Pod Insights The Property Academy Podcast They Thought This Deal Would Make Money⎟Ep. 2472 About this episode Property development looks simple on paper: Buy a site. Build a few townhouses. Make a profit. But once you run the numbers, the reality can look very different. I
n this episode, Ed and Andrew break down the real cost of developing property in New Zealand.
You'll learn:
What you must calculate before buying a development site How a development can lose more than $400k despite looking profitable at firstThe 4 costs first-time developers usually forget to include The surprising part? The biggest mistake isn't overpaying for the land. It's getting excited about the potential profit before you've worked through the numbers.
Book a meeting https://bit.ly/3QE2XJN to start your path to financial freedom with a detailed financial plan for $0.
For more from Opes Partners:
Sign up for the weekly Private Property newsletter https://www.opespartners.co.nz/newsletter-sign-upInstagram https://www.instagram.com/opes_partners/TikTok https://www.tiktok.com/@opespartners
Transcript 0:08 Speaker 00 Hello and welcome along to the Property Academy Podcast by Obus Partners. I'm your host, Sebik Knight.
0:12 Speaker 01 And I'm Andrew Nicom.
0:13 Speaker 00 And this is the show that helps Kiwis go from zero to five investment property. So you could be financially free and stick around for the next 15 minutes because you're going to learn the real cost of developing property, what you must always do before you buy a property to develop and the four costs first time developers usually miss. Now, what is it that you've got to do before you buy a property to develop, Andrew? Because you've, you've developed a few properties in your time.
0:39 Speaker 01 Yeah, well, the main thing is you've got to run the numbers to make sure there's actually some money in it and there's a bit of fat in it for things that go wrong. Because I can tell you from experience, things go wrong and, and by wrong, I mean they cost you more than you're expecting. So you need to have a realistic idea of how much you can actually make. And the issue I see all the time is people either go out, get excited because they see a piece of land and they know, okay, I can put seven units on this. If I sell those, I'm going to make a whole lot of money. Or they might have a property and then they might buy the property next door and they think, I'm going to develop all of this. And then when they run the numbers, actually there's no money in it. What's the point?
1:16 Speaker 00 And to do that, you've got to have what's called a feasibility study or a feasibility spreadsheet. And if you're a really cool developer, you call it a FISO. So I've got your, no, you do, you do. They go, oh, it's the FISO. It's like the renovators. Oh no, I don't do a renovation, I do a reno. Now, I've got your, why are you laughing at that?
1:36 Speaker 01 Yeah.
1:37 Speaker 00 That's true. That's not, that's not without a word of a lie, that's true. Now, I've got your feasibility spreadsheet in front of me, Andrew. So what are the first numbers that you plug in when you start doing a FISO?
1:49 Speaker 01 So I think the main thing to begin with is figure out what the end sale value is. So not the land, not the build, what can you actually get at the end of the project? If you sell these units, what, what are they going to actually sell for? And then you work backwards from there because at the end of the day, it's all about what the market's going to accept for the end product.
2:12 Speaker 00 So how do you know, like if you're doing this spreadsheet and you're like, okay, I'm going to build seven units and they're going to be in Wellington City. How do you figure out what that end value is?
2:25 Speaker 01 I'd probably start by jumping online and having a look around and kind of figure out, okay, that looks like a similar type of product than what I'm going to put here. They're asking for 700,000. I might take a little bit off because just asking for 700 grand doesn't mean you're selling for 700 grand. And if you're, if you don't have a lot of experience, well firstly, probably don't want to do development, but you might get a valuation and probably your fund is going to ask for one anyway.
2:48 Speaker 00 The difficulty there as well in doing that is usually I say to people, and I was doing this with a web developer the other day who's interested in buying a house. And he was like, how much might I pay for, for this specific house? I say, oh, what you do is you jump on realestate.co.nz, you go to the sold section and you go and look at what is sold recently. Now, the difficulty is with development that if a developer is selling their own stock, their own properties, then that won't show on realestate.co.nz. It won't show in the Real Estate Institute of New Zealand database because they're not being sold by real estate agents. So just to give you an example of like, if a Mike Greer salesperson sells a Mike Greer property
3:33 Speaker 00 or a Williams Corp salesperson sells a Williams Corp property, that's their own data, that they don't have to publish that anywhere, right? That's not going to make it onto One Roof or realestate.co.nz necessarily. And it might make it onto homes, but way later. And so you're going to have to do a bit more digging than you usually would need to do, right? Because you want to justify that, actually, this is the price that I'm going to get. I have seen too many developers, especially first time developers, who think, yeah, I'm going to be able to sell these properties for 700K. Push comes to shove and I've spent all this money building the properties and they can't sell it for 700K. They can sell it for 625K, but actually their margin was 75 grand and uh, there's no margin left in it.
4:17 Speaker 01 There's a lot of that at the moment and a lot of developers that thought this year it's going to be a lot easier to sell properties. So I'm going to build them and sell them at the end rather than sell them off plans. And now they're getting to completion or the market's not that much easier. All of a sudden they're having to drop to below probably what it's costing them in a lot of cases.
4:35 Speaker 00 Now, the next thing that you'd probably need to think about is your land cost. About how much is it actually going to cost to buy this thing?
4:42 Speaker 01 And again, this is where I see quite a common mistake. So if you're buying the land, that's pretty straightforward. If you already own the property and it might have a house on it. So you've got to allow for demolition. But if you're, if you've just owned some land, you have to put the number in as if you're buying it on the open market from yourself. And the reason you do that is because, well, you could sell that. So if you bought the property 20 years ago for $50,000, but it's worth 500,000 now, you put 500,000 because with zero risk, you can sell it for 500,000.
5:15 Speaker 00 Aye, that's fair. So let's say you bought it for 50K, you sell it for 500K, ignore the real estate agent costs at the moment. Cool, you make 450K. Now, if you put in 50 grand, because that's what you paid for the land. And then after the developments all said and done, you made 300K. You go, yeah, I made 300K. But you made way less than you could have if you just didn't do the development and like didn't take the risk. The other one I want you to talk about are development contributions.
5:42 Speaker 01 Yeah, so for every additional unit or property you put on a section. So if you, if there's already two houses on a, on a couple of sites and you bowl them over, you basically get two free houses that you can put on. But if you're putting eight units, you've got to pay six developer contributions to the council. And that goes towards increasing the infrastructure load because you've got more units there now.
6:05 Speaker 00 And this can be like 40 to 70 grand if you're in Auckland, right?
6:09 Speaker 01 Yeah, and even in Christchurch, there's been like this huge increase over the last wee while. And actually. I was talking to a developer just the other day and there's a lot of competition right now in Christchurch in the townhouse market. And part of that is because the council announced we're going to increase from this date. Everyone went and bought their land, applied for consent and got the old pricing. And now they're all building at the same time, rather than, you know, trickling them out over a period of time.
6:37 Speaker 00 Yeah, that's one of the reasons why we've started to see developers stop buying as much land and in areas like Christchurch, because they basically went on this land buying binge to try and get the lower council fees, right? And now the stocks come to market. So I was actually talking to an investor the other day. We're seeing down for dinner, he's like, well, I'm hearing about all of this competition of properties in Christchurch. I know that property values are going up in Christchurch at the moment, but what's your take? And I was like, part of it is just manufactured because the council, we're going to charge them way more money. So all the developers thought, oh, it's easy. We'll save the money by buying the land now, getting the cheaper price. And then it has had this effect of lots of properties coming to market, but you'd expect that backlog to clear out, given that a lot of developers have stopped buying land.
7:22 Speaker 00 The other thing though, that people really need to think about, if you're going to develop properties and you're putting your feasibility study or spreadsheet together, is we've got to think about professional fees and consents, because you are going to spend money on a surveyor and a geotech and a planner and an architect and an engineer. And this all really, really adds up. Even if we look at a resource consent deposit, that's six and a half grand building consent.
7:48 Speaker 01 It's a lot of money just to get started.
7:51 Speaker 00 It's a, it's a lot of money. Like, what would be a reasonable budget for all of those professional fees? Like, like if you were putting together a feasibility study, what would you put in?
8:00 Speaker 01 I'd normally actually budget for about $50,000. It might be less than that, but I normally say $50,000 for kind of fees to get you started.
8:09 Speaker 00 Gosh, it is a lot of money. It's a lot of cash money. I mean, hopefully you make a lot of cash money as well, right?
8:15 Speaker 01 But it's a lot of money to put on the line upfront. And I think that's where all of a sudden people get this great idea of developing. And then they get one of these bills and they think, holy heck, I don't know if I'm made for this.
8:26 Speaker 00 Well, in many ways, it's a bit like going into business, right? Lots of people think, wow, if I start a business, I can potentially make a lot more money. But in order to start that business, you might need to go through a period where you have no income because you've got to quit your job so you can focus on it. I mean, you can start things up as side hustles and things. I understand that. But my point is that you've got to have the cash or the finances to be able to start that business in the beginning, right? In order to get that return a little later on. And then there's the one which is really obvious, which is building costs.
8:59 Speaker 01 Yeah. So according to Money Hub, the national average is about $3,250 per square meter, which is kind of a little bit higher than what I would normally use. I kind of use, you know, just under 3,000, maybe 2,900. Now, obviously, the thing about averages is it captures probably some really valuable properties in there as well. So the numbers, it might be slightly skewed. For an appropriately spate rental property, you're not talking about high end most of the time. So you're probably wanting to be somewhere between that late twos to maybe early threes at the maximum.
9:33 Speaker 00 Well, the other thing you've got to think about, once you get these costs into your spreadsheet, is actually validating them as well. So I know we were recently looking at a piece of land in Auckland, Andrew. The plan was to bowl over the house and to build some units on it. Now, one of the things that was interesting about this site is it was on a slope. It was on, it was on, you know, pretty decent hill. And so we're putting together the spreadsheet. Okay, we're going to need some retaining walls in there because it is quite sloopy. Okay, that might cost $400,000. Bang that in the spreadsheet, Andrew. Okay, sweet. Does the deal look good? Oh, yeah, this deal looks pretty good. Then we go and we check, how much is that retaining wall really going to cost? It was like 900 grand.
10:17 Speaker 01 Yeah, and that's if everything goes. Smoothie, so call it a million dollars. All of a sudden, no money in that project.
10:23 Speaker 00 Well, if you're like, okay, it's gonna cost an extra six hundred grand over six units. That's an extra hundred grand per unit. And so you start going, oh, wow, maybe we won't go with that deal. Now, the point of that story is just to show that putting all of these costs into your spreadsheet. Yes, that is very, very important and we're sharing these costs so that if you do wanna develop or you're thinking about it, you know how to start running the numbers and you don't forget any of these very important costs. But there is a second, more important step, which is validating that those are actually the costs rather than just your best guesses, right? That's incredibly important because if you don't do that, there is a much higher risk that you go broke. And while we're on it, the other thing you've got to think about are the holding costs.
11:07 Speaker 01 Yeah, so if you've ever bought a property off plans and it's a turnkey, you pay a deposit at the start and you pay for the rest of it at the end. You don't pay any interest during the build. Now, if you've built a property and you've done progressive payments, then you'll know that your loan's going up in increments as you're making payments and you're funding that interest. Now, the same goes with a development loan. Now, the interest is probably gonna be capitalized, but you still have to take that out of your profit. So, construction loans, generally speaking, if you go to a bank, might be somewhere between five and a half, six percent. If you go to a non-bank, which a lot of developers do, you're looking more like nine to eleven percent. So, generally speaking, if you're kind of, if you're using both of these, which lots of developers do, they might get whatever they can with the bank and then go to a non-bank
11:51 Speaker 01 for the difference, you might be talking eight percent as a blended interest rate. And in terms of timelines, if you're looking from consent to settlement in Auckland, it could be kind of sixteen to twenty-four months. Now, you obviously don't take out the full loan for that entire twenty-four months, but you're gonna be drawing it down in stages. Generally speaking, you pay for the land with cash, but then as you're starting to pay your builders and your contractors and everything like that, your loan gets bigger and bigger and bigger, the longer it takes to get that project finished and settled, the more interest you pay.
12:25 Speaker 00 And then the other thing you've also got to think about it is, is marketing and legal costs, right? So if you're going to go and use a, a real estate agent to sell them rather than selling them yourself, and it's probably a good idea to use a real estate agent if you're developing for the first time, like, like some of the bigger developers have their own marketing machines and they have their, their, a sales team. And if you're Mike Greer, you can probably do that, right? But if you're not Mike Greer and you're starting out, you're probably gonna want to, want to have a real estate agent help you out. And that can cost you, you know, four percent on the first four hundred grand plus some two percent on the balance of it. It could cost you a six hundred thousand dollar property, you know, twenty four to thirty grand pretty easily.
13:09 Speaker 00 Plus, you've got marketing fees on top of that. That could be two and a half to five grand per unit. You're gonna have to hire a lawyer to sell each unit because you're a, you're, you've got to ha- do the conveyancing of it. That might be two and a half, three grand each. Well, if you're selling six properties, that's two and a half to three times six, you're talking up to eighteen grand there. And the other thing is GST. A lot of people forget about this. Now, remember, if you're registered for GST and you would need to be if you're selling off your, like, six hundred thousand dollar properties, you're gonna be able to claim back some GST on your expenses, but you're also gonna have to pay it on the sale price to the person purchasing it. So when you say, okay, I'm gonna sell this property for six hundred and fifty grand,
13:54 Speaker 00 that doesn't mean you get to get six hundred and fifty grand into your coffers, you gotta pay the GST first, right? That, that'd be a rookie mistake people forget about.
14:02 Speaker 01 And actually, just while I'm thinking about it, on the marketing piece, when you're selling a property that doesn't exist, you have to spend a whole lot more money on things like renders. So renders can be actually really expensive because it's not like someone can just turn up and, and you can say, oh, yeah, yeah, there'll be a three bedroom unit there, all good. No, we wanna see what it looks like.
14:21 Speaker 00 One hundred percent. And how many pre-sales would like a first time developer have to do in order to get the money to start the project? Because it's not like the bank just says, oh yeah, you're a first time developer. Here's the money, build the houses, then sell them later on.
14:36 Speaker 01 So generally speaking, the funder wants to know that there's enough pre-sales that they'll get their money back. They don't really care after that. So let's say you're borrowing sixty percent. Then you're probably going to have to sell sixty percent of the project.
14:49 Speaker 00 That's quite a lot, eh? So if you've got six units, you've got to sell four of them before you can even start.
14:55 Speaker 01 Yeah. And generally speaking, most people borrow more than that.
14:59 Speaker 00 And at that point, you know, typically we say to people, you really want to make sure that at the time you're selling the properties, that you've already bought the land or at least got a contract to buy the land. And then on top of that, it's best to have resource consent because if you're trying to sell a property that doesn't have resource consent, by the time you go through council, you might have to change a lot of the property, right? So that's not going to make your buyers happy. So you will have had to shell out quite a bit of cash and got a lot of your ducks in a row in order to be able to go out and do those, those pre-sales. But if you get it right, like I don't want to scare too many people off development. A lot of people should be scared off development because they're not at the stage where they can do it, right? But if you get it right, what sort of money can you make?
15:42 Speaker 01 So right now, developers have definitely had their margins squeezed. Like I know there are some of them making no money on a project. They're just keeping their staff employed and they're getting rid of their backlog of land. But generally speaking, in a normal market, you'd expect to make somewhere between ten and twenty percent margin of the total project. So it is a lot of money when it's going well.
16:04 Speaker 00 So if you think about a, a project, and let's say you sell all the properties for three mil after, after you pay your GST. So your margin on that might be three hundred to six hundred grand, all going well.
16:15 Speaker 01 Yeah, you'd expect probably six hundred grand.
16:17 Speaker 00 I mean, it's a lot of money in, but it's a lot of money out as well. Now, if you are running your FISOs, the four costs that first timers often forget is having some working capital in there. Like, yes, you're going to be able to borrow some money in order to pay your invoices, but you've also got to remember, you've got to have some buffer in there, right? You can't run this thing in solvent where you get a bill and you can't reasonably pay it. You've got to have some cash flow, some money in the bank so you can pay those costs. Marketing's the other big one, you know, all in. It could be 30 grand in, in order to make sure, including your real estate costs in order to sell those properties, your lawyer's fees per property. Again, if you're selling three units, that's paying your lawyer three times for selling
17:02 Speaker 00 them and also income tax on your profit. That's the other thing. So if you've got a day job and then you're going in and making a couple of hundred K off a development, well, it might've taken you two years to build that development, but all of that income is going to hit in one tax year, right? So you're probably being pushed out into a 39% tax rate. So you've just got to factor in all of these things before you get too excited and go and say, I'm going to purchase this land and then build all of these things. If you've got to do something that's high risk, you've got to make sure you're walking in with those eyes very, very, very wide open. And over the last 15 minutes, you've learned the real cost of developing a property, what you must always do before you buy a property to develop and the four costs that first
17:47 Speaker 00 time developers usually miss. Right, let's wrap it up there, but please don't forget to rate, review and subscribe to the podcast really does help us get the message out to more people.
18:02 Speaker 00 Thanks for listening to the Property Academy Podcast. I'm your host, Stephen Knight.
18:05 Speaker 01 And I'm your host, Michael.
18:05 Speaker 00 We're going to be back here tomorrow with even more daily strategies, tactics and insights to help you get the most out of the estate and property market. Until next time.
Previous The Co-Ownership Problem Nobody Sees Coming⎟Ep. 2471 Next The Couple Who Could Retire Tomorrow⎟Ep. 2473 Page updated November 14, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated