Pod Insights The Property Academy Podcast How much can tenants damage a house … and still get their bond back?⎥Ep. 2081 About this episode In this episode, we discuss what actually counts as “fair wear and tear” — and how much damage a tenant can do before they’re forced to pay. You’ll learn:When landlords can legally take money from the bond to cover repairsWhat the Tenancy Tribunal considers “normal” damage (vs neglect or intent)And the wild case where one tenant had to pay $4,500 — just in insurance excessesWant peace of mind that your property is being looked after? Learn how property management in NZ can help protect your investment. Register to try Opes+ out for yourself, it's free for everyone to use. For more from Opes Partners:Sign up for the weekly Private Property newsletterInstagramTikTok
Transcript 0:08 Speaker 00 Hello and welcome along to the Property Academy Podcast by Opes Partners. I'm your host, David Knight.
0:12 Speaker 01 And I'm Andrew Nicoll.
0:13 Speaker 00 And this is a show that helps keep us go from zero to five investment properties. So you can be financially free even when your tenant damages the property. Now, stick around for the next 15 minutes because you're going to learn when you can take money out of the tenant's bond to fix up issues that have left in your house. What damage you as the landlord actually have to pay for? And what counts is this, and this is a very important term, what counts as fear, wear and tear? Now, this is one of the most misunderstood concepts in all of property investment. So you walk into your rental property after your tenants have moved out and there's a mark on the wall or the carpet's a bit scuffed, maybe the stove's looking a bit, little bit worse for wear.
0:55 Speaker 00 And you think, hold on, the tenant should be paying for this, but do they actually have to? And this actually happens, right?
1:04 Speaker 01 Yeah, we've been talking to our property management team a lot about this recently because they've got the best stories. Like property managers always have the best stories because they're in people's lives.
1:12 Speaker 00 And by best, we mean like-
1:14 Speaker 01 Most interesting.
1:15 Speaker 00 Yeah, most interesting.
1:17 Speaker 01 Better work stories. And they gave me an example last year where the tenants were in a property for about seven months and when they left, the place was covered in scuffs and dents, like not just here and there, it was everywhere. And way more than you would expect than just normal wear and tear throughout the course of seven months.
1:36 Speaker 00 And I want to come back to that example to see who had to pay. But even before we get there, this brings up quite an important question actually of, is it fair wear and tear?
1:47 Speaker 01 Yeah. So if it is fair wear and tear-
1:49 Speaker 00 We're going to say that a lot in this episode, eh?
1:52 Speaker 01 If you're doing this at night or after 12pm, drink every time we say fear, wear and tear.
1:57 Speaker 00 Oh, you're up to six drinks already.
1:59 Speaker 01 And the reason this is important is because if it is fear, wear and tear, then that's on you as the landlord to pay for it. If it's careless or intentional damage, then the tenant pays for it. And so obviously when you think about any kind of investment, you want to know who's paying for what. And it doesn't really matter what you or the tenant thinks, what the phrase means, because the tenancy tribunal, they're the people that decide this kind of stuff. And if you end up having a dispute with your tenants, you'll end up with a tenancy tribunal and they will decide.
2:26 Speaker 00 And the important thing here is that politicians have written that phrase, FWT, fear, wear and tear.
2:33 Speaker 01 Hang on, let me get a drink.
2:35 Speaker 00 They've written that into the Residential's Tenancies Act, but they don't actually define what that is. So this is determined or defined by what's called case law, which is that landlords and tenants get into a dispute. They go to the tenancy tribunal and by looking at the specifics of each case, over time, we find out what that phrase means by all of the various decisions that the tribunal adjudicators have come up with. So when the tenancy tribunal is deciding what counts as FWT or not, that phrase, what are some of the things they're going to look at?
3:12 Speaker 01 Okay, so I'll give you some examples. So imagine there's a small dent or a mark on a wall behind a couch. Now that might be the result of the couch just rubbing against the wall. I don't know why someone's moving that couch so much, but anyway, it's probably not a biggie. That's just fear, wear and tear.
3:26 Speaker 00 Oh.
3:27 Speaker 01 Hang on. Okay. Whereas if you've got a hole that's been punched in a wall in a hallway, well, that's intentional damage, right? That's not fear, wear and tear. But like, take another example where you've got a high traffic part of the house, like a stairwell or a hallway or something like that. If the carpet's worn out, then the tribunal are probably going to say, yep, that's a place where people walk all the time. It's fear, wear and tear.
3:51 Speaker 00 So the first thing they're going to look at is like, where is the damage? If it is a high traffic part of the house, then it's more likely they're going to call it fear. Now, the tribunal also is going to take into a Count the tenant's views. So let's say you've got a house and there's two stories to the house and that when the tenants moved in, they needed to get a mattress up the stairs. Well, that might take a bit of maneuvering. So if some painters scraped off the wall.
4:16 Speaker 01 If there's a mark because you've rubbed the wall with your mattress on the way past.
4:21 Speaker 00 Yeah, those kinds of things. Then if the tenant says, yeah, but the house or the stairs were too narrow to get a mattress up there and I needed to get a mattress up there, then the tribunal is more likely to say, well, that's fair because how else were they going to get their stuff in? Of course it's going to cause a mark or something along those lines. What else are they going to be looking at?
4:43 Speaker 01 I think one of the big things is, you know, the age of the property and actually the condition before. Like if you've got an older property and everything's a bit worn out and then something breaks, it's probably just fair wear and tear. If you've got a brand new property that's immaculate and all of a sudden there's a broken benchtop, it's not fair wear and tear.
5:00 Speaker 00 But it also depends how long the tenant's been in there. So if they've been in there for seven months versus seven years, there's going to be way more things that will wear out over seven years. So you could expect some of that. That's a cost of doing business. And then I think the other one is if there's damage to an appliance, what's that appliance actually worth? So sometimes a tenant will damage an appliance and let's call it a dishwasher. But even though that dishwasher is banged up and you have to pay to replace it as a landlord, the tenant might not have to pay anything, even though they actually broke it and it actually was their fault. And the reason is that dishwashers and appliances, they typically
5:42 Speaker 00 only last for about between six and seven years. And so what the tenancy tribunal will look at is the book value of that dishwasher. So let's say you've had a dishwasher in there for 10 years and then the tenant beats the hell out of it, you know, doesn't use it the way it should be, but breaks it. Well, that dishwasher has no book value, right? From an accounting perspective, that dishwasher has been fully depreciated. So even though it's going to cost you to replace, the tenant might not have to give you any money for it because that dishwasher wasn't worth anything to begin with. So the tribunal doesn't take into account what's called betterment. So the tenant doesn't owe you a new dishwasher
6:26 Speaker 00 because that dishwasher wasn't worth anything. You couldn't sell it and get any money to begin with. Actually, I was having a drink with Tiffany, who's in our Auckland team just the other day, and she was telling me about this thing called the $2 rule. And it's kind of the industry standard way of figuring out who's responsible for the damage. And the way it works is if there's a mark on the wall and it's smaller than a $2 coin, most property managers would say, well, it's not damage, it's just wear and tear. It's the landlord's responsibility if we want to get that fixed. But if it's larger than a $2 coin, or there are lots of marks, then generally speaking, that's the tenant's responsibility. How many people, what percentage of people listening to the show do you think just held up their thumb and their finger trying to figure out how big is a $2 coin?
7:11 Speaker 00 In my head, as I was saying that, I was thinking, I haven't seen a $2 coin in a while, I wonder how big it is. Yeah, but you said- It's about that. Oh, I think, no, no, no, it's smaller than that. That? Yeah, that's about right. But it's so funny how automatically you're like, okay, let's just, let's put my thumb and finger together and see how big it is. It's like whenever somebody says something's 10 centimetres, I use my thumb and my finger and I'm like, how big is that? I don't think that's 10 centimetres. Do you think I'm overestimating or underestimating?
7:41 Speaker 00 So let's come back to that case we talked about at the start of the show where the tenant was in there for seven months and there were heaps of scuffs and dents. So what actually happened there? So they actually had an insurance adjuster come in and they came in and said, okay, well, the, the property needs to be repainted, the dishwasher's dented, there are scratches on the front door and the ranch slider's a bit damaged. And I know that in this case, the tenant tried to come back and remember, the tenancy tribunal take into account whatever the tenant's opinions are. Now, the tenant tried to say, well, I don't want to pay for the damage. So with the ranch slider that was damaged, they said, well, that was broken into, somebody tried to break into the ranch slider, that's what caused the damage to it. Great, give me the police report.
8:26 Speaker 00 But then what the property managers did was they went and looked at all the photos and they said, but the damage is only on the inside of the door, there's no damage to the outside of the door. So it's pretty obvious, this wasn't somebody trying to break in because it happened from the inside. So your story's not adding up. Two and two ain't making four, Steve. So that's not fair wear and tear and the tenants actually ended up having to pay. But this is where the story gets very, very interesting.
8:54 Speaker 01 Yeah, the landlord, they've got insurance, right? So they make a claim and the tenant has to pay the landlord's excess. And then, of course, the insurance company pay cover the rest of the bills. Now, in this case, the excess was five hundred dollars. And so you'd be right in thinking, okay, well, the tenant just pays five hundred dollars to the landlord. Case closed, right?
9:14 Speaker 00 And then they they go and claim on the insurance. It all gets paid, all done within within a couple of weeks.
9:20 Speaker 01 Yeah, now that wasn't what happened. Now, because the insurance adjuster said the whole property needed a repaint. The excess is normally per incident. So they counted it per room. So they said, okay, the kitchen, five hundred dollar excess. The lounge, five hundred dollar excess. Hallway, five hundred dollar excess. All up, it would have to be nine different excesses, so four and a half grand.
9:44 Speaker 00 And this is actually very important. So rather than the tenant owing the landlord five hundred dollars, they actually owed four and a half thousand dollars. And what's important about this is, as you can probably guess, the tenant didn't have four and a half grand lying around. And so what actually happened is the landlord's got to pay the four and a half grand out of their own pocket. And then the tenant owes them that amount of money, right? But how likely is it they're going to be able to get that?
10:11 Speaker 01 Slum to none.
10:12 Speaker 00 It's going to be paid off at five to ten dollars a week for the next nine to eighteen years. So there's a good takeaway here, which I didn't really understand until a property manager told me this story, which is sometimes as landlords, we want to pay less in terms of our house insurance premium. How much we pay each month to the insurance company? And when we do that, we accept that there's going to be a slightly larger excess. But sometimes you don't want to do that, right? Because if you're going to have to claim on your insurance and sure, your tenant's going to pay your excess. And as a landlord, that can make sense in your head because you're like, well, if I've got a claim on my insurance, maybe the tenant's going to pay me for that.
10:53 Speaker 00 But if your excess is two grand and there are a couple of instances, are you actually ever going to see that money from your tenant? The answer may be no. And it's not that I want to scare you too much because this this only impacts a small. Minority of tenants, right?
11:06 Speaker 01 That's very rare.
11:07 Speaker 00 And of course, the reason we're telling you the story is it's a good story. And it's a good story because it's a scary story. But I just want to get across to you how bad it can get. Because sometimes the tenants who even come back with good checks and they they all turn out, oh yeah, their references are good. Sometimes it can turn bad. I'll tell you another interesting story. So there was a situation, we actually didn't manage this property, but it's a good one that has stuck in my head. So there was a situation where a tenant had moved into a townhouse and it was kind of like a middle unit. Now, at the back of this townhouse was a small garden area. It might be like twenty square meters, this grass.
11:48 Speaker 00 And so you think, oh, that's quite nice. They've got some actual grass there. That's all good because sometimes townhouses have fake grass. But then the grass died. Okay, that's not very good. So the tenant moves out, not because the grass died. They moved out and the grass had died, it turned out. And so the landlord thinks, well, hang on, the tenant is responsible for the lawns. So why has it died? When they went to the tenancy tribunal, the tenant said, well, there was no access to this lawn. There was no back gate where I could drag a lawnmower through. And there wasn't a garden shed. So yes, I had this grass that I was meant to take.
12:22 Speaker 01 But how was I supposed to do that?
12:23 Speaker 00 But how's I supposed to do that? Because I couldn't get a lawnmower, I'd have to drag a lawnmower through my kitchen and lounge in order to get it to the back garden and then I'd have to drag it back out again.
12:33 Speaker 01 Completely right. I also think if the lawn dies, like people don't have a natural green thumb, sometimes it's just the way it is.
12:40 Speaker 00 But my point here is even though the tenant has the responsibility for the lawn, sometimes the tenancy tribunal will take into account the the practicality of it of, well, where were they going to put their lawnmower and did they have access? Well, well, they'd have to drag it through the main living area to get there.
12:55 Speaker 01 Not everyone has a neighbour like Ed that just does his lawns for him. I'm very grateful. Thank you, neighbours. Thank you, 8A.
13:03 Speaker 00 But I guess, Andrew, there's a lot of messages here, but what's our main one?
13:06 Speaker 01 The main thing is that as an investor, it's completely natural to get a little emotional about the valuable asset that you've bought and you want people to look after it and you look after your own home. And so you can't understand how someone would be so careless as to scuff the wall when they're dragging a mattress up. But actually, that just happens. Like, that's just life. And you can't sweat the small stuff when it comes to investing. And so you need to separate the emotion from the logic and understand that, yeah, your brand new property isn't going to look perfect in 20 years' time. And so long as it is just fear, wear and tear, then you just deal with things as they come out. Focus on the big things. Don't stress about every mark. Don't stress about the lawn dying
13:48 Speaker 01 or having a patch in it because, you know, the dogs weed on it or something like that. Just worry about the really important things.
13:55 Speaker 00 All of that stuff can be fixed when you come to sell the property. And I also think that's why you don't want to buy something that's too luxurious, because you're often responsible for maintaining it and it might break your heart. And these are some of the hard-won realisations that I suppose, Andrew, you've come to have, having invested for 20 something years and owned a whole heap of properties. But if you like to hear about Andrew's mistakes, and I always like to.
14:20 Speaker 01 You love them.
14:21 Speaker 00 I love your mistakes. We've actually written Andrew's full story about how he went from growing up in a working-class suburban grassroots to owning 43 investment properties. And I'm quite grateful that you've let me do this because I know that you are a Kiwi, so you don't like to tell all of the details about your story. But we've written it up. And for the first time, we're giving it away actually within Opus Plus. So for the next 30 days, we've written 4,000 words about how Andrew ended up building this big property portfolio. And it's in there as a guide in Opus Plus. Now, remember, this is our app that we've created for you guys, the community, where you can run all of your numbers about an investment property. And it's a bit of an incentive to get you to
15:02 Speaker 00 go create that account. We are putting Andrew's story live for the next 30 days. So go ahead and sign up for that before we pull this. Now, in the last 15 minutes, you've learned when you can take money out of your tenant's bond to fix your house, what damage you as a landlord have to pay, and what counts as fear, wear and tear. Right, let's wrap it up there, but please don't forget to rate, review and subscribe to the podcast. Really does have us get the message out to more people.
15:33 Speaker 00 Thanks for listening to the Property Academy Podcast. I'm your host, Seb Knight.
15:35 Speaker 01 And I'm Andrew Nichol.
15:36 Speaker 00 We're going to be back here tomorrow with more daily strategies, tips and insights to help you get the most out of the property market. Until next time.
Previous Who can legally sell property in NZ? (The 5 levels explained)⎥Ep. 2080 Next The $50,000 mistake: How one tradie poisoned this Kiwi’s home⎥Ep. 2082 Page updated November 15, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated