Pod Insights The Property Academy Podcast "I haggled $116,000 off a house!"⎥Ep. 2034 About this episode In this episode, we discuss how Andrew managed to negotiate a massive $116,000 discount off a property. We also share how much you can realistically shave off a purchase price in today’s market. We break down: The actual data on how much buyers are negotiating off properties in Auckland, Wellington, and Christchurch The discounts you can get off New Builds and existing properties And the tactics you can use to get a better deal — even if the market feels tight. You’ll also hear how Opes investors are getting up to $51,000 off the market value (according to registered valuations) — and why the best negotiators are always willing to walk away. For more from Opes Partners:Sign up for the weekly Private Property newsletterInstagramTikTok
Transcript 0:08 Speaker 00 Hello and welcome along to the Property Canopy Podcast by Upas Partners. I'm your host, Seb at Night.
0:11 Speaker 01 And I'm Andrew Nicole.
0:12 Speaker 00 And so the show, we're talking about how I haggled 116K off a house. That includes how Andrew haggled over 100 grand off a house. How much you can potentially negotiate off a house price when you go to buy one. And also, how does it change between new builds and existing properties? And I'll tell you why this is interesting, because I recently got an email from a staff journalist saying, "Ed, can you help me run some numbers about how low you can go when making an offer on a house?" So I ran some numbers for her and it ended up getting published. I always like it when they use the photo of when I was skinnier.
0:46 Speaker 01 You like that photo, don't you? That's some of David's finest work.
0:50 Speaker 00 Yeah, David, our photographer, mainly because that was back in the days when I was skinnier. And so what I did was I looked at 8,000 properties that have been sold in Christchurch, Wellington and Auckland over the last three months. So from the start of January through till today. So over four and a half thousand in Auckland, about 1,800 odd in Christchurch. And what I did was just look at those that have an asking price or had a price on it when it was advertised, right? So that was kind of half the properties in Wellington, just over half, just under half in Christchurch. Interestingly enough, less than one in five Auckland properties that were sold in the first three months of the year actually had a price attached to it.
1:33 Speaker 01 That feels really low.
1:35 Speaker 00 Well, just because in Auckland, like over, yeah, over half of the properties tend to go to auction.
1:40 Speaker 01 It's really interesting because an investor that I'm meeting with on Thursday, he is trying to sell a property at the moment and just wants a really, really quick sale because he's got another commitment. And as a result, he is willing to price quite aggressively. Now, his agent said, "Okay, we're going to go to auction." I didn't think that was a very wise decision right now in Auckland.
2:02 Speaker 00 Why not?
2:03 Speaker 01 Because I just didn't feel like there was enough momentum in the market to warrant it.
2:07 Speaker 00 Yeah.
2:07 Speaker 01 And it turns out I was right, it hasn't had anyone bid on it.
2:10 Speaker 00 Yeah, a lot of agents push for auctions.
2:12 Speaker 01 Yeah.
2:12 Speaker 00 Because then even if there's only one buyer in the room, you can still sell at auction. It's just that you're trying to force that person to make a cash unconditional offer.
2:22 Speaker 01 Get the deal done on the day.
2:24 Speaker 00 Which is obviously what real estate agents are incentivized to do, right? Like, if you're a real estate agent, you don't make more money by selling properties for ten percent more. You make more money by selling.
2:35 Speaker 01 More properties.
2:35 Speaker 00 Ten percent more properties.
2:37 Speaker 01 Yeah.
2:37 Speaker 00 Because the commission is is higher within the first four hundred odd grand. And when I ran those numbers for stuff, I found that actually the median property in Christchurch only sold for about half a percent less than asking. In Wellington, it was about zero point four percent, so not a hell of a lot. In Auckland, the median property or average property was only selling about two point seven percent under asking. And so let me put that into context for you. Let's say that, you know, the median property in Auckland is listed for a million bucks. Well, on average, it's only selling about twenty seven thousand dollars under asking. In Christchurch, it's closer to five thousand dollars. Now, what's your take on that?
3:18 Speaker 01 Given that we're in a market where it is a buyer's market right now, I would have expected there to be a larger discount or a larger discount asked by buyers. Maybe that just tells you that people are pricing really fairly at the moment. People's expectation as a seller is that I've got to be realistic to get a buyer right now. And agents are are relaying that message and so therefore they're pricing aggressively to begin with. Or, one question I've got is, does that rely on the price not changing? So, okay, I list a property at a million dollars or one point one, then I reduce it to one oh five oh, then I reduce it to a million and then there's a sale that takes place?
3:55 Speaker 00 Yeah, that's the interesting thing. So we get this data directly from real estate agents and it's whatever the real estate agent put in as the listing price.
4:03 Speaker 01 Okay, well, listing price would would make me think that's the original listing. So therefore, if I've discounted from there, then that's the bottom price. And the top price.
4:13 Speaker 00 But then at the same time, the other thing I was thinking is, well, the agent is putting in list price, but there are a couple of different sales processes that you can use where you actually put a price on a property. So for example, we've got asking price, it might be asking price a million bucks, but it could also be buyer's inquiry over
4:32 Speaker 01 Yeah, yeah.
4:33 Speaker 00 A million bucks, which would probably explain that even once you start looking at the distribution of it, there are properties that according to this data sell like fifteen percent above that list price.
4:45 Speaker 01 Yes.
4:45 Speaker 00 So I was like, okay, maybe it's not just that people are bad negotiators. Um, maybe that's what was causing this. Maybe it's that it's not just asking price. Sometimes you have buyer's inquiry over a certain amount. One other thing that's interesting, before we get into your own haggling, Andrew, and negotiating up to a hundred grand off a property. When we look at the data, there is this big, big spike across Auckland, Christchurch and Wellington in terms of people negotiating or a lot of properties selling about one to two percent under asking. So if we look at the people who are getting ten percent off asking, there's not many of them, but there are heaps that are kind of just slightly under asking. What's your take on that?
5:27 Speaker 01 Well, that makes me think that again, the bulk of the market is pricing their properties correctly when they put them to the market.
5:34 Speaker 00 Yeah, I think the other thing, probably my read on it, is that buyers want something.
5:38 Speaker 01 Yeah.
5:39 Speaker 00 So if you list it for a million bucks, you know a buyer's probably not gonna wanna pay a million bucks.
5:44 Speaker 01 Well, no one in a buyer's market pays the value price, right?
5:48 Speaker 00 But if you can get twenty grand off, that at least makes you feel, okay.
5:52 Speaker 01 I got a deal.
5:53 Speaker 00 I got a deal. I got them down. One other thing that's interesting is when we look at, if you're a really good negotiator, so let's say like the best twenty five percent negotiators, how much are they getting off? So not the average person, but you know, the, the top twenty five percent.
6:10 Speaker 01 Okay, let's say Chris Voss, who wrote, uh, what was the book called?
6:14 Speaker 00 Never Split the Difference.
6:15 Speaker 01 Never Split the Difference. It's coming in. He's a great negotiator. What's he gonna get off?
6:20 Speaker 00 Okay, so if we look at not the average person, but the top twenty five percent of negotiators. We're looking at about two and a half percent, just under two and a half percent in Christchurch. People are getting off about three percent in Wellington, but in Auckland, up to five percent off.
6:37 Speaker 01 Okay.
6:38 Speaker 00 So again, if you think about that million dollar property that's listed for a million bucks, you know, maybe you're getting fifty two grand off.
6:45 Speaker 01 Yeah, I mean, it's not, not here, it's still not, I know fifty two grand is a lot of money, but it's not insane, like, it's not like it's a thirty percent discount, right?
6:54 Speaker 00 Okay, okay. Well, well, put your money where your mouth is. Now you've got to say what you're able to do, because all of these numbers we've been talking about are kind of open market or negotiating something that is advertised on the market for sale. But I know that most of the stuff that you do is off market.
7:11 Speaker 01 Yes.
7:12 Speaker 00 So explain to us how that works.
7:13 Speaker 01 Okay, so the way that works is we're working with developers and so we go to a developer and say, okay, what kind of price are you thinking for this? What does it kind of look like? And then we'll look at not just what's on the market now, but what is there as far as a pipeline that's coming to the market next few while and then kind of use that to negotiate. Now, one of the big things that I think is really important at the moment is substantiating a value with an actual independent valuation. So usually that would be a step in a process that a real estate agent, a general real estate agent wouldn't do that, right? They're not going to say, okay, the person wants a million dollars. What does a valuer who's independent of this process say? Now, I do have to say, don't just think that because there's instances that we're talking about,
7:56 Speaker 01 a massive discount, like that, that is a ma- a hundred and sixteen thousand dollars is a huge discount of a property.
8:02 Speaker 00 So this is your highlight reel, not your average.
8:04 Speaker 01 Yeah, yeah, yeah, that is the highlight reel. But also just remember, value is what someone's willing to pay for it. So I do think that sometimes a valuer might say, okay, in a normal market, this would achieve this amount, but there are instances where developers or sellers at the moment are so desperate, they have to get sales to pay back their finance, that they're willing to do deals that maybe they wouldn't normally do. And that might just be a limited number of properties. For example, let's say a developer had ten million bucks that they had to pay back to a Development finance company. And the interest rate on that was like fifteen or twenty percent because they were in default of their terms, right?
8:44 Speaker 00 Yeah.
8:44 Speaker 01 What they might do is they might say, right, we just need to seriously discount this property that's worth eight fifty in a normal market, down to seven fifty, just to get some pre-sales.
8:55 Speaker 00 Okay, so you're saying that you are going to take advantage of these poor business people that are going through tough times and are being absolutely rinsed by the people who have lent them money just so that you can get some invested discount?
9:10 Speaker 01 Yeah.
9:10 Speaker 00 You greedy, you bad person, naughty nickel.
9:16 Speaker 01 Negotiating nickel.
9:18 Speaker 00 Okay, so effectively what we're talking about is in this example with the hundred and sixteen thousand dollar discount, you've identified some people who really need to get get properties moved. And it's important to kind of segue for a little bit and just say, one of the things that we've started doing in our company, Opes Partners, because we do so much off-market, like we don't help people buy properties on trade, we don't list properties on trade me, we help investors who come to us. And so what we've started doing is going out and getting a valuer to put a value on all of the properties before we recommend them to investors. So you actually know, well, what is this property worth? And we've probably been doing that for maybe three to six months.
9:53 Speaker 01 Yeah, maybe a little bit longer.
9:55 Speaker 00 And so what we then do is we push developers, most of the time, to sell those properties under valuation so that investors get a there a good deal.
10:03 Speaker 01 Well, I think the biggest thing in the market right now, like you said before, is people want to feel like they've got a deal, right? If you're buying today, you're still buying at a relatively high interest rate. You're going to be topping up the property if you're borrowing a hundred percent, if you're using the no cash needed method. You want to feel like you're getting something in return for that added level of risk that you're taking right now.
10:23 Speaker 00 And so I'll come back to the hundred thousand dollar haggle, because I really want to get some more details off that. But as you said before, that's the kind of extreme example. If we look at the median kind of discount that that we're getting at the moment, if the market is getting an average of about half a percent in Christchurch, our median's about three point six percent. So I know with one property, it's a Townhouse in Christchurch in a suburb called Waltham. The registered valuation is about six hundred and five K. The price that our investors are getting is twenty six thousand dollars or four point three percent under that, which is five hundred and seventy nine thousand dollars. That's the average. Now, they're not all three or four percent under valuation.
11:05 Speaker 00 Some have no discount at all, but about half of the properties have some discount between, you know, six grand and fifty one thousand dollars. Now, let's dig into the hundred grand haggle. So how did this actually work? Give us some details.
11:18 Speaker 01 Well, I think in this instance, it wasn't so much that the developer wanted to accept this deal, it's just that they didn't really have much of a choice. Because at the moment, projects coming up to settlement. Again, if you're a developer with development finance, it's not like a normal mortgage with the bank that you've got thirty years to pay back that loan. You've got to pay that back at completion of the development. Now, again, depending on the level of debts that you've got, might be able to refinance things out. So I know there are a lot of developers at the moment that are sitting on completed properties because they've just refinanced it to a more normal credit facility and they're just paying the interest, they're renting those properties out or Airbnb the properties out and then servicing that debt.
12:00 Speaker 01 But for most developers, you've got a level of debt that you have to repay once that development's complete. And if it's complete and you've gone beyond your terms, the interest rate kind of goes up like in some instances double. So it's better for you economically just to take a lower price and get that lending repaid as quickly as possible or run the risk of the finance company winding you up. So in this instance, it was a case of they desperately needed sales. The conversation with the developer and I was what price will get ten of these sold like that? And so I said, okay, well, I think that the fair market value is kind of around that eight hundred thousand. Make it seven fifty. Make them so good that it's hard to say no to that.
12:44 Speaker 00 Yeah, so that investor say, okay, I actually want that deal. How does that conversation go? Because surely they, they're like, okay, I'm going to take a hundred K bath on these properties.
12:53 Speaker 01 It's a long, slow process. So normally that. Over the course of a year because the developer wants to see the market recover and sell it at a more reasonable price for them. At this price, both the developer and the finance company are likely taking a hit on this. The finance company is probably not going to get all their money back and the developer is definitely not going to make a profit. They're going to make a loss, so they're going to lose some of that capital that they've put in originally. But that is the risk of being a developer, right? That's the hard side of being a developer. And so normally, this would not be a conversation that would happen at the start of the project, in the middle of the project. It's when it gets to the end of the project, when they've kind of got their back against the wall.
13:34 Speaker 01 And I don't want it to sound like, you know, you're taking advantage of a developer because, you know, we work in partnership with developers. And what it's come down to is, hey, this really has to be a no brainer deal for an investor to pick up today. If you make the deal too good to say no to, that's how you're going to get the sales. Now, what will happen is they will get the minimum number of deals done to then satisfy their lender to give them a bit more time. And then they'll reset the price and probably put it up fifty, a hundred grand.
14:05 Speaker 00 Okay, so that's kind of for off market new builds, but I also wanted to dig into existing properties. So we've kind of got the, the broad market data to say, okay, maybe the discounts aren't that big. Yeah, you've given us some examples in off market new build deals where the, the discounts might be four percent. Sometimes, yeah, in dollar terms up to over a hundred grand. I also wanted to talk to some really good negotiators or property coaches who are out there all the time saying, okay, what do you see? So I called up Steve Goody, he runs, I think Steve Goody Property Coaching or, is that what it's called? Let's, let's go with that. And I said, okay, well, what do you see? And he said, well, it's pretty hard to put an exact figure on it for you. But what it usually comes down to is what is the seller willing to accept?
14:50 Speaker 00 I, you know, how low mentally can they go? But also what can they accept? So for instance, if you're buying a property off a homeowner and let's say the fair market value, if they didn't really need to sell it quickly, is eight hundred K, well, if their mortgage is. Seven hundred K, they probably can't accept any lower than that, even if they would be willing to, because they still need to pay back the bank. I said, okay, come on though, Steve, give us some numbers, give us some numbers. He said, well, you know, quite frequently I'll see properties that are listed for eight hundred K. And then nobody buys it a couple of weeks later, all of a sudden they're advertised for seven hundred K. And so, you know, around that hundred K ballpark is what some people will see some of the time.
15:32 Speaker 00 Important to to remember, whenever you hear us or any other people talking about property, often there is a tendency to use that higher side of the deals, you know. So we didn't call this podcast, the title's not going to be, I haggled twenty five thousand dollars off a property.
15:49 Speaker 01 Three dollars off.
15:50 Speaker 00 You use the zero point four percent off, you know, it's the big deals, the best deals that tend to get the most attention.
15:57 Speaker 01 Yeah, and you've got to be really careful when entering a market where you are going to see a lot more property coaches, because the market is getting a bit more bubbly, you will start to see more of these extreme stories on Instagram. I had an investor the other day and they they said, oh, I saw that someone made a few hundred thousand dollars on a property flip or something like that, which I think is great when that happens. But I'm telling you now, that is the rare deal as opposed to the normal deal. But I think the other thing to remember is it really comes down to how motivated that seller is. Because the only way that you're going to get a significant discount is if someone really has their back against the wall. There was a developer in Wellington that I heard about who they were selling properties way under what I think would be a fair market value.
16:41 Speaker 01 And the reason for that, I found out later, was because the couple were going through a divorce. And again, they had no choice, they had to offload those properties, they had to separate everything out for relationship property. And so as a result, some people got some really good deals.
16:54 Speaker 00 But Andrew, the the thing is, it's not just other people who use those bigger numbers, like everybody does that. And so the important thing, whenever you're watching a YouTube video or listening to a podcast, is if you you hear about somebody who negotiated a hundred grand off a deal, you know, don't think that that's going to be easily replicable all of the time. Yeah, as I said before, the median on the market is is something like. Like a couple of percent. Even our median is like 4%. So it's not like 10% discounts are happening all of the time. It also depends on the time of the market. You know, if you're at a hot market, there aren't going to be any discount most of the time. You know, you're probably not going to be able to negotiate under value. So this can give you some idea, but it's not necessarily saying, well, this is the average experience when you invest in property.
17:40 Speaker 00 So that's how Andrew negotiated or haggled over a hundred K off a house. How much you can potentially negotiate off a house or a property when you're out in market? And how does that change between new builds and existing properties? Right, let's wrap it up there, but please don't forget to rate, review and subscribe to the podcast. Really does help us get the message out to more people.
18:04 Speaker 00 Thanks for listening to the Property Academy Podcast. I'm your host, Stephen Knight. And I'm Andrew Nichol. We're going to be back here tomorrow with even more daily strategies, tactics and insights to help you get the most out of the new selling property market. Until next time.
Previous "I make $100K+ a year on Airbnb (from just ONE property)"⎥Ep. 2033 Next Best apps to manage your money (Personal finance app comparison)⎥Ep. 2035 Page updated November 15, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated