Pod Insights The Property Academy Podcast How much should property management cost? (Hidden Fees EXPOSED)⎥Ep. 2063 About this episode In this episode, we discuss what property managers should really charge — and the hidden fees that could be quietly draining your rental income. You’ll learn:What a “normal” property management fee actually includesThe sneaky charges many landlords get stung withAnd how to spot when your manager is overcharging for basic servicesWant to know if you’re paying too much? Here’s the breakdown of property management costs in NZ and how to compare what you’re being charged. For more from Opes Partners:Sign up for the weekly Private Property newsletterInstagramTikTok
Transcript 0:08 Speaker 00 Hello and welcome along to the Property Academy Podcast by Opes Partners. I'm your host, Stuart Knight. And I'm Andrew Nichol. And this was the show that helps key investors go from zero to five properties. So you could be financially free, even when you think your property manager's ripping you off. Now, over the next 15 minutes, you're going to learn how much property management should cost you, the time that Andrew had a property manager steal from him and the hidden costs that property managers sometimes sting you with. Now, Andrew, we recently got an email from a listener of the show who was pretty pissed off.
0:37 Speaker 01 Yeah, and the reason for that is because they've been charged a lot more than what they were expecting and they were really surprised about that. Now, just to give you some context, property managers normally charge like a percentage of the rent. So it can kind of range from kind of six to 10%, but let's just call it 8% plus GST. Now, on top of that, this particular person is paying admin fees, they're paying a premium on top of any contractor's invoice. If the plumber goes out and it's a hundred dollars, they might be paying five dollars on top of that for the property manager to facilitate that.
1:09 Speaker 00 Yeah, the property manager marks up the invoices and then flicks them on.
1:13 Speaker 01 Inspection fees, general advertising fees and letting fees. So she rightly thought, okay, 8%, that's pretty straightforward. I can put that into my spreadsheet. I know exactly how much I'm going to be getting after the property manager's fee. And then all of a sudden, all these extra deductions keep coming out of the rent every month.
1:31 Speaker 00 And so I've kind of been thinking, well, what's normal for the industry? And I think there are three types of fees that you typically get charged. Now, just keep in mind, as you're listening to this, Andrew, I actually own a property management company with our other business partner, but we'll try and keep this real unbiased, but just keep in mind and call us out if you think, oh, they're just pushing themselves too much. So the first thing pretty much everyone charges is some sort of management fee. Now, that's a percentage of the rent collected. So that's typically, I mean, you said six to 10%. I thought seven and a half to eight and a half percent plus GST seems to be kind of the average, but you're seeing some quite low?
2:08 Speaker 01 Yeah, well, I've definitely seen six percent. Centres particularly in like a really competitive spot like Auckland.
2:13 Speaker 00 Okay, that's interesting. You typically also get a tenant sourcing fee. So a couple of years ago, it used to be that the tenant actually paid that. It was called a letting fee. Which actually, when you think about it, was so bad.
2:24 Speaker 01 I know. I, I, I was just thinking about this the other night. I, I don't know why. And I was thinking, it's so funny that a tenant who's coming to rent a property, they're applying, they're saying, yes, I'd like to live here. Now I've got to pay a whole big fee just for the privilege of living here?
2:41 Speaker 00 Yeah.
2:41 Speaker 01 Ridiculous.
2:42 Speaker 00 Through the property manager, it was quite ridiculous, isn't it, when you look back? Now, that's usually one week's rent plus GST. And pretty much everyone I've seen charges those, those first two fees. The management fee, the tenant sourcing fee, that's real standard.
2:54 Speaker 01 And the tenant sourcing fee, one thing to remember about that is even though we normally recommend your budget for it as an annual cost, it might not be something you pay every year because if your tenant stays for three years, you only pay it once in those three years.
3:07 Speaker 00 But then you sometimes get these additional charges and not everyone.
3:11 Speaker 01 Add-ons.
3:11 Speaker 00 Yeah, not even, well, they're charged as add-ons, but they're not really add-ons in terms of the service you expect of a property manager. I mean, I get real grumpy about these, but you know.
3:22 Speaker 01 You get grumpy about most things.
3:23 Speaker 00 But some property managers will charge you forty to a hundred bucks for a routine inspection. Maintenance surcharges, so chucking five or 10% on top of the maintenance invoice. I mean, what do you think about this, Andrew? I personally think that's real unethical because I just think that's what you're paying them for in that percentage of rent. And if we think about a routine inspection, that is not optional. Like you have to have that every three months for your insurance. So paying extra for that, to me, that leaves a real bad taste in my mouth.
3:51 Speaker 01 It kind of makes me ask, well, what's my eight percent for? What, what am I getting for that eight percent? Is that just collecting the rent and paying it on to me? Which is a computer system that does that.
4:00 Speaker 00 Yeah, I, I mean, some others charge for tenant checks. So as part of getting them in, oh, if you want me to do a credit check on the tenant, that's going to cost you twenty five dollars. But then again, I think, well, isn't that what's in the tenant sourcing fees? You know, these annual account or admin fees, maybe some debt collection charges. This is another one that it doesn't. Doesn't sit right with me, tenancy tribunal charges. So if your tenant goes rogue, you're gonna pay, I've seen kind of a hundred to two hundred dollars for the property manager to represent you at the tenancy tribunal. And so, I mean, not everyone charges these, right? Yeah, no. But, but it's kind of what the industry calls the plus plus model, which is basically we charge you for managing your property and then we add these extra charges on.
4:44 Speaker 00 Personally, it doesn't sit right with me because I think, well, that's what I'm paying you the money for. Do you know, that, that was one of the number one things that I found frustrating when I had lots of different properties with different property managers? And when I started Opus and Opus Property Management, that was the one thing I want, just want to have a, a, a set percentage fee. Like, I understand that it's mostly done as a percentage, but I wanted a fixed fee. That was one of the big frustrations that I had. I know other property investors did as well. And even I remember our accountants being like, you know how you guys could make more money through your property management company? Just start charging for these extras. I mean, that's what they do. And I'm like, no, I don't think that's right. Anyway, this isn't bad us. But if, if you add up some of those extras,
5:27 Speaker 00 it does start to add up. So let's say that you've got a property, it rents for five hundred bucks a week. If you're paying eight percent plus GST and we count for the fact that your property is not going to be full, you know, a hundred percent of the year, you're probably paying your property manager about two thousand, three hundred bucks a year, like just as a standard in that management fee. But if then you're also paying, you know, forty five dollars plus GST per inspection. And again, those aren't optional. That's an extra two hundred and eight bucks per year. Let's say you spend five hundred bucks on a plumber. I've spent well over five hundred bucks with plumbers recently. And they add on five percent plus GST. Well, that's the extra twenty nine dollars clip that they're clipping the ticket on there.
6:08 Speaker 00 And let's say that they're charging you at twenty five dollars plus GST for a credit check as well. That's another twenty nine bucks. So add up some of those costs. It could be an extra two hundred and sixty six dollars a year that you're having to pay to your property manager. And you know, they might say it's eight percent plus GST, but once you factor in the tax and those extra costs, it can end up over ten percent of the rent that you collected. And especially if your property is negatively geared while interest rates are kind of high, like let's say you fix it at quite a high interest rate. If your property is negatively geared, you're the one like paying that out of your own pocket. But if we take a step back, Andrew, and kind of look at the property management industry or the companies out there. I kind of think that property managers fall into three distinct tiers.
6:49 Speaker 01 So I think the cheapies first of all, so you have kind of six percenters and actually in that tier of kind of the cheaper options. There are kind of a subcategory of more DIYers. And so there are different companies that offer different levels of input. And in the past, there have been other, other companies, basically places like WeRent, for example. They do a flat fee, it's a hundred and eleven dollars per month. And then they just charge an inspection fee on top of that. And we spoke to Mike Stenveld, who's the founder of WeRent, and their company ethos is they want to give property investors a low cost option. And the way they do that is they make sure that their property managers or the people helping them out, they all work from home.
7:30 Speaker 01 So rather than have big flashy offices in the centre of Auckland, they just get their people to work from home and keep the cost down. And now they can pass those savings on to property investors.
7:39 Speaker 00 It was quite funny when we were talking to him, he said, look, we're not going to call you up and hold your hand and tell you everything happening in your property every week. If you want that, go somewhere else effectively. So it's kind of, hey, this is a low price. And so, you know, there are going to be some trade offs, I guess, in terms of them being able to deliver that low price, which I kind of appreciate. Hey, another one that seems to have gone off the radar entirely is Kit, because they came out with a hissy of raw. Couple of years ago, offering like property management starting from ten dollars a week.
8:09 Speaker 01 Yeah, they were gonna, I, I remember meeting the owner, Alex, or the founder, Alex. And he was going to change the industry because it was, it was wrong, property managers were charging too much. He was going to go on this low cost model and they rolled it out and lo and behold, there's no money in it. And so as a result of their ten dollars a week, I think it was, the property investors who were using those services just found it a bit complicated. Because it was ten dollars, but actually you got their software for that for managing your cash flow, but you had to. Get someone else to do an inspection or you had to do it yourself. And all of a sudden, this thing that was meant to be a passive investment wasn't very passive.
8:47 Speaker 00 Well, the other thing that's real interesting, and this isn't to rip into them too much. But when I looked at their Google reviews recently, it was like a 2.7 stars out of five. A lot of people saying, oh, I paid this onboarding fee and then I ended up moving somewhere else. And I never got any service out of them. So I do think that for a business to make cheap property management work, typically they've got to load up their property managers. I'm talking about Kit here rather than WeRent to such an extent that maybe you, that you don't typically get that kind of level of service that you want. I mean, remind me that story of the missing property manager.
9:21 Speaker 01 I always love a story where I get ripped off. So this was when I went with one of the really cheap options. So I remember I was referred onto this property manager in Christchurch. I can't remember his name. It'll come back to me at like three in the morning tonight. And he was a bit rough around the edges, but the person that referred him to me was a very renowned property investor. And I think he might've even been in jail at one stage, or at least he'd been done for like fraud or something like that, right?
9:48 Speaker 00 How did **** get to know this guy?
9:51 Speaker 01 I don't know, but she's infamous for giving people a second chance or a third chance, more so than me now. She's such a nice lady. And anyway, I got put onto this guy and he was, it was just a bit of a smooth talker. Like he would have been great in car sales or something like that. Sorry for any of you car salespeople out there. And I remember I just, my tenants were falling behind in the rent and I, and it was always a story. Are they going to catch up and this is going to happen? And then I was just getting more and more frustrated with the lack of money hitting my bank account and, you know, excess charges. I drove over to his office, which was ironically enough in the jailhouse accommodation precinct in Addington. Anyway, I go there and he's gone.
10:35 Speaker 01 He's packed up and left and he's taken my rent, he's taken other people's rent and he'd taken the bond. He never loaded the tenant's bond, so that was something I had to wear, I think in the end.
10:45 Speaker 00 Now, that's not to say that every cheaper property manager is going to do that. But it's a, it's a story that always sticks in my head. Now, the next tier, after we get out of the cheapies, kind of the middle tier are bigger companies that have more processes and they charge a bit more. Yeah, this is typically that seven and a half to eight and a half percent plus GST. And some of them might have that kind of plus plus model. So it opens property management where seven point nine nine percent plus GST, plus your tenant sourcing fee. APM, which used to be called Auckland Property Management, but they've shorted it to APM now. They've kind of got two main options. I think it's seven and a half percent or eight and a half percent. If you want like a rental guarantee in there. Property Scouts, that kind of seven and a half to eight and a half percent.
11:28 Speaker 00 Though every franchise charges differently and sets their pricing differently. I think Barford and Thompson, eight and a half percent plus GST or nine and a half percent if it's furnished. Like they're all kind of around that. And some of them will have the plus plus model and some of them, them won't. The main thing to say here is that because they're bigger companies, you'd expect them to have more robust processes. Yeah, in terms of if the tenant is late paying their rent, what is their process around that? We call it phone, email, phone. You know, if the tenant's late, you phone them, you email them, you phone them again.
12:03 Speaker 01 All in the same three minutes.
12:06 Speaker 00 Not in the same three minutes, but there, there should be processes around this. The property managers shouldn't have so many properties within their portfolio that they're managing. Kind of a hundred and ten, a hundred and twenty is pretty normal so that they can actually give you some service because it's real interesting. When I see people complain about property managers, often it's because they're not getting emailed back and getting, getting good service.
12:29 Speaker 01 It's the comps.
12:30 Speaker 00 Yeah, and feeling like they're being talked to. I suppose the other one is feeling that your property manager's on your side and that they're working for you. But then we kind of move up a tier and then we've kind of got more specialist property managers.
12:42 Speaker 01 Yeah, so a great example of this is my friend Hayley in Queensland who's House Smart. So Queensland is such a unique market and as a result does tend to have a bit, a few more of these specialist ones. So House Smart, for example, their fees are at the premium end. Their base fee is 10% plus GST, inspection fee. Are fifty dollars plus GST. But one thing that they've got that I really like, particularly for Queenstown, because the rents can be such a high weekly amount. Like, if you think about like, a house there you might rent for two thousand dollars a week, right? If you paid a leasing fee of two thousand dollars plus GST, that's a lot of money. They actually have a flat leasing fee, so they say, well, it's gonna cost us the same amount to screen a tenant, whether or not it's a two thousand dollar a week house or a five hundred dollar a week house.
13:25 Speaker 01 So they just charge a flat letting fee of five fifty plus GST, which makes sense in my mind. And one thing I would say about Howsmart is you're getting what you pay for. Like, you genuinely are getting a company with robust systems, but just they are gonna deliver that really, really good service. Hayley's been like in the industry forever. And another type of specialist property management would probably be the Airbnbs. Now, they charge a lot more, and often that's between fifteen and twenty percent, because that is a lot more handholding than a normal property manager. You're far more active.
13:57 Speaker 00 And I guess in my mind, for most people, that mid-tier is probably appropriate, where it's not the most expensive, probably appropriate, where you've got a company you can kind of, kind of trust, because they've got some more processes in there. But the big thing to look at is if they're using that plus plus model where lots of things are added on. Now, some of you will be comfortable with that and be like, actually, I quite, I quite like that. Others of you will be like, nah, I'm not really that interested. What I do think is very important is that every property manager, in my view, should have their pricing on their website. And I'll tell you the reason why, because then I think, well, if you don't wanna tell me it, what are you hiding? Is it that you are adding on all of these fees? And I think it's very important that investors are able to compare different companies and say,
14:41 Speaker 00 well, this is what the price is, so I know what I'm getting myself into. And I, I always hate it when you go on a property manager's website and they've got like a get in touch button or something like that.
14:51 Speaker 01 But, but without pricing, you mean?
14:52 Speaker 00 Yeah, because I mean, well, yes, you're like, you need some way to get in touch with them if you wanna use them. But I hate getting in touch for pricing and then you call them up and they're a bit cagey about what their pricing is.
15:02 Speaker 01 It's almost like, okay, well, the pricing is whatever we can charge you. And if you've been to some other people, then it might be less.
15:10 Speaker 00 Exactly. The last thing this listener messaged in is, well, what if I were to make a complaint about my property manager? Is there someone I can go to?
15:18 Speaker 01 Yeah, this is a hard one and definitely a bone of contention in the industry. So with financial advisors, for example, because Opes Partners, we are one. If you've got a complaint, there is a set process, same with the mortgage team, same with real estate, right? There's processes and there's regulatory bodies that monitor what people do and the advice people give and how they operate. With property managers, there kind of isn't anything and that makes it really, really tough. Now, having said that, in New Zealand, we have certain laws that would protect you. So you might, if it was pretty extreme, go to the Commerce Commission and make a complaint and say, hey, I think I've been ripped off by this property manager for misleading advertising or something like that. But the Commerce Commission, that is a pretty heavy-handed approach.
16:03 Speaker 01 There's not a set process there like with the FMA or the REA. So there probably needs to be some change around regulations. So probably the best thing you can do, in all honesty, is if you're not happy with your property manager, just change. And actually, we did a podcast recently, episode 2046, about breaking up with your property manager. The best way that I would complain about my property manager is I'd just go somewhere else.
16:27 Speaker 00 So over the last 15 minutes, you've learnt how much property management should cost, the time Andrew had a property manager steal from him, and some of those hidden costs that property managers sometimes sting you with. Right, let's wrap it up there, but please don't forget to rate, review and subscribe to the podcast. Really does help us get the message out to more people.
16:50 Speaker 00 Thanks for listening to the Property Academy Podcast. I'm your host, Stephen Knight.
16:53 Speaker 01 And I'm Andrew Nicoll.
16:54 Speaker 00 We're going to be back here tomorrow with even more daily strategies, tactics and insights to help you get the most out of the selling property market. Until next time.
Previous Should I Buy A House In 2025 Or Wait Until 2026?⎥Ep. 2062 Next Airbnb vs Mid-Term Rentals vs Long-Term Rentals: The TRUTH⎥Ep. 2064 Page updated November 15, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated