Pod Insights The Property Academy Podcast We Let AI Pick an Investment Property – Here’s What Happened⎟Ep. 2419 About this episode Could AI replace a $25,000 property investment expert… or make a six-figure mistake on your behalf? In this episode, Ed and Andrew run a live experiment using AI to see if you can skip paying for advice. You’ll learn: Whether AI can actually recommend the right type of investment property How well it analyses deals Where AI gets it right… and where it falls short compared to a human adviser The key takeaway? AI is powerful – but it’s not a silver bullet. For more from Opes Partners:Sign up for the weekly Private Property newsletterInstagramTikTok
Transcript 0:08 Speaker 00 Hello and welcome along to the Property Cadaver Podcast by Obus Partners. I'm your host Stephen Knight.
0:12 Speaker 01 And I'm Andrew Nichol.
0:13 Speaker 00 And this is the show that helps Kiwis go from zero to five investment property so you can be financially free and stick around for the next 15 minutes because you're going to learn, can AI replace a $25,000 property investment expert? We're going to do a live experiment to show you if you could save yourself tens of thousands of dollars just using AI, or we're going to find out if AI recommends a six-figure money mistake that could cripple you for life. Because the truth is that some Kiwis spend tens of thousands of dollars working with property coaches and property investment experts, and it could cost you $25,000 or more. And I got thinking, could you replace that with a $30 a month AI?
0:58 Speaker 01 You love AI at the moment. Which one do you use, Claude?
1:01 Speaker 00 Yeah, all about Claude.
1:02 Speaker 01 Every time, every day, oh, me and my mate Claude.
1:06 Speaker 00 Yeah, well, Claude doesn't laugh at me, Andrew, and make jokes at my expense.
1:10 Speaker 01 Just getting to know you.
1:12 Speaker 00 About my appearance. But how much do Kiwis actually spend working with coaches and like property investment experts?
1:20 Speaker 01 We spoke actually recently about Positive Real Estate who recently closed down. I think they were about 10, 20 grand. Property Apprentice, they're about 10 grand, but it can go all the way up to like a 25 grand course with, you know, some of those experts like Steve Goody or Elsa Wolf, the people that are really hands-on in developing a program or a solution for you.
1:38 Speaker 00 And I don't want to say that they're not worth it, right? Because that's not what we're saying at all. In fact, some of their clients do very, very good things. But I think these days I'm seeing more people ask, well, could you just bypass all of that and just use AI and save yourself a lot of money? So we are going to use the number one app on the iPhone Store, which is Claude. It's on track to become the number one AI app. Don't give me that look.
2:03 Speaker 01 Buy from Claude, yeah.
2:05 Speaker 00 So can it actually help you find an investment property? Can it actually help you analyse the numbers? Does it know what it's talking about? We're going to give it a go. So the first thing I want to ask it is, I want to find the highest yield property in New Zealand I can possibly find.
2:25 Speaker 00 Can you find one for me? Yes, to buy, Andrew, to buy.
2:30 Speaker 01 Okay, all right.
2:30 Speaker 00 You see? Oh, I can't wait to find the highest yielding property in New Zealand. Oh. No, won't recommend to me one because that's financial advice.
2:40 Speaker 01 You know, I can't personally recommend a property for you to buy. That'd be financial advice without knowing your full situation. And even as a resident economist, I wouldn't do that to a mate. Sorry, I wouldn't do that to a mate.
2:53 Speaker 00 Well, I'm glad it knows it's my friend. Oh, I love when it uses our website and says the median yields four and a half percent. Okay, don't find me a property, but where should I look if I want massive yields? Okay, in the cargo, if you want the highest gross yields, yields around six to eight percent. Do you agree, Andrew Dickle?
3:15 Speaker 01 Yeah, I mean, I don't know if that's the case at the moment, but yeah.
3:18 Speaker 00 Okay. And then the other places, Wanganui, Rotorua and Dunedin, kind of around that five to six and a half percent. Those are actually lining up with what the kind of numbers I would expect to see. But can you search Trade Me and find me a property that could be high yielding? Like if you, what's the word? If you read what the agents wrote, because that's the source of truth, isn't it, Andrew? Oh, you can't straight trade me. Okay, but I could go to Wanganui or.
3:52 Speaker 01 I like that it's given you how to calculate yield. I mean, it obviously doesn't rely on your ability to do that as your mate.
3:59 Speaker 00 Well, here is a property I found earlier in Springvale in Wanganui. It's got an asking price of about $450,000, so higher than 300K that AI was talking about. And how would you describe this property, Andrew? Because this is the first time you're looking at this, but just for everybody on the podcast.
4:17 Speaker 01 So it looks like it's a little flat type of property. Is it adjoining another unit or is it just?
4:22 Speaker 00 No, it's not. It's standalone, but it's three bed, one bath.
4:25 Speaker 01 It's actually, I mean, it's well presented. It's.
4:27 Speaker 00 That's AI staging, Andrew.
4:29 Speaker 01 Is it?
4:29 Speaker 00 Yes, that's AI staging. That's not actual staging.
4:33 Speaker 01 That's very good. That's come a long way since last time.
4:36 Speaker 00 You think that's good? Look at, look at that. They've got the bedside table in front of the wardrobe.
4:42 Speaker 01 Just bear in mind, I'm quite blind. The TV's quite far away from me. I'm impressed with it though. It's better than it used to be.
4:49 Speaker 00 Okay.
4:50 Speaker 01 I think that the property looks like it's a, it's a relatively older property, but it's, but it's, you know, been tidied up quite well.
4:57 Speaker 00 So let's grab the URL.
4:58 Speaker 01 Good bones.
4:59 Speaker 00 Let's find it. Let's find out. Is this a good investment property? Oh, it's gonna be a rundown. It's gonna be a rundown. What's it say?
5:07 Speaker 01 Okay, the listing doesn't mention a rental appraisal or the current tenancy, which is a yellow flag for an investor. So they're saying that the rent is roughly three eighty to four thirty a week, based on Wanganui rentals. So it's a four point six percent gross yield. That's just the national average, but not that high for Wanganui. I agree with that. Even saying at the top end of the range is not that exciting.
5:31 Speaker 00 But what I'd say is you'd have to verify that, right? Because if it's just taking the average, and we've seen this in the past where sometimes properties might rent for above average. So if you just take the average for the area, you know, it might not be that exciting. But if you actually find out that it rents a bit higher than it could be.
5:49 Speaker 01 Correct. And then it says you want to either be paying less for the property to make it stack up, or again, you want to verify that rent.
5:56 Speaker 00 Well, if I negotiate really hard, because if I was working with a $25,000 property coach, they'd probably say, well, maybe we can negotiate really hard. So maybe say, if I negotiate hard, what could I buy this for?
6:09 Speaker 01 But also maybe what techniques would I use?
6:11 Speaker 00 And what techniques would I use? Oh, this is really a question for your Opus colleagues more than me.
6:18 Speaker 01 Wow, Claude's deferring to me.
6:21 Speaker 00 They'll have sold data. I think they mean solid data. I mean, Claude's even getting me things wrong. Oh, but it could do some checks. This is very annoying. Well, what I want to know.
6:29 Speaker 01 There's some of my, my techniques.
6:31 Speaker 00 What's that?
6:32 Speaker 01 Start low and car hard.
6:33 Speaker 00 Okay, so, so maybe offer 390K. Okay, it's been on since September. So it's been, it's been online for a long time. So you could maybe use that against them because it's obviously not selling at that price.
6:45 Speaker 01 I really like that. Claude, I'm gonna get on, offer a lower price. It's not an insult, just the market talking. That sounds more like you.
6:53 Speaker 00 Oh, come on, Andrew. Well, the other thing, if I was working with a $25,000 property coach, is they would probably look at the floor plan.
7:01 Speaker 01 Yes.
7:02 Speaker 00 And see how they might be able to adjust the floor plan in order to be able to get an extra bedroom in there, which would typically increase the value and would typically increase the amount of rent you could get. And what I often see, there's this, I don't know how I got involved in this Facebook group, but it's an Australian like flipping Facebook group, which always comes up in my feed. Cause I'm old and I now go on Facebook.
7:24 Speaker 01 Yeah.
7:25 Speaker 00 And what often happens is people will like draw on floor plans with how they'd change it.
7:29 Speaker 01 Yeah.
7:30 Speaker 00 So what I want to do is I want to take that image and I want to save that down. And I'm going to say, okay, if I wanted to renovate this property to add an extra bedroom, where could I put it in the floor plan?
7:47 Speaker 01 And maybe what you do, bear in mind, I wouldn't want to go to the council and apply for consent changes.
7:54 Speaker 00 Oh, yes, yes. Okay, what are we gonna see? And I'll pull up.
7:59 Speaker 01 I think this is a really good example as well of being careful what you ask AI to do or not do. And again, we're just doing this on the fly. There might be more considerations that someone who is an expert in this field of renovations would ask and add in there.
8:12 Speaker 00 Okay, so the first thing they'll say is the garage to an e- extra bedroom. So they're saying, oh no, that's actually incorrect.
8:19 Speaker 01 Yeah.
8:19 Speaker 00 They're saying converting a garage to a bedroom is just considered maintenance work.
8:24 Speaker 01 No.
8:24 Speaker 00 As opposed to a change, that would be incorrect because what kinds of things would you need to do to legitimately turn the garage into a bedroom?
8:32 Speaker 01 You'd have to insulate it. You'd have to make sure that you applied to the council for that thing as well.
8:38 Speaker 00 Yes, you'd definitely have to go apply for consent. The other interesting thing is I said, the smarter play might be to just get consent. Garage conversions are straightforward. They're like, oh, typically that's not the advice a lot of people would give. Another place, when you look at the floor plan and bearing in mind that if you're listening on the podcast, you can't see this, right? But the living room is quite large, it's about four by six metres. So what if we said, what if I put an extra bedroom in the lounge? Would that work?
9:09 Speaker 01 Technically, yes.
9:10 Speaker 00 But it creates livability problems is the only living space. Well, actually, it's not picking up the real issue because when I was testing this out before, it was like, oh, you should carve off the living room because there's a living room, a kitchen and a dining area. So you might think like, okay, what I'll do is I'll just carve off half of the lounge. And then this can be my new bedroom, right? Were you thinking that as well?
9:37 Speaker 01 Yes, and then you can walk through, you walk through the kitchen, get a dining area and open that up.
9:41 Speaker 00 Well, that would make a lot of sense, except you idiot.
9:45 Speaker 01 There's a window in the middle.
9:46 Speaker 00 There is a massive sliding door window in the middle. And this is kind of like one issue that we sometimes used to hear when we offered like a renovation coaching service. Is that people would think, oh, this is great. I'll half the lounge, but if there's a massive ranch slider in the middle of your lounge, how are you going to build a wall to like half cut off the ranch slider? And if you extract that or remove it, you're going to have to go to consent and council. Because now all of a sudden you are changing the structure of it. Now, obviously I am no renovations expert, but I would have thought that you would have carved off the kitchen, turned that into a bedroom and then made this an open plan, living dining area there.
10:27 Speaker 01 Yeah, that sounds very, very expensive doing it that way.
10:31 Speaker 00 Well, that's exactly what I know some investors have done and some Hamilton properties.
10:35 Speaker 01 I guess maybe if the kitchen, if kitchen is pretty worn and you're replacing that anyway, or you're thinking about replacing anyway, maybe, but I just think about like plumbing and stuff like that.
10:44 Speaker 00 Well, you'd need to go and get consent for that, right? But it's just to say that that might be preferable, not that you could necessarily add an extra bedroom in here. But that would probably be preferable to replacing the dining area because then you've got a a random kitchen and a random living room that aren't really speaking to each other. And again, although I'm, I'm no renovation genius, this is probably a structure or a wall.
11:05 Speaker 01 Yes.
11:05 Speaker 00 So anyway, I probably wouldn't listen to either A I or myself in those situations because both are probably wrong. What else could we ask it to really test if I could reply like what would somebody ask a twenty five thousand dollar property coach?
11:19 Speaker 01 Why don't we go down the path of if I were to purchase this property for let's say four hundred grand and do some cosmetic renovations and give me a good estimate of what those are, don't add on an extra room, but then I flip the property, what could I expect to make in profits and what would my tax be on that?
11:40 Speaker 00 Okay, what it would cost, how much I could sell it for and what my profit and tax would be, because these are all like basic things that a property coach would be able to tell you, right? So, oh, this is in the financial advice and legal.
11:57 Speaker 01 Okay.
11:57 Speaker 00 I can give you a framework, so we're talking about the bright line, that's nice.
12:01 Speaker 01 Interestingly, I think it said ten year bright line, isn't it?
12:05 Speaker 00 Oh.
12:06 Speaker 01 So it's actually got those details in.
12:08 Speaker 00 Oh, it's incorrect. And what's it saying? Twenty five to forty three grand.
12:12 Speaker 01 It doesn't seem unreasonable. Um, it's quite, it's quite a big number on a four hundred thousand dollar property. So call it thirty five as a working number and then it suggested I might be able to, to uncomplete the purchase and the renovations, some purchase cost of a few grand and then, and then agent at two and a half percent, all in, I'm up for four hundred and fifty grand, give or take. Optimistic sale price is four hundred and ninety, so the gross profit is circa forty grand.
12:38 Speaker 00 Okay.
12:39 Speaker 01 Now, if I'm in the marginal tax rate and I, I trigger bright line, then I could be twenty seven after tax. Now, that's for six to twelve months of work and capital tied up, so the honest verdict is the numbers are quite tight.
12:52 Speaker 00 Do you agree with that?
12:53 Speaker 01 Absolutely.
12:54 Speaker 00 Yeah, I agree with that. Actually, I don't think the numbers that they've given are too insane. Of course, I would tweak them.
13:00 Speaker 01 Pretty reasonable, there's some holding costs in there.
13:02 Speaker 00 Yeah, so that's like interest because you're going to be taking down a mortgage. If you're doing this flip, it has infected that in.
13:07 Speaker 01 I think the agent's cost might go higher than that. Two and a half percent seems pretty low.
13:12 Speaker 00 Has also has infected in like marketing that you're going to have to spend. Like, there's going to be another two, three, four grand on marketing as well for the, when you sell it.
13:19 Speaker 01 It's also got like three grand with the legal cost, but that probably constitutes your purchase, but not your sale.
13:24 Speaker 00 Yeah, so we'd have to take that off as well. Like, this is obviously a bit tight, but there'd be an issue if you were buying a property, wanting to do a flip. And then it turns out that there are lots of costs that you didn't think about.
13:36 Speaker 01 Yes, that comes down to just experience, particularly, you know, if you are really going to turn around that property in a short period of time.
13:44 Speaker 00 Well, I suppose the thing that I'm taking from this is if you're spending like a lot of money, whether it's 10 grand or 25 grand. If you're spending money on a property coach, or let's say you're, you're not even spending money on a property coach. You've got to buy a new build and you come to somebody like an Opes Partners, right? What are you really doing there? You're really going to talk to these people, not just for the information, so that's part of it. But it's also for the confidence that you're not going to make any mistakes, right? And even sitting here, like testing this out, I don't think this is at the, the point where if you are somebody starting out and you're really needing that confidence, somebody to sit with you to make sure you're not making any mistakes. I don't think it's there yet because we can sit here and poke holes in it, right? And be like, oh, that's not right, that's not quite right. Or I'd adjust that because that's too optimistic.
14:28 Speaker 01 But that's because we know.
14:29 Speaker 00 But that's because we know. But if you're somebody being like, okay, should I spend money working with an expert? Or should I just use A I? It doesn't look like it's there yet. Though one thing I wanted to test is, can you, because I know Claude can start to this. Can you build me a tool that helps me analyse an investment property? So it's pumped me out a tool where I can look at the cash flow of a property. So let's say, and this has just done this in what, about 60 seconds?
15:00 Speaker 01 Yeah.
15:00 Speaker 00 So let's say we bought that for $450,000.
15:03 Speaker 01 Yeah, hasn't got the renovation there, but that's okay.
15:06 Speaker 00 But we, we, let's say the rent was 500 bucks a week. It's an existing property, so I'll have to do 30%. Though interestingly. It didn't tell us that like um because otherwise you might think, okay, it's going to be a twenty percent deposit. Okay, let's say a five percent interest rate and we'll.
15:21 Speaker 01 Ah, interesting here. So for the cost, it's given you, a scroll back up. It's given you rates, insurance and maintenance and property management. It hasn't given you other things that we always say you need to include.
15:33 Speaker 00 Like accounting and vacancy because you're not going to have a ten.
15:36 Speaker 01 Or even the letting fee.
15:37 Speaker 00 Well, do you know the other thing it doesn't have? It doesn't have mortgage.
15:39 Speaker 01 Hmm. But you'd assume that would factor that basically deposit.
15:43 Speaker 00 Oh, yes, it has factored that in actually. It's sorry, I lied to you. But what it hasn't done is assumed that, like for instance, if I put in a zero percent deposit and so use the no cash needed method. Okay, cool. It does have negative cash flow, which is what you'd expect to see.
15:58 Speaker 01 And as looked at the cash flow over ten years, total cash flow over ten years. I wonder what it's doing as far as applying inflation and and changed interest rates.
16:07 Speaker 00 Nah, wouldn't it wouldn't be forecasting interest rates, right? This would be pretty basic.
16:12 Speaker 01 Yeah.
16:12 Speaker 00 But you can see that, I suppose, one cool thing that a lot of people wouldn't realise is that you can get it to pump out basic tools like this. Boy, now there are some things you want to be careful about, right? That's why I spent hundreds of thousands of dollars building Opus Plus and building our cash flow modelling tool. Because then you have more control about, but what happens if interest rates go up or what happens if interest rates go down? Or what happens when my costs go up or my rent goes up or I switch my mortgage from interest only to principal and interest at the moment? This is just an interest only kind of scenario. So there's a bit more to it than that. But that's starting to get more useful and shows you where AI is going and you start thinking, okay, well, maybe it it doesn't replace a twenty five thousand dollar property coach today. But give it a year or two, maybe it might.
16:54 Speaker 01 That's really interesting.
16:55 Speaker 00 Oh, that's.
16:56 Speaker 01 That is, that is, that is a bit better than I expected it was going to be. But I do think, like you say, that there are quite a few gaps, so I wouldn't be solely relying on this just at the moment. Because like when we see developers or people who aren't financial advisers putting together a rough spreadsheet for someone, there's stuff missing. And if you go and make a financial decision based on something that hasn't been signed off from a financial advisor, you run the risk of getting it wrong.
17:21 Speaker 00 That's the thing, right? Tells you to do something and you end up losing fifty grand or a hundred grand, right? There's no one you can complain to. You can't call up, oh, ring, ring. It's the CEO of Anthropic, which makes Claude. Hello, I'd like to make a complaint. I lost money because I listened to it.
17:36 Speaker 01 It won't even be a person on the other end of the phone. It'll be Claude himself.
17:40 Speaker 00 Like there, there, there are disclaimers up the wazoo here, right? Around like you shouldn't be relying on any of this either. But like, maybe if you're really experienced, you understand what you need to be asking, you understand and can be like, oh, that's actually not correct. I'm not going to listen to that. Then maybe this could replace a property coach. But if you can do all of that, you're probably not going to use a property coach anyway. Because in that case, you've already got the confidence that you know what you're doing, right? And over the last fifteen minutes, you've learned can AI replace a $25,000 property investment expert? The live experiment to show you if you can save yourself tens of thousands of dollars, or if AI recommends a six-figure money mistake that cripples you for life. Right, let's wrap it up there, but please don't forget to rate, review and subscribe to the podcast.
18:24 Speaker 00 Really does help us get the message out to more people.
18:33 Speaker 00 Thanks for listening to the Property Academy Podcast. I'm your host, Siobhan Knight. We're going to be back again tomorrow with even more daily strategies, tactics and insights to help you get the most out of the new selling property market. Until next time.
Previous He Walked Away With Nothing… Then Made $286K⎟Ep. 2418 Next You’re Probably Wasting Thousands on This⎟Ep. 2420 Page updated November 14, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated