Pod Insights The Property Academy Podcast Five Unhinged Tenancy Tribunal Cases⎟Ep. 2463 About this episode A tenant demanded more than $10,000 over a missing duvet. Another claimed an oven was poisoning her... In this episode, Ed and Andrew unpack some of the wildest Tenancy Tribunal cases they could find.
You’ll learn:
What happenedWhat the Tribunal decidedThe practical lessons landlords can actually take away from the chaosEvery one of these cases sounds unbelievable… until you realise they all ended up at the Tenancy Tribunal.
For more from Opes Partners:
Sign up for the weekly Private Property newsletter https://www.opespartners.co.nz/newsletter-sign-upInstagram https://www.instagram.com/opes_partners/TikTok https://www.tiktok.com/@opespartners
Transcript 0:08 Speaker 00 Hello and welcome along to the Property Academy Podcast by Opes Partners. I'm your host, Tim McKnight.
0:12 Speaker 01 And I'm Andrew Nichol.
0:13 Speaker 00 And this is a show that helps Kiwis go from zero to five investment properties. So you could be financially free and stick around for the next 15 minutes because you're going to learn the most unhinged tenancy tribunal cases we could find, the tenant who demanded $10,000 over a missing duvet, and the cat damage that was hidden under a blanket, and why the insurance company refused to pay a cent. Now, these are some of the worst of the worst cases that we could find where there are disputes between the tenants and the landlords, but I often like sharing them anyway because they can give us some really important lessons around how the law works and things we need to keep in mind as landlords. Now, Andrew, what is the first case that we've found?
0:58 Speaker 01 So this was actually one of our tenants at Opus and the tenant, they were in the property for 18 months and then the tenancy ends and then they demanded $10,000 from the landlord. Now, the main concern, the main reason that they were claiming this $10,000 was a missing duvet and some issues around the oven. And another complaint was that the property didn't have enough car parking. But here's the thing, the property never had a car park to begin with. It was rented out without a car park. And so the landlord says, no way, I'm not paying any of that money. So this goes to the tribunal.
1:32 Speaker 00 Now, what was fascinating here is the tenant was clearly just having a bit of a go, right? So they were in the property for 18 months, no issues. And then what happened at the end, because this was a furnished studio apartment, is the property manager did say, hey, look, it looks like there is a missing duvet. So what must have happened was the landlord would have paid to have a duvet in this furnished apartment. And then the tenant says, actually, that wasn't listed in the chattel list in the tenancy agreement. So no, it's not missing. And I think this must have got up the tenant's goat by the looks of things because then they started. Coming back with every little difference between the tenancy agreement and the reality.
2:14 Speaker 00 So if we look at the oven, for instance, the tenancy agreement, and this, this was an administrative mistake by the original property manager. The tenancy agreement said there was an underbench oven, so a standard oven, but there wasn't in the property. And there never was when the tenant viewed it. Instead, there was a countertop convection oven and some hobbs. There was never a full oven, but it said it in the tenancy agreement. So then he's trying to claim for that. The other thing in the tenancy agreement was it said the maximum number of cars at the property will not exceed one. And then he tried to say, the tenant, that, well, that means that there was a car park given with the property. I never got a car park because the property didn't have one.
2:55 Speaker 00 So therefore I'm going to try and claim some money back because this shows that this property was meant to come with a car park. And it didn't come with one. Now that's despite the fact that on the rental listing, the original one, it said there is no car park, right? Because the property didn't have one. So this ends up going to the tenancy tribunal. And ultimately they dismissed everything. And they said, look, the tribunal is not a complaint service. We're not an investigative body. We're here to resolve genuine disputes. And ultimately you got your bond back. I understand that there might have been some administrative issues with the tenancy agreement. With it not matching up exactly. Okay, the duvet wasn't on there.
3:37 Speaker 00 But you never complained over eighteen months. It seems like you were pretty happy with this property. So actually we're going to dismiss this all. And no, we're not refunding your filing fee to the tenant because it seemed like they were having a go. Now, in this, there are some good lessons around making sure that the tenancy agreement does exactly line up with the property, just to avoid the potential for these kinds of issues in the future, right? It's a very good lesson for property managers and one we're obviously talking to our team about as well. Anything else you're picking up from this one?
4:08 Speaker 01 One thing I found really interesting is that the tenant applied for name suppression, so a sealed order. So basically this wouldn't go out in the, in the public. And the tenancy tribunal actually refused that. Now, what that means is that. There is going to be this on record. And so any future landlords, if they do a search and see that tenant, they might think, hmm, I just need to be really careful with this tenant and make sure all my Ts are crossed and Is are dotted.
4:37 Speaker 00 And I suppose the good thing there for tenants as well is if you're going to have a go about something that actually wasn't that much of an issue, but now you're going to give it a go, then ultimately the risk is that it could be published that you did that, right? Talk to us about case number two.
4:54 Speaker 01 Another oven situation. This one was a bit more severe about the oven. The oven's poisoning me. And again, this is through our property management team and Tiffany was telling me about the situation where a tenant noticed the slight residue on the oven and the inside because it had been cleaned. Now, the tenant had been advised to turn the oven on high and burn off any remaining residue. Now, the tenant said, well, that hasn't worked. And so Tiffany sends a second cleaner out to remove the residue for them. And the tenant thinks, no, not good enough, files with the tribunal claiming that the team has poisoned her with this oven.
5:32 Speaker 00 Okay, so, so what, what happened?
5:35 Speaker 01 So the tenant wanted to move out because she said, well, the property no longer complies with healthy home standard because I'm being poisoned, so that's not healthy. And she can't breathe when the oven was on. And now our team said, well, actually you've signed a 12 month tenancy. We've got the right to remedy something if there is an issue and we believe we have done that. You can break the lease, but you have to pay the break lease costs. And the tenants thought, well, no, that's not fair. That's unreasonable. But in the end, they came to a resolution where the tenant ended up paying the trade me relisting fee. She moved out, new tenants moved in two days later. No complaints from the new tenants about the oven or anything else.
6:13 Speaker 00 It's quite interesting because all of these situations are quite nuanced, right? And obviously the oven was not poisoning the tenant, right? That would be a big issue. And this wouldn't even be considered a breach of the healthy home standards either.
6:25 Speaker 01 I think sometimes people use excuses. Maybe something else was going on and she didn't want to live there. And she was just using that as a way of getting out of it. Whereas, you know, most property managers and landlords are pretty reasonable if you just have a conversation with them.
6:39 Speaker 00 But I mean, some people in the world are a little bit, I'm gonna use the word unhinged. Like after, after moving out, the tenant filed another tenancy tribunal claim for a huge amount of compensation. And what she did was she went to Google and she typed in, is oven cleaner poisonous? And she screenshotted that of, of Google saying oven cleaner is poisonous. Sent that in and the tribunal dismissed it, like didn't even do a hearing. It was like, we're not gonna hear this. I've reviewed the evidence, just threw the case out before it took up any court time. Now I'll tell you about another case in Papakura in Auckland. This isn't one of ours, but there was a tenant who left the property with meth contamination.
7:24 Speaker 00 It was at 280 micrograms per 100 square centimetres. Remember, anything over 15 micrograms would be considered contaminated. So this is like 20 times the threshold, more or less, like 19 times the threshold. And the tenant said, well, this, this must have been my associates. My associates must have brought meth into the house. And the adjudicator said, well, this is, this is manufacture. You don't, you don't get that high most of the time, but just smoking meth. We did a recent podcast about this. It looks like somebody was cooking meth here. You're gonna have to pay 73,782 dollars to the landlord for remediation. Now you might think, well, wait a second.
8:07 Speaker 00 Tenants are usually only responsible for the excess. So usually with, with meth contamination, the tenant might have to pay 2,500 dollars. The insurance company would typically pay out the rest, usually up to 30 grand. That didn't happen here because it turns out that the landlord had not been doing the right inspections. And so the insurance company wouldn't pay out. Ultimately, it did land on the tenant then.
8:33 Speaker 01 And this is a good case of why we always. Say you've got to make sure you do your regular inspections, particularly private landlords that manage their own properties miss this. But without the inspection records, the case is just impossible to win. And I think the other learning here is consider getting a baseline test before and after the tenancy starts and ends, because if you don't do the baseline test, then there's no way of proving later that the contamination wasn't pre-existing. Even if it's a brand new property, if there isn't that baseline test at the start, you are going to have a hard time attributing that damage to the tenant. Now, personally, I don't do meth tests because manufacturing meth in a house
9:17 Speaker 01 is very uncommon. However, you've just got to be aware that that's got to be something that you've got to decide yourself whether or not you're prepared to take that risk or not.
9:27 Speaker 00 Now, I know there's this other one that I mentioned at the start about the cat damage under a blanket. What's the story here?
9:34 Speaker 01 So the tenant was living in a furnished rental and they had a cat that wasn't signed off by the landlord and it clawed a sofa and peed everywhere. Now, the tenant thought, well, I know what I'll do. I'll cover that up. So they covered up the damage on the sofa with a blanket and the landlord didn't see it. And by the time they discovered it, well, the bond had been refunded and the tenant had gone. So the landlord thinks, oh, bugger this, I'm going to claim through insurance. And that gets declined because the landlord, again, couldn't produce those inspection records. And the reason for that is because the tenant refused every inspection and the landlord just let that slide. They didn't go and say, no, tough luck. That's part of your tenancy agreement. And if you don't have the records, the insurance will not pay out.
10:17 Speaker 00 I'll tell you one really interesting one as well, is there was a case where a tenant jammed her finger at the property and her fingernail later died, jammed it in a door. She filed a tenancy tribunal claim looking for compensation for ongoing manicures because her damaged fingernail needed because better cupcake.
10:36 Speaker 01 So she did it herself? She jammed her own finger in there?
10:39 Speaker 00 Yeah, the tribunal obviously declined that part of the claim. And I like sharing some of these just because not every- Every claim at the tenancy tribunal actually has merit, right? And you as a landlord can have confidence that the tribunal will dismiss claims that don't have a clear legal basis, right? There are times where they will throw it out, but it also does show you that sometimes tenants will have a go. Now, it doesn't mean that this is going to happen all the time. It doesn't mean it's going to happen to all landlords. I, me myself, I've never been to the tenancy tribunal, even though I've been investing for, for years and, and got five rental properties. I mean, how many times have you been to the tribunal in the 22 years you've been investing
11:23 Speaker 00 across 40 odd houses?
11:25 Speaker 01 Once, once, the only time is when I had those tenants in Regiord that I managed myself, it's the only time.
11:32 Speaker 00 So other than that, you've never even had a property manager go to it, go to it for you?
11:36 Speaker 01 Not that I can recall.
11:37 Speaker 00 So, so I suppose we're telling you this because there are times where this can happen and we want to prepare you for in the unfortunate situation that your tenant has a go, how do you manage that? But it's not to say that this is going to happen all of the time, right? So over the last 15 minutes, you've learned the most unhinged tenancy tribunal cases we could find, the tenant who demanded 10 grand over a duvet, and the hidden damage that a cat did under a blanket and why the insurance company refused to pay out. Right, let's wrap it up there, but please don't forget to rate, review and subscribe to the podcast really does help us get the message out to more people.
12:17 Speaker 00 Thanks for listening to the Property Academy Podcast. I'm your host, Steve Atknight.
12:19 Speaker 01 And I'm your host, Nick.
12:20 Speaker 00 We're going to be back here tomorrow with even more daily strategies, techniques and insights to help you get the most out of the New Zealand property market. Until next time.
Previous What NZ Buyers Want … And It’s Not What You Think⎟Ep. 2462 Next What Happens if NZ Super Gets Cancelled? Page updated November 14, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated