Pod Insights The Property Academy Podcast How to stop bleeding cashflow on your properties [Case Study]⎥Ep. 2042 About this episode In this episode, we discuss how to stop the cashflow bleeding on your investment properties — and what to do if you think you’ve made a mistake. You’ll hear:The #1 thing to do if your investment is underperforming•How to tell if it’s time to pivot your strategy or hold the courseA real-life case study of an investor who is trying to turn things around. If you’re feeling the financial pinch, this episode is your guide to making smarter, more profitable decisions. You'll also hear when it's time to talk to a financial adviser in NZ. For more from Opes Partners:Sign up for the weekly Private Property newsletterInstagramTikTok
Transcript 0:08 Speaker 00 Hello and welcome along to the Property Academy Podcast by Upus Partners. I'm your host, Seven Knight.
0:11 Speaker 01 And I'm Andrew Nichol.
0:12 Speaker 00 And on the show, we're talking about should I change my property investment strategy? That includes how to stop bleeding cash flow on your properties, the number one thing you need to do if you think you've made an investment mistake, and how to tell if it is time to cut your current investment strategy and move to something else to try and make more money. And I'll tell you the reason why we're talking about this. I was on a plane the other day going from Christchurch to Walkland. And I was like this, I'm sitting next to a guy and he goes, Ed. Yes, yes, hello. And he goes, yeah, I listen to your podcast. I'm like, great, he's great.
0:45 Speaker 01 You're sitting next to him.
0:46 Speaker 00 Yeah, so I'm in like 5B and he's in 5C. I hate the middle seat.
0:52 Speaker 01 How do you end up in a middle seat?
0:53 Speaker 00 Because I changed the time of my flight on the same day.
0:56 Speaker 01 You forgot to change the seat.
0:57 Speaker 00 No, it's because the flight was so full, there were only middle seats left. Now, the interesting thing, I mean, gosh.
1:04 Speaker 01 I would have just taken the later flight.
1:05 Speaker 00 Just to, oh no, it's because as, as most people know, I'm somewhat recently engaged.
1:11 Speaker 01 You're nesting.
1:12 Speaker 00 So I try and get home at a good time so that I can see my fiance before we fall asleep 30 minutes later. Anyway, so it's quite, I'll paint a picture for you. So I'm sitting there at 5B, he's in 5C. This poor lady in 5A has got a two-year-old screaming, climbing all over her. And she was like, I'm so sorry about this. I'm like, don't feel sorry for me, I feel sorry for you. She's like, yes, I've got two older kids and none of them were like this. I was like, oh gosh. So anyway, so I'll paint this picture for you. She's there with the kid in 5A. I've got this lovely listener of the show, you know, we're trying to talk about his numbers, which we'll talk about today in 5C. And then you've got the Air New Zealand announcements about put on your seat belt and the thing.
1:55 Speaker 00 And I'm like, oh gosh, I should have taken that later flight. But as I was talking to this nice guy, he was kind of saying, look, I think that I might need to change my property strategy. So here's the situation, he's about 57 years old now. And he's tried property in the past, but he only really got back into it in 2019. So quite recently. And over that time, he's bought four properties. He did work with a property investment company, didn't work with us, worked with one of our competitors, which is totally okay. That competitor is no longer operating. And so that's why he's, you know, got some questions about his strategy now and saying, look, I've, I've had some business ventures in the past.
2:38 Speaker 00 We sold the company right at the start of COVID, so I didn't get the price I wanted. Maybe, you know, not all of these business ventures have worked out. But I'm now in a business that I'm really happy with. It's going very, very well. I earn a good income, but I've got six properties in total. One's my own home that's got a big mortgage on it. And then because of the current high interest rates, you know, my investment properties, all four or five of them, I think one might be a holiday home, are pretty heavily negatively geared. So should I start renovating or should I sell some of these properties in order to improve my cash flow? And so what I kind of said to him was, we'll talk about it on the podcast. And I think he had come and seen one of our financial advisors at one time in the past.
3:22 Speaker 00 And so obviously the good news is we've got all of his financial information. We're obviously not going to share the details, but that means we can have a decent, you know, conversation around it. So Andrew, before we get into the cash flow side, which he was obviously quite worried about, how have these properties gone for him over the last four to five years?
3:40 Speaker 01 So they've gone quite well. So he's made kind of around 400K over the last four or five years. Now, one of them in particular has gone the other way and it's lost 125,000 since the peak. So I guess once you have a big drop like that, you can kind of start to think, oh God, and, and then panic and throw the baby out with the bath. Well, no, I do see that a lot with people, particularly if you're invested, as you should, across the country, the markets go up at different times and come down at different times.
4:10 Speaker 00 Yeah. So he's got one in Auckland, that's like a, a high yield property. We've got two growth properties in Hamilton and one growth property in Rolleston. And three of them have made money in terms of, you know, they're currently valued 50 grand, 110 grand and 230 grand above what he paid for them. Of course, we've got this other one that's lost 125K. The good news is that he is up, so that seems to be working quite well. But what about the cash flow?
4:38 Speaker 01 Now, this is kind of the most important thing because while it's all well and good to say, okay, well, property tends to go up over time. And if you hold it for the next 20 years or for 10 years or 15 years, whatever, you're probably gonna do all right. If you can't afford to hold on to it for the long term, that's when it becomes a problem. So look at the cash flow. We don't have all the numbers, but from what we can kind of piece together, we've got about $3 million of investment properties with 2.5 of debt. Now, we did what we would recommend any person do and go and put all this into Opes Plus to get a real understanding of what the cash flow looks like now, but also into the future. And we're kind of thinking that based on high interest rates he's probably on at the moment, he's probably contributing about
5:18 Speaker 01 a thousand dollars a week against those four properties. Now, that's probably not actually that uncommon at the moment if people have got a significant amount of debt. Now, this hasn't taken until Cat's holiday home or his own or occupied property, but you know, a thousand dollars a week for four properties, that's probably not uncommon.
5:36 Speaker 00 It depends on the interest rates he's set at. I've kind of assumed that he's, because I don't have all the details of it, but I've said, well, maybe you're still on 7% or some of them are on a little bit lower. But once he refixes, I'd expect that to drop quite significantly. That'll probably half to, you know, maybe $500 a week, depending on the number specifically put in. But I think the first step, and this is one of the things I said to him, I was like, have you put your numbers in Opes Plus? He said, no. I was like, that is your first step to do. And just for anybody who doesn't know what that is, we used to give away this return on investment spreadsheet where you could put all your numbers in and it would tell you roughly what the cash flow of your properties is and how that would change over time. The issue with that, it was far too complicated. And while me and a couple of real numbers dudes loved it, I don't think
6:19 Speaker 00 it really hit the mark or gave all of the investors what they need. And, you know, people say to me, I can only put three properties in. I've got 12 properties. How do I do that and see what my overall portfolio cash flow is? So we scrapped the spreadsheet. We built a kind of online web app where you can sign up for free, put in your details and it gives you all of the good stuff from the return on investment spreadsheet, but much, much more simply. So this is kind of my new holy grail of how to forecast your cash flow or see what your property investment Cash flow is in New Zealand. You can sign up for free. By the way, I'll put the link down in the show notes. Or if you go to opespartners.co.nz and look for Opes Plus, you'll be able to sign up for free. But this would kind of be the first step is loading your properties in. So you could kind of see where you are.
7:02 Speaker 00 And if you are bleeding this year because you're on higher interest rates, hopefully this gives you a little bit of comfort when you see those top ups going down. Once we get into, you know, next year or the year after that. Now, one thing that's really important to mention as well, though, Andrew, is that obviously today, we're not giving financial advice. We're certainly not personalised financial advice. That's where we actually say, mate, sitting next to me on the plane, I recommend you do this. Because this is just a podcast. We're talking generally about us numbers, but we don't have all of them. But what are some things that we might do to get the cash flow up?
7:41 Speaker 01 One thing I think that's really important is making sure that you're getting the appropriate level of rent. So if you can get those rents up, that's going to make a difference to that cash flow. So having a look at the properties again, one property's got in Rollison. It looks pretty low compared to what I would consider normal. So I, I think that you could kind of get all those properties up to kind of around that four and a half percent yield mark at the moment, because Auckland, Hamilton, Christchurch, have all seen reasonable increases in rents over the last four years. And that's just based on what I'm kind of seeing people rent properties for right now. So yes, I know that the rental market is a bit softer. But again, there's been this big upswing of rents. So I think maybe he might be a bit under rented.
8:22 Speaker 00 Yeah. One thing I like to do, just as a bit of a test, is take the current value. And I always like to get it out of QV because I think QV is the most accurate. Look at the rent per week and just calculate the, the yield, the gross yield based on your current rent and the current value of your property. So for one of his properties, it's sitting at 3.9%. That feels low to me. Typically, we're seeing properties rent for around four and a half, 4.3%. So that just gives you a sense of, am I a little bit under rented? Of course, you need to go away, do some due diligence, jump on Trademe or real estate.co.nz, see what similar properties you actually are renting for. But that's Kind of the first thing I'd look at. So, or that's the second thing after I load it up into Opus Plus. The second thing I would, I want to get your opinion on Andrew, is what about clearing some debt?
9:06 Speaker 00 Because he does have quite a lot of debt, both against his own home. Like, I think it's into the seven figures from the numbers that I have. But he's also got a lot of investment debt. So one thing he might consider is, well, should I sell one of these properties that I bought recently? And even if I take a little haircut or make a bit of a loss, at least I can save money on the cash flow by bringing my overall debt down. What's your view on that?
9:32 Speaker 01 I think that realistically, okay, if you sold, you know, the one that's gone up the most, which actually is the one that most commonly people think about selling. So I've got a client that I work with at the moment who basically said the same thing to me, oh, that one's gone up so much, should I sell it, pay down some debt and then I can keep the the lesser performing ones a little bit longer. I think the downside of this is, okay, now you've gone from having four assets that are, you know, potentially going to fund your retirement to three. And so it does make a big difference over the long term. So whilst I think that is a good short term solution, if you're really, really desperate, I don't know that that would be the thing that I'd be first recommending.
10:09 Speaker 00 One other thing, we were just talking off air though, was break fees. So one option that I'll kind of outline then get your take on is let's say that he's paying a lot of debt and maybe it's even his home loan, which is, you know, quite large. Let's say he's paying seven percent on that at the moment. If he breaks and refixes, he might be able to get that down to closer to five percent and that would save, you know, twenty grand plus a year in interest. Now, of course, he would have to pay a break fee. But if he put that into the mortgage, then he could smooth that out and his cash flow would improve. What do you think about that?
10:45 Speaker 01 Yeah, that, that is a solution. It's kind of, that would be a lever that I would pull before I sold off assets because I'm not one for selling assets quickly. I think it'd be really, really good to hold on to them and if it fixes your cash flow, yes, you're going to end up paying more interest because you've added a break fee onto your loan. But you go to a lower interest rate today, so it brings down your cash flow. That's probably a good alternative option.
11:10 Speaker 00 And one thing I I would say is looking at the the properties he's got. Obviously, he worked with one of our competitors, but even though I I don't think these were necessarily the most ideal properties that could have been bought at the time. I still think it's probably better to hold them rather than to flick them off.
11:30 Speaker 01 Yeah.
11:30 Speaker 00 You know, and I think even though, you know, this is not our client, it's still important to, you know, help all New Zealanders think through their options in terms of what do they do with their properties? Just on break fees, though, uh, that's not the ideal situation because if you pay a break fee, chuck it into your loan and then pay it down slowly over time. That could lead to paying more interest, so it might not be the ideal situation. But it's just a lever that some people might not think of when they're thinking about how do I improve my cash flow right now? What about downsizing? So he's got quite a valuable property in a very nice suburb in Auckland. And one option would be to say, okay, I'm gonna sell that and I'm gonna pay down some debt and downsize a bit. What do you think about that?
12:13 Speaker 01 Yeah, he could do that. The downside with selling in Auckland right now is it's a terrible time to sell. But obviously, buying and selling in the same market, then you get the advantage of that when you go out to buy something cheaper for yourself. I would probably say he'd be better off downsizing later on when he gets closer to retirement so that he can end up with a property that will be ideal for him in retirement without having any debt, I would I would hope because his property will continue to go up, his mortgage will continue to go down.
12:39 Speaker 00 Yeah, that's what he did say as well. The other thing that I'd just mentioned is he's got some kids who are at high school. So I can understand that from a personal point of view, you probably don't wanna do that when you've got kids.
12:50 Speaker 01 Disruptive.
12:51 Speaker 00 Especially if you've got a nice home, you've probably like upgraded to this so that, you know, you can have a nice family home, you probably don't wanna take that sacrifice right now. If you know that your business is also going well and you don't have to do that.
13:04 Speaker 01 Yeah, again, it's, I mean, I guess this episode's about exploring different things that he could try. It's probably not the thing that I would recommend unless he absolutely had to.
13:15 Speaker 00 Okay. And then that kind of leads us to the question that he was actually asking is, well, should I start renovating properties? So should I follow a burst strategy where I, I buy some existing properties, I do them up, I cash flow hack them so that I get some positive cash flow and that can offset some of the costs of the rest of my portfolio?
13:37 Speaker 01 A lot of investors that I've been talking to in the last wee while when I'm just doing annual reviews with them have asked about high yielding properties. I should have just bought a high yielding property and that'll pay for the losses that I'm making on the other properties at the moment because the cash flow is so terrible. And generally speaking, even if you put in a property with a high yield, it's losing money as well. If you're using the no cash needed method. And I think that would probably be true if you went and bought a property, did a renovation project, you're probably unlikely to make enough money to actually make any kind of meaningful dent on that cash flow.
14:08 Speaker 00 Well, what do you mean by meaningful dent? Because I know that some investors do renovate properties and those properties might be cash flow positive.
14:15 Speaker 01 How much cash flow? Like a hundred dollars a week on a thousand dollars and it might take him six months to do it. Is it really worth it? And that's if everything goes well, or even if it's $200 a week, his contributions are going to go down by half, just with the interest rates being refixed in the next wee while by our calculation. And then maybe getting that rent up, you might be down to a third just by two things that are going to happen by default.
14:37 Speaker 00 Yeah. So you might need to do, for example, two renovations, you know, buy, renovate, hold and assuming they go quite well, you'd probably need two of those to make the portfolio neutrally geared. I guess the main thing you need to weigh up is given that you're very excited about the business that you're running and the potential for that, given that you are the, the main person running that, if you decide to renovate more, does that take your eye off the real ball? Because, you know, we're talking about here, how do we make an extra? If we're talking about, you know, four or $500 a week, once interest rates come down, we're talking about 10 to 25 grand a year. Now, that is actually a significant amount of money. Like,
15:19 Speaker 00 that is a lot of money, right? And so one option to make up that shortfall is Is to say, I am going to do two renovations or three renovations and I'm going to spend money buying these properties and I'm going to spend money doing them up so that I can get that extra $500 a week. That's one option. The other option is to say, to be honest, I'm more excited about my business opportunity at the moment. And given the industry he's in, if he gets one more client, that could possibly just cover that shortfall.
15:51 Speaker 01 Yeah.
15:51 Speaker 00 And so sometimes the answer isn't, okay, sweet. I've bought these properties. Some of them have performed well. One of them has not. Interest rates went up faster than expected. Rather than saying, I need to fix this property problem with property in this specific situation, I think fixing the property problem with with his business interests might actually be the simplest solution.
16:13 Speaker 01 Yeah. And I do think when you have everything loaded into Opus Plus and you've got some interest rate, some realistic interest rate forecasts in there, people seeing the light at the end of the tunnel tend to make a bit more of a, a, a, a wiser decision just to kind of stay that course that little bit longer. Like we are at kind of the end of these horrible high interest rates and people are coming off fixed rates and rarely noticing a difference now. Suddenly the, again, the reviews that I'm doing with customers who have, who have invested in pretty turbulent times are now say, oh, okay, now we can see our way clear to holding these properties for the long term again. And, and if you can see that in a physical graph, then that's going to make it a lot easier.
16:55 Speaker 00 A physical graph versus digital.
16:57 Speaker 01 So you know what I mean.
16:59 Speaker 00 I know exactly what you mean. So over the last 15 minutes, we've talked about, you know, what do you do to stop letting cash flow on your properties? The number one thing you need to do if you think you've made that investment mistake, which is get it all on Opus Plus. And also how to tell if it's time to cut your investment strategy to move to something that might make more money. Right, let's wrap it up there, but please don't forget to rate, review and subscribe to the podcast. Really does help us get the message out to more people.
17:29 Speaker 00 Thanks for listening to the Property Academy Podcast. I'm your host, Stephen Knight.
17:32 Speaker 01 And I'm Adrian McCall.
17:32 Speaker 00 We're going to be back here tomorrow with even more daily strategies, tactics and insights to help you get the most of news on the property market. Until next time.
Previous How Trump's tariffs could LOWER your mortgage rates⎥Ep. 2041 Next Foreign buyers: The housing market's last hope? ⎥Ep. 2043 Page updated November 15, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated