Pod Insights The Property Academy Podcast Is the Media Rigged Against Landlords?⎟Ep. 2458 About this episode “Greedy landlord raises rent.”
“Investors cash in while renters struggle.”
Property headlines can feel relentlessly negative… but is the media actually biased against landlords?
In this episode, Ed and Andrew dig into the research behind property coverage in New Zealand media ... and run their own experiment scoring real headlines from major outlets across the country.
You’ll learn:
What academic research says about whether the NZ media is pro- or anti-property investors Which media outlets appeared more pro-landlord or anti-landlord in their analysis What one study found when they looked at 598 housing articlesAlthough some headlines may appear negative, the broader context tells a different story.
For more from Opes Partners:
Sign up for the weekly Private Property newsletter https://www.opespartners.co.nz/newsletter-sign-upInstagram https://www.instagram.com/opes_partners/TikTok https://www.tiktok.com/@opespartners
Transcript 0:08 Speaker 00 Hello and welcome along to the Property Academy Podcast by Obus Partners. I'm your host, Stephen Knight.
0:12 Speaker 01 And I'm Andrew Nicoll.
0:13 Speaker 00 And this is the show that helps Kiwis go from zero to five investment property. So you can be financially free and stick around for the next 15 minutes because you're going to learn, is the media rigged against landlords? How anti or pro each media company is? And what one study found when they looked at over 10,000 news articles. Now, sometimes us property investors feel hard done by when we open up the New Zealand Herald or stuff. Because the tenancy tribunal cases, because they're public, they're often sensationalised. Either the landlord's the worst of the worst or the tenant is the worst of the worst. And most landlords nod along thinking, oh, every headline does seem like a bit of an attack.
0:55 Speaker 00 Whether it's greedy landlords raising rents or tenants struggling as investor profits soar. But is it actually true? Well, today, we're going to look at some data and go through our number crunching to figure out whether it's true. Now, before we go through all this, what's your perception, Andrew, before we go through?
1:13 Speaker 01 Yeah, I feel like a landlord, we're given a pretty hard time in the media.
1:18 Speaker 00 You think it's rigged?
1:19 Speaker 01 Well, I don't know if it's rigged, but definitely.
1:21 Speaker 00 That's going to be a headline.
1:22 Speaker 01 We're an easy target.
1:24 Speaker 00 You're an easy target. But what does the research actually say?
1:29 Speaker 01 Now, there was a study and so the researchers at Victoria University looked at over 10,000 news items over 10 years. Like, that's a huge amount, right? And they narrowed those down to articles specifically about housing. And what they found was the New Zealand Herald wrote eight times as many stories about properties, looking at properties as property investment compared to property as a social issue like homelessness.
1:58 Speaker 00 And so I suppose that'd be like articles about house prices going up or down, rents going up or down. Looking at it as numbers rather than as a social issue. What about, say, the Post?
2:08 Speaker 01 So they wrote nearly six. Times has been the articles about property looking at as an investment compared to a social issue. Now, when the media writes about property, they mainly do so looking at it about the money side of things. The investment side of things and house prices.
2:22 Speaker 00 And so that could be about supply and demand and all of those kinds of things. Now, that doesn't necessarily mean that those articles about investors are balanced, right? But what that specific study was trying to do was say, well, when the media talks about property, they look at it almost as if the people reading it already own houses. Because they care about house prices going up or down, or rents going up or down, looking at those kinds of numbers. Now, there was also some research from Australia. And I think what they were trying to get at with that study is that people who own properties tend to be the types of people that are going to buy a New Zealand Herald subscription or subscribe to the post. And so the articles that are written are written to be of interest, generally speaking,
3:07 Speaker 00 to people who might be a little bit wealthier and are willing to spend on media. And who are probably going to be a good audience for advertisers. Because they're the type of people who are going to go and buy a new fridge at Harvey Norman. Now, I wanted to start with that study just because there isn't that much research about whether the media paints landlords in a good or bad light, but I thought that was an interesting finding. So because there wasn't that much academic research, I got my podcast producer to look at thirty recent articles. So small sample size, but thirty articles that have been published in New Zealand over the last six months and score them on a scale from negative two with a very anti landlord to positive two with a very pro landlord and neutral or somewhere in the middle.
3:52 Speaker 01 Now, you mean, you mean our actual Jackie. You don't mean like AI or anything, you mean?
3:57 Speaker 00 No, well, what I did, Jackie's our podcast producer, but I got him to find the articles, use AI to score them as a starter and then to double check each score. Because what I didn't want is people saying, yeah, but Jackie works for a property investment company and so he's biased. So start with AI, then have a human checker. And what we looked at was like, is the headline very loaded or is it neutral? So if it was like greedy landlord, then that would be
4:25 Speaker 01 Negative two.
4:26 Speaker 00 That would be negative two. If it was like explicitly positive, like.
4:31 Speaker 01 Wonderful landlord.
4:33 Speaker 00 It would be positive too. There weren't many positive headlines. We also looked at the source balance. What I mean by that is if there was an article about property investment, did they just interview, say, Renters United, who are very pro tenant, and then only give one line to a property investor? Or was it fairly balanced, right? When it talked about investor profits, did it talk about like windfalls at tenants' expenses? Or was it talking about it more just as a normal business? We also looked at regulation. Did it talk about tax cuts for landlords? Or was it more balanced? And same around like, were tenants framed as victims or adults making a choice?
5:13 Speaker 00 So we kind of did this all. And give us an example, Andrew, of maybe a very pro landlord story, and then a very anti landlord story, just so that people could understand what we would consider as pro or anti landlord.
5:26 Speaker 01 Okay, so let's use an example of a pro landlord story. So this one was from One News. The headline was consent-free granny flat rules to be expanded. Now, it's pretty neutral. It's talking about the benefits to investors for these new rules, where people can put a granny flat on with more limited requirements through the council.
5:46 Speaker 00 And we gave that ultimately a score of positive four out of 10.
5:51 Speaker 01 Okay, so you're going at four ones and a zero?
5:54 Speaker 00 Yeah, that's right. So the headline wasn't particularly positive, but it was neutral enough. Like, this wasn't talking about rogue landlords' plan to build granny flats and charge tenants more money. Tenants upset at loss of backyard or anything. It was very neutral. You go through it, you're like, okay, it's not specifically about landlords, wonderful, but it's, it's neutral enough. That would be what we consider a pro landlord story.
6:18 Speaker 01 Okay, here's your anti landlord story then. That was on One News. Headline was Queenstown landlord fined $113,000 for unlawful boarding house. Now, the story might be true, right? And it's definitely newsworthy, right? That's a significant amount of money. But it definitely paints landlords as an industry in a bad light. And if you have too many of these types- Stories, you kind of think, okay, was the media lacking balance?
6:46 Speaker 00 Yeah. And so that's just to say, again, we would classify that as an anti landlord story, even though it might both be news worthy and true. But it's just like, if you had 20 of those in a row, you would be like, okay, the media's wrecked. If you only had one of them, you'd say, well, actually, it's pretty balanced. That's just a normal story, right? So I'm just trying to give you a sense of how we're trying to analyse this. Now, I ran the framework over 30 real stories covering Radio New Zealand, One News, interest.co.nz, the spin off and stuff and the post and all of these. The average result from the story, I think it might surprise you. The average result was positive 0.3 out of 10.
7:24 Speaker 01 Which is basically nothing.
7:25 Speaker 00 Basically as neutral as you could possibly get. In our sample, we had what we considered 20 positive stories, eight negative stories and two bang on neutral. The reason it nets out to slightly positive though, rather than hugely positive, is just that when the stories are negative about landlords, they are really, really negative. Right? When they are positive about landlords, they're only slightly positive about landlords. Like I haven't seen a single one saying landlords, best thing since to society. If you want to see that, go to my YouTube channel. Now, bear in mind, what I'm about to do are very small sample sizes, but which outlets in our number crunching appeared to be the most pro and anti landlord?
8:10 Speaker 01 So pro landlord, One Roof, which I don't think that's surprising. He writes for One Roof and they specifically write a lot about property. Hence the name and the MBR. And those publications, I mean, MBRs aim towards business people and about business news. So that kind of makes sense.
8:26 Speaker 00 And similarly with One Roof, they're targeting people who are wanting to buy property. Right? So they're probably going to be a bit more neutral, a bit more positive about property because they want people to buy property compared to maybe a news organisation, which is more geared towards, say, younger people and renters. So if the MBR and One Roof in our small sample were the most positive, who was the most anti landlord?
8:49 Speaker 01 So that was the spin off. Doesn't mean that we're saying if you're a landlord or if you're into property investment, don't read the spin off, it'll just make you feel like landlords are losers. We're not saying that at all. We're just pointing out what our small sample size of articles and the way we've assessed it, what they showed.
9:07 Speaker 00 So for example, one article from the spin off, the headline was, will pet bonds really be a win win? I'm not holding my breath. So obviously right from the start, the headlines there being a little bit more anti landlord by saying, well, look, we've got this new policy coming in. I think it's going to be negative. So we've counted that as more on the negative side. Having said that, I read the spin off.
9:30 Speaker 01 Yeah, I do too.
9:31 Speaker 00 Do you actually?
9:32 Speaker 01 I think it's quite good. There's some articles I think quite good. Like they are provocative and some of their like angles, but that makes for some interesting reading.
9:40 Speaker 00 Yeah. And the reason I read the spin off is, you know how people talk about eco chambers and how, how if I only read new sources that
9:47 Speaker 01 Support your.
9:48 Speaker 00 That confirm my beliefs, then I get even more entrenched. And I think like, and I think, okay, wow, I'm just so right. It's like people who, who post wild stuff on Facebook.
9:58 Speaker 01 I know, I know. I know what you're gonna say. Don't say his name.
10:02 Speaker 00 No, I wasn't going to. Then they get people saying, oh, you're so right. You're so right. And you think, oh, I'm so right. And everyone else is like, oh my God, you're off your head. Um, so can I say that?
10:13 Speaker 01 Yeah.
10:14 Speaker 00 Which is why I started reading the spin off to like read stuff that doesn't often agree with what I think, but actually helps you be a little bit more balanced, you know, otherwise you're just going to walk around thinking you're right all the time.
10:25 Speaker 01 I don't know if you're a great example of someone who doesn't think they're right all the time or is balanced.
10:30 Speaker 00 Andrew Nickel. What I will say though, is that even if we look at the pro property investor content, or what, what we have defined as pro property investor in our sample, that doesn't mean that every article was saying that being a landlord is a good idea. So for instance, the New Zealand Herald wrote an article saying, mum and dad investors are pulling back from property investment. Now we scored that as a plus four out of 10, right? We scored that as pro landlord, even though. It was saying that being a landlord might not be a good idea. Not that I necessarily agree with that, but what we are assessing here is the tone of how property investment is talked about, not whether they are saying that property investment
11:14 Speaker 00 is great or property investment is bad. Same thing around like talking about property prices going down as they did over the last couple of years. Even if an article said property prices were going down, we wouldn't necessarily say, well, that's negative against landlords.
11:28 Speaker 01 It's a fact.
11:29 Speaker 00 Because it might just be a fact, even though of course we know that the media is is more likely to emphasise negative news rather than positive news because it gets more clicks. But that's just to show you what we're trying to assess in here. So based on all of this, do you think, is the media really rigged against landlords?
11:46 Speaker 01 Well, the honest answer actually is no. And if anything, it's slightly pro landlord rather than anti. And I probably think that that goes to the fact that Kiwis, we do love property, both from, you know, buying a house and renovating a house to investing in property. Like, we are big on property in New Zealand. And so I guess the media organisations, they are trying to put out content that is interesting to people.
12:10 Speaker 00 I do think as well, though, that it's quite interesting looking at and being like, oh, okay, when the articles are negative, they tend to be really negative.
12:20 Speaker 01 Yeah.
12:20 Speaker 00 When they're positive, they're not really positive.
12:23 Speaker 01 And we kind of forget those ones and we ho- hold on to the ones that we're like, oh, so and so politician said this and it's really got us riled up.
12:31 Speaker 00 And often it is, like, the ones that are most negative in our sample are where landlords have actually done really bad things. There was one from Radio New Zealand, the headline was Tribunal Orders Landlord to Pay $3,400 For Polling To Maroo Rental. Again, that probably is newsworthy and worth reporting on. But if you read too many of those, like this other one that was from Radio New Zealand, Concerns Legal Loophole Allowing Underground Boarding Houses, the, it like, and, and the Queenstown landlord fined for $113,000 for unlawful boarding counts. If you see lots of those, those are the ones that you probably hold on to and remember because they were so negative. But on. It seems that in our small sample size, they're kind of broadly neutral.
13:16 Speaker 00 And over the last 15 minutes, you've learned is the media rigged against landlords? How anti or pro each media company is? And what one study found where they looked at over 10,000 news articles. Right, let's wrap it up there, but please don't forget to rate, review and subscribe to the podcast. Really does help us get the message out to more people.
13:38 Speaker 00 Thanks for listening to the property academy podcast. I'm your host, Ed at night. We're going to be back here in tomorrow with even more daily strategies, tactics and insights to help you get the most after you sell on property market. Until next time.
Previous How Long Should Landlords Expect Tenants To Stay?⎟Ep. 2457 Next Heritage Dwellings: Beautiful … But Dangerous?⎟Ep. 2459 Page updated November 14, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated