We saw 29% rent growth in 2023 and 4.7% growth last year in 2024. There's a whole bunch of value-add strategies that are possible. You can buy existing and increase the value by renewing the leases.
17:43 Speaker 00 You can take some of the existing ones that have small bay offices and market that to office clients that are looking to downsize from other offices. You could remove the offices and return it to an open bay and go after a different tenant. You can look at tenants that need more space and try and consolidate space. You could look at outdoor storage. You can look for retail, for small to medium-sized business. And then another one that's emerging quickly is medical. We're starting to see medical imaging, dialysis labs, testing labs, things like that, looking to occupy this sort of space. That type of business does not need to be on a main street or in a retail space.
18:28 Speaker 00 Someone who's going to that for an appointment, as long as they can get there relatively easily, as long as they can get perhaps public transit to it, as long as the location is good, it doesn't have to be in the most expensive real estate. And that's, that makes this product ideal for that sort of thing. So it's, small bay is one of these products that's in tremendous demand. It fits a gap in the marketplace and it's one that we're actively pursuing within our company. It's one that I think is an opportunity for investors as well. And it's one that we've not talked an awful lot about at Oreo, where, you know, folks tend to be more focused on residential, residential multifamily.
19:10 Speaker 00 This is a segment that I think is not getting enough attention. So with that, I'll bring it to a close and we'll open it to questions. [applause]
Previous Scaling Up with Ashley Garner Next When Economic Adjustments Can Mislead You Page updated November 15, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated