Pod Insights The Property Academy Podcast The Question Every Investor Gets Wrong⎟Ep. 2443 About this episode Most Kiwis automatically choose a principal-and-interest mortgage. But for investment properties… that’s not always the strategy investors use.
In this episode, Ed and Andrew break down the real difference between interest-only vs principal-and-interest lending.
You’ll learn:
Why many investors prioritise cashflow over paying down rental debt fasterThe hidden risk when an interest-only term ends The strategies investors use to extend interest-only lending over time Main idea? Interest-only lending isn’t about avoiding debt forever, it’s about where you choose to direct your money. Used well, it can improve flexibility and cashflow. Used poorly, it can create serious pressure later on.
For more from Opes Partners:
Sign up for the weekly Private Property newsletter https://www.opespartners.co.nz/newsletter-sign-upInstagram https://www.instagram.com/opes_partners/TikTok https://www.tiktok.com/@opespartners
Transcript 0:08 Speaker 00 Hello and welcome along to the Property Academy Podcast by Opes Partners. I'm your host, Stephen Knight.
0:12 Speaker 01 And I'm Andrew Nicoll.
0:13 Speaker 00 And this is the show that helps Kiwis go from zero to five investment property. So you could be financially free and stick around for the next 15 minutes because you're going to learn principal and interest versus interest only mortgages. What's the right mortgage for your investment property? What we're seeing investors do right now with their home loans and the pros and cons that you can't ignore. Now, when you take out a mortgage, you typically sign up, you know, if it's just your own home, sign up for 30 year principal and interest mortgage. That's pretty standard. And most Kiwis assume that, well, if that's what you're going to do with your own home, maybe that's what you should do with your investment property as well. Now, just before we go into the reasons why about a third of investors actually use
0:55 Speaker 00 interest only mortgages, Andrew, just briefly explain the difference for anyone new to the show.
1:00 Speaker 01 So if you're paying down principal and interest, so you've got a P and I loan, a standard table loan, every week or month or fortnight, whenever you're making your payment, you're paying the bulk of it's usually interest and then you're paying a little bit of that principal back to the bank to get the loan paid off over whatever the term is. Now, if it's interest only, as it sounds like, you're paying just the interest component of that, you're not actually paying down the principal.
1:23 Speaker 00 And if we look at the numbers, about 14% of loans to owner occupiers are interest only, 86% are on principal and interest. But when we look at the investors number, about a third of investor loans are interest only. So why is it the case that we see that happen?
1:42 Speaker 01 So typically, if an investor's buying a rental property, they might be using a whole lot of the bank's money and not a lot of their own money. That's often the case. Now, if you're taking out a big loan, that's probably going to be your biggest cost. And so often, cash flow is a big consideration for an investor. How much am I going to have to put in every week from my own pocket to cover the difference between the rent I'm getting in and all the costs, including that mortgage? Now, if you're paying down principal, that mortgage payment will be higher if you're paying. Interest only, it'll be lower. So again, you're not paying down that principal. So you're relying on the property going up over time. But if the cash flow is is your main concern at the start, then you go interest only. And actually, I'm surprised it's only a third.
2:24 Speaker 00 Well, I think it's a third of total loans as opposed to new loans. And in fact, when I was talking to Robert from our mortgage team, he is telling me that about eighty percent of new investor loans that he sees tend to go interest only. And one of the reasons for that is let's say that you've taken out a five hundred thousand dollar loan and we're going to keep the maths really, really simple. Let's say you take out that five hundred K loan and pay a five percent interest rate. Now, if you just go on interest only, you're going to pay twenty five grand per year, which is about four hundred and eighty bucks per week. Now, if you put that same loan on principal and interest, you're going to pay about six hundred and nineteen dollars per week. So it's about a hundred and forty dollar difference based on those numbers.
3:08 Speaker 00 And so if you're trying to improve the cash flow, one decision investors make is, okay, I'll put the investment property on interest only because then my repayment is lower. There's also a tax benefit as well, right?
3:20 Speaker 01 Yeah. So to get a bit more technical, from a tax perspective, the debt on your investment property is tax deductible. So what that means is the cost will offset the income you're receiving. So if you're receiving thirty grand a year in in rental income, that's an income that you could be taxed on, but that's offset by the interest payment because that's a cost. Now, your personal house, that doesn't have any interest deductibility. So if we're just thinking purely on a what's the best use of my cash, the extra cash that I've got to pay down debt, paying it off your own home is usually the better option from that perspective.
3:59 Speaker 00 And so basically what Andrew's saying there is, okay, you could pay down your investment property's mortgage with that extra hundred and forty dollars a week. But why don't you take that extra hundred and forty dollars a week that you would have paid off against your investment property, why don't you take that and just pay off your own home faster? And that's the conversation that a lot of our mortgage advisors will have with some of our clients. But having settled. This, there are pros and cons, right? Because if you go interest only on a mortgage and your entire payment is going to interest never paying off that debt, then over the lifetime of that loan, you will pay more in interest, right? Because if you're paying off principal, well, eventually it's all going to be gone.
4:40 Speaker 00 And over time, more and more of your payment is going to go towards paying off that debt. But if your payment only ever goes to interest over the life of the loan, you'll pay more in those interest costs. The other downside or potential con is having higher repayments in the future. So let's say you take out a mortgage. Typically, the way this is structured is it's on a thirty year term. And you don't actually get interest only for thirty years. The most that I've seen recently is ten years, say ANZ or T S Bank. So if ANZ approves your ten year interest only, it's an interest only period on that loan, which basically means after ten years, you've only got twenty years left now to pay off that loan.
5:23 Speaker 00 And what that's going to mean is, okay, if I've got a five hundred grand loan, if I pay it off over thirty years, well, my repayment will be lower than if I pay it off over twenty years. And so what you'll tend to see is, let's say you go interest only for ten years, allow that period to lapse, don't do anything. You're going to see that your mortgage payment will jump up because now you're going to be paying that off in a shorter period. Now, as we're going to talk about, there are some things that you can do to try and mitigate that happening if you're worried about that, such as the extend and lend strategy, which Andrew will talk about a little later on.
5:58 Speaker 01 And look, I know that it's ingrained in us to pay back debt. Like, that is just something that that we all know is a good thing to do. And I guess the way you've got to kind of think about it is what's the most efficient debt I should pay back first? Because all of us have got a limited amount of money every week that we can put towards stuff. And if you've even got just one extra dollar and you want to get the best return on that dollar in terms of your debt repayments, obviously, assuming you don't have, you know, high Interest rate, credit card debt and all those kind of things. If you're just looking at your home loan and your investment property, it just makes more sense to pay off your personal mortgage faster because you want to get rid of that monkey off your back.
6:42 Speaker 01 And I think people often forget this when they're thinking about, okay, well, I've got this investment property over here. I really need to be paying down principal on everything. And to be fair, sometimes the banks don't necessarily explain it as well as they could, and nor is it their job to. So I think people fall into the trap of thinking their rental property is costing them more than maybe it needs to because they are paying back principal.
7:04 Speaker 00 And that's where sometimes people might see Andrew and I on Instagram or on the podcast talking about interest only and the fact that I think almost all my properties, oh, except for one, is on interest only and I love interest only. And they think those guys don't like paying down debt. That's not the case. We're just saying that sometimes it's a bit more tax beneficial to pay off your home loan. On top of that, it can also be more motivating if you put your surplus money into paying down your personal home first, rather than trying to pay off everything at the same time. Because then you get your statement at the end of the year or you look at your statement and you think, gosh, is that all I've paid off? Whereas if you're trying to take the snowball method and just tackle one at a time,
7:48 Speaker 00 what you can find is it's a lot more motivating. So there you go.
7:52 Speaker 01 The other thing that I might just cover in terms of kind of a risk of having more debt on your rental properties is sometimes people think, okay, I've got that 500K mortgage that Ed said before, and I'm paying my $490 a week in terms of interest payments. What if that interest rate jumps up to 7%? Shouldn't I be trying to diligently pay down that loan? So I'm, I'm future-proofing myself against higher interest rates? I completely understand that line of thinking. But again, if you're directing that extra money to your personal mortgage, that might give you some flex in terms of reducing your mortgage repayments, your personal mortgage repayments in the event that you needed to reallocate your cash later on. So again, I understand how people go down that path.
8:35 Speaker 01 But I think, you know, after a conversation with a mortgage broker about this, Better way of structuring is to pay into your personal mortgage first.
8:43 Speaker 00 Well, one other pro I think people often miss around interest only mortgages is that they can allow you to get a higher return on your investment property in some cases. And what I mean by that is when you buy an investment property, there are two different types of investments you might make into it. The first is going to be your deposit, the second is any cash flow top up. Now, if you think about the property going up in value, which is the way that many investors make the most amount of money from it. Whether you have an interest only mortgage or a principal and interest mortgage, that has zero difference on how much your house is going to go up in value. Of all the things we talk about on the show, of the things that influence your capital growth on a property, your personal mortgage type has nothing to do with it, right?
9:27 Speaker 00 And so if I think about paying down a dollar of debt against my investment property, what is like the benefit I get from that? Well, it's one dollar. I paid off one dollar. I put a dollar in, I paid off one dollar of debt. And so what are you seeing investors do in 2026?
9:45 Speaker 01 Now, the vast majority of investors that I work with do go interest only because most of them have a personal mortgage. And if they don't, they tend to be wanting to build up their portfolio. And so cash flow is really important because again, if it's the difference between topping up your rental property, $200 a week on interest only with all your costs or $400 a week. Well, most investors would rather have two rental properties paying $200 a week than one property and trying to pay down principal. So most people are going interest only. And I think because we've seen a lot of change in the interest only kind of renewal process. What I mean by that is some of the banks were a bit more challenging when when interest rates were a bit higher with the renewal process.
10:26 Speaker 01 A lot of people are going for those longer term interest only approvals, so T S B and A and Z, I think Ed said before. They will do interest only for up to 10 years. And if you can get that approved, 10 years is a great length of time to not have to worry about it again.
10:41 Speaker 00 And one thing that a lot of people ask though is, well, okay, well, what happens at the end of those 10 years? When I just said before, Europayment jumps up, one strategy we. Talk about in our book Wealth Plan is what we call the Extend and Lend Strategy, which is let's say you've got that 30 year principal and interest loan. You get to the end of five or 10 years, you go back to the bank and say, can we extend that loan back out? So rather than switching directly over to principal and interest, can I just extend it back out to 30 years? And subject to all of their checks and approvals that they need to do, you might find that they say yes to that. Another strategy we see is, well, if one bank says no at the end of 10 years, switch across to a bank that says yes.
11:23 Speaker 00 Subject to them actually, you know, one of the other five banks saying yes, it doesn't always work out. But this is what we see a number of investors do. It doesn't mean you're always going to get a yes from the bank in five years though.
11:34 Speaker 01 Yeah, and I think the key thing is talk to a mortgage advisor about this because there also might be other considerations. So I'm just thinking about one of my investors at the moment. So they have got interest only renewed, they're coming to the end of their investment journey. And they're going to hold some properties into retirement, so they want the cash flow to be as strong as possible. Now, for two of their properties, they managed to get the bank to extend interest only for another 10 years. And like again, they're 65 in two years' time, so that's great. They've got eight years in retirement, they can hold those properties without having to worry about principal payments. So the cash flow works. Their bank has got one of their rental properties as well, they've refused to renew the interest only. And the reason for that is they've just got different criteria.
12:17 Speaker 01 And so now those investors are thinking, okay, well, maybe that's the one we'll sell first. But also we can afford the cash flow on that one because we've had it for quite a long period of time. So maybe it doesn't matter. What they could do, they could pick up that property and move it to Bank B, the one that's already just renewed. Because they clearly meet that criteria with the other bank, the servicing criteria. The danger is that now all their eggs are in one basket as far as the banks go. And so whilst there is a benefit, there's also a con. So you don't want to always think, okay, I'm fixated on split banking, I'm fixated on interest only, I'm fixated on one thing or the other or the cheapest rate, without considering all the other moving parts. And that's where a mortgage advisor will be best to direct you.
13:01 Speaker 00 A hundred percent. You don't want to just think, oh, those guys on the podcast talked about interest only, and that's the be all and end all. But then we also talk about splitback here. We're also talking about, you know, everything. You've got to assess everything is the most important thing. The other thing I want to mention as well is when you do try and extend out an interest only period, every time you do that, you are going to have to put in a full application to the bank. And there are times like when interest rates go up, that that can be harder. So remember how in COVID times, interest rates were really low, quite easy to get a mortgage approved. Then interest rates went up, but harder to get a mortgage approved. And so what I saw with one investor is she had her own home, she had an investment property.
13:44 Speaker 00 Initially, it was on interest only. Three years later, she went to extend that out and say, cool, can I get another interest only period? The bank said no, because with those higher interest rates, they couldn't approve an extension to that interest only period. And so one thing I'm hearing our mortgage advisers say to investors at the moment is if you're worried about interest rates going up in the future, then let's say you've got one year left on your interest only right now, what you might do is go and apply to extend it for another five years now, rather than waiting for it to lapse. Because if you're really worried about the war in Iran, inflation, the potential for higher interest rates, maybe you can take action now if that is a specific concern for you.
14:29 Speaker 00 When might principal and interest in paying off debt on your investment properties, though, actually make sense?
14:36 Speaker 01 If you've got no mortgage on your personal home or your rent, so you don't have a personal mortgage to pay off, and you've already got surplus cash, or you can afford the top ups even with principal payments, then yeah, maybe then you do say it's kind of compulsory savings. Now, just bear in mind, any of those compulsory savings, it's kind of like your Kiwi savings, locked in there until a certain time in the future, and usually that's when you sell that property. So there is a disadvantage of not having that money liquid. But for some investors that I work with, if they're making extra cash, they know they're going to spend it probably otherwise, it's probably quite good to have it locked up in there.
15:14 Speaker 00 And I'll give you a good example, like when I built my first investment property, I went principal and interest because I didn't have my own home. I was an investor. Okay, that's fine. Then property prices went up. I borrowed against that property to go buy some more investment properties. Oh, that's very nice. Cool. We've got some more. Then when I eventually bought my own home, the value of that first investment property had dipped and it now doesn't have enough equity within that property for me to go back and get interest only on it. Now, you might look at that and say, well, that's a real con, isn't it? But I look at it as a positive and say, but it helped me buy an extra two properties. I'd rather have those extra two properties than be able to just put that on interest only because the loans, you know, not what I consider to be particularly large, maybe 260 grand.
15:59 Speaker 01 I'll tell you another example where I've seen someone paying down principal quite aggressively as well is there's an investor who had a large chunk of cash and they've bought a cash flow property to help fund their retirement. Now, they're only five years out from retirement. So what they've decided is in the next five years, because they earn a really, really strong income, they want to pay down their mortgage in full. So they want to get to retirement with a mortgage free rental property, but they've only got five years to do it. So they've made the decision to take out a P and I loan and pay it back aggressively because when they retire, they don't want their rent going to the bank. They want the rent coming to them.
16:35 Speaker 00 And I suppose what that shows is like, there could be a general thing that we do, like what I said before, like 80% of the investors Robert's working with tend to go on interest only because that's what's suitable for them. But there are lots of other reasons why you might actually pay principal and interest, even if you are an investor. And so it's kind of a what works for you. And if you want to try and figure out what works for you, then you definitely should talk to a mortgage advisor. And if you are looking for a good mortgage advisor, you might like to reach out to Opus Mortgages. If you go to opusmortgages.co.nz and click the big orange button, you can book a meeting with our team. And in the last 15 minutes, you've learned principal and interest versus interest only, what's the right mortgage for your investment property, what we're seeing
17:16 Speaker 00 investors do right now, and the pros and the cons you can't ignore. Right, let's wrap it up there, but please don't forget to rate, review and subscribe to the podcast. Really does help us get the message out to more people.
17:33 Speaker 00 Thanks for listening to the Property Academy Podcast. I'm your host, Steve Attenborough.
17:36 Speaker 01 And I'm John Nicholl.
17:37 Speaker 00 We're going to be back again tomorrow with even more daily strategies, tactics and insights to help you get the most out of the new sound property market. Until next time.
Previous Why Your Neighbours Could Kill Your Airbnb⎟Ep. 2442 Next Can You Retire Off Property Without Selling?⎟Ep. 2444 Page updated November 14, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated