Pod Insights The Property Academy Podcast The Problem With Commercial Vacancy Rates No One Explains⎟Ep. 2346 About this episode How risky is commercial property, really – and how long do buildings actually sit empty? In this episode, Ed and Andrew break down the real vacancy risk in commercial property and why the numbers you see in reports can be seriously misleading if you don’t know how to read them properly. You’ll learn:How long commercial properties really sit vacant The 3 main types of commercial property, and which one consistently has the lowest vacancy riskWhat actually drives vacancy This is a must-listen if you’re considering commercial property – or want to avoid the costly mistakes many investors make by trusting the wrong numbers. Don't forget to create your free Opes+ account and Wealth Plan here. For more from Opes Partners:Sign up for the weekly Private Property newsletterInstagramTikTok
Transcript 0:08 Speaker 00 Hello and welcome along to the Property Academy Podcast by Opes Partners. I'm your host, Stupak Knight.
0:12 Speaker 01 I'm Andrew Nichol.
0:12 Speaker 00 And this is a show that helps Kiwis go from zero to five investment properties. So you could be financially free and stick around for the next 15 minutes because you're going to learn how long commercial properties really remain empty, not earning any rent, the three types of commercial properties and which one has the lowest vacancy and what actually drives vacancy risk and how to check it yourself. Now, I was recently at a musical, Andrew. It was the Dolly Parton musical. You know, I'm right into them down here at Christchurch.
0:40 Speaker 01 What a wonderful night. Who took you to that?
0:42 Speaker 00 Myself, me, myself and I, it was a self date. The company was amazing and it was helped by the fact that a podcast listener. I wasn't, I had one glass of wine, Andrew. It was just a very full one. It's because nobody wanted to go with me. Nobody wanted to go see Dolly with me. Anyway, somebody was there, a podcast listener, young guy. What's he doing at a musical? I don't know, but he comes up to me. I'm not young anymore, Andrew. Anyway, I'm at this musical down here in Christchurch. Young guy comes up to me, he's a podcast listener and I said, I need to know, what do you want to care more about on the show? And he said, commercial property. And we got talking about how commercial property can often get you a high yield, i.e. more rental income for the price of the property.
1:26 Speaker 00 But one of the big risks we talk about is not having a tenant, right? What happens if you've got this commercial property? Nobody wants to rent it off you. It's pretty easy to find a tenant for your residential property because people are looking all the time, but there aren't as many businesses sniffing around commercial properties, you know, day to day. And so what I said to him is, I reckon we could quantify this. I reckon we could get some numbers out of this. And I think one thing you need to know is that if you go and read a report from CBRE or Colliers or some other commercial property company, the vacancy rate you see in their reports can be a little bit misleading.
2:05 Speaker 01 Yeah. So the vacancy rate is the percentage of space that's empty, right? Now, so if you look at a report from CBRE, it might say something like vacancy rate is two percent or six percent. But often a residential investor might think, okay, that means the average property is empty X percent of the year. But that doesn't mean the average property is empty eleven percent of the year. So it means that right now, eleven percent of this total stock is vacant. Now, eleven percent of the year, that's like five or six weeks of the year, right? So in a residential world, that might be okay at the moment, but you know, on the higher side. But if I think about commercial landlords, if they only had five or six weeks vacancy per year,
2:50 Speaker 01 they'd be very, very happy.
2:52 Speaker 00 Well, that's where there's a difference between the vacancy, which is how many of the commercial properties are empty versus the time to lease. And I really wanted to understand, well, how do you calculate these vacancy rates, right?
3:04 Speaker 01 Because How do you know that eleven percent of them are empty? Is that what you mean?
3:08 Speaker 00 That's the thing. Because we produce and share our vacancy rates on the Opus Property Management website and they update and we can know that because those are our properties, we manage them, the data comes straight out of our system. But how do you know what the vacancy rate is for the commercial property market generally? Well, I got chatting to Hamish Fitchett from Colliers, he's their National Director for Research and Economics. And he said, and I was really surprised by this, that they get people to literally walk buildings city by city and verify listings and see how many listings there are, but they will actually walk the streets and walk the buildings to see how empty something is.
3:50 Speaker 01 So someone from Colliers has got this clipboard and he's wandering down the street and he says, empty, empty, empty, least, least, least.
3:58 Speaker 00 Well, I'm not sure as well whether it would be like a Colliers employee. You might outsource that to like university students or something? And I think what this discussion about vacancy versus time to lease can kind of mask is that some commercial properties stay empty for years and years and years. And I know you've got an example for me.
4:20 Speaker 01 Yeah. So in residential, you can typically find a tenant within a few weeks. Like if you have a really bad run, it might take you a couple of months kind of thing. But with commercial, it can be multiple months or even years. So I always like to look at Hamilton. I'm flying to Hamilton tomorrow after recording this.
4:35 Speaker 00 What are you flying to Hamilton for?
4:36 Speaker 01 I wanted to get a lay of the land of the Hamilton market. And you kind of only really know when you get your boots on the ground. So I'm gonna go do that. I told you this yesterday. You never listen to me anymore.
4:46 Speaker 00 You didn't give me the reason. The last time you were in Hamilton, you crashed a car. I hope you don't do that again.
4:50 Speaker 01 I reversed and I reversed, uh, down a long driveway and crashed the car. Now, anyway, I saw this office space online. It looks like a really nice building, big building, and it's right in the heart of the CBD. It was listed for rent seven years ago. Imagine having seven years with a vacancy on a rental property.
5:10 Speaker 00 Yeah. And, and I mean, I can imagine there might be an argument where it's like, oh yeah, but maybe that's an old listing they never took down.
5:17 Speaker 01 But not for seven years.
5:18 Speaker 00 But I know Hamilton and, uh, this particular building, it won't be the entire office building, but it might be a floor of it. It's about twenty seven hundred square metres. But I would not be surprised if it was empty for a long time. I saw another one that's been empty for ten years. It's just a huge amount of vacancy, right?
5:35 Speaker 01 And that was in Auckland, right?
5:37 Speaker 00 Yeah, this is a retail store in Newmarket that I know has been empty. I think they might have had a couple of pop-up stores, you know, come and go. But that's not the same as having a longstanding tenant for a couple of years at a time.
5:50 Speaker 01 When you get into commercial, often you are playing with the big boys at that stage. And so you might have syndicates or you might have overseas money who can actually afford to sit on a property vacant for that long. You think about a residential investor, they've got big mortgages and a lot of commercial investors as well as well. But like to get no return on investment for a ten-year period, that's obscene to me.
6:11 Speaker 00 Well, that risk does come with high yields, right? So if we think about a residential property, average yield in New Zealand, about four and a half percent for a residential property. For a commercial property, not only would you expect to get a higher yield, and we'll tell you kind of some ballpark in a second. But on top of that, the tenant pay- For your rates and for the insurance and they cover a lot of those operating costs that as a residential landlord you're paying for. But if we think about vacancy, there are really three different types of commercial properties and some have more vacancy than others, right?
6:47 Speaker 01 Yeah, so office and no surprises probably for a lot of you at the moment. They've got the highest vacancy rate, retail is second. And then industrial has been the star performer with the lowest vacancy rate. Now a caveat here, neither CBRE nor Colliers, who are the two big companies in this space, publish a single New Zealand wide vacancy rate. Instead, they publish vacancy by cities.
7:12 Speaker 00 But that's the trend we kind of see, you know, industrial doesn't have as much vacancy at the moment. Office has a lot more. Now, if we think about the vacancy rate of like industrial, so we're talking about warehouses, the sort of properties that maybe a mechanic or a panel beater might in, that would be considered more industrial. It's certainly not office, it's certainly not retail. Those tend to have very low vacancy rates. Auckland's industrial vacancy rate is just like 1.6% right now, according to the latest CBRE figures. Christchurch is about 2%, Wellington just over 3%. And I think the reason why industrial is doing so well is you've got more e-commerce these days. People buy more stuff online rather than at the store. Because of that, we've got logistics, you need to have warehouses full of stuff that can be shipped out to people.
7:56 Speaker 00 If we think about New Zealand Post, they deliver 88 million parcels per year at the moment. And every time you order something from warehouse or the Briscoe's, it's coming out of a warehouse and especially Wellington, there's a bit of a land shortage really. I mean, on one side, you've got Oriental Bay, the big ocean. And then on the other side, is that what it's called Oriental Bay, that whole thing? Yeah, on the other side, you've got mountains, so there's basically no.
8:22 Speaker 01 They're landlocked.
8:23 Speaker 00 There's, there's like no land you can actually build on, but industrial tends to be doing really well. Office is the worst, right?
8:30 Speaker 01 Yeah, well, if you think about the, the post-COVID world, where we all got locked up at home and we figured out how to use our printer at home and get a couple of screens set up. So many more people are working from home now using Zoom and stuff like that, that I think that as a result, it's really put pressure on that office space. And, and if you look at Auckland CBD office vacancy, it's at 18.8% according to CBRE, which when you think about it, that means that one in five offices is currently sitting empty. Now, back in December 2019, before the pandemic, it was 4.7%. So vacancy has nearly quadrupled. Now, if you go to Wellington, CBD office vacancy is about 18% and in Christchurch it's about 9%.
9:12 Speaker 00 But what's really interesting is it's not spread evenly. So in commercial property, you've got this idea of prime and also the secondary, secondary stock, right? So the prime stuff's the really good stuff, to be honest. It's the sort of offices that PWC or Deloitte or the big consulting firms are going to be in, you know, the really good stuff.
9:33 Speaker 01 The fancy ones.
9:33 Speaker 00 Yeah, people are still in there, right? Spark or Vodafone, actually it's not called Vodafone anymore, it's called 1NZ. Those companies are typically in prime office space and that's got a low vacancy rate. It's about 11% in Auckland, so one in 10 rather than one in five. But if you look at secondary CBD office space, so the stuff that a smaller company might be in, it's got a vacancy rate of over one in four, 27%. So it is a little bit of a tale of two markets. And even if I think about the office building that we're in in Auckland, we've got most of a floor at Opes Partners, but there was probably about a quarter of a floor next to us that was empty for well over two years. And it was just like, gosh, nobody, nobody's in there. They actually had to lock the door so that we wouldn't go in and use it.
10:18 Speaker 00 Cause we, our team were like, oh, well, we're running out of meeting room space, we'll just go in there. Then they were realised, oh, no, no, no, can't have that.
10:24 Speaker 01 They should have just locked us into it.
10:26 Speaker 00 Well, they tried to, but they wanted an obscene amount of money for it. That wasn't worth it.
10:31 Speaker 01 Tell him he's dreaming.
10:32 Speaker 00 But what's interesting is retail is probably the most visible. And if you're walking around Auckland CBD, you probably think the vacancy rate is quite high. But actually, it's it's less than the office space.
10:42 Speaker 01 Yeah, so Auckland CBD retail vacancy hit thirteen percent in May twenty twenty five. And it's a national record, according to Baileys. And just again, to give you a comparison, Wellington CBD, the figure is eight point five percent. So yep, Auckland's had it pretty rough. Retail space and office space, you do kind of see that stuff more. Retail probably more so because if you walk down, you walk down Cuba Street in the thick of a downturn in the market, like we're getting today or back in the GFC, it feels like a ghost town.
11:15 Speaker 00 But what's important to also recognise is there is that combination between yield and risk, right? The higher risk, the higher the yield. So if we look in Auckland at the secondary office space, right? The one where over one in four properties are empty, the yield on that is over eight percent. Huge yield, huge yield. But if we look at prime industrial, which has the least vacancy, it's about five and a half percent at the moment. And then obviously everywhere else is somewhere between that. The prime CBD office space has a yield of about seven percent, you know, compared to the over eight percent for the secondary market. But that comes with that higher vacancy. The thing about commercial yields is they are great if you can get them.
11:57 Speaker 01 Yeah.
11:57 Speaker 00 That's what you've got to remember. It's great if you can get it, but if one in four are empty, uh, that can be quite difficult.
12:04 Speaker 01 I think sometimes as investors, we can get way too caught up on the on the top line numbers and and and see a high yield and think, that's why I've got to get into commercial. So I guess then what you're going to be thinking about was, well, how long is my lease going to be? And are these properties going to be rented for quite a long period of time? So I've got some certainty. And Releas actually did some research. They looked at forty thousand New Zealand commercial tenancies. Office leases, their average tenancy was just under three years. I'm quite surprised about that. I thought most offices might have taken longer leases than that.
12:34 Speaker 00 Yeah, but there'll be some really small. Companies that take a very, like a really small lease.
12:39 Speaker 01 Hmm.
12:40 Speaker 00 Like, so for instance, in the other episode that we've done about commercial property, we give an example of like one big, big company that's taken a 20 year lease on a, on a site.
12:50 Speaker 01 Yeah.
12:50 Speaker 00 Whereas if you're just a small business, you might take a, a two year lease on an office space, especially when commercial landlords and secondary spaces are having to be a bit more accommodating.
13:03 Speaker 01 Retail averages just over three and a half years and industrial just over three years. The retail is another one that surprises me. Industrial, like, I kind of get that. But I kind of think with retail, if I've set up a store, I want to have, you know, a longer lease so that I'm established. But again, retail is pretty hard. Right now, as you say, landlords have to be a bit more accommodating. So if I want to go into the retail space, I probably want some flexibility that if it doesn't work out, I can close. And if it does work out really well, I can expand.
13:32 Speaker 00 Now, one thing I do want to mention is if you already own investment property, whether it's commercial or residential, a big part of managing vacancy is understanding what's going on in your portfolio. So you can manage it all in one place. And if you are a residential property investor, I do want to mention some new features that have just gone live in Opus Plus. Remember that this is our property investment app, which is kind of like Sharesies for property, where you can both look at investment properties and analyse them, but you can also manage your portfolio in one place. And one thing I think a lot of people have missed is that if you turn on Pro Property Management, you can get a real person, a property manager, to look after your property. And you can also get complete visibility of your properties inside the app, like your inspection reports, your rental summaries.
14:17 Speaker 00 We even trained an AI to read all of your documents and let you know how your property is really going. And it's the only property management in the country that works this way. If you want to check it out, if you log into Opus Plus, click on Property Management and book a quick meeting. Andrew and my team can then look after you from there. And one of the things I just mentioned though, around if you want to understand commercial property, is to go into realestate.co.nz or Trade Bank, go to the Commercial Property section and sort by. Oldest listings, oldest listings first, because then you can see just how long some of these properties really do languish on the market. And I think that could give you a little bit of a better idea of the realities of what does and what doesn't rent than any numbers in a vacancy report.
15:02 Speaker 00 And over the last 15 minutes, you've learned how long commercial properties really remain empty, not earning any rent, the three types of commercial properties and which one has the lowest vacancy and what actually drives vacancy risk and how to check it yourself. Right, let's wrap it up there, but please don't forget to rate, review and subscribe to the podcast. Really does help us get the message out to more people.
15:26 Speaker 00 Thanks for listening to the Property Academy Podcast. I'm your host, Tim at night.
15:29 Speaker 01 I'm Andrew Nicol.
15:30 Speaker 00 We're going to be back here tomorrow with even more daily strategies, texts and insights to help you get the most out of the estate and property market. Until next time.
Previous The Commercial Property Reality Check at Every Price Point⎟Ep. 2345 Next The Property Negotiation Move That Saves Money Without Backfiring⎟Ep. 2347 Page updated November 14, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated