Pod Insights The Property Academy Podcast The Worst Way to Predict House Prices – and Everyone Does It⎥Ep. 2112 About this episode Think you can guess where house prices (NZ) are headed based on what happened last year? Think again. In this episode, we reveal why using last year’s prices to predict next year’s market is one of the most common – and costly – mistakes investors make. We dig into the data to show whether good years really follow good years … and what actually happens next. You’ll learn:How often property prices really go upWhy the past is a poor predictor of the futureThe data behind short-term property market randomnessWhat Palmerston North can teach us about recency biasWhy smart investors never rely on headlines aloneThis is a wake-up call to stop investing with the rear-view mirror and start looking through the windscreen instead. Don't forget to create your free Opes+ account here. For more from Opes Partners:Sign up for the weekly Private Property newsletterInstagramTikTok
Transcript 0:08 Speaker 00 Hello and welcome along to the Property Academy Podcast by Opes Partners. I'm your host, Sebikai.
0:12 Speaker 01 And I'm Andrew Nicoll.
0:13 Speaker 00 And this is the show that helps Kiwis go from zero to five investment properties. So you can be financially free and stick around for the next 15 minutes because you're going to learn, if we could use this year's property prices to guess what's going to happen next year, how often property prices really go up and the common thinking trap that could cost you thousands. Now, Andrew, why are we talking about this?
0:32 Speaker 01 Well, I think it's only natural that when the market's going hot, people think, oh, this property price is going up every year. They're definitely going to go up again this year. Or on the flip side, property price has been going down every year for the last two years. It's probably going to go down again this year.
0:48 Speaker 00 And I guess it's because asset prices, shares in property and all other assets tend to move in cycles. You might think, okay, well, whatever happens this year is definitely what's going to happen next year. If I just look at what property prices or share prices did over the last 12 months, that will tell me what's going to happen in the next 12 months. And I saw the most fascinating graph that came out from a company called Consilium. They're really active in managed funds and they tested this and it was fascinating what they did. They started by lining up all of their annual returns. So they looked at it over the last 30 years and they said, let's look at them from the worst returns on the left to the best returns on the right.
1:31 Speaker 00 So there we go. There's our worst case scenario. There's our best case scenario. The worst return was down 10%. The best return was up 12%. So a bit of a spread there. And then what they said, and this is the really clever bit. Okay, based on that, what happened in the next year? So were the bad years followed by more bad years? Were the good years followed by more good years? And when they grafted out, they found that there was no discernible pattern. In other words, if you sat here today and you looked at the returns from last year, that basically gives you no clue about. What was going to happen the next year? And so what I wanted to do was apply this to property.
2:15 Speaker 00 So I did exactly the same thing for the New Zealand property market. And I said, okay, let's look at the last thirty three years of data. And what we found is the worst ever annual return for property was property prices falling fifteen percent. The best ever return was property prices up thirty percent. So we lined them up from best to worst and five times out of six, the New Zealand property market has gone up in value. So property prices have gone up. But then, Andrew, we started looking at, well, what happened in the year after that? I.e. were bad years followed by more bad years? Were good years followed by good years? And did we spot a pattern?
2:53 Speaker 01 Again, there was no pattern.
2:55 Speaker 00 So give us an example.
2:56 Speaker 01 So if you go back to March nineteen ninety three, if you looked at the twelve months before that of price data, you would have seen that property prices had barely moved. They'd gone up like two point two percent over that twelve month period. And if you were in that market, you'd probably think, yeah, the market's dead, it's going nowhere. But then what happened next? Well, prices jumped over twelve percent the following year. Now, if we look at the flip side, fast forward to July twenty twenty one, property prices had gone through the roof. They were up over thirty percent in a single year. And so if you're thinking about investing, you'll think, I'm doing so well. I've been investing and everything I touch turns to gold. I might as well keep doing it, let's keep investing. And then the following year, prices fell by three percent.
3:42 Speaker 00 And it's so fascinating, Andrew, because I was just looking at a comment on our YouTube channel, where I think we'd talked about, you know, property prices over the long term go up by five percent or might go up by six percent, depending on where you're investing. And somebody said, I'm not sure if you've looked at the house price data over the last two or three years. House prices have been either flat or going down. And my message to them was, that's what's happened over the last three years. That doesn't tell you anything about what's going to happen next year. Which is to say that you could see that house prices were flat or only up one or two percent over the last twelve months. You don't know whether it's going to go up by. Five, six, seven, 10%, you don't know if it's going to go down by five, six, seven, 10%.
4:24 Speaker 00 What you do know is what the long-term average is, but last year's property price increase, decrease, or stay the same crease, that doesn't tell you anything about what's going to happen over the next 12 months. Basically, the recent past is not an indicator of the near future. It's quite funny, Andrew, because I remember we did, I think it was like episode 10 of this, the Property Academy podcast, where we talked about, don't be afraid of investing in a flat market, and this is effectively the same message, but just with better data to back it up.
4:53 Speaker 01 And probably better quality. And it actually reminds me of the psychological thought pattern called recency bias. And Eni and I were talking about this just the other day and how prevalent it is, because we always take the most recent information and we let that blind us into thinking that that's probably what's going to keep happening. And it can definitely happen in a downward or an upward market, and we assume this is going to keep happening forever. But the actual market doesn't work like that. It doesn't actually own you a pattern. So don't let last year's numbers lull you into this false sense of certainty. That's why smart investors, they look beyond the headlines. They're not looking at what the past 12 months were. They want to dig into what's actually relevant today.
5:36 Speaker 01 And actually, a good model for us that we use all the time is that overvalued, undervalued model. We want to know what the market is doing right now, but we want to apply that to long-term data, not the short-term data.
5:47 Speaker 00 And look, we always say you can't just look at the New Zealand property market, because you're not investing in the overall New Zealand property market. You're buying a specific property in Nelson, or Gisborne, or Whangarei. So does this pattern hold in other cities? Like, when we look at the annual returns from the best to the worst, do we still see that once we get into the city-based data, Nelson, Gisborne, Whangarei, that last year's data is still not a good predictor for next year's data?
6:19 Speaker 01 So we did the same numbers for Palmerston North, and property prices have gone up roughly every two out of three years. Now, was there a pattern, i.e. bad years following bad years, or good years following good years? No, again, there wasn't a pattern.
6:33 Speaker 00 In fact, the highest year, where I think property prices in Palmerston North went up like 60% one year, it actually came after house prices had gone down by about 3% the prior year. And so this basically tells you that Returns, whether it's from shares or property, they are much more random than you think. Now, that's not to say that, that property cycles and asset cycles don't exist. Of course, they do. Markets rise, they fall, they eventually recover. But in terms of those short-term shifts, they are very unpredictable and the data is very noisy. And so I always just think, if you're looking back at the last 12 months and saying, well, that's exactly what's going to happen in the next 12 months. It's a bit like driving
7:17 Speaker 00 using the rearview mirror, because you're just looking in the, you're looking up, oh, what's behind me, what's behind me, that's going to be what's in front of me. And that's how you crash, because we all know, nobody would drive that way. But that's the way some of us invest, because we're looking at the rearview mirror, what happened over the last 12 months, and we don't see what's coming in the next 12 months. So we've got to look ahead rather than backwards, because what's behind us doesn't tell us what's coming directly in front of us. And over the last 15 minutes, you've learned if we can use this year's property prices to guess what's going to happen next year, how often property prices really go up, and that common thinking trap, recency bias, that could cost you thousands. Right, let's wrap it up there. But please don't forget to rate, review and subscribe to the podcast. Really does help us get the message out to more people.
8:07 Speaker 00 Thanks for listening to the Property Academy Podcast. I'm your host, Tim McKnight.
8:10 Speaker 01 And I'm Adrian Nicole.
8:10 Speaker 00 We're going to be back here tomorrow with even more daily strategies, tactics and insights to help you get the most out of your new property market. Until next time.
Previous Can Average Kiwis Still Afford To Invest In Property?⎥Ep. 2111 Next Why It’s Taking Longer to Find Tenants – and What You Can Do About It⎥Ep. 2113 Page updated November 15, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated