Pod Insights The Property Academy Podcast Why Some Tenants Hate Landlords (and They’re Not Completely Wrong)⎥Ep. 2190 About this episode Some tenants say landlords are greedy, careless, or even exploitative. And while many investors are fair and responsible, there are real horror stories that explain why tenants sometimes feel this way. In this episode, Ed and Andrew dig into the frustrations tenants talk about most – from sudden rent hikes to mouldy houses and landlords who show up unannounced. They also share what it actually takes to be a landlord that tenants respect rather than resent. You’ll learn:4 shocking stories that reveal why tenants often feel burnedThe biggest complaints tenants have (and how to avoid being “that landlord”)A simple framework to build better landlord-tenant relationshipsIf you want to grow your wealth without damaging your reputation, this episode shows you how to invest smarter and keep your tenants onside. Don't forget to create your free Opes+ account here. For more from Opes Partners:Sign up for the weekly Private Property newsletterInstagramTikTok
Transcript 0:08 Speaker 00 Hello and welcome along to the Property Academy Podcast. I'm your host, Sepp McKnight.
0:11 Speaker 01 Andrew Nicoll.
0:12 Speaker 00 And this is the show that helps Kiwis go from zero to five investment property. So you could be financially free and stick around for the next 15 minutes because you're going to learn why some tenants hate landlords and why they're not completely wrong. Four stories that show what tenants actually complain about and how to be a good landlord that your tenants don't hate. Now, Andrew, are tenants anti landlord?
0:34 Speaker 01 No, I don't think so. I think most tenants are pretty happy with their arrangements. And what their expectations are, they want a warm, dry, safe house. And they don't want landlords showing up that haven't got any reason to be at the house. I heard of an example the other day where a landlord just kept showing up just to check on the tenants like every single week. They just want to live in their house, pay their rent and have a nice environment. But there are some instances where tenants get really kind of miffed at the kind of things that landlords might do. So we've taken four stories where the property investors are just being pricks.
1:13 Speaker 00 I often say, you know, most tenants aren't anti landlord, they're anti cold, damp, unfair power place. So one thing that really annoys tenants is where the landlords are just being greedy. So I heard this story recently where the landlord wanted to put the rent up by 70 bucks a week. So the tenant jumps online, goes through Trademe, it looks at what similar properties are renting for right now. And so he finds a couple of cheaper ones online that are similar, gives them to the landlord and he says, look, I just feel like this is not a market rent increase. Like you're wanting to increase it way more than what the market rent is. And maybe just because you know, it's going to cost me money to move. And so
1:56 Speaker 00 maybe I'll just accept it, but that's actually not fair. And that's not what the law says. And so it's really easy to see that this tenant feels like they're being ripped off by a greedy landlord. And honestly,
2:10 Speaker 00 The landlord just seems a little bit delulu. And I think the lesson there for landlords is we are in a position of power where the law lets us say, hey, the new rent is this. In sixty three days' time, or whatever it happens to be today, but in a couple of weeks' time, the rent is going up by X dollars. And then it's on the tetter to push back and complain against that. But because we've got that first mover advantage as landlords, we are in that position of power. And if you abuse that and be greedy, you could understand why some tenants would hate that sort of behaviour. Now, this, I want to be very clear. This is not most investors. Most investors do that. But there are a couple who do bad things and then we all get tainted by the same brush. I think that happens to tenants too, where there are some bad tenants
2:55 Speaker 00 and then all tenants get tarred with that same brush. But Andrew, I know you've dug into story number two.
3:00 Speaker 01 Yeah, number two is just old, worn out properties that really aren't fit for tenants to be living in there. And I read this outrageous story where these tenants were living in a property, the shower flooded and the wastewater, so the sewage, that leaked into the kitchen. Like, that's disgusting. And it got worse when it rained. The tenant ended up showering with a bucket.
3:23 Speaker 00 What do you mean with a bucket? Like pouring it over themselves?
3:26 Speaker 01 Standing there pouring it over themselves. Like, that's horrendous. I get annoyed if there's not enough water pressure in the hotel I'm staying at. Imagine a bucket and the landlord, they didn't deal with it, they just ignored it. And this ended up just going on and on and on, to the point where the tenant said they had to drill a hole so the sewage could drain. Like, that's gross and it's unsafe, right? They could get sick as a result of that. And the sad thing again is that these tenants put up with it and they probably just thought all landlords are just not interested in our wellbeing. And that's definitely not the case for the majority, but there are these extreme cases like this which are unacceptable.
4:08 Speaker 00 And Andrew, I found some photos of a similar case. And I want to show you just how dilapidated these ones are. So I'm going to show you these photos. I want to hear your actual reaction, okay? So this is the outside. What are you seeing?
4:23 Speaker 01 It looks very, very damp.
4:25 Speaker 00 Okay, and we've got like just rubbish all out on the outside. But here is one of the bedrooms.
4:33 Speaker 01 Oh my god, is that carpet moulding?
4:36 Speaker 00 Yeah, that is damp A F. Look at this one.
4:41 Speaker 01 That's disgusting. This looks like something you'd see in Trainspotting.
4:46 Speaker 00 Uh, is that a movie? Is that a scary movie?
4:49 Speaker 01 Yeah, no, yeah, yeah.
4:50 Speaker 00 Mold over here, the cracks in the ceiling, like, that is not damp. That's like, the house has been dunked in a swimming pool, right?
4:57 Speaker 01 How could people be expected to live in an environment like that? That's horrendous.
5:02 Speaker 00 And this is the, this is the bathroom, this is the bathroom with the bucket.
5:06 Speaker 01 Oh my god, that's disgusting.
5:08 Speaker 00 It's actually terrible. And the worst thing is that this landlord was happy to take people's money, living in a very terrible house. I understand the thought process of like willing buyer, willing seller, but it's just not really right, eh?
5:23 Speaker 01 That's not good enough. That's just taking advantage of someone's need to find a house.
5:28 Speaker 00 Yeah, I saw another story where a tenant moved into a property and it was all good until winter arrived. And they started seeing mushrooms growing out of the walls, like little tiny mushrooms. And they tried to pull down the, the, like, some of the, some of the gib to see what was going on with all these mushrooms. And there's just black mould all behind it. And like the window frames were starting rotting. It's just absolutely terrible. And I think some of those pain points just keep coming up and up again.
5:57 Speaker 01 Yeah, I think if you ask tenants what their main gripe is, generally it's repairs that don't get dealt with. Mold, absolutely. And that's like, that's a health concern, so I get that. I think sudden rent hikes is a big one. Privacy breaches, so that might not sound like it goes on a lot. But I think some landlords are a bit overbearing and they just turn up unannounced. And definitely there can be fights about bond at the end.
6:23 Speaker 00 And if we just dig into the privacy breaches and landlords turning up unannounced, I saw this other story on Reddit. Where this landlord just keep turning up to the apartment without notice. And obviously, if you're a landlord and you're self-managing, you've got keys to the house. And so this landlord wasn't even doing a. A knock, knock, knock.
6:40 Speaker 01 What, they're just opening the door?
6:42 Speaker 00 Just, oh, here's the keys, landlord, rattle the keys, hello, hello, hello, anyone home? And the tenant's girlfriend was sometimes there alone and the landlord would walk in even when she's half dressed. And then the landlord says, no, she's not allowed to visit, where legally she can. Like what landlords sometimes don't realise, it's your house, but it's the tenant's home. So they can have people over, that doesn't mean they could have ten people live in the house with them. But they are allowed people over.
7:10 Speaker 01 And look, I think as landlords, we do have to recognise that there is a bit of a power imbalance. Like if we own a property, yes, we own that. And we can sometimes think we've got all the rights because we own the property. We can choose who lives there and we can kick them out if they don't like it. And as a landlord, you can actually kick out a tenant with 90 days' notice, so long as they're not on a fixed term tenancy. Now, if you're a tenant and, you know, you don't have a lot of extra money, the thought of having to move and having to find another property and having to pay another bond, that really puts you at a disadvantage. And I do think as landlords, if we're going to be decent people and decent landlords, we do need to consider this because
7:52 Speaker 01 you don't want to use that position of power to take advantage of someone's need for a house.
7:57 Speaker 00 Yeah, even if a landlord's messing around with your bond especially and not releasing it, like saving up another four weeks' worth of rent to go somewhere else, like that is actually a lot of money. Now, of course, there are reasons and times where like it is absolutely fair for the landlord to keep some of the bond. For instance, if the property wasn't left in the legally required clean and tidy condition. Like that would be totally fair, but we need to be really careful that you don't abuse the position that you are in. Which is, you know, you are in a more powerful position than the tenants and I think it's fair to recognise that. And look, we are a pro property investor podcast, right? This is a podcast for property investors. But I think we can still acknowledge that some landlords, some property investors do the wrong things
8:41 Speaker 00 and that gives the rest of us a bad day. And I think that's okay to say.
8:45 Speaker 01 And the great thing in New Zealand is we do have a very easy system for deciding who's right and who's wrong if you do have a breakdown in that kind of situation. So I've been reading some emails recently where a tenant thought that their property was clean enough to hand back over to the property manager. Property manager said, no, we disagree and got cleaners in. Now, as a result, that comes out of the bond. Now, the tenant's not very happy about this because their claim is they made the house nice and clean and presentable. We did a good enough job. Now, it's a differing opinion now, and if you are in control of the bond, you can understand as a tenant, you might get frustrated that, well, they get to have the final say. Well, that's not the case. If you disagree, you can go to the tenancy tribunal.
9:30 Speaker 01 There's a small filing fee. What is it, 20 bucks or something?
9:34 Speaker 00 I think it's about $22 last time I checked.
9:36 Speaker 01 Yeah, but then you'll get someone who will look at all the facts and they'll decide impartially who's right and who's wrong.
9:43 Speaker 00 But because of all of these stories, tenants will say things like, and I read their comments online, classic landlord S-word. I won't say the word because sometimes there'll be kids in cars listening to this. Don't swear, kids, it's not good. They'll try and pressure you, the landlords, not the kids. They'll try and pressure you or extort you into taking the bond with no real justification. So because there are some bad eggs out there in landlord land, that's the view that some tenants have of landlords. Now, having said that, there are some things that tenants criticize us about that is actually not fair. And one of the main ones is that landlords are all rich and that any increase in rent is totally unfair.
10:26 Speaker 00 So I've seen comments online, I've been trawling through them to understand what do tenants really think about us landlords? And I saw one person say that landlords seem to be hiking prices as high as they want and waiting to see how desperate people will be to grab them. And we should collectively do a renter's strike and all stop paying rent in protest. But what was really interesting to me, Andrew, is I expected to see those comments, right? But I didn't expect to see that some tenants actually didn't feel that way. There was another person saying, you know, interest rates on mortgages are through the roof, local council rates are getting higher too. What do you expect? I'm a renter, not a landlord, but you should expect that rents will, you know, go up over time.
11:07 Speaker 00 Another tenant said, three to four years ago, mortgage rates were about 2% and landlords were able to deduct interest from their taxes. Now, all of those costs are passed on to renters, so, you know, perhaps it's not so surprising.
11:20 Speaker 01 So, these were tenants saying that?
11:22 Speaker 00 These were tenants. There was another one who said, why are there so many sad people out here who attack landlords? They just get and rent what the market is willing to pay. So, I don't think it's fair to say that all tenants hate landlords either, but I think all tenants hate bad landlords. And so, how do you be a good landlord that your tenants don't hate?
11:39 Speaker 01 Well, I think when it comes down to the property that you're renting out, you've just got to ask yourself, would I live in this property? And if the answer is no, then you probably need to do a bit of maintenance. Like, if there's mushrooms and mould and leaks, that's unacceptable. You wouldn't live like that, so make sure you get that dealt with. And I think the other thing is, always just be fair and have open lines of communication. I think that's probably the biggest thing.
12:03 Speaker 00 I always think the best thing we ever said, Andrew, and it comes from our book, is it's your house, but it's the tenant's home. And I think that's a good principle for landlords to live by, because if it's the tenant's home, you're probably not knocking on the door saying, hello, I'm here to check in every week, because legally you're not allowed to do that. That's just harassing your tenants. But also, yes, it's your house, but you don't live there, you don't have rights to just pop around. Your rights are defined by law and they're pretty clear what they are. But I think the issue is, a lot of those people who are bad landlords, to be honest, aren't listening to this podcast. Do you know what I mean?
12:38 Speaker 01 And also, they're probably the DIY property investor, they're probably managing it themselves. Now, there's, again, lots of people that manage their own properties that do a good job, but I think if you don't understand the laws and your obligations, you can be a bit more relaxed.
12:52 Speaker 00 And over the last 15 minutes, you've learned why some tenants hate landlords and why they're not completely wrong. Four stories that show what tenants really complain about and how to be a good landlord that your tenants don't hate. Right, let's wrap it up there, but please don't forget to rate, review and subscribe to the podcast, really does help us get the message out to more people.
13:13 Speaker 00 Thanks for listening to the Property Academy Podcast. I'm your host, Seb McDiener. We're going to be back here tomorrow with even more daily strategies, tactics and insights to help you get the most out of your selling property market. Until next time.
Previous Is The Media Is Rigged Against Property Investors?⎥Ep. 2189 Next Furniture Packages: Scam or Smart Buy?⎥Ep. 2191 Page updated November 15, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated