Pod Insights The Property Academy Podcast We tested if selling your house at auction ACTUALLY makes you more money⎥Ep. 2091 About this episode In this episode, we discuss whether auctions really get sellers a better price … or if it’s all just hype from real estate agents. We reveal:What the actual data shows about whether auctions sell for more than other methods (like negotiation or deadline sale)Why some houses do better at auction, while others flopHow long it takes to sell your property using each methodPlus, we share the unexpected truth about how real estate agents treat selling their own homes … and what it means when they’re selling yours.👉 If you’re getting ready to sell, check out this free guide on how to sell a house in NZ to help you get the best price possible. Don't forget to create your free Opes+ account here. For more from Opes Partners:Sign up for the weekly Private Property newsletterInstagramTikTok
Transcript 0:08 Speaker 00 Hello and welcome along to the Property Academy Podcast by Obus Partners. I'm your host, Seb Knight.
0:11 Speaker 01 And I'm Andrew Nicoll.
0:12 Speaker 00 And this is the show that helps Kiwis go from zero to five investment properties. So you can be financially free even when you don't know whether to trust your real estate agent. Now stick around for the next 15 minutes because you're going to learn how to sell your house for the best price, the fastest way to sell your house and what economics reveals about how real estate agents really sell their own homes. Now, this comes from a listener of the show who emailed in and said, look, I don't understand why real estate agents always suggest auctions in my area. She says, in my experience, a deadline sale or a tender is better for a seller, though I personally love auctions as a buyer. So do the numbers actually show that auctions result in higher sales prices?
0:57 Speaker 00 So, great question. We've gone away, we've crunched the data. And just before we get into whether auctions deliver a better sale price, how many properties actually go to auction? And are real estate agents favouring auctions?
1:12 Speaker 01 So if you jump on realestate.co.nz, there are over 43,000 listings overall right now. Now, of those, 24,000, which is 56%, have a price. They've got an asking price on there or a buyer's inquiry over something like that.
1:27 Speaker 00 Did that surprise you?
1:28 Speaker 01 I was actually very surprised about the numbers in this episode.
1:32 Speaker 00 I was very surprised because in my experience, maybe it's just the properties that I've looked at. I'm like, they're all auction or by negotiation.
1:41 Speaker 01 Yeah, hard to get a price out of it.
1:44 Speaker 00 Yeah, but when you break it down, I was like, that's interesting. There'll probably be some big regional differences there too.
1:49 Speaker 01 I think so too. 14,000, which is about a third, they're by negotiation, so no price shown. 5% of them, 2,100, were deadline sale. Only 5%, 2,000 properties were auctions. And then the other 1% was tenders, which is kind of like auctions. But that number is way lower than I expected it to be. So a lot of real estate. State agents do recommend auctions, but the data shows us that right now, that's probably not the case, the same as it has been in the past. Most properties are selling by negotiation type of process and over 80% of properties listed for sale right now are some type of negotiation.
2:27 Speaker 00 Either listed by negotiation without a price or asking price, which is effectively just by negotiation as well. Now, I was thinking about this because I know for a fact that more than 5% of properties in New Zealand sell by auction. And I was thinking, it must be that auction listings only stick around for kind of three to four weeks.
2:48 Speaker 01 And then they might price it afterwards if it gets passed in.
2:51 Speaker 00 Yeah, because either if it go, if a property goes to auction, most of the time it either sells or it gets relisted as by negotiation deadline sale or some type of other process.
3:03 Speaker 01 But hang on, if you said more properties sell at auction than 5%, doesn't that count to your argument? Because if they come off the auction 5% and then they.
3:13 Speaker 00 No, because what I'm saying is because an auction sales process is often quite quick, right? Like you list it for auction, three weeks later, there's an auction. And so they turn over very, very quickly.
3:24 Speaker 01 Well, I also wondered whether or not properties that end up not selling and get, what are they called, like de-listed, do more of those occur with properties that are priced?
3:35 Speaker 00 Yeah, but I suppose my main point here is it doesn't seem from this set of data that real estate agents are unfairly recommending auctions, which is kind of what this, the question from the list of the show implied. So that leads to a good question. Do you actually get more money if you sell your property via auction? Now, when we're digging into that question, there's a right way to answer it and the right data to look at, and there's the wrong data to look at. I mean, what would be the wrong data to look at?
4:07 Speaker 01 Well, I don't think we can say, let's look at the properties sold at auction and what was the average price of those? And then let's look at the properties that were sold by negotiation. And what was the average price of those? And then compare the two, because they're completely different properties, right? You could have properties that are more valuable, that may be more likely to get sold at auctions. And then you might have properties which are more affordable, more likely to have a price on them. I don't know if that's the case, but let's say that was the case. All of a sudden, you're not comparing apples with apples.
4:38 Speaker 00 Cause what you really wanna know is, if I have a house, will I get a higher price for my house? If I sell it at auction or a deadline sale or something else? So the most correct way that I can think of to do this, even though it does have some weaknesses, which we'll talk about, is looking at the house price compared to the CV. The capital valuation, the ratable valuation, the government valuation.
5:01 Speaker 01 So what, so how much more or less than the CV you get using one of these sales methods? Is that what you mean?
5:07 Speaker 00 Yeah, because then we could take into account the differences in how valuable the house was to begin with. And it's a ballpark, but at least it gets us into the right ballpark rather than just guessing. So if we say that a one million dollar property sells at auction and goes 5% above CV, whereas a one million dollar property that sells via negotiation, let's say it went for 2% below CV. Well, that would show us that auctions get higher prices. So this is kind of the method, the setup for how we're gonna see whether auctions get better prices. So I've looked at sales over the last three months, March, April, May. And I've split them out into properties sold at auction, properties sold by negotiation,
5:51 Speaker 00 which actually includes deadline sales. I can't split them out in the data set that I've got, but auctions, negotiations and tenders. And what we've found in Auckland City over the last three months, the average property sold at auction sold for 8.8%, so call it 9% below CV. And that's because the CVs were set when property prices were much higher. When we look at the average property sold by negotiation, including deadline sales, it's 14% below CV. So it's actually quite, quite a big difference. Auctions, 9% below CV, negotiation, 14% below CV. And when looking at my data and we looked at like well over, I think it was well over 1500 property
6:34 Speaker 00 sales in Auckland City over that period, it was statistically significant.
6:39 Speaker 01 5%.
6:40 Speaker 00 Yeah, five percentage points different. So in this dataset, we actually did find that properties that sold at auction on average got a better price. Now, that does not mean that auctions are right for every single property. And if your real estate agent doesn't recommend an auction, da da da. That's, we're not saying that, we're not saying that. But what we are saying is that properties that do sell at auction, and that's very important, the ones that actually do sell at auction, they do get slightly better prices based on these numbers. Again, I haven't split out negotiation from deadline sales, so I can't tell you that auctions are better than deadline sales in the data, can't split it out. But actually, this surprised me.
7:24 Speaker 00 Auctions did come out on top in Auckland City. But we've also looked at the numbers in Christchurch.
7:30 Speaker 01 Yeah, slightly different story there. So the average property sold at auction sold for 5.7% above the CV. Now, the average property sold by negotiation sold only 2% above valuation. So again, there is statistically significant differences in these numbers. You're still talking, what's that, 3.7% more money if you sell at auction based on these sales. And again, Ed's right, this doesn't necessarily mean that you're going to get 3.7% more money if you're in Christchurch and you sell at auction. This is just the properties that have sold and what the results were there.
8:07 Speaker 00 And that's where we've got to talk about selection bias, which I sometimes call it winner's bias, because here we've talked about properties that sold at auction. So those are the success stories, the ones that met reserve, that that met the price that the seller was actually happy with. So there was competition and the price did get up. And so those are the success stories. Whereas the properties that went to auction and didn't sell got passed in, they probably move into selling by negotiation and later on, they might sell for a slightly lower price.
8:39 Speaker 01 Yeah, maybe there was no competition for the seller, they were unsuccessful at the auction, now it's gone into negotiations and they're kind of done with the process, they just want to get a price.
8:49 Speaker 00 The other side to look at though is, well, how long does it take to sell a house via auction versus negotiation? Because one of the other benefits of auctions is they're quite quick.
9:01 Speaker 01 You get it all wrapped up pretty quickly, right?
9:03 Speaker 00 Which is good for the seller, but it's also good for the real estate agent because they get their commission more quickly. So if, as this listener of the show who emailed in, and I realise there are a lot of real estate agents who listen to the show, so I never like to badmouth you, even though it feels sometimes like a national pastime. What we see in Auckland is that properties that sell at auction sell way faster. So the median property in Auckland City took 35 days to sell if it was an auction. The median property by negotiation took two weeks longer, 49 days on average. And what's interesting is there's a bit of a long tail. So if I look at the properties that sell quickly by negotiation and the properties that sell quickly at auction, they're kind of the same.
9:45 Speaker 00 So if you've got a really good property and it's going to sell quickly, no matter the sales process, we see that. Whether you sell it by auction or negotiation, if your property is above average, it can sell quickly. And when I say above average, I mean in terms of, not necessarily in terms of the quality of the house, but in terms of just how fast it sells. But when we start looking at properties that sell slowly via auction or properties that sell slowly via negotiation, that's where we start to see a really big difference, that actually properties sold at auction sell faster. Does that surprise you at all?
10:17 Speaker 01 No, because I do know that if you do want a quick sale, generally speaking, my belief was that auctions are the way to do that. Because people have to do their work upfront, there's less likely that the can's going to be kicked down the road for longer based on you going back and forth with negotiations, maybe dealing with a couple of different people, drumming up more buyers, creating a multi offer situation.
10:39 Speaker 00 Hmm. And a fair question that you might be thinking as you're listening to the show. Is, is this a good way to measure whether auctions are successful or not? Because when we were talking about prices before, we were talking about comparing it to CVs. And a lot of people in New Zealand would say CVs are crap.
10:57 Speaker 01 Which is fear, to establish a value, yeah.
11:00 Speaker 00 Now, there are issues with CV, like are these council valuations accurate predictors of value? The answer is no, they're not. And we've definitely dug into that in other shows, I won't re-go through those reasons again today. But what I would say is that sale price to CV or sale price to what's sometimes called appraised value, that is how some of the big data firms, like the Real Estate Institute of New Zealand, that's how they figure out if house prices are going up or down. So when I talk about things like the Ryan's House Price Index, and we say, oh, that's a really good measure of data, that uses the same underlying data, looking at the sale price compared to the CV. So it's not perfect, but it is an industry standard way of measuring these numbers.
11:45 Speaker 00 So look at it all, what's better, auctions or not auctions?
11:49 Speaker 01 Well, I think that's when it depends on your actual property. So if your property is going to drum up a bit of competition and it can sell at auction, then yeah, that makes sense. It will potentially get you more money and get your sale quicker. But if your property is more specific and it's not going to generate the same level of urgency and competition, then probably not.
12:12 Speaker 00 And one thing we haven't actually talked about is tenders. I've left tenders out of this analysis because not that many properties sell at tender. And so the data starts to get very noisy. But just to say the complete opposite of what we just said, in terms of real estate agents doing the right things and choosing auctions for the right property. This conversation did remind me of one of my favourite books. I know you've read it too, Freakonomics, do you remember that?
12:39 Speaker 01 Yeah, I've been listening to Stephen.
12:41 Speaker 00 Levitt?
12:41 Speaker 01 Yes, Stephen Levitt on TED Talk just this morning.
12:45 Speaker 00 Was it on YouTube? Was it, was it the 15 minute talk on YouTube or was it a 60 second clip on TikTok?
12:51 Speaker 01 YouTube.
12:52 Speaker 00 And in that great book where they tried to, it was basically pop economics. You know, they took economic concepts and they wanted to explain it really simply, which I totally understand. And what they found in a study from the University of Chicago is that when real estate agents sell their own homes, they leave their properties on the market for about 10 days longer and end up selling them for about 4% more compared to if they were selling those same properties for a client. And the reason is that if you are a real estate agent and let's say you sell a property for an extra $20,000, well, you might get 2% of that and 2% of $20,000 is 400 bucks. And you're like, okay, that's pretty good.
13:37 Speaker 00 But then you've got to remember, well, the real estate agent has got some fees to pay. They're going to be paying part of their commission to their real estate office. So if they work for Ray White Mission Bay or Barfoot and Thompson Milford. And roughly, Andrew, how much of that commission would a real estate agent pay to their office?
13:54 Speaker 01 Probably half of the total commission.
13:56 Speaker 00 That's what I would expect. So if a real estate agent sells your property for an extra 20 grand and they get 2% of that, that's 400 bucks. But then they're only keeping half of that, which is an extra 200 bucks.
14:07 Speaker 01 But it might take them another three weeks to do, to get that extra money.
14:10 Speaker 00 And so what they were saying in Freakonomics, certainly when they looked at the data within Chicago over in the States, is that real estate agents over there didn't have a big incentive to keep the properties on the market longer to eke out that extra 20K because for them it wasn't really material in terms of the extra money they got. But if they were selling their own homes, well, now if I'm selling my own home, am I going to wait an extra 10 days and put in the extra effort to get an extra $20,000? Absolutely. 20 grand is a hell of a lot of money. Now, I'm not saying that real estate agents are dodgy or doing the wrong thing. That's not what I'm saying. But I thought this was a very interesting study and it is an old study. It came from the nineties.
14:54 Speaker 00 It was in Chicago rather than in New Zealand. And rather than saying agents are bad people, I'm saying, hey, look, there are incentives. At play, one reason you might think that a real estate agent recommends an auction is because they sell faster. Now, in some cases, that works for you because you get a high price. But if your property doesn't sell at auction, you've spent some money on an auctioneer and an auction campaign and it hasn't worked out. And obviously, the incentive sometimes for real estate agents is to sell a lot of properties quickly, rather than necessarily get the best price for every single person. Now, Andrew, again, I know there are a lot of real estate agents who listen to the show. Am I being unfair here?
15:30 Speaker 01 No, that, that, that is just the numbers of it. I think you get a pretty good feel for an agent if you meet with someone and, and they're telling you to go auction. You think, yeah, no, that seems reasonable in this instance, or actually, I don't know, maybe they're just peddling auctions.
15:44 Speaker 00 And I know that that's maybe not going to make me very popular. To be honest, I don't go to real estate agent conferences anyway, but I'm sure that, that, you know, saying this won't make me popular with real estate agents. But I also know that if you were at a bar, and you're new in the real estate industry, and you were talking to, to some people who had been in the industry for a long time, they'd probably say the same. The way you make money as a real estate agent is by listing a lot of houses and selling a lot of them, not necessarily waiting to get the best price for every single house. Is that unfair?
16:11 Speaker 01 No, that's true.
16:13 Speaker 00 Well, I'm glad you said that because I know you've had a lot of experience with real estate agents over the years. I know that you yourself have been involved in over a hundred transactions and negotiating over a hundred contracts. And that's actually one of the reasons. We've recently written a guide about how you've gone from zero to 43 properties by the age of 40. And we've written this all out in about 4,000 words in a lot of detail. And we're giving that away for free for the next 30 days in Opus Plus. Now, remember, that is our free tool where you can analyse and run the numbers on any property, any investment property in New Zealand. All you've got to do is go to the link down in the description, or to be honest, just Google Opus Plus. It'll be the first thing that comes up. You create your free account. Not only can you run the numbers on
16:56 Speaker 00 any property in New Zealand, you can also read that guide about how Andrew built the portfolio that he has today. But that will be coming down in the next 30 days. And in the past 15 minutes, you've learned how to sell your house for the best price, the fastest way to sell your house, and what economics reveals about how real estate agents sell their own houses. Right, let's wrap it up there. But please don't forget to rate, review and subscribe to the podcast. Really does help us get the message out to more people.
17:28 Speaker 00 Thanks for listening to the Property Economy Podcast. I'm your host Stuart Knight. And I'm your producer Nicole. We're going to be back here tomorrow with even more daily strategies, tactics and insights to help you get the most out of the future of the property market. Until next time.
Previous The best way to find investment properties in 2025⎥Ep. 2090 Next The EARLIER You Invest, The RICHER You Get⎥Ep. 2092 Page updated November 15, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated