Pod Insights The Property Academy Podcast How to make your Property Manager increase your rent⎥Ep. 2004 About this episode In this episode, we discuss how to make your property manager increase your rent. This comes after a listener of the show emailed in ... talking about how her property manager hadn't increased the rent of any of her properties over the last 4 years. We go through the Right Rent system, The Cashflow Keep Up strategy, and how to get the data so you can have a good conversation with your property manager. That way you'll be able to really see if you can raise the rent. For more from Opes Partners:Sign up for the weekly Private Property newsletterInstagramTikTok
Transcript 0:08 Speaker 00 Hello and welcome along to the Property Academy Podcast by Ipsos Partners. I'm your host, Seb McNight.
0:11 Speaker 01 And I'm Andrew Nicoll.
0:12 Speaker 00 And today on the show, we're talking about how do I get my property manager to increase the rent? Now, this comes from a listener of the show, one of you guys who have emailed in. And over the next 15 minutes, you're going to learn, can you and should you put up the rent for your property? How do you deal with your property manager to actually get them to listen to you? And what to do if it all goes tits up? Now, I had a message in from Caitlin who said, look, we've got a property manager and we've got four investment properties. We own them as a group and we've had them for four years. Now, here's the interesting thing. This property manager came really highly recommended. Lots of people I know use them, but not once have they increased the rent for any of the properties over the last four years.
0:57 Speaker 00 And look, Ed, every year I ask them about, can we get an increase in the rent? And they say, just leave it as is because of the market. But I'm seeing news stories about rents increasing. So what do I do? Should I push the property manager? How do I have this conversation with them? Because there's a lot of maintenance with some of these properties. Now, Andrew, have you ever been in this position where the property manager just doesn't want to raise the rent?
1:23 Speaker 01 I think personally, one of the things that I struggled with when I was starting out as an investor is I always worked on everything as a per room basis. Because I didn't know anything about property investment, so I thought I was an expert. So what I would do is I'd say, okay, well, it was, the standard was $80 a room. And so for a five bedroom house, what's that, $400? I'd say, I should get $400 because it's $80 a room. Now, if you rented them out room by room, sure, you'd get $80 a room. But realistically, the market rent was probably more like $300 because you're renting it as a house. And so I'd always be pushing for the per room basis. I remember property managers saying, if you want to do it that way, you will end up with degenerate tenants. And I did. But I've had clients all the time that have said this kind of thing like, hey, we really
2:07 Speaker 01 want to put up our rents because we're feeling the pinch at the moment. Interest rates are higher than we were expecting, but the property manager is saying we can't do it.
2:15 Speaker 00 Well, there's a bit of a difference there because just because your maintenance costs have gone up or your interest rate has gone up or whatever it happens, that doesn't mean that the market rent for the property has gone up because the rents are decided by what tenants are willing to pay and what landlords are willing to accept, not what any of our personal costs are. So for instance, if I have a massive maintenance bill because I've got to replace my roof, that doesn't mean that I can just increase the rent or that the tenant should have to pay for it. That's my cost. The market rent is decided by, well, how motivated are tenants and how motivated are landlords? But I understand where Caitlin's coming from because I don't know where these properties are in the country, but if you're talking about the last four years, today, the median
2:59 Speaker 00 rent in New Zealand is $600 a week. Four years ago, the median rent was $490 a week. So certainly over the last four years that you've owned these properties, the median rent across the whole country has gone up 22% or $110 per week. So when you send me an email like that, that makes me think, yeah, I think that there probably should be some rent increase there unless you're in a part of the country where the market genuinely hasn't moved. But on average, the market has moved. Now, usually when we talk about this, we kind of dig into the data to see how big of an increase you can get, and we certainly will in a second. I want to cut to the part with the conversation with the property manager. So why might the property manager be pushing back?
3:44 Speaker 01 So I think there's a couple of things. And number one is maybe they just think that the rent is actually where the market is determining that rent at the moment and there's not actually any room to move. That's one part of it. So they might say, right, at the moment, there are other properties available which are the same sort of price. And so, yeah, you could ask for more and yes, they might accept it, but they might not either because all it would take is the tenant to jump on Trade Me and say, well, actually, that's not a fair market rent because the one next door is renting for $20 less and the one down the street's renting for the same money. Remember, even as a landlord, if you have a tenant and agree to a rental increase, and then it's determined that that's above market rate, you can actually be pulled back down to market rent. The other thing is, at the moment, in certain areas like Auckland, for example, there are a lot of options available for tenants.
4:30 Speaker 01 And what you don't want to have happen is you ask for another $10 a week, $500 a year, say, or $20 a week, $1,000 a year. And your tenant says, you know what, I'm actually going to look around. Then they find something for similar money, or maybe even a bit more money, but it's a nicer property. They decide to move to that. Now, all of a sudden, it might take you six weeks to find another tenant in some instances. Okay, well, six weeks, let's say your rent is $500 a week. You've completely wiped out any potential gains you're going to make from that $20 a week increase.
5:00 Speaker 00 Yeah, sometimes not having a tenant for a couple of weeks loses you more money than keeping your rent a little bit lower than what you might think it'd be. Any other reasons they sometimes push back?
5:12 Speaker 01 Sometimes the property manager might just be being lazy. But I don't think that that's a very common occurrence. I think that genuinely most property managers want to get the best deal for the tenant, but also the owner.
5:23 Speaker 00 The main thing, coming back to a property manager believing that the current rent is the market rent. To me, I'd be wanting to see some evidence of that then. If that is genuinely true, how are you justifying that? So when I think about having this conversation with the property manager, I think you've got to go in armed. You've got to know what the market rent really is. And it's very easy to figure this out. The first thing I talk about is what we call the right rent system. We talk about this in our book, Wealth Plan, which is where you go in to Trademe. You find your suburb with what's currently online, and you look at those properties that are currently listed, and you kind of compare them to your own property. So if your property is a two-bedroom, one-bathroom place, and it's currently renting for $500 a week,
6:06 Speaker 00 and there is a two-bedroom, two-bathroom listed, so a property with an extra bathroom listed on Trademe, for $50 more than what you're currently advertising, you're like, okay, well, I should be under whatever the better properties are renting for, and my rent should be higher than what the bad properties. Renting form, he could kind of go through that process and we've done some podcasts and YouTube videos about how you use the right rent system to kind of figure out where you sit in the market. And then the piece of feedback that I sometimes get when I talk about the right rent system is people say, well, that's all very well and good, but in the specific suburb that my property is in, Ed, there aren't that many properties available for rent. You know, there's not that many listed
6:47 Speaker 00 online, so I can't really do that process. That's where I often recommend going on to the MyRent website, MyRent. They have maps and data available where they actually show you what properties have rented for, because MyRent is like an app where people can self manage their properties and they get some of that data and release a little bit of it. So if you're in one of those suburbs where you're like, oh, there's not that many properties online on Trade Me, at least you can kind of justify it that way. But the first step would be to say, well, what do you think the market rent is? And how do you justify that? What's your evidence? And then you can have that conversation with them. Now, let's say that this investor Caitlin does this. She's got the information. How do you have that conversation with the property manager?
7:29 Speaker 01 Well, I wouldn't go in and just blind sub my property manager by just calling them up and saying, well, this is the information that I've got. I'd actually give them time to consider the information, but also do their own research. So I'd probably send them an email in advance and say, hey, this is kind of what I'm thinking. I really think the market rent is $20 a week higher. This is kind of the evidence around that. I provide some other listings or some other data to show that actually other properties have been achieving that kind of level and then ask for their feedback. And that way they can give a considered response to you. But also, the one thing you don't want to do is come across like a jerk. You don't want to come across like you're telling them how to do their job because they are the professional. They do this day in, day out and they benefit from
8:10 Speaker 01 getting the rent going up as well because they take a percentage of the rent. So it is financially in their best interest to get a higher rent for you as well. So just bear that in mind when you are drafting them an email so that you don't piss anyone off.
8:25 Speaker 00 But does it surprise you that the rent hasn't gone up in four years?
8:28 Speaker 01 To be honest, I do find that property managers can be a little bit reactive as a as a general whole. So I thi- I think that quite often if a tenant is not causing any grief and there hasn't been a major market shift, then they tend to just renew the rent.
8:44 Speaker 00 Yeah, because my view is kind of like, I understand the idea that, oh, but but property managers generally are trying to look after tenants and landlords. And, you know, that's true, but that doesn't mean that everyone, like, all professionals are always acting optimally, right? Or acting a hundred percent in the best interest of the landlord. So I think, you know, four years is a long time. If that was me, I'd be on trade meet looking through what are things renting for? I'd be on my rent looking at what are things renting for to try and figure out what is the market rent? How far below am I? I'd probably be looking at tenancy services, where you might go on to our website and use area analyzer to see how far have rents gone up in the suburb or in my city
9:25 Speaker 00 over the last four years. Because whichever index you look at, whether you look at Stats NZ data or the tenancy services data, rents have gone up in most places over the last four years. I'd be very interested to know which suburb this is in, if rents haven't gone up, because we know that incomes have certainly risen over the last four years. They've been pushed up along with inflation. So I'd be very surprised if it was completely flat.
9:46 Speaker 01 I think one of the key things to remember as a as a property investor is a certain period of time doesn't guarantee you any increases in rent or in prices, but four years is a relatively long period of time. So that's when you at least want to be proactive in your reviewing of the rent.
10:02 Speaker 00 I I've been wondering, does it complicate things that she's been buying in a group? Because you might be managing these properties by a committee. So let's say you, me and two other people are buying a property. I, and it would be me, because I get a bit in my bonnet about things.
10:15 Speaker 01 Oh, you want to raise the rents, don't you?
10:16 Speaker 00 You know, so I say, hey, I've been on the trade meet.
10:18 Speaker 01 Yeah.
10:19 Speaker 00 And I think it could go up. And then the other three people are like, oh, I don't know. Does that complicate it at all in your mind?
10:25 Speaker 01 I I don't think much. The one thing about buying in a group is you're sharing the wins and the losses. So if you get a $20 a week increase, which is quite a big increase, that only really benefits your $5 a week. So maybe it's, you know, it softens the increase. But it also softens the blows because if you don't have an increase, well, or it goes back $20 a week. Well, it only affects me $5 a week.
10:45 Speaker 00 And look, we're not saying that you need to rinse your tenants for all they're worth and just try and.
10:50 Speaker 01 God, we're gonna have Reddit comments again.
10:52 Speaker 00 You're talking about the time where.
10:54 Speaker 01 Parasite, I got called a parasite.
10:55 Speaker 00 Yeah, well, they're just a very good judge of character. But we do call this idea of increasing your rent in line with the market. We call it the cash flow keeper. Because what tends to happen is your costs will go up over time. The market rent tends to increase over time, though sometimes the rents go up a bit, sometimes they go down a bit. But on the whole, on average, they do go up over time. And in order to make sure that your properties are generating the cash flow that you probably want them to. It's important to keep that rent increasing because that's your revenue coming into your property investment business. So to keep that cash flow up, you've got to keep reviewing that rent. But what happens to that kind of tits up scenario where, can I say that on the show? I know we're family friendly.
11:36 Speaker 01 I think so.
11:37 Speaker 00 You think that's okay? So what happens if your tenant freaks out then? When your property manager sends that letter saying, hey, the rent's going up?
11:45 Speaker 01 Well, the tenant can do two things. Number one, they can take you to the tenancy tribunal, as I mentioned before. So if you increase the rent and even if they accept that and then think, actually, I'm being taken advantage of here. This isn't fair market rent. They can apply to the tenancy tribunal for you to adjust your rent back down to a reasonable level. Now, don't get me wrong, that doesn't mean that in three months' time, they can say, oh, well, I found one $10 cheaper. And so I want $10 off. I remember reading a case where someone had challenged the rent, but the adjudicator did say, actually, well, everyone's agreed on this. And it's within coe of what market rent is. So suck it up, princess.
12:23 Speaker 00 Knowing the tenancy tribunal, they'd never be that blunt.
12:27 Speaker 01 No, but you know, like they said, you have accepted that. But then similarly, like there are people who have maybe price gouged when there's been a big shortage after an event like the floods in Auckland or the Christchurch earthquakes. And the tenancy tribunal have come down on landlords for charging what is not a fair market rent.
12:43 Speaker 00 The important thing to mention as well is you've said a couple of times and your tenant accepts it. Your tenant does. Doesn't have to accept it, right? You send your letter saying the rent's going up in a roughly two months' time. And they can, of course, push back and say, hey, would you accept less? But if you say no, well, that's what the rent's going up to, unless they decide to go to the tenancy tribunal. It's not like you or your property manager writes a letter to the tenant saying, hey, would it be okay if we put the rent up? Tick yes, tick no. It's the rent's going up. Of course, the tenant can choose to come back and say, oh, well, I'm not too sure about that. I don't think that's the market rent. The tenant can choose to go to the tenancy tribunal, but it's not that they have to say, yes, I agree to that increase.
13:26 Speaker 01 Or they can vote with their feet, they can leave. And that, of course, is that risk that we're talking about before about vacancy. And, you know, if you're talking about a $10 a week increase and your rent is $500 a week, well, it only takes one week of vacancy to completely wipe out what you would have made in the extra $10 a week rent increase.
13:44 Speaker 00 Yeah, but let's say that you're massively under rented at the moment. Let's say your property's renting for 500 bucks a week, and you think the market rent is $600 a week because you've really let it get away from you over the last four years. Well, if you were able to get that extra 100 bucks a week, that's an extra $5,200 a year coming into your property investment business. So that's about 10 weeks of your current rent, right? Now, if your tenant moves out, as long as you can find a tenant within 10 weeks, you're ahead of where you otherwise would be. And on top of that, they've still got to give three weeks' notice anyway. So if that was me in that situation, I'd take the punt, risk the vacancy personally, because I'd say, well,
14:25 Speaker 00 it's quite a substantial increase. So Caitlin, you'll have a feeling about where you and your business partners sit and how much you want to increase the rent. But I think the first thing is to find out what the market rent is. And I would not feel bad about having a robust conversation with your property manager to get that rent up. And if not, you can always try another property manager as well. So, over the last 15 minutes, we've talked about can you and should you put up the rent? How do you deal with your property manager to get them to listen to you? And what do you do if your tenant calls it quits? Right, let's wrap it up there. But please don't forget to rate, review and subscribe to the podcast. Really does help us get the message out to more people.
15:07 Speaker 00 Thanks for listening to the Property Can It Be podcast, I'm your host Steve Atknight.
15:10 Speaker 01 And I'm Andrew Rickle.
15:11 Speaker 00 We're going to be back here tomorrow with even more daily strategies, tactics and insights to help you get the most after you sell on property market. Until next time.
Previous $60,000 to remove this from your property: The nightmare you need to avoid⎥Ep. 2003 Next "We have money dates" – How this couple manages their money⎥Ep. 2005 Page updated November 15, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated