Pod Insights The Property Academy Podcast The TRUTH about Homes.co.nz listings⎥Ep. 2059 About this episode In this episode, we discuss why you can’t always trust the numbers you see on Homes.co.nz — and what it means for your investment decisions. You’ll learn:How inaccurate online valuations really are (hint: up to 10% off)The hidden risks of owning a property with quirky or unusual featuresAnd how to avoid overestimating your wealth based on “paper value”If you’re building a portfolio and planning for the long term, make sure you’re not relying on inflated numbers. Get the real insights on house prices in New Zealand and how to plan your wealth with confidence. For more from Opes Partners:Sign up for the weekly Private Property newsletterInstagramTikTok
Transcript 0:08 Speaker 00 Hello and welcome along to the Property Academy Podcast by Opes Partners. I'm your host, Stephen Knight.
0:12 Speaker 01 And I'm Andrew Nicoll.
0:12 Speaker 00 And this is the show that helps Kiwi investors go from zero to five properties. So you can be financially free even when homes.co.nz, QV or One Roof lied to you. Now, stick around for the next 15 minutes because you're going to learn how much homes.co.nz and other websites like it are wrong. Some of the signs that your property might be harder to sell. And then lastly, how to decrease the risk that you don't have enough money for your retirement. And I'll tell you where this all comes from. I got an interesting email from Paul. He's a listener of the show and he said to me, Ed, I see one of the big risks in property is I invest in some properties. And then I check in every couple of years being like, oh, that, that value on homes.co.nz. Oh, it's going up in value quite nicely. But what if that's just giving me false hope?
0:57 Speaker 00 What if when I actually come to sell that property, try to pull the cash out so I can fund my retirement? What happens if I don't get as much money as I thought I was going to get? And I suppose, Andrew, when could that happen?
1:09 Speaker 01 I think if there's anything unusual about a property, one of those online websites, they're not going to pick that up. They're not going to pick up the fact that if someone walks into the house and thinks, oh, this is a weird layout. Or it just feels a bit old and damp. And yep, it might be a 150 square metre house on a 600 square metre section. So, you know, in theory, it might be worth 700,000. But when someone actually comes to view it, they're seeing what the council websites and then the homes.co.nz type websites, the things that they don't see, the unusual things that they wouldn't see.
1:42 Speaker 00 I'll give you a really good example. So I was looking at a deceased estate out in Pointe Cheffe, right? And it was such an odd property. Now, what would homes.co.nz see? Four bedrooms, two bathrooms. There was probably 400 square metre section, decent sized house. And they will be automatically looking at other similar sales or sales that look similar on paper. And saying, okay, we think this property is worth X price. But when I looked at this deceased estate, Andrew, it was probably the weirdest house I've ever been in. So there was one part of the upstairs. So you go up one set of stairs and it was like the master bedroom.
2:18 Speaker 01 Did we look at this on the show one time?
2:20 Speaker 00 No, I don't, oh, maybe it did.
2:21 Speaker 01 Was it right next to a creek?
2:24 Speaker 00 No.
2:24 Speaker 01 Okay.
2:25 Speaker 00 No, it wasn't that one. But then you go up another set of stairs and there's another bedroom, but the whole upstairs wasn't good. It did, it was all very weird. Now, homes.co.nz and other online valuation platforms can't see these odd features, which would kind of decrease the value of that property. So how often is homes.co.nz and those types of websites wrong?
2:46 Speaker 01 Well, I think a lot of the time. So on average, homes.co.nz is about 10% inaccurate. So say, for example, your property is showing as a million dollars. Well, it could go anywhere from 900,000 to 1.1 million dollars, which is a big range, right? 200,000 is a lot of money.
3:02 Speaker 00 Well, even worse than that, it's not, that's the range. On average, it either goes for 900K or 1.1 million dollars. The average property is 10% wrong.
3:12 Speaker 01 Okay.
3:12 Speaker 00 And, and if you, you could actually like, if you Google that, how wrong is homes.co.nz? They release their statistics for every single part of the country. And some places might be 8%, some will be like 12% wrong. But across the country, most of the time, 10% is like a great rule of thumb. So if we think about the risk that I'm getting false hope from homes.co.nz, well, there is a bit of risk there because on average, it's pretty wrong. Now, Andrew, I know that our journalist gave Emma Bendel a buzz. She's a real estate agent and has been for about 21 years. What did she say?
3:46 Speaker 01 She said that online valuations are not an accurate representation of actual market values of properties. And as a result, they can be quite misleading. And particularly in her experience with people who are a little less experienced. So say, for example, if you're selling a property and it's likely to go to a first home buyer, those types of people tend to rely on online valuations a lot more. And so as a result, it might be a little bit harder to sell if your property is listed for a price that actually doesn't seem reasonable.
4:17 Speaker 00 Well, the most important thing there, or the thing that I try and drum into people, is that any sort of forecast or online estimate is not gospel. And we, we need to treat them as bullparks as opposed to that is what it's going to be. And some people do get hyper fixated to this. And so what I'd say to Paul, you know, this investor who sent this question in is, okay, if we're thinking about a property that's got a weird layout, then sure, homes dot coated NZ can't see it, but you can see it when you buy it, right? So what I haven't seen evidence of as well, if a property's got an odd floor layout, it's going to double in value more slowly. I haven't seen that, but what I do know is if it's got a weird floor layout or there's something wrong with it,
5:00 Speaker 00 you can buy it for less money when you purchase it. But then when you sell it, you're probably gonna have to sell it for less money than whatever homes dot code NZ shows you. It's that premium in, premium out principle. So I kind of see like the real risk for this is that you look at a property that has an odd floor layout and then you just pay whatever homes dot coded NZ tells you it is. And then you're like, oh, oh, when I go to sell it, I can't get what homes dot code NZ told me it's worth. Do you know what I mean?
5:27 Speaker 01 Yeah, I I'm also just wondering whether or not, because all these online websites are relatively young, right? They're relatively young businesses with relatively new data. I kind of wonder whether or not their data will become more robust as more properties transact. So for example, right, say there's a really weird property right now and Home says it's worth a million dollars, but someone pays seven twenty because that's all anyone's willing to pay, right? Once it's now recorded as a seven twenty transaction, surely their algorithm picks up that, okay, well, there must be something a bit unique about this property.
5:59 Speaker 00 It doesn't at the moment. So what they'll do is say, you've got a four bedroom, two bathroom property. This is what other properties are selling for with those same features in the area. Therefore, the value of this should be X. My understanding is they don't do what you've described as the repeat sale method, where they're like, oh, okay, that property's a bit weird because there could be lots of things that impact a sale price. It could be that the seller's desperate, not necessarily that there's something wrong with the property. But again, I think the real issue here is, well, if you're worried about properties, like, oh, if I buy a property that's got a weird floor layout, it's gonna be hard to sell later. Just don't buy a property with a weird floor layout. Like, that's kind of the main thing here. Like, if you're worried that, oh, if I buy something quite unique and I pay whatever the website tells me to pay now,
6:43 Speaker 00 or maybe I can't sell it for what the website tells me it's worth later on, well, just don't buy that property. Like, buy something more, more normal. And if you are gonna buy a weird property, make sure that you are negotiating down from whatever that price is, because then you're gonna have to do that when you sell it later on. I know I've gone on about this kind of premium in, premium out principle. What I mean by that is that most properties tend to double in value at roughly the same rate. And I wanna run you through a little example, Andrew. Like, if you're an investor and you've got two properties side by side, one's worth half a million dollars, one's worth a million dollars. Now, if they both double in value, the cheaper property has made you half a million dollars. The more expensive properties made you a billion dollars.
7:26 Speaker 00 But as an investor, we should be ambivalent between those two, because the rate of return was the same. They both doubled in value. And so as an investor, if you're thinking, well, okay, how am I gonna spend my money? One option is to say, okay, but if I buy the more expensive house and it doubles in value, I make the million dollars. Yeah, but just buy two cheaper properties then, and then you can spread your risk a little more, assuming that everything else is equal. And so the main thing I say to investors is we've gotta care about the rate of doubling, not so much about, well, was the property more expensive or less expensive? And in this case, with something that's got a weird layout, what's gonna stop it doubling in value well is if you overpay for it upfront. So the kind of two options are either negotiate really aggressively upfront,
8:10 Speaker 00 or don't buy the property with the weird layout to begin with.
8:13 Speaker 01 Which is what we say to people all the time, right? The secret sauce of investing, other than buy and hold for the long term, is actually just buy something that everyone wants to buy, or the masses wanna buy and the masses wanna rent.
8:23 Speaker 00 The other thing that I was thinking about in terms of, okay, we're investing in property for our long-term retirement. How do we make sure that we are more likely to hit however much? Money we need and we close our wealth gaps. And one of the things I often talk to investors about is kind of over investing. So one of the things I've started thinking about is the probability that you hit that goal. And if you want to get really nerdy with this, you can actually run what's called a Monte Carlo simulation. We actually run this for every single investor who goes through the open partners process, which basically says, okay, how fast do properties usually grow in value? And I'll tell you the reason why. If you're planning for your long term retirement, and this is whether you're investing in like shares or property or crypto or whatever it is.
9:06 Speaker 00 The biggest unknown, the biggest risk in that plan is, well, you do not know how fast property prices or share prices or crypto prices or any asset price is going to go up in the future. That is the unknown part. And so one of the things I like to do is rather than just say, okay, well, what's the average been? On average, how fast have shares gone up? On average, how fast have property prices or crypto prices gone up? Because if you just then plug that average into your spreadsheet or to your retirement planning, half of you listening to the show will get less money than you forecast and half of you will get more money than you forecast. Because half of you will be above average and half of you will be below average. And that is exactly what an average is.
9:51 Speaker 00 And so I always say, well, if you're just putting an average into your spreadsheet, if you say, oh, probably prices have gone up by an average of seven percent. So let me just plug that in my spreadsheet. Well, you've basically only got a 50 50 chance that you're going to get however much wealth you've projected within your spreadsheet. And so actually I was literally running a little script for our YouTube channel, Andrew, before. And I was looking at some developer had their website, oh, you know, on average, over the last 10 years, Wellington property prices have gone up by eight percent a year. So invested a property in Wellington because it will go up by eight percent a year.
10:23 Speaker 01 Very selective timeframe, choosing 10 years, first of all.
10:27 Speaker 00 First of all, very selective timeframe. But secondly, I'm like, okay, but even if that repeated itself, only half the people who invest in Wellington will get that. Half of you will do better, half of you will do worse because that's just the market average. And the average means you've got a 50 50 chance of meeting it or beating it. So my prof- Good way is to say, well, I don't want average. I want below average. And I'll tell you the reason why. If you then say, okay, I'm investing in Wellington. And so I was literally doing this this morning, running the numbers for it. And what I was saying is when I run a forecast in a spreadsheet or air modeling, what I want to do is I don't want to know, well, what, what do I get 50% of the time? Or how much wealth can I get 50% of the time?
11:10 Speaker 00 I want to know how much wealth can I build 75% of the time? Or two thirds of the time? I want a 75% chance that I'm going to hit that goal that I've got in my retirement, which basically means using more conservative estimates than the market average and also over investing to make sure you actually hit that goal that you have. Now, I know I've got on a massive rant here, Andrew, but I guess what I'm saying to Paul here is if you're planning for your retirement, you're thinking, okay, I'm going to invest in these properties. They're going to go up at X percent, blah, blah, blah. All of that, that kind of good stuff, which you absolutely should do. One thing you can do to lower your risk and make sure you hit your goal is whatever property growth rate you're using, dial it back a couple of percent.
11:54 Speaker 00 And that will probably be like, oh my gosh, okay, my properties aren't going to make me as much money. So I need to invest in some other things as well. So basically the more you invest, whether it be in property shares, crypto, well, maybe not crypto. I don't want to be saying that on this show. Whatever asset you invest in, the more you invest, the more likely it is you hit your goal. And to make this more robust, you can play around with those figures. Now, again, if you're going through our process, we've got the, you know, this, this kind of nerdy Monte Carlo simulation going on that spits out the probability that you hit that goal. I say to most investors, we really want to be aiming for kind of 67% chance that you hit that goal. A two thirds chance that you meet your goal rather than a 50 50 chance. Maybe we'll talk about this more in, in future episodes because it can get quite nerdy. But over the last 15 minutes, you've learned how much Home Stock Coded Inc. is wrong.
12:38 Speaker 00 Some of the signs that your property might be hard to sell, like if it's got a weird floor layout and how to decrease the risk that you don't have enough money for retirement. Right, let's wrap it up there, but please don't forget to rate, review and subscribe to the podcast. Really does help us get the message out to more people.
12:58 Speaker 00 Thanks for listening to the Property Academy Podcast. I'm your host, Seb Bitknight. And I'm Andrew Dackel. We're going to be back here tomorrow with even more daily strategies, tactics and insights to help you get the most after using the property market. Until next time.
Previous 8 unethical (but legal) things landlords do explained⎥Ep. 2058 Next The dark side of property developers EXPOSED (This should be illegal)⎥Ep. 2060 Page updated November 15, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated