Pod Insights The Property Academy Podcast This Church Deal Looked Amazing… Until the Maths Hit⎟Ep. 2441 About this episode An old church. A near-$1 million budget. And a possible Airbnb conversion in Timaru. So… would Andrew actually invest in it?
In this episode, Ed and Andrew walk through a real deal that Andrew looked at. They break down the renovation costs, Airbnb assumptions, and the harsh reality.
You’ll learn:
How to analyse an unusual renovation project step-by-step Why heritage-style properties can become financial traps The biggest risk with complex renovationsMain idea? A property can look incredible and still be a bad investment. The best investors don’t just fall in love with the story, they stay disciplined enough to walk away when the maths don’t work.
Book a meeting https://bit.ly/3QE2XJN to start your path to financial freedom with a detailed financial plan for $0.
For more from Opes Partners:
Sign up for the weekly Private Property newsletter https://www.opespartners.co.nz/newsletter-sign-upInstagram https://www.instagram.com/opes_partners/TikTok https://www.tiktok.com/@opespartners
Transcript 0:08 Speaker 00 Hello and welcome along to the Property Academy Podcast by Obus Partners. I'm your host Steve McKnight.
0:12 Speaker 01 And I'm Andrew Nichol.
0:13 Speaker 00 And this is the show that helps Kiwis go from zero to five investment property. So you could be financially free and stick around for the next 15 minutes because we're going to go through a live deal workshop. Will this investor spend the money and invest? How to run the numbers on an unusual renovation? And what's the return on investment for an old church? Well, as well as investing in new builds, Andrew, my co-host here, also uses lots of other property strategies. And recently he looked at quite an unusual one. So today we are going to walk through the numbers and at the end of the show, Andrew will tell us if he's going to invest in this property or not. And I think the reason we want to do this is it's good to show you guys that we're actually investing in properties too. So what was the project that you were looking at?
0:57 Speaker 01 So this was a unique one. So one thing that I really like is historic buildings. I just think they're cool. And because Ed and I are both church guys, I thought, well, what I'd really like to do at one stage is I like to restore a church and turn it into something cool. Because I've seen online, some people have done this and something about them just makes me emotionally attached to doing it.
1:19 Speaker 00 It's your grand designs moment.
1:21 Speaker 01 I know, I know.
1:23 Speaker 00 So, but you know how grand designs works. The renovations always go over budget and take twice as long. So what was the specific property you found and how did you find it?
1:34 Speaker 01 Okay, so it started because I thought, well, if I'm going to do this, the renovations are going to be expensive. That's just the way it is. So the only way that I could justify in my mind, making the numbers work is I'd have to buy the church or the property at a low value. And so then I started to think, okay, well, where are there lots of older buildings where maybe there isn't the same historic building restrictions that might hold me up in council? Where I could buy one for a pretty affordable rate? And I kind of want to be able to be within driving distance. So over Easter, I jump in the car with a couple of friends and we drive to Tamaroo. And then we go and spend the afternoon being taken around with a really nice Harquards agent, showing me churches and commercial buildings there.
2:19 Speaker 00 Now, one thing I was really surprised about was like, why are you gonna invest? And I said this, Andrew, I was like, why are you gonna invest near Timorou? Cause you're thinking about buying this old church, doing it up and turning it into an Airbnb. And Skeptical Old B was like, Andrew, who's going on holiday to Timorou? Or like, like, who's, who's going on a business trip to Timorou and booking an Airbnb? Surely there's not much of an Airbnb market there?
2:46 Speaker 01 Well, yeah, and sometimes even I fall into the trap of getting emotionally invested in an idea. And then I start to get confirmation bias and, and, and so I actually went online. Cause the plan was we're gonna all go down there, three families, and we're gonna stay the night in Timorou. And I couldn't find any decent accommodation. And look, I'm a bit of a princess, but there was nothing there that I was prepared to stay in. And it was all quite expensive, like the hotel there that's just been done up is like $500 a night. And it wasn't for me. And so I thought, okay, there's my market opportunity.
3:24 Speaker 01 But really, my driver was being able to buy an asset at a affordable rate that I was prepared to take a bit of a punt.
3:32 Speaker 00 But also, I know off air, you were telling me that the, the local agent and councillor was saying that actually there's a bit of a shortage of hotel accommodation in Timorou. Talk to us about that, cause like, that surprised me.
3:44 Speaker 01 Yeah, so I did, I did say my plans would be to renovate this, turn it into a really cool Airbnb. And what do you think the market's like? And look, sometimes you have to take what an agency's with a grain of salt. But this guy would just seem like a decent guy. And he said, yeah, that's, it's a common complaint we get. They've got a stadium there where they do sports matches. I'm not much of a sports guy, so, so I'm just taking his word for it. And he said, often they just get absolutely stressed with the accommodation. And as such, that's why you're seeing these expensive rates online for something that maybe isn't what you'd pay if like, you, you know, if you spent the same money in Auckland, you'd get really nice hotel for the night.
4:22 Speaker 00 Okay, so there might be a bit more of a market opportunity that, that Skeptical Old Ed wouldn't have initially seen. If you are gonna buy an old church, like, who do you buy it from? Is it the, the, the people who used to worship at the church? Like? Like do you buy it off a parish council?
4:42 Speaker 01 So sometimes, so there was one that I looked at that was running in town and that was still owned by the church and the negotiations would have been with them. Now, as such, they were very selective and they'd entered negotiations that hadn't closed with someone, but they they weren't that happy with kind of the plans for the church. Now, they've got every right to sell whoever they want to. And for them, it wasn't about getting the highest money. It was about making sure, well, we don't want a bar or a brothel or something crazy like that going into our our place of worship, which which I get. Now, the property that we actually ended up going quite deep on with due diligence, that one had already been purchased from a church by an individual. It had been taken off the historic's register, so that meant that actually you could do more with it.
5:27 Speaker 01 You had more flexibility there. And this particular lady, she'd done a bunch of plans to convert it to basically the same thing I was, a residential property. And then I believe she split with her partner and so it didn't work for her anymore. She'd bought a property somewhere else and moved out and now it was basically a big storage unit.
5:43 Speaker 00 Okay, so what was this gonna cost you?
5:45 Speaker 01 So she'd bought it for three hundred and ten thousand dollars. It had been listed at three hundred and seventy five. So I think, oh, this is great. Like, you know, what a bargain.
5:53 Speaker 00 Look at the capital growth.
5:54 Speaker 01 Well, yeah, and and then and then I start to dig into the renovations.
5:59 Speaker 00 Well, one thing that I just wanted to point out is we are seeing more and more historic churches coming to market in New Zealand. And that's because we do have declining congregations. So I saw in Catholic news that church attendance has fallen from about twenty to twenty five percent of the population in two thousand nine. Ten years later, it was just under fifteen percent. I saw that one agent in Southland sold six churches in six years. And there are some churches that are being decommissioned. So the supply is real. The question is, do the numbers work? Because we all have watched enough grand designs to know that, oh, it's so lovely you do up an old church. And then it looks, it looks absolutely beautiful at the end, right?
6:42 Speaker 00 But you've got to keep in mind that some of these older buildings are earthquake prone. And so one of the reasons these churches are sometimes decommissioned is that the local congregation or the parish might not have enough money to undertake those works. So what would you need to do to this this one that you looked at that you said was a bit of a storage unit now? What would you need to do to renovate it into an Airbnb?
7:09 Speaker 01 So I worked on the the figure that I'd negotiate down a little bit and purchase it for three hundred and fifty thousand dollars. Now, the renovation, this is where it went sideways. So I contacted a friend of mine who's a Q S and I said, this is kind of what I'm thinking. The lady had some plans, I kind of knew roughly what I wanted to do. And in my mind, in my simple mind, I thought, well, this is going to be relatively easy. All I'm going to do is I'm going to extend the mezzanine. I'll put a bedroom up there and a bathroom. I'll put two bedrooms underneath that and two bathrooms. And the rest of it, I'll just kind of leave open plan, do some nice joinery, tidy it up. He came back with a number that made me almost fall off my chair, seven hundred and something thousand dollars plus GST. And then I suddenly thought, okay, so so what we're saying is about a million bucks
7:54 Speaker 01 just to kind of get this thing up to a level where I would be happy to rent it out. Now, that doesn't mean it's going to be worth a million dollars. I don't think it'd be worth a million dollars in my lifetime if I did that. So I thought, okay, well, I need to try and get these renovations down. So I started trimming out things to see how much I could move the dial. Now, in the end, I think the best kind of number I could get to was about six hundred thousand dollars. So the total investment would have been still close to a million dollars. I'm thinking, if that valued up at six fifty, which might have been a stretch, let's face it, that valued up at six fifty, I've got to have so much extra capital in that, because the bank's not going to lend me a million dollars on a six fifty property, that it
8:36 Speaker 01 was going to hold up so much cash that I don't know how you can make that work in your head, even though I love the concept.
8:45 Speaker 00 But why would you even consider spending nine hundred and fifty thousand dollars to have something that was only worth six hundred and fifty thousand dollars? I mean, even if you borrowed the money, you're still paying the money, right?
8:57 Speaker 01 Yes, I know, Edward. Sometimes we all go down a path, but we realise, actually, what the hell am I doing here? If a client told me this, I would laugh and say, don't be an idiot. And then I had that come to Jesus moment, so to speak, where I suddenly realised, actually, this isn't an investment, this is a hobby, a really expensive hobby, that I'm thinking about doing. And the biggest thing that Meant that I couldn't really move the dial from a renovation perspective. Was that strengthening side of things? So, commercial buildings might have a grade that's acceptable when they're a commercial building. Now, if you convert that to residential, which would need to happen, all of a sudden that standard is much higher and you've got to make sure that it's safe for people to live in.
9:40 Speaker 01 Now, the cost of doing that was astronomical and there's no way around that.
9:45 Speaker 00 Well, I suppose the other thing about a church renovation is because typically these are big, open spaces. They will require a lot of work. If you're gonna put two bathrooms downstairs and one up on a mezzanine floor, that's gonna be a lot of plumbing work because typically there might not be bathrooms in that area of the church, right? So, you're gonna have to get all of the plumbing in. And again, because it is a big, open space, you're gonna have to put the walls in. There's so much more work you'd have to do compared to just a normal residential property, where the walls are already up and the bedrooms are roughly where they are. The other thing, just to keep in mind, is that the strengthening work can run over budget.
10:26 Speaker 00 In fact, in Timor, there was another church that was going through earthquake strengthening works. They had a twenty thousand dollar overrun and an eight-week delay. And actually, that's probably not even that bad. That was because they discovered corroded steel. So, I think that's probably your best-case scenario. Now, having said that, I did run the numbers in Opus Plus with the new Airbnb feature, looking at, well, what would happen if you did do this? And let's say you were renting it out for five hundred dollars a night. What sort of occupancy would you expect? Maybe fifty percent?
11:02 Speaker 01 Well, actually, I think I would have got more than that. So, I was working on renting it out for kind of seven hundred dollars a night.
11:08 Speaker 00 Including GST?
11:10 Speaker 01 Including GST.
11:11 Speaker 00 Yes.
11:12 Speaker 01 And I think that probably in terms of occupancy, I kinda was thinking this is probably gonna be a weekend getaway. So, probably make it, you know, you have to book two nights minimum kind of thing. But I kinda don't expect to get every single weekend. This is how I was working it through in my head. I thought, well, maybe you get forty-five weekends of the year.
11:32 Speaker 00 Okay, so what's that as a percentage?
11:34 Speaker 01 Go on, you're the economist, Ed, hang on. Uh, forty-five times two divided by three sixty-five, twenty-five percent.
11:41 Speaker 00 Twenty-five percent, I mean, that's not, that's not great.
11:44 Speaker 01 All right, all right.
11:45 Speaker 00 I mean, I can already tell you where these numbers are going, Andrew Nichol. But twenty-five percent, including higher fees and higher rates and, and maintenance and all of these things. And look at the loan that you would have needed to take out. The cash flow likely would have been positive based on those numbers. Maybe about thirty-five dollars per week. But if you're having to put in about three hundred and fifty thousand dollars to get thirty-five dollars a week in cash flow, maybe it's not so good.
12:10 Speaker 01 Yeah, that's what it came down to. Like, not only, not only was I over capitalizing to the max and exposing myself to, you know, if you're big cost renovation and that blows out by ten percent, that's a big number. Like another sixty thousand dollars, seventy thousand dollars on top of my already ridiculous set of numbers. You've got that risk and then I think, okay, but I've got to put in so much cash. What's the return on my actual cash investment? And everything else aside, that was just so rubbish that I thought, actually, I am talking myself into this deal.
12:40 Speaker 00 Now, having said that, you are right that when churches are renovated, they do look beautiful. Here's one that I found in Lake Hawaia in Queensland Lakes District, which is currently on Airbnb. It's a beautiful, oh, that'd be a stone church, right?
12:56 Speaker 01 Yeah, a lot of them are. And that's where I'm like, oh, well, they're, they're, they're strong, but it's not quite that simple.
13:01 Speaker 00 And on the inside, the renovation has just been absolutely spectacular. This is a one bedroom being rented for five hundred dollars a night. Bear in mind, it's in Lake Hawaia, which I would gently suggest might be a better location than, than Timur. That's not going to get me cancelled, is it? But it's only one bedroom, so perhaps you were right around that five to seven hundred dollar mark. So ultimately, what was your decision here?
13:26 Speaker 01 I made the decision that I was doing exactly what I encourage investors not to do and get emotionally invested. And so we said no to that deal sadly, because I really like the concept. But maybe you'd do this if you were going to live in it yourself and you had oodles of money. But that's not the case.
13:43 Speaker 00 So what are you going to do next? You're going to keep looking?
13:45 Speaker 01 I actually have got an idea of how this could work. I spoke to a friend of mine who has done a lot of conversions of historic buildings and he's given me a tip. Now, I'm not going to talk about that on the show yet because I don't want to create competition for myself, but on the assumption that that goes ahead at some stage, I will talk about it afterwards, but I've got, I've got a plan.
14:05 Speaker 00 Okay. And if you want to check out the numbers on your investment properties before you buy, make sure you use Opus Plus, this is our free property investing app. If you Google Opus Plus, it'll be the first thing that comes up because over the last 15 minutes, we've gone through our live deal workshop. Will Andrew spend the money and invest or not? How to run the numbers on an unusual renovation? What's the return on investment on an old church? Right, let's wrap it up there, but please don't forget to write, review and subscribe to the podcast. Really does help us get the message out to more people.
14:38 Speaker 00 Thanks for listening to the Property Academy Podcast. I'm your host, Eben Knight.
14:41 Speaker 01 I'm Andrew Nico.
14:42 Speaker 00 We're going to be back again tomorrow with even more daily strategies, tech insights to help you get the most out of the UCL property market. Until next time.
Previous Cut These 7 Expenses Now to Get Rich Faster⎟Ep. 2440 Next Why Your Neighbours Could Kill Your Airbnb⎟Ep. 2442 Page updated November 14, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated