Pod Insights The Property Academy Podcast Why Property Investing is Surprisingly Good for the NZ Economy⎥Ep. 2156 About this episode Some experts claim that investing in shares grows the economy, while investing in property doesn’t. But is that really true? In this episode, Ed and Andrew break down an article from RNZ that encouraged Kiwis to “break up with property,” and challenge the idea that property investment is bad for New Zealand’s future. You’ll hear:Why comparing $100 in shares vs $100 in property misses the full picture. The hidden productivity behind property investment – from builders to Bunnings sausages. Why both shares and property can contribute to economic growth – and how. Don't forget to create your free Opes+ account here. For more from Opes Partners:Sign up for the weekly Private Property newsletterInstagramTikTok
Transcript 0:08 Speaker 00 Hello and welcome along to the Property Academy Podcast by Opes Partners. I'm your host, Sir Midnight.
0:11 Speaker 01 And I'm Andrew Nicoll.
0:12 Speaker 00 And this is the show that helps Kiwis go from zero to five investment property. So you could be financially free and stick around for the next 15 minutes because you're going to learn the number one reason why shares appear to outperform property, what this share market expert got wrong about investing in property and the real reason that property investing is better for the New Zealand economy than you might think. And people send me articles all the time, people like yourself who listen to the show. And one of the ones that got sent to me a couple of times was one from Radio New Zealand, which was written by Susan Edmonds and the headline was New Zealanders urged to break up with property. And the head of private wealth at Craig's Investment Partners, a guy called Jeremy Williamson, was quoted in there and he was making some points around how buying and selling a house
0:57 Speaker 00 can't grow the economy and that investing in shares could help grow the economy and that's what we needed to be doing. And one of the things that caught my eye was he said that property investment is not the most efficient way to create a better life for the next generation of Kiwis. And he had some interesting stats in there, which we'll go through and figure out, you know, are they true or not? But he said that if you'd invested $100 in a New Zealand house 30 years ago, today that'd be worth nearly $600. But if you'd invested in New Zealand shares, it would be worth about $1,100. So I want to break down these claims, see if they're true. Andrew, that last one around $100 in shares versus property 30 years ago, is that true?
1:41 Speaker 01 I think partly. So first of the NZX 50 didn't start until 22 years ago. So you didn't have 30 years that you could do that. But say you compared it to the American Stock Market Index, $100 in the American Stock Market Index 30 years ago would have turned into $1,177. So absolutely the return makes sense. And so it is completely plausible that if you put $100 in New Zealand shares 30 years ago, that could be $1,100 today.
2:08 Speaker 00 And of course, the NZX was. Around, you know, over thirty years ago, but the NZX fifty index, which allows us to easily track how New Zealand shares have gone, that doesn't exist as much. So, you know, you look at a US stock market index, you say, that sounds plausible.
2:23 Speaker 01 And now again with property, if you put a hundred dollars in property back, you know, thirty years ago, it could be worth five hundred and sixty dollars today. So again, that checks out. Okay. So now you're thinking, oh, what Andrew and Ed have put me wrong. I would have twice as much money if I put that money into shares. But remember, we haven't factored any debt in there. So what I disagree with most about the claim is that property investment is not the most efficient way to create a better financial future.
2:51 Speaker 00 Well, what he said was property investment is not the most efficient way to help create a better life for the next generation of Kiwis. Now, it depends what you mean by a better life for the next generation of Kiwis. Are we talking socially because you don't want property prices to go up? Or are we talking about as a wealth builder? So I wonder whether there's been some quite clever language in there because I think most people reading that would say, oh, so property's not as efficient as a wealth builder compared to shares. But he might say, well, no, I meant more socially. So we don't really know. We actually invited Jeremy to come on the show so that we could have a discussion, not a, not a debate or a you're wrong, I'm right. But so we could have a good discussion. He
3:35 Speaker 00 politely declined and we respect that.
3:37 Speaker 01 So if we do look at the numbers and you think about that hundred dollars that actually now I'm going to put it into property rather than the shares. Well, remember, you're not buying a hundred dollar house. When people invest in property, generally speaking, they are using some leverage. So that hundred dollars, based on a twenty percent deposit, that's actually a five hundred dollar house. Now, again, I know you're not buying a five hundred dollar house, but we're just comparing like for like here.
4:01 Speaker 00 Because when we're talking about leverage, we're talking about getting a mortgage, right?
4:04 Speaker 01 Debt. We're talking about getting some debt. And so because you've used as a deposit, the bank will lend you some money. And if you take that five hundred dollars, and if you could buy a five hundred dollar house or put that into a property thirty years ago, well, that five hundred dollars is now worth. Two thousand eight hundred and thirty dollars. So your equity in that house, that hundred dollars that you put in, that's gone from a hundred dollars to two thousand four hundred and thirty dollars. Now, remember, going back to shares, which got you the better return on the surface, that hundred dollars in shares went from a hundred dollars to eleven hundred dollars. So if we are, if we forget about the social aspect for a minute.
4:44 Speaker 00 We'll cut back to that, though.
4:45 Speaker 01 Yeah, if we're just talking about the most effective way to build your wealth, well, over the last thirty years, a hundred dollars in properties, if you leverage it the correct way, then you will have built twice as much wealth with the same money amount in that than shares, even though it's a lower return.
5:01 Speaker 00 And so, yeah, if you compare it, yeah, taking a hundred dollars to get into twenty four hundred dollars through property or one hundred and going to eleven hundred dollars through shares. And look, I don't think that Jeremy or or Craig's were trying to be misleading. But I do think that a shares person will naturally talk about the good part of shares. And a property person like us, we're naturally going to talk about the good things about property. And if you want to make shares look better than property, you just forget the debt side of it. You know, you just say, oh, you know, buy a five hundred thousand dollar investment property or put five hundred thousand dollars in shares. Well, that's not how it works for most people because you are taking out a mortgage. But there are different ways to do it. I remember talking on YouTube. One person said, if you're going to compare property versus shares,
5:46 Speaker 00 you've got to make it look like you're borrowing five hundred thousand dollars and putting it into shares. And I obviously said, well, that's ridiculous, though, because if you were going to invest five hundred thousand dollars in shares, that could be two or three deposits for investment properties, and you might be able to buy two million dollars worth of property versus five hundred thousand dollars in shares. We've got to think about the leverage aspect. But, you know, depending on on what you want to present, you either include the mortgage or you don't. And so what do I do? The only thing I can do, Andrew, I called up Susan Edmonds from RNZ. And I said, come on, Susan, I think we need to put a counterpiece out there. And she did. And so we released another article with the headline, Property Investors, It's Not Time to Break Up Yet. Now, generally, articles that are positive don't get as many clicks.
6:30 Speaker 00 And don't get as well read as ones that are generally negative. So I'd forgive you if you read the other one, but not my one. But there were two things I was on the phone to Susan and said, Susan, we've got to, we've got to get this across. The first part is about the mortgage debt. So we've kind of talked about that. And I said to Susan, although mortgage debt can be good because it gets you high returns in this example. When property prices go the other way, it can really hurt you. So let's say you put a 20% deposit in for a property in Lower Hut. If that property falls in value by 20%, your entire deposit has just been wiped out, at least on paper. Whereas if you put a 20% deposit into a property and it goes up by 20%,
7:11 Speaker 00 well, the market only moved 20%, but you doubled your money because you only put in a portion of it. But the other thing I really wanted to tackle, and I'm really passionate about this one, is this idea that investing in shares is productive for the economy. It improves the economy and investing in property, nah, that's dirty. That doesn't grow the economy and I think it's wrong on quite a few levels. I'll, I'll let you rant first before I get on my soapbox.
7:39 Speaker 01 Yeah. And you know what? The interesting thing is, back before I met you, I probably was on the camp that I thought, oh yeah, as a property investor, I'm not really stimulating the economy the same way that if I invest in a company, I would be. And, and she is like, I, I, but I just accepted that. Like I'm, I'm here to build wealth for myself. Like I just accepted that I was being credited.
7:59 Speaker 00 You selfish property investor.
8:01 Speaker 01 The reality, but the problem was I hadn't really thought it through. I hadn't gone down the path of thinking, well, what does it actually look like? Cause if you invest in shares, yeah, it can help the economy, but it doesn't always improve the economy. Like people think, okay, I'm going to go out and I'm going to buy some shares in. What's a good New Zealand company? Like my food bag or something like that'll spark, right? And then they're going to have more money to invest in. That's going to employ people and, and it's going to go towards improving the economy. Well, that's not necessarily the case. So if I go and buy a share in NZME for a dollar 15, that dollar 15, that doesn't go to NZME.
8:35 Speaker 00 So the Herald doesn't have more money to go invest in printing presses?
8:39 Speaker 01 No. That's not at all what happens. That money goes to whoever owns that share at the moment.
8:44 Speaker 00 And so if Andrew's got a share, you know, in NZD, a million, a dollar fifteen, and I buy him off for a dollar twenty.
8:50 Speaker 01 It improves me.
8:51 Speaker 00 Yeah, that additional money doesn't go to investing in a company. That goes instead to Andrew Nickel. And so there's this idea that, oh, well, you can't get rich with buying, you know, just buying houses and buying and selling them between each other. That is generally true, but it is exactly the same with shares and that makes up quite a hefty chunk of the market. And even if you think about companies that are raising capitals through an IPO, what's called an initial public offering, that's where, yeah, a company gets listed on the, on the stock market for the first time. If we look at the My Food Bag IPO as an example, they sold a hundred and eighty-five million shares at a dollar eighty-five each, right? So they are raising some serious money.
9:33 Speaker 00 Now, only about thirty million of those shares were newly issued. So they did raise money. They raised fifty-five million dollars to grow the business and invest in the business. And if you bought one of those shares, your money would be going to growing a New Zealand company. But on top of that, there were a hundred and fifty-five million shares that were effectively sold on the secondary market, which is basically the founders and the people who had already invested it cashing out. So fifty-five million dollars of that IPO went to growing the business. Two hundred and eighty-seven million dollars paid out the founders. Now, it's very important that people who are entrepreneurs and start companies can get a good return. So I'm not knocking them.
10:15 Speaker 00 But I am knocking this idea that if you just invest in shares, there's going to be much more money available for New Zealand companies. You buy a share that gives a company money so that they can grow and invest and make the economy better. And that's partially true in this case, but the majority of the money, two hundred and eighty-seven million dollars, was just a transfer from one owner to another owner. And so shares aren't always quite as productive as you might think. Of course, having said that, if more people are investing in shares generally, there's more money sloppier. Around in the share market. When companies do want to raise capital to invest, that makes it a little bit easier. So I'm not trying to say a one sided thing.
10:59 Speaker 00 Shares is always unproductive, but I'm just challenging you to really think about this. Maybe it's not always as productive as you might think. And maybe property isn't always as unproductive as you might think.
11:11 Speaker 01 Yeah, one of the arguments that kind of people have is that New Zealand isn't going to get rich by people buying and selling houses to ourselves at higher values, which is the same as those shares going between people as well. Like, that's completely true. Like, that doesn't necessarily improve everything. But that's not all that property investors do. Just trade properties between themselves and pay more money each time. If you think about, you know, someone like a property flipper, that's productive. Okay, they take an old house, they spend some money on builders, tradies, materials, and they improve the housing stock. And that creates economic activity. That's productive. And if you think about people that are doing new builds, again, like, you know, a building company like Mike Greer Homes, big company, employs a bunch of people,
11:55 Speaker 01 buys a bunch of supplies, pays for a bunch of labour, gets our electricians in there, all the plumbers, there is more money going into the economy as a result of that.
12:03 Speaker 00 That is the definition of economic activity. Even if we think about renovators, if you're popping down to the local Bunnings or the Mine at Ten, yes, you're getting your Bunnings snag, but that's not just the economic activity.
12:15 Speaker 01 Do they still have them?
12:16 Speaker 00 Yes, they do. And I love it every time I go to Bunnings on a Saturday. I make sure I get that. That's my little cheat meal. And if Angela doesn't see me having my first one, then I can have a second one. And I can cheat twice. As well as your snag, you're going to be picking up jib or you're going to be buying new showers or taps. If somebody had to create those taps and somebody owns the warehouse that the Bunnings is in, and Bunnings had to pay somebody to run the ads and the paper. There's power in there, there's staff in there. All of these things are literally economic activity. And if you only think that property investors just buy a house and wait, and you don't see all of the things that they do as well, like doing up property.
13:00 Speaker 00 Properties, sometimes selling them, sometimes keeping them, building new properties. You probably don't think about all of that economic activity that it creates. Even if I think about myself when I'm holding on to those properties, you might use a property manager. You might hire an electrician to come in. You might pay for some materials when, you know what always messes up and craps out is the, uh, the insincereators. When you've got to have that fixed every two years. All of this is economic activity.
13:28 Speaker 01 Your accountant.
13:29 Speaker 00 That property investors are paying for, or your accountant as well.
13:32 Speaker 01 What about money that you pay to the bank? That then gets used to pay interest to the term deposit holders. Like, it isn't just as cut and dry as saying property investment is a lazy kind of investment. It doesn't benefit anyone. Lots of people benefit from it.
13:46 Speaker 00 And you could also make the argument that, well, do you know what though? But if property investors weren't in the market, maybe first home buyers would be able to purchase these houses and they would do all of that maintenance anyway. That's not always the truth. Often we see that when a first home buyer does a reno project, how long does it take them to turn around that reno project? Usually a very, very good long time. And the reason is because they might not be able to afford the reno project. So a flipper even coming in, buying a property, doing it up on selling it. That can make it easier for a first home buyer to have that nice finished home. And it all comes down to bank lending because if they buy it off a flipper, then they're able to borrow eighty percent of the money for effectively those renovations.
14:29 Speaker 00 So there's a lot more economic activity that goes on. It's not just shares productive, property unproductive. And similarly, it's not just the other way around either. Property good, shares bad. You know, there's somewhere in the middle. You know, and Susan did say to me, oh yeah, but if somebody buys some shares and bids the price of a share up, you know, nobody lives inside a share. You know, that doesn't disadvantage first home buyers, whereas if Andrew and I bid up the price of an investment property. Well, perhaps that makes the price of housing more expensive for those first home buyers and so it can have a social harm. And to that I said, well, that's probably very true, Susan, but all I can say is that if I think about how.
15:10 Speaker 00 How I invest, I've added four houses to the New Zealand housing stock and another one of them was heavily renovated, so improved the housing stock. I imagine you've probably built at least 20 houses yourself. And if I think about the investors we work with at Opes Partners, we help build over 600 new homes, new warm dry homes for tenants every year. I can't take responsibility for how everybody else invests, but I can take responsibility for the way that we run our business, Andrew. And what I know is we are enabling a lot of economic activity, as are the investors we work with, creating these new homes for people. And I think that is incredibly productive. Not only do I think it's economically productive, I think it's socially productive, because that means there are more homes available
15:54 Speaker 00 for tenants and for first home buyers when these investors eventually sell. And this isn't about saying, again, that property is better than shares, but it's just tackling some of those traditional arguments. And over the last 15 minutes, you've learned the number one reason why shares appear, that they outperform property, but maybe they don't always, what that share market expert got wrong about property, and the real reason that property investing is better for the economy than you think. Right, let's wrap it up there, but please don't forget to rate, review and subscribe to the podcast. Really does help us get the message out to more people.
16:31 Speaker 00 Thanks for listening to the Property Academy Podcast. I'm your host, Tebbit Knight. Hello, Andrew Nekon. We're going to be back here tomorrow with even more daily strategies, tactics and insights to help you get the most out of the New Zealand property market. Until next time.
Previous Use 1 house to buy 5 more Next The Real Reason Your Council Rates Are Skyrocketing⎥Ep. 2157 Page updated November 15, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated