Pod Insights The Property Academy Podcast Should I Get a Pre-Nup? (Relationship Property Agreements Explained NZ)⎥Ep. 2147 About this episode Most Kiwis think a trust will protect their assets in a break-up. But that’s not always true. In fact, without a relationship property agreement (a prenup), even your trust could be challenged in court. In this episode, we break down the real risks of not having a prenup – including how one Kiwi lost his house, despite putting it in a trust – and explain how to put a contracting out agreement in place. You’ll learn:How NZ’s relationship property law really works – and when the 50/50 split kicks inWhy a trust doesn’t always protect your property after a breakupHow much prenups cost, and the life events that should trigger a reviewDon't forget to create your free Opes+ account here. For more from Opes Partners:Sign up for the weekly Private Property newsletterInstagramTikTok
Transcript 0:08 Speaker 00 Hello and welcome along to the Property Academy Podcast by Opes Partners. I'm your host, Seb at Night. And I'm Andrew Nichol. And this is the show that helps Kiwis go from zero to five investment properties. So you could be financially free and stick around for the next 15 minutes because you're going to learn how to get a prenup in New Zealand and what happens if you don't get one. How one Kiwi lost their home after a relationship bust up, even though they thought they were protected and what you must, must, must put into your prenuptial agreement. Now, Andrew, as a lot of listeners will know, I recently got married, like a couple of days ago. And of course, there's nothing more romantic when you're getting married than to talk about relationship property agreements. So why do you even need a prenup?
0:52 Speaker 00 In New Zealand, we tend not to call them prenups. We call them relationship property agreements, but I think the official legal term is contracting out agreement. And the way that works is, interestingly, I was listening to a podcast on prenups the other day and the host or the guest actually said, everyone actually has a prenup. It's either that you've got your own defined one or you have the state issued one, which is if you separate, everything's 50 50, everything's 50 50, even if you bought assets into the relationship and the other person bought in nothing, everything's going to be split. But if you've got a contracting out agreement set up, basically what you can do is say, okay, we don't actually think that that's fair, that it's 50 50. What we're going to do is we're going to outline how we would divide our assets in
1:36 Speaker 00 the event that we don't stay together. And a lot of Kiwis think that, okay, I don't need a prenup necessarily because I'm already established and I've actually got a family trust or I've got a trust. And so I've protected my assets myself. But actually, there's been a lot of cases where that hasn't stood up to scrutiny. So I read about this one story, this guy thought he'd done everything right. He'd been in like a 26 year marriage or something. The relationship ended and he ended up having his family home after that relationship. And he thought, right, I really want to make sure that I protect my house moving forward. So he puts that property into a trust, meets another lovely lady and that relationship
2:17 Speaker 00 lasts 10 years. And when they split, remember he had this house to begin with, the woman actually challenged the trust and said, well, that's my house too. Yes, it's in a trust, but I've considered that. My property and we've been in a relationship for 10 years. Now, the family court went through this and said, you know what? Yes, the property was in a trust. But to us, it looks like you've just put that property in there just to protect it from relationship property and we don't stand for that. So in the end, the new partner, she got half of the house. So this is probably a good time to remember that trusts aren't as robust as they used to be, particularly around relationship property challenges. Yeah, a trust on its own isn't bulletproof. You really do need that agreement.
3:00 Speaker 00 And we call it a contracting out agreement in New Zealand because effectively you are contracting out or you are setting up a contract so you don't have to follow those laws. You're contracting out of them. Now, how much does it cost? Now, I've had a look online to see what some people say. And I saw someone say 1,000 to 3,000 dollars. God, that would be nice. No, that is, that is very, very low in my experience. I think if it was that sort of money, you probably wouldn't have any assets to protect to begin with. Well, I did one, this would be five years ago with a previous partner, not with Angela. And I reckon I spent three to four grand on that myself.
3:40 Speaker 00 And then she went and used a different lawyer, which you absolutely need to do. So both of you need to use a lawyer. So I spent three to four grand. I reckon she spent seven grand on it. So all up, it would have cost about 10, 11,000 dollars. It is a lot of money to do this. And I get that some people say, well, I don't want to spend that. So maybe I'll just not do that. But I still think that can be worth it because spending 11 grand upfront could save you a lot, a lot, a lot of money later on. I think because of the high cost and the fact that you do have to use two separate independent lawyers, a lot of people try and cheat out of this. So I've seen situations where one of my, one of my friends, actually, I didn't know this till after the fact.
4:25 Speaker 00 He went and got a friend of his and his wives to set up a, a relationship property, a contracting out agreement for both and represented both of them. Because of that, when it came time for them to separate. It got challenged and it wasn't with the paper it was written on. So if you don't follow the prescribed process of having two independent lawyers giving independent advice, you'll find it's not with the paper it's written on. And I'll come back to some of those what are called informal agreements in a second. But one thing that's important to understand is talking about relationship property can make people feel really uncomfortable because you're in a happy relationship and you're like, hey, I want to talk about what happens if we split up.
5:06 Speaker 00 But the thing that I really am trying to get across to a lot of people these days is it is necessary to talk about this because the laws that govern relationship property were written in 1976, like almost 50 years ago. And if you think about what relationships looked like 50 years ago, they are very, very different to today. You know, I could totally see if mum and dad have been together for 20 years, she didn't work, he did, they had three kids, she gave up her career to raise them. Now they're 50 years old, they decide to split, he can earn an income and she's now basically starting out from the beginning when it comes to having to go out and earn an income. I can totally see why we're splitting up assets like that.
5:50 Speaker 00 And I've, I've just used him and her because that's kind of what it was back in, in 1976. It's different today, but lots of things are different today. People have way more partners, they have more long-term relationships, you know, and then they break up more frequently. There are more divorces today than there were back in 1976. And we're getting together a lot later in life. You know, back in the seventies, the average age of marriage for a guy was 24, for a girl it was 22. So you came into these relationships with not a hell of a lot. Now the average age is 31 and 33. So you come in and maybe you already own a house. And so it's quite different today. I'm not saying that the law necessarily should change because that would be a minefield to change that specific law.
6:34 Speaker 00 But I do think that we as New Zealanders should think about relationship property because I don't think those rules are broadly appropriate for everyone. And of course, the other thing is now, we're going to get into. With the de facto rules, you can be with someone for three years and then all of a sudden they've got rights to half of your stuff or you've got rights to half of their stuff. And I'm not sure whether that's entirely fair either. So Andrew, what happens if you don't get a relationship property agreement? So if you don't have a relationship property agreement and you're considered in a relationship by marriage or in a de facto relationship, which we'll talk about more later, then when you'd separate, everything is split fifty fifty. That's all property.
7:17 Speaker 00 So anything that you bought together in the relationship, but also everything that you bought into the relationship. So that could be a house that you already own, it could be your Kiwi saver, it could be your business and that's probably a really big one. So think of business owners, for example, ta- take our business for example, we've got three business owners, Ed, Ollie and myself. And in the event of one of us separating, if we didn't have contracting out agreements with our partners, then they would essentially become entitled to either a payout from the company or via via us individually, or they could become shareholders, which would not be a good result for anyone. And look, when the family court does decide how everything's going to be separated, generally speaking, it is fifty fifty.
8:01 Speaker 00 But also you can have a disproportionate amount awarded to one person. So there's a lot of cases where, like Ed was saying before, let's say mum has been at home for twenty years and she hasn't worked and mister is working and earns a really high income. There are lots of cases now where the court will say, you know what, she doesn't have the ability to earn the same amount as him. So we're actually going to give her seventy percent, him thirty percent, for example. Now, obviously you don't want to rely on this and in fact, I don't think you should rely on any of this. Everyone should have a contracting out agreement and a conversation at least around what should happen with the assets. But again, the standard is everything's fifty fifty, everything you bought in and everything that you bought together.
8:44 Speaker 00 And come back to that de facto thing about, okay, well, what if you don't get married, but you're living together or you've been in a in a relationship for a couple of years, which is very, very, very common these days, when does it kick in? Yeah, so I know this quite intimately. So under the law, if you live with someone for three years, you're considered a couple the same as if you're married. Three years, like it it sounds like a long time, but three years can go in the blink of an eye, right? Someone moves their toothbrush. And some hair clips in and then three years can pass like that. And all of a sudden, by the law, you're basically considered married. Now, when does the clock for that de facto start? Because I, I keep hearing different things.
9:29 Speaker 00 Is it when you live together? Is it when you start dating? I think the law says living as a couple, like, what does that mean? Yeah, that is a grey area and this is, this is where there can be a lot of challenges in court. So there's no set particular date. The, the court is going to look at things like, okay, where was your stuff at X date? Or like, you know, did, did you move all of your stuff in? So I have heard about them looking at things like social media posts or, and it might not be we're in a relationship, but it might be, you know, someone might have made a post, for example, saying we're doing a housewarming in our house. Like they might use that as evidence or whether or not I got a removal company to move a box of stuff in. That could be considered evidence.
10:13 Speaker 00 Now, obviously, if you, if you just, you know, in the dating scene and you've got someone leaving their toothbrush overnight, that's probably not considered a start date. The court's going to want something a bit more robust than that. But the key message here is it is a bit grey and it'll come down to whether or not someone can prove enough evidence that, yep, the relationship started in this days and that, that can be just via texts and stuff like that. All of those things could count as the start date of that three year relationship. And throughout this podcast, we've kind of been saying him and her as if the guy's the hire in Kamuna. We know that sort of ways, the case, I'll tell you a really great story. This is one of my favourites. So there's a couple I know and at the time they got together, he owned a business, she was starting her own one.
10:57 Speaker 00 And so they were putting together a relationship property agreement. And he offered, you know, the, the hire in Kamuna in this case said, maybe I'll put some, you know, give you some more stuff in the event that we break up. She was like, no, I want to be completely, yours is yours, mine is mine, we're going to be separate, right? And you think, why would she do that? Well, 20 years later, she's the one with this massive business. His one unfortunately has not done so well and now. She's really protected herself and she said to me, well, I always knew that I was gonna be the more successful one. So I wanted to protect my own assets. And so I'm like, I absolutely love that. I love that so much in so many ways.
11:39 Speaker 00 But the other point I want to get across is do not be that couple. Do not. And I know so many of you are like this. Do not be that couple who comes into relationships with different amounts. It's different if you both come in with the same amount or you both come in with effectively nothing. It's a bit different. But if you come in with different amounts, different amounts of assets, do not say, well, we'll just split our stuff. What's his is his, what's mine is mine. And we'll just split it that way. Whenever we break up, because maybe we both come into this relationship with a house and he'll take his, I'll take mine. We'll all be happy. No. Doesn't work like that. Ever. It never works like that. And the reason is because of feelings.
12:22 Speaker 00 You might be all logical right now before the breakup, but totally illogical afterwards. And it's all well and good, and maybe your relationship bust up is okay. Until the point that someone moves on and gets another partner. Yes, that that has definitely been my experience. So I've worked with lots of clients and and also helped through a number of friends go through separations. And the number one thing that changes people's level of reasonableness is when someone starts seeing someone else. Always. And especially if that other person wants to enter like, so let's say that you and I are in a relationship. Here we go.
13:01 Speaker 00 We have a kid, then we have a bust up. I found somebody else and I want to introduce that somebody else to the kid. That's when it starts to get very, very, very murky. And that's where it can morph into, I'm gonna take this person for all they're worth. But despite all of this and these warnings, and they are big scary warnings, most Kiwis don't care. So a study from the University of Otago showed that only 10% of separated people, so people who had broken up and gone through a splitting of assets, only 10% of people had signed a formal relationship property agreement. Now, 9% of people said they had an informal verbal or written agreement. Which is no agreement.
13:46 Speaker 00 Which is no agreement, and I'll show you some data about that. And another nine Percent had said they'd discussed it, but there was no agreement. So effectively ninety percent of people do not have protection. That's horrific. Yeah. And these are people who did split up, not looking at the number of people who are still happily married. If you've got a prenup, maybe you have to stay married. Well, no, if you don't have a prenup, then you'd need to stay married because it'd be too costly. But one thing that's important to recognise is the difference between what happens when you break up and if you have a formal agreement or you've just talked about it in the past. Oh, we're going to be reasonable when we break up, Andrew. If you have a formal contracting out agreement and we look at all of those people who got separated,
14:31 Speaker 00 sixty-three percent of them say their agreement was fully followed. We broke up, we followed to the letter our agreement. Twenty-one percent said we had a formal agreement and it was partially followed. Only sixteen percent of people said it wasn't followed at all. So it got overturned by the courts. Now, if we look at the people who said they had an informal prenuptial agreement, so maybe they wrote something down, but oh, we didn't, we didn't go get the lawyers signing it. We don't need to do that. Fifty-six percent of those people said it wasn't followed at all. Only less than a third said that that informal prenuptial agreement was followed. So if you wanted like a piece of paper or an envelope where you write down what it's going to be or a verbal agreement,
15:15 Speaker 00 that's not going to cut the mustard. It needs to be formal. So if you are going to do this, Andrew, and we're being hard on you guys, I know we're being hard on you guys today. It's because this is really, really important and we know what people do where they say, oh, we'll just do this. No. So how do we start putting a relationship property agreement together? So I'd start by actually having a conversation about it. So lawyers are going to have to get involved. That's just the way it is here in New Zealand. But the best way you can save some cost around that is actually have a conversation and just bullet point what you both expect on how you'd like it to work. So, okay, I own a rental property. I think that should be mine in the event we separate. You've got a KiwiSaver and some shares that should be yours. We've got some business interests that are together, but I put more money in, so we're going to split that.
16:00 Speaker 00 Or whatever it is, make the bullet points to begin with and then go and see a lawyer. And you're going to have it drafted up and then the other person needs to go and find a separate lawyer. Now, often you you might think, wow, jeez, hard enough for me to find one lawyer, let alone two. That's okay. If you've got a lawyer who's doing this for you, you can probably get a referral from them to go and talk to someone else. And then they're going to create a legally binding document. The key thing is if you don't follow that part of the process, you don't have an agreement as far as the law is concerned. And it's important to understand that the trouble with these agreements is that they have to allow for life changes. So for instance, if you're two years into a relationship, you're not thinking about marriage and kids.
16:43 Speaker 00 You know, you could probably do a hardcore, what's yours is yours, what's mine is mine split. That makes sense, but once you put this relationship property agreement in place, it doesn't expire. It continues on and so you will need to review it. So for instance, that hardcore split, what's yours is yours, what's mine is mine. That doesn't make as much sense if you have kids and especially if one person, whether it's him or her decides that, hey, I'm going to slow down from work and it might be I work part time or I work, I don't work at all, I'm stay at home. Well, that person's giving up their ability to earn an income in the future, which means that they're going to go through a really tough time if you do split up.
17:23 Speaker 00 So at that point, you'd often need it to be relaxed so that that person is still looked after in the event that you split up. And if you're not having kids right now, you really need to be thinking about this. So sometimes the way that's managed is let's say that she's got more money to buy a house. He doesn't have as much money, so she's going to pay a big part of the deposit. Now, if they break up, she gets her deposit back and then you split any capital growth. But if they have kids or they're married for five years, then it's all fifty fifty. So cool, if this is just a short relationship and you break up with me, I want all my money back. But if we're going to be married for five years, then I'm happy with that deposit to be fifty fifty because it's been a good long marriage and we've got some kids.
18:07 Speaker 00 So that kind of makes sense. Yeah, and I think one of the key things around some of the cases I've read is if you have a relationship property agreement that's too unreasonable, it will more likely be challenged, right? So if you're too tough in terms of your stance of things and you're not fair, then the court will decide how to be fair on your. So it's really, really important that you consider these things and you're reasonable. Because if you're not, again, the court will step in. That's why you have an incentive to review this agreement every five years. Because if you have kids and you've taken that hardcore stance, you might then decide that you need to relax it a little bit. And I've got a really good example of that coming in tomorrow's podcast.
18:51 Speaker 00 Now, as I've been talking about relationship property agreements recently, a lot of people have said to me, well, what if you're the person with a few more assets? You want to get a relationship property agreement and the other person says no. What do you do? Well, the only thing to do is if that other person really says no, is you either accept that you're going to go 50 50 with them. Or you break up. And it is on you as the person who wants this agreement. So you're the one who wants to change from the default, because the default position, the relationship property agreement you've already got is if you live together for three years, you're 50 50. That's the status quo. That's the default.
19:30 Speaker 00 Well, you want to change that and you want the other person to give up some of their rights to your assets that they would otherwise have. And that might be totally fair. I'm not saying that's unfair, but you're the one who wants the change. If you need this change and your partner's not willing to give it to you, there are only two choices. You either accept the default that it's going to be 50 50 or you break up. And it's on you to make that decision. And sometimes the right thing will be to break up if you're like, wow, this is a real sticking point for me. Maybe I'm not comfortable being in this relationship anymore. Now, these are hard choices. These are hard, hard choices, but they are the choices that you have. Yeah, and I know that sounds harsh, but to be honest, as as someone that's, you know, worked for quite a long time and tried to build up my assets.
20:13 Speaker 00 If I entered a relationship where the other person wasn't going to be respectful of me protecting my assets. I would consider that a red flag. I would break up with that person. Now, it's different for all of us. We've got to figure out how much we accept risk and, you know, what we think. So we're not telling you what you should do, but we are saying those are your choices. And when I had one of these with my ex, when I left, we never discussed assets. Agreement was already made. There was never a phone call about it. What was mine was mine, what was hers was hers and we left it and we never discussed it. And that was a really beautiful thing. And I think the big part to this is if you don't have to have the added pressure, the added stress of working through the financial stuff when you're clearly both hurt,
20:58 Speaker 00 it just allows you to both be able to move on and hopefully still have a friendship afterwards. Or at least, you know, a respectful feeling towards each other. If you feel like you've been taken advantage of afterwards because you didn't have this all drawn out and then someone has taken advantage, that's really going to sour any possibility of a future relationship. And if you add kids into the mix, that's not good. So over the last 20, 25 minutes, you've learned how to get a prenup in New Zealand and what happens if you don't get one. How one Kiwi lost their home after a relationship bust up even though they thought it was protective. And what must, must, must go into your prenuptial agreement. Right, let's wrap it up there, but please don't forget to rate, review and subscribe to the podcast. Really does help us get the message out to more people.
21:47 Speaker 00 Thanks for listening to the Property Academy Podcast. I'm your host, Stephen Knight. I'm Andrew Nichol. We're going to be back here tomorrow with even more daily strategies, texts and insights to help you get the most after you sell on the property market. Until next time.
Previous The Ultimate Guide To Mortgages In New Zealand⎥Ep. 2146 Next Divorce Horror Stories: How to Protect Your Wealth⎥Ep. 2148 Page updated November 15, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated