Pod Insights The Property Academy Podcast The Boarding House Catch Nobody Talks About⎟Ep. 2484 About this episode Boarding houses can generate rental yields that most property investors only dream about. But there's a reason for that.
In this episode, Ed and Andrew unpack the reality of investing in boarding houses.
You'll learn:
Should you invest in boarding houses … pros and cons revealedHow much rental yield can a boarding house generate Who should buy a boarding house ... and who should probably avoid it While boarding houses can produce significantly more cashflow than a standard rental, the higher returns often come with more management, more compliance, and more moving parts than most investors expect.
Book a meeting https://bit.ly/3QE2XJN to start your path to financial freedom with a detailed financial plan for $0.
For more from Opes Partners:
Sign up for the weekly Private Property newsletter https://www.opespartners.co.nz/newsletter-sign-upInstagram https://www.instagram.com/opes_partners/TikTok https://www.tiktok.com/@opespartners
Transcript 0:08 Speaker 00 Hello and welcome along to the Property Academy Podcast by Opes Partners. I'm your host, Seb at Night.
0:12 Speaker 01 And I'm Adrian Niccol.
0:13 Speaker 00 And this is the show that helps Kiwis go from zero to five investment properties. So you could be financially free and stick around for the next 15 minutes because you're going to learn, should you invest in boarding houses? We're going to talk about both the pros and the cons. How high a rental yield you can get from a boarding house and also the extra costs involved? And who should buy a boarding house and who potentially shouldn't? Now, I actually lived in a boarding house for a short stretch when I was 18. My friend Leo and I rented a small room. I'm pretty sure we paid something like a hundred and $20 a week each, right? And it worked because it was very, very cheap. So in terms of what that actually looked like, we would rent our room.
0:57 Speaker 00 There was a shared bathroom, there was a shared kitchen and dining room. And I think there was something like maybe 25 people within the boarding house. It was quite large.
1:07 Speaker 01 25?
1:09 Speaker 00 Yeah, it was quite, it was, it was a massive boarding house. I don't think I ever walked around the whole thing, but it got me a foot in the door of Auckland. I didn't have any family here, so I had to live there. And what I wanted to do was kind of flip the question and talk about, well, not what it's like to, to live in a boarding house, but what does it take to buy one as an investment? Who's it for? Who's it not for? What does the data actually show? Have you ever lived in a boarding house?
1:35 Speaker 01 No.
1:36 Speaker 00 You'd be a bit too precious for that, eh?
1:38 Speaker 01 Yeah, and I'm not very good with being outside of my comfort zone or other people. I had a flatmate once for a couple of months. That was it.
1:47 Speaker 00 Did you kick them out? What happened?
1:48 Speaker 01 It's terrible. She was, she was, she was a nice girl, Hannah, something or other. And she never paid any rent. I think her parents had died. It was a pretty sad situation. And, and so she had this money that was managed by a lawyer and he was meant to pay it, but there was just never paid the bills and she just drank my booze and ate my food. And, and it was basically like having a girlfriend, but it wasn't my girlfriend.
2:11 Speaker 00 Well, let's come back to the topic for a moment. What legally counts as a boarding house in New Zealand?
2:18 Speaker 01 So according to the law, a boarding house is a premise that can occupy at least six tenants at any one time. And each tenancy will have a room, but they'll share the facilities like kitchens and bathrooms and laundry. Now, really important nuance here, and it's worth actually clarifying this, the threshold is six or more tenants, not six or more bedrooms, which actually to be fair, I would have said six or more bedrooms. So anything below six tenants is just treated like a normal tenancy.
2:46 Speaker 00 And I'll give you an example of that. After I moved out of the boarding house and a couple of years later, I was living in a property in Green Lane, and this was a six-bedroom townhouse. One of the bedrooms was quite small, and there were five of us living there, and each of us had our own tenancy agreement with the landlord. So we weren't all renting it together with one tenancy agreement. So it was five separate tenancies. The landlord did ask us, oh, maybe we should rent out, or maybe they might like to rent out that that sixth small bedroom. Now, if they'd done that, because we all had separate tenancy agreements, that would have kicked them into legally running a boarding house, whereas if they had five separate tenancies, that wouldn't
3:31 Speaker 00 count as a boarding house. So even though this is a normal property, if they signed one more tenancy agreement, kicks over, now it's a boarding house.
3:39 Speaker 01 Or if someone moved to partner in.
3:41 Speaker 00 My understanding is it's not the number of people, it's the number of tenancy agreements.
3:47 Speaker 01 Gotcha. Okay.
3:48 Speaker 00 Because it's about the number of tenancies.
3:51 Speaker 01 Yeah, that's an interesting point, just to clarify then.
3:54 Speaker 00 And the reason this actually matters is the tenancy rules are very different for boarding houses compared to a standard rental. And I think this is the bit that landlords get caught on. So tenants can give notice to leave with 48 hours, pretty much no reason required for all.
4:11 Speaker 01 So you just say, I'm out, I'm out in a couple of days, sayonara.
4:14 Speaker 00 That's much shorter than the 21 days under a standard periodic tenancy. The landlord for no reason could give notice of 28 days, not 90 days like a standard tenancy. And if you've got rent arrears in the behind, then there is a 10 day written notice for them to comply. Then 40 hours of termination. So, so there are mu- much different rules when it comes to running a boarding house. As opposed to just renting out a property, which we usually talk about on the show. Now, what does it actually cost to buy a boarding house?
4:47 Speaker 01 So the honest answer upfront is that most boarding houses sell by negotiation. So public fixed prices, it's actually quite hard to get. And so we've had to work off some real examples that we can find. The best documented recent example was actually a place in Dunedin. It was called Alva House. I love how they call, they have all these names. I've got a couple of clients with a couple of the infamous properties in Dunedin that they have as their student accommodations. And you mentioned them to even a bank and they're like, oh yeah, we know what you're talking about. Now this one, Alva House, was a 25 bedroom boarding house. And it was generating just under 240K per year. Now that includes GST. And that's the gross rent collected.
5:28 Speaker 01 And this property had a ratable value of 1.56 million dollars. So if you just look at the gross rent and the value, that's a gross yield of roughly 15%. It's massive. Now, the property was listed in June 25, but it was not actually sold successfully. So it's actually back being rented and one studio is actually still available for rent by Ray White right now.
5:50 Speaker 00 Now, I reckon one of the reasons why it might not have sold, and this comes down to something to watch out for. If you're a first timer looking to buy a boarding house, which is that there are a lot more stringent compliance costs. When it comes to boarding houses and there's a very important reason behind this. And you might remember back in 2023, there was a very sad fire in Wellington. At Loafers Lodge and five residents died in that fire. It was a 92 bedroom boarding house. And it was a building. With no sprinklers. And because of that tragedy, we now have higher requirements for boarding houses.
6:30 Speaker 00 And actually, um, the Ministry of Business Innovation and Employment, MB, they actually did a report looking into boarding houses. And they found that when you've got a boarding house, you've got to have a, I, I believe you've got to have a building warrant of fitness. But if you were going to buy a boarding house, you're like, oh, cool. Here's the building warrant of fitness. You've got to remember that that's not issued or verified by the council. It's the owner's own, like yearly declaration that they've got the, the right systems, they've been inspected, they've been maintained. But that's just effectively taking the owner's word for it. So you'd actually want to make sure that all of those systems are in place, right? But there's more in terms of the compliance side.
7:14 Speaker 01 Yeah. So MB did another assessment and they inspected fifteen boarding houses. And they found that fourteen out of fifteen did not comply with the healthy home standards. Now boarding houses, they've got, they had to comply since first of July twenty one, so earlier than the normal rental property deadline. So if you go and buy one, there's a good possibility that it might not be up to healthy home standard. And so you need to factor that into the cost of acquisition because you need to have it compliant.
7:44 Speaker 00 Because if you bought a boarding house and you found that it didn't have sprinklers, yeah, you might have bought that. Let's just take the, the Dunedin one. Let's say you did buy it for one and a half million dollars. I don't know what the cost of putting in sprinklers is, but I'm assuming that it's not very cheap.
7:58 Speaker 01 No, I can't imagine so.
8:01 Speaker 00 Now, what's the financial upside though? Cause we've talked about so, some of the cons, like are there, are there some pretty good returns that, that compensate for that?
8:10 Speaker 01 Yeah, I think from a cash flow perspective, like if we just look at the gross yield first of all, that's, that's what people look at. So remember I said that, you know, the, the one example in Dunedin was like fifteen percent. But generally speaking, you might have seen between a eight and twelve percent or even higher gross yield. And it is really hard to find a clean data set for this information. So we're, so we're using a bit of a, a finger in the air. But you know, if you think about that compared to the national median gross yield of, you know, four percent kind of thing. It's, you know, double or triple the amount of gross yield. But you're just going to remember the gross yield is a bit misleading sometimes. And if you're really wanting to assess this kind of investment, you need to be thinking about the net yield because it really comes down to what drops out the bottom.
8:53 Speaker 00 And that's just because boarding houses like Airbnbs, right? Have higher costs associated. You're gonna have a higher property management fee because it is way more work to manage a whole bunch of tenancies and people moving in and people moving out compared to a long-term rental. A long-term rental might be, say, seven to 10% plus GST in terms of the rent. A boarding house could be 10 to 20% plus GST. And I know that some property management companies will decide not to work with boarding houses because it is so much more work. If we think about power, water, internet, well, in a normal rental, the tenant pays for that. In a boarding house, it's typically landlord pay. They pay their 110 or 120 dollars.
9:36 Speaker 00 It's not 110 to 120 dollars anymore, it'd be 200 dollars. 200 dollars a week for the room. And then you, as the landlord, end up paying those, those extra costs. If we think about tenant turnover, typically in a standard rental, you, you'd get at least a year out of most people. In a boarding house, there's gonna be many more shorter stays. I think that I was in the boarding house for maybe two months that we were in that, in that property.
10:04 Speaker 01 What was it like?
10:06 Speaker 00 Well, it was really interesting seeing the sorts of people in there because I had a view that it would kind of be, I'm gonna, I'm gonna really show my privilege here, like, down and out.
10:18 Speaker 01 That's what I, that's exactly what I thought.
10:20 Speaker 00 You know, it's gonna be people who are really doing it tough. But actually, you get talking to them. There were so many really nice people. And I remember talking to one guy who was in there because he recently got divorced. He needed somewhere to stay, so he moved in there because he got kicked out of his house.
10:39 Speaker 01 And he just wanted something temporarily, that makes sense.
10:42 Speaker 00 He just needed something temporarily. For others, there were some people in there who were, who are a bit more long-term. And it might be people who, for whatever reason, don't wanna be in a flattening situation. I mean, effectively in a boarding house, it, it is like a flattening situation, but don't wanna have to go and find a, a group of people to, to live with, or maybe they don't, don't. Have as many friends in the city if they've just moved there, but they can't afford to go and rent a property for themselves. But I remember that, cause we're two young guys and they were eighteen years old. We don't really know anything about life. And some of the other residents were very kind to us in terms of like sharing food sometimes and and all of these things. So it was a very good learning experience and one of those times where you really do need to check your privilege and
11:27 Speaker 00 and just be like, oh yeah, this is fine. Like, like I had a view about who might live here, but actually on the whole, people are actually very nice and kind.
11:35 Speaker 01 And something that actually just jumped into my head, like, you know, if you think about someone that might rent for their entire life. I know lots of people, particularly if you're listening to the show, you strive to buy a property, but there are plenty of people that that's just not for them. They'd rather invest their money in something else, or maybe they just don't have any extra money to invest. If you're renting a boarding house, you've probably got a lot more stability than a normal rental, because a normal rental might get sold every seven years, say on average. Whereas a boarding house is probably always going to be a boarding house. You're probably unlikely to be kicked out unless you start to breach the house rules.
12:06 Speaker 00 Yeah, that's actually probably a good point from a tenant's perspective. Now, let's talk though about who actually runs boarding houses at scale in New Zealand. Do people really do this?
12:17 Speaker 01 Yeah, so we've just spoken on the show previously about Liz Harris, who who's a very successful, lovely lady in Christchurch who runs a long established portfolio of boarding houses across the country, particularly in Christchurch where she's based. Wiggrem Lodge, the Christchurch Apartments. And I remember actually there was a a property she bought in Nelson. I I'm pretty sure actually it was a convent, like it was a nurse's convent. And they converted that into, it's now a hundred and ninety rooms and it's completely full and employs twelve staff. So like, that's huge. Imagine that, a hundred and ninety rooms all being rented out. It's a lot of people.
12:55 Speaker 00 It is a lot of people. The other thing that I like about that story is it does show you that if you've got a boarding house at scale, then you are gonna need some staff in there, right? Because you're gonna need some people to go in and clean the various common areas. We're going to need to have so, like a boarding. Boarding house manager, I know it, the one that I lived in all of those years ago. There was somebody living on site who was the boarding house manager. And so you can expect to be paying somebody in there. And again, that's where you get some additional costs as well as that higher revenue coming in. And the other thing that I just mentioned is I tried to go online to find boarding houses. So I went to like Auckland Trade Me and I just typed in and, you know, you use the curly brackets when you search.
13:38 Speaker 00 Because if you type boarding houses.
13:41 Speaker 01 It'll search for boarding and houses and boarding houses.
13:45 Speaker 00 And so then you're going to get lots and lots and lots of searches. So if you put your, your quotation marks around boarding houses and to trade me and search for it. It's going to bring back results that only have the whole word boarding house in it. There were two results in Auckland. One was not actually a boarding house. It was one that you could potentially convert to a boarding house. The other was a boarding house. And what that showed me was, okay, there ain't that many of these going around. There are going to be some around the country. I remember, I think we even had them on the podcast. We had a wonderful couple out of Invercargill who'd turned a property in Queenstown into a boarding house and done very, very well out of it. But there aren't that many boarding houses around the country that are currently listed online for sale.
14:30 Speaker 00 So if you can't buy one, what you might need to do is convert one if you're really into it. But as a financial advisor, Andrew, what's your honest verdict here? Who, who might invest in a boarding house? Who was it not so much for?
14:43 Speaker 01 It's funny, um, because literally just about a week ago, I was in the Auckland office. And one of the financial advisors asked me exactly this question.
14:51 Speaker 00 Oh, really?
14:52 Speaker 01 Yeah, yeah, yeah. And my immediate response was that they're not for the faint hearted. Now, I think they can be wonderful investments for people who are experienced investors, who are well capitalized. I, they've probably got a bit of cash because you're probably going to carry low debt on these things because you're looking for an income now. You probably want a long-term horizon with a cash flow forecast. And you're probably not so focused on the capital growth side of things. Because an asset like this is going to increase in value as the income increases. Value because the next buyer isn't going to fall in love with it and think about raising their kids there, they're thinking about it as an investor mindset as well. And so you've just got to think, okay, if I'm looking for cash flow, you probably want
15:36 Speaker 01 to be hands on as well. If you're happy with a bit more touch than a normal rental property, this could be the right investment for some people. Now, it doesn't suit people that want to be a passive investor who are looking for capital growth and certainly not a first time investor. I don't think you'd want to get into this as your first investment or anyone who just kind of wants to be hands off.
15:59 Speaker 00 Yeah, I reckon if you had a million bucks in cash and you got to buy something for one and a half bill, carry 500K worth of debt on it, and you really wanted to get some income off that million dollars in cash, you might consider this among lots of other things that you'd also consider. That's kind of where I'd see it, see it leading. And over the last 15 minutes, you've learned should you invest in boarding houses? We've talked about the pros and cons, how high a rental yield you can get from a boarding house and some of those extra costs involved and who should potentially buy a boarding house and who should maybe leave it? Right, let's wrap it up there, but please don't forget to rate, review and subscribe to the podcast really does help us get the message out to more people.
16:42 Speaker 00 Thanks for listening to the Property Academy Podcast. I'm your host, Steve McKnight.
16:45 Speaker 01 And I'm Andrew Nakom.
16:46 Speaker 00 We're going to be back again tomorrow with even more daily strategies, tactics and insights to help you get the most out of the use on the property market. Until next time.
Previous Can You Trust the Prices You See on Trade Me?⎟Ep. 2483 Next The Things That Shock New Landlords Most⎟Ep. 2485 Page updated November 14, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated