Pod Insights The Real Estate Espresso Podcast Real Estate Is Product Design About this episode Today's show is a recording from a talk I gave earlier this year in New York City. In this talk I am making the assertion that all real estate is the result of designing a product with a specific customer in mind. It's viewing the finished property through the lens of product design with a specific customer in mind. --------------**Real Estate Espresso Podcast:** Spotify: [The Real Estate Espresso Podcast](https://open.spotify.com/show/3GvtwRmTq4r3es8cbw8jW0?si=c75ea506a6694ef1) iTunes: [The Real Estate Espresso Podcast](https://podcasts.apple.com/ca/podcast/the-real-estate-espresso-podcast/id1340482613) Website: [www.victorjm.com](http://www.victorjm.com) LinkedIn: [Victor Menasce](http://www.linkedin.com/in/vmenasce) YouTube: [The Real Estate Espresso Podcast](http://www.youtube.com/@victorjmenasce6734) Facebook: [www.facebook.com/realestateespresso](http://www.facebook.com/realestateespresso) Email: [[email protected] ](mailto:[email protected] ) **Y Street Capital:** Website: [www.ystreetcapital.com](http://www.ystreetcapital.com) Facebook: [www.facebook.com/YStreetCapital](https://www.facebook.com/YStreetCapital) Instagram: [@ystreetcapital](http://www.instagram.com/ystreetcapital)
Transcript 0:01 Speaker 00 Welcome to the Real Estate Especial Podcast. Your morning shot of what's new in the world of real estate investing. I'm your host Victor Manash. This is the weekend edition. We've got a very special show for you today. Today's show is a recording from a talk that I gave in New York City earlier this year. On today's show, we're talking about real estate development through the lens of a product designer. Enjoy today's talk from New York.
0:24 Speaker 01 So, White Street Capital, we're five partners. We're split between the US and Canada. I live in Ottawa, Canada. We're probably 90% US in terms of what we do. We're in nine states. We build multifamily apartments, senior housing, storage, flex multi-tenant industrial, do a fair bit of land development as well. This is our largest project. I think, Matt, you're in this as well. This is in Colorado Springs, 1,783 acres. Perimeter of the property is seven miles. And we just completed, going through planning commission last month. We'll be in front of city council Tuesday night as part of the annexation. And we bought the land, I
1:05 Speaker 01 think, at a reasonable price, 23 cents a square foot. And post-annexation, it should value, I don't know, somewhere in the $3 to $5 a square foot on 77 million square feet. You can do the math. It's a pretty decent lift. We're essentially building a large master plan community. There are a number of different products. The title of today's talk is using market segmentation to define a product. And because of my background in the tech industry, I have a product developer's mindset. I'm always thinking about developing a product for a specific customer. Our immediate neighbor to this property, you can see Pike's Peak,
1:47 Speaker 01 just over my right, my left shoulder there in the background at 14,000 feet. It's a beautiful area. But our immediate neighbor on the other side is Shreve Air Force Base, which is a US Base Command. There's not 50 of those in the country. There's one. And so it's a unique opportunity to create something that is really going to be in support of that critical national
2:10 Speaker 01 Which is US Space Command. And yeah, you know, Mr. Trump has talked about moving Space Command to Huntsville, Alabama. I can promise you, he's not going to be going, you know, to China and saying, you know, can you just pause for like three or four years while we move this to Alabama? This is not going anywhere. This is, this infrastructure soldered into the ground. And, and it's growing. Seven thousand people go through the front gates every day. We've already had discussions with the leadership at Reaver and we know what their, what their shopping list is. So it is a fairly major expansion of the city of Colorado Springs. It'll be about eighty-four hundred rooftops eventually, four different densities of residential,
2:53 Speaker 01 retail, commercial, schools, fire, electric substations, the whole nine yards. Sixty-seven thousand linear feet of, of roadways and so on. Whenever you look at any project, you want to look at three things. This is how we look at it, and I suggest you do so as well. You want to diligence the team. You want to diligence the specific sub-market, and then you look at the specifics of the deal. You want to look at all three of those. Oftentimes, we, we often hear things about, well, this is a great market. Okay, but that's not enough. You really want to break it down. Now, what I'm going to share with you today is a, is a screw-up. And I'll share with you how we reconceived this into what we believe is going to be a successful project from the ashes of a screw-up.
3:38 Speaker 01 So this started out, I'm go, I'm going to go even back further than this slide. This started out as a market rate apartment complex in Spokane, Washington. And it originally was going to be a hundred and fifty units. It was going to be in two phases. Along came the pandemic, along came supply chain constraints, along came interest rates, and then it was just no longer working. The numbers didn't work. So we said, all right, what can we do to fix it? Well, if we do this as a monolithic building, build it out fully to two-hundred-and-fifty-nine units, we ran that as a scenario, yes, we can get the numbers to work. So, okay, great. Re-engage the architecture team, redesign the building, two-hundred-and-fifty-nine units, five stories, et cetera, et cetera. We got, we got a winner. And it was good. It was good.
4:22 Speaker 01 But in today's environment, if you got anything from From the talk just before lunch, "Good is not good enough in the current capital environment. It's not good enough." And so, we were struggling to raise the capital. And it was a good project. It just wasn't a great project. So, in order for something to work in today's environment, it's gotta be a great project. Even with all those other things, it's a very, very tough environment right now. So, we said, "All right, what do we do?" With any project, you really only have three variables to play with. You've got rents, you've got the cost of capital, and the cost of construction. And how many of those do you control? Like, none. Zero. So, what do you do? You don't set interest rates.
5:06 Speaker 01 You don't control the construction costs, although maybe you can, maybe within 5% by doing some value engineering, but you're not really moving the needle in a big way. And you don't control the rent. That's it. So, what do you do? So, we looked at the income side, because we thought that had potential. Because now, we're thinking more like product developers. If you view... My mentor, one of my mentors, a gentleman, Dr. Nito Kubain, says something that I absolutely love. I carry it with me every day. And he says, "When the value is unclear..." You'll wanna write this down. "When the value is unclear, the discussion always degenerates to price." "When the value is unclear, the discussion always degenerates to price." That's the definition of a commodity.
5:51 Speaker 01 If gasoline is five cents cheaper across the street, you don't care if you're buying from Sunoco or Mobil, you'll go across the street. That's a commodity. It's price-driven. "If the value is unclear, the discussion always degenerates to price." And I often get in conversations with folks, where they start talking to me about price, and it immediately clicks in my head, "Oh, shoot, they don't get the value. They really don't understand what this is all about." And that's where we need to take the conversation back to, is understanding the value. That's foundational. Now, one of the observations we made is that a market rate apartment, you know, would be, I don't know, anywhere from 1,300 to 1,900 a month in rent. In a brand-new building, we looked at market comp, so we knew what...
6:35 Speaker 01 With some confidence what the numbers were. But independent living is pricing at forty five hundred a month. That's a big gap. Why are they able to command such a higher price? Yes, there's a whole lot more services in there, but that's a much higher price. So is there something between, call it seventeen hundred a month and forty five hundred a month that could be explored? Is there some opportunity to fill that gap? That was the question that we took ourselves through. So let's just talk about positioning. Talk about senior housing. We've built senior housing. You go through this progression based on acuity, based on needs, from independent living to assisted living to memory care to skilled nursing,
7:20 Speaker 01 and then maybe hospice. But you go through this progression. And what is filling that gap right now is this kind of brand new segment called active adult. Sometimes called concierge. It is, it's a gap filler. It's not independent living. You're not getting meals served cafeteria style. So there's no meal service. You don't have the transportation to the mall or to your doctors. You don't have all those other things that you would have in independent living. But it's a step between a market rate apartment. It's age restricted. It's got a bunch of other things. And it starts to fill that gap. So we started to look at this particular space.
8:02 Speaker 01 So first thing is active adult is amenities rich, really focuses on community. One of the things that happens in our society is that we often get disconnected. And that's only become amplified with the amount of time that people spend in front of a screen, especially if the screen is, you know, the size of the palm of your hand. We get very disconnected. And as people get older, there's a very high proportion of older, single people. If we look at the makeup of residents in the active adult segment, it's thirty percent couples, seventy percent single people. Of the singles, women outnumber men six to one. For those older guys, just a, just a hint. So.
8:45 Speaker 01 There's a lot more services that come with this, but it really centers around community. And what makes these communities work is a lot of activity, a lot of social activity, a lot of connection, a lot of friendships. It's part of the reason why these communities are age restricted. It's not a lot of this in the nation. Only 73,000 units of active adult in the entire country, which on a population of 340 million is a drop in the bucket. Yeah, it's in about 45 states. It's not even in every state. So we started looking at this and we said, you know, that we think this has potential. There's a lot of amenities. It's a very amenities-rich product. So some of them can require special purpose things, like an indoor resort-style pool. You've got to build that.
9:29 Speaker 01 But you don't need a dedicated quilting room. That can be in a multipurpose room. That can be, you know, you can repurpose, multipurpose space to hold many different types of activities. And then, of course, some need to be dedicated. The gym needs to be dedicated. The yoga studio, not necessarily. So it's just a lot of amenities that get built into this. Let's just talk about, talk numbers here. So when we look at some of the neighboring property in the market, a lot of the buildings in the market are what we call three-story woody walk-ups. This building was going to be unique in that it already had elevators designed into it. If you're downsizing from a detached, single-family home, nobody wants to carry their groceries up three or four flights of stairs. Nobody, I don't care who you are.
10:10 Speaker 01 Already having the elevators set the building apart, but that wasn't enough. Remember, we had a good product, not a great product. So we looked at our rent. We said, you know, we'll match the guys next door, you know, dollar for dollar in terms of rent. The rent per square foot was coming in around $1.92 bucks a square foot, so we were in the right range. Our unit sizes were similar, so we felt like we had the right, the right metrics. But again, it wasn't good enough. We looked at independent living and said, what is this delta between 1,500 a month and 4,500 a month, plus an extra 850 for the second occupant? But a lot of that's bound up in these extra services, like the meal services, which we would not provide. So then what happens if we look at act-
10:54 Speaker 01 Active adult and we start to compare. We used numbers from the competitors in the market. There's another competitor called Affinity. Has two buildings in the market, they're full. One's two and a half miles away, the other one's 12 and a half miles away. And we basically looked at their units. We secret shopped. We sent our staff and secret shopped those facilities. So we got to see them behind the scenes. A person we had doing the secret shopping for us was actually a traveling nurse. She was able to talk with the staff on another level. It was, it was really, really good. We got great intelligence. And we said, well, you know, we can, with the addition of a few services, without a major redesign of the building, we can get a whole lot more rent.
11:36 Speaker 01 But it's designing a product, not a building, a product for a very specific customer. See the difference? Let's talk about the local context. So that's the site with the, the red dot. We've got a bunch of assisted living around us. And we're kind of bookended with assisted living and independent living. We've got a Walmart Supercenter across from Interstate 90. We've got Bella Test, which is one of those Class A multi-story woody walk-ups. We're in a good area. We know that the demographics are good. But we don't, there isn't a lot of active adult in the immediate area. So what do we do? So we took the design of a building. It had a lot of parking, which you would need. You need a parking ratio 1.75 for a market rate apartment.
12:19 Speaker 01 You don't need that much parking for active adult, especially when 70% of your folks are single. So we could actually reduce the parking and use some of that space for outdoor amenities space. We could add the pickleball courts. We could add the dog park. We could add more things in the property. We, we realized that we lacked storage. If you're downsizing from a detached home, you need place to store your stuff. So you actually need more storage lockers in the building. So what we did is we took the two bedroom units, a portion of them. We took about two, two bedroom units on each floor. And we cut off the second bedroom, added a second entrance to the, the hallway and put a bank of 10 storage lockers. So now you have storage.
13:05 Speaker 01 On every floor of the building, you don't even have to get in the elevator if you want to go get a box of photos or whatever that's in a storage locker. So thinking through this whole process. And then the last thing we did is we started engaging with the number one operator of active adult in the nation. And no surprise, they're also the number one operator of apartments in the nation. That's Graystar. So Graystar has about 100, do you remember Robbie, is it 140 or 170 properties? Something in that range. So they're the number one operator of active adult. And so we engaged them to actually do a third-party market study for us so that we weren't just relying on our own analysis.
13:47 Speaker 01 We were working with folks that were really deeply immersed in this, have done this repeatedly. And that's in fact who we've selected when this is finished construction to actually operate it for us. We considered building our own brand. I think the first project that comes out with this, we were using one of the Graystar brands, a brand called Elate. And then if we decide to do five or six or 10 of these, maybe we'll develop our own brand later on. But we're going to start with the Elate brand that's already got proven, got a proven track record and by virtue, again, not having any ego around it, bringing someone that is clearly institutional quality. As soon as I say to a lender that Graystar is going to be the operator, it's a short
14:32 Speaker 01 conversation. They're not asking us a million due diligence questions. They say, can you send us the Claritas report? They even know what the report is called. They just know. Makes a whole lot of due diligence conversations disappear.
Previous Market Selection with Jason Hartman Next Diligence On A Property With Insurance Claim History Page updated November 15, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated