Pod Insights The Property Academy Podcast Why High Earners Stay Broke – 3 Traps Kiwis Must Avoid About this episode From the outside, he had it all: a clifftop Mission Bay mansion, sports cars, cocktails in the spa. Then his company collapsed ... and it turned out the house was rented and he owned almost nothing.
So how do people earn so much, yet end up with so little?
In this episode, Ed and Andrew unpack the high-income illusion. You'll learn:
Why income and wealth are two completely different thingsThe 3 traps high earners fall intoA simple formula to check if your net worth is where it should beA big salary can just fund a fancier version of broke. Knowing the difference is what actually makes you rich.
Book a meeting https://bit.ly/3QE2XJN to start your path to financial freedom with a detailed financial plan for $0.
For more from Opes Partners:
Sign up for the weekly Private Property newsletter https://www.opespartners.co.nz/newsletter-sign-upInstagram https://www.instagram.com/opes_partners/TikTok https://www.tiktok.com/@opespartners
Transcript 0:08 Speaker 00 Hello and welcome along to the Property Academy Podcast by Obus Partners. I'm your host, Stephen Knight.
0:12 Speaker 01 And I'm Ajun Nicom.
0:13 Speaker 00 And this is a show that helps Kiwis go from zero to five investment property. So you could be financially free and stick around for the next 15 minutes because you're going to learn why people with high incomes still end up poor, the traps that keep high income earners broke and the simple proven plan to dig yourself out so you can finally build wealth. And the reason that this caught my eye is there's a guy called Peter Knight in New Zealand, right? He ran a company called Pipe Vision, which was actually one of New Zealand's biggest pipe maintenance firms. Like, what a business to be in, pipe maintenance.
0:46 Speaker 01 What pipes are around that he's maintaining?
0:49 Speaker 00 All of the pipes underneath all of the councils that are like broken, which is why our water systems are messed up in New Zealand. Oh, what a great job to be in.
0:59 Speaker 01 How would you even know? Oh, you've got broken pipes. We're just going to go in there and fix those again.
1:03 Speaker 00 Well, nobody, nobody ever grows up wanting to start a pipe business, right? So there'd be bugger all competition. But if you looked at him from the outside, you would have been like, this guy's so successful. He's living in a cliff top mansion in Mission Bay. He's driving sports cars. His team members would say that he liked to gloat about his pool and drinking cocktails in the spa pool. But then his business collapsed in 2025. About a hundred staff lost their jobs. The company owed over $30 million. And it turns out the house he was living in was rented previously advertised for about 3K a week. And he actually said to the papers, look, I don't own everything. Everything I had was in the company. Now, let me be clear. I take no pleasure in talking about a New Zealand
1:48 Speaker 00 business that fell over, right? The point I'm trying to make is even if people have very high incomes, they can end up being poor if they're spending too much. And the truth of the matter is, if we look at the data, this is not a one-off occurrence, right?
2:09 Speaker 01 No, not at all. I just can't believe you didn't use the joke of this being a pipe dream. Yeah, there was a, there was a study that came out of Goldman Sachs, a massive investment firm. And it showed that a quarter of workers earning more than a hundred grand a year, so good income, they were living paycheck to paycheck. And what was also quite surprising is that if you increase that to like between three hundred and five hundred, so like really high income, forty one percent of those people, almost half, say that they live paycheck to paycheck. I think the key message here is just because you earn a lot of money, doesn't mean you're got it actually managing it.
2:49 Speaker 00 Well, it's almost unbelievable, right? You can understand that if we look at people over in the States who earn less than fifty K a year, okay, fifty seven percent of them are living paycheck to paycheck. That makes sense to me. And then as your income goes up, right? Like if you're earning two hundred to three hundred thousand dollars a year, sixteen percent of them are living paycheck to paycheck, still a pretty big amount. But once you get above that threshold, it skyrockets and more and more of those people are living paycheck to paycheck. So how is it that people find themselves earning three hundred thousand dollars a year and still are not wealthy?
3:30 Speaker 01 Well, I think the problem is that, that people confuse income and wealth. And just because you're earning this money from week to week, doesn't mean you're actually taking some of it and investing. And you have to actually put some of that money aside if you want to actually be rich. And being rich, that isn't just about having a high income either, because there are plenty of people who have just a normal income, but because they've been investing, they've built their wealth over time.
3:56 Speaker 00 Well, I think being rich is about wealth. It's not about income. But if I think about when I was growing up, if you saw somebody who drove a flash car or, or, you know, had a high income, you're like, daah, rich. But that's income. You're seeing income, but being rich is about the hidden stuff. It's about what do you actually own? That is what wealth Really about.
4:20 Speaker 01 Yeah, and definitely from working with investors, I do think you can earn such a healthy income sometimes that you can be a bit more lazy with your money. And you kind of think, I'll get around to investing later on, or I can afford to buy this nice new car. And people just, that lifestyle bleed just creeps up on them and it gets out of control.
4:40 Speaker 00 Well, that's actually the first of three traps that I want to talk about that high income earners fall into. And I saw the Herald talk a wee while ago about what they called the new wealthy poor. So these are people who have a big house, a big salary, but almost nothing left at the end of the month. Because they're spending it all, right? They're spending it all. And the thing is that if you keep increasing your spending every time you get a pay rise, and that goes to a new car, a bigger mortgage, private school fees, then you could be in no better position.
5:17 Speaker 00 The person earning 300K that spends 300K is worse off than the person who earns 50K a year and spends 45K. Because the person earning 50K a year is is building their wealth by $5,000 a year, while the person earning the massive salary is not getting ahead. And we all fall into it, right? I've fallen, I've fallen into these traps too. I need to beat myself up. I need to learn from the Property Academy podcast. But what we often see is that yesterday's treats really start to become today's must haves. Like, private school is a really good example, right? Nobody needs to pay for private school.
5:57 Speaker 00 But once you start paying it, all of a sudden, it becomes a must have. You can't possibly go back. If you start travelling business class, you can't possibly go back to economy.
6:08 Speaker 01 That's the worst one.
6:09 Speaker 00 But that's the thing, today's treats start to become the new standard and then you feel like you can't go back. But Andrew, talk to us about trap number two.
6:19 Speaker 01 And this example comes from Louis, who's one of our financial advisers. He's got this client, they earn massive income, like $750,000 a year. Huge, right? And, and that's because they're in a, a high ticket sales role. And he came to us in his early 50s, 3.5 million dollar home, couple of small rentals, huge income, big house, big holidays. And the key thing is, even though he's got all these kind of assets, he wants to maintain a high passive income for when he retires. Because of course, one thing you don't do, generally speaking, is you don't go from a 750K a year income down to like 50 grand a year in retirement. People just can't make those adjustments.
7:03 Speaker 01 You get used to the business class flights or the bottle of wine and all those kinds of things. Now, for this guy, he kind of has two options. He can either downsize the house and reduce the mortgage because there's so much equity tied up in it. But that was a no-go for him. So his decision was he needs to start investing. And, and part of that will actually have to coincide with paying down that mortgage. Because no point investing and then getting to retirement, but still having a massive mortgage if you're not prepared to downsize. Now, for this guy, he like has to do some serious investing because he doesn't have a huge amount of time left if he's being in his early 50s. So he needs to invest in 10 properties over the next 15 years. Now, given he's got the income to do that, I think good on him for doing it.
7:48 Speaker 01 And awesome that he's actually doing something rather than getting to 60 and going, it's too late.
7:52 Speaker 00 It's quite interesting, that idea of living paycheck to paycheck. I feel like a lot of people use it, but don't necessarily know what it means. And so I'll give you an example. At our company recently, our CFO, for some reason, decided to change pay systems, right? Now, previously, we used to pay our staff a week in advance. So if you start this week, like working this week, we'll pay you for the work you're about to do this week. With the new system, the new system didn't allow for that. We had to start paying people in arrears. So, okay, you work for a week and then we'll pay you for the week just gone. That's pretty Standard in New Zealand. That's why the software was like, oh, what you guys, you guys are doing it a bit differently. Anyway, so CFO says, we're going to change this.
8:36 Speaker 00 Now, the outcome of that was all of our team basically had to skip a payday. Right? Because we were paying you advance, now we're going to start paying you behind. We did put a system in place, like if you really couldn't do that, we could, we can make it, make it work. But, and most people were like, yep, sweet, we're going to have to skip a payday. And it was a really interesting time because it got me thinking that a lot of New Zealanders wouldn't be able to do that. And that's a really good test of are you living paycheck to paycheck? Which is if you didn't get paid, if you had to skip a payday, how much would it ruin you? And I'm not talking about like, would it not be nice? Like, of course it's not nice to skip a payday, but would it ruin you is the question? Could you handle it?
9:21 Speaker 00 Now, I was, I was pretty lucky. I'd, I'd been investing, you know, I had some liquid shares available. I was like, oh, cool. I'll just not put my savings aside that particular week. I'll just take some money out of my savings and then it'll be okay. But when that happened, I was like, this is the test of if you are living paycheck to paycheck. Is could you skip a payday and would it ruin you? And that probably brings us on to trap number three that high income earners fall into. What, what, what is that?
9:50 Speaker 01 And that's the median household holds ninety-two percent of its wealth in the family home. And I think the key thing here is it's great to have your home and pay that mortgage off over time. Great to have a roof over your head. You need to have somewhere to live. But you don't want all your eggs in that basket because your home gives you somewhere to live. It doesn't give you an income. Like you might, you might have a room that you can rent out or something like that. But you can't just sell it when you get to retirement and live off that money unless you're going to go renting. But not many people are going to do that. And isn't it funny? Like if ninety-two percent of your wealth is in your house, probably the rest of it's in your Kiwi savour. That means that people have got sweet effort, basically.
10:29 Speaker 00 Actually, I've got a bonus trap for you, Andrew. I've got a bonus trap. I think trap number four is that high income earners think that they have more time. The fact that Earn a bigger income does not mean that you can start investing later. I'll tell you what I mean. Let's say your take home pay is double the average in New Zealand. That's your take home pay. Oh, you're on a great take home pay. You might think, well, that's cool. That means that I can like wait to start preparing for my retirement. Cause I can just save more later on, cause I earn a high income. But if you want to maintain that higher level of spending later on in life, when you eventually quit work for good.
11:08 Speaker 00 And you want to spend double the amount of the average person, then you're going to need double the amount of assets. You're going to have to save twice as much. You actually don't have more time or the ability to delay it. If you're going to save 20% of your income and, and the average person saves 20% of their, their income. If you want to spend double what the average person does, you're going to have to save twice as much as they do as well. It's not like you can magically cut it in half. You're gonna have to do the same thing as everybody else if you want to have that, that twice as nice lifestyle later on. Does that make sense? I know it makes sense in my head, but sometimes the words don't come out.
11:50 Speaker 01 It does make sense, but I also think the other part is if you are earning a good income, you often have more options available to you when it comes to investing than people that don't have a high income. And so as such, people then look at everything and they overanalyze the hell out of everything and then just don't do anything. Like I, I met with someone yesterday, paid off house, under 40, really strong incomes, can't make up their mind what they want to do. And if I put that into contrast with like, you know, just regular people who really just don't have a choice, but to invest in property and like get it done now, they're taking action faster than the richer people.
12:27 Speaker 00 I'll tell you one other trap that I see. Oh, look, I thought there was only going to be three. I've got a fifth one for you that I've thought about. If you're rich, every person, every lender loves you, right? If you earn good money, oh God, have a mortgage. You want a bigger one? We'll give it to you. Oh, what's that? You want a credit card? Yeah, you've got a great income. I'll give you a credit card. They will lend you. Money to buy more stuff, even if you don't have the money today. Want a car loan to buy a Maserati? Oh yeah, you can do that. But it's so much easier to tick up consumer credit bubble gum debt. If you're on a high income, whereas if you're a poor person, you probably got to get told no a lot more, right? In terms of being able to take out more debt.
13:12 Speaker 00 You want a credit card? Nah, we're not giving you a fifty K credit card. Here's a five grand one. You want to take out a loan to buy a car? You're not buying a Maserati. Go buy a Toyota Corolla, which is a great car, by the way. I'm not talking down a Toyota Corolla. I drove one for many, many, many, many years.
13:26 Speaker 01 But also the banks just send you the credit cards nowadays. Well, actually, I don't know if they still do that now. But like my card just arrived in the post one day, massive limit.
13:34 Speaker 00 I bet you would have started using it as well.
13:36 Speaker 01 I still do.
13:37 Speaker 00 I remember my first economics teacher, Vinda, who I talk about in our book, actually. I remember her coming in and talking about that. In the mail, she'd just received a credit card with a higher limit because she was using it and the bank said, oh, there you go. We'll send it to you. Now, bear in mind, this is sixteen years ago, right? So I'm not sure if they still do that. But one thing that is really surprising is that nearly a hundred thousand Kiwis are more than ninety days in debt arrears. So they're more than three months late on paying their debt, right? If we look at it.
14:10 Speaker 01 What was, sorry, what was the number again?
14:11 Speaker 00 A hundred thousand Kiwis.
14:15 Speaker 01 Oh.
14:15 Speaker 00 That's a lot, right? But I know of one who was earning about three hundred thousand dollars a year, right? Good mate of mine, but he's still got behind on his power bill. I'm like, how are you earning three hundred grand a year and getting behind on your power bill? Like, you realise that they can shut your power off, right? Like, the electricity company could do that.
14:35 Speaker 01 You do need your power.
14:37 Speaker 00 I mean, that happened to me at nineteen and I was like, never again. Never again will I let that happen.
14:43 Speaker 01 I had that with a rental. It's such a hard process to get the power switch back on.
14:47 Speaker 00 And then you've got to have like the, the maintenance work come in, or at least I did at that point, to turn it back on.
14:52 Speaker 01 Yeah, yeah, I know, I know. It's a pain in the butt.
14:54 Speaker 00 And the reason I think this is so important is for two reasons. One, so that. If you are on a high income, you're like, oh yeah, maybe I do need to get my A into G. Like you can spend more, right? You can be a little less careful than somebody who's on a really modest income. But you can't completely slack off and think it's all going to be okay. And then also I think it's important if you're on a lower income as well. It's important that you're like, oh, everyone's got money problems, right? But you can still get ahead. It's not like having a high income solves absolutely everything. We've still got to get into the right habits. And that's why over the last 15 minutes, you've learned why people with high incomes can still end up poor.
15:35 Speaker 00 The traps that keep high earners broke and the proven steps to dig yourself out and finally build wealth. Right, let's wrap it up there, but please don't forget to rate, review and subscribe to the podcast. Really does help us get the message out to more people.
15:55 Speaker 00 Thanks for listening to the Property Academy Podcast. I'm your host, Stephen Knight.
15:58 Speaker 01 I'm Jacob.
15:59 Speaker 00 We're going to be back here tomorrow with even more daily strategies, tactics and insights to help you get the most out of the new selling property market. Until next time.
Previous How Far Would You Go to Save $100k? The 5 Levels of Savings Next How to Invest in Property on One Income – 5 Real Kiwi Stories Page updated November 14, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated