On the Media: American Emergency

A little while back, our friends over at On the Media released a gripping and immersive reporting series about FEMA, the agency that is supposed to be there for all of us in the wake of disaster. In American Emergency (https://zpr.io/MtrUmJU3yEMW), OTM investigates how the agency tasked with saving America became distrusted, despised… and defunded. Today we talk to On the Media co-host Micah Loewinger about how this project came out, what reporting went into making it happen, and play a couple of fun and truly surprising bits of the story that the OTM team uncovered. And it’s a story that highlights the ideal and promise of good government, right alongside the frustration with bureaucracy and mismanagement, and of course the undercurrent of profound mistrust in governmental power. As natural disasters are getting more extreme and less predictable, this series makes sense of that tangle, and provides a prescient peek into FEMA’s future. Special thanks to On the Media. To hear Micah in person, talking more about the complex history of FEMA, join him on June 24th at WNYC's The Greene Space (https://wnyc.org/events/otm-fema). Signup for our newsletter!! It includes short essays, recommendations, and details about other ways to interact with the show. Sign up (https://radiolab.org/newsletter)! Radiolab is supported by listeners like you. Support Radiolab by becoming a member of The Lab (https://members.radiolab.org/) today. Follow our show on Instagram, Twitter and Facebook @radiolab, and share your thoughts with us by emailing [email protected]. Leadership support for Radiolab’s science programming is provided by the Simons Foundation and the John Templeton Foundation. Foundational support for Radiolab was provided by the Alfred P. Sloan Foundation.

• 0:01Speaker 00

  Radiolab is supported by AT&T. We all love to connect via video calls or texts. Right now, at AT&T, you can get the new iPhone 18 Pro for $0 with iPhone Trade-In, any condition. It has the ultimate pro camera system and big leap in battery life, so you can turn this deal into a long-lasting connection. Learn how you can trade in your iPhone for the new iPhone 18 Pro. Requires trade-in of iPhone 14 or higher, excluding iPhone 16e and eligible plan. Terms and restrictions apply, subject to change. Visit an AT&T store for details.

• 0:38Speaker 01

  Wait, you're listening?

• 0:40Speaker 02

  Okay.

• 0:41Speaker 01

  All right.

• 0:42Speaker 03

  Okay.

• 0:43Speaker 01

  All right.

• 0:45Speaker 03

  You're listening to Radiolab.

• 0:48Speaker 01

  Radiolab.

• 0:48Speaker 03

  From...

• 0:49Speaker 01

  WNYC. See?

• 0:56Speaker 00

  This is Radiolab. I'm Latif Nasser. And to state the obvious, we here at the show are normal, human people, mostly, even occasionally civically-minded people. So there are stories and topics, especially newsy sorts of things, that we think are important and that we care about, but they're just not the kind of thing we usually cover. And when something is going on that we feel that way about, often our friends over at On The Media are covering it, and then we realize, oh, this is even more interesting and strange and tricky than we thought. And that was the case recently with a series of episodes they did about the Federal Emergency Management Agency, or FEMA, which, under the current administration, has been fighting for its very existence.

• 1:39Speaker 04

  I'll also be signed in as executive order to begin the process of fundamentally reforming and overhauling FEMA, or maybe getting rid of FEMA.

• 1:47Speaker 00

  The series they put together is a deeply researched and reported dive into the agency's origins, its troubled history over the last few decades, and it's also a prescient peek into its uncertain future.

• 1:59Speaker 04

  It just complicates it. I think we're going to recommend that FEMA go away.

• 2:04Speaker 00

  The series sprung from the mind of On The Media co-host, Michael Lowenjer.

• 2:09Speaker 05

  Okay, here I am.

• 2:10Speaker 00

  Congratulations.

• 2:12Speaker 05

  Thank you.

• 2:12Speaker 00

  God, you've been working on this for a really long time. So today, we're going to play some excerpts from that series. We're going to talk to Michael about his reporting because it feels like a very American, very now story about, on one side, the idealism and promise of good government. On the other side, the frustration with bureaucracy and mismanagement, and under it all, a profound distrust in government power. It's also just an impressive, compelling, and immersive bit of journalism that we'd like to share with you.

• 2:44Speaker 05

  Thank you.

• 2:44Speaker 00

  With kind of at its heart, I think, is like an agency to help people.

• 2:48Speaker 05

  Yeah.

• 2:48Speaker 00

  But then it's like to kind of watch the swirl of this money, all this power, all these politics, all these moves around this very simple, very pure drive, Americans wanting to help Americans.

• 3:01Speaker 05

  Yeah, and that was the kind of, the thing that caught me off guard about diving into FEMA. You take that mission and then you kind of compare it to like the stories that have been told about FEMA.

• 3:12Speaker 00

  Right.

• 3:12Speaker 05

  And it's like, how did we get to a place where the agency that's supposed to like be the backstop between you and like financial and literal ruin? How did that become like one of like these villains of the internet?

• 3:27Speaker 00

  The series basically takes on that question. How did FEMA become so hated by so many people? It's four episodes long, but I want to start by playing you some of episode one, which details the origin of FEMA as an agency. Turns out, all the conspiracy theories that plague it today were there from the very beginning.

• 3:48Speaker 05

  Yeah, the conspiracy theories about FEMA that date back to this era of the agency that no one thinks about or talks about anymore, when it was hiding things from the American public.

• 4:02Speaker 00

  And it all starts, as you'll hear in the piece, with a plane wreck.

• 4:12Speaker 05

  On December 1st, 1974, heavy rain and fog rerouted a passenger plane over northern Virginia, some 50 miles from Washington DC. On its descent, the aircraft dropped into the forest below, tearing off the treetops and crashing into the side of Mount Weather. The two pilots were killed first, lanced by trees that burst through the cockpit. The rest of the aircraft crumbled into pieces, a mangle of shrapnel and the body parts of the 92 passengers and crew members. There were no survivors. One woman, whose parents were on the flight, said it seemed like the mountain had jumped up and bit the plane.

• 4:57Speaker 05

  News coverage of the day quickly turned to the blame game and the miscommunication from air traffic control amidst a violent storm. But our focus is something that was buried in the reports. When TV crews arrived at the crash site, they discovered, rather ominously, that Mount Weather had already been sealed off on the orders of federal security agents.

• 5:19Speaker 06

  The quick action was taken because the big jet had landed almost a mile away from a super-secret government installation, an underground complex of emergency offices set up for federal officials in the event of nuclear war.

• 5:35Speaker 05

  The crash had inadvertently uncovered a tightly-guarded Cold War secret. Inside Mount Weather was a massive covert facility. And somehow, that undersells it. Through a tunnel that burrows into the mountain and behind a 34-ton blast door lies a subterranean Strangelovean lair. A freestanding city with a hospital, a crematorium, an emergency power plant, and even a broadcasting studio. Everything that the White House and thousands of federal workers would need to run the country underground while millions melted on the surface. "I expect your people to save our government." That's what President Dwight Eisenhower told the first director of Mount Weather after

• 6:20Speaker 05

  it was built in 1955. It's still operated by FEMA today. It's actually being renovated as I speak. But back in the 1950s, Mount Weather was run by FEMA's predecessor, the Federal Civil Defense Administration, the FCDAs, which poured billions into making America nuke-proof, or at least lulling people into the belief that with enough preparation, they might survive atomic hellfire.

• 6:48Speaker 05

  The FCDAs was behind this delightful, if slightly morbid, PSA, instructing schoolchildren to hide under their desks during bomb drills.

• 7:15Speaker 05

  For adults, the FCDAs organized Operation Alert, a series of dramatic exercises where millions of people acted out the day of their likely demise, emptying the streets of America's biggest cities. While the sirens wailed their grim warning, hundreds of thousands of New Yorkers scurried for shelter against the attack, riders and drivers taking cover in a realistic drill for a day all Americans pray will never come. Operation Alert was also the first time that Mount Weather saw action. As soon as the alert sounded in Washington, President Eisenhower reached for his hat and strode to a waiting limousine to be driven to an emergency base of operations in the mountains outside Washington. Exact location kept secret.

• 7:57Speaker 05

  Kept secret until that terrible plane crash in 1974. Fortunately, nuclear obliteration never came, and Mount Weather was never truly put to use.

• 8:08Speaker 05

  But there's something ironic and revealing that a single storm brought more death and destruction to the base than 30 years of the Cold War. By the 1970s, it had become clear that the nuclear preparations had done little to protect America from an arguably greater threat: Mother Nature.

• 8:29Speaker 01

  We just didn't have that many nuclear wars, which is great, but we do have a lot of natural disasters.

• 8:36Speaker 05

  Garrett Graff is a journalist and author of a book about the origins of FEMA titled Raven Rock: The Story of the US Government's Secret Plan to Save Itself While the Rest of Us Die. Before the agency was created, America's disaster response system was, well, barely a system.

• 8:54Speaker 01

  It didn't make sense for every state to be developing its own totally independent ability to respond to a hurricane, because in any given year, most states don't get hit by a hurricane.

• 9:11Speaker 05

  Which became a big problem in the 60s and 70s, when the country was rocked by a series of record-breaking disasters.

• 9:18Speaker 04

  No one knows the full size of the disaster yet. In Betsy's wake, there's only darkness, confusion, and death. After suffering one of the most serious earthquakes in history, Alaska had to undergo the further ordeal of over 40 severe earth tremors. Imagine being there as the streets reared up around you, like the scene of some terrible biblical retribution. They called her Camille. Born of the sea, she turned like a woman scorned. She screamed, and ripped, and flooded, and killed.

• 9:55Speaker 05

  These big disasters overwhelmed towns and counties and states, the big ones often do, but when they asked for help, the federal government was too disorganized to act quickly or efficiently. Supplying extra ambulances, delivering food and water to survivors, fixing roads and power plants, each piece of the emergency management process could come from a different office or department. 100 agencies might play a role. Navigating this patchwork of services and jurisdictions was a major pain in the ass for local leaders, especially during a crisis, when lives are on the line and every second counts. Like in 1972, when another big storm hit.

• 10:35Speaker 06

  Many of the people here and others in the path of Hurricane Agnes were completely wiped out. Many of them feel that federal aid is too slow in coming and too little.

• 10:46Speaker 05

  Trump says FEMA should return its responsibilities to the states, which is odd because states often bring in FEMA when they're unable to respond on their own. And anyway, it was the states that asked for FEMA in the first place. In 1978, the National Governors Association drew up plans for a streamlined, one-stop-shop for federal emergency response and delivered it to a sympathetic White House.

• 11:11Speaker 04

  Washington President Carter proposed merging five big federal emergency preparation and disaster relief agencies into one agency as part of his reorganization plan. Civil defense experts say it will provide much-needed communication between the state

• 11:26Speaker 05

  and federal levels. In 1979, Jimmy Carter signed an executive order giving life to the Federal Emergency Management Agency. FEMA was a federal Frankenstein with a dual mission: Cold War civil defense and disaster relief. I wish I could illustrate this moment by playing you like a triumphant speech from President Carter or some colorful news footage, but either that stuff never existed or no one thought it was important enough to archive. Even the earliest employees at FEMA were confused about how to talk about it.

• 11:59Speaker 04

  We had a new director there, and there was a message that went out to us that said that if we're referring to the agency publicly, we should say either Federal Emergency Management Agency or FEMA, because the word FEMA, he thought, sounded too much like a laxative.

• 12:16Speaker 05

  This is Leo Bosner, a retired FEMA official, who's taught me a lot about the earliest days of the agency. He was working as a flood insurance specialist with the Department of Housing and Urban Development in one of the offices that was folded into FEMA.

• 12:31Speaker 04

  We're all working along in the office, and one day they tell us, okay, everybody go down to Photo ID, you're getting new photo IDs. So we walk down the stairs, get new photo IDs that say FEMA, turn in our photo IDs that say Housing, Urban Development, and then we're all told, we're all getting new job titles, and our new job title is Emergency Management Specialist. And I'm thinking, what on God's earth is an Emergency Management Specialist? Like, this is the end of my career. What kind of a dead-end job is this?

• 13:00Speaker 05

  Leo would spend the next 30 years at FEMA. He eventually found really satisfying work helping hospitals and medical organizations prepare for floods, wildfires, and hurricanes. But less than two years after he started getting the hang of his new job, FEMA fell into a decade-long tailspin.

• 13:19Speaker 04

  The big shift really didn't come until 1980.

• 13:23Speaker 06

  Ronald Reagan appears to be heading toward a landslide electoral victory tonight across the United States.

• 13:29Speaker 04

  Ronald Reagan got elected president, and there's a super U-turn from Jimmy Carter, who was mostly all about social welfare, and Ronald Reagan was more about national defense.

• 13:40Speaker 05

  To run FEMA, Reagan picked someone who would stir up a lot of trouble for the agency: this man. Only a masochist with a death wish would accept the job of directing FEMA. Army Colonel Louis Chafrida, speaking here with a caller on Larry King's radio show.

• 13:57Speaker 07

  I really don't believe that we can be saved if there is a nuclear war. I mean, how are you going to save me if you're blown up too?

• 14:04Speaker 04

  But you're not suggesting that because we both might be blown up by a nuclear war that we shouldn't have in place a system that would take care of us if there was an earthquake, or tidal wave, or a hurricane, or anything that sort of.

• 14:17Speaker 05

  While Louis Chafrida paid lip service to FEMA's disaster relief mission, he was quietly funneling most of FEMA's budget towards Cold War civil defense. Leo Bosner.

• 14:27Speaker 04

  All of a sudden, we start seeing all these military officers signing in at the login desk. We're going, why these military people here? Military, you'll go to floods or something? And then we learn, little by little...

• 14:38Speaker 05

  That FEMA's mission was really, really going to be to get ready for the big nuclear attack from the Soviet Union. In the early 80s, Leo started to hear whispers about classified programs at the agency. Every day on his trip up the elevator at FEMA HQ, he'd ride by a secret fifth floor manned by a security guard. Mostly, he rolled his eyes at all the Cold War theater, wishing FEMA would focus more on preparing Americans for natural disasters. But he still wondered, what were they doing in there?

• 15:10Speaker 01

  The majority of its funding.

• 15:13Speaker 05

  Garrett Graff.

• 15:14Speaker 01

  And about a third of its workforce was actually hidden in the nation's classified black budget, the special budget that Congress oversees that protects our most secret programs and capabilities. And FEMA, on a daily basis, is in charge of tracking the whereabouts of everyone in the presidential line of succession. So that in the event of a nuclear war, it knows where all of those people are, how to get them to secure relocation sites like the Mount Weather bunker, and who would be best positioned to be the person who takes over as president of the United States in the event of a nuclear war.

• 16:01Speaker 05

  I wonder if this classified continuity of government planning helps explain why there was so little media about FEMA when it was first created. I think the feds just didn't want to draw attention to their secret plans. That said, the coverage did pick up when the agency launched a controversial new initiative.

• 16:19Speaker 04

  The head of emergency management, Louis Giuffrida, says the heart of the proposal is crisis relocation.

• 16:25Speaker 02

  What we want to accomplish is taking the maximum number of people from high-risk areas. To areas of lesser risk.

• 16:35Speaker 05

  A mass evacuation program.

• 16:37Speaker 01

  There was sort of the sense of, well, if you could just get 20, 30, 50 miles away from a major city, you would at least have a chance to survive the initial blast from the nuclear weapons and then live into nuclear winter.

• 16:55Speaker 05

  Government officials estimated that in the worst case, 60 million Americans could survive an attack. Can you imagine all those urbanites swamping small towns and rural areas? News reports at the time featured a mixture of fascination and incredulity.

• 17:11Speaker 02

  My god, you're going to have modified anarchy after that sort of thing. How in the world are you going to coordinate the recovery and putting leadership back into place? How are you going to do that?

• 17:22Speaker 01

  60 million is still a lot of people. That is the modern population of France. Those people would need a functioning government and functioning infrastructure afterward.

• 17:35Speaker 05

  This is where we start getting into the bizarre conspiracy theories that haunt FEMA today. In 1982, in an effort to game out some of these post-apocalyptic scenarios, President Ronald Reagan signed a secret executive order to create a covert program called Project 908.

• 17:54Speaker 01

  That's 908, but they called it 908.

• 17:57Speaker 05

  It pooled billions of dollars in top officials from the National Security Council, FEMA, and the FBI.

• 18:04Speaker 01

  The FBI was in charge of pre-identifying buildings that could serve as refugee camps.

• 18:12Speaker 05

  If I have this right, basically, you had FBI agents working undercover for FEMA, traveling around the country, visiting warehouses, car shops, casinos, Walmarts, helping identify businesses that could be used to house citizens after a nuke was dropped on an American city?

• 18:38Speaker 01

  Yes, and often without telling the businesses that they were being scouted for these purposes.

• 18:46Speaker 05

  There was thankfully never a need to construct these refugee camps. But the secrecy went way deeper and darker. Just five years after the launch of Project 9/8, a bombshell report from the Miami Herald revealed that before Jafreda was asked to help run FEMA, he'd written his master's thesis on how the military could quell race riots by detaining millions of black people and putting them in concentration camps. Members of Congress were given a copy of his thesis during Jafreda's confirmation hearings, a horrifying detail that makes me think they considered this to be part of his qualifications for the job. The most damning part of that Miami Herald piece, though, was news that Jafreda had

• 19:31Speaker 05

  worked with Reagan's National Security Council to write plans for declaring martial law and putting the country temporarily under a sort of shadow government. And not just in the case of a nuke, but also in a so-called "national crisis," like a war.

• 19:48Speaker 01

  A bunch of this comes out in the late 1980s amid the Iran-Contra hearings and investigations. It turns out that Lieutenant Colonel Oliver North, who is the central figure at the White House of Iran-Contra, was also one of the planners for Project 9/8.

• 20:12Speaker 05

  Oliver North was asked about these martial law plans during the Iran-Contra hearings.

• 20:16Speaker 02

  Colonel North, in your work at the NSC, were you not assigned at one time to work on plans for the continuity of government in the event of a major disaster?

• 20:27Speaker 05

  North was questioned by Texas Representative Jack Brooks. We see North pause and whisper to his attorney. Then the chairman of the hearings, Daniel K. Enoway, jumps in to respond on the government's behalf.

• 20:41Speaker 02

  I believe that question touches upon a highly sensitive and classified area, so may I request that you not touch upon that, sir. I was particularly concerned, Mr. Chairman, because I read in Miami papers and several others that there had been a plan, a contingency plan, that would suspend the American Constitution. And I was deeply concerned about it and wondered if that was the area in which he had worked. I believe that it was, but I wanted to get his confirmation. May I most respectfully request that that matter not be touched upon.

• 21:19Speaker 05

  The government never acknowledged any of this stuff until much of it was declassified years later. Luis Giuffrida ended up resigning from FEMA for totally unrelated reasons following a congressional fraud investigation.

• 21:35Speaker 02

  According to Senator Albert Gore, Giuffrida had spent $170,000 of federal money to build a house on federal property for his own use.

• 21:44Speaker 05

  By the start of the 90s, FEMA employee Leo Bosner was beyond tired of the dysfunction and the kooky national security schemes. Frankly, for me, once that stuff was in the rearview mirror, it's like, fine, that's the trash. I hope they come on Friday and pick it up and dump it to the landfill. There were some pretty nutty people working back there then. Fortunately, nothing much ever came of that, except they ate up most of our budget. He was eager for the agency to shift resources to preparing for floods and hurricanes. But all this doomsday planning had done a number on FEMA's reputation. I would talk on my off-duty time to people on Capitol Hill, news reporters, and say, "Look, this is a dangerous thing. We're ignoring these natural disasters."

• 22:27Speaker 05

  And I was having lunch with a news reporter one day, and I'm telling him this, and the guy's looking really bored. He says, "Yeah, Leo, that's all really bad, but tell me about FEMA's secret plan to round up all the liberals in the country and put them in concentration camps." What? Yeah. I said, "Buddy, these people are so inept, they couldn't organize a two-car parade, and they're never gonna round up everybody in the country. Come on, get out of here, will you?" Leo didn't know it at the time, but those FEMA camps conspiracy theories had started popping up in fringe message boards on the early internet.

• 23:01Speaker 03

  The FEMA plans to imprison American citizens have generated a lot of interest in locating the potential prison camps throughout the country.

• 23:08Speaker 05

  This woman, Linda Thompson, a sort of godmother of the right-wing militia movement, made a 1994 documentary, "America Under Siege," which warned that FEMA was part of the New World Order, a global authoritarian takeover that would require rounding up anti-government dissidents.

• 23:27Speaker 03

  These may be facilities that have other uses, but which could be quickly used to detain large numbers of people, such as this Amtrak facility in Beech Grove, Indiana.

• 23:35Speaker 05

  Following in her footsteps a couple decades later were militia leaders like Stuart Rhodes of The Oath Keepers, one of the January 6 guys. A lot of this stuff is dual-use. They put together a detention center or... Emergency center, supposedly for refugees from other countries. And Infowars host Alex Jones. People are waking up in droves to the FEMA camps, to the new world order, to the troops on the streets. These FEMA camps. And Glenn Beck, when he was still on Fox News. I'm tired of hearing, you know about them? Sure. We've now, for several days, done research on them. I can't debunk them. After whipping up this paranoia, Beck did eventually debunk the theory with help from the editor in chief of Popular Mechanics.

• 24:17Speaker 06

  This is an Amtrak repair facility in Beach Grove, Indiana. We set a crew there the other day and we got. Is this your video? Yes. And sure enough, what did we find? They're repairing trains in there.

• 24:29Speaker 05

  Remember how earlier Garrett Graff told us about stores like Walmarts being scoped out by the government to be used as refugee camps? They don't exist, but people on TikTok and YouTube still like to make videos about them.

• 24:41Speaker 04

  It's like military style entrance, kind of like a FEMA camp.

• 24:47Speaker 04

  Why in the hell does Walmart Supercenter need that? See the Walmart trucks?

• 24:51Speaker 05

  These videos are low effort and easy to laugh off, but I mean, if FEMA could operate amount weather, why not amount Walmart?

• 24:59Speaker 01

  The challenge of a lot of these conspiracies is that they have a germ of truth to them.

• 25:06Speaker 05

  Garrett Graff.

• 25:06Speaker 01

  In the early stages of the Cold War, J. Edgar Hoover at the FBI had pre-selected lists of suspected communists and political dissidents that he wanted to round up in the event of a nuclear war.

• 25:21Speaker 05

  Not to mention the fact that the US imprisoned over 100,000 Japanese Americans during World War II.

• 25:27Speaker 01

  I think FEMA has always been in a difficult place, and this is true, by the way, across all of the continuity planning and doomsday planning. You just can't talk about these classified bunkers and classified operations, even if you're trying to debunk conspiracies.

• 25:47Speaker 05

  The secrecy in and of itself is naturally going to feed conspiracy theories.

• 25:51Speaker 01

  Absolutely.

• 25:54Speaker 05

  The kicker to all this is that some of what the conspiracy theorists warned about is happening, just not to them. This past July, FEMA, under Kristi Noem's Department of Homeland Security, revealed a new program.

• 26:07Speaker 06

  FEMA allocating $608 million in state grants for construction of detention centers.

• 26:15Speaker 05

  Migrant detention centers, part of Trump's mass deportation program. The announcement came right around when Florida Governor Ron DeSantis opened Alligator Alcatraz, the notorious facility in the Everglades. And while he built the jail using state emergency funds intended for natural disasters, he claimed that federal reimbursement was on the way. A spokesperson for the Department of Homeland Security confirms Florida did submit an application to FEMA and were awarded two days ago the full amount Florida applied for, $608 million. The coverage made it sound like the money was in Florida's bank account, but at time of recording, those FEMA funds have actually been held up by Trump's Justice Department.

• 26:59Speaker 05

  Florida officials say the money is still likely, but who knows? Despite that uncertainty and many legal attempts aimed at closing it, Alligator Alcatraz remains open.

• 27:09Speaker 03

  Amnesty International says immigrants held at the ICE jail in Florida were shackled inside a two-foot-high metal cage and left outside without water for up to a day at a time. In a new report, they also detail unsanitary conditions, lights on 24 hours a day, poor quality food and water, and lack of privacy.

• 27:29Speaker 06

  And while Governor DeSantis says the conditions are up to standard, the families of migrants being held inside are calling it a concentration camp.

• 27:36Speaker 01

  That is the most real FEMA camp ever built.

• 27:39Speaker 05

  What do you think it says that FEMA would actually use public funds for the very thing that has been a far-right boogeyman?

• 27:50Speaker 01

  I mean, there is something uniquely dystopian about a right-wing government elected on the backs of the anti-government conspiracies that it is now implementing.

• 28:12Speaker 00

  After the break, Micah will explain how we got to this present day iteration of FEMA and help us understand what might happen to it going forward from here. We'll be back in just a minute.

• 28:27Speaker 03

  Radiolab is supported by Capital One. With no fees or minimums on checking accounts, it's no wonder the Capital One Bank guy is so passionate about banking with Capital One. If he were here, he wouldn't just tell you about no fees or minimums. He'd also talk about how Capital One cafes are open seven days a week to assist with your banking needs, even on weekends. It's pretty much all he talks about, in a good way. What's in your wallet? Terms apply. See CapitalOne.com/BankGuy. Capital One, N.A., Member FDIC.

• 28:52Speaker 03

  Midlife brings a lot of changes. Your Turn with Alison Aubrey is a new podcast to help you navigate the twists and turns. From health and relationships to creativity and purpose, we can help steer your next chapter with Your Turn with Alison Aubrey. Find it on the NPR app or wherever you get your podcasts.

• 29:16Speaker 00

  Hey, this is Radiolab. I'm Latif Nassar, talking to Micah Lowinger about the series he put together over at On the Media about FEMA with help from their senior producer, Eloise Blondio. And the series picks up that story in the 1990s, when FEMA stops obsessing over nuclear winter and focuses on climate disasters. It's still the subject of conspiracy theories at that point, but was relatively popular with the general public. Then 9/11. With all the concerns about counterterrorism, the agency's attention was once again divided. And the series shows how that was a big part of what led to their catastrophic mishandling

• 29:57Speaker 00

  of Hurricane Katrina in 2005. Micah then told me how FEMA hit its next inflection point with Hurricane Helene.

• 30:05Speaker 05

  Hurricane Helene hits in 2024 and brings historic flooding to western North Carolina. FEMA, in a way, was not caught off guard by the actual hurricane. It had pre-staged water and medical supplies and search and rescue teams. Nothing like what happened during Hurricane Katrina. That said, what FEMA was not ready for was just an absolute onslaught of misinformation and conspiracy theories and political lies aimed at making it look like FEMA totally screwed up.

• 30:42Speaker 00

  Yeah.

• 30:43Speaker 05

  We're talking about a month before the 2024 election, Donald Trump, he spreads a lot of conspiracy theories about FEMA's response, among them that FEMA is running out of money because it's given all of its money to migrant housing. He told a story of FEMA just giving money away to migrants at the expense of American hurricane survivors, which was just not true. That was a lie.

• 31:05Speaker 00

  Micah told me that those old stories about FEMA camps also resurfaced during this time, and there were stories about FEMA favoring Democratic voters over Republican voters.

• 31:15Speaker 05

  And it leads to violent threats against FEMA employees, intimidation and harassment of federal workers on the ground. And so just a few weeks later, Hurricane Milton hits Florida, and this one canvasser for FEMA who's going door to door knocking, telling people, hey, these are the assistance programs you can apply for, her team that she's managing, they're telling her, hey, we're being harassed, especially at houses with Trump campaign signs. So this woman, Marnie Washington, FEMA manager, says, well, you guys can just skip these Trump homes to be safe. That gets leaked to the right wing press, it goes viral, and then now, now basically

• 32:00Speaker 05

  MAGA and Trump have proof. They have proof. They created this chaos with lies, and then when it kind of filters out and leads to like fear among FEMA employees, they end up with evidence that, yeah, FEMA was neglecting Trump supporters all along. And so I just found that it felt like he like threw a boomerang in Hurricane Helene, caught it in Hurricane Milton, and then sort of ran with it as soon as he became president. Trump, three days after inauguration, does a press conference in North Carolina where he straight up said- I don't like FEMA very much. It's really expensive. They don't do a very good job. I think we should either reform or get rid of it altogether.

• 32:42Speaker 00

  Micah says that in the year and a half or so since that speech, FEMA has been locked in a struggle to survive. That's basically the fourth episode of the series. And I want to play just one part of that episode here for you because Micah managed to score an interview with a guy named Cameron Hamilton, who is the interim head of FEMA in the early days of Trump's second term, right after Helene, who was fired a year later. And then, in a strange turn of events, may now be the man who holds FEMA's future in his hands.

• 33:12Speaker 05

  On March 27, 2025, Cameron Hamilton, Trump's interim top leader at FEMA, was meeting with some high-ranking officials in an undisclosed, secure location. He wouldn't tell me who he was with or where, just that he had to run out abruptly.

• 33:29Speaker 06

  I received a phone call that was very distressing.

• 33:34Speaker 05

  It was Corey Lewandowski, a special government employee working closely with Department of Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem. Lewandowski was ripping mad.

• 33:44Speaker 06

  He proceeded to berate me over the fact that the media got a hold of a story and was running a topic that they felt was too sensitive and not fit for public domain.

• 33:55Speaker 05

  The topic was abolishing FEMA.

• 33:57Speaker 06

  Correct.

• 34:00Speaker 05

  A day earlier, Politico had published a story about a meeting where Corey Lewandowski, Kristi Noem, and Cameron Hamilton had discussed whether to dismantle the agency and how they might do it. Lewandowski was now calling because he believed Hamilton had leaked the story.

• 34:16Speaker 06

  To which I responded, I'm not a liar, I'm not a leaker, I'm a man of honor. And if I tell you the truth, it's the truth.

• 34:22Speaker 05

  Lewandowski didn't buy it.

• 34:24Speaker 06

  I wanted to choke somebody, and that's exactly what came to my mind. Just living in my flesh, doing some very un-Christian things to a certain person, but nonetheless.

• 34:35Speaker 05

  A certain person being Mr. Lewandowski?

• 34:38Speaker 06

  No, no, we're, yeah, I think you can read between the lines on that statement.

• 34:42Speaker 05

  After his call with Lewandowski, Hamilton got an email from a DHS official asking him to submit to a voluntary polygraph test, as in a lie detector. Hamilton told me he had nothing to hide, but he was shocked and not sure how to respond. So he started calling his friends around Washington.

• 35:01Speaker 06

  I called people in the White House. I called people in Congress, people in the Senate. My first question is, is this normal? I've never encountered such unprofessionalism ever in my life, to which unanimously their perspective was, I've never seen something like this. And then the second argument that I had received from others was, do I resign in protest? Or do I do this? Overwhelmingly, the advice was, please do not resign. They will try to destroy you if you do publicly. So they said, the honorable thing to do is to take the test, pass it, and then look them in the face and remind them that you're not a liar. So that's what I chose to do.

• 35:40Speaker 05

  Just a quick bit of context here. Micah actually interviewed Cameron Hamilton five months before they released this episode, so early in 2026. And one of the reasons Micah wanted to talk to him was because Hamilton was acting head of the agency at the moment when Donald Trump gave that speech in North Carolina, saying he might maybe want to abolish FEMA, which apparently took everyone by surprise.

• 36:07Speaker 06

  My phone was blowing up. Probably about at least a dozen members of Congress called me that Friday, saying basically, is this really what's gonna happen?

• 36:16Speaker 05

  This was just Hamilton's third day on the job, and all of a sudden FEMA's 20,000-plus workforce and the entire world of emergency managers were spinning out.

• 36:27Speaker 06

  There were state directors and governors that heard this and thought, this is a terrible idea.

• 36:33Speaker 05

  FEMA employees at the agency's headquarters were barging into Hamilton's office in tears.

• 36:39Speaker 06

  I assembled a leadership team and said, guys and gals, this is our moment. This is our make or break testing period here. We can either let this sword of Damocles drop on us and let us fail, or we can dig down deep, which is what emergency managers do, and deal with this crisis and meet it head on and do it with a smile on our face.

• 36:57Speaker 05

  Some seasoned FEMA staffers I spoke with were not happy to have Hamilton leading them through this crisis. They believed his appointment was part of the problem. The Post-Catrina Emergency Management Reform Act requires that FEMA's leader have significant experience responding to disasters. Trump's last FEMA administrator, Pete Gaynor, who served in Trump's first term, had done over 10 years of emergency management in Rhode Island before coming to FEMA. Hamilton's resume looked nothing like that. He had served for a decade as a Navy SEAL and then in DHS and the State Department. Running FEMA, even temporarily, was a gigantic promotion. He got the job

• 37:40Speaker 05

  because, as the second Trump administration was taking shape, he was a well-connected MAGA warrior, saying all the right things.

• 37:47Speaker 06

  Cameron, tell me about your race. Hey, well, good morning. Thanks for having me. And all the patriots out there, thank you for listening. So I'm running in the Virginia--

• 37:54Speaker 05

  This is an interview on Real America's Voice from March 2024, when Hamilton was running for a congressional seat in Virginia, about 10 months before he ended up at FEMA.

• 38:05Speaker 06

  I've worked in the federal government in various different jobs and capacities, and I understand exactly the bureaucratic sickness that our government is plagued--

• 38:12Speaker 05

  The bureaucratic sickness that our government is plagued by.

• 38:16Speaker 06

  So are you ready and able to dismantle the administrative state? I think so, absolutely. When Trump is president, if you win, are you--

• 38:24Speaker 05

  He lost in the Republican primary three months later. After Donald Trump was elected that fall, Hamilton began seeking the approval of conservative groups in the hope of scoring a role in the incoming administration. The Heritage Foundation had lobbied for decades to reduce the size and role of FEMA. Its Project 2025 stopped short of calling for the end of the agency, but it laid out ambitious plans, like scrapping preparedness programs, pushing much more recovery costs to the states, and privatizing the part of the agency that offers home flood insurance to 4.7 million households.

• 39:07Speaker 06

  My recommendation, leader or not, when I talked to Heritage was actually about move FEMA to the Department of Interior. And I'm, I say this as a constitutional, limited government conservative. I don't think DHS should exist.

• 39:18Speaker 05

  Dismantling DHS and moving FEMA to the Department of Interior were also two goals of Project 2025. During Trump's transition, Hamilton was put in touch with the DHS Secretary-to-be, Kristi Noem.

• 39:31Speaker 06

  The interview went very well, and we discussed the principles of emergency management.

• 39:36Speaker 05

  How did you make the case to her that you were the man for the job?

• 39:39Speaker 06

  I worked in emergency management more specifically at my time at the State Department. So while the traditional model of emergency management is domestically focused, all my experience was overseas, dealing with mass evacuation planning, dealing with biocontainment for Ebola, you name it. I did not pretend or presume by any means to be the most qualified individual, but my arguments to her were simply, I would love to be an asset for you, to have an ally within the agency, but also still give the president time to make his determination.

• 40:11Speaker 05

  As in, time to decide whether to nominate Hamilton officially for the job, or find a more qualified FEMA administrator who might have an easier time passing Senate confirmation?

• 40:22Speaker 06

  Nowhere in this conversation was there ever a discussion about abolishing FEMA. And that didn't happen until the president traveled to North Carolina when the president spoke at that press conference.

• 40:33Speaker 04

  I'll also be signing a executive order to begin the process of fundamentally reforming and overhauling FEMA, or maybe getting rid of FEMA. I think frankly FEMA is not good.

• 40:42Speaker 06

  All of a sudden, every action, everything that we did, was now immediately under the microscope.

• 40:49Speaker 05

  That afternoon, Hamilton asked that FEMA remove climate resilience from the agency's top three goals, in an effort, he said, to make it seem less quote-unquote "political." But it was a little late for that. In a matter of weeks, Elon Musk sent his Doge goons to FEMA. Hamilton told me he was wary of them, but he gave Musk's team full access to the agency's payment systems.

• 41:15Speaker 05

  No one was more hell-bent on gutting the agency than Secretary Kristi Noem and her special employee Corey Lewandowski, a MAGA operative and former pundit who was rumored to be having an affair with Noem. Neither of them, says Hamilton, knew the basics of FEMA's history or its disaster relief systems.

• 41:34Speaker 06

  The general lack of understanding from DHS, at least at the senior political level, of what it is that FEMA does is what necessitated the meeting to be held in late March.

• 41:44Speaker 03

  We were tasked by Corey Lewandowski and the secretary to write a memo on how we would abolish FEMA.

• 41:55Speaker 05

  This is Mary Ann Tierney, who was Hamilton's deputy, his number two. She's a longtime emergency manager who had risen through the ranks at the agency in the decades following 9/11. And now here she was, helping craft plans for how to radically reduce the staff at FEMA.

• 42:12Speaker 03

  It was very upsetting, but part of your job as a senior executive is to implement the prerogative of political leadership, right? And that's something that I still take seriously. And so what our memo laid out was how you could do it, but also raise the legal concerns associated with it.

• 42:30Speaker 05

  As we discussed in episode two, the Post-Katrina Emergency Management Reform Act limits how much DHS can meddle with FEMA. The memo identified parts of FEMA that, with help from Congress, could be killed or doled out to different agencies. And so that March meeting between Kristi Noem, Corey Lewandowski, and Cameron Hamilton was an opportunity to discuss these different strategies.

• 42:54Speaker 06

  They were eager to see my plans on reform, and then I think that they wanted to have a rebranding.

• 43:00Speaker 05

  Hamilton's memo suggested some potential name changes for FEMA, including the National Office of Emergency Management, N-O-E-M, as in Noem.

• 43:11Speaker 06

  And she said, "I love this. Let's just rename it and we'll call it abolishing." And then politically, it would look like it was an abolition. When in reality, it was just a relabeling and a reshuffling of the deck.

• 43:21Speaker 05

  That was just one idea, but Hamilton told me he insisted that they wait to see what Congress and Trump's FEMA review council proposed before taking action. And you know a bit about what happens next. Politico reported on the existence of that meeting and Lewandowski blamed Hamilton for the leak, despite the fact that many other people knew that the meeting was happening.

• 43:41Speaker 06

  That meeting was transmitted to us through an exec process, the executive secretariat. The meeting's label was FEMA: abolish or reform. So the meeting topic itself was visible to about 50 to 100 people.

• 43:57Speaker 05

  Nevertheless, Lewandowski insisted that Hamilton sit for a polygraph test.

• 44:02Speaker 06

  They're not always perfect. You can get them wrong.

• 44:05Speaker 05

  Yeah, I feel like they're famous for not being that accurate.

• 44:07Speaker 06

  Well, they're more accurate than people realize. It's just the difficulty now is there are more people in the American populace who have had training on how to defeat them and how to overcome them.

• 44:17Speaker 05

  I see.

• 44:18Speaker 06

  I've had that training before in the military, specifically as a Navy SEAL. My interrogator understood this and they made it very clear. You are not to use certain techniques. But I will just say I made my statements there without any methods to shield myself from accountability.

• 44:39Speaker 05

  Hamilton was cleared, but he never received an apology. Then DHS began working its way through the agency's senior leadership.

• 44:47Speaker 03

  I would say about eight to 10 FEMA staff were polygraphed as a result of the meeting and the memo.

• 44:53Speaker 05

  Mary Ann Tierney was spared from the witch hunt.

• 44:56Speaker 03

  I even consulted an attorney because I thought I was going to be polygraphed. It traumatized our workforce.

• 45:05Speaker 05

  Did they find the leaker?

• 45:07Speaker 06

  No.

• 45:10Speaker 06

  Well, I suspect I know where the leak came from. It did not come from FEMA. I'll put it that way.

• 45:18Speaker 05

  When Cameron Hamilton was called to testify on May 7, 2025, before the House Appropriations Committee, he knew his days at FEMA were numbered.

• 45:27Speaker 06

  The morning of my testimony, at about 10, maybe 10:30, FEMA security received a phone call from DHS security, asking them to terminate my access to the building, which is essentially a firing, if you will.

• 45:41Speaker 05

  Yeah.

• 45:41Speaker 06

  Mary Ann had asked, "How would you like us to handle this?" And I said, "I'd like you to notify DHS that I'm submitting a letter to the Appropriations Committee now that will indicate that I've been removed and that I will not be able to testify." The department then realized the optics of it would not look proper, so they backtracked, essentially indicating, "Hey, just sort of pretend this didn't happen."

• 46:04Speaker 05

  "You can go ahead and testify, but when you come back, you're fired."

• 46:09Speaker 06

  "That's not what they said, but that's what I understood it to mean."

• 46:14Speaker 05

  "Does this administration seek to eliminate FEMA? And do you support eliminating FEMA?" U.S. Rep. Rosa Delgado of Connecticut questioned Hamilton later that day.

• 46:26Speaker 06

  "I do not believe it is in the best interest of the American people to eliminate the Federal Emergency Management Agency. Having said that, that is a conversation that should be had between the President of the United States and this governing body."

• 46:37Speaker 05

  Acting head Cameron Hamilton was abruptly fired yesterday. It came one day after he testified before Congress that FEMA should not be scrapped.

• 46:50Speaker 05

  Then, this March, just when morale at FEMA had hit rock bottom.

• 46:54Speaker 03

  So, Secretary Noem, at any time during your tenure as Director of Department of Homeland Security, have you had sexual relations with Corey Lewandowski?

• 47:07Speaker 06

  Mr. Chairman, I am shocked that we're going down and peddling tabloid guards.

• 47:11Speaker 03

  in this committee today. reclaiming my

• 47:14Speaker 05

  in a congressional hearing lawmakers like California representative Sidney Comlager Dove grilled Kristi Noem.

• 47:21Speaker 03

  okay for you to be offended by the question. But it is also a real question. So what I would say to you is that what we do at the Department of Homeland Security

• 47:31Speaker 05

  on a wide range of topics, including her decision to delay disaster recovery funds to North Carolina and allegations of corruption and dysfunction at DHS more broadly.

• 47:41Speaker 03

  Chair, before I yield my time, I would like to enter into the record some articles, and I'm asking for unanimous consent. Noem tightens her grip on DHS. Lewandowski fired FEMA admin. Without objection. Okay. The next one is Kristi Noem secretly took a cut of political donations from ProPublica. Without objection. Uh, Kristi Noem fires pilot over a blanket, but is forced to reinstate him to fly home. Wall Street Journal. Without objection.

• 48:09Speaker 06

  We're coming on the air because President Trump has just announced that Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem is out of a job. This follows reports that the president was frustrated by her recent testimony on Capitol Hill.

• 48:27Speaker 05

  After Noem was abruptly fired in March, FEMA's fortunes began to slowly turn around. Trump's new DHS Secretary Mark Wayne Mullen brought a decidedly more conciliatory tone when he traveled to North Carolina to meet with local emergency managers, first responders, and regional FEMA staff working on the Hurricane Helene recovery.

• 48:48Speaker 01

  We're going through this conversation. Let us know if we can do better, not just beat up on FEMA. That's not the point because they've done a great job, but what is it that we could maybe tweak just a little bit?

• 48:57Speaker 05

  Over the past couple of months, Secretary Mullen began to lift Kristi Noem's $100,000 review policy. President Trump also released some state disaster relief funding that his White House had withheld. But most surprising of all.

• 49:12Speaker 06

  The former head of the Federal Emergency Management Agency, or FEMA, is about to get a second crack at the job. President Trump has nominated Cameron Hamilton to lead the agency a year after he was removed from that very same position.

• 49:27Speaker 00

  So Trump is now trying to rehire the guy who just a year or so ago he fired?

• 49:31Speaker 05

  Yes, he get, not even just his old job, but now he's up for Senate confirmation. So he gets to be like the real deal, the real McCoy.

• 49:39Speaker 00

  He's like the guy drummed out in disgrace and then they just call him back like they're like, oh, and by the way, will you just take your old job back?

• 49:45Speaker 05

  Yeah.

• 49:46Speaker 00

  Okay, so I want to play you just one last bit of tape here from that episode four, because after Cameron Hamilton was nominated to lead FEMA again, Mica and his senior producer, Eloise Blondio, got a call from Hamilton.

• 50:01Speaker 05

  Hi Eloise, how are you? I'm good. Hey Cam, I'm here with Mica, who you spoke to before. Okay, excellent. Well, thank you. I wanted to call and reach out because I understand that you are getting ready to air our previous conversation and I wanted to speak with you about that if you have some time. Yes, Cam. Hey, I just wanted to let you know that I am recording this conversation, but I'm happy to talk about it. Earlier this week, Eloise and I got a call from Cameron Hamilton. When we called him back, he asked us to delay the release of this episode. He was concerned that our interview from five months ago could draw negative attention ahead of his upcoming Senate confirmation hearing. I told him I thought the request was inappropriate and that we would release

• 50:44Speaker 05

  the episode as planned. It's true that he may face tough questions about his qualifications. If confirmed, he would be the least experienced FEMA administrator since Hurricane Katrina era leader, Michael Brown. And my sources believe Hamilton will still likely get the job.

• 51:18Speaker 00

  So what is the status now? Is FEMA still on the bubble? Is FEMA still going to exist? What, how do we, what does it look like?

• 51:26Speaker 05

  So it's, I do feel like the agency has like turned a corner in a significant way. That said, you know,

• 51:36Speaker 05

  The disaster season is about to begin. Hurricane season, wildfire season is basically about to start. And there are serious concerns about the agency's capacities to respond to these disasters.

• 51:49Speaker 00

  It's like we're punching ourselves in the face at the time when we, when we need to be most on it. You know, it's so depressing.

• 51:58Speaker 05

  Absolutely. That, that is incredibly depressing for me, too. And in a way, it felt to me like the continuation with the problem with FEMA at its core all along. Which is that it is the agency where our leaders like dump their worst fears. And it really matters what you're afraid of as a country.

• 52:19Speaker 00

  Interesting, interesting.

• 52:20Speaker 05

  During the Cold War, it was nuclear annihilation. After 9/11, it was the war on terror. DHS basically had FEMA throw out the old book and, and write new emergency response protocols with terrorism at the heart. Then we have Hurricane Katrina. And arguably, a version of that has happened again today under Kristi Noem and this Trump 2.0, where fear of immigration became like the thing that DHS was obsessed with. And they even tried to pull FEMA workers out of the agency and make them help out at ICE.

• 52:57Speaker 05

  Just to illustrate, once again, how this national security paranoia is always sort of intentioned with natural disasters. And like, there is a gulf between what a growing chorus of Americans feel threatens our future and the ways that fear among our leaders manifests in the way they run our government.

• 53:18Speaker 00

  But like FEMA is not going anywhere.

• 53:21Speaker 05

  FEMA is not, FEMA is not going anywhere. But I don't think that FEMA is out of the woods. I think that Americans will, will continue to approach it with incredible suspicion and paranoia. And it's true that.

• 53:41Speaker 05

  A lot of people who are suspicious of FEMA, I think, are generally suspicious of the federal government. That's something that I encountered when I was doing reporting in North Carolina, speaking to Hurricane Helene survivors and people who were there. It's, I don't know that this agency can wriggle its way out of a kind of distrust that's so much bigger than FEMA.

• 54:25Speaker 00

  Okay, that's our show for today. Big, big thanks to the team at On The Media, especially co-host Michael Lowinger and senior producer Eloise Blondio, who reported and produced the series together. They did a terrific job. Go check it out. There are all kinds of stories, detailed reporting in there that we didn't cover here. You'll hear FEMA workers, this is actually one of my favorite parts of the series, these FEMA workers who worked through Katrina and Helene. It's so inspiring to hear from them because, I mean, they know how hated the agency they work for is. They know all these conspiracy theories. And yet, it's so important and fulfilling to them to be showing up for victims

• 55:07Speaker 00

  of these catastrophes, to be there on the worst day of these strangers' lives. And it just, I don't know, that completely melted me. You can listen to the whole series at onthemedia.org or wherever you get your podcasts. I'm Latif Nasser. Thanks for listening. We'll be back with some brand spanking new Radiolab content next week, same podcast time, same podcast channel. I'll see you there.

• 55:36Speaker 00

  Hi, I'm Maya, and I'm from London. And here are the staff credits.

• 55:40Speaker 06

  Radiolab is hosted by Lulu Miller and Latif Nasser. Soren Wheeler is our executive editor. Sarah Sandberg is our executive director. Our managing editor is Pat Walters. Dylan Keefe is our director of sound design. Our staff includes Jeremy Bloom, W. Harry Fortuna, David Gable, Maria Paz Gutierrez, Sindhu Nainasambandhan, Matt Keelty, Mona Mordgaucka, Annie McEwen, Alex Neeson, Sarah Kari, Natalia Ramirez, Rebecca Rand, Joanna Strogatz, Anissa Vitza, Arianne Whack, Molly Webster, and Jessica Young, with help from Gabby Santos and Maya Appleby-Malamed.

• 56:21Speaker 06

  Our fact checkers are Diane Kelly, Emily Krieger, Natalie Middleton, Angelie Macado, and Sophie Samai.

• 56:34Speaker 06

  Hi, I'm Monica, and I'm calling from Mexico City. Leadership support for Radiolab science programming is provided by the Simons Foundation and the John Templeton Foundation. Foundational support for Radiolab was provided by the Alfred P. Flon Foundation.