Pod Insights The Real Estate Espresso Podcast Beginner Series on Underwriting About this episode On today’s show we are doing another in the beginner series. The Real Estate Espresso Podcast is unlike other podcasts in that most others are focused on a more entry level audience. Our listeners are sophisticated. Many of you own large portfolios of apartments. But you also have people in your life who are interested in learning more, but maybe don’t have access to high quality information. The idea of sending your spouse to a $199 weekend bootcamp for beginners where they are going to be abused by sleazy sales people sounds unthinkable. So where do they go. Look no further. We are going to dedicate a couple of shows a month to topics that will accelerate the learning for less experienced investors, and might give the most sophisticated investors a new way of explaining a concept that is otherwise complex to describe. Today’s show is focused on underwriting where I’m reviewing the underwriting from a new investor who is looking at their first multi-family acquisition. There are numerous pitfalls in underwriting which unless you have the experience, you don’t know what you don’t know. This project is the first syndication for them and they don’t have experience having put together a compliant offering. ------------**Real Estate Espresso Podcast:** Spotify: [The Real Estate Espresso Podcast](https://open.spotify.com/show/3GvtwRmTq4r3es8cbw8jW0?si=c75ea506a6694ef1) iTunes: [The Real Estate Espresso Podcast](https://podcasts.apple.com/ca/podcast/the-real-estate-espresso-podcast/id1340482613) Website: [www.victorjm.com](http://www.victorjm.com) LinkedIn: [Victor Menasce](http://www.linkedin.com/in/vmenasce) YouTube: [The Real Estate Espresso Podcast](http://www.youtube.com/@victorjmenasce6734) Facebook: [www.facebook.com/realestateespresso](http://www.facebook.com/realestateespresso) Email: [[email protected] ](mailto:[email protected] ) **Y Street Capital:** Website: [www.ystreetcapital.com](http://www.ystreetcapital.com) Facebook: [www.facebook.com/YStreetCapital](https://www.facebook.com/YStreetCapital) Instagram: [@ystreetcapital](http://www.instagram.com/ystreetcapital)
Transcript 0:02 Speaker 00 Welcome to the Real Estate Espresso Podcast, your morning shot of what's new in the world of real estate investing. I'm your host Victor Manash. Today is another show in our beginner series. The Real Estate Espresso Podcast is unlike other podcasts in that most others are focused on more of an entry level audience. Our listeners are sophisticated. Many of you own large portfolios of apartments, but you also have people in your life who are interested in learning more. Maybe they don't have access to high quality information. The idea of sending your spouse or a family member to a $199 weekend bootcamp for beginners, where they're going to be abused by sleazy salespeople just sounds unthinkable. So where do they go? Well, look no further. We're going to dedicate a couple of shows a month to topics that will accelerate the learning for less experienced investors and might give the most sophisticated investors a new way of
0:46 Speaker 00 explaining a concept that's otherwise complex to describe. Today's show is focused on underwriting, where I've reviewed the underwriting for a new investor who's looking at their very first multifamily acquisition. There are numerous pitfalls in underwriting, which unless you have the experience, you don't know what you don't know. This particular project is the first syndication for them and they don't have the experience having put together a compliant offering. They also don't have the experience of knowing what are realistic numbers for a project. The spreadsheet being used is clearly from an education company. The entire analysis is concentrated in a couple of sheets within the Excel workbook. There's simply not enough granularity to contemplate the breadth of elements in analyzing a multifamily apartment building. Here are some of the rookie mistakes
1:30 Speaker 00 that are readily apparent in the analysis. Number one, starts with the financing. A syndication is not a joint venture. A joint venture is a true joint venture where all of the parties are putting in money, time, effort, management into the project. If any one of those folks are passive, then it's a syndication because at that point you are selling a security and you have to be compliant with securities regulations. It's not going to cost $3,000 to put together the paperwork. The legal paperwork for syndication is anywhere between $15,000 to $20,000, not $3,000. Number two, there's nothing budgeted for unit turnover or leasing commissions. This is different from repairs and maintenance. You need to model the percentage turnover each year and include the cost of a unit turn,
2:15 Speaker 00 including cleaning, painting, carpet replacement, fixing broken blinds and so on. That's different than maintenance. This is somewhere between 1,000 to 2,000 a unit as a minimum. And unless the unit turn can be done in one day, you're likely to incur one month of vacancy between tenants. If you pay a leasing commission, also one month of rent, then each unit turn, even if you get it done quickly, is going to cost you two months of economic vacancy. And I don't think this is properly modeled in the vacancy allowance. So if, let's say you assume that a quarter of the building turns over every year, even that's a fairly aggressive assumption, you need to budget for the fact that you're going to have four and a half percent economic vacancy, just with leasing commissions and unit turn costs. And that's assuming you get things leased very quickly.
3:01 Speaker 00 Next is title insurance. Title insurance is going to be way more than $500 based on the value of the property. You're also going to need to buy a lender's title insurance policy. So it's not just the title insurance policy on closing, but you're going to need to buy a title insurance policy for the benefit of the lender. Next, we have the loan structure. This is going to be a government-backed loan with the Canada Mortgage Housing Corporation, and they have new premiums associated with their loans. These premiums are added to the loan amount. So for example, if CMHC is charging a 6% premium, they're going to increase the total loan by 6%. The formula for calculating the premium is complicated depending on which loan product you're using, the amortization period, and the loan-to-cost ratio. Now, what's strange about this is that CMHC does not include the premium
3:46 Speaker 00 in their qualification criteria, even though it's actually going to impact your cash flow. So my recommendation is that you treat it as if it's part of the loan, and you include the fact that it is a real loan cost. Otherwise, you'll end up in a situation where you have negative cash flow. And in that instance, the lender may actually let you do it. Next, there was nothing budgeted for cleaning and upkeep of common areas. If you've got a multi-unit building, you will have hallways and entrances and all of those sorts of things that do need to be maintained on a regular basis. It's not the property manager's job to do that. You're going to hire separate cleaning staff for that. And it needs to be budgeted for. Next, the budget for utilities seems way off, especially for electricity and water. It was hard to tell from the analysis whether you're expecting the tenants to pay utilities,
4:31 Speaker 00 whether the units in the building are submetered or not, or whether you're planning on using a rubs method. But there needs to be an allowance for common area utilities as a minimum, and the numbers for the utilities per unit on a per unit basis need to be much more realistic. They probably need to be more than double what's currently in the analysis. Next, the financial model shows that the building is renting below market. And so the question in my mind is, how do you know that? Where is the third-party market study to show what market rents really are? And are the rents that are being called market rents, are they really comparable buildings, similar-sized properties with no amenities? I often see people comparing what you could get for a top-end property with what they're currently getting and treating that as if it's the market average.
5:15 Speaker 00 It's not the average, that's the top of the market. So you want to look at where you are relative to the middle of the market, or at least as a minimum, comparable properties within a small radius of the current property. Next, there is nothing in the financial model for loan origination fees. That's going to be somewhere between 2% to 3% of the loan amount, which needs to be added to the closing cost. Typically, that's going to be 1% for the commercial broker and 1% for the lender, maybe 1.5% for the lender, depending on the loan amount. That needs to be factored in, and in a commercial loan, the closing cost from the lender will also include the legal fees for the lender to draft the legal documents. That can be a significant amount of money. I'm finding the loan closing cost to be significantly under-reported in the financial model. Next, I saw a reference to possibly doing short-term rentals.
6:00 Speaker 00 You're not going to be paying 8% or 9% in management fees for short-term rentals. You should expect to pay somewhere between 25% to 30% in management fees for short-term rentals. That's something that needs to be part of the budget. A short-term rental business is very different than a long-term rental business. It's much more management-intensive because you have a move-out and a move-in every couple of days as opposed to every couple of years. So the costs are going to be significantly higher for short-term rentals. Next, there was nothing in the budget for accounting and bookkeeping. These are real costs. Associated with a project that are unique to the project. Even just the tax return alone for that single entity is going to cost you 2,000 bucks on the best day ever. That needs to be part of your budget. When I add in all the real world costs associated with running a project like this,
6:44 Speaker 00 without anything extraordinary happening like a bad tenant, what was originally a project generating about 40,000 a year in cash flow will in fact experience negative cash flow. Of course, the lender won't allow you to build a project with negative cash flow. So that's going to mean lowering the loan amount, increasing correspondingly the equity contribution. So instead of a loan at 80% loan to value or 80% loan to cost, the lender is going to limit the loan to meet their debt coverage requirements. So instead of 80% loan to value, the actual loan is going to be limited to about 65% loan to value in order to meet the debt coverage requirements. Now, in this case, the remaining cash flow at the end of the day is not going to be anywhere near 40 grand a year. It's going to be right at that debt coverage minimum at about 15,000 a year.
7:28 Speaker 00 I felt it was important to take you through the thought process of analyzing the property in a much more realistic manner. These are the types of questions an experienced underwriter will be asking of themselves. And most rookie investors end up underwriting a far too optimistic picture. As you think about that, have an awesome rest of your day. Go make some great things happen. We'll talk to you again tomorrow.
Previous How Has A Career In Investing Change With AI? Next When Do Government Denials Become Unlawful? Page updated November 15, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated