Pod Insights The Real Estate Espresso Podcast Looking Into The Future with Robby Butler About this episode Robby Butler is Managing Director at Y Street Capital. He's based in St. Louis plays a key role in our company. On today's show we are talking about how real estate trends are affecting long term strategies of investing. To connect with Robby , visit https://www.linkedin.com/in/robby-butler/ or at https://ystreetcapital.com---------------**Real Estate Espresso Podcast:** Spotify: [The Real Estate Espresso Podcast](https://open.spotify.com/show/3GvtwRmTq4r3es8cbw8jW0?si=c75ea506a6694ef1) iTunes: [The Real Estate Espresso Podcast](https://podcasts.apple.com/ca/podcast/the-real-estate-espresso-podcast/id1340482613) Website: [www.victorjm.com](http://www.victorjm.com) LinkedIn: [Victor Menasce](http://www.linkedin.com/in/vmenasce) YouTube: [The Real Estate Espresso Podcast](http://www.youtube.com/@victorjmenasce6734) Facebook: [www.facebook.com/realestateespresso](http://www.facebook.com/realestateespresso) Email: [[email protected] ](mailto:[email protected] ) **Y Street Capital:** Website: [www.ystreetcapital.com](http://www.ystreetcapital.com) Facebook: [www.facebook.com/YStreetCapital](https://www.facebook.com/YStreetCapital) Instagram: [@ystreetcapital](http://www.instagram.com/ystreetcapital)
Transcript 0:02 Speaker 00 Welcome to the Real Estate Espresso Podcast, your morning shot of what's new in the world of real estate investing. I'm your host Victor Manash. This is the weekend edition where we interview notable people from the world of real estate investing. Today is no exception. We have a great guest all the way from St. Louis. Welcome to the show Robby Butler.
0:17 Speaker 01 It's great to be back Victor. Good to see you today.
0:19 Speaker 00 Well, great to have you here. Now Robbie, you are Managing Director here at Y Street Capital, and thought it would be kind of cool to take a look into the distant future, perhaps even a little bit over the horizon, at some of the things that underpin the strategies within our company. They form part of that foundation. And but maybe before we dive into that, give maybe a very short backstory and how you got here.
0:45 Speaker 01 Sure. When I joined Y Street years ago, I knew that one of the things that I was best at was working with investors. It was what I loved. It is still what I love. It's core to everything that I do. I think about, are my relationships better because they knew me? It's a basic principle, one of those things you reflect back on constantly. But I also have always found myself in leadership positions because I enjoy that as well. Part of those relationships is, are we all pointed in the same direction? Are we thinking about things from a consensus or from a clear group agreement that this is the direction, our ship is sailing? And are we all driving this or are we all paddling in the same direction?
1:29 Speaker 01 So the leadership roles I've had over time have all come because of that kind of the group thinking that I worked to do. Are we all talking the same language? Are we all marching in the same direction? The efforts pursuing? And as I grew in our organization and took opportunities that were given to me for little leadership roles and larger leadership roles, it brought me to Managing Director today. And it's where we're going in this conversation about that long-term trajectory, because there are some things that are just baked into technological development across human history. The way real estate has transacted over the last, let's call it 200 years since the first title companies appeared, all these things are pointing towards the evolution of the industry. And
2:13 Speaker 01 it's when you start to see it for what it is, you can't unsee it.
2:17 Speaker 00 Absolutely. Now, you glossed over one thing that maybe if folks haven't met you before, you mentioned talking to investors. Now, you started raising capital specifically for philanthropy as a teenager. That's not a typical career path. So maybe just a little bit about that so that people can connect the dots on that.
2:37 Speaker 01 Sure. I was fortunate that when I was in high school, I had a mentor who was in the world of philanthropic development. And the more I learned from him, the more I realized that's a fascinating industry. You meet people, you travel, you understand their philanthropic goals, and look to find places to put that money to work, to put that charity to work in ways that are meaningful for them and for society together. And that was my whole career, and I thought I would never leave it. But I also had the entrepreneurial spark that is very annoying. Once it starts to kick, like the engine, the spark plug goes and a whole lot happens once it goes. And so that is, long story short, that's how I transitioned
3:19 Speaker 01 into first real estate and then into my work with Y Street Capital. But that philanthropic background taught me first, simply to be a listener and to look for connections that may not be obvious. You know, people think raising money is find a good deal and put money into it. There's so much more to that. And reading your book 10 years, or not 10 years, probably eight years ago, was what helped me to realize there are good principles for this as well. So a long time ago, but been special ever since.
3:47 Speaker 00 Love it. So as we look forward, there's a few inexorable truths, you can call them trends if you want, that kind of underpin everything that is core to being a real estate investor, being a real estate developer. I think back, for example, I interviewed the author of a book that was the history of Irvine Ranch, which is now the modern city of Irvine, California. And the financial model for that, at its inception, bore no resemblance to what it ultimately looked like the day that it incorporated almost 90 years later. There's just no way. You couldn't even value the dollar on the On an equivalent basis. And, and so a lot changes over that time period.
4:33 Speaker 00 We often, you know, today, we have a, a set of market conditions where the market is clearly saying, well, don't count on quite so much rent growth in the future. But what do you think? Is rent growth stalled or is it here to stay?
4:49 Speaker 01 Right. There's a great chart from the St. Louis Fed that I used to refer to all the time when I was first entering into real estate, which showed rent growth linearly tracking up. It sometimes flatlined, sometimes paused for years on end, but it never, especially from an industry-wide perspective, it never dropped down significantly enough to ever move nationwide rent growth average down. Rent growth always trended upwards, meaning like 100 years, 200 years, always trended upwards. And that is also here to stay in the same reason that you described. Yes, little markets may move little pieces down. You may see temporary rent growth, but the trajectory is clear in the same ways you're describing.
5:31 Speaker 00 Just this past week in the Wall Street Journal was reported that New York City is proposing to raise minimum wage up to $30 per hour. And the folks who are going to be the beneficiaries of that are going to feel great for a little while, but only a little while because it's just another step in that spiral.
5:51 Speaker 01 Yep. The discussion that I think is worth always hearkening to when talking about long-term trends is similar to that. The economic underpinnings, we know where the dollar moves. We know where, where values adjust, but on a dollar basis, your, your comparisons have to be made clear. Are we comparing it just based on the dollar? Because the dollar is a moving landscape as well. There is another trend that I'm excited to talk through today, which is to me the most important real estate specific trend to be measured. And that is the movement towards efficiency in the real estate marketplace. Efficiency from an economic sense, the ability to transact quickly with less friction.
6:34 Speaker 01 The, the ways that friction appears in real estate are obvious. Right now, a buyer knows something a seller doesn't. A seller knows something a buyer doesn't. An agent knows something that neither of them know. And maybe it's just that they're both gonna do the deal and the agent's gonna make the margin. But the point is, as we move towards efficiency, real estate will have changes in its fundamental economic operation that will be fascinating to behold and will also produce some fantastic returns over time. So I am excited to get into this.
7:06 Speaker 00 It used to be the case that people held key positions because they had unique information that nobody else did. And that information is power concept was prevalent. Today, in the world of AI, a lot of those walls are being broken down and just completely obliterated.
7:25 Speaker 01 Obliterated. The information age is moving into the artificial intelligence age. And you could say, okay, that's a technical description, that's a technical line. But three years ago, any AI tool you picked up could not do what it can do today. Absolutely non-negotiable. Some of the financial analysis, some of the underwriting work, some of the graphic descriptions, some of the actual graphics that can be produced were impossible to do, and that's only three years. So technology is moving forward. And that is a long-term trend that has to be acknowledged when you talk about the movement towards efficiency. Technology is the long-term trend for civilization.
8:08 Speaker 01 But specifically for real estate, moving towards efficiency is because of what technology will be able to do. We could highlight components of the industry here. Robotics entering construction. Suddenly you have cheaper costs of labor that never gets tired. Networking functions, the ability to know what a market or what a sentiment is saying. You know, we say, oh, like banks are scared. Well, that suddenly is going to become a much more knowable thing when you can see all banks, all private banks, interest rate policies, all at the same time. And you understand, well, is that a true statement or is that a generalization? What's the specific insight? On a group of people on a, an industry, that's all knowable information because it's more efficient.
8:53 Speaker 01 As the world keeps turning, we move towards tokenization, the blockchain. Suddenly, every transaction you can see all in one ledger, meaning going back to the, the first time you built the multifamily project. Well, how many times has it been sold since then? All on one ledger, crystal clear. That type of information is just now entering the marketplace. But when it's prevalent, we have efficiency. And what does that really mean? It means that you'll be able to buy and sell faster, more liquidity will be in real estate, which really means more money will be in real estate because less people will be scared of doing so.
9:28 Speaker 00 So, I mean, if I think about the things that drive liquidity, it's the fact that, you know, it still takes forty five to ninety days to get a loan approved. You know, it doesn't matter, it doesn't matter who the borrower is, that's just the process. So that obviously affects the liquidity. It doesn't matter if you can transact in two hours or ten seconds, you still have ninety days in front of that. You know, that, that's an element to the friction. Do you see things happening that will collapse those timeframes?
10:02 Speaker 01 Absolutely. Here's an easy example. A bank asks for your documentation. Well, then the underwriter at the bank reads through it manually. I gave a talk at the Texas Bankers Association two weeks ago to a group of people who were by and large not yet adopting AI. They're in a heavily regulated, very strict industry. Their recommendation from FINRA and the SEC is to use AI to summarize things for them. That is like a toe in the water of what AI can do. But suddenly, AI is now available to summarize a lender's application. That's better for a banker than sitting there for three hours, reading through your personal financial statement.
10:44 Speaker 01 That is a mark of efficiency. But imagine when a bank says, yes, AI will do the first level of underwriting. You're saving days off of a forty five day transaction, purely because the banker's not checking his email, it's occurring automatically. In the back end. So we've taken forty five days. We've shrunk it to forty one. That's a ten percent reduction. You let AI go a little further, underwrite the property, do the do the structural analysis, do the review of components, look through other elements of the application to get a loan. You're down another ten percent and another ten percent. This is the march towards efficiency.
11:22 Speaker 00 Absolutely. I see it, for example, when you're going through and validating a construction budget. Today, the inspector is doing that in a very manual process. There can be literally hundreds of line items. We just went through one ourselves with seven hundred and twenty line items. And that's an intensely manual process. An AI tool can make short work of that by simply validating a lot of just removing a lot of the noise. And yes, you still need to put your eyes on it, but if you apply the eighty twenty rule and apply that your effort to that twenty percent that really requires attention. You don't need to spend, you know, an awful lot
12:03 Speaker 00 of effort validating that the bank withdrew their whatever ten dollars a month charged to to keep the bank account open every month. That has not a lot of value added for the quantity surveyor to to validate that line item. There are things that are far more important. And so it can really collapse those types of timeframes.
12:23 Speaker 01 A real estate investor, like the listener on this podcast typically is, knows that real estate is hard for an outsider. So we're over that hurdle with you, the listener, already. But imagine what that's like when you are making your first real estate investment, like go back twenty or thirty years to when you first bought a property. That is a big learning curve. And all of this that we're talking about, this move towards efficiency, is lowering that learning curve, which for some people, they might, you know, hold on clutching your pearls. Oh, no, we we're going to have more entrance into real estate. But the fact of the matter is, that's coming. And it means that that efficiency means there will be more people putting money.
13:07 Speaker 01 After deals, which for the current owners of real estate is a very good thing. And for the future means, yes, that efficiency will cause faster transactions, but we will see deal timelines close. You will no longer be have an uncertain hold period in the majority of asset classes because pricing will be efficient. People will know this is worth paying this dollar figure for this single family rental. Or this plot of land uh in in the heart of Dallas, or this plot of land in the middle of Arkansas. All of that will be much more knowable, which will mean more people will be willing to pay prices. And for the existing owners, they'll get a better cap rate, meaning a lower cap rate because of that money movement being easier. Just examples of that.
13:51 Speaker 00 Today, if we want to participate in a in an investment, that's typically done through a syndication, unless it happens to be a public offering like a REIT. And and that's shares in a in an LLC or some kind of investment vehicle. There is a lot of discussion where Wall Street is looking to fractionalize ownerships of single family homes and allow people to buy 10% of grandma's homestead. And that's new, that that's not really here yet, but if that happens, that will change the landscape. It will make just nuts and bolts real estate available on a very, very large scale that doesn't exist today.
14:32 Speaker 01 And imagine the way that this has happened in other markets. Did efficiency in the 1950s through the 1980s improve the stock market? That's an open question, but it definitely improved the traders sitting on the floor waving their paper. That is no longer an active method to transact stocks. And capital moves much faster. And because of that same efficiency, stock market prices move up. Like we said at the beginning of the podcast, you also have an issue with the dollar that is underpinning all of this, which needs to be thought of very carefully, but to keep it simple, that level of efficiency in the stock market allows people to feel more comfortable, even if stock market value.
15:17 Speaker 01 Are completely unhinged as a as a typical metric, you know, a price to earnings, et cetera. But the efficiency piece is is clear there. You don't need to call your stockbroker any longer. What happens?
15:31 Speaker 00 Well, that and even just think about, you know, an ounce of silver, an ounce of gold. Yes, you can still line up at the counter and walk away with a wad full of mid full of cash for for that ounce of gold. But that's not the way most gold is transacted today.
15:44 Speaker 01 Yeah.
15:45 Speaker 00 Most of it is transacted as a paper certificate.
15:47 Speaker 01 So imagine the world where suddenly you want to sell one of your single family homes and it takes three days because you don't need to call an agent and sign a listing agreement. You just put it out there and immediately syndicated by some Wall Street firm that has targeted Atlanta as its geography. That is efficiency. Three day transaction is not just because of an all cash buyer anymore. It's because the market has all the functions able to close the transaction within itself.
16:13 Speaker 00 So if I look at how industries evolve, for example, let's talk about electric vehicles. That started really at one segment of the market, the luxury segment of the market, and then worked its way down. Where do you think it's going to happen in real estate first? Is this going to be in commercial real estate or residential?
16:30 Speaker 01 Oh, that is a good question. It already is more prevalent in residential purely because of the number of buyers. So that is one piece that has to be acknowledged that the number of buyers in single family rentals means that typically that's considered slightly more liquid. I would, I would say it probably will march fairly equivalently because there's more dollars to be made in the commercial sector, but there's more buyers in the residential sector. So my inkling is it will probably happen in an equivalent basis in fits and starts over a longer time period than what we currently account for.
17:10 Speaker 00 Love it. Well, Robbie, fascinating conversation. If folks want to connect, if they want to connect with Wall Street Capital, what's the best way?
17:17 Speaker 01 Find me on LinkedIn. We'd be delighted to keep up the conversation with you. My LinkedIn profile, we talk about these things all day long, or reach out to us at YStreetCapital.com.
17:27 Speaker 00 Love it. Robbie, always great to connect for this time for the listeners. I get to talk to you multiple times a day within the company. For listeners at home, definitely reach out to Robby Butler at YStreetCapital.com or connect with him on LinkedIn. The links will be in the show notes. And in the meantime, have an awesome rest of your weekend. Go make some great things happen. We'll talk to you again tomorrow.
Previous Stagflation Will Be Back Next Asking Better Strategic Questions Page updated November 14, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated