Pod Insights The Property Academy Podcast I Own 43 Properties But I Wish I Learned This Sooner⎥Ep. 2104 About this episode Most investors dream of building a massive portfolio – Andrew Nicol actually did it. He owns 43 properties … but along the way, made some major mistakes. In this episode, Andrew shares what he’d do differently if he had to start again. You’ll learn:How he built his portfolio from flipping homes to long-term holdsThe moment he nearly lost it all after the Christchurch earthquakesWhy letting go of bad investments is sometimes smarter than holding onWhether you’re just starting out or deep into your journey, this episode shares the real behind-the-scenes of growing a successful portfolio. Want to run the numbers on your next investment? Use the free Opes+ Property Investment Calculator to check the cashflow and capital gains before you buy. For more from Opes Partners:Sign up for the weekly Private Property newsletterInstagramTikTok
Transcript 0:08 Speaker 00 Hello and welcome along to the Property Academy Podcast by Obus Partners. I'm your host, Stevie Knight.
0:11 Speaker 01 And I'm Andrew Nicol.
0:12 Speaker 00 And this is a show that helps Kiwis go from zero to five investment properties. So you can be financially free, even if you don't have millionaire parents. Now, stick around for the next 15 minutes because you're going to learn how Andrew built a portfolio of 43 investment properties and the lessons that he wished he learned earlier. The major mistake that nearly broke him and the three different errors of Andrew's investing life that helped him get to that point where he now owns 43 properties. And the interesting thing about you, mate, is that a lot of people look at you and think, this rich prick.
0:48 Speaker 00 But what, you know, it's true.
0:50 Speaker 01 Like, apparently so.
0:53 Speaker 00 But what do you think most people get wrong about property investors and especially your journey?
0:58 Speaker 01 Well, I think to begin with, they think you've got to be really rich to get into property investment, which is completely not the case. Like, there was no handout for me, there was no handout for anyone in my family. And we basically came from a lower socio economic area of Christchurch where money was really tight. So both parents worked, in fact, multiple jobs. We, I think dad would bike to work on freezing cold Christchurch mornings. We'd have, you always liked the Teagle offcuts story. So I remember we would get these giant sacks, I think like 20 kg or 10 kg bags of Teagle offcuts, the chicken.
1:38 Speaker 00 What makes it an offcut? Is it like the chicken knee or something?
1:42 Speaker 01 It's just a bit, like, they're a bit like, kind of lumpy and they just, they weren't supermarket perfect, I guess.
1:48 Speaker 00 Yeah. So you ate deformed chicken.
1:50 Speaker 01 Yeah, fine. And it was actually quite good. You just chuck it in a casserole or something like that and Bob's your uncle.
1:58 Speaker 00 Follow me for more cooking tips. And, and I know that in a lot of Kiwi families, the day you get paid at the start of the month, your family feels like you're absolutely rich. So you're out for fish and chips. And then by the end of the, the month, the money's run out and so you're back on the teagle off cuts.
2:14 Speaker 01 Yeah, that was the rough time because of course dad got paid monthly because it was an international brand that he worked for. And because of that, and because of the fact that they were so useless with money or managing the cash flow, there was just no money by the end of the month. Like you'd know, we have to wait till next week to ask for anything because there's no money.
2:32 Speaker 00 Yeah. And so I think that, that idea that property investors are born wealthy is kind of not correct. Like for many Kiwis, you start investing in property and that's how you get wealthy. But the other thing that's quite interesting at your duty is you started out with a very low deposit, but it took you some time to build it and you had some really interesting jobs when you were young.
2:54 Speaker 01 I had so many jobs. So I'd, I'd either be trying to sell something or peddle off something to someone. I worked for Terry Delors Carpet Kingdom, gathering up the smooth edge. Do you remember that one?
3:03 Speaker 00 Tell us about that.
3:04 Speaker 01 So Terry Delors Carpet Kingdom was on Wilson's Road, across the road from our house. And I went and I used to vacuum their floors, their showroom floors for them every day after school. I used to prepare the underlay for the jobs for the next day. So I'd cut it to size. And the worst job was the smooth edge. So smooth edge goes along the edge of your, uh, thing. And it's, um, there's little planks of wood and they got all spiky tacks in it. So I'd take my little girly arms and I'd get thirty four of the smooth edge as per the order. And I'd try and bundle them up with rope and I'd have scratches all up my arms.
3:38 Speaker 00 He's still got them today with his delicate skin. Tell, and tell us about when you were a magician. Cause I remember once we were out for dinner and I think somebody came up and was like, you used to do magic at my restaurant.
3:50 Speaker 01 Yeah. Oh, that's right. That was Pat from south of the border. So when I was about maybe fourteen, fifteen, I used to do magic shows for kids' parties and balloon animals, learnt to do balloon animals. And then I thought, actually I could make some money out of this. So I used to go around to restaurants. And I remember my first ever one. Blue Jean Cuisine, a really nice man called Murray Trail that owns lots of McDonald's now. He gave me my first job and I, I worked Thursday, Friday and Saturday night for an hour session each night. And he paid me something like forty dollars. And it was a lot of money back then, buy a house with that back then. And then I'd also get tips. So I'd, you know, I'd make sure that I'd go and spend a lot of time with that, that guy that was on the first date. Because you wanna get a first date there because he wants to show off to his girlfriend.
4:34 Speaker 01 And so he's gonna give you a twenty dollar tip because he wants to be the big man. So you make sure you focus on them. You don't go for someone like you who just looks like an accountant that's never gonna give you a tip.
4:44 Speaker 00 Well, I'm not a charity, Andrew.
4:46 Speaker 01 No, so I made a lot of money doing the magic at restaurants, but all sorts of jobs. I would do anything to make a buck.
4:51 Speaker 00 And I suppose the reason we're talking about this is you just had an opinion piece on stuff where you shared the story of how you went from owning zero to forty three properties. It was very, very popular. So we know that Kiwis are really aspirational. They're interested in how do you go from not having millionaire appearance, starting basically at zero and pulling yourself up. And I know that one of the very interesting stories you shared in that stuff piece was about how you got your first start and how a kind of older mentor helped you out.
5:21 Speaker 01 Yeah, so I'd been working hard. Um, at that stage I'd got a proper job. I'd gone to work for the B and Z. I was saving diligently. I didn't spend a lot, so I, I would do things like brew my own alcohol. I'd cook at home, I would, I, there wasn't much that I had to spend any money on. And as a result, I'd, you know, diligently save away my deposit. And then I, I remember I'd been thinking about investing in property for quite a long time. But I kept kicking the can down the road because I was a bit nervous and I didn't really know where to get started. Didn't know if I could get the money. And I got taken out by a guy called Tony Mount, who's a friend of mine now, who was like the mortgage legend of the South Island for the B and Z. And he was just showing me how his role as a mobile mortgage manager worked.
6:06 Speaker 01 And I remember we were talking about kind of the fact that I was thinking about buying a property. And he said, how much deposit do you have? And I think I said twelve thousand dollars. And he said, oh, how much does you pay? And I said, Forty thousand dollars.
6:18 Speaker 00 Where did forty thousand dollars in two thousand and three?
6:21 Speaker 01 Oh, maybe it wasn't. Maybe it was twenty eight thousand. How would I know? Like, that's so long ago. I don't know. No, it might have been twenty eight thousand or something like that. And then Mountsey said, oh, just do it then. What's stopping you? Just do it. Go and buy something. And so then I started going and making offers.
6:37 Speaker 00 Now, I think there's two lessons in there. First of all, if you're a property investor, you don't have to come from a rich family, but you do have to start. And that is the main thing that, you know, you don't buy your fortieth investment property before you buy your first. And sometimes investors get so concerned about, okay, but if I buy this property, what is the path to buy my sixth or seventh? Well, you don't know that yet. You've just got to get your first. And just before we go on to Andrew's three areas of his life. If you want to read the whole story, you've got to check out Opes Plus. This is a free app that we've released for you guys, where you can actually run the numbers on any investment property in New Zealand. It is completely free to sign up. And as an added benefit, if you do this, under the Guides and Courses section,
7:22 Speaker 00 you can read Andrew's full story in about four thousand words, way more detailed than on stuff, and see how it all happened, including a couple of cute pictures of Andrew's early life as a child. So go check that out. If you either Google Opes Plus or just go to opespartners.co.nz, click Opes Plus, you'll be able to create your free account.
7:43 Speaker 01 Look at that carpet.
7:44 Speaker 00 That is some ninety nineties carpet right there. I remember we would have had, no, that's almost, when were you born? That's like maybe early, late eighties, early nineties.
7:55 Speaker 01 Dummy.
7:56 Speaker 00 Oh, is this you here? You're the blog one.
7:58 Speaker 01 Yeah, yeah. And like, who did you think it was? And look, I was sporting some interesting socks back then as well.
8:04 Speaker 00 Look, not much has changed, has it? So let's move on to those three eras of your life. So we can actually find out, well, how do you go from nothing to forty three properties? So I know we're calling era number one, your hustle era. So what happened in this first stage of your investing life?
8:21 Speaker 01 So this is when I was completely starting out and I didn't have much cash to start out with. My deposit, I think I had saved that twelve thousand dollars. And what I needed to do is I needed to grow my wealth because I had an okay income, like it was a starting out income, but I didn't have many expenses. So therefore my limitation was really around my deposit. And so I needed to turn that money into more money as quickly as possible. So everything that I would do was about adding value. So I'd go out and I'd buy, I, I remember the first street I bought was Beclues Street. I can't remember the address now, but you probably do. And
8:55 Speaker 00 Twenty seven.
8:56 Speaker 01 Twenty, was it twenty seven?
8:57 Speaker 00 I don't know, just made that up.
8:58 Speaker 01 No, it was number, I think it was number five. And I would buy a property and I would do cosmetic renovations. And I'd do most of it myself because I didn't have the money to pay for someone to do it. So I'd do it badly, by the way. But I would do it as quickly as possible. And then I would either keep that property and try and extract equity. Or more often I would sell that property because this was before the days of Brightline. So you didn't, you didn't have tax on, on the profits that you sell. So if you could sell that property, take out your money, you could go and buy another one. And I'd just do that as many times as possible to try and grow my wealth as quickly as I could.
9:31 Speaker 00 And I know that over kind of four or five years that this happened from two thousand and three to two thousand and seven. You actually flipped a lot of properties. How many, how many was it all up?
9:39 Speaker 01 Uh, I think, uh, uh, there would have been about twenty five, I think in those early days. And that certainly ramped up as time went on as well because the first couple or the first few, that happens really slowly because you're still figuring things out. You're still, even, even things like learning how to sell a property and what price to accept when you're selling a property and, and you know, not to hold on to a property too long. That takes a bit of learning. So I think the biggest thing that people would kind of get wrong is they think that it should all happen all at once. And they think, oh, well, you know, I want my forty properties. So therefore I need to buy four a year for the next ten years. Probably not at all. Probably you buy one property a year or maybe two properties a year and then it ramps up as time goes on.
10:21 Speaker 00 And the other thing that's interesting is that by the end of those five years, you'd flipped twenty five properties, but how many did you actually still own by the end of those, those five years?
10:31 Speaker 01 Uh, nowhere near that number. So more like seven.
10:33 Speaker 00 Yeah, okay. And so a lot of this was building up equity so that you could go and buy more properties because you didn't have a lot of deposit at the start.
10:41 Speaker 01 Yeah, correct. And also, the bank just wasn't going to, with my income levels, let me keep that number of properties.
10:48 Speaker 00 But if you could go back in your time machine,
10:53 Speaker 00 cool, we're back in two thousand and five, let's call it, let's buy as many houses as possible and hold on to them. What mistakes do you think you made in that first era of your investment journey?
11:05 Speaker 01 I think the mistake I was making back then is I was, I was chasing the cash rather than thinking about my long-term strategy. So if I think back to, okay, well, I, I, I knew that I wanted to make money. I didn't want to not have money. So what I was trying to do is get my cash out as quickly as possible. So maybe I wasn't as focused as I probably should have been on, okay, maybe I just need to build my career and my personal income. So that then that will propel me into the next phase of my investing career.
11:31 Speaker 00 But if you were talking to some youngins today, nineteen-year-olds in twenty twenty-five, because you started out investing when you were nineteen, what advice would you give them now if people are starting out in their hustle era?
11:42 Speaker 01 I definitely think that accepting that the method that we often talk about on the podcast, i.e. the buy and hold or the build and hold strategy or the burst strategy, that's not right for you at that stage. Like, I actually met with a, a young guy just the other day and he'd just finished reading our book, Wealth Plan. And I said to him, what you need to do now is you need to find a property that you can add value as quickly as possible. And you need to take your deposit, which was actually pretty sizable, it was bigger than my deposit. And you need to repeat the process of buying and flipping and buying and flipping and paying your bright line tax if you fall into that, and just repeat the process.
12:20 Speaker 00 And I remember you once telling me that when you were starting working at the bank, you realised that, like we were saying before, you don't need to necessarily have a lot of money and already to be rich to invest in property, but investing can make you rich. Do you remember that story?
12:34 Speaker 01 Yeah, I think that was probably quite interesting. The branch that I worked at had quite a wide range of people with different wealth journeys or in different parts of their wealth journey. And I remember there was this really, really sweet old man that used to come in all the time. And he, he hardly ever wears shoes and he'd come bowling into my office, no appointment, right? And he, he looked like he didn't have any money. And that would have been my assumption. And. He actually owned a huge amount of properties around Addington, which is actually an area where we do a lot of work nowadays with like hardly any debt, right? And I think probably that made me realise, okay, well, you can't judge a book by its cover. That's probably a big thing, but also that I needed to educate myself on, well, this guy,
13:19 Speaker 01 who really just kind of had a modest income, he's really rich. He's richer than a lot of people that you'd meet today. So I need to learn what it is that I need to know before I get into investing. And so that's when I started reading things like Rich Dad, Poor Dad, actually started educating myself, which is so much easier nowadays than it was back then. So you go to the library and get a book out and then have to return it a few weeks later. You know, nowadays you've got the internet, you've got YouTube, you've got podcasts, you've got everything.
13:46 Speaker 00 So your first era, 2003 to 2007, mainly flipping properties, flipped 20 properties, ended up coming out of that era with seven properties in total. And then we move on to kind of what we call your expanding era, where you did buy a lot of properties there quickly. And this happened over about nine years from 2007 to 2018. So what happened over those nine years?
14:10 Speaker 01 So at this stage now, I'm a mortgage broker, I'm making better money. I'm quite familiar with property investment. I'm mixing with property investment circles. I thought, right, I'm going to get my parents into investing, convince them to invest with me in some property. And then the GFC hit. And so that first property that they were finally brave enough to ever buy, by the time we bought that, it was down 25 grand. So it was quite a lot of money, given that the purchase price was under $400,000, I think, from memory. So I just talked them into doing something and they've lost some money. The GFC hit, so it's harder to do my job as a mortgage broker. But I'm just continuing to invest, continuing to invest, because I understand it's about the long term. As I'm continuing to invest, I'm doing what a lot of people do,
14:52 Speaker 01 which is just buying properties around them, i.e. in Christchurch and thinking, oh yeah, this is going well. It's so easy. Property in Christchurch is cheap, not like that scary Auckland that's so expensive. And then the earthquakes hit. And all of a sudden, I was in a point of time where, okay, I've got quite a lot of properties, but quite a lot of debt. My income was potentially going to be affected by the fact that the earthquakes meant you couldn't borrow against a house in the short term unless you'd had things signed off, or you couldn't settle a property without insurance, which was hard to get. And now I've got a point where I'm like, this was really dumb. I should never have put all my eggs in one basket. I know, I should know better than that. That's completely stupid. And it could have actually meant the end of me.
15:36 Speaker 01 If I had had more properties that were damaged and insurance companies not paying out and tenants leaving, that would have wiped me out.
15:43 Speaker 00 Cause you're still, you still would have had to pay your mortgage.
15:46 Speaker 01 Yeah.
15:47 Speaker 00 But you would have had no rental income.
15:49 Speaker 01 Yeah, like even the top up was bad enough without taking out, you know, a couple of tenancies and or maybe, you know, a fifty grand repair bill because the insurance was not enough for that property or something like that.
16:00 Speaker 00 And then on top of that, because you were, you were basically a contractor, right? At that point, you weren't earning a salary. You're self-employed. So because you were writing mortgages in Christchurch and then after the earthquakes, you couldn't write mortgages for houses, right? Because the bank wasn't going to lend any money against the property in Christchurch before they figured out whether it was damaged or not, because they want to make sure that that property actually has some value. And it was so uncertain after that. So is it fair to say that you almost went broke at that point?
16:29 Speaker 01 Yeah, a hundred percent. Had the chips not landed the way they did, it could have gone very, very badly for me.
16:34 Speaker 00 And so what have you done since then to kind of take that lesson on board?
16:39 Speaker 01 So the number one thing that I've probably done is I've made sure that I have more buffers in place. So that's, that's something that I can control very easily. The other thing I could control very easily is, okay, well, I, I can't control where a natural event happens, but I can control where my properties are. So I put a lot more focus on investing outside of Christchurch after that day.
16:59 Speaker 00 And the other thing that's interesting is out of that horrific tragedy came some opportunities in property.
17:06 Speaker 01 Yeah, there was a period of my investing where I really ramped up because there was some arbitrage between properties that were on the market that were earthquake damaged. And the fact that people wanted to just get rid of it. They they didn't want to have the hassle of that anymore. They want to move out of their house and move on with their life. And the fact that, oh, I could actually have this repaired because now I've got a lot of contacts in the building industry. I could repair that property, reinsure that property and sell it out to a nice other new buyer. That is quite happy to buy a property that's been earthquake repaired, but it's a good deal for everyone. And so that was a time when I probably, a lot of my properties I would buy, renovate, fix and sell. And then I would pocket the best ones for myself and just grow up following all of that.
17:49 Speaker 00 And then I know at the same time, as you're doing this earthquake damage stuff, flipping some, keeping some, you're also loaning up on new builds.
17:56 Speaker 01 Yeah, because my business at that stage was a new build, my Opes Partners. I was thinking, okay, well, this is actually quite a nice, easy way of investing. I want to keep the best of the properties that I've renovated. And I want to just have properties that are going to be stress free because bear in mind now, I've got, you know, 15 years worth of buying older properties and having quite big maintenance bills. So some of my properties were were quite maintenance heavy. So I was just buying new builds and parking them aside and making sure I was buying in places like Auckland, where I didn't have to be exposed to the Christchurch market.
18:31 Speaker 00 So by the time we end this expanding era in 2018, you would have been investing for 15 years. How many did you have at that point?
18:41 Speaker 01 So I think probably around there, it was probably early 30s, so 32, I think.
18:44 Speaker 00 So 15 years to get your 32 properties. What was the last era? What happened there?
18:49 Speaker 01 So this is kind of me now, which is the long term era. So now what I'm doing is I'm saying, okay, well, property's been really, really good to get me to where I am today. But I had a whole lot of properties that were tax inefficient because of the government's changes to interest deductibility, high maintenance bills and, you know, maybe just a bit more hassle. So some of the stuff in Christchurch that had been repaired, there would be things come up like, you know, a tenant would call you and say, oh, there's something funny happening here. I just needed to take away the mental bandwidth that that was taking away from me just carrying on doing my job. And now I'm at a stage where, okay, having a family. More important to me. So what I did was start to sell down a lot of those inefficient properties and replace them with new builds that I didn't have to worry about.
19:35 Speaker 01 And so I could carry on growing my portfolio, but the time and the energy becomes more of a focus for me now.
19:41 Speaker 00 So it's been seven years in this kind of long term era. And you're up to forty three, so you would have got another eleven properties over the last seven years. But you've been selling some, buying some. How many do you think you've bought over the last seven years?
19:56 Speaker 01 So I would say it's probably around twenty. I couldn't tell you off the top of my head without looking at my spreadsheet, but probably twenty.
20:02 Speaker 00 It's quite a lot of properties. So you're talking about like basically three a year, a little under three.
20:06 Speaker 01 That would sound right.
20:07 Speaker 00 And what do you think people get wrong about when they move into this era of investing, where you're thinking more about the long term?
20:14 Speaker 01 An interesting conversation I had with an investor the other day was I told them to get rid of a property and they said, I don't want to get rid of that property. You say never to sell a property. I'm like, yes, but that is a rubbish investment now. They'd lived in the property previously, so they they had this emotional attachment. Property investment is just about the numbers. I get that houses we live in and we get emotionally attached to. But you've got to just focus on the numbers. So don't get emotionally attached. If something's a dog of a deal or doesn't make sense anymore. If it's got you to this level and now you're ready for the next stage of your investing, get rid of the stuff that doesn't work and replace it with better properties.
20:51 Speaker 00 And I know that in this last era, you actually bought a house for the first time. So after buying like thirty two investment properties, you finally bought your own home. And I know that that had some some interesting eye openers as well.
21:04 Speaker 01 Yeah, I think the biggest thing is that because I am such an investor mindset, buying an owner occupied property, it was really challenging for me because it didn't make economic sense to me. I'm like, I'm tying all this money in an owner occupied property. I don't want to do that. It's feels like a waste of money. And it kind of made me realise, well, for all these years I've been telling owner occupiers to get into the investor mindset and it's hard for them, so it can go both ways.
21:33 Speaker 00 Yeah, I remember when I've bought my first time. After buying five investment properties, I think it was four or five. And then you start looking at your own home and you get real emotional about it. And you're like, wow, this is so interesting. And probably very normal that you get emotionally invested in your house. And then you think, well, I've got to change my mindset when I move from investing to buying a house. Imagine what it must be like if you're going the other way as well, where you've got to turn off the emotion. And then turn on the investment kind of principles and they are very different ways of buying houses. Now, if you were to summarize it all up and say, what was your biggest learning and your biggest mistake? Over those twenty one years investing now, buying, I know you've owned forty three properties now, but bought and sold probably over a hundred houses yourself. Biggest learning and biggest mistake.
22:19 Speaker 01 So I think the biggest thing is you want to go hard when you're young and you've got, you know, double income, no kids. You know, I went hard, but I probably could have gone a lot harder if I wanted to. I think the biggest learning was when I almost lost everything by being so exposed in one city. Like that was just dumb. I should have known better. And if I'd gone broke, that would be my story. Hey, I went broke and I learned from that. So I think that don't get so caught up in what you know, that you just make a stupid decision like that. And I think that if you are young, then you do need to focus on the flips. Or if you're just starting out, you need to focus on the flips, you need to think, focus on the things to grow your wealth as quickly as possible. So that you can transition into that long term.
23:02 Speaker 00 And when you say young, what do you mean by young?
23:05 Speaker 01 So young, I just mean starting out. Like if I meet someone that's forty or fifty and they don't have any, oh, they've just got enough money for the first deposit. I'd tell them the same thing. So young, I'm talking about starting out.
23:16 Speaker 00 And at what point would you say to people, right? You've started out, now it's time to focus on the long term.
23:23 Speaker 01 So probably two things. Number one is that they've got their own house at that stage. They're relatively settled there and they've got some equity in that. Because the reason I had to flip is because I didn't own my own house. So I couldn't leverage against that. So I had no choice. So if you've got your own house, that's probably a good sign. But also if you've got your own career. Again, you know, while I was working at the bank, I worked long hours, but I had. A lot of spare time and so I had the time to be able to go and do those renovations after work. But I worked till midnight, right? You're not going to do that if you're building a career.
23:54 Speaker 00 Or if you've got young kids.
23:55 Speaker 01 Yeah, if you've got a career of kids and you've got your own home with some equity in it, then at that stage you need to start to be thinking about the long term era.
24:02 Speaker 00 And if you want to dig into the the entire story and get a little bit more detailed, check out that full guide that we've released on Opus Plus. I'll put a link down in the description where you can create your own free account and you'll be able to find Andrew's full story in the guides and courses section. And over the last 15 minutes, you've learnt how Andrew built a portfolio of 43 properties, the major mistake that nearly broke him and the three eras of Andrew's investing life. Right, let's wrap it up there, but please don't forget to rate, review and subscribe to the podcast. Really does help us get the message out to more people.
24:42 Speaker 00 Thanks for listening to the Property Academy Podcast. I'm your host, Stephen Knight. We're going to be back here tomorrow to think more daily strategies, tactics and insights to help you get the most out of your selling property market. Until next time.
Previous I Own 43 Properties But I Wish I Learned This Sooner⎥Ep. 2104 Next Are We Really at the Bottom of the Housing Market?⎥Ep. 2106 Page updated November 15, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated