Pod Insights The Property Academy Podcast Think Your House Is Worth More? Think Again⎟Ep. 2494 About this episode Think your property is worth more than it really is? That mistake could stop your next mortgage application before it even gets started.
In this episode, Ed and Andrew explain why so many investors overestimate their property's value, how it affects your borrowing power, and the simple check to make before you walk into the bank.
You'll learn:
The one mistake that can kill your mortgage application Why investors often overestimate their property's value The one thing to do before applying for your next loan Guessing your property's value is easy. Knowing what the bank thinks it's worth is what really matters.
And if you want to talk to one of our mortgage advisers, just reach out to Opes Mortgages https://www.opesmortgages.co.nz/book-your-free-session for a free meeting.
For more from Opes Partners:
Sign up for the weekly Private Property newsletter https://www.opespartners.co.nz/newsletter-sign-upInstagram https://www.instagram.com/opes_partners/TikTok https://www.tiktok.com/@opespartners
Transcript 0:08 Speaker 00 Hello and welcome along to the Property Academy Podcast by Opes Partners. I'm your host, David Knight.
0:12 Speaker 01 And I'm Andrew Nichol.
0:13 Speaker 00 And this is the show that helps Kiwis go from zero to five investment property. So you can be financially free and stick around for the next 15 minutes because you're going to learn the one trick that kills your mortgage application, the common mistake investors always make and the thing every investor should do before they walk into the bank. Now, Andrew, what is that common mistake?
0:36 Speaker 01 I say it all the time. So people think that their property is worth more than it is and nearly everyone does this. And what we see is that investors think, okay, I want to buy another house and they put in a mortgage application. And when you do that, you fill out your assets and liabilities for the bank. And what happens at that time is that the person will put an optimistic value for their property and they think, well, homes.co.nz says it's worth 950. I think it's worth a million dollars. And so the numbers look good. The broker says, this should be no problem. We're done with a deal. And then they get a prior approval, says subject to evaluation. You pay a thousand dollars for your valuation. Turns out your house is worth $950,000 and there's not enough equity in
1:20 Speaker 01 there. So now you can't use that approval. You're essentially declined.
1:24 Speaker 00 Does that really happen?
1:26 Speaker 01 So I actually spoke to Pete from Opes Mortgages about this and a client was sure that their property was worth 1.5 million dollars. And Peter sort of thought, well, that seems quite high, but that's what they were sure of. And their whole plan to buy another property hinged on that number being accurate. Now, the registered valuation came back at 1.2 million dollars, so a $300,000 gap. And that meant there was no usable equity that they could actually borrow against to buy another property. So... They simply couldn't get it across the line. The bank just said no.
2:00 Speaker 00 This is where valuers become your best friend, right? Because if we just put this into context, right? If you have a property that's worth a million bucks and you've got a seven hundred thousand dollar mortgage on it, right? Remember, you can borrow up to eighty percent of the value against your own home. So if the valuer comes in and says, yeah, sure, sure, this property is worth a million bucks. The bank will say, sweet as, we're gonna trust that. We're gonna lend you up to a hundred thousand dollars, right? So you can go off and buy another investment property with that, or at least put it towards it. If instead the value is not your best friend and they say, nah, nah, nah, this property is worth nine hundred thousand dollars, it's worth a hundred K less. Well, all of a sudden, you can't borrow an extra hundred K against your property anymore.
2:45 Speaker 00 You can only borrow an extra twenty thousand dollars against your property. Ah, so a valuer coming in and putting a higher value on your property means that you can go ahead and borrow more. Now, because valuers have such an important role, you can't just go out and pick your own valuer anymore. Because that's what used to happen when people realised, like, wow, the valuer should be, they're my best friend. So just talk about how that changed. And when did it change? Because you used to be able to go and just choose any old valuer, right?
3:16 Speaker 01 Yeah, so a number of years ago, I think it might have been roughly ten years ago, the banks thought, you know what? Seems like you might get a different result depending on the valuer that you use. And, you know, you might ring up your mates and say, Ed, who was that valuer you used? That was really generous when they valued your property. They wanted to make sure it was completely impartial. And so what they did is they've set up a rule and you've got two different providers that different banks use. You can either go through velocity or quartality. And what the broker does, or the bank does, is they put in the request and that gets randomly assigned to usually three different valuers. And you choose blindly which one you wanna use. And you pay the fee and then you get a notice that this valuer is gonna come out and value your property.
4:01 Speaker 01 So there's no ability for you now to sway or have any influence on the valuer because you've used that guy ten times and you know he's really good.
4:11 Speaker 00 Yes, you can't slip them a couple of hundies to get a higher amount. Now, having said that, one thing that I've found quite useful is that the valuer will contact you to go through the property. And I just think you wanna be so nice to them, you're just like so, so nice. And I used one trick.
4:27 Speaker 01 It's the only time you are.
4:29 Speaker 00 And I remember saying to you once, Andrew, I'm attributing this to you in case I ever get into trouble.
4:34 Speaker 01 Yeah, I see what you're up to.
4:36 Speaker 00 You said to me, well, you should go and say to the valuer, I see the value sitting at five hundred and eighty thousand dollars. And like going through and finding properties that had recently sold and kind of giving them some evidence around why you think that's the case. Now, I've done this multiple times and I'm so nice to them. There was one guy who I said, I think this property's worth, I think it was like five hundred and fifty K or something. He was like, oh, this is really good. He was nice to me. He came back at five hundred and eighty K.
5:05 Speaker 01 Wow.
5:06 Speaker 00 Yeah, yeah, yeah. It was really good. I was able to borrow quite a lot of money against that property. It was a absolutely wonderful thing. We got on like a house on fire. Then another time for a, for a property, I'd a valuer come over. This was in a downward market. And I knew that there were some properties that had sold recently around the area that were a bit more rundown. Now, she might not have been able to see that, look at what was available online. So I was able to say, cool, this is the reason why th- those properties sold for quite low. I see the value sitting at whatever I thought it was at. And I said to her, look, to get my mortgage approved, I really need this to be at five fifty. And she did say, oh, I'm not sure if we're gonna get there, but we'll see what I can do. Anyway, it came back at five twenty five. I was reasonably happy with that.
5:52 Speaker 01 Yeah, and look, I think the key thing to remember here is that no valuer is gonna put their ass on the line to help out Ed McKnight, even if he is nice every now and then. But if you can provide some context as to why you think that the value should be higher than maybe some of those other sales might suggest, i.e. they're a bit rundown, there was a mortgage sale here, all of those kind of things. They'll take that information because it's their job to take all the information they can find and then make an estimate as to what the market might achieve if you sold that property.
6:28 Speaker 00 Now, the other thing just to point out is there are actually two types of valuations that banks use.
6:33 Speaker 01 Yeah, you've got a desktop valuation and a registered valuation. So desktop valuation, they tend to be a bit more conservative and these are just using an algorithm, basically. Whatever software you're using, we'll have a look at how many other properties have sold recently within the area that are a similar type or a similar size property. A registered valuation, someone actually comes out and they'll measure the property and they'll look at the quality of the property and they'll go and look at other photos of properties that have sold and they'll actually do that manually. And the benefit of that is if you have got a property that you know that there might be some unusual circumstances around some of the other sales in the block or in the
7:15 Speaker 01 neighbourhood, well, you can actually have a human being set that value rather than just a computer.
7:21 Speaker 00 Well, the other thing that's interesting is that depending on whether the banks use velocity for their desktop values or totality, what used to be called CoreLogic, that can have quite a bit of a difference. And I'll just give you an example. In Opus Plus, which is our free app for property investors for you guys to run your numbers on, we pull through values and we originally used velocity. Now, that started getting a bit expensive, so I went away and found a cheaper option, which was the Real Estate Institute of New Zealand. Now, both of these people can provide the values for properties, but just like if you go on homes.co.nz or oneroof or realestate.co.nz, they're all going to tell you your property's worth a little bit different.
8:02 Speaker 00 Now, I went through, and before we did the changeover, did a bit of an analysis and found that, call it when we switch over, the Real Estate Institute of New Zealand values are on average two percent lower than velocity. So there's got to be a bit of a change. Now, did your property really change its value just because we switched out the data source? No, not at all. Your property's still your property. But the values can look slightly different. But that might not always be the case. In my own house, when I ran it through the updated data source from Reins, Reins thinks my house is worth an extra $300,000 than what velocity did. So these are, it's just to show you that it's all a bit different.
8:43 Speaker 00 And I know that this actually matters when you are deciding which bank to actually put your mortgage with, right?
8:49 Speaker 01 Yeah, Peter also said that he had a client that recently went to him and then he put them to the banks. And the banks that use Velocity showed that they were at sixty five percent LVR. So they had plenty of usable equity, but when they went to the banks that use Quartality, it was even lower, it was fifty nine percent LVR. So about a five to six percent swing on that exact same property. So if their house was worth six hundred thousand dollars, that's the difference between having ninety thousand dollars worth of usable equity and a hundred and twenty six thousand dollars worth of usable equity. So quite a meaningful amount of difference with that usable equity, particularly if they're going to use that money and then go buy another property.
9:28 Speaker 00 And that's not to say that you should always go to a bank that uses Cotality to source its property values. And of course, you as a, as a normal investor, it's very hard to see who uses Cotality, who uses Velocity as their data provider, right? But your mortgage advisor should know that. And what you might find is that for your property, Velocity might show a higher value than Cotality and that may help decide which bank you end up going with. So at the start, I mentioned that would tell everybody the one thing they should do before they go into the bank. What do you reckon it is?
10:00 Speaker 01 I would talk to a mortgage advisor first. And the reason that's important is because you want to make sure your numbers are realistic before it even hits an application. So if they run their desktop valuations first through Velocity or Quartality, if the number is just wildly inaccurate, well then, yeah, you can say, well, I'm pretty confident that if I got a registered valuation, that would actually take into account some of those things that maybe the online valuations aren't taking into account. And then like Ed, you might be able to provide some context to your valuer. But again, it might be that once you run those numbers, oh, okay, well, in this case Velocity's a bit higher. So therefore I can get the amount of approval I want through my bank. So let's just get that done before I end up spending any money.
10:44 Speaker 01 But again, it means that you've got this realistic budget rather than putting a finger in the air.
10:49 Speaker 00 And look, I think the other thing is don't start with your CV. A lot of people do this because they think, oh, it's the council valuation or oh, it's the government valuation. There are a lot of areas in New Zealand where properties are selling underneath CV at the moment. So if I think about Auckland, the average property in April this year sold for 4% below CV and Kaikoura, it was like 16% under and in Topea, it was 8% under. Meanwhile, in some other parts of the country, in Vicarago City, their house prices are selling on average 20% above CV and Mackenzie District is 26% above CV. And so that's going to be, it is likely to be out of date and extraordinarily inaccurate.
11:33 Speaker 00 So when your mortgage advisor is saying to you, hey, look, what is the value of your house? Don't put down the CV. It's often going to be way, way out of whack. And over the last 15 minutes, you've learnt the one cheque that kills your mortgage application, the common mistake investors always make, and the thing that every investor should do before they walk into the bank. Right, let's wrap it up there, but please don't forget to rate, review and subscribe to the podcast. It really does help us get the message out to more people.
12:06 Speaker 00 Thanks for listening to the Property Academy Podcast. I'm your host, Stephen Knight.
12:09 Speaker 01 No, Richard, no problem.
12:10 Speaker 00 We're going to be back here tomorrow with even more daily strategies, tactics and insights to help you get the most out of the New Zealand property market. Until next time.
Previous This Is Exactly How I Manage My Money Now⎟Ep. 2493 Next We Moved Overseas... And Kept Both Houses⎟Ep. 2495 Page updated November 14, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated