Pod Insights The Property Academy Podcast What If I lose Everything? And Have to Start Again?⎥Ep. 2184 About this episode It’s the nightmare scenario every investor worries about: the market crashes, your property value halves, you lose your job … and you’re left with nothing but debt. In this episode, Ed and Andrew tackle that fear head-on. They walk through what a true worst-case scenario might look like – and why it’s often not as devastating as you think once you break it down. You’ll learn:The 3-step process to work through the fear of losing everythingWhy even in downturns, most Kiwi property owners still make a profit on resaleHow to weigh the upside against the downside (with real numbers from NZ property data)This episode isn’t about ignoring risk – it’s about putting it into perspective so you can keep investing with confidence. Don't forget to create your free Opes+ account here. For more from Opes Partners:Sign up for the weekly Private Property newsletterInstagramTikTok
Transcript 0:08 Speaker 00 Hello and welcome along to the Property Academy Podcast by Obus Partners. I'm your host, Seb Knight.
0:12 Speaker 01 And I'm Andrew Nichol.
0:12 Speaker 00 And this is the show that helps Kiwis go from zero to five investment property. So you could be financially free and stick around for the next 15 minutes because you're going to learn what if I lose everything and have to start again, how to protect yourself against losing all your money and the three steps to help you think through this fear. And I think one of the biggest fears that property investors have is that they will lose everything, that they buy an investment property, interest rates go up, house prices go down, they lose their job, they're now in negative equity and they've got to sell because they can't afford the mortgage. And all of a sudden, after you sell that property, you still owe money to the bank and you've got nothing to show for it. You've got to start again completely from scratch.
0:53 Speaker 01 Yeah, and I think it's a genuine fear because if you think about how most people invest, most people use the no cash needed method. So they're going to borrow 100% to buy a rental property. Now, you can only do that if you've got equity in your own home or another rental property. So you might have all this equity that you've built up over the years diligently paying down your mortgage. Are you going to put all of that at risk to invest in property? And if the market does drop, your house value goes down, your rental property value goes down. If you have to sell everything, you could be starting at zero again.
1:26 Speaker 00 And we've got three ways to think through this fear to kind of try and tackle it. And the first one that sounds really weird and counterintuitive is to say, well, maybe that's okay. Now, let me be clear, it's not, it's not okay if you lose everything, but I do want you to think through what that looks like. So I'll give you an example. So someone told me about a guy once who was 35 years old. He was leveraged up to his eyeballs. He had borrowed as much money as he could and bought as many houses as he could, right? So I think he had about six or seven properties at this age of 35, which has gone really, really well, but he had a lot of debt. And I know that his friend said to him, what happens if you take out too much debt and you go broke?
2:07 Speaker 00 And he said, well, maybe that's okay because if I've got to start again at 40, that's actually not so bad. That's the same position as a lot of people are going to be in anyway at that age. So I might as well go hard.
2:20 Speaker 01 Now, just to clarify, Ed's not saying, just don't worry about the risks, just go take out a whole bunch of debt, it doesn't actually matter. What he's saying is to think through what the worst case scenario actually looks like. Because maybe when you look at the worst case scenario, you're okay with it.
2:39 Speaker 00 It's a bit like a horror movie. Yeah, I always think about, let's say it's Jaws or, what's that other one where there's a big T-Rex?
2:46 Speaker 01 Jaws isn't a horror movie, is it?
2:48 Speaker 00 I don't know, I've never watched it, Andrew. This is a bit like the other podcast we did about, don't just read the headline, but for movies, I do that. Or Godzilla, or, you know, when there's a movie, it might be a thriller, Scream. And then the scariest part is when you can't see the killer. The scariest part is where you can't see the monster, because you don't know what it looks like. And I think that is exactly the same when it comes to thinking about risks and worst case scenarios. If you can define what the worst case scenario is, and say, this is what the worst case scenario is, it's all of a sudden not quite as scary. Because you say, well, if that happens, what would I do? Now, again, I'm not saying, I'm not saying that maybe that is okay, but if you actually
3:32 Speaker 00 said, um, what would that look like? It will make it less scary.
3:35 Speaker 01 And I'll give you another example. I was talking to a friend the other day, and she's thinking about going self-employed. Now, for a lot of people going self-employed, not having that certainty of income, that's quite scary, right? You might not be able to pay your bills. And obviously, she's been hesitating with this decision because she's got those natural concerns. But when she thought about what the worst case scenario is, I'll just go back and get a job again. Well, that's manageable.
4:04 Speaker 00 Well, that's what you're doing now, isn't it? Like, if you go out self-employed as a contractor, or you start your own business, obviously you lose, lose some income, you might have to dig into your savings in order to be able to fund your lifestyle, where you're getting this business up and running, or going out as a contractor. But the worst case scenario often is that you go back to what you were doing before. And so her current position is kind of her worst case scenario. Now, yes, she's going to spend some money starting that business, you'd want to quantify that, but actually, the worst case scenario is doing what she's doing now with a little bit less cash, or with a little bit less savings. And actually, when you put it that way, the worst case scenario is not that bad.
4:40 Speaker 01 And then the other side to that is, if she stays in her current role, her worst case scenario is, well, her income might not increase as much as if she goes self-employed.
4:49 Speaker 00 Now, the step two in thinking through this is to quantify the percentage chance that things go right or wrong. And the reason I say this is, let's say that you come up with the upside and the downside. So let's say it's investing in property and like, okay, what are the upsides? Well, the upside is the property might go up in value. The downside is the property might go down in value. And the risk here is that you think that the odds are 50 50. That the upside is just as likely as the downside and the downside is just as likely as the upside. But often, that is not the case. Sometimes the downside might be more likely than the upside and the opposite can be true as well. And so when it comes to property, the main thing that I look at is Cotality's pain and gain report,
5:34 Speaker 00 which basically says, of all the people who sold their properties over the last three months, how many people sold their properties for more than they bought them for? And how many people sold their properties for less than they bought them for? And about 90% of people who sold their properties in the last three months, at the bottom of the market, is about 90%, 89.4% if you want to be pedantic. Which means that one out of 10 people currently selling their properties, one out of 10 people are selling them for less than they bought them for. But nine out of 10 sellers are walking away with a gain. Which is basically to say, well, the odds aren't 50 50, right? In terms of buying a property and it going up in value. And I realise that's quite a crude measure of success.
6:17 Speaker 00 Because if you really want to get into it, you'd also factor in things like cash flow. You might factor in things like opportunity cost. Well, if I didn't buy this property, maybe I could have invested in shares. This is a kind of crude way of looking at it. But I also know that that's the way that a lot of New Zealand investors do look at investing in property. And so saying, actually, 90% of homeowners are currently at the bottom of the market, selling their properties for more than they bought them for. That kind of tells you the odds aren't 50 50. Even if I go through and I use one of my fancy economic models to figure out what's the chance of a whole heap of bad years happening in a row, such that you buy a property and, you know, the market just turns to crap. Well, if you own a property for 10 years,
6:57 Speaker 00 my model suggests there's about a 10% chance that the value of your property's gone down. But there's a 90% chance of some increase. Again, the odds aren't 50/50. If you buy a property and you hold it for 20 years, well, some properties just aren't that good. So my economic model says there's about a 4% chance that property values have decreased or your property value has decreased, even though you held it for 20 years. But then on the other side, there's a 96% chance that there's been an increase in the value of that property. Again, the odds aren't 50/50. So if we're thinking about the ups and the downs, we've got to think, can we handle the downside? Which is step one, but then you've got to think, well, how likely is the upside versus the downside?
7:41 Speaker 00 Because often it's not 50/50. And that brings us to step number three.
7:45 Speaker 01 And this is when you weigh up and quantify the upside versus the downside. And so what you're looking at is how much you could realistically gain versus what's your worst case scenario of what you could realistically lose? So I'll give you an example. Let's say you've got a 90% chance that you double your money. But there's still a chance that you lose half of your money, but that might only be 5%. So in that example, I'd look at that and say, okay, I'm a betting man. The odds are in my favour, I'd probably invest.
8:15 Speaker 00 It's quite hard sometimes to run these numbers, right? Because again, you could say, I'm about to invest in property. The upside is my property goes up by $300,000. The downside is my property could go down in value by $300,000. But again, those things aren't equally likely because property values tend to increase over time. And so again, I did a simulation, I used one of my economic models, which takes data from the past and basically use that to figure out, well, how likely is it that property prices go up or down in the future? So I want to make these numbers really simple for you. If you buy a $500,000 property and you hold it for 10 years, there's about an 80% chance, about an 80% chance that you make at least $109,000.
9:00 Speaker 00 So that's the upside, 80% chance of making at least $110,000, basically. But there is a 5% chance that you lose at least 85 to 90 grand. So if the market turned to absolute crap. And we got bad year after bad year after bad year. There is a small chance that you lose about $90,000. But there is an 80% chance that you make at least 110 grand. Now, these are all based on assumptions. It is a simulation, right? It's an economic simulation, one that most financial advisors use. But what we're trying to hear is talk about probabilities. Acknowledge that there is a chance that the market turns to crap. But there is a high likelihood that even if there are quite a few bad years in a row, you can still make decent amount of money.
9:44 Speaker 00 Again, an 80% chance that you make 109K. So that's just over 20% return. And there is a small chance, a 5% chance, that you lose at least 85 grand.
9:53 Speaker 01 And I think also the extreme cases are the ones that we talk about. So the guy that made half a million dollars on a property that he owned for a few years. You talk about that. Similarly, the guy that lost half a million dollars investing in a property and had to sell it. We talk about that. If you're considering investing, I can understand how people work themselves up one way or the other.
10:15 Speaker 00 And so again, recapping those three steps, what are they?
10:18 Speaker 01 So number one, you've got to think through what's the worst case scenario? And what does that actually look like? And part of that is, can I tolerate that? Number two, you've got to think about the likelihood that it goes that well or that badly. And number three, consider the upside as well as the downside.
10:35 Speaker 00 Yeah, and putting some numbers around this, quantifying what that upside and downside is. Like, it's easy for me to sit here or stand here and start rattling off numbers and say, this is what the probability is. And you're like, well, that's great for your simulation, but my situation's a little bit different. So how do I run these numbers myself? The honest answer is, is you either go and get a full year economics degree or...
10:57 Speaker 01 Ask AI.
10:58 Speaker 00 Well, you could ask AI, but what you'd really want to do is talk to a financial advisor. Financial advisors in New Zealand should be running these kinds of numbers for you and be talking about probability in a way that you can really understand and be like, oh, cool. Now I understand that, yes, there is some downside or potential downside, but I know how likely that is. And over the last 15 minutes, you've learned what if you lose everything and have to start again? How to protect yourself against losing all your money? And the three steps to help you think through that fear. Right, let's wrap it up there, but please don't forget to rate, review and subscribe to the podcast. Really does help us get the message out to more people.
11:40 Speaker 00 Thanks for listening to the Property Academy Podcast. I'm your host, Sibby Knight.
11:43 Speaker 01 I'm Andrew Pickle.
11:44 Speaker 00 And we're going to be back here tomorrow with even more daily strategies, tactics and insights helping you get the most after you sell property market. Until next time.
Previous The Government Won't Pay Me NZ Super – Here's Why⎥Ep. 2182 Next Brutal Money Advice That ACTUALLY Helps⎥Ep. 2185 Page updated November 15, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated