Pod Insights The Property Academy Podcast Should I FIRE my property manager?⎥Ep. 2046 About this episode In this episode, we discuss how to fire your property manager — without the awkward conversations or unnecessary drama. You’ll learn:The exact process for switching property managers (it’s easier than you think)What to watch out for in your management agreementAnd real-life examples of investors who’ve made the switch smoothlyIf you’re not getting the service you’re paying for, it’s time to take control. And if you’re looking for a new manager you might like to give Opes Property Management a try. For more from Opes Partners:Sign up for the weekly Private Property newsletterInstagramTikTok
Transcript 0:08 Speaker 00 Hello and welcome along to the Property Academy Podcast by Opes Partners. I'm your host, Stephen Knight.
0:12 Speaker 01 And I'm Andrew Nichol.
0:13 Speaker 00 And this is a show that helps Kiwi investors go from zero to five properties. So you can be financially free, even when your property manager isn't doing the best job. And that's the reason why over the next 15 minutes, you could learn how to fire your property manager. Without it being an awkward breakup, you're going to find out the actual process for switching properties and a couple of examples of how it works in the real world. And Andrew, I know that some listeners are asking about this.
0:39 Speaker 01 Yeah, so Geoff and Julia emailed in and they said, we love listening to the podcast. Thank you. And we'd like to hear your thoughts on changing property managers. And particularly, what if someone has been your property manager and they've found the tenant? So, you know, they've done the heavy lifting there, but now they're not performing and we just want to break up with them.
0:58 Speaker 00 Well, what are some of the things that, that make a property manager not perform? Or what are some of the things that causes someone to think, I'd really like to break up with this property manager?
1:08 Speaker 01 Well, I think one of the biggest ones is the financial pressure if a tenant falls behind in their rents. Because obviously this happens, that's just part of being a property investor. Sometimes you'll have tenants that become delinquent. Now, as an investor, you get quite frustrated and you think, is my property manager doing everything they could? And actually, I think the flow on from that is it's not so much that the tenant's behind, because we all understand that that can happen. But it's the communication you get from your property manager around that. So if you're contacting your property manager saying, hey, what's going on here? And they're kind of not coming back to you, but you're worrying about paying your mortgage. And then you're wondering, well, if they're not coming back to me, are they actually chasing up the tenant in enough of a manner that I'm going to get my money back? I think that's the major one.
1:51 Speaker 01 And obviously the other part to that is, well, if this tenant is not paying their rent. Has my property manager done the right job and put the best tenant in rather than just the first tenant in?
2:01 Speaker 00 Yeah, and so I suppose it's important to say, well, what is the actual process of changing tenants? And what I usually see happen is you first find the new property manager you want to move to. And so you go to them and they will say, this new property manager will say, great, here is a management agreement to sign. And that just gives that new property manager the right to act on your behalf. Because until you give them that ability to act on your behalf, they can't really do anything. Now, that new property manager will typically go to your old one, the one that you're breaking up with and say, hey, look, old Mary Jean is switching across to our property management. We're gonna come, we're gonna collect the keys, we're gonna get all the documents off
2:44 Speaker 00 you, the tenancy agreement, the bond, all of that sort of stuff. And then a little closer to the takeover date where their formal switch over actually happens, the new property manager will go and get the keys from the person we're breaking up with. And they'll get the tenant to stop paying rent to the old property manager, switch it across to the new one. And one of the interesting things that you said just was so nice that we get a bit worried about breaking up in person or over the phone with a property manager, but do you actually have to talk to them?
3:14 Speaker 01 Firstly, I'm surprised that you rate yourself as a nice person, Edward McKnight. I could, I could imagine you having a cold heart when it comes to the breakup. In fact, I know.
3:24 Speaker 00 Hey, hey, hey, hey, the kindest butcher has the sharpest knife.
3:30 Speaker 01 So yes, you do kind of have to talk to your property manager, but you can probably offload some of that responsibility onto your new property manager and have them do most of the breaking up for you. And actually, I'll tell you a story. This is one you don't know, I don't think. So a long, long time ago, I must have been like 15, I was dating a girl, I won't say her last name, her name was Alana. No, her name was Alana.
3:54 Speaker 01 And I remember one day I went to the school pool with her and my good friend Luke. And I won't use his last name. And he walked her home. He was kind enough to walk her home because they lived nearby.
4:07 Speaker 00 Your girlfriend.
4:08 Speaker 01 Yep. And do you know what? The next day I get a phone call. Hey, it's Luke here. Just wanna let you know that Alana's breaking up with you. We are now dating.
4:17 Speaker 00 Wow.
4:19 Speaker 01 Could you believe that that happened to me?
4:21 Speaker 00 I hope that you're the one laughing now and she regrets that decision from when she was 15 years old.
4:27 Speaker 01 So now I've personally been never any good with a breakup. And so that's why if I'm in the position where I want to get rid of my property manager for any reason, I get the new one to do it. I'm a bit of a wuss when it comes to that kind of thing. And there've been a couple of times where because I've had different properties at different property management companies all over the country. If I move something, I just email my new person and say, would you mind doing this for me?
4:51 Speaker 00 You absolute wimp.
4:53 Speaker 01 Yep.
4:53 Speaker 00 And I know that Jeff and Julia wanted to know, well, if I switch property managers, do I have to get rid of my tenant because that old property manager found that tenant? Or can I take that tenant with me? Look, the short answer is yes, you can take the tenant with you. Because when the property manager, your, your, your old one, found that tenant, you probably paid them a tenant sourcing fee. Or, you know, if you didn't, then that tenant sourcing is part of the fee you're paying anyway. So you've paid them to do a job. They've done it. I always think you don't owe them anymore. Your tenant can come with you. And to be honest, it's quite difficult to get rid of tenants anyway. So you'd ideally want to take them with you if they are any good. Now, what are some examples of where this happens, Andrew?
5:36 Speaker 01 So I was actually talking to Tiff in our property management team in Auckland. And she had a case, which I got copied in a few emails, where the property investor was extremely unhappy with their current property manager. And that's because the tenant had been living there for about a year and they owed a heap of money. And the property manager was just not being proactive in collecting that. Turns out that they Never even collected a bond. So that's pretty bad.
6:02 Speaker 00 And that's basic, eh?
6:04 Speaker 01 Like even, even you and I know to collect the bond. We know property managers, but we know to collect the bond. And the other big thing, as I mentioned before, is the communication just wasn't there. So the property manager wasn't even giving regular updates to the investor who was getting increasingly agitated.
6:20 Speaker 00 Maybe we should be property managers for a day.
6:22 Speaker 01 I reckon.
6:23 Speaker 00 T and Andy, we're here for our inspection.
6:25 Speaker 01 I reckon you and I should go out on the road and just do the different jobs within the company one day. So we have a greater understanding of the pains that property managers go through. Actually, I'll tell you one story. I'll just deviate for a second. So I was a property manager for a day. So I turned up to a property that had just completed in Auckland because I just wanted to see what the development looked like. And as I was wandering around, I saw these people wandering around and I said, oh, hello, can I help you? And they said, oh, we're actually meeting your property management team. We want to rent one of these properties. And I said, oh, no problem. It was Sammy and I. I was like, come on through, we'll show you through. And so we went through and we showed them the cupboards and all the great features of the property. And then they said, okay, well, what's the next step? We love the property. We want to take it. I said,
7:07 Speaker 01 excellent. So I text the owner. I said, good news, someone's going to take your property. And then I sent the people away, linked them up with the property manager who was running late in Auckland traffic. That's why she wasn't there. Turns out these guys had terrible credit, terrible references. That was my one and only attempt at being a property manager and I was no good at it. Anyway, where was I?
7:26 Speaker 00 Okay. So come back to this person where the property manager hadn't collected the bond, the tenants been there for a year, but owes them lots of money. So what happens next when they're wanting to switch property managers?
7:38 Speaker 01 So they actually emailed the property manager themselves and said, hey, we want to change. We're not happy. And the property management company replied and said, no, you can't. You're locked into a five year contract. Now, just to be clear, because I was copied in on some of these, that is very unusual, a five year contract. Normally you might expect it to be a one or a two year contract. Now Tiffany said, send me the contract. I'll have a look. Turns out it was a two year agreement and it only had five months remaining anyway. Now, in this instance, the owner said, hey.
8:12 Speaker 01 While I've got five months remaining, I am just sick of dealing with these guys because I'm trying to run an investment property here. I've got a mortgage to pay. I don't have the rent coming in. This is a real problem and I'm concerned about damage to my property where I don't have a bond in place. So Tiffany stepped in, superwoman, and emailed the previous property management company and said, "Guys, you've done a pretty average job here. Let's just call it what it is. You haven't stuck to your end of this contract. You haven't collected the bond. You haven't done the right thing by the landlord. Let's all just part as friends and we'll take over the management from here." And that's what happened after a few more tense emails.
8:50 Speaker 00 And so they switched over?
8:52 Speaker 01 Yep.
8:53 Speaker 00 Now, there is something important to bring up, which is those fixed terms. So as you said, typically a property manager might have a fixed term contract where you've got to stick with them for 12 to 24 months, one to two years. And I was talking to Tom, who's one of our other property managers, and he said, "Look, some property management companies will strictly enforce those fixed terms. Some others are more flexible." The way that I think about it is, well, if someone genuinely wants to move, do you really want to keep an unhappy customer? Because if you tie them to yourself, you're just going to annoy them even more. That client's just going to be even more unhappy and they're probably going to go on to Google and write a mean Google review and it's just not going to be good for anybody.
9:33 Speaker 01 Yeah, it's an interesting one because I'm seeing a lot more of this at the moment. So people offering really good deals for property management, but they'll tie them into a long-term contract. And definitely some people who I know would enforce that contract. So you've really got to be careful what you sign.
9:48 Speaker 00 And it's important to mention that when you do decide to break up with a property manager, there is a notice period. It's typically going to be one to three months notice that you've got to let them know about. But when would it be a good time to change managers?
10:02 Speaker 01 So if you're really unhappy with your property manager, and even if your tenants are currently in the middle of their term, you can move it across. But the ideal scenario is when the tenancy ends. It's a really good time to switch property managers then if you're unhappy. Because this allows that bond that the current property manager is currently in control of to be released to the existing tenants and then a new bond to be lodged by the new property manager.
10:27 Speaker 00 And then you've got your new property manager to find those new tenants for you. One other thing that's really important that we need to discuss is, well, how does it work from the tenant's point of view? Because I know a lot of property investors love to do the right thing by their tenants. And they don't want to do something that is really going to annoy the tenants or inconvenience them. So if I decide to change property managers for one of my properties, how does that impact the tenant?
10:50 Speaker 01 It doesn't really affect them at all, other than they now have to pay their rent to a different account. So obviously a new property manager, they'll have a new trust account that where the rent gets paid into. And they'll have to update that with their bank. Other than that, I don't think they have to do anything. I get one thing that I actually don't know, but I'm sure is the case. I'm sure you have to assign that bond. So again, the new property management company can release that when the tenants exit. But seriously, it'd be a 10 minute job all up for the tenants.
11:17 Speaker 00 And I just want to give you one more example of when investors have switched their property managers. And I want to give you one where somebody switched away from us to a different property manager. Because I don't want to just be sitting here acting like we're the greatest thing in the world. So I was talking to one of our property managers and they said, we've recently had an owner and they wanted to increase the rent for the property. And we kind of said to them, look, you're already at the market level. We don't recommend you do that. And here's the data that shows that you're currently in line with the market. And to be honest, if you increase the rent, we think you're going to lose your tenants. Now, this person had talked to another company that company had said, actually, we do think we can get you more rent. So, you know, this investor, this owner said, okay, look, I'm going to do it anyway. And I want to switch across. And we said, okay, that's cool.
12:03 Speaker 00 So they proceeded with saying to their tenant, we're going to increase the rent. The tenants did give notice and decide to leave. Now typically, there would be a three month notice period in our managements. So that would be in this case, we would find the tenant for this, this owner and then hand it over. But we said, look, why don't we just make it really simple? We'll just end it early when that tenant leaves. So rather than three months, it might be one month or three weeks. And that just means that your new company can find those new tenants. So overall, it was a peaceful breakup. And I think it's important to say, well, you know, we manage something like. 1100 properties, so it's not always going to work out for everyone. And so that's okay. So if people want to move away, it's really important that you just let them do that and say, sweet, we wish you all the best.
12:48 Speaker 00 Peaceful breakup. So over the last 15 minutes, you've learned how do you fire your property manager without that awkward breakup? The actual process for switching managers and just a couple of examples of how they work in the real world. Right, let's wrap it up there, but please don't forget to rate, review and subscribe to the podcast. Really does help us get the message out to more people.
13:14 Speaker 00 Thanks for listening to the Property Academy Podcast. I'm your host, Tim McKnight.
13:16 Speaker 01 And I'm Dr. Nicole.
13:18 Speaker 00 We're going to be back here tomorrow with even more daily strategies, tactics and insights to help you get the most out of the use of the property market. Until next time.
Previous Home and Income properties: smart investment or financial trap?⎥Ep. 2045 Next How I went from $5/hr to $8.5 million in property⎥Ep. 2047 Page updated November 15, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated