Pod Insights The Property Academy Podcast NZ Herald is wrong – what they missed about retirement⎥Ep. 1993 About this episode In this episode, we discuss why the NZ Herald is wrong and a few things that respected financial commentator, Mary Holm, missed when talking about retirement numbers. We walk through how the choices an investor makes has an impact on the amount of money they'll need for retirement. And you can use this information to get a sense of what your retirement will cost. For more from Opes Partners: Sign up for the weekly Private Property newsletter Instagram TikTok
Transcript 0:08 Speaker 00 Hello and welcome along to the Proper Canterbury Podcast by Opes Partners. I'm your host, Stephen Knight. And I'm Andrew Nicoll. And today on the show, we're talking about the New Zealand Herald is wrong. So over the next 15 minutes, you're going to learn what the New Zealand Herald was most recently wrong about, how much you really need for retirement and why you can't trust any number, whether it's on our website or any website that says how much that you need for retirement when you're searching online. And the reason we're talking about this is I was lying on my bed in my hotel room on a Saturday, I opened up the New Zealand Herald while Angela's doing her makeup. And so I've got at least 15 minutes.
0:48 Speaker 00 And it was an article talking about Massey University's recent numbers around how much you need to retire. And I thought, oh, this is really good. Let me go have a look at it. And I saw Opes Partners, I saw a company name on there. And it was a column from Mary Home and the question was saying, do I really need $1.45 million to retire? And the reason this number came out is if you go onto our website and you look at some of the retirement numbers, if you want to live some lifestyles, I think the highest number we gave in a range was $1.45 million. And so of course, that's the figure that gets quoted. And Mary Home, who's a very, very well respected financial journalist, was saying, hey, I think that number looks high in saying some other things.
1:32 Speaker 00 And look, we've been talking a lot about this recently, probably because Massey University has just released their retirement expenditure guidelines. It's got a lot of headlines, it's got a lot of commentary. And so there are a lot of flow on questions that come from this, both from you guys who are listening to the podcast, but also seeing it in stuff in the Herald and Radio New Zealand as well. Now, one thing that I definitely need to say is that Mary actually made some good points in terms of why our numbers are higher. And actually, we're going to, we're going to probably talk a little bit about it today. But I've also got another podcast next week and we're going to get real nerdy with numbers. It's going to be a great lot of fun. But I also think there is some stuff that... She missed as well. I did invite Mary to come on and have a discussion. Look, she politely
2:14 Speaker 00 said no, but let's dig through. Andrew, what is your read on this? What was your read on what Mary said in the New Zealand Herald? Well, she's right in the sense that our numbers can be higher. And when you say high, you mean higher than what the Massey University's report shows? As comparison, ours often is higher because if you want to live that choices lifestyle in retirement, and actually I spoke about this on my private property last week, I reckon you might need about 890,000 to 1.45 million dollars. Now, Massey University's equivalent lifestyle, they estimate that you need 717,000 to about a million dollars, right? Look, Mary seemed to put this down to advice companies like us fiddling with the numbers. Her quote
2:57 Speaker 00 was, Opus's numbers are higher than Finned's, which is hardly surprising, given that they want to encourage people to invest. And just so you know, Finned is the Financial Education Centre, which is based out of Massey University who put the report. But the top end of our range isn't way higher than Massey's, just because we're fiddling with the numbers. Well, it's not because we're fiddling with the numbers at all, thank you, Andrew. No, it's because we look at things differently in terms of how an investor wants to set up their money. Yeah, I'll jump in here because I do a lot of the number crunching. One thing that's really important to remember is that when you create a financial plan, when you invest, you are going to make a lot of decisions. So do you want to spend your savings in retirement?
3:38 Speaker 00 So do you want to start out with a million bucks and then once you hit 90 or you die, do you have no money left and you die with zero? And some people really want that. They do. They want to spend all of their money before they go because they want to make sure that they live a really good life and make the most of it. That's one approach and that's perfectly reasonable. But there is another approach where you say, well, I don't want to spend my savings throughout my retirement. I want what we call the golden goose. I want to make sure that I am just living off the returns or the interest of my investments so that I never spend all of my savings and I can pass that down. I can leave a legacy or some generational wealth. Well, if you don't want to spend all your savings and die with zero.
4:20 Speaker 00 You're gonna need more money. And so we factor that into the range. That's why you might need a bit more. The other thing is that the price of things keep going up. And as that happens, do you wanna spend more or you're happy buying a little bit less? So you might say, okay, well, maybe I just can't buy as much stuff this year. Some people are happy with that. Some people aren't. If you wanna make sure that your retirement is inflation proofed, you're gonna need a bit more money. The other thing is, well, how much do you wanna rely on New Zealand superannuation? Do you want it to be a big part of your plan? Or do you wanna treat it as a bonus? If you wanna treat it as a bonus, not rely on it at all, you're gonna need more money. Now, the truth of the matter is, I love Massey University's report. We called up the person who wrote it. We're gonna tell
5:02 Speaker 00 you what they said in a second. But they take one specific view. And that is, that's perfectly fine, because they disclose it all in their report. I'm not knocking them for it. But they kind of had this view that you spend your savings throughout retirement, you die with zero, that you have quite a large dependence on the New Zealand superannuation. And they don't fully factor in the cost of all things going up. They factor in some inflation, but not necessarily the inflation you will face as a retiree. But that is the reason why I like to give people more of a range and say, you might need somewhere between eight hundred grand and up to one point four five million dollars, depending on how you wanna set it up, because you can't just have a single number. Now, Massey do like to put out single numbers. And the reason is because it makes it very clear. If you have a single number,
5:47 Speaker 00 people will say, okay, that's the number that gives me a really good ballpark. But that's the reason why there can be differences in the numbers. I suppose the other big thing is you've got to think about when you die. Yeah, this is the one of the hard things. So Massey University, they assumes that everyone dies at ninety, which is not a bad assumption if you're kind of sixty five now. But the younger generations, they will live longer. And if I take Lauren, for example, my partner, by the time she retires, she's got an eleven percent chance of living to a hundred. And there's a fifty percent chance that she's gonna live to ninety three. Now, knowing Lauren, she'll probably live to a hundred and forty three. But the younger you are, the longer you are likely to live. And so you need to factor this into your retirement plan as well, because the last thing you want
6:30 Speaker 00 Is to say, right, I'm gonna spend all my money until I die. And that's gonna be when I'm ninety and then on your ninety first birthday think this sucks. I've got no money. Yeah, well, I'm just living on New Zealand superannuation. So if we're thinking about a robust financial plan, one thing you wanna consider is, okay, like, what's the chance that I live longer than ninety? Again, if you're sixty five now, you've probably got a great chance that you're gonna gonna die by ninety. Oh, thank God for that. That's my retirement plan. Oh, wonderful. Eighty six, I'm sorry, I say sixty six. I thought your retirement plan was to die at forty nine.
7:08 Speaker 00 The clock is ticking, but that again is why there might be a range. And so what we're trying to get across here is that reasonable people can come to different numbers based on how they have been calculated and how granular you wanna go. One of the big things that impact how much money you're gonna need is the returns that you expect to get in retirement. Right? So if we think about, okay, I'm gonna retire at sixty five, I'm gonna invest in a balanced fund. And that's gonna give me a a good balance between risk and reward. I'm gonna get a decent return, but the value of my assets aren't gonna, or my investments aren't gonna jump up and down too much. Well, how much is a balanced fund gonna return?
7:53 Speaker 00 Well, if I go to sorta.org.nz, they said three and a half percent. Others who I talked to will say six percent is a pretty safe bet. Myself, I ended up working with a company called My Fiduciary, they are an investment consultancy. We paid them some money, they said use four point four three percent, so, okay, we'll use that. And the fact of the matter is, if you assume that your investments are gonna get a higher return in retirement, if you're investing in a fund, well, you don't need as much money to retire. If you think your investments are gonna get a lower return, you're gonna need more money. So that is gonna be the part of the difference between Massey's numbers, our numbers and somebody at anybody else's numbers that you see on the internet.
8:33 Speaker 00 So again, it's not that there's some jiggy pokery going on, like I'm not sitting here with my spreadsheet. I don't know whether that's what Mary thinks I'm doing. Yeah. But you know, I'm saying, how do I get this number higher? Yeah. Yeah, just, just add a few zeros on, like plus five hundred thousand dollars or something like that. Oh, well, Andrew, of course you need a five hundred thousand dollar buffer for safety. That's not what's going on. It's that reasonable people can have differences in how they calculate their numbers. Now, that is not to say that, well, my numbers are right and everybody else's numbers are wrong. It's that everybody's numbers are quote unquote wrong. My numbers are wrong, your numbers are wrong, and well, I write your numbers, so it doesn't count. Everyone's numbers are wrong.
9:18 Speaker 00 Macy's numbers are, are, are wrong. Sorta.org.nz's numbers are wrong. Not Mary's as well. Everybody's, well, Mary doesn't tend to give specific numbers, but everybody's numbers are quote unquote wrong. In that, we all will come to different answers. And the truth of the matter is, the right number for you is the one that you calculate for yourself. Now, that doesn't mean you've got to create your own spreadsheet, but if you either use some tools that are online or you work with a financial advisor, whether it's us or somebody else, to create your financial plan. The right number for you will not be found in a Macy University report. The right number for you will not be found on the Opes Partners website. It will not be found in an article that is written by a journalist or even a financial advisor.
10:03 Speaker 00 You've got to calculate the right number for you yourself and be comfortable with those assumptions so you know what's going on. And so that's the reason why everybody's numbers are right, but everybody's numbers are also wrong. Because it depends what the right number is for you. And I guess you've got to also think about like, well, how much risk am I willing to take, right? If I don't want to invest, I, I want to use some of my money now and I want to enjoy my life now. Then you might use some more modest assumptions around what you're spending is going to be later on in life so that you don't have to save as much. Or if you're really near retirement, I know that, I was talking to some people just a couple of weeks ago and they are like six and a half years from retirement. They can't really be doing a whole lot more investing than what they're already doing at the moment.
10:47 Speaker 00 Rather than aim for an ambitious goal, what they've actually done is said, okay, well, we probably just need to really tighten our belt when we're in retirement and spend a little bit less money then. And then they don't have to take in any more risk. But then on the flip side of that, most people that I meet with, they say, Well, look, I'm gonna err on the side of caution and and make sure that no matter what happens, I do have enough money at retirement, even if I live to a hundred. I know that you got some replies where people were saying, well, even if the number I personally am aiming for, or that that investor is aiming for, is quote unquote a bit high. If I've got too much money at retirement, is that so much of an issue? No one can, I've ne- I'm yet to have someone complain about having too much money. Now, don't get me wrong, too much money comes with extra risk and savings now, and extra investing now.
11:32 Speaker 00 So there is a, there is a trade off to that, but too much money isn't a problem, in my view. But one thing I I would say to that, it, cause the counter view to that, which I guess is what, where I wanna say, like, Mary actually says some really good things. I don't want you to think this is a a merry home beat up, uh, cause she's more respected in in finance than I am. Well, that's fair, can I say that? Yeah, yeah, it's funny. I think that's true, she's been writing, she's been writing since I was a diapers man. Probably, and probably will be until I am.
12:03 Speaker 00 But I suppose the counter view to that is, which is really what the Society of Actuaries is saying, which are are basically even near to your number crunchers than me. Where they're saying, well, if you put out estimates that are too high, perhaps that discourages people from starting their journey and saving. And so the number crunching that Mary referenced was talking about Massey universities numbers being too high. And that what Massey do is they say, okay, you wanna retire on fifty grand, for instance. And they do bake in some inflation going up, right? Sad rate of inflation, I think they use about two percent. And so they say, okay, cool, you wanna spend fifty grand this year, and you wanna buy the same amount of stuff next year, and the same amount of stuff the year after that, and that for after that, and forever and ever and ever until you die at ninety.
12:48 Speaker 00 And that's, I actually think that's a pretty fair assumption. But what the Society of Actuaries said is they looked at research from overseas, and I'm gonna talk a little bit more about this in about a week, cause I've got, I've done some research, I've got lots to say about it. But they say, well, over time, when we observe what happens over the US and the UK, people tend to spend less as they get older. So at sixty five, you might be travelling, you might be living it up. Having a great time and as you get to say ninety, a lot of your friends might have died. Yeah, not as a good health. So you stay home more and you're not doing as many activities because you physically can't. You don't eat as much and so you don't spend as much over time. What about healthcare though? Don't you think you spend more on healthcare or are you just relying on the public system?
13:33 Speaker 00 They don't have a comment specifically about healthcare, but this is, this is the trend they're observing, which we'll talk about. We, we will really dive into it because I've got a whole new financial model around it. But what they are saying is that people spend less over time and Mary was saying, okay, well, maybe Opes Partners had missed that. Well, she was actually right about that because that report came out in December last year, twenty twenty four, probably as I was about to shoot off on the holiday. Ah, you'd already clocked out. And so it wasn't until I read Mary's thing, I'm like, oh, there's a really interesting new report that we will obviously dig into. I actually put that to Associate Professor Claire Matthews, who wrote Massey University's report. And she says, look, fundamentally, we just present the data based on what retirees are spending and we think this is pretty good.
14:15 Speaker 00 So we go out, we look at what people are spending and there are more sixty five to seventy year olds than there are ninety year olds, right? At New Zealand, because quite a few of the sixty five year olds today won't make it to ninety. So you don't have as many ninety year olds as you do sixty five to seventy year olds. And because of that, the average of what people spend will reflect more what those younger retirees will spend, right? So when you look at these averages, it gives you a better picture of what younger retirees are spending compared to what older retirees are spending. Because there just aren't as many of them. And so, yes, we probably would expect that over time, maybe you do spend a little bit less.
14:54 Speaker 00 But we're not trying to factor that in. We're trying to provide a really good ballpark. We tell everybody how our data is calculated. We tell them all of the weaknesses of it. So it's not that our data is wrong. Our data is what our data is. And you can still gain a lot from that. I do think keeping it simple is really important as well for people. So, so, you know, even in our model, so in our nest egg model, for example. That says that there's a particular date in time that you're going to liquidate all your assets all at once. And often that's sixty five for people. So on your sixty fifth birthday, you blow out the candles on your cake and you sell your properties, you pay off the debt, you cash in your KiwiSaver and you start getting the superannuation if that's part of your plan. Now, the truth is, you don't need all your money all at once. You might use your KiwiSaver
15:37 Speaker 00 for the first ten years of retirement and and use that to supplement your superannuation. Then you might sell your first rental property and pay off the mortgage and use some of that cash. And then you might continue to do this, getting, bringing in the money and when you want it. So again, no model's perfect, but we're trying to make this really easy for people to understand so that you can make an informed decision. I suppose the other thing there is, let's say you retire at sixty five and you're like, cool, I've got this money, I've got my KiwiSaver, I'm going to sell down a property. A lot of numbers will say, like number crunching will say, cool, we're going to assume that we're going to put that into a balanced fund and our return's going to be, as we said, three and a half to six percent. Well, in practice, you might not do that. You might say, well,
16:18 Speaker 00 I can put a small part of my wealth into a balanced fund now and I'll use that over the next five years. But I've still got a lot of other wealth. I can put that into a growth fund and I'm actually not going to need that for ten years. So I can put a portion of my wealth into a higher risk investment because I'm not going to need to call on it. Well, if you're doing that, you can get a higher return than we would assume within a lot of our number crunching. So there are ways around this, but I, if I bring it back to what I think's going on here, I think your view on this probably comes with the stories you hear. So if you think about the people we talk to, Andrew, we talk to a lot of people who are somewhere between twenty five and fifty five. You know, those are a lot of the people that we're talking to because they want to invest in property.
17:03 Speaker 00 They've got a long time horizon. They're able to borrow money from a bank. And so their perspective is, I want a robust financial plan. I want to make sure that I do not run out of money in retirement. And so my goal is not to say, what is the minimum amount of money that I need to live a really good life with all of these assumptions. They want a more ambitious goal and say, I'm not going to include New Zealand super. I'm going to make some very conservative assumptions so that. If there are quite a lot of bad shocks, oh, it's easy, I'm not going to be able to weather them. Yeah, sure, I might not spend as much when I'm 90 as I do when I'm 65, but at least I'm not going to run out of money. That is really robust and those people who are kind of 25 to 55, you've got time, you've got the luxury to be able to do that.
17:49 Speaker 00 Now, if I put myself into a different position, if I was hearing stories more of people who are 65 or who are 60 and are extraordinarily worried about retirement because it's only five years away. And then I go on someone's website and they tell me I need 1.45 million dollars and I've only got a hundred thousand dollars in my KiwiSaver and I haven't invested a lot. Now I'm really, really worried. And I think it is perfectly legitimate for a journalist like Mary or the Society of Actuaries to say, hang on a minute, hang on a minute, just calm your horses. Maybe you don't need as much because we can factor in some of these other things and maybe that number is a bit high. I think that's why people get emotional about it, right? And I think sometimes people do think of it as a bit of a judgment.
18:32 Speaker 00 So what I mean by is I've read online that, and again, I must stress, this was the maximum number for that specific lifestyle. I might need up to 1.45 million dollars. I've only got a hundred thousand dollars. Well, that number's ridiculous because that's not even possible for me. Well, it might not be for you, but it can be for a lot of other people who are preparing well in advance. That is not to say that you have necessarily done the wrong things with your money or to be judgmental, but that is just to talk about the facts and the reality of the situation. And so I think both are appropriate. And we're going to really dig into that Society of Actuaries report because I actually think there are some really, really good things. And we can share how it might help you think differently about retirement as well.
19:12 Speaker 00 And I think it's really just important to remember if you are closer to retirement and you maybe don't have as much money, don't necessarily, again, like you said before, rely on anyone's number. Go either build your own model, if you're into that, if you're a nerd yourself, like Ed, you want to do that yourself. Or go and talk to a financial advisor and figure out how you can use the numbers you actually have to kind of provide the lifestyle and realise, okay, well, maybe I do need to cut down my spending in the later part of life or maybe I just need to. Rely a bit more on the government superannuation, those kind of things. Get a number that's specific to you because that's the only number that actually matters. It's got nothing to do with anything on our website or anyone else's. I'll tell you one last thing, speaking with Claire Matthews, again, Professor Claire Matthews,
19:55 Speaker 00 she's actually got a doctorate. I don't know whether to call her Professor Claire Matthews or Dr Claire Matthews, but anyway, smart Claire Matthews out of Massa University. It was really interesting when she said, look, you've got to think that these guidelines are just a starting point and then you go and you work with somebody to figure out your number. And I was so surprised, Andrew, when she says, even if you're a finance expert, having someone else to look at your numbers or talk to you or act as a sounding board can be helpful. Even though she's writing these reports, she's got a financial advisor. Wow. And so it almost doesn't matter which financial advisor you work with, whether it's us or somebody else, as long as you, if you just start thinking about this, that's a good thing. And so even though I don't agree with everything Mary said, the fact that people are engaging
20:39 Speaker 00 and thinking about the numbers for retirement, that is a very good thing. So what have we learnt? We've learnt some of the things that you didn't hear what was wrong about, some ideas about how to figure out what you really needed in retirement and why you cannot trust any number that says how much you specifically need, yes, you listening to this specifically need for retirement when you read it online. Right, let's wrap it up there, but please don't forget to rate, review and subscribe to the podcast. Really does help us get the message out to more people.
21:10 Speaker 00 Thanks for listening to the Property Academy Podcast. I'm your host, Tipit Knight. And I'm Andrew Nicoll. We're going to be back here tomorrow with even more daily strategies, tech insights to help you get the most out of the news on the property market. Until next time.
Previous How to investigate any property developer (NZ)⎥Ep. 1992 Next How much does a home renovation actually cost?⎥Ep. 1983 Page updated November 15, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated