Pod Insights The Property Academy Podcast The #1 Wealth Killer No One Talks About (But Should)⎥Ep. 2181 About this episode Most investors think the biggest risk is choosing the wrong strategy. But the real danger isn’t what you invest in … it’s how you behave. In this episode, Ed and Andrew reveal the $200,000 mistake most investors don’t realise they’re making: switching in and out of investments at the wrong time. We show you how emotional decisions can quietly drain your returns – and why staying the course often beats “tinkering” with your portfolio. You’ll learn:Why investors often earn less than the very funds they invest inHow switching from property to property (or fund to fund) racks up huge hidden costsThe power of patience: why doing nothing can sometimes make you the most moneyDon't forget to create your free Opes+ account here. For more from Opes Partners:Sign up for the weekly Private Property newsletterInstagramTikTok
Transcript 0:08 Speaker 00 Hello, welcome along to the Property Can Be Podcast by UBS Partners. I'm your host, Seven9.
0:11 Speaker 01 I'm Andrew Nakal.
0:12 Speaker 00 And this is a show that helps Kiwis go from zero to five investment properties. So you can be financially free and stick around for the next 15 minutes because you're going to learn the $200,000 mistake that most investors don't even realise they're making. The real reason why your investment behaviour matters more than your investment strategy and how much more you could make just by staying put. And you see, Andrew, the mistake that I see investors make is often they get a little bit nervous and they start thinking with their heart more than their head. And I think you really see this within the numbers because there was a very surprising stat that I saw the other day.
0:47 Speaker 01 Yeah, so let's say you invest in a fund and that fund is expected to get, or it does get, an 8% return a year. Morningstar actually did a report which showed that a lot of people actually perform worse than what their fund performs.
1:02 Speaker 00 Now, this is a bit weird though, but how do you, how do you be in a fund that generates 8% per year, but you don't get an 8% return?
1:08 Speaker 01 You get less than that. Well, the way that that ends up happening is people end up getting a bit spooked, right? So for example, if you're in an aggressive fund and you're getting this really good return and then the market drops and you think, oh God, I've lost money. So then people switch funds and go to a more conservative fund, lock in their losses, right? And then when the market starts to go up again, they think, oh God, I missed out on that money, I'll switch back to the aggressive fund. And because they flip flop from one to the other, they end up underperforming what the fund would have done if they'd just stayed the course.
1:41 Speaker 00 And my understanding is it's about 1.1%, right?
1:44 Speaker 01 Yeah, 1.1% is quite a big chunk of that return, right?
1:48 Speaker 00 So if the fund was making 8% a year, some investors are making 6.9% a year because they're panic switching funds.
1:56 Speaker 01 Yeah, which I like, we will have seen a lot of that in COVID times. Like I remember some investors I know taking all of their money out of different funds and then again, piling back in when the markets went up. I mean, in their case, they probably did. Okay with the timing, but for a lot of people, they will have ended up losing money as the market goes down and then crystallising those losses. And then piling back in when the market's going good again. And so they don't get that benefit of just staying the course and getting that eight percent return. And actually, I think it's an urban legend. We've spoken about this on the show before, but I actually heard this recently in a Diary of a CEO podcast. Who's the girl like Chloe Sanchez or something like that? Do you know that girl?
2:36 Speaker 00 Yeah, yeah, yeah.
2:36 Speaker 01 Yeah. So don't give me that face.
2:38 Speaker 00 Of course they do.
2:39 Speaker 01 All right. Well, I just wanted to hear.
2:40 Speaker 00 I don't think her name's Chloe though.
2:41 Speaker 01 No, what is it? Chelsea, Chelsea or something.
2:44 Speaker 00 It, it, no, it's not.
2:45 Speaker 01 Anyway, she's told the story like I tell the story as if it's complete facts, but we haven't been able to fact check this.
2:51 Speaker 00 No, no, no. We know that, that it doesn't exist. There's don't.
2:53 Speaker 01 Well, she, she and I both are of the opinion that it exists. Fidelity, who are a major investment firm in, in the United States, and they did a study on the.
3:03 Speaker 00 Cody.
3:04 Speaker 01 Cody Sanchez.
3:06 Speaker 00 I knew it wasn't Chloe Sanchez.
3:07 Speaker 01 All right. Well, you didn't know what it was though. And um, they did a study where they looked at who in their funds had performed best. And the group of people that had performed the best all had one thing in common. They're all dead. And so as a result, they weren't flip flopping their fund.
3:23 Speaker 00 Yeah, either dead people or people who had forgotten about it are typically the people who make the best returns. And the issue is that if you're, you're in a growth fund, you might switch to a conservative fund. Then you see the market heating up and it's increased in value. Then you switch back to growth. But the issue primarily comes down to if the market has dropped, well, it's already dropped. Switching funds doesn't reverse that drop. Now, of course, the reason people do that is they want to stem the losses. But the issue then as well is if you then switch back into a growth fund when asset prices are rising. Well, that growth has already happened. So you're trying to get on the bandwagon of something after it's already happened or get off the bandwagon after something's already happened. And you know, I read this really interesting study, came out of the University of Berkeley and it's a little bit old.
4:08 Speaker 00 But what it showed is that if you look at individual investors, right? Individual investors who are out there and let's say they're trading between funds, they're trading stocks like a lot. Well, over the period they looked at, the annual return that those people got, and it was a high return, but just stick with me on this, it was about eleven point four percent over the period they looked at. This was like, I said it was old, it's before two thousand. Then they looked at what the market return was, and the market return was seventeen point nine percent. So the cost was about six percent per year of trading frequently. And then they looked at the people who traded infrequently. Well, in this particular study, they made eighteen point five percent.
4:49 Speaker 00 And so there is a big benefit to staying put rather than trying to tell ourselves that we're making intelligent financial decisions and switching constantly. And so this has got me thinking, well, how much does panic switching? And this can happen both in funds and Kiwi savers, but also with property, where people buy and sell really, really quickly all the time. How much could that cost you? So I came up with a scenario and I looked at, I think it was Milford's Fund. So big fund manager in New Zealand and they've got growth funds, they've got balance funds. And I looked back over the last twenty years and I said, what if you started with fifty grand and you're putting five hundred bucks a month into the fund? And let's go back and look at how much growth funds went up and how much conservative funds went up.
5:33 Speaker 00 And if the growth fund drops by like five percent in a month, we need to switch, it's down five percent. We're moving it to conservative. And then, once you see the growth fund going up by three percent, you think, share prices are going up, I need to switch back into that.
5:48 Speaker 01 So did you model this out?
5:49 Speaker 00 So I modeled it all out.
5:50 Speaker 01 Such a nerd.
5:51 Speaker 00 And of course, you could change, like, you could change the factors to create your scenario. If you're sitting in the YouTube comments saying, I don't like what he did. That's all right, come up with your own scenario, it will show similar things. And what I found is, at the start, the people who stayed in growth no matter what and didn't switch their fund actually made slightly less money in the first, what, five to seven years. So panic switching in the early days, just in this one scenario.
6:24 Speaker 00 Did end up saving this person a bit of money.
6:26 Speaker 01 Is that because there's less money in there and it's has less of an effect because of the the length of time?
6:33 Speaker 00 Well, the reason would have been that you see here that the growth fund went down in value by quite a lot.
6:38 Speaker 01 Hmm.
6:39 Speaker 00 So when you initially panic switched, you did stem the losses temporarily and end up with a bit more money. But over 20 years, we see that the growth fund massively outperformed. You would have made about $450,000 if you're just stuck in the growth fund compared to about $250,000.
7:00 Speaker 01 So it's almost double.
7:01 Speaker 00 Panic switch. So that's why I said at the start, you make an extra $200,000 in this scenario if you just stuck with growth as opposed to panic switching. So, I mean, when you hear that, what's your takeaway from all of this?
7:14 Speaker 01 I think the key thing is that switching costs you and I completely understand the emotional decision to wanna stem those losses, right? People worry about how bad it's going to get. And in fact, one of our independent board advisors, when we were away with him, it must have been our last board meeting or the board meeting before, and there was some major turmoil in some of his investments, I remember him being like, oh God, he's a very seasoned investor that was gonna stay the course. But you think about someone who maybe didn't have that kind of level of sophistication, you could absolutely think, I can't, I can't be in all this tech stuff. It was around the Nvidia share drop.
7:54 Speaker 00 Correct. And one of the things that's interesting is, as we've seen in that scenario is switching can actually stem those losses sometimes. So even in the scenario we gave you before, oh, for the first seven years, that strategy worked out. I bet you made far less in the long run in this scenario, in this way of running the numbers, but it can make sense. And that's the difficulty of it. Because it can make sense, you can reason to yourself that, oh, maybe if I switch, it will stem the losses. But actually, it can also lock them in and over the long term, you will end up with less money or it's highly likely that you'd end up with less money. And it's quite funny because as some of you know, that my wife is. Is a financial advisor. And so our pillar talk is just quite fascinating when we talk about
8:38 Speaker 00 different scenarios that we've run into. And she would say to me, you wouldn't read about it, but there are so many engineers who get very spooked when markets go down. And so even though they are highly analytical people who could read all of the research reports that we're talking about here today and say, oh, that makes a lot of sense. But when they see the market going down, they switch. And then when they see the market going up, they sometimes switch back. Now, of course, that's not every engineer, but she was saying it's an interesting trend that she has noticed. And even though these people are highly intelligent, what they almost don't realise, well, maybe they do realise it, but they do it anyway, is that over the long term, they are likely to end up with substantially less money. This is the number one wealth killer that a lot of people don't talk about.
9:22 Speaker 00 And I actually think that this applies to property too.
9:25 Speaker 01 I'll give you an example of actually something I'm seeing quite a lot of at the moment. So I still think that Christchurch has got some serious legs in terms of being an investment opportunity. But is it my number one place that I've recommended for people? Oh, not at the moment. I, I think like from an affordability standpoint, absolutely. From a growth perspective, it'll get steady growth over the next wee while. But it's coming close to kind of where we would expect it to be based on our overvalued, undervalued model. However, because it's had some growth, I'm seeing a lot of investors who have got Auckland properties going Auckland's underperforming, it's not working for me. I want to sell it and buy a couple of properties in Christchurch. Now, that is not what I would advise someone to do, but that's the mentality. And, and interestingly enough, I've seen a few developers and property investment companies
10:11 Speaker 01 going online, talking about how great the Christchurch growth has been and how we're only like a fraction of a percent under the peak of the market. Now's the time to invest. No, that's completely the opposite of what you should be doing.
10:23 Speaker 00 Yeah. And although you can make an argument for investing there, that big opportunity that was there in 2019 is no longer there. The opportunity is somewhere else. This is really where that, that old adage of past performance doesn't guarantee future performance. That is really what, what that is talking about, where you see an asset or you see a, a property market that's Had huge growth and people think, well, I want to get into that. Well, just because it's happened over the last six years doesn't mean it's going to continue. In fact, the opportunity might be somewhere else where the market has been flat or been absolutely hammered. It's so funny, Wellington is so depressed at the moment that I'm like, damn, there's going to be some opportunities there. I'm not sure if it's there right now, but I'm like, you keep an eye on the Wellington City property market, the lower heart property market.
11:08 Speaker 00 There are going to be some opportunities there and probably over the next five years. And the reason is because it got so hammered in the downturn. Everybody's like, oh, Wellington's going through a tough time. I'm like, there are going to be some big property opportunities there.
11:21 Speaker 01 I think the other thing to remember is like, like, say, for example, you have got a property in Auckland at the moment and you think, okay, I want to get into the Christchurch market that's been a bit stronger in terms of performance in the Auckland market. If you've got, say, a hundred grand worth of equity in that property and you sell it and you have to pay an agent's fees and you pay some staging, you have a bit of vacancy, pay your lawyer, might cost you thirty, forty grand all up, right? You erode a big chunk of your equity in that property in that single transaction, then to reallocate that money to Christchurch. And then again, you, you, you might not get the same growth out of Christchurch as what you will out of Auckland. That really hasn't performed over the last ten years.
11:57 Speaker 00 Well, the big thing though in property is that the transaction costs, which we always say, if you sell your property for a million bucks, allocate fifty grand for transaction costs because you're going to have to pay a lawyer and your real estate agent. And there's going to be some real estate marketing and of course, the real estate agent's fee is three percent, but it's three percent plus GST. So it's always a little bit higher than what you think it is. So allocate that money. Now you might sell that property for a million bucks, but you probably had a mortgage on that. So if you had an, an eight hundred thousand dollar mortgage on that and you allocate fifty grand for your transaction costs, you've eroded twenty five percent of your equity in that example, just by selling the property.
12:36 Speaker 00 And so I ran some numbers and what I wanted to look at was, well, what would have happened if you started investing twenty years ago? And I, I haven't thought about panic switching here, but every five years, you take the gains of that property, you sell it and you go in and you invest in something. And by my numbers, if you'd done that, you bought a property and then every couple of years you sold it and you repurchased somewhere else. So you would have ended up with about $500,000 worth of equity by buying and selling and buying and selling. Whereas if you just bought a property and held on to it and didn't incur those transaction costs, you'd be about $75,000 better off because every time you decide that you're going to sell a property and buy something else, it's going to cost you about $25,000
13:21 Speaker 00 and that comes off your actual equity.
13:23 Speaker 01 Yeah. And it's like, when you think about it, you're like, oh, $75,000, is that a huge sum of money? Well, it is when you're talking about kind of half a million versus 75.
13:31 Speaker 00 Hell, yes. 75 grand's a lot of money. It's an enormous amount of money.
13:35 Speaker 01 I know, only because we're talking millions of dollars sometimes with property. Sometimes people can think of that as a small number, but you think about that in relation to the percentage, it's quite large. Now, before I get a bunch of emails about this or heated phone calls from my team saying, you said Christchurch was a bad place to invest. No, that's not what I was saying. What I was saying is Christchurch has had some really good growth. What I'm trying to think about as an investor is where hasn't had the growth and why is that? Is there an opportunity there?
14:01 Speaker 00 Well, similarly, if you look at a place like Mackenzie District, like where Twizl is in New Zealand, that has had just astronomical property price growth. And so if I was in Wellington City at the moment, I wouldn't be selling my Wellington City property to go invest in Twizl because Wellington City has been absolutely hammered. I'd expect that you'd have much better property price appreciation there than in Twizl over the next five, 10, you know, maybe even 15 years. And so what you want to ask yourself is, are you panic switching? Are you moving from an underpriced asset to a more overpriced asset? Because that is the danger if you constantly panic switch. And as we saw in the shares example and the property example, you know, this could kill your wealth by
14:42 Speaker 00 $75,000 or reduce your wealth by up to $200,000 in the example we gave with the shares. And so it's, it really is the number one wealth killer to think about. And that's one of the reasons why people who use financial advisors generally end up with more money over the long term. And we've done some podcasts on that previously as well. And the main reason is that if you use a financial advisor, yes, you're probably more likely. Likely to actually invest and make more investments than you otherwise would. But you're also much, much, much less likely to panic switch. And that's the main thing you've got to think about. And that's why over the last 15 minutes, you've learnt the $200,000 mistake that most investors don't even realise they're making. The real reason why your property investment behaviour matters more than your investment strategy and how much more you could make just by staying put.
15:25 Speaker 00 Right, let's wrap it up there, but please don't forget to rate, review and subscribe to the podcast. Really does help us get the message out to more people.
15:36 Speaker 00 Thanks for listening to the Propic Academy Podcast. I'm your host, Tip at Night. And I'm your host, Michael. We're going to be back here tomorrow with even more daily strategies, tactics and insights to help you get the most out of the estate and property market. Until next time.
Previous We Built Our Own House – Here's How⎥Ep. 2180 Next The Government Won't Pay Me NZ Super – Here's Why⎥Ep. 2182 Page updated November 15, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated