Pod Insights The Property Academy Podcast "I’m 3 years from retirement ... and It’s SCARY" [Case Study]⎥Ep. 2018 About this episode In this episode, we discuss a case study of a property investor's Mum. She's 3 years away from retirement and is worried about what life looks like when she stops working. She's trying to keep up with her partners (who has more money) and isn't sure what to do next. We walk through a few of her options and what she should do next to get more comfortable with her retirement. For more from Opes Partners:Sign up for the weekly Private Property newsletterInstagramTikTok
Transcript 0:08 Speaker 00 Hello, welcome along to the Property Academy Podcast. I'm your host, Stephen Knight.
0:11 Speaker 01 And I'm Andrew Nichol.
0:12 Speaker 00 And so the show, we're talking about, I only have three years to retirement. What should I do? And this is a bit of a case study from a listener of the show who's really worried about her mother. So over the next 15 minutes, you could learn what your options are if you're only three years away from retirement. How do you create an income for life and beyond? And what do you do if you're really worried about your parents and their money when they retire? And the really wonderful thing about doing this show is sometimes you guys email us quite deeply personal situations. And just say, you know, what are the options here? And I think it's really wonderful that you're willing to do that. So Andrew, tell us about the story.
0:51 Speaker 01 So the listener of the show said, Lesley, her mum is three years away from turning 65. And she says that her mum's a quite a risk averse person, still working 32 hours a week, so four days a week, earning quite a good salary, so $90,000 a year.
1:05 Speaker 00 Go Lesley.
1:06 Speaker 01 Now, she already owns a property in Auckland and it's completely mortgage free, which is awesome. And she rents that property out. Lesley lives with her partner so she can afford to rent out her property in Auckland. Now, the partner's a bit older and has a business and he's quite rich. He's got a good amount of money. Now their finances are separate though.
1:27 Speaker 00 Okay, so this is all sounding quite good to be honest, Andrew, because if you're like, okay, you're 62, you've got a reasonably well-off partner, you've got a mortgage-free house. Okay, this kind of sounds okay.
1:38 Speaker 01 Now, the challenge is though mum tries to keep up with the well-off partner. And she feels quite stuck in her job and to be fair, she probably is at the moment. She needs money to travel and one thing to bear in mind is that the partner travels to Europe every year and he travels business class. Now, I don't know how it will work if you kept your money separate, but let me imagine this, Ed. You travel business class to Europe, Angela decides she can't afford that and she's down on an economy.
2:07 Speaker 01 It's gonna be quite a quiet trip in Europe, isn't it?
2:12 Speaker 00 I can imagine the looks I would get getting off that plane.
2:16 Speaker 01 It would be best just not to get off that plane. Anyway, the daughter wants to know, hey, what's mum's options here? She's got money in this house. Can she do anything? And should she use the sell one to buy two strategy to get more income?
2:30 Speaker 00 Yeah, look, before we get into this, it's always really important to say that we're gonna talk about some general situations on here. So this isn't what you'd call personalised financial advice. That's where you actually go to someone and they say, this is what I recommend you specifically do. Obviously, this is a podcast, so we're not gonna be able to say, Lesley, this is what we recommend you do. But we'll talk generally about some scenarios and you can kind of interpret this for your own situation. So where are we gonna start with this, Andrew?
2:57 Speaker 01 I'd start by thinking about, well, is that property that Lesley's got, actually a good investment property? So mum's a bit older, so really she's gonna want to focus on cash flow as opposed to capital growth. Now, the property's rented out for 6.50 a week. QV says that the property's worth about 900,000. So let's just say 900,000 dollars is the value of that property.
3:19 Speaker 00 And so I suppose the first thing is, is that a good investment? Is that giving you a decent yield? My feeling is probably not. So the rental yield on that is about 3.76%. It's probably about average for an average property rented out, but you could do a bit better than that, especially if your focus was yield. Typically would expect a gross yield at this stage of life of around 6% is what you'd probably aim for. If I look at her current cash flow and just like ballpark estimator, I'm using Opus Plus, our software to figure this all out, by the way. I reckon she's getting about 311 dollars a week in cash flow out of this. So, I mean, that's pretty good.
4:00 Speaker 00 It's about 15 grand a year, but it's probably quite low, given that she's got 900,000 dollars tied up into this property. And so if we think about the cash flow she's getting, if we say it's 300 bucks a week or so, it's kind of one .7% of the property's value that she's drawing out per year. And so if you think about that, that's actually not very good. If you sold that property and used the rule of four percent, you'd basically be able to double the amount of cash flow you're getting out of that. That's not to say that, again, that's what you should do, but it's just saying that actually this asset's probably not performing particularly well. And then in practice, the cash flow numbers we're looking at, Andrew, are potentially quite high because it's an older property.
4:45 Speaker 01 Yeah, one of the things with older properties, particularly as you're crossing the finish line and you're enjoying the rent from your rental properties, you really want your things like your maintenance and your vacancy to be a bit more stable. And I know in this situation, Lesley actually did do a renovation of the bathroom and it cost her way more than she thought. I can relate to that. And they discovered rotten wood in the walls and now she might have to replace a deck. So if you think, okay, well, there's a surplus of 15 grand a year, that can very, very easily be eaten up by one single project, like a bathroom or a deck.
5:21 Speaker 00 Okay, so that sounds quite scary. So what are mum's options?
5:24 Speaker 01 So if she does nothing, she's probably going to struggle for money, to be honest. When she gets to retirement age, she's going to have 21K come in from the super. She's got 15K coming in from her property and that's probably best case scenario. So a total of 36K in income after tax. Now, there might be some money in KiwiSaver, which will get dwindled away pretty quickly. But to fly business class to Europe, you're probably talking about $11,000. So you're talking about a third of your annual income just going on the flight. That's not a very sustainable lifestyle.
5:57 Speaker 00 Yeah, and so there are a couple of scenarios that Andrew and I have been knocking about to think about, okay, what are some options? One option that some people don't think about is just working a little bit longer. So let's say that Lesley worked to 67. That has two benefits. The first is that you've then got fewer years in retirement, so fewer years where you're not working, which just means that you've got fewer years where your money has to last for. The other really important part is that, let's say she's able to support herself for another two years through. Her work, that means she can take the forty odd grand from superannuation that she'd get from the pension and be able to save that and stash that into her nest egg. So that did give her the ability to save up a little bit more.
6:39 Speaker 00 But again, if we're thinking about that savings amount compared to the kind of fixed expenses that are quite important to her or appear to be quite important, like going on these big overseas trips, that's probably not going to last that long. So I don't love this option for Lesley, but it's something to put on the table. I suppose the, the second one, which is the most obvious, that I think most people are probably screaming at this podcast, is have the tough conversation with the partner. I mean, it's important to say that these guys have been together for 10 years. Like this isn't a, a one year relationship.
7:12 Speaker 01 Flash in the pan.
7:13 Speaker 00 So I understand the idea of people keeping their finances separate. I'm not necessarily opposed to that, but I think it'd be really important for Lesley to talk to her partner who's got a bit more money and she's sharing her life with to say, hey, I'm really worried about my future.
7:28 Speaker 01 Well, one thing I, one thing I see a lot with situations like this is someone holds on to what was their home previously and they're happy to rent it out and get a modest amount of income off it, but they don't want to sell it because they don't want to be homeless. They don't want to not have a house to live in because I reckon, you know, for example, if you said, okay, well, even if you use that sell one to buy two strategy, Lesley's going to think, well, I need to be able to live in one of these properties because I always need a house to live in in case my partner either breaks up with me or he dies.
8:01 Speaker 00 Well, I suppose just diving a little bit into that situation, one thing that's really important to consider is how is his will set up? Why would we need to think about that?
8:10 Speaker 01 Well, let's say, for example, he passes away, all of a sudden his kids inherit the house, which would be completely normal. Well, does that mean that mum's going to be kicked out and now in her older years, she's going to have to find a house to live in? And actually this happened to a friend of mine. His dad had been seeing someone for a number of years. He passed away. The partner had been living with him for a long, long period of time.
8:32 Speaker 00 But they weren't married?
8:33 Speaker 01 But they weren't married, no, no joint assets and now she. To go find somewhere else to live because the kids inherited the house. Now, if that were me, if I like, just thinking this through in terms of what might be a sensible conversation. If the partner has lots of money and there's some other pockets of money that the kids might inherit. Maybe what you would do is you'd give your partner a licence to occupy. So they might be able to live in there until they can no longer live in that house because they need to move into a rest home or something like that. That means that, yep, the kids still own the house, but you've got the right to occupy it until you no longer want to. And that way as well, everyone kind of wins.
9:11 Speaker 00 Yeah, because I suppose in this case, if if Lesley could get certainty that she's gonna have somewhere to live. She can use this house to fund her retirement. It might be selling the property, stashing the money into a managed fund and then drawing some income off that. That might work really well. It might be that you sell that and you buy another rental property and live off the income. That's another option. But we've kind of got to get certainty around this. And I think there are a couple of other tough conversations she really needs to have with her partner. And I would say, I like the idea of starting this off with, I am really worried about my future. Can we talk about it? Because you're not saying to him, hey.
9:48 Speaker 01 Write me into the will.
9:49 Speaker 00 Write me into the will. You need to pay for my business class flights to Europe. You need to do this. You need to do that. That's probably not gonna go down very well for you if you potentially come across as quite entitled, right? But starting it with, hey, I'm a bit worried. Can we have a conversation about it? Because he might start suggesting some things that you might have asked for, you might not even have even thought of asking for. So I think the first thing is figuring out that living situation. But similarly, maybe talking about these flights, these big expensive trips to Europe. I actually understand why he would want that. Because he's seventy now, right? He's made his money. He's like, well, I need to enjoy the time that I've got left because I might not be able to travel overseas forever.
10:31 Speaker 00 I might only be able to do it for the next five years. So I want to make sure that I'm having a really comfortable time. But it'd be important to say, well, what are my options? My option might be to fly in a different class. Now, I don't particularly love that option, but it might be something to consider. It might be that he pays for you. Upgrade from economy to business class if he was willing to do that. But it's really important that we do the really tough thing, which is probably the thing that Lesley doesn't want to do, but is the most important thing she should do, because it'll take, you know, it might be in our conversation, but it's going to be the most important hour of her next 10 years potentially, is to actually sit down and talk about some of these situations. What happens if she gets stuck? Can she reduce her expenses? Can she spend less on those big trips? Can she do something with her own home and get some comfort around that?
11:15 Speaker 00 What other options do we see around the property side, Andrew, for Lesley?
11:19 Speaker 01 So the daughter's suggesting, hey, do we use the sell one to buy two strategy? Now, that's a great strategy if you've got really good income, but you're struggling with the equity, because you've got some of these inefficient assets. But in this case, Lesley has low income and high equity, so it's probably not the right strategy for her. Also, she's unlikely to be able to sell that property and then buy two properties with the same level of debt, i.e. none. She'd have to take out some debt and at 63, I don't think that's appropriate advice. We want to be reducing the leverage as we get into our later years. Maybe she might sell that property and buy something, you know, like a dual key apartment that has lower maintenance, higher yield. Yep, maybe that's an option. But I think at the moment, the reason why she's probably reserved for doing that
12:03 Speaker 01 is because of the living situation and needing to know that she's got somewhere to go back to. So my guess is that's the issue as opposed to the yield side of things.
12:12 Speaker 00 One of the scenarios that I quite like as well is that if she was able to get some certainty about her living situation, you know, talk about the world's all of that stuff. If she was able to sell that property, put it into a managed fund with an investment advisor and just use the rule of 6%. So if she sold the property, she'd probably come out after you pay the staging or the real estate agent or the lawyers, she might come out with 800 grand. It's actually a pretty sizable nest egg. You know, if you bundle that up with whatever KiwiSaver you have, put that with an investment advisor and say, I'm going to use the rule of 6%, which is where you just take out 6% every single year. So let's say that with her KiwiSaver, real round numbers, she ends up with a million bucks, right? So sells the house plus her KiwiSaver.
12:57 Speaker 00 Well, that means that she could draw out sixty thousand dollars a year. Now, she wouldn't increase that with inflation. When you use the rule of six percent, it's just sixty grand every single year, flat. You don't adjust it for the cost of living, so over time, your spending's not keeping up with inflation. But it means that when you're sixty five, you can spend a little bit more. And people do tend to spend a bit less as they get older. Well, she'd possibly be able to get that sixty grand a year, plus an extra twenty one K from super. You're probably living off eighty one thousand dollars a year, which is
13:28 Speaker 01 Probably more than what she's living on at the moment, to be honest.
13:31 Speaker 00 Yeah, so it'd allow her to live a pretty good lifestyle once she ends up retiring at sixty five. But this is premised on sorting out the living situation. So knowing that she's going to have a place to live in throughout her retirement. She's thinking about what happens if my partner passes away before I do. Because what you wouldn't want to get into a situation is where you sell the house, you spend all of that money. You get to eighty, your partner's now gone and his kids are kicking you out of the house and you're like, but I've spent most of my money now, I'm just living off super, what am I gonna do? So there are some things to think through here, but that's another scenario just to keep in mind.
14:10 Speaker 01 Sometimes we look at these kind of situations and say, the problem is money and the problem is cash flow. I actually think in this scenario, the problem is that we haven't had a tough conversation. And I get that completely because mum probably doesn't want to have to ask for help. They probably appreciates the fact that she's got somewhere to live. And is wanting to support herself, but also have a backstop in case something goes wrong. But I would be just having that conversation now, have that tough conversation now. Because probably that will liberate her from these feelings of nervousness. And then they can actually enjoy their retirement together. The other thing to think about is now's not a great time to be selling something in Auckland. So I was thinking, okay, well, if mum's sixty three at the moment, maybe she can have a few more years working
14:54 Speaker 01 and get some of that catch up growth that Auckland probably is going to have over the next couple of years.
14:58 Speaker 00 Yeah, it's real interesting. I like what you said about that money's not necessarily the issue here. It's about protecting the downsides and dealing with some of those. Risks and worries that Lesley's probably got because if we can sort those, that actually gives her a whole lot more options with what she does with the money or the assets that she has. So hopefully that gives you some things to think about. And over the last 15 minutes, we've talked about, you know, what do you do if you're in this situation? You're only three years away from retirement. How do you potentially create an income for life? And in some cases, depending on what you do with it, beyond. And what do you do if you're really worried about your parents' money when they retire? Right, let's wrap it up there. But please don't forget to rate, review and subscribe to the podcast. Really does help us get the message out to more people.
15:46 Speaker 00 Thanks for listening to the Property Academy Podcast. I'm your host, David Knight. And I'm your host, John Echol. We're going to be back again tomorrow with even more daily strategies, techniques and insights to help you get the most out of the estate and property market. Until next time.
Previous Make more money NOT investing at the bottom of the market ⎥Ep. 2017 Next [Must listen] They skipped insurance – then disaster struck⎥Ep. 2019 Page updated November 15, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated