Pod Insights The Property Academy Podcast "I Don't Know What To Do!" (Live Property Coaching)⎥Ep. 2061 About this episode In this episode, we are joined by Daniel for another Case Study Sunday. Daniel — a first-home buyer turned landlord — isn't sure what to do with a quirky property he picked up during a chaotic auction. You’ll hear:How he scored a property for $100k below asking (and why it almost fell apart)Whether he should pay $24,000 in council fees just to renovateAnd what live coaching revealed about whether he should sell, hold, or upgradeIf you’re ever unsure of your next move, getting expert advice can make all the difference. Talk to a qualified mortgage broker in NZ to make sure your next step actually moves you forward. For more from Opes Partners:Sign up for the weekly Private Property newsletterInstagramTikTok
Transcript 0:08 Speaker 00 Hello and welcome along to the Property Academy Podcast by Opes Partners. I'm your host, Seven Knight.
0:12 Speaker 01 And I'm Andrew Nicoll.
0:13 Speaker 00 And this is the show that helps Kiwi investors go from zero to five properties. So you can be financially free, even if you're wondering, oh, did we buy the right house? Now, stick around for the next 15 minutes because you're going to learn if this investor bought the wrong house. Should Danny, who's joining us, give the council over 24 grand just to get permission to do his renovation? And if he does do that, will he make any money? Now, Danny, thanks for joining us for Case Study Sunday. Where are you coming from in the country at the moment?
0:41 Speaker 02 Hey guys, happy to be here. I'm coming from Auckland, Auckland Central.
0:45 Speaker 00 Yeah, fantastic. Now, you and your wife bought this property that we're talking about today in 2021. You were first time home buyers. Tell us about some of those twists and turns of how you bought this property. It's a fascinating story.
0:57 Speaker 02 Yeah, it was basically during COVID and the peak of the market where everything was going to multi-oper or auctions. We'd been trying for a while, but it was just so hot, we basically couldn't get our hands on anything. Originally, we had a renovation type strategy, but the market made us sort of increase our budget and think outside the box a little. And we're currently staying in a large multi-unit rental and planning our wedding at the same time. So we just decided to try and get a home and income and take all our flatmates with us. And it worked perfectly after a few hurdles to jump over.
1:28 Speaker 00 Oh my God. So you're planning a wedding. You've got lots of people living with you and you decide, I know what I'll do. I'll make it a bit more complicated and buy a house.
1:37 Speaker 02 Yeah, basically. And lucky we got a big enough house.
1:40 Speaker 00 And so tell us about the property you ended up buying and the process you went in buying it.
1:45 Speaker 02 Yeah, so we found the property and then we're speaking to the agent and it originally sold at auction before Christmas. But the bidder ran away. So then it became on the market and an investor was currently had it under contract. So we put in a backup offer on him and on his building report, he actually found unconscented work. So he pulled out. I spoke to him and he kind of told me about what he found in the building report. And we found out that it had an unconscented oven and hole. So the advertised home and income was incorrect.
2:19 Speaker 01 Oh, so it was advertised as a home and income property, which means legally two different families could live in it. But actually, it turns out that the kitchen, I think it's in the downstairs in this case, actually didn't have have the proper consents from council.
2:34 Speaker 02 That was actually a bar in Rumpus area, but it's basically looks like a kitchen with an oven put in it.
2:39 Speaker 01 I would say there's a lot of houses that have been retrofit like that to be home and incomes and inverted commas. And aren't actually consented. So some investor comes along. This was this the person that pulled out after winning an auction? Or was this in the second?
2:54 Speaker 02 Um, no, a large family bought it at auction and basically ran away. And then it went to the market and the investor kind of swooped in because it had a rental appraisal, home income, all the right advertising. The numbers worked and then, yeah.
3:07 Speaker 01 So some, some investor comes along and thinks, okay, this is a great return on investment because look at all the cash flow. Look at the cash flow I'm going to get from this property. I'm going to pay X. I'm going to get all this rental income because I can rent it out as two separate units. And then finds out, well, it's not actually consented for that. So I'd have to rent it out as one house. And therefore it's not going to be as good a yield as I want. And so then you come in and decide to buy. One thing you said you spoke to the investor. How'd you get his details?
3:34 Speaker 02 Basically off the agent. He must have been investor he works with and he knew. And I ended up speaking to him and he just over the phone and yeah, he said it'd kind of be perfect for someone like myself who plans to live inside it. But it doesn't work for his numbers and his purpose.
3:48 Speaker 01 Interesting. Okay. And so you've owned this property for four-ish years now. What have you done with it so far?
3:53 Speaker 02 Well, we've done basic soundproofing at a low end level, just to reduce noise vibration and landscaping. But the main purpose of it was just the room by room rentals. So we've just, yeah, just rented out the room by room at max capacity. We're getting about nine hundred a week where they, while we're living downstairs in our two bedroom unit.
4:11 Speaker 01 Okay. So you live in the downstairs unit, you rent out the rest of the house for nine hundred dollars a week. What did you pay for it?
4:18 Speaker 02 We paid a million fifty thousand.
4:21 Speaker 01 A million and fifty. So you're getting quite a good return, given that you're also getting to live there, right?
4:27 Speaker 02 Yeah, exactly. And that was kind of the goal, I guess, to upfund the wedding and travelling lifestyle while we owned property.
4:34 Speaker 01 This is quite a ballsy or an outside the box type of purchase for a first time buyer. What made you decide to do that?
4:43 Speaker 02 I guess influence and I guess property training. I mean, we didn't exactly know what we're doing, but we thought we did at the time. And we just thought it'd be a wise investment based on the area. We love Avondale where the house is situated. So we just thought the area itself would help the sort of property.
5:01 Speaker 01 And just before we get into what you might do next, because I know we've got some questions around that. You mentioned that you'd gone through some training and I know you went through the property apprentice program. What was that like?
5:12 Speaker 02 Yeah, it was really good. We enjoyed it. We chose the program because of my skill set. I'm in the building industry. And we just, well, I especially wanted in-class learning. It just helps coming from building, I guess. I never done, you know, I wasn't a classroom person, but I just wanted that in-class learning with a kind of teacher, so to speak.
5:30 Speaker 01 One thing that I'm curious about, and I know listeners of the show will be, is what does it cost and what do you get for that?
5:36 Speaker 02 From memory, it's been a few years, I think, maybe around 10K. And you get lifetime, because I've contacted them recently as well. You could just pick their brain and ask questions and get advice and usually contacts within a kind of property apprentice. They kind of line you up with managers or people who you can leverage off as well and ask information.
5:57 Speaker 01 Often people think 10K is a lot of money because it is a lot of money, don't get me wrong. But when you're talking about a, you know, million dollar purchase here, if you can get some good advice and and save some costs in your renovations, then it pays for itself pretty quickly, right?
6:11 Speaker 02 Yeah, they did. I remember they did say that, you know, you'd make your money back on your first purchase. And we did for sure, being able to navigate a sales and purchase agreement with the right clauses and the confidence to, in a hot market especially, just not being scared, basically.
6:26 Speaker 01 Okay. And now you're thinking about spending quite a bit of money with the council to get this kitchen signed off. Talk to us about this process and what you're thinking.
6:34 Speaker 02 Yeah, we're planning a few renovations with bathrooms and I guess extractor fans and getting things to kind of healthy homes. But the main plan is to consent the kitchen, which we've started the process now. We, I work with an architect. Goes by the name of Sam from Moodle Architecture. We, I engaged him and we've had a pre-start meeting with the council already. Where basically that's when the development contributions were flagged, which I kind of thought would always be there, but I kind of hoped it wouldn't. I thought we could slide in and get away with it, but that was not the case.
7:08 Speaker 01 Yeah, the council seem to be pretty savvy with picking up the times that they can charge a development contribution. And for the listeners of the show, what are you actually paying for when you pay a development contribution?
7:18 Speaker 02 From my understanding, I was trying to, we're consenting it as one unit still, but based on the miserable meeting, they deemed it the possibility that it could be used as a separate dwelling. So basically it triggers development contributions. I was surprised at the amount. I was hoping, I guess because I'm a small fry, in a way that it wouldn't be that much, but yeah, I guess I think it's the type of situation where it's two-story living. That is more expensive from speaking to the architect.
7:47 Speaker 01 So essentially the council are saying, right, there is going to be an increased load on our infrastructure now because there's potentially more people going to live in this property. So you're going to pay as if you're putting another unit on the back of your property, which you're not, but you are potentially increasing the load. Although in saying that, it sounds like for all intents and purposes, you're, you're already operating the property in the way that you want to operate in the future. You're now just doing it in a consented way, in a legal way.
8:15 Speaker 02 Yeah, that's right.
8:16 Speaker 01 And I guess the big question for me is then, okay, well, if you spend that $24,000 plus the renovation money, what's the property going to be worth in the future? After you've done this work, how much is going to improve the value? And then are you going to get any more rent or are you going to be able to get any more rent by doing that?
8:34 Speaker 02 Yeah, I guess that's a question I'm not too sure of until, um, basically when we do the renovations. I think that we will trigger a new updated GV from the council because of the development contributions. Then we'll get a registered valuation and a rental appraisal and cross our fingers basically and see whatever.
8:51 Speaker 01 Well, as, as much as I'm all for hoping for the best, when it comes to spending my money, I want to know what the outcome's going to be. So it's fine that you don't have the numbers today, but here. Is the process that I would go through if I were going to look at spending twenty four thousand dollars or anything on a renovation project. I'd start by saying, okay, I need to get an expert in to tell me what the value is today. And the value is after these changes. So you do that through a registered valuer. So you get a registered valuer to come out and they will do a before and after shop. So you give them all your plans and tell them exactly what you're planning to do with the property. And they might say, right, today, that property is worth, let's just say, one point one million dollars. Cause there's been a little uplift since you bought the property.
9:35 Speaker 01 So one point one million dollars today, you plan on spending twenty four thousand dollars on development contributions. And let's say all the other renovations you're going to cost brings it up to another two hundred thousand dollars worth of spending. Okay, now what I would want to know is, does the valuer think it would be reasonable? That that property is worth at least one point three million dollars, being the one point one million dollars it's worth today. Plus the two hundred thousand that you're going to spend. Now I say at least because as an investor, I want to get a return on my money. Now you are living there as well. So you might say, well, I'm happy so long as I don't over capitalize. I don't end up spending two hundred thousand and only getting a hundred thousand dollars worth of value increase.
10:20 Speaker 01 But if it comes in that the valuer says, well, after you spend that money, it could be worth one point five million dollars. And then you'd get a rental appraisal, which might say, okay, and then we think if we could legally. Rent these two properties out as two separate dwellings, one at nine hundred thousand, one at six hundred thousand. So we've got a combined income of one thousand five hundred dollars per week. Then you do your numbers based on that. So you punch all of those numbers into a spreadsheet or Opus Plus. And you look at what the return on investment looks like. And then I would say, is there a better use of that money? So if I took the two hundred thousand that I was going to spend. And I just went out and bought a different property and used that as a deposit. Would I get a better return on investment? And again, because there's a personal use to this property.
11:05 Speaker 01 You might say, well, yes, there is, but this is what I want. I get that. But if you're just. Looking at what the right financial decision is, I wanna know what I'm gonna spend and what I'm gonna get out first of all. And then is there a better alternative?
11:20 Speaker 00 And I should just say, some of you guys would have picked up, Andrew said if you rented out for six hundred thousand, nine hundred thousand, obviously he meant six hundred bucks or nine hundred bucks a week. But that's just a little thing to ignore, you know, a little blip, the rest of it was gold. Now, you just threw a lot of stuff at Danny here.
11:34 Speaker 01 Oh, sorry.
11:35 Speaker 00 Danny, what are you taking? That's okay, that's your job. Danny, what are you taking away from what Andrew just said?
11:40 Speaker 02 It's good. Actually, I did reach out to a registered valuer because we haven't actually quite pulled the trigger on the project. I think we got a quote, was it fifteen hundred or thirteen hundred? And I just haven't quite, I don't know whether to part with that money and get that valuation or put it towards the kitchen, so to speak. So it's good to hear that that was the right option to go down that path.
12:01 Speaker 00 Out of interest, because it's good to hear that, hey, look, you also talked to property apprentice because you spent the money. So, you know, you can get good advice out of them. What kind of things were they saying to you in terms of whether you go ahead with this renovation or not? Just to get a sense of the different perspectives that are out there.
12:16 Speaker 02 Basically, when I spoke to them, we didn't quite plan to sell the property, so it was mainly just renting. And they basically gave me the contacts of a member who's can give me a rental appraisal based on having the oven consented or having it there and not having it there and seeing if the rent is actually worth justifying the renovation, so to speak. Yeah, that was the advice given. I just haven't quite followed up on that.
12:42 Speaker 01 One thing that I'm curious about is if you buy a property and then you use it outside of what it's consented for, potentially your insurance isn't worth the paper it's written on. So what I mean by that is if you're using an uncon consented stove and the house burns down, or even if it's something that's not related to that oven, right? Say you accidentally flood it, there is a good possibility that your insurance company says, hey, you didn't have insurance or true insurance because it's not consented for that, we're not gonna pay that claim. Have you had any conversations with anyone about that?
13:17 Speaker 02 Yeah, so basically when we bought the property, that's exactly what happened. The valuation flagged up the uncon consented oven and basically we couldn't get any insurance. We tried a insurance broker and all avenues to kind of keep costs down and he, yeah, it was deemed too high risk. We had to get permission to. Remove the oven and hob from the vendor, basically, and they agreed, but under conditions of no price reduction, that if we don't go unconditional, we have to restore it. And yeah, it was a definitely insurance became a big factor at that point.
13:50 Speaker 01 Yeah, it's a really interesting thing. And because again, I've seen lots of instances, particularly with older properties where they've been repurposed or rooms have been repurposed and people think, oh, this is all well and good. It works for our family unit, not realising there's some pretty extreme ramifications if you use something illegally. And, you know, you might think, well, it's not, not the end of the world. I can use my house how I want to. Yeah, you can. But if something goes wrong, your insurance company will not pay you if you've been using a property illegally.
14:20 Speaker 00 So in your mind, what is Danny's next step in terms of figuring out what to do next? Cause you're thinking, A, should I do the renovation? But are you also thinking, once I do that, should I sell this property? Is that what's in your plan, Danny?
14:33 Speaker 02 Um, I'm guessing the renovation in my mind would have ticked two boxes in terms of being able to rent it and being able to sell it. So I was kind of leaning towards that avenue, basically of ticking two boxes. Cause we do have a toddler at home now, a one, one and a half year old. So our situation and I guess our strategy's changed. So we're looking to move on, I guess in one way or another.
14:53 Speaker 00 And let's say that you do this renovation, you sell the property, what would you do with the money? Just before I flick it back to Andrew to give his thoughts on next steps. What would you, if you sell the property, what would you do with the money?
15:03 Speaker 02 It's a bit odd ideas, I guess, especially here in your podcast on rentvesters and kind of invest the money and rent a more suitable family home, I guess is what we're leaning towards.
15:14 Speaker 00 Okay, that's interesting. That's what, I was kind of like, okay, cause there are two options. Basically what you said is, okay, one is we buy a really nice family home for you because maybe you're like, that's what I really want now that I'm growing a family. Or the other option of course would be to rent vest or try and do some combination of it. So there's a lot under here. What's your view, Andrew, of what Danny's next steps could be?
15:34 Speaker 01 So I think the biggest thing, Danny, is just get some real certainty, as much certainty as you can, because it's everyone's educated guess, but more certainty around the cost and the return, then you'd Way up. Okay. Well, let's figure out, is this worth doing first of all? I suspect it is, is my guess. So then you go through that process of getting the consent, doing the work, having the property fit for purpose and being used in a legitimate way. Then you'd, once you've done all that, you'd probably talk to a real estate agent and see what their take is of the market right then and there. And hopefully this takes enough time to complete the project that, you know, the market in Auckland's got a bit more bubbly at that stage and you can get a bit more of a premium than you can today. Then you decide, okay, well, I'll sell this property. And when you find out exactly how
16:19 Speaker 01 much money you've got in the bank, that's when you decide on your next steps. Are we going to become rent vesters or are we going to become owner occupiers again? If you're owner occupiers, you'd put all of that cash into your property to have it the smallest mortgage as possible. Then you'd leverage against that to buy other investments, if that's what you want to do.
16:36 Speaker 00 Really important to say as well that this is a podcast episode, yes, not what we would call personalised financial advice. Personalised financial advice is where one of you guys sitting at home sits down with a financial advisor, you fill out all of this information, the advisor comes up with a big old plan and you go through a big process. And so I always just want to make sure that everybody understands that when we're talking with somebody like Danny here on the podcast today, where he's actually here, or whether it's somebody's situation, these are general ideas about what you could do, not Andrew sitting here saying, this is what my formal financial advice is for you to go and do these sorts of things. Just want to clear that up as well, Danny. And if we think about your next steps, what have you got in your mind? What do you take away from this conversation?
17:21 Speaker 02 Definitely to get more certainty around the renovations. Um, I guess being a builder, I kind of just naturally lean towards renovating, but yeah, definitely actually going with what I started and engaging the valuation side and the rental appraisal and just getting certainty about what I'm doing.
17:36 Speaker 01 And also remember to price in your time. One of the things that I see that builders do all the time is they say, oh, well, I can do this renovation for cheap, which is true, but that takes your time away from your job or your family. And so you've always got to factor in the cost to you as well.
17:52 Speaker 00 And over the last 15 minutes, you've learnt if this investor bought the wrong house, should he spend over 24 grand with the council just to get permission to do his renovation? And if he does, will he make any money? Right, let's wrap it up there, but please don't forget to rate, review and subscribe to the podcast. Really does help us get the message out to more people.
18:16 Speaker 00 Thanks for listening to the Property Academy Podcast. I'm your host, Tim McKnight and I'm Andrew Nicoll. We're going to be back here tomorrow with even more daily strategies, tactics and insights to help you get the most out of the new property market. Until next time.
Previous The dark side of property developers EXPOSED (This should be illegal)⎥Ep. 2060 Next Should I Buy A House In 2025 Or Wait Until 2026?⎥Ep. 2062 Page updated November 15, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated