Pod Insights The Property Academy Podcast The Tax Rule Most Investors Get Wrong⎟Ep. 2452 About this episode Donald Trump reportedly used a US$916 million tax loss to avoid paying federal income tax for years. So… could a New Zealand property investor do the same thing?
In this episode, Ed and Andrew break down how tax losses actually work in New Zealand property investing, and the common misunderstandings that trip investors up.
You’ll learn:
How rental property tax losses can reduce future taxable income Why Trump-style tax strategies don’t really work the same way in NZWhat actually happens to accumulated tax losses when properties are sold Main idea? Tax losses can absolutely be valuable, but they’re far more limited than most investors realise.
For more from Opes Partners:
Sign up for the weekly Private Property newsletter https://www.opespartners.co.nz/newsletter-sign-upInstagram https://www.instagram.com/opes_partners/TikTok https://www.tiktok.com/@opespartners
Transcript 0:08 Speaker 00 Hello and welcome along to the Property Academy Podcast by Opes Partners. I'm your host, Nick Knight.
0:11 Speaker 01 And I'm your host, Nick.
0:12 Speaker 00 And this is a show that helps Kiwis go from zero to five investment property. So you can be financially free and stick around for the next 15 minutes because you're going to learn how tax losses really work for property investors, how Donald Trump paid $0 in tax for 18 years, and if you can use the same trick in New Zealand, and what actually happens to your tax losses when you sell your property. Now, if I wind back the clock to 1995, Donald Trump, the now president, but wasn't at the time, filed a tax return showing a $916 million loss. Now, this came from three Atlantic City casinos, the Plaza Hotel, and a failed airline.
0:54 Speaker 00 And that single year's loss was enough to legally wipe out his federal income tax for up to 18 years.
1:04 Speaker 01 That's crazy, isn't it? Imagine that. Imagine a successful businessman.
1:09 Speaker 00 Well, I mean, arguable. I mean, my understanding is it wasn't that successful.
1:12 Speaker 01 No, you make such a significant loss that for the next 18 years, no tax.
1:18 Speaker 00 And by the way, this show is not actually about whether you like Donald Trump or not, right? Because he's mental. But this show is about tax losses, right? And explaining how they work in New Zealand. So what are these things called tax losses?
1:32 Speaker 01 So the way it kind of works in New Zealand, or the way you'd be thinking about it in New Zealand, is if you've got a property and it makes a taxable loss one year, now that means that the expenses are more than the revenue. So let's say you make a loss of $1,000. The next year, you can make a profit of $1,000 and they cancel each other out. Now, just to be clear, a tax loss and a cash flow loss can be two different things. And that often confuses people. So you could, you could actually make $1,000, but have things like depreciation or your home office and these other non-cash expenses that you're not actually paying out that offset your Revenue, let's just clarify that your tax loss and your cash flow loss are two
2:14 Speaker 01 different things, but if you make a loss, that carries forward to the next year.
2:18 Speaker 00 And so the way this worked in the U S is that if you make a big, big loss in nineteen ninety five or nineteen ninety six, it might take you eighteen years to climb out of that loss in the, the tax collector's eyes. Now, how does this work for property?
2:36 Speaker 01 Now, it changed a little bit back in two thousand nineteen, so you can only use residential rental property losses against residential rental property and can. So if you buy an investment property with a big mortgage and you claim all the depreciation and so all up, you've got thirty thousand dollars worth of tax losses, you can make thirty thousand dollars of profit in the future and not pay tax on it so long as it's through that property entity.
3:01 Speaker 00 And you can actually do this in Opus Plus when you are running the numbers on your investment property. Not only does it calculate your tax losses and have them carry forward, if you've got existing tax losses, you can put them in and see how it would impact the cash flow. In fact, I just had an investor email me the other day, say, Ed, I'm trying to put up my tax losses, it's not working. I was like, oh, whoops, I'll fix that quickly. So it's working.
3:24 Speaker 01 Yeah, I actually, yeah, I actually forgot completely about that and meant to email you about that, but it's really handy tool because there are quite a few people that maybe have accumulated losses when the interest rates were higher and they, they've got some properties that are making a profit now that they want to be able to offset it and you can just go and you do it through the assumptions tab.
3:43 Speaker 00 Yeah. And I think the reason why tax losses are really important, and, and this is probably the one time I'm like, oh, good on you, the I R D is they're basically saying, look, if you make a loss, we're not going to share in that loss, right? We're not going to give you a tax refund, but if you make a profit in the future, we're obviously going to tax you, but we'll let you pay back that loss before we start taxing you so that over the long term, we're only really taxing your profits and not unfairly taxing you because one year you might make a profit and the next year you might make a loss. And I think that's really important. And that is why it's also important to still claim. All of your deductions and use a property accountant, even if your properties are negatively geared, so that you are accumulating those losses, because if you don't,
4:28 Speaker 00 then what's going to happen is you're going to pay more tax than you otherwise would. So let's say you buy a rental and you make lots of tax losses. Could I then make some Trump-style tax savings?
4:39 Speaker 01 No. In New Zealand, the law changed so that now your property losses are ring-fenced to that property entity or that particular property. So you can't use those losses against personal income.
4:52 Speaker 00 But what happens if you, say, sell your properties?
4:56 Speaker 01 So let's say you've got two properties, one's in a trust and one's in a company. The one in the company, that's making a loss, and those losses, they accumulate. They're basically being banked at the IRD. When you sell that property, they disappear. Now, that's unless you trigger Brightline and then it can offset that. But once you sell that property, because there's no more properties in that entity, that company, they're gone.
5:18 Speaker 00 And the important thing here in this setup is we've got one property in trust, one in a company. We sell the property in the company. Those losses don't get transferred over to the trust. They stay within that company and we're assuming that these two are not related.
5:31 Speaker 01 And actually, just one thing to point out there. If you've got multiple properties in a company and you sell one of them, those losses are retained by that company. If you have nothing left in that company or nothing left in that entity, well then that's tough luck, those losses are then wiped and reset. And if you buy more properties in the future, sorry.
5:50 Speaker 00 But what you could do is let's say that you've got a property and you buy it in year one. You're planning to sell it in year six and year five you buy another property. Well, even though you bought another property five years later, they still stay within that company or stay within that trust because at the time you sold the property, you still had another property.
6:08 Speaker 01 It's still active. Yeah, think of it like it's still actively engaged in the business of rental properties.
6:14 Speaker 00 And this is why there is a bit of an incentive to structure all your properties as a portfolio, assuming a lot of disclaimers I'm about to give you. But let me tell you the reason why I say that. Because if you pull all of your residential properties together, then they can start. To offset each other. So for instance, you might have a property that's making a taxable loss of five thousand dollars. Then you've got another property that's making three thousand dollars. If that property that was making three grand was in a different company, you'd have to pay tax on that income. But if the two properties are in the same entity, whether it's a trust or a company, well, it doesn't matter that you were making three grand off one property, you made a loss on the other one. So they cancel each other out and you've got two grand worth of taxable
6:59 Speaker 00 losses to carry forward into the next year. And then similarly, if you decide to sell one property, any tax losses that you have accumulated, they are then retained within that entity. Now, that doesn't mean that you should always have all of your properties in one entity. I don't. That's because over time, my portfolio has matured. It was the right move for me originally to buy properties in my own name. Then I've got a few more things going on with my life, with relationships and both business and personal relationships. Then it was the right thing for me to start buying properties in a trust. It was then appropriate for me to buy properties at a different entity when I started buying properties with with friends and business partners. And so it's not always the right thing to have all your properties in the same entity. But if
7:42 Speaker 00 you've got a simple situation, there can be some benefits. So of course, you'll talk to your accountant and lawyer before making your final decision.
7:49 Speaker 01 Now, one thing I've noticed though, is people do struggle to get their head around like how these losses get dissipated every now and then. So I'm just going to give you a couple of examples of when you might be able to use these and when not. And I know I've kind of covered some examples, but just to really get it in your mind. So the myth is that people have is that their losses carry forward forever. Even if I sell up, the reality is it really depends on how it's structured and whether or not the sale of a property is taxable. So let me give you the first scenario. So you sell a property, but you keep at least one rental. Now, the losses offset the future rental income of the remaining properties within that entity. So they survive. Now, another example is
8:31 Speaker 01 you sell a property and the sale is taxable, i.e. it falls under the bright line. Well, the losses that you've accumulated, they can offset the taxable profit that you've made on the sale.
8:42 Speaker 00 So a good example of that would be if you have owned some property for a couple of years, especially when interest rates were high, as long term rentals, they've made some losses. So then you think, okay, I know what I'll do. I'll go and do a flip and you might make $50,000 through that flip. Usually you'd pay tax on that, but if you've got some accumulated losses, okay, that flip, yep, is caught under the bright line test, but you might not have to pay any tax if you've got enough of those losses accumulated. So that's good. It might save you quite a big tax bill.
9:11 Speaker 01 Yeah, that's a great example, actually.
9:13 Speaker 00 I know, I just came up with that one on the fly.
9:15 Speaker 01 And I'll give you one final one. You sell all your properties in that entity and none of them are caught by Brightline. So they don't trigger any Brightline tax. Now the losses, they're stranded in the entity and you've got no property in that entity anymore. So effectively they're lost. You've given those away. You've shut your bank account with the IRD. The losses with the bank of the IRD, if you buy another property in the future, that can still be in the same entity, but those losses have gone.
9:40 Speaker 00 And we were talking about entities, we're talking about trusts and companies, look through companies, maybe even if you buy it in your own name. And I get that this is like quite a technical thing. The reason we're talking about is a, one of you guys messaged in and said, hey, can you talk about tax losses? One of the things I was really keen on when we first started this podcast was to go into enough detail about property that you can actually understand some of these technical nuances because nobody else, funnily enough, was out there talking about tax losses for rental properties or any of these like quite nitty gritty things that are actually quite important for property investors to understand. So even if you're listening to this being like, hey, maybe, maybe I'm just at the start of my journey and I don't really understand exactly what you're talking about. That's okay. This is a bit more of an advanced show because typically there aren't that many people out there talking about quite advanced property investment content, which is what we're here for.
10:26 Speaker 00 So there's something for, for all types of property investors. Now, if you are thinking of buying or selling a property or you're interested in, in how this might impact you, have a chat with your property accountant and if you are looking for a good property accountant, I always recommend Opus Accounting. Of course, that's Andrew and my company. If you go to opusaccounting.co.nz, you can book in a free tax consult with one of our team. And over the last 15 minutes. You've learned how tax losses really work for property investors, how Donald Trump paid $0 in tax for 18 years and if the same trick works in New Zealand, and what actually happens to your tax losses when you sell your property. Right, let's wrap it up there, but please don't forget to rate, review and subscribe to the podcast. Really does help us get the message out to more people.
11:14 Speaker 00 Thanks for listening to the Property Academy Podcast. I'm your host Stephen Knight. We're going to be back here tomorrow with even more daily strategies, excellent insights, how to get the most out of the new selling property market. Until next time.
Previous Retired At 29: How She Actually Did It⎟Ep. 2451 Next They Arrived In NZ With Two Bags Of Clothes … Now They Own Two Properties⎟Ep. 2453 Page updated November 14, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated