Pod Insights The Property Academy Podcast What's The BIGGEST Misconception About Ideal Tenants?⎥Ep. 2114 About this episode When you imagine the perfect tenant, who comes to mind? A young professional couple? No pets, no kids, high income, long-term renters? That’s what most new landlords think. But they’re wrong. In this episode, we reveal the surprising truth about who actually makes the best tenants – and how first-time landlords often get it backwards. You’ll learn:Why the tenant who looks worst on paper might be your best long-term renterThe crucial difference between “ideal buyer” and “ideal tenant”Why high income doesn’t always mean low riskWhat real property managers look for when picking the right personHow to challenge your assumptions (and avoid costly turnover) Don't forget to create your free Opes+ account here. For more from Opes Partners:Sign up for the weekly Private Property newsletterInstagramTikTok
Transcript 0:08 Speaker 00 Hello and welcome along to the Property Academy Podcast by Opes Partners. I'm your host, Steve Knight.
0:12 Speaker 01 And I'm Andrew McCall.
0:12 Speaker 00 And this is the show that helps Kiwis go from zero to five investment properties. So you can be financially free and stick around for the next 15 minutes because you're going to learn how to spot the perfect tenant, the psychology of renting versus selling and what most property investors miss around this, and when the wrong tenant on paper actually turns out to be right. Now, let me give you an example of what I mean. I was talking to some of our property managers in Christchurch and I've been looking for a tenant for a property. Now, they did a viewing, this lady turns up. Now, she's just been living in social housing, she's kind of got limited English, been on the benefit, single mum, and the rental reference that she'd put down of call this person to
0:54 Speaker 00 make sure I pay my rent was a kinder or a tenancy manager. Now, if you think in your mind about whether this is going to be a good tenant or a bad tenant, most people would say, that's not the sort of person I want to be renting to. You know, maybe she's not going to pay your rent on time, maybe she's not going to stick around, maybe there's going to be some damage in the property from her kids. But that happened back in 2023. Two years later, the tenant's there, she's paid her rent every single time, on time, the house is immaculate, she's actually put down some like protection or like, she's put some mats on the floor to protect the carpet from like wear and tear, and the oven, the appliances, they still look brand new.
1:39 Speaker 00 And so today's show is about challenging those ideas or stigmas that we sometimes have around what the ideal tenant looks like. Because Andrew, if I was to ask you, what do most new landlords imagine when they think of the perfect tenant?
1:57 Speaker 01 They probably think about themselves back when they were in their twenties or thirties, where you know, maybe they're maybe they're starting their family out, but they're, you know, they're a nice young couple, both of them probably working at the moment. Decent incomes, maybe, let's imagine a doctor or a lawyer and maybe a, you know, a teacher or something like that. No pets, no kids probably, you know, maybe that that's on the horizon, but the reality is they don't have any kids at the moment. Basically, they just don't have any inconvenience. They come home, they have their dinner or they have dinner out, they come home to sleep and then they go back to work in the morning. And they're probably not going to have parties or anything like that. But to be honest, that's not your regular tenant. That's a unicorn. You might get someone like that, but the reality is you're probably not going
2:41 Speaker 01 to. And if we think about, you know, those type of people, they're probably the people that you're going to sell that property to in, you know, 20 years' time. That's probably your future buyer for this property. That's probably not your tenant now.
2:55 Speaker 00 And that's the important thing. When we say the difference between selling a property and renting a property, because those people who have good incomes might be in the position where they're only going to stick in your property for six months, 12 months, then they might end up buying somewhere else and buying their own home and they're not long-term tenants. And I guess the issue with this is that when we think about that ideal tenant, you know, the doctor and the teacher who have no kids and no pets, that kind of picture in our minds is just an image. It's not really based on anything. And as I kind of said, even if they look great on paper, there's no guarantee that they stick around. And I saw this with another property that we were, we were managing. About 1,300 investors trust us to look after their properties. And so I like to
3:39 Speaker 00 keep tabs. There were some fantastic tenants on paper, kind of mid 30s couple. They're both working, you know, good jobs. They moved into the house pretty quickly. And they are great people, but after six months, they ended up buying another house. And it all worked out fine because they were on a fixed term tenancy. So they kept paying the rent until a new tenant was found. But if you are a landlord, sometimes it's better to have someone in there for three, four, five years, who's consistently paying the rent, because then you don't have to worry about finding a new tenant and going through that. And you don't have to worry about any vacancy. I'm not saying that, oh, wow, we never should have rented to that lovely couple who ends up
4:21 Speaker 00 buying their own home. I only want to rent to people who can't afford homes. Ha, ha, ha. That's, no, that's not what we're saying. We're just saying that that ideal tenant in your head also has some drawbacks, which is that they might not stay that long.
4:34 Speaker 01 Actually, that reminds me of a property that I rented once back when I was managing properties myself, like renting them out myself. I remember, this is probably what gave me the unjustified confidence that I was an excellent property manager, because the first tenant I ever put into one of my properties, they just transferred to be like really high up in one of the banks. And he and his wife had moved down there, no kids, just wanted a big house. I couldn't believe it. They wanted a four bedroom house for just the two of them. And I was like, absolutely fine. Paid the rent every single week, no problem whatsoever. The property was basically brand new, you know, a year later when they moved out. But of course, yeah, sure enough, once they got settled in, they started looking for a house because they had money to be able to do it.
5:19 Speaker 00 I'll give you another example. You know, a lot of landlords don't initially think, I'm going to rent to retirees, because you might have in your head that retirees, maybe they're just living on the New Zealand superannuation, maybe they don't have a lot of money. So potentially, you might not be able to increase the rent by the market rate in the future. But sometimes, these might be people who, for whatever reason, have decided they don't want to own a home, but they can still be really good tenants. And I think this goes with single mothers as well. You know, my mum was a single mother and she has owned her own house forever. We were never renters, but we would have been, you know, we would have been great renters. We would have stayed in place for a long time.
6:00 Speaker 01 And actually, I'll tell you what I heard the other day. So again, we're talking about doctors being those perfect tenants before. So, you know, high income, stable jobs, but we had a property which was rented to a doctor and the property manager went and did an inspection where the house had been kind of rented out room by room to a bunch of doctors. Now, because the doctors worked such long hours, they had no time or interest in doing any of the housework. And actually, cleaning the house was just not on their radar. So as a result, the property was just a shambles. And actually, I'm just thinking about this. I dated a girl who was a doctor a long, long time ago, and she's messy as hell.
6:41 Speaker 00 Really?
6:41 Speaker 01 Yeah, always had stuff on the floor. Couldn't believe it.
6:44 Speaker 00 Okay, that's interesting.
6:45 Speaker 01 Yeah.
6:46 Speaker 00 And we're not obviously saying all doctors are messy people.
6:48 Speaker 01 No, no, no, no.
6:49 Speaker 00 Saying that sometimes you have the picture of the perfect tenant, oh, that doctor's never home. So that it's gonna be so clean. But sometimes if you're renting out to somebody who has a high pressure job, well, unless they hire a cleaner, maybe house cleaning isn't that high up on their radar. So it's not a dig at doctors, it's just to say that we typically have this thought process that high income tenants are good tenants and low income tenants are bad tenants. Because maybe they're not gonna pay the rent on time.
7:18 Speaker 01 Were you a good tenant?
7:19 Speaker 00 And that's not always the truth.
7:20 Speaker 01 Were you a good tenant? Were you tidy?
7:23 Speaker 00 Uh, not particularly.
7:25 Speaker 01 Your desk is never that tidy, that's what made me just kinda.
7:28 Speaker 00 Oh, no, my house is usually pretty clean. But e- even if we think about, so when Angela and I moved up to Auckland, we were renting. We had a nice place and in fact, we rented a place that the tenants prior were both doctors. And so they had set up this, this code to get into the storage locker where the code to get in was pill. I only say that to reveal all their secrets.
7:49 Speaker 01 Yeah.
7:49 Speaker 00 But we only stayed in that property for eighteen months before we, we bought a house. And so that kind of goes, goes to show that really does happen. But I'll give you another example where looks can be deceiving. I was talking to another property manager, this one was from Barford and Thompson in Auckland. And this property manager told me they were doing a viewing for a house and she had two older men turn up to the property. They'd been renting together for, for a long, long time, they were good old mates. But the house that they'd been living in ended up being demolished. And so th- these guys turn up looking for a new property, they kinda look rough around the edges. Didn't, you know, just, I wanna say a bit unkempt, if I can say that, you know?
8:29 Speaker 01 It's not like you've named them, you can say it.
8:32 Speaker 00 They look a bit unkempt.
8:33 Speaker 01 Oh, Stephen Bill.
8:35 Speaker 00 Hey, you can't say that. Can't say that about Stephen Bill and the couple of holes in their T-shirts. But they ended up passing all of their checks, like a credit check, you know, talked to previous landlords. Actually, they were all fine. Four years later, they're still there.
8:50 Speaker 01 Really?
8:51 Speaker 00 And.
8:51 Speaker 01 This could be you and me post divorce.
8:53 Speaker 00 Post our divorce, I'm taking it for every dollar I can.
8:58 Speaker 00 And don't you listen to the previous episode?
9:03 Speaker 00 But these guys do their own gardening, they do their own like minor maintenance. The house is still immaculate, a good tenant despite the fact that they didn't turn up in a suit and tie at the viewing inspection.
9:15 Speaker 01 And look, we're not saying go out and find your own version of Bill and Steve, the scruffiest two that you have got the lowest possible income. And you're thinking, oh, this might be a little bit sus. They might be sus as well, but what we're saying is you can't judge a book by its cover. Like there are so many instances where I've been so pleasantly surprised once I've given someone a chance when renting out a house to them. And there's been other times where I've been really disappointed where I've kind of thought something was a sure bet and it really isn't.
9:44 Speaker 00 And one of my favourite economists, who's not really an economist, was a guy called Daniel Kahneman. And unfortunately he's passed away now, but he wrote a book called Thinking Fast and Slow. And he introduces this idea of system one and system two thinking. So system one thinking is the thinking fast side of things. And that's where I ask you a question, what's the perfect tenant? And you go, somebody who is a doctor or a teacher and they earn good incomes, so they don't have kids, they don't have pets. And that's just your initial reaction. That's system one, quick thinking, which sometimes is wrong. System two thinking is the slower, more deliberative thinking where you think, well, who actually is the best hand? Probably someone who's going to stick around for a couple of years because that minimises my vacancy.
10:27 Speaker 00 And if they're going to stick around for a couple of years, do you know what? They're probably going to look after the place. And you might not think that single mums initially are going to be the greatest tenants because maybe they're just on one income. But then you think, well, I've met a lot of single mums and they're usually pretty organised people and they want to do right by their kids. So sometimes, you know, of course, some single mums are going to be messy, some are going to be very clean. And when I talk to single mums, their number one priority is keeping a roof over their kids' heads. And so in my experience, they tend to make sure the mortgage is paid and the rent is paid. And so the reason we're recording this podcast is to try and get you out of system one thinking. We were just like, who's, who's the best hand? Single person with no kids and no, and no pets. And get into more, well, who really is the ideal tenant?
11:13 Speaker 00 Maybe it's if you've got a four bedroom house, it's going to be a family who is going to stick around for a couple of years, probably.
11:21 Speaker 01 And of course, you still want to do your checks. Okay. So yep, maybe a bit of gut feel there, but also do your credit check. And I think one of the biggest ones is talk to the person's previous landlord and or their employer. Like, I know that that's what our team does with the properties that we look after. But, you know, if you're doing this yourself, credit checks, chat to previous landlords and or employer, and, you know, again, apply a little bit of that common sense. And if you're looking at a credit check, sometimes you might not just go off the credit score. So maybe someone's got a really low credit score, but there might be a reason for that. If it is a single mum that just, you know, can't afford to be putting things on tick, maybe they don't take out after pays and pay them back, or credit cards and pay them back. So they, their credit score might be relatively low, but there's a very good reason for that.
12:05 Speaker 00 Because they don't use credit at all. And I think especially at a time when the rental market is a little slower, and also the tenancy rules have changed, like the 90 day no cause terminations, where if you really do rent to the wrong person, you can ask them to move out with 90 days' notice. That gives you a bit more option to give someone a chance. And it just makes me think of Debbie. We recently had Debbie on Case Study Sunday, and she talked about that she'd bought a property in Vicargal and rented that out to a single mum who had a child who was autistic. And you might initially think like, oh, okay, maybe there's going to be some, some issues depending on, you know, how far on the spectrum this person is for autism. But in the end, that tenant paid the rent every single time and wrote
12:48 Speaker 00 Debbie a letter saying how grateful she was to live in that home for that time, and that Debbie gave her a chance. And I'm not saying that, oh, you should just do the most heartwarming thing that you can possibly think of. It's to challenge your assumption around what is the ideal tenant, because sometimes it's not going to be the person you think it is. And so over the last 15 minutes, you've learned how to spot that perfect tenant, the psychology of renting versus selling, what most property investors often miss, and when the wrong tenant on paper actually turns out to be right. Right, let's wrap it up there. But please don't forget to write, review and subscribe to the podcast. Really does help us get the message out to more people.
13:31 Speaker 00 Thanks for listening to the Property Academy Podcast. I'm your host, Tim Atten.
13:34 Speaker 01 And I'm Andrew Nichol.
13:35 Speaker 00 We're going to be back here tomorrow with even more daily strategies, tactics and insights to help you get the most after you sell property market. Until next time.
Previous Why It’s Taking Longer to Find Tenants – and What You Can Do About It⎥Ep. 2113 Next Our Top 9 Unhinged Financial Mistakes (NZ)⎥Ep. 2115 Page updated November 15, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated