Pod Insights The Property Academy Podcast The Wealth Mistake Most Homeowners Don’t Realise They’re Making⎟Ep. 2385 About this episode Most Kiwis think the goal is simple: buy a house, pay it off, and you’ll be financially secure. But that strategy can leave many people “Broke Rich.” You’ll learn:The #1 money mistake many Kiwis make The three traps that turn homeowners into “Broke Rich”What you can do instead to build wealth that actually supports your lifestyleEd and Andrew break down why many Kiwis end up asset-rich but cash-poor ... and how using equity to build income-producing investments can create far more flexibility later in life. Don't forget to create your free Opes+ account and Wealth Plan here. For more from Opes Partners:Sign up for the weekly Private Property newsletterInstagramTikTok
Transcript 0:08 Speaker 00 Hello and welcome along to the Property Academy Podcast by UBS Partners. I'm your host, David Knight.
0:12 Speaker 01 And I'm Andrew Nichol.
0:13 Speaker 00 And this is a show that helps Kiwis go from zero to five investment properties. So you can be financially free and stick around for the next 15 minutes because you're going to learn the number one money mistake Kiwis always make, the three traps that cause Kiwis to become broke rich and what you can do to fix it. Now, if I think about the, the number one money mistake I see Kiwis making, it's not spending too much on coffee, it's not the avocado on toast. For me, I think it's got to be pouring every cent you have or all of your money into your house and ending up what I call broke rich. Now, broke rich is when you look wealthy on paper, your net worth might be quite impressive. You might own a house with, you know, $700,000, maybe, maybe even over a million dollars.
0:56 Speaker 00 But if your income stopped tomorrow, you're screwed, right? I know you see this all the time. I mean, what do you see broke rich look like?
1:03 Speaker 01 Yeah, I think it's exactly that. So people that have all these personal assets that don't bring in any money, often a lot of debt, but no income generating assets or limited income generating assets. The wealth's there on paper, but the financial freedom isn't there. And it's not a fringe problem. About two thirds of Kiwis aged 65 or older own their home outright, but many of this group have got nothing else really. They've got no other savings. The New Zealand super is their only income.
1:32 Speaker 00 And when we talk about lifestyle assets, right? It's things like if you have a boat that's worth a hundred thousand dollars and you don't have any debt against it, well, that boat is an asset in that you could sell it and get money from it. But I think that's very different from what I would call an investment where we're looking to purchase something that is either going to produce some cash flow for us or potentially increase in value over time. And if we think about boats and cars, yes, it's an asset that you could sell, but it's not an investment asset, it's a lifestyle asset. And the risk that I see happen too often is people load up. On lifestyle assets, a bigger house, a boat, a nicer car, that might not have any debt on them,
2:17 Speaker 00 but that's not going to help you to retire in the future or stop working or get through a tough situation. If you lose your job or lose your income. And the downside about lifestyle assets is that in order to realise their value and use them to fund your retirement or fund your holiday or fund whatever you want to do, is you have to take a step back in terms of your lifestyle to sell the boat or sell the car to get that money to then spend on whatever you need to. So you've got to take a backward step in your lifestyle in order to get the benefit of selling that asset.
2:53 Speaker 01 I've actually got a good example, just to freshen my head. An investor that I'm working with, I've worked with for a few years. Um, he bought an investment property, he owned an apartment in Auckland. The apartment in Auckland, he's moved out of that, that was where he lived and he moved in with his partner. Now he's renting out the apartment to his daughter, not even enough to cover the body corporate costs, let alone the rates and all the rest of it. So he's losing money there. He's also got a half share in a holiday home that he owns with his ex-wife that they never use, but he doesn't want to get rid of because he wants.
3:25 Speaker 00 He's got an emotional attachment.
3:26 Speaker 01 Emotional attachment.
3:27 Speaker 00 Loves remembering the whole lovely times I had with my ex-wife, got to remember those.
3:31 Speaker 01 And I.
3:31 Speaker 00 Can I say that?
3:32 Speaker 01 Yeah, and I, because I said to him the other day, at the moment, you are off track for your retirement goals. So you have to do something, like just either get rid of the apartment, oh, I don't want to kick my daughter out, or get rid of the 50% share in the holiday home. Like, either way, you've got these lifestyle assets that are tied up, not doing anything for you at the moment that you can't realise. And again, you know, another investor that I've got, they've got a massive owner occupied house, really young people. They're about to have a $6 million owner occupied property with no debt, which is awesome. But the great thing about these people is they're smart enough to realise, what the hell's the point of having a $6 million house if we don't have anything else? Because how do we pay the bills?
4:13 Speaker 00 Yeah, and, and you'll never hear Andrew or I say, don't buy lifestyle assets because you want to. Live a good lifestyle as well, but it's the over indexing or the overspending on lifestyle assets without thinking about the other assets as well. That's the mistake we see. And the reason people fall into them is because of kind of three traps about why people end up broke rich. And I think trap number one is that people do confuse lifestyle assets with investments because whenever I say on YouTube, oh, because cars tend to go down in value over time, I always get comments, what if it's a, a collectible car or what about this? And I'm like,
4:52 Speaker 00 oh, I'm saying most of the time, like, it's like art, art is an asset that you could sell, but it's not necessarily what I would consider a normal investable asset. It's more fringe or an alternative asset that it might go up in value, but you're buying the art because you like hanging it in your house, not because it's going to fund your retirement necessarily.
5:16 Speaker 01 I've got a ton of art. In the event that I wanted to raise some cash and liquidate that art, I'm not going to be able to find a buyer to buy all my quirky art to, and get, and make my money off it.
5:27 Speaker 00 Like there are situations, like I know of one person who I think spent $20,000 on a piece of art and later sold it for I think $50,000, but that wasn't her retirement strategy, right? And I think we love to convince ourselves of buying lifestyle assets because we want the good thing now. But actually, sometimes we have to not buy the good thing now. We need to invest in investment assets as opposed to lifestyle assets.
5:52 Speaker 01 And look, I think the reason that we love calling things like this an investment is because it makes us feel better about spending the money. Like, I, I think I've done that. Like, I've bought some art and oh, that's an investment. It's not an investment. And you know, if you think about your house, right? You buy a house and then that might go up over the next 10 years by 600 grand. And you go, great, on paper, you know, there's been a great investment owning this house. Yeah, but you're not going to sell it to fund your lifestyle. So it's not an investment at all. It's just a, most of the time, there is sometimes that downsizing can work, but typically, if you sell your house, you've got to buy another house in the same market at similar prices. Whereas if it was an investment property that goes up in value, you can sell that,
6:33 Speaker 01 pocket the cash and not have to move your fridge and all of your furniture to move to somewhere else. So it is different. The second trap that I see is the upgrade trap. And that's the lifestyle inflation and usually through housing because you buy your first home and it's probably modest, it's probably a foot on the ladder. Your income goes up, the bank says, hey, you know what? We'd actually lend you an extra million dollars. So you think, wow, we'd actually like to have a bigger section or we'd like to move suburbs or we want a nicer kitchen and we want a rumpus room. All of a sudden you upgrade that house and then the income goes up again. So you upgrade again, second lounge, walk-in wardrobe, the scullery, the wine cellar, all those kinds of things.
7:13 Speaker 01 But the catch is every time you upgrade, you're redirecting surplus money and yeah, you might be taking out a mortgage, but you've got to pay that mortgage back. Now you're redirecting cash flow that you could be investing. And so, yeah, you've added 200K to your mortgage, but that could have been a deposit on a rental property. You got higher mortgage payments. Well, that could have made money that you're putting into a managed fund or shares or something like that. Either way, you're choosing to have the here and now be better, but the later you is going to suffer as a result.
7:45 Speaker 00 But the way I think about it is would I rather have a $1 million house in Auckland, so the average property in Auckland fully paid off and have a million dollars in shares or investment properties and managed funds, so $2 million net worth, right? Million dollars in the house, million dollars in other investment assets. Or would I rather have a $2 million house fully paid off? Now, in both those situations, the net worth is $2 million. That'd put you in just under, just outside the top 10%, I think of New Zealanders, really good net worth. But with the first situation where you've got a million bucks in shares, you're like, I could retire really easily. I've got heaps of money.
8:26 Speaker 00 In the second situation, you've got a lovely house and maybe some granite benchtops, $2 million house, but not much else.
8:33 Speaker 01 And probably a big rates bill.
8:35 Speaker 00 And so if you look at that, it's like, well, what would you prefer? Now, it's easy to say, well, I'd wanna be number one. I'd wanna have the million dollars in shares. But then, if you're in it and you're like, but then we could live a really nice life. We could have a two, if we have the two million dollar house, like we could, we'd live in a much nicer house.
8:50 Speaker 01 We've worked hard.
8:51 Speaker 00 That's where the upgrade trap starts to come in. And again, it's not about telling you that there is one way to go here. It's about making you think, cause sometimes we've got to realise that, oh, do you know what? Maybe that's me. Maybe we are spending too much on the lifestyle assets as opposed to thinking about the investment as well. And then there's trap number three.
9:11 Speaker 01 Yeah, which is the debt equity trap. And Kiwis are exceptional at paying down debt. Like I, I, I've seen some really young people pay off a mortgage quite aggressively. You might have been grinding at the start of your mortgage and then your income goes up. We pour money into our homes where, you know, we might do some renovations. We might, you know, fall into that upgrade trap. Now we've got to a point where we're paying down debt diligently, cause we wanna have that paid off before retirement. Now, the problem is whilst it's great to pay down debt, you've kind of got all this equity locked up in a house, which doesn't do anything for you. I mean, it might still carry on going up in value, but you can't eat the value of your house.
9:51 Speaker 01 And when you think about the fact that, okay, well, if you, if you do the second scenario where you've got a paid off two million dollar house, well, that's all well and good, but that, that isn't doing anything for you. And if you had two million dollars sitting in a bank doing nothing for you, you'd be pretty unhappy.
10:06 Speaker 00 And so I suppose the opportunity is to use that debt equity to actually start buying some investment assets. Now, I wanna give you an, an example though, of the maths behind investing while still paying down a mortgage. So let's say that you've got an extra two hundred bucks a week, right? And you're thinking, should I pay that off, my half a million dollar mortgage? Or should I start investing it in, for example, shares and managed funds? Well, if you were to take that extra two hundred bucks a week and pay it off your mortgage, you'd pay off that mortgage about six years earlier. If you were already paying it off over twenty years, you're gonna bang an extra two hundred bucks a week in there. You're gonna be mortgage free six years earlier.
10:47 Speaker 00 You might then say, well, that's great because then I've got my extra 200 bucks a week and my mortgage payment, which would be about 960 bucks a week. For six years, I'm just gonna smash that into managed funds and shares.
10:59 Speaker 01 That makes sense.
11:00 Speaker 00 Okay, so that's option one and what a lot of people might decide to do. Option two is to just keep paying down your mortgage at the normal rate. 760 bucks a week, pay it off over 20 years. But for those 20 years, taking that extra 200 bucks a week and just investing it. And let's say you get a 7% return on that for your managed funds. Now, over those 20 years, you've paid the same amount of money in, right? You've paid exactly the same amount of money into your house and into your share portfolio. On top of that, in both situations, you end up with a mortgage free house. But if you were consistently investing over those 20 years by these numbers, you'd end up with about $70,000 more in your share portfolio.
11:42 Speaker 00 And the reason behind that, the reason you end up with 450 grand rather than 380 grand when you're consistently investing is because the return you get out of investing in shares and funds and potentially investment property could be higher than the interest rate you're paying on your mortgage. So in this example, I've used a 5% interest rate on your mortgage. A lot of people at the moment will actually be paying less interest than that on their own home. But the long-term return you get out of shares and managed funds could be 7%, maybe even higher. On an investment property, once you include leverage, could be higher again. So it's about putting your money where it has the highest potential to compound over time. And that compounding over time is why, in this example, you end up with 70 grand more if you're consistently investing,
12:27 Speaker 00 rather than smashing down your mortgage and then deciding to invest.
12:31 Speaker 01 What I also like about that strategy is that if you change your mind, you put some money into a fund, 200 dollars a week, you do it for 10 years, something, actually, I just wish I'd paid off my mortgage. You can always take that money out and pay it off your mortgage. You can't really do it the other way around. Unless the bank says, yeah, we'll let you borrow that money again and then invest in shares.
12:49 Speaker 00 So what do you reckon the bottom line is for all of us?
12:52 Speaker 01 So I think having a house is really nice, but I don't think, even though we call it an asset, you should ever think of it that way. It's just something that you are using for your own lifestyle. And if that makes you happy, all well and good. But the goal, when it comes to financial success, is not to look wealthy, is to build financial freedom and resilience. And you can only do that by having assets outside of your house.
13:16 Speaker 00 And it's about finding the right balance, right? And I think the issue that we sometimes see is people overweight the lifestyle assets and don't think about the investments. Now, if you've got five investment properties and you're thinking, you know what, I really want to buy a boat. This isn't Andrew and I saying, don't you dare go buy that boat. It's about, okay, maybe it might be appropriate for you to go and do that thing because it's going to make you happy right now. And you've got assets already outside of your home, depending on your situation, right? Like, I'm not sitting here on a podcast saying, hey, yes, you listening to this, Ben, go buy a boat, right? It's about thinking though, are you buying a boat and spending all this money on lifestyle assets when you haven't got any investment assets yet? That's the risk we see. And if you are thinking, hey,
14:00 Speaker 00 well, do you know what? Maybe I do have some debt equity in my home that I want to go and do something with. Well, that's exactly what an Opes Financial Advisor can help you figure out. And if you want a free session to, to talk through this, just go to our website, opespartners.co.nz, click the big orange button, choose your financial advisor, choose a time that suits you, and you can start on your journey. Because over the last 15 minutes, you've learned the number one money mistake Kiwis make, the three traps that cause Kiwis to become broker-rich, and what you can do to fix it. Right, let's wrap it up there. But please don't forget to rate, review and subscribe to the podcast. Really does help us get the message out to more people. Thanks for listening to the Property Academy Podcast. I'm your host, Stephen Knight.
14:43 Speaker 00 We're going to be back here tomorrow with even more daily strategies, tactics and insights to help you get the most after you sell the property market. Until next time.
Previous Is $100K, $250K, $500K and $1M Enough to Retire Comfortably?⎟Ep. 2384 Next Which Makes You Richer – Property or Business? (It’s Not What You Think)⎟Ep. 2386 Page updated November 14, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated