Pod Insights The Property Academy Podcast The Truth About Selling Your House Privately⎟Ep. 2445 About this episode Thinking about selling your house privately to save on agent fees?
In this episode, Ed and Andrew break down the real numbers behind private sales vs using a real estate agent. They unpack when selling privately can genuinely work, and when it quietly backfires.
You’ll learn:
How agent commissions actually compare to the price premium agents often achieve The situations where private sales work best and where they usually struggle The legal and negotiation risks that many private sellers don’t think about Main lesson? Saving money on commission doesn’t automatically mean you make more money overall. The best method depends on your property, your market, and whether you’ve got the skills to handle the process yourself.
For more from Opes Partners:
Sign up for the weekly Private Property newsletter https://www.opespartners.co.nz/newsletter-sign-upInstagram https://www.instagram.com/opes_partners/TikTok https://www.tiktok.com/@opespartners
Transcript 0:08 Speaker 00 Hello and welcome along to the Property Kennel Podcast by Urbis Partners. I'm your host, Stuart Knight.
0:12 Speaker 01 And I'm your Unico.
0:13 Speaker 00 And this is the show that helps Kiwis go from zero to five investment properties. So you could be financially free and stick around for the next 15 minutes because you're going to learn about private sales. Do they save you 25 grand or could they cost you $90,000? Should you fire your real estate agent and sell your house yourself? And when private sales actually work and when they just create problems? Now, this comes from a listener of the show who said, hey, you guys haven't talked about this in a while. Should I skip the agent and save on the commission? Or are real estate agents really worth it? Now, let's say you do decide to sell your house yourself, Andrew. How much money could you save?
0:54 Speaker 01 Well, let's just think about it from how much an agent charges you, first of all. So standard commission in New Zealand is kind of 4% on the first 400K and then 2% on the balance after that. So if you sell for $300,000, it's going to be 4%. If you sell for 500,000, it's going to be 4% on the 400 and then 2% on the 100,000 above. Now, remember you've also got to add GST on top of that.
1:16 Speaker 00 They forget the GST all the time. It's an extra 15%. Oh, that's 4% of the first one, 2%. Oh, I hate it.
1:25 Speaker 01 It's so bloody complicated. And then, so we have got a calculator on our website so that you can kind of figure it out as a rough guide yourself. But on a million dollar property, that's about $32,000. So, okay, theoretically, if I can make the same money and I just think about the commission I'm going to pay to my agent, if I sell that property for a million dollars myself, that's $32,000 that I can save.
1:51 Speaker 00 And that, I mean, that's real money, right? Like, if you think about it.
1:54 Speaker 01 Real cash money.
1:55 Speaker 00 Well, if you're selling your own house and going to buy, you know, a different house, I always think you don't realise how much you're paying the agent. But because you're potentially going to take a mortgage out on your next house, you're effectively borrowing the money to pay the real estate agent in many cases. Now, there is a bit of a catch to this because I saw some analysis from the Real Estate Institute of New Zealand that showed that the median sale price that an agent gets is about 11% higher than a private sale.
2:27 Speaker 01 Now, can I just stop there and just, oh, no, maybe, maybe actually.
2:31 Speaker 00 You can, God, stop me.
2:32 Speaker 01 So I immediately think, okay, you've got the Real Estate Institute, who want real estate agents to be successful.
2:39 Speaker 00 Because all of their members are real estate agents, right? That's how they keep the doors open.
2:43 Speaker 01 Come up with some data and then I look at it and I think, well, hang on, does that mean that me as a private seller is getting less money? Or does it just mean that people are listing higher value properties with agents? And so that's skewing the numbers?
2:57 Speaker 00 Yeah, there does seem to be a bit of a gap there because what we tend to see is if you've got a really cheap property, then maybe you go, no, just sell it myself because somebody will buy it at this price. If you've got a really expensive property, you might go, no, I can't be bothered. I'll use a real estate agent. So that data there that I gave you, the 11% difference, it doesn't mean that if you sell your property, that you are going to get an extra 11%. I mean, that actually a real estate agent pays for itself. Now, if I look at some data out of Cotality, who used to be called CoreLogic, they also did the same numbers in 2023. And they found that there was a 12% premium for using an agent.
3:42 Speaker 00 So about a $78,000 gap with the same caveat that they're not necessarily looking at the same properties because people who own cheaper properties might decide to list them themselves. But what I did see is that agent sales are more likely to succeed.
4:01 Speaker 00 So if we look at the last decade, seventy six percent of properties that were listed by agents ended up selling. Compare that to only sixty five percent of privately listed properties selling. So putting that in other words, if you use an agent, there's about a twenty five percent chance that your property doesn't sell. If you try and sell it yourself, there's a thirty five percent chance that it doesn't sell. Actually, the difference isn't that bad. Like, you might have expected that the difference would be larger than that, right?
4:33 Speaker 01 Yeah, I would have thought so because I can imagine that, you know, John and Jenny list their property, they're unrealistic, they get fed up with open homes and they get some average offers because people are nervous probably buying privately, you know, people are bad enough buying a car privately, let alone a house privately. And then maybe all of a sudden they think, oh, I'll bugger it, I'll just take it off and try again later.
4:56 Speaker 00 Now, let me ask you this, though. Now, we're sitting here, I mean, not begging real estate agents, but they're so easy to beg. We've got some good friends who are real estate agents. Have you ever sold a house privately, as in Andrew Nichol was there smiling at the open home with some flyers that he's designed on Canva? Have you ever done that?
5:17 Speaker 01 Absolutely not, and nor would I.
5:20 Speaker 00 So even though I was sitting here, oh, agents, you'd still use them?
5:23 Speaker 01 No, no, no, no. I was begging the stats because I actually think, like, it just seems like selective data. I mean, you haven't screamed data abuse in a while. I'm not suggesting that it's like, you know, the real estate industry is trying to trick everyone, I'm not saying that at all. All I'm saying is-
5:39 Speaker 00 Well, especially because one of our companies is a member of the real estate industry.
5:42 Speaker 01 Yeah, what I'm more saying is, there's more to that number. You've trained me now to get my kind of, hang on a minute, how is that data actually telling the story that's being told? Or is it just an interpretation? Maybe there's more to dig into there, but then have you got any bright idea of how you might extrapolate some more, more helpful data? It's not like you can split test the sale of a house unless you had like six units and three were sold by agents and three were sold by individuals.
6:12 Speaker 00 Well, I think it's just very difficult to calculate. You'd wanna compare all of the private sales in, for example, Dunedin, compared to all of the pri- all of the real estate agent sales in Dunedin, which I totally understand is a very loose valuation. But this is a way that many of the property indexes are calculated. As you'd say, well, if I use a real estate agent, am I likely to get substantially more compared to CV versus if I, if I sell it myself? That'd be the, the closest way to do it.
6:43 Speaker 01 Yeah, someone should do that. We're not gonna pay for that one, but, but someone else should do it. We've paid for lots of data.
6:48 Speaker 00 Nah, we've, we already keep some of these data companies afloat and otherwise. Now, the other thing to ask though is, okay, let's say that there was a gap and that real estate agents can get more for a house. Why might that be the case?
7:01 Speaker 01 So I honestly think like the number one thing for me as someone, if I were looking to buy a property through a private seller is just the buyer psychology around it. Like, I personally, cause I have looked at some private sales. I kinda find the people a bit difficult to deal with sometimes. I might've gone to like five open homes by private sellers back in the old, old days. I'm not talking about private sales in the as is days. I'm talking about like something that's been listed on Trade Me and I've turned up and, and exactly like you described before, someone's smiling there and they own the house and you wander around, have a look around. I just, I find it a bit meh and I think most people do. And also like the other thing is sometimes people might think, well, I don't really know the process.
7:45 Speaker 01 And you know, the seller probably doesn't know the process as well as a real estate agent. So this all just feels a bit harder. They're trying to hide something or, or you know, is this just gonna end poorly? Another kind of factor is the buyer pool size. So agents, they might have hundreds of active buyers right now in their database that they're kinda working with them within their office or within their organisation. Private seller doesn't, they've got zero. So I kinda think, okay, well, if I'm gonna sell, I wanna go to someone that might say, huh, I know someone that might buy this property and then go out to that buyer and kind of, and show them that. Property for me. And then the kind of the final thing is if you're the owner,
8:26 Speaker 01 you're more emotionally invested, right? So if I go through the property and I go, you know, it's all really nice, but you know, this is a bit of a funny layout, isn't it? And then all of a sudden, Tim, who's put that that extra room, then goes, well, what's wrong with that room? Or what's wrong with the color of the room? There's nothing wrong with that. We've loved it forever. And all of a sudden it turns into this just weird negotiation. Whereas agents will be like, yeah, yeah, no, I agree. But you could fix that up with a bit of paint. And then I think, okay, well, that's good.
8:53 Speaker 00 Well, actually, that's one thing that I think real estate agents do really well is when you're in a house and you're looking at it and you're like, oh, this is a bit weird. And you say that to them. They often will come up with, well, here's what you could do. You could take out that backsplash in the kitchen that you don't like the look of. I mean, the funniest thing is I bought a house that I didn't like the backsplash of, but I haven't changed it.
9:16 Speaker 01 Yeah, you did nothing, right?
9:17 Speaker 00 Absolutely nothing to it. But you know, you go through open homes and they're like, oh, well, you could actually open this up if you wanted to and and do X, Y, Z things to it. And then you as a buyer go, oh, yeah, that's quite cool. Whereas if you are a private seller, because you're not going through as many homes and seeing renovations done, perhaps you don't have the ability to offer those solutions in the same way. Now, having said that, there are people who do private sales really well. There are some people who who don't do it really well. I literally just over the weekend read a story and stuff about a couple in Auckland who ended up selling their property for 1.3 million dollars themselves. And they used a company called Home Sell, which we've talked about on the show before.
10:00 Speaker 00 That's a company where you pay about 750 to a thousand dollars and they will help you with the marketing and the systems and a little bit of advice. So that you have some assistance in selling this property yourself. Now, they looked at their property. They said, we think it's going to sell for 1.3 million dollars. They got an offer at 1.3 million. They accepted the offer at 1.3 million. So they are very, very happy with that. Though it did make me think, well, if the buyer's first offer was where you wanted it to be, why didn't you like, I get you're happy with it, but why don't you push back for a little bit?
10:34 Speaker 01 Nobody takes the first offer. Don't be ridiculous.
10:38 Speaker 00 Yeah, a hundred percent. That's why you've got to come in really low.
10:42 Speaker 00 My third offer is your first offer.
10:43 Speaker 01 Isn't it great that Ed is neither a financial advisor or a real estate agent who says whatever the hell he likes on here.
10:52 Speaker 00 Do you know what? That's actually what, what one of our compliance people once said to me, they were like, because I was thinking about becoming a financial advisor, like, no, you won't be able to say as many things like you do. Now, what about a story where it doesn't go quite so well? I saw another example in Royal Oak, this is again in Auckland, and this couple bought the property for 510K and then they were trying to sell it for about 1.4 million dollars. That was the CV. And they did five open homes across four different weekends, had quite a few people through, right? Like 15 people through in the first weekend, 11 in the next weekend. They come to auction and there's a good crowd in the auction room, but no bids. Ah, nobody bid on it.
11:36 Speaker 00 Then they said, okay, well, we'll set an asking price, we'll make the asking price 1.6 million dollars. Ah, nobody bought. They ended up selling it seven months later for 1.5 million dollars. Now, that might have happened if they did have a real estate agent, right? Like, the same thing could have happened. But it's interesting to be like, oh, wow, seven months with no sales, actually quite a long time. So there are some people who this will work for, there are some people who this won't work for, right? But from your experience, Andrew, 20 odd years in the property industry, when do private sales tend to work?
12:10 Speaker 01 So I think if you've already got a buyer, so a great example of that might be you're going to sell to a family member, or often I hear people say, well, my tenants are interested in buying. I've just recently had an investor do exactly this, or sometimes the neighbour next door. So the negotiation, the hard part of the negotiation is mostly done, you're 80% of the way there. Another example might be the market's just hot, a standard three bedroom property in a popular suburb where 30 buyers are going to be looking at the property at any time, then less marketing and skills involved in actually closing that deal. And I think the final thing is, if you're really patient, maybe you've got some sales skills and you've got a bit of spare time. So maybe you, you know, maybe if you're a lawyer, not saying that you necessarily got
12:55 Speaker 01 sales skills, but you know, maybe, maybe you're a car salesperson or something like that, you're, you're used to negotiating with people or you've been in business, maybe that might be the right time. Would you ever do it yourself?
13:07 Speaker 00 Nah, I don't have the patience for it.
13:09 Speaker 01 I know that, I just wondered if you did.
13:12 Speaker 00 But if we think about when private sales maybe don't work quite as well, if you're in a slower market, or if you've got like a standard suburban property where agents might have a big database for your sort of property. And I think the other one is if this is your first ever time selling a home, as in you've bought a property, you've never sold it though through a real estate agent before. If this is your first ever sale, I think it's probably a good idea to use a real estate agent. And the other thing you've just got to keep in mind is there's a lot of legal stuff and responsibility when you're selling a house yourself, and you really can't skip this. And I'm really talking about your disclosure obligations.
13:52 Speaker 00 Like you have to tell buyers no one issues, leaks and weather tightness or any meth history, unconsented work. If you hide any of that, you could be sued even years after the sale. Whereas if you use a real estate agent, they're going to know what to look for and what to ask, and then therefore know what to tell the buyers to make sure that you don't have people come after you years later. And over the last 15 minutes, you've learned about private sales. Do they save you 25 grand or cost you 90? Should you fire the real estate agent and sell your home yourself? And when private sales actually working when they just create problems? Right, this wrap it up there, but please don't forget to rate, review and subscribe to the podcast. Really does help us get the message out to more people.
14:41 Speaker 00 Thanks for listening to the Property Academy Podcast. I'm your host, Tim McKnight.
14:44 Speaker 01 And I'm Andrew Nichol.
14:44 Speaker 00 We're going to be back here tomorrow with even more daily strategies, tactics and insights to help you get the most out of your sale property back. Until next time.
Previous Can You Retire Off Property Without Selling?⎟Ep. 2444 Next Bought a House at 19 – What He Knew That Most Adults Don't⎟Ep. 2446 Page updated November 14, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated