Pod Insights The Property Academy Podcast Make the same money with less risk (in property) ⎥Ep. 2016 About this episode In this episode, we discuss why property investors need to diversify and think about diversification. This includes how to make the same money (generate the same return) while lowering your risk. And how you practically do this as a property investor in NZ. For more from Opes Partners:Sign up for the weekly Private Property newsletterInstagramTikTok
Transcript 0:08 Speaker 00 Hello and welcome along to the Property Academy Podcast by Oberspartners. I'm your host, Andrew Knight.
0:12 Speaker 01 And I'm Andrew Nicole.
0:12 Speaker 00 And so we're talking about how to diversify your property portfolio, which is really about saying over the next 15 minutes, you're going to learn how to get the same return with lower risk, why you can't believe every graph that a property developer shows you, and how to diversify your portfolio when the average property costs $700,000. And I think the main reason I wanted to record this today is that people often say, buy where you know, right? Buy property where you're comfortable with. But if you only ever invest in places you know, you're probably only going to buy properties that are right around you. And that just means that you're really exposed to just one single property market. But Andrew, before we dive into that, what do I mean when I say you can't believe every graph a property developer shows you?
0:56 Speaker 01 I think one of the ones that I see very frequently, and I always like to send it to Ed because I know it winds him up, is when a property developer puts up the average house price growth for New Zealand. And they say, look, house prices are up another 0.3%. Woohoo, we all made a bit of money this year. Well, the problem is you're buying in Auckland, or you're buying in Wellington, or you're buying in Gisborne. The New Zealand market is the average of all property markets. So Auckland might be completely flat while Wellington's up. So the average is going up potentially. If you look at the graph of New Zealand property prices, but it's not like everyone's happy. The people in Wellington might be, but the people in Auckland right now, they're probably not. And then fast forward five years later, it could be a completely different story.
1:40 Speaker 01 Wellington could be flat, Dunedin could be up. So the average again is going up, but the people in Dunedin are happy. The people in Wellington aren't happy at this stage.
1:49 Speaker 00 Yeah, and the difficulty with that is if you look at a graph of the average house price in New Zealand, or the median sale price of properties in New Zealand, it does look like property prices will always go up. And then we all nod and say, yes, oh God, property prices go up quite consistently. But the value of your property won't do that because the individual market that you're Operating in will be flat for a time and then it booms. But what's pulling the average up is that sometimes it's this region's turn and then it's the other regions turn, but the average is consistently going up, but it's not actually like that in practice. And so Andrew's right, I get a B in my bonnet. That's so good. I see my B in my bonnet. But the thing is that property prices in each individual
2:32 Speaker 00 region are more up and down, they're more volatile than the country as an average. So if you imagine kind of a standard bell curve, right, of property price growth with how fast properties are increasing per year. Well, for the New Zealand market overall, the bell curve's quite tight. Property prices are going up pretty consistently. There's not as much variation. Yeah, of course, sometimes it's up, sometimes it's down, but there's not as much variation. But if we look at an individual region, say we're looking at Auckland or we're looking at Wellington or Invercargill or Gisborne, that curve, that bell curve starts to get much broader. There's a wider range of how
3:13 Speaker 00 property prices move each year. So property prices aren't going up as smoothly. It's not as consistent. And that means that property prices in, especially in smaller regions, tend to fluctuate quite a lot. They go up and down a lot. You'll see sharp periods of growth and then there might be really long periods of stagnation. One that I always talk about, because I've got the stats to hand, is if we look at what happened in Gisborne between 2008, property prices were pretty flat for about 12 years, just over 12 years. It wasn't until 2015-ish that they started going off and they tripled within a couple of years. Same thing happened in Wanganui. Property prices flat for really, really
3:55 Speaker 00 long periods and then they ended up booming. And so if you were just looking at the average house price in New Zealand, what did we see? Oh, well Auckland had a pretty good run between 2012 and 2016. Property prices shot up by quite a lot. That pulled the average of New Zealand up. Then property prices in Auckland were flat for four years, but Wellington and Gisborne started taking off as well as some of the other regions. So again, Why you'll look at New Zealand house prices, oh, so smooth, so consistent. But actually, your individual investment will be more volatile than the overall New Zealand market. And that kind of brings us to this idea of diversifying or buying in different regions. Talk to us about that, Andrew.
4:38 Speaker 01 So the idea is that you spread your investments across multiple regions to smooth out the lows, but also the highs. Now, again, let's compare the Gisborne property market to the New Zealand property market. So for as far back as they recall, from 1992, right the way up to currently, the Gisborne and New Zealand property market both increased more than seven times, okay?
4:57 Speaker 00 Yeah, so New Zealand was 7.6 times, Gisborne was 7.7 times. So like about as close as you can get.
5:03 Speaker 01 Yeah, but the way that they got there was so different. Because Gisborne is way more boom and bust than the average New Zealand price. Now, in the worst year, national prices were down 14%. Gisborne was down a whopping 21%. But in the best year, national prices were up 31%, but Gisborne increased over 43%. So if you look at Gisborne just as an individual market, it's much more volatile than New Zealand as a whole. So using the New Zealand data smooths out that. So you want to take advantage of that smoothing out. In those really, really good years, you might think, geez, I wish I had five properties just in Gisborne.
5:45 Speaker 01 But in those worst years, you'll be pleased you don't have five properties in Gisborne, that you've got them around the country.
5:50 Speaker 00 And so the idea, I guess what we're really saying is that if you were able to have one property in a region that was going really, really well, and you had another property in a region that wasn't going so well, your overall wealth is still going up. Now, when we say the same return for lower risk, what do we actually mean by that? It's really important to define what risk means. And in an investment context, we're talking about that volatility, the ups and the downs within the individual market. Now, as Andrew showed you, if you'd bought the average property in New Zealand and it followed the New Zealand market perfectly compared to Gisborne, and it followed the Gisborne market perfectly, the Turns were roughly the same between nineteen ninety two and two thousand and twenty five.
6:35 Speaker 00 They both went up by roughly by seven point six, seven point seven times, right? The returns very, very comparable, but Gisborne was more risky because there were very, very, very long periods where the market was incredibly flat. So it is not just about the final outcome as an investor that we care about. We also care about the bumps in the road and smoothing those bumps in the road out. Why might that be important? Because you might want to borrow more against some of your properties to go and buy another one. If you'd solely bought in a market where property prices are flat, you can't grow your property portfolio because they've not increased in value. So you don't have more equity in there to go and borrow more against. There's also a mental game that we're going to come back to as well.
7:16 Speaker 00 And so when we're talking about diversifying, what we really mean by that is trying to more closely approximate the New Zealand property market so that we can have our wealth going up more consistently. That's the important part. It's about getting the same outcome of building a decent amount of wealth while smoothing out the path that we use to actually get there. And one of the things that I remember Adrian Orr, the now former Reserve Bank governor saying, is that the only free lunch in investing is diversification because you can get the same return with fewer bumps in the road. And that's the, the, the really, really important part of it. And talk to me about how this impacts people mentally, Andrew, and the mental side of it.
7:58 Speaker 01 So if I think about anyone that invested heavily in the Auckland market a couple of years ago, and now they've seen the market go down, they're making contributions. Because they haven't diversified, they could be excuse for thinking property investment doesn't work. I'm putting all this money in, I'm getting no return. If anything, I'm losing money. Why would I invest more in property? And so now they're not going to go out and invest anymore. Whereas, you know, I'm thinking about a couple that I deal with at the moment, and they are much more risk adverse than your average investor. And they invested in Auckland and Christchurch at the same time. Now their Auckland investment hasn't gone very well yet. Their Christchurch property has. And so he said to me the other day, I should have just bought two.
8:40 Speaker 01 In Christchurch. Now, I think if we think about what this is going to look like in 10 years' time, probably the Auckland property is going to far outperform the Christchurch one. But because the Christchurch one has performed better than the Auckland one so far, he's got limited perspective of seeing that Auckland one do well.
8:58 Speaker 00 Well, I think the important part there, though, is really about saying that he's like, okay, it's not that property investment doesn't work, it's that that market's not done so well, but this one's done okay, so I feel a bit better than that. You know, if you bought one in Auckland at the top of the market and at the same time you'd invested in Dunedin or Queenstown, you'd be pretty happy because your Dunedin or Queenstown one, or even if you'd invested in somewhere like in the Cargill or Southland, property prices have actually gone quite well here. You'd probably be sitting there being like, oh, this property investment thing does work, but I can see that my Queenstown one's going quite well. I can see that my Auckland one's not going so well, but hey, that's the market. And so when we talk about smoothing the bumps in the road, some of it's from the investment return side, but it's also the mental side.
9:40 Speaker 01 And I also think the other part to it is just from a natural disaster standpoint. So I'll tell you a personal story from me. I remember when the Christchurch earthquakes hit and I had properties that were damaged because all of my properties, all of my eggs were in one basket. And I remember thinking to myself, why was I so stupid? How could I have been this stupid to have all of my eggs in one basket? Now my entire property portfolio could be taken away from me because I am so overly exposed in Christchurch. What if I can't find tenants? What if the market just isn't here anymore? And it was a real wake-up call that diversification was something that I needed to consider more.
10:19 Speaker 00 Because in that case, did you have a lot of tenants have to move out of those properties and now you don't have any rent for them?
10:24 Speaker 01 Yes, but I think the bigger concern was I didn't know where the Christchurch market was going to go. I didn't know if I'm going to be even able to sell my properties in 10 years' time. And I just, I remember thinking, I should have known better.
10:36 Speaker 00 Well, luckily you've now got a podcast where you can atone for your sins. And hopefully people can be like, oh, okay, that's a good lesson. I don't want to go through that same thing. I mean, this does apply across all of your portfolio, right? Like, you don't diversify a portfolio by solely investing in property. You know, you're also doing things with your KiwiSaver. It comes down to a lot of things. But the reason I wanted to talk about this specifically within the context of property is I might often ask people, how did you get into invested property? Oh, easy, I bought the house down the road. Or I was driving down the street past my local supermarket. I saw a property for sale. I thought, oh, I'll go have a look at it. My property's done pretty well for me over the last couple of years. And that's kind of your classic old school way of investing,
11:20 Speaker 00 where we just bought the house down the road and hey, it's turned out all okay as long as you hold long enough. But if we're thinking about how do we take investing to the next level and be a little bit more sophisticated about this? Well, then we probably do want to be thinking about buying properties more around the country. That comes with some extra things about making sure that we get really good property managers in there and that we're looking after those properties. But in terms of decreasing your investment risk while still getting the same return, that's where thinking about investing in some other regions becomes quite important. I suppose the other last question is, how do you diversify when the average house price costs $700,000?
11:58 Speaker 01 Yeah, it's not quite as simple as buying one apple share, one Coca-Cola share, and being able to, you know, do it with just the money you got in the bank. Because, you know, a $700,000 property, you're probably not buying one of those every single day. So I think the key message is you do it slowly. So you actually plan out your property purchases over a number of years. And don't be concerned that you can't do it all at once, because the longer you invest for, the easier it becomes.
12:24 Speaker 00 So over the last 15 minutes, we've talked about how to get the same returns with lower risk, why you can't believe every graph a property developer shows you, and how do you diversify when that average house price is so expensive? Rightly, let's wrap it up there, but please don't forget to write a review and subscribe to the podcast. Really does help us get the message out to more people.
12:49 Speaker 00 Thanks for listening to the Property Academy podcast. I'm your host Steve Atknight.
12:51 Speaker 01 And I'm your host Nick.
12:52 Speaker 00 We're going to be back here tomorrow with even more daily strategies, tactics and insights to help you get the most out of the estate and property market. Until next time.
Previous "My neighbour wants to poison my dog" – how to deal with bad neighbours⎥Ep. 2015 Next Make more money NOT investing at the bottom of the market ⎥Ep. 2017 Page updated November 15, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated