New vs Old House: Which Makes More Money?
- 21m
- Transcript
Summary
Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.
This episode evaluates whether new or old investment properties make more money by putting two $700,000 houses in Kaipoi head-to-head across seven rounds. The host and the guest compare what each property offers for the same cash, deposit requirements, value-add potential, maintenance surprises, loan rules, rental yields, and capital growth. They explain how Reserve Bank rules, debt-to-income caps, and leverage affect returns. Ultimately, they argue that while capital growth rates are similar, new builds win on leverage because smaller deposits allow investors to multiply their initial cash more effectively, though individual investor preferences and renovation skills still play a massive role.
- Investors can purchase new builds with a lower deposit than existing homes because new builds are exempt from stricter Reserve Bank lending rules. 3:31
- Renovating older properties can successfully create value-add potential, but it requires substantial upfront capital for both the purchase and the renovation work. 4:16
- New builds come with built-in protections such as a 12-month defect period and a 10-year structural guarantee, reducing immediate maintenance surprises. 7:48
- Capital growth rates between new and existing properties show little meaningful difference over long periods based on data from Cotality. 15:12
Chapters
- 0:08Podcast Intro and Episode Overview
Hosts introduce themselves and outline the comparison of new versus old houses.
- 0:54Round One: Value for Money
Discussion of what buyers actually receive for the same price, favoring the existing property for land.
- 2:35Round Two: Deposit Requirements
Explains higher deposit for existing properties versus lower deposit for new builds due to Reserve Bank rules.
- 4:14Round Three: Value Add Potential
Existing property offers higher renovation upside, while new build has limited scope for value addition.
- 5:54Round Four: Maintenance Surprises
New builds likely have fewer unexpected maintenance costs compared to older homes.
- 8:17Round Five: Loan Eligibility and Lending Rules
New builds benefit from looser debt-to-income rules, giving borrowers more flexibility.
- 21:03Wrap‑Up and Listener Engagement
Hosts summarize findings, invite feedback, and promote future episodes.
Highlights
- 1:01
Comparing Two Same Priced Propertiesstory
The hosts compare a new three-bedroom build in Kaipoi and a 1960s three-bedroom existing house in the same area, both costing $700,000, to start their head-to-head comparison.
- 2:04
Data from Cotality shows a 6% price premium for new builds compared to identical existing properties, driven by modern building codes and double glazing.
- 3:24
Deposit Requirements And Renovation Costsstrategy
Existing properties require a 30% deposit plus roughly $70,000 for renovations, whereas new builds require only a 20% deposit under current Reserve Bank rules.
- 4:38
Targeting Renovation Value Upliftinsight
Strategic renovations on older homes aim for a two-dollar return in property value for every single dollar spent on the upgrade.
- 8:28
Debt-To-Income Restrictionsinsight
New builds are exempt from debt-to-income caps, whereas investors buying older properties may be restricted by the seven times income limit unless they spend less.
- 10:39
Calculating gross yields on identical assumptions yields a virtual dead heat between the new build at 4.3% and the existing property at 4.2%.
- 15:28
Historical Capital Growth Datadata
Cotality data tracking 2008 cohorts showed existing properties in Auckland grew 0.6% faster annually, while Christchurch new builds outperformed existing by 0.2% a year.
- 18:02
Leverage And Return On Depositinsight
Because new builds require a smaller deposit, a doubling in property value yields a five times return on initial cash compared to 3.3 times for an existing home.
Quotes
“So the new build's 114 square metres versus 122 for the existing.”
Unnamed speaker · 1:23 “If you had a property that was exactly the same and it was existing versus new, the new property is slightly more expensive.”
Unnamed speaker · 2:09 “So when we're just thinking about deposits, this one clearly goes to the new build.”
Unnamed speaker · 4:04 “In Auckland, the existing properties, the ones that were already built before 2008, they went up by 0.6% a year more than the new builds that they followed.”
Unnamed speaker · 16:04
About this episode
One house was built when Kiwis still got paid in pounds and shillings. The other isn't even finished ... the builders are still on site. And they cost the same: $700k. So, which one's the better investment? In this episode, Ed and Andrew score a new build against an existing one across seven rounds. You'll learn: Where existing wins and where new builds win Whether there's really a "drive-it-off-the-lot" effect on capital growthThe round that decides the whole thingIt's closer than the online die-hards admit ... but on the numbers, one of them edges it 4–3. Let us know your thoughts by leaving us a voice message on the Property Academy Hotline https://www.speakpipe.com/PropertyAcademy For more from Opes Partners: https://www.opespartners.co.nz/newsletter-sign-upStay ahead of the NZ property market https://www.opespartners.co.nz/private-property-sign-up?utm_source=podcast&utm_medium=promo&utm_campaign=pp_signupInstagram https://www.instagram.com/opes_partners/TikTok https://www.tiktok.com/@opespartners
Transcript
4,012 words · 2 speakers
Topics
- Reserve Bank
- Kaipoi
- Cotality
- Opes Partners
- Opus Mortgages
- Opus Plus
- North Canterbury
- Auckland
- Christchurch
Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated