Pod Insights The Property Academy Podcast Testing the Property Speculation Strategy: Does It Actually Work? ⎥ Ep. 1899 About this episode In this episode, we discuss the property speculation strategy. This includes how much money you can make, the best time to use this strategy, and all the risks. That way property investors and landlords can decide if they want to use the property speculation strategy (and how to do it). For more from Opes Partners: Sign up for the weekly Private Property newsletter Instagram TikTok
Transcript 0:08 Speaker 00 Hello and welcome along to the Property Academy Podcast by UBS Partners. I'm your host, Stephen Knight.
0:12 Speaker 01 And I'm Andrew Nakle.
0:12 Speaker 00 And it's our show, we're talking about the speculation strategy. Does it actually work? Well buckle up because over the next 15 minutes, we're going to talk about what the speculation strategy is and how much money you can make. We're going to talk about the risks of this strategy and how much you could potentially lose if it doesn't go right. And on top of that, you're going to learn how to figure out whether this is something you actually want to do. Now, Andrew, some people are going to be listening to this thinking, well, what is the speculation strategy?
0:39 Speaker 01 So this is when you buy a property and you sell it off relatively quickly. So normally, if you're investing in property for the long term, that's normally seven to 10 years or more. Speculation is more the short term, between kind of less than a year. So sometimes you might have a property flipper that might own a property for a few months, maybe even a few hours in some cases, right the way out to kind of two years. So these are the type of people that are captured by the bright line test.
1:03 Speaker 00 And there are a couple of different types of speculation strategy, right?
1:07 Speaker 01 So yeah, firstly, there's a spec build. So that's where you buy a piece of land and either you hire a builder to build a house on it and then sell it off, or you might be a builder yourself. And, and often builders tend to do, you know, their normal construction job. And then they might do a couple of spec homes a year on the side. That's fairly common.
1:23 Speaker 00 Now, where was I? I think we were at a cafe somewhere. You're going to have to remind me which one it was. And we met a guy who was doing spec builds in Nelson. I remember we were in Christchurch at C1 and we had our papers everywhere.
1:37 Speaker 01 This must have been ages ago.
1:38 Speaker 00 This was years ago and there was papers everywhere. And this nice lady said, oh, it looks like you guys are taking over the world.
1:44 Speaker 01 And oh yeah, I remember this. And they were sitting to the left hand side of us. I had to hold my hands up left and right then in the corner. And then they'd heard our podcast or something like that.
1:52 Speaker 00 Yeah, no, she'd read our articles on our website. And he was telling us about how he'd been buying just a plot of land in Nelson, hiring somebody to build a house. And then once it was finished, he'd sell it off.
2:03 Speaker 01 They said they were going to come and see me and you never did. So if you're listening, you never came back to me. Anyway, so that's the spec build.
2:10 Speaker 00 And actually, no, and speaking of times where we meet people at bars and cafes, remember that one we met in Queenstown that just gave us a bit of dodgy vibes? You dragged me along.
2:21 Speaker 01 That was it. Yeah, yeah, yeah. So one of the common things that I do is if I, I'm very nice sometimes, sometimes, and I agree to these meetings. And then leading up to the meeting, I think, why the hell did I agree to this meeting? Anyway, there was this one particular time, I think we were away on a board meeting, and it was at like a four o'clock on a Friday, and I'd pushed this guy out twice already. So I thought, okay, I really need to go meet him. So I said to Ed, why don't you just come along with this guy? He sounds really, really interesting. But Ed, he's cottoned on to me now after years of being together.
2:51 Speaker 00 Andrew always does this. If he doesn't want to talk to someone, like even some of his friends, he'll invite you over. He'll invite you over.
2:58 Speaker 01 For dinner.
2:59 Speaker 00 So he's got some company.
3:00 Speaker 01 And so then I dragged Ed along. This guy was based in Queenstown and he was a consultant. Now, his consulting business basically said, okay, well, I'll go find some land for you, then I'll engage a builder for you, and you'll sell the property at the end, and I'll take a fee. So basically, he was doing the speculation, but he couldn't get the finance to do all these things himself. I think he had a bit of a cheque had passed, but from memory, and someone else was taking all of the risk and he was taking a percentage of the gains.
3:28 Speaker 00 And I remember him telling us about how, oh, well, it's so safe, I get my daughters to do it. I was like, that is a, that's a sales tactic if ever I heard it. So that is what we call a spec build.
3:40 Speaker 01 Now, spec buy is also something that people do. So this is where you buy a property with the hope of selling it a year or so at a higher price. So an example of this is with new builds. So if you're buying off plans and you only have to pay a 10% deposit, or in some cases, 0% deposit, and then when it gets to completion, you sell it for more money, that's a spec buy. Now, I actually remember before Opus, so maybe going back 15, 20 years ago, I remember I had a client that I worked with, I can remember her name, based in Christchurch, and she did this. This was back before Brightline, so she'd sign up for a property, when it got to completion, she'd sell it, and she would make 20, 30 grand and she'd pay off chunks of her mortgage. And she actually successfully paid off her mortgage doing that.
4:23 Speaker 00 Oh, good on her. Now, let's say.
4:25 Speaker 01 It was a small mortgage, don't get me wrong, it was like under a hundred grand.
4:28 Speaker 00 Oh yeah, but if it was 20 years ago, that's when properties only cost you 200K. No, it was 20 years ago, properties did cost 200K. And let's say that this all goes well, how much money can you make out of a spec buy or a spec build?
4:43 Speaker 01 So nowadays, if you're doing a spec buy, I kind of think you might make 20, 30 grand. If you're doing a build by engaging a builder, you might make 30 to 50 grand, so maybe a bit more than that. Sometimes I'll be working with an investor who's a builder and they might make a hundred grand or maybe even a little bit more than that, but what they don't factor in is their time doing the project. So they go, oh, well, I can do this really cheaply because I'm not being charged any labour. Yeah, but you've got the opportunity cost of doing that rather than doing your job. So I think you always have to be very realistic about your numbers if you are going to work this out.
5:19 Speaker 00 And just bear in mind, obviously with either a spec buy or a spec build, you aren't going to be paying bright line tax as well. On top of that, you've got to factor in that you're going to be paying a real estate agent, right? So you might sell the property for, let's make up some numbers, a hundred K more. But by the time you pay some tax and you pay your real estate agent and your staging fees and all of that, it starts to whittle down that profit. But it's also important to recognise the risks behind it. And there was a really interesting article in the Herald recently with the headline, "Property investor couple portraying themselves as naive retirees told to pay $2 million." So Andrew, what happened?
5:57 Speaker 01 So back in 2021, this couple signed up for two off the plans properties. Now they were both $1.2 million, so a total of $2.4 million worth of purchase. It's a lot of house.
6:08 Speaker 00 Yeah, and this is a spec buy, right? So they're going to sign up for a turnkey off the plans property through a developer.
6:14 Speaker 01 Correct, paid a deposit to the Developers' Lawyers Trust account and that reserved that property. And the whole plan was that they were going to sell those properties when they got to completion. Now, the couple said that the company, the real estate firm that they bought through, never told them that they'd have to settle the properties. So because the whole plan was the real estate firm said, allegedly, "We'll sell those properties when they get to completion, you'll make a tidy..." Profit, you'll get back your deposit, everyone goes away happy. So essentially, these guys are spec buyers and they were hoping to make kind of thirty to fifty grand per unit. So refund their deposit and make an extra thirty to fifty grand each, which is about a two and a half to four percent margin.
6:54 Speaker 00 Okay, so this all sounds sounds great, but why are they having to cough up two million bucks now?
6:59 Speaker 01 Well, they got to completion, the properties probably weren't worth what they paid for because the timing of when they bought it. They can't find another buyer to buy them, so the onus is on them to settle the property.
7:10 Speaker 00 Okay, so because they might have bought a little bit higher in the market, say, I can't remember what it was, was it twenty twenty one?
7:17 Speaker 01 Yeah.
7:17 Speaker 00 And then since then, property values have come back, they've realising, oh gosh, we can't sell this on as a profit because the price has gone down. And then on top of that, it's a harder market, there's lots of stock on the market, more difficult to sell properties. So maybe they're not even able to sell them on time and they've got this looming deadline where they're contractually obliged to actually pay the money and buy the properties.
7:40 Speaker 01 Well, also if they have retirees and they don't have an income to service any debt, the banks probably unlikely to lend them the money as well.
7:46 Speaker 00 Yeah, so they've put down a two hundred K deposit and they've got to find what is it, an extra two point two million dollars to pay for those properties. They realise that they can't in this case and so they end up going to court. And that's why they started to portray themselves, as the judge said, as naive retirees, trying to say, oh, we didn't know this. And the real estate firm actually came back and said, well, we did talk about examples where we have sold off properties before, where somebody's purchased them, held it for a little while while it's been built, then on sold it for a profit, we gave examples of that. But we didn't say that they're not going to have to settle the property because there's no such thing as making, you know, a lot of money risk free.
8:31 Speaker 01 Yeah.
8:31 Speaker 00 Right? So of course there's some risk to this. And so I guess the risk, if you are going to do a spec buy, especially off the plans, the risk is that you can't sell the property later on or that you can't get the right price for the property. And so you actually have to find the money for it. And so I really don't think you can. Even contemplate a spec build or a spec buy if you can't afford to settle the property and kind of weather that worst case scenario.
8:57 Speaker 01 Yeah, no, you'd be mental to do that. You, you, you run the risk of not only losing your deposit, which sometimes I hear people say, oh, you know, worst case I'll lose my deposit. That's not the case. You're still obligated to settle the property and or cover any losses to the developer or the vendor, the person selling the property. So if you get yourself into a situation where you can't settle, if the developer or the seller sells the property at a loss, you're obliged to pay those losses.
9:23 Speaker 00 Yeah, I also see that you make more money by holding the property long term anyway.
9:26 Speaker 01 Absolutely.
9:27 Speaker 00 If you do a spec buy or a spec build, you're going to give a third to thirty nine percent of your, your profits to the government, whereas if you hold it for a bit longer, that's all tax free. So you make more money by holding it for two years or more. And then on top of that, you get the compounding returns from the property going up in value. So I think a lot of people will, will hear, oh, wow, I can make thirty to fifty grand in, in twelve months by doing this. Bugger the risks, I'm going to do it anyway. And I'm like, well, it is far less risky if you hold on to a property for the long term and you make more money. To me, that kind of makes more sense, but I get that people kind of like that, that kind of more immediate hit. And Andrew, have you ever had any investors come to you wanting to do spec build, spec buys? Kind of what's the advice you tend to give them?
10:10 Speaker 01 Yes. And the answer is generally I'd tell them, don't do it. I just don't think it's, it's a viable investment model. Spec stands for speculation and you can't be certain of the outcome. And in fact, I remember one investor that came in. They were not in a position to be able to settle and their whole plan was to do exactly this. Put down a deposit which they could scrape together, sell the property when they got to completion, make a little bit of money and, and that, that little bit of money would have made a big difference in their life. But it was too risky for them to put their money on the line and I told them not to do it.
10:43 Speaker 00 Yeah, then on the other hand, I did have one investor approach me wanting to buy three properties off the plans, effectively to do a spec buy. Now for him, I think it was a little more achievable because A, he understood the risk, but also he had a boatload of money. He was a very successful entrepreneur and if he had to settle and hold on to them, he'd actually have the ability to do that. So you've got to judge it by your situation. I think there will be more people thinking about this as property prices start to rise. And if that's the case, it becomes more of a viable strategy, not one that I would do, but some people will actually go out and do it. Now, how do you figure out whether this is something you actually want to do, Andrew?
11:24 Speaker 01 Well, I think the main thing, as you alluded to just then, is you need to figure out if it's the right market for it. So we've just come through a market where you could sign up for something and then it'd be worth less by the time it's complete. That is not a viable market to be doing speculation in. But as the market's plateauing out and we're saying to see rises again, absolutely in certain areas, I could see that that would be something that people might consider. The other thing is you need to figure out whether or not you've got the capability of settling, in the worst case that you have to. So if your stars don't align and you don't find another buyer at an amount that's acceptable to you sell the property for, then you're going to settle that property and rent it out for a couple of years.
12:04 Speaker 00 And I want to be real clear because sometimes people will listen to a podcast like this and say, Ed and Andrew said the speculation strategy was absolutely wonderful. You can make all this money. Actually, that's not what we're saying. We like to talk about all property investment strategies on this podcast. Andrew and myself wouldn't do this strategy because we're long-term investors. But because some people will do it, we like to talk about it and talk about the pros and also the cons. And I'd just say as well, if you are going to do speculation, you'd probably do it in conjunction with a longer term strategy as well, because it's very important that you think about your long-term future self and how you're going to make sure that future you has got enough money. And you just want to make sure that you're not so focused on how to make money right now, this year, that you miss out on protecting your future self. I do think as well that
12:49 Speaker 00 spec buying, spec building is a little bit different from flipping and trading. You know, flipping is when you buy a property, actively improve the value and sell it off. There's a bit of speculation in there, but fundamentally, the increase in value You isn't coming from the market, it's coming from you actively improving that property. And on top of that, if we think about trading, that's usually where you might buy a piece of land and then flick it on to a developer relatively quickly. Generally, you would know that you're able to buy something cheaper and then flick it on pretty quickly to a developer. So it can be a little bit different there as well. So what have we learned today? We now know what the speculation strategy is and how much money we could make. We know some of the risks and how much money we could lose.
13:31 Speaker 00 And also how to figure out whether it's actually something you want to go ahead and do. Right, let's wrap it up there, but please don't forget to rate, review and subscribe to the podcast. Really does help us get the message out to more people.
13:48 Speaker 00 Thanks for listening to the Property Academy Podcast. I'm your host, Stephen Knight. I'm your host, Michael. We're going to be back again tomorrow with even more daily strategies, tactics and insights to help you get the most out of the new Zealand property market. Until next time.
Previous The Townhouse Trap – Listen to this before buying a townhouse in 2025! ⎥ Ep. 1898 Next "I Bought My First Home for $290,000" (2024) ⎥ Ep. 1900 Page updated November 15, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated