Pod Insights The Property Academy Podcast Inside the Tenancy Tribunal: Are Landlords Getting Screwed?⎥Ep. 2206 About this episode Many landlords believe the Tenancy Tribunal is stacked against them, but is that actually true? In this episode, Ed and Andrew examine the data, the law, and 1,000 real Tribunal cases to uncover whether the system really favours tenants. You’ll learn:What MBIE told us when we asked for Tribunal outcome dataWhat happened when we hired a data scraper and analysed 1,000 rulings ourselvesWhy the numbers show landlords often win more cases than most people thinkThis episode busts one of the biggest myths in property investing and gives you a data-driven look at how fair the Tribunal really is. Don't forget to create your free Opes+ account here. For more from Opes Partners:Sign up for the weekly Private Property newsletterInstagramTikTok
Transcript 0:08 Speaker 00 Hello and welcome along to the Property Academy Podcast by Opes Partners. I'm your host, Stephen Knight.
0:12 Speaker 01 And I'm Andrew Nicoll.
0:12 Speaker 00 And this is the show that helps Kiwis go from zero to five investment properties. So you can be financially free and stick around for the next 15 minutes because you're going to learn, is the tenancy tribunal rigged against landlords? What the tenancy tribunal said when we asked them that specific question? And what happened when we analysed a thousand tenancy tribunal cases to see if we can spot this bias? And I'll tell you why I want to record this because so many landlords really do believe that if you go to the tenancy tribunal, that the system unfairly favours tenants. And I wanted to know, is that actually true? And can I find data to say, yes, the tenancy tribunal is biased?
0:55 Speaker 00 Or actually, nah, I don't think it is. Now, Andrew, it's pretty hard to test bias. So we sat down for a couple of drinks, thinking, how are we going to sort this out? What did we end up doing?
1:06 Speaker 01 So Ed came up with the idea that we'd write to MBE, which is Ministry of Business and Innovation and Employment, and sent an Official Information Act request. So basically, if you've got a government agency and you want to get some information from them, you can send one of these requests and they're obliged to send you some information. Now, because MBE oversee the tenancy tribunal, what we asked for was the data on how many times a tenant wins a case and how many times a landlord wins.
1:32 Speaker 00 Now, what'd they say to that?
1:33 Speaker 01 They came back and said, we consider the outcome of a mediation to be an agreement rather than a decision in favour of one or the other parties.
1:41 Speaker 00 What an absolute load of nonsense. I can't say it on the podcast, but you know, it starts with S and runs with hit.
1:48 Speaker 01 Yeah, I mean, if you're having to pay some money, no one's agreed to pay money you've been ordered to.
1:53 Speaker 00 Yeah, I don't think any landlord or tenant thinks that the outcome of the tenancy tribunal is an agreement between the two of them. It's definitely a decision that you then have to follow. So, okay, MBE doesn't want to give us the data and they say they don't capture it because they don't consider that one party. Either wins or not. I can kind of understand that. So what are we gonna do to try and test the bias?
2:16 Speaker 01 So Ed then thinks, well, I'm not gonna stop at that, because anyone that's had an argument with Ed knows he doesn't stop. And says, okay, well, just tell me then, who gets paid more often? Do landlords have to pay more money to tenants, or is it the other way around? And they said, well, we can't provide this information either. We don't record it that way.
2:32 Speaker 00 And this is the point where I go, bugger this. I know what I'm gonna do. So on a couple of previous podcasts, I've talked about my Russian data scraper. So I've got this guy who is a genius at scraping websites to to get lots and lots of data out of it. And it's so funny. I believe he lives in Greece and we pay him in a Lithuanian bank account in US dollars. And he's from Russia and it's, it's all a bit dark.
2:59 Speaker 01 I'm not convinced it's not just you working in the background, doing it yourself, and we're just paying you into some offshore account.
3:05 Speaker 00 Oh, then I just said the couple of invoices. That'd be quite smart. I should start doing that. Oh, he's put his prices up, Andrew. So what I did is I got this guy to get me a thousand cases from the tenancy tribunal. So when the tenancy tribunal come to a decision between a landlord and a tenant, mediating the agreement, as they would say it. They release a a pretty hefty document sometimes outlining what the decision was, what the factors of the case was, and who has to pay who money. And so I got these thousand tenancy tribunal cases. And then I hooked them up to an AI agent to read them and crunch the numbers that the government has told us that they don't actually have.
3:49 Speaker 00 And the idea behind this was, could I use AI to see if the tenancy tribunal was biased? Now, there are a couple of ways to test bias, and it's a little bit difficult. Because I initially thought, well, why don't I just get the AI to read the document and it'll tell me if it's biased or not? But then you've got to ask yourself, well, what really is bias? So is it that we've got fair laws and maybe the tenancy tribunal just doesn't apply them fairly? In which case, you know, if that was the case, then you could say, oh, yeah, the tenancy tribunal's biased. Is it that we don't have fair laws, that the laws are biased towards tenants or towards landlords? And the tenancy tribunal just applies the law fairly, in which case it's the law that's biased, not the tenancy tribunal?
4:32 Speaker 00 Or is it that us landlords, maybe we're biased and when we win, we think that's fair? And when we lose, we think that's unfair? And so it all became very hard to test because how do you tell what bias is? And so what I figured out is let's just focus on the objective outcome of who pays who? Do tenants have to pay landlords more? Do landlords have to pay tenants more? What's the effective win rate? Because then we've got some actual data, rather than just chucking some documents into an AI engine and say spit me out an outcome. So when people go, landlords and tenants go to the tenancy tribunal, Andrew, what does the data say? Who ends up paying who more often?
5:14 Speaker 01 So of the total cases we looked at, eighty-two percent of them ended up with someone having to make a payment, either the landlord paying the tenant or the tenant paying the landlord. So we looked into what the split was within those payments. Now, of the eight hundred and twenty rulings where one person had to pay the other, in the average case, the tenant had to pay the landlord eighteen hundred dollars. And in terms of the total split, eighty-seven percent of the cases resulted in the tenant paying the landlord. Only thirteen percent of the cases, the landlord ended up paying the tenant.
5:47 Speaker 00 And so hearing that, you might think, okay, well, if in the average case, and in fact, in the vast bulk of cases, the tenants have to pay the landlord money, then maybe the tenancy tribunal is biased in favour of the landlords. But then you've got to factor in that most of the cases that come to the tribunal are actually brought by landlords. So about eighty-two percent of the cases that happen at the tenancy tribunal, the landlord is bringing the case. And if you're bringing the case, you probably think you're in the right. You probably think that you owed some money. So maybe the fact that in the average case, and in fact, in most cases, landlords win money, maybe that doesn't tell you that the tribunal is biased in favour of landlords.
6:30 Speaker 00 And so that's why I wanted to look at the win rate. Now, the what I'm calling this is if a tenant takes a case to the tenancy tribunal, what is the percentage chance they get a payment? So if the tenant takes you to the tribunal, or if we look at a hundred tenants taking their landlord to the tribunal, what percent of them get a payment? And if a landlord takes a case to the tribunal, what is the percentage chance that they get a payment? And this becomes really interesting because if a tenant initiates a case and there's a payment involved, they win seventy three percent of the time. That's based on our sample. Seventy three percent of the time, if they take a case to the tribunal and there's a payment,
7:15 Speaker 00 then they're getting money from the landlord. But if a landlord initiates the case and there's a payment involved, they win ninety eight percent of the time. They get money from the tenant. And that's probably very different from the public perception. A lot of people think the tribunal is biased towards tenants. However, if you look at the difference between what we are calling and what we are determining as the win rate, landlords are winning ninety eight percent of the time. They're getting more money from the tenant than they have to pay the tenant. But for the tenant, the win rate is only seventy three percent. Andrew, what is your take on that?
7:53 Speaker 01 I was actually very surprised about these numbers. I definitely had the opinion that the tenancy tribunal was heavily supportive of tenants and probably a little bit more bias in their favor. But certainly the numbers don't show that. And I was actually surprised at the amount of the payment as well, the average payment being eighteen hundred dollars. It's quite a lot of money.
8:13 Speaker 00 Now, having said that, this doesn't mean that the tenancy tribunal is biased towards landlords because on the other hand, you could say, well, landlords are the ones who are providing the product. And typically, if you look at why do landlords take their tenants to the tribunal? It's often unpaid rent. So maybe it's to be expected that the tenants would be ordered to pay landlords money. Maybe this doesn't say that there is bias towards landlords. Because there could still be bias towards tenants if maybe landlords are applying, but they're not getting as much money as they think they should get. In which case they could say, yeah, we get money, but it's not as much as we thought it would be. But laying it all up, you go, okay, I'm looking for evidence of bias.
8:57 Speaker 00 I'm not necessarily seeing it in these numbers. Now, one question you might ask, which is a very important question is, you're only looking at a thousand cases yet, and Andrew, is this a fair sample? And that's, that's a good question because there are about 25,000 cases that go to the tenancy tribunal every single year, and we've only looked at a thousand. But when I look at the split of my application, so of the thousand in our sample, about 77% of the applications came from landlords, about 18% from tenants. The rest were cross-applications. That lines up pretty closely with MB's and the Tennessee Tribunal's own published data in terms of how many applications come from landlords, how many come from tenants.
9:39 Speaker 00 So I've got a decent amount of confidence that, you know, this sample's pretty robust. We didn't have to look at all 25,000 cases from the last year. Looking at a thousand was probably enough. But Andrew, after we got this data, we wanted to talk to a couple of property managers just to see what they think. Do property managers say that the tribunal is biased?
9:57 Speaker 01 Yeah, so property managers obviously represent landlords all the time by going to the tenancy tribunal if there's a dispute. So I spoke to Tiffany from our property management team in Auckland, and she said that the tenancy tribunal is often perceived by landlords as favouring the tenants. So having that opinion that I had as well. And historically, that was probably the case and was probably intentional because back when the tenancy tribunal was established, that was in 1986, it was designed to protect tenants from landlords who could just throw people out when, you know, the laws weren't as robust to protect tenants. But since then, renting has become just far more normal, and so the tenancy tribunal has become more balanced.
10:37 Speaker 01 I also think that the other thing is we often hear about the cases where it's an extreme case of a tenant getting a huge judgment against a landlord because a landlord's rented out a property that's not fit for them to. Be able to live in. And so that probably creates this bias in our minds around the tenancy tribunal being favouring the tenants.
10:57 Speaker 00 Oh, you only hear about the cases that are really extreme and the, the ones that make the news are only the ones that truly are newsworthy. The other 24,592, which are pretty standard, never, never even make the news. And we're actually going to do another podcast within the next week where we go and look at some of those extreme cases. But this data has got me thinking, maybe the tenancy tribunal and the poor adjudicators get a little bit of a bad rap. There are certainly cases where they are just applying the law, but the law can seem a little bit unfair. And the, the example that I always use is like the case of a, a broken dishwasher. Let's say that you own a rental property, there's a dishwasher in there, the dishwasher is 15 years old.
11:40 Speaker 00 The tenant goes and smashes it up. You say, okay, well, the tenant should pay me some money because I've got to go and replace that. And it's going to cost me some money to replace that. And the tenancy tribunal goes, yeah, but the dishwasher wasn't worth anything. It was fully depreciated. In your accounts, you're not depreciating it anymore because, you know, the 15 year old dishwasher was worth $0. The purpose of the tribunal is not to do what's called betterment and put you in a better position. So actually the tenant doesn't owe you anything. And the landlord might say, but that's very unfair because I've still got to pay money to replace it. That is the law that, or, or that is the way the law is applied. Those are the rules.
12:20 Speaker 00 And so although it might seem unfair, although it might seem a little bit biased, you could make that argument. Actually, it's not biased. That's just the way it is. So sometimes there is a bit of a difference between bias and just what the rules actually are. But hopefully this makes property investors and landlords be a little bit less scared about the tenancy tribunal. Because the numbers that I'm seeing make me think, oh, actually, it seems pretty fair to me. And over the last 15 minutes, you've learned, is the tenancy tribunal rigged against landlords? What the tenancy tribunal said when we asked them that question? And how we analysed a thousand tenancy tribunal cases to see if we can spot the bias. Right, let's wrap it up there, but please don't forget to rate, review and subscribe to the podcast. Really does help us get the message out to more people.
13:11 Speaker 00 Thanks for listening to the Property Academy Podcast. I'm your host, Cebic Knight.
13:14 Speaker 01 And I'm Edra McCall.
13:15 Speaker 00 We're going to be back again tomorrow with even more daily strategies, tactics and insights to help you get the most out of the New Zealand property market. Until next time.
Previous The Secret Psychology of the 1%⎥Ep. 2205 Next The Ridiculous Jobs That Pay $10,000 An Hour⎥Ep. 2207 Page updated November 15, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated