Pod Insights The Property Academy Podcast The Everyday Actions That Are Costing You Wealth⎟Ep. 2431 About this episode Why do so many people start investing… and then quit? In this episode, Ed and Andrew use a simple analogy – the gym – to explain why building wealth is less about knowledge… and more about behaviour. You’ll learn:Why people who go to the gym are the best investors 5 similarities between going to the gym and investing The one thing you should do NOW if you’ve been putting it off for yearsMain idea? Getting ahead financially isn’t about knowing more, it’s about sticking with the basics long enough to see results. The people who succeed aren’t perfect… they just don’t quit. And check out our list of the Top 10 Financial Advisers in NZFor more from Opes Partners:Sign up for the weekly Private Property newsletterInstagramTikTok
Transcript 0:08 Speaker 00 Hello and welcome along to the Property Academy Podcast by Urbis Partners. I'm your host, Stephen Knight.
0:12 Speaker 01 And I'm Andrew Mickle.
0:13 Speaker 00 And this was the show that helps Kiwis go from zero to five investment property. So you could be financially free and stick around for the next 15 minutes because you're going to learn why people who go to the gym are the best investors, five similarities between going to the gym and investing, and the one thing you should do now if you've been putting it off for years. Now, Andrew, you're a bit of a gym goer these days. Why is it that you think that people who go to the gym make for better investors?
0:40 Speaker 01 Okay, so if you think about the kind of person that might sign up for a gym, normally it's at the start of the year and you think, right, my new year's resolution, I'm going to get back to the gym, you're really excited, then you go a few times, you feel good, bit sore, and then life gets in the way and you quit. And 14% of people cancel their gym membership within the first month. That's much higher than I expected, but 50% of new gym members quit within six months.
1:07 Speaker 00 That's actually extraordinarily high, isn't it?
1:10 Speaker 01 That's way higher than I would have thought. Now, compare that to investing. With KiwiSaber, there are 3.4 million members, but 30% of them, roughly a third of working age members, they're not contributing at all. Now, everyone wants to be rich and everyone wants to be fit, but very few people actually do the work to get there.
1:34 Speaker 00 And I suppose what you're saying is that if people are going to the gym regularly and despite the fact that nobody really enjoys it, I mean, somebody will say, I enjoy it. I'm like, I don't. If you're the sort of person who does it anyway, then maybe you've got some strictu tiveness about it. And I think the reason that people tend to both quit the gym and quit investing is because of this term that we have in behavioural science, which is called status quo bias, which is when you know you should do something, you know you should be better with your money, you know that you should get to the gym, but if you were sitting on your couch... Cheating your Tim Tams.
2:11 Speaker 01 As I do.
2:13 Speaker 00 Then you're sometimes you're more comfortable just doing what you're doing right now than making a change in your life, right? So even if you know you're gonna have a worse quality of life if you don't go to the gym or don't invest, sometimes it's just easier to decide to do nothing and do what you are doing right now. And we kind of see this with KiwiSaver funds as well. So one in 10 people are still in default KiwiSaver funds. They haven't made a decision about who they want to put their money with. They haven't made a decision around what sort of funds they wanna be in. And in fact, right now, forty percent of new KiwiSaver members just go straight into that default fund.
2:56 Speaker 00 And so I would bring that up because it's very similar between investing and improving your health, which is, you know, you probably should, but it's easier to do what you're doing right now rather than make a life change. The second similarity I see it between investing and going to the gym is the number of times you turn up. Now, Andrew Ballpark, how often do you think, not that you're a fitness expert, but you do go quite a lot and you're fitter than me, how many times do you think that somebody should go to the gym per week?
3:24 Speaker 01 Four to five.
3:25 Speaker 00 Four to five? Oh, gosh. I would say three. If I make it three times, I'm pretty happy.
3:30 Speaker 01 Well, three's a good ifa, but I think to kind of make significant change, four to five.
3:34 Speaker 00 So there was one study out of the US that found that gym members who paid a seventy dollar a month fee, in this study, went to the gym just once a week.
3:45 Speaker 01 Really?
3:46 Speaker 00 Yeah, sixteen dollars per visit.
3:49 Speaker 01 So in New Zealand, that would be considered one of the lower cost gym memberships, I would have thought?
3:54 Speaker 00 That'd be about sixteen dollars a week. I think I pay twenty dollars a week and that's a discounted rate.
4:00 Speaker 01 So if you pay more, are you more likely to go more frequently?
4:04 Speaker 00 The study doesn't specifically address this, but I think what it's showing is that if you're going once a week on average, that's probably not enough to see progress. And if you don't see progress, you quit because it feels like it's not working. And I think you see something similar happen with investing. Like if you're not investing enough to see some progress, then it's just like not doing enough reps at the gym or not turning up to the gym frequently enough that you don't see enough progress and so you quit. I mean, I think it's really good if people are just starting out with a small amount to dip their toe in the water and then they grow, right? Because you've got to start somewhere.
4:42 Speaker 01 Yes.
4:43 Speaker 00 But if you're doing it sporadically, say, okay, I just save what's left over at the end of the week or what's left over at the month, you might not be doing it consistently enough, investing consistently enough to see the progress that's going to turn the start of a life change into an ongoing habit. And so what I always say to people is you've got to make sure that you are investing automatically every time you get paid.
5:06 Speaker 01 Yeah, and I, I really think, just, just in terms of the conversations I've been having with some of our financial advisors recently, sometimes we set our goals way too big. And because of that, we don't see those mini wins. And if we don't see the mini wins, we just don't bother. If something seems way too hard, we're just like, I'll bugger it. I'm just not going to do that. But if you can see some progress with your KiwiSaver going up or your arms getting stronger, then all of a sudden you're more likely to repeat that process.
5:35 Speaker 00 Well, it's quite funny because in our previous episodes where we've talked about goal setting, I've talked about setting like 30 year goals, which are massive, big goals, right? And the, the purpose of that is to inspire you to start the journey and get on your way. But you also need what you just talked about, which is the small goals as well, to feel like you are making progress. So you keep on doing it. Now that brings us to the third similarity, which I know you want to talk about. Leg day.
6:05 Speaker 01 Now, it's funny that I'm covering this one today because I just got my new four week programme from my PT and I opened it up yesterday and he's moved my leg day from Thursday to Monday. And I thought, bugger that. Now, I hate leg day because it's just so rough and then you spend the next four days hobbling around and then you're about to do it again. And for anyone that doesn't like going to the gym, you kind of just put that off and you're just thinking, I'll do upper body day and then, and then you do what I did and you're going to do legs today. Now, guys often do this because they hate it and I think girls tend to do it because they want to have, you know, nice butts. And of course, the issue is if you're a guy and you're just going to do upper body and then you end up with tiny little legs, you're out
6:50 Speaker 01 of proportion, right? And so if you think about it from an investing standpoint, you've got to have that balance as well. And so you've got to have that diversification. Now, if I'm thinking about, you know, investors in property, this is where they go, right, I live in a nice house. I really like my neighbourhood. It's got a good school zone. So I'm going to buy the house down the road because I've seen it's for up for sale. So let's do that. Here's the problem. Now, all of a sudden, all your property investment, even though your house isn't an investment, is concentrated in one area and you've got to think wider than that.
7:24 Speaker 00 Okay. So, so people who have all of their properties in the same area, or maybe just investing in one individual set of shares, it's a bit like skipping leg day.
7:35 Speaker 01 Yeah, that's it. I was, I knew there was something in there.
7:39 Speaker 00 The fourth similarity I see is that if you're not seeing results, you might need some help. So I know someone who's in his late 50s and he said to me, look, I really need to do something with my fitness because I'm feeling like I'm 70 years old at the moment, despite the fact that I'm still in the 50s. I said to him, well, there's a gym in your suburb just down the road. Let's go on right now and book you a PT.
8:01 Speaker 01 Did you try to do that? Who was this?
8:04 Speaker 00 Let's do it right now. And the reason I said you've got to get a PT and we need to book it in now is because if we don't do this right now, the status quo bias is going to take over. And in three months' time, we're going to be catching up for a drink again and you won't have gone to the gym once. And the reason that I think that a P T is very important is because if you don't know what to do or don't know all of the exercises you should be doing and in what order and some of the mistakes to avoid, you might be worried that you're going to look really stupid or that people are going to stare at you or judge you and you might feel embarrassed. And so because of that, you don't bother even stepping into the gym. You just put it off for later.
8:46 Speaker 00 And I think that that is incredibly similar to investing in that people don't get started because they don't know, well, which app should I use? Should I use Hatch or should I use Sharesys or should I use Consilium? Or should I use something else? And then, okay, I I've heard about these index funds. Index funds seem to be the way to go. Okay. So not financial advice. So then what I'm going to do is, oh, wait a second. There's about 60 different index funds that I could possibly invest in through this app. I don't know which one to go for. Okay, let's just close the app and I'll come back to it later. And then you never come back to it again. And I think the solution here is just like how you get a P T because there are so many pieces of equipment in the gym and there are loads of different weights. So there's loads of different things you could do.
9:30 Speaker 00 You get a financial advisor, right? So somebody who can help figure out what you want to do and what your goals are. And then can help you go ahead and invest the money the way that you want. And that's going to suit your goals.
9:42 Speaker 01 Yeah, I think I think that's right because people are probably overwhelmed by both of those concepts, not knowing what they don't know and then just feeling embarrassed with a bad outcome. And here's what the data says on all of that. So research by Vanguard says that a financial advisor adds roughly 3% per year in net returns. Now, what's the single biggest component? Behavioral coaching. So stopping you from panicking. So those moments where we invest in something, Tesla, because we heard it was a good investment on a diary of a CEO. And now it's all of a sudden tanked and we panic and go, oh God, we're going to get out of that. And so we pull our money out and then think, oh, I'll put it into Uber. That'll be much better. Then they tank and then you flip flop and you basically just end up losing money.
10:28 Speaker 00 Isn't that amazing that Vanguard is one of the largest? Just investment managers in the world. And yet they are saying having a financial advisor can add three percent per year in terms of your return. So if you just put that into context, let's say you get five percent if you're investing yourself. And maybe you get eight percent if you're using a financial advisor. Now, often it's not because the financial advisors are God's gift and, and understand how to stock pick accurately. Although they will help you construct your portfolio. We're talking about here, financial advisors specifically working in funds and shares and those kinds of things. But the reason that financial advisors often get a higher return is because they stop you from doing really, really, really dumb things.
11:12 Speaker 00 Like selling everything when the market tanks. Or over investing in a stock that's already gone up and had its increase. And then you invested at the top and then you haven't, haven't got that or maybe get a slight decline. So it's really the behavioural stuff that tends to add those returns in. And I know that you've, you've seen a different study around gyms.
11:33 Speaker 01 Yeah. So, so going back before, we said that about fifty percent of people drop off within the first six months of signing up for a gym. Eighty seven percent of people who use a P T, they're still going after six months. And it is just the fact that now I've got someone else that I'm accountable for. So I'm feeling more comfortable in the gym because I understand the equipment. But also now I have to tell that guy Todd that I'm no longer going to be turning up. And Todd will say, you're still a fatty, get back here. And so that, I think that accountability piece really helps drive the success.
12:08 Speaker 00 Is Todd actually your P T?
12:10 Speaker 01 No, I made that up.
12:11 Speaker 00 Oh, you made that up. Well, my, mine's Tim. And I think the other thing that I've just mentioned that a, a P T should do is they'll create a training plan for you. And for instance, I could go into my app right now, it's called Kahuna's. And I could show you my trading program of what I've got to go and do tonight at the gym. While Tim's standing there yelling at me that I need to lift harder. He doesn't do that, he's very good. And basically a financial advisor does the same thing is they create a financial plan around what are the steps you actually. Actually need to take in order to get closer to your financial goals. Now, just like how if I do Tim's plan that he's put through to me, even if I follow it perfectly, it doesn't guarantee that I'm going to start looking like Arnold Schwarzenegger.
12:56 Speaker 00 But, but it will get me closer than if I didn't have a plan at all. I think that's very similar to a financial plan. A financial plan does not guarantee that you are going to be able to retire rich, but it will get you much closer, or it's more likely to get you much closer than if you did it on your own. And like, if you're an Opus client, you can log into your Opus Plus app right now. It's actually about to go live on Android very soon. And you can see your plan, right? And I think that's very important that people have the ability to do that. And that brings us to the fifth similarity, which is.
13:31 Speaker 01 Your diet is your cash flow. Now, you can go to the gym seven days a week. You can hire the best P T, but if you go home, Edward, and you eat that entire packet of Tim Tams every single night, doesn't matter what you're doing. You're not going to get fat. Your diet is the foundation and if you max out your calories on junk food, you're never going to see the results. So when it comes to investing, your spending is your diet. So if you're eating all of your cash and you've got nothing left to invest, it doesn't matter if you're using the best financial advisor. If Andrew Nichols put together a great property plan for you, you won't get the results because your cash flow is rubbish and none of it's going to work.
14:13 Speaker 00 Well, it's a bit like you, it, it, in order to lose weight, you've got to have a calorie deficit, right? If I want to lose my tum tum, then I need to be eating fewer calories than I am using. And it's exactly the same with investing. You've got to be at a spending deficit. Effectively, you've got to spend less than you earn. So you have extra money that you can go ahead and invest. And it's so funny that there are so many analogies or so many similarities from the gym to investing. And I know a lot of you guys listen to this podcast while you're out walking the dog or, or maybe driving or a lot of you going to the gym. And so you might start to see these parallels yourself. Now, if you've been putting off investing for three, five Or even 10 years, I think there are two things that you can do this week.
14:55 Speaker 00 One thing is to like, just do it, which might be that you download a sharesies app and you start putting your $50 a week into there and have it automatically investing. I think that's a great way to start investing, right? Because it's very difficult to just go out and buy an investment property and then, okay, sweet job done. You're probably not going to be able to do that in a day, whereas you can set up those automatic payments and start investing through a sharesies or a Hatch app within an hour. The second option, I think, is to get a PT for your money. So book your session with a financial advisor. Now, you don't even have to use our company, Opus, right? I've got a list of the top 10 financial advisors and I'll ask producer Dave to put a link down in the show notes so you can check out what your options are, right?
15:40 Speaker 00 Because while Opus does property, not all of you will want to be investing in property right now. And so you can choose, okay, am I looking for somebody who can help me in property? Or am I looking for somebody who can help me in shares and funds? And if you find someone you can trust, they can start putting that plan in place for you. I'll drop that link down in the show notes. And over the last 15 minutes, you've learned why people who go to the gym make the best investors, five similarities between go to the gym and investing, and the one thing you should do now if you've been putting it off for years. Right, let's wrap it up there, but please don't forget to rate, review and subscribe to the podcast. Really does help us get the message out to more people.
16:20 Speaker 00 Thanks for listening to the Property Academy Podcast. I'm your host, Tipit Nain. And I'm Junakum. We're going to be back again tomorrow with even more daily strategies, techniques and science to help you get the most after you've seen the property market. Until next time.
Previous From 15% Hype to 6% Reality – Here’s What’s Going On⎟Ep. 2430 Next The Tiny House Plan That Backed Their Financial Goals⎟Ep. 2432 Page updated November 14, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated