Pod Insights The Property Academy Podcast Do I Really Need a Family Trust? Or Is It Just Another Cost?⎥Ep. 2105 About this episode Thinking about setting up a family trust but unsure if it’s worth it in 2025? In this episode, we dig into the real reasons Kiwis set up trusts – and whether you still need one today. You’ll learn the 3 benefits trusts can offer (and when they don’t apply), why most trusts fail, and the legal traps that can make your trust worthless. Plus, we reveal how people can still bust into your trust and take your assets … even when you think they’re protected. If you’re wondering whether a trust is right for your situation, this episode is a must-listen. Need help with structuring your property portfolio? Start by speaking to a property investment planner – it’s free. Don't forget to create your free Opes+ account here. For more from Opes Partners:Sign up for the weekly Private Property newsletterInstagramTikTok
Transcript 0:08 Speaker 00 Hello and welcome along to the Property Academy Podcast by Opes Partners. I'm your host, Stephen Knight.
0:12 Speaker 01 And I'm Andrew Nicoll.
0:13 Speaker 00 And this is the show that helps Kiwis go from zero to five investment properties. So you can be financially free and stick around for the next 15 minutes because you're going to learn. Do you really still need a family trust in 2025? The three reasons that Kiwis still use trusts and whether they apply to you or not, and how people can still bust into your trust and take your assets. Now, Andrew, there are a lot of trusts in New Zealand. Why is it that people love trusts so much?
0:40 Speaker 01 Yeah, do you know we've got one of the highest levels of trust per capita in the world, which is interesting. And when I say highest, to put some numbers on around that, there's between 300,000 and 500,000 around the country, and that's according to the Ministry of Justice, which is interesting. I don't know how they get that number because there's no actual database for trusts like there are for companies. Do you know?
0:58 Speaker 00 Some of it is the IRD levels because if you have a trust, you've got to file a tax return. But the IRD are currently getting somewhere between 200,000 and 250,000 trusts filing a tax return each year.
1:10 Speaker 01 So that's probably the active ones, I guess. And they've been part of our financial culture for kind of three main reasons. There's the asset protection, which is to stop people coming and attacking your assets. There's tax planning, so often there might be more tax efficiencies by owning properties or assets in a trust. And also a stake planning. So if you've got some kids and you think, okay, well, if I die, I want to make sure that, yeah, I protected my assets for my kids, but I don't want some new guy to come along and steal half of my partner's assets that she inherits. That could be a really good reason to have a trust.
1:41 Speaker 00 And do you know, I was really surprised. I didn't know there were six main types of trusts.
1:45 Speaker 01 I didn't know that either.
1:46 Speaker 00 But we found that out within our research. Today, we're mainly talking about family trusts, which is what you guys all care about. Now, it's really important to understand how trusts actually work because trusts are a separate legal person, right? So if you have a family trust and you put your house in it, you don't own it anymore.
2:06 Speaker 01 Yeah, so you've handed over the ownership of your assets to the trustee. The people who are kind of like the directors of a company. Now they're going to operate in the best interests of the beneficiaries, who are like the shareholders of the trust. And they're going to make sure that the assets are protected and do the things that you intended to do. I, again, if it was going back to the kids, making sure that the kids' education are provided for or that money is distributed on birthdays and things like that.
2:32 Speaker 00 And it's really important to understand some of those technical terms that Andrew said, because when you set up a trust, you need to understand what is your role. And there are three main roles, and you might actually find that you are every single one of them. So when I set up my family trust and I decided to put some assets into it, I was the settler. That's the person who puts the assets into the trust in the first place and sets it all up. So the settler. And then you've got the trustees. Now, those are the people who looks after the trust's property, decides how it's used, make all those decisions. And then you get the beneficiaries. So these are the people who can get the money or the benefits of the trust. And in most cases, a lot of people are all three of those as well.
3:16 Speaker 00 But you need to think about which hat are you wearing when you are setting up your trust, which we'll come to later. But the really important part of trusts and why they're probably quite popular is you can get the benefits of protecting your assets and stop people taking control of them while also still potentially using those assets. So if you put your house into a family trust, yep, sure, you don't technically own it anymore, but you can still live in it. So you get some asset protection while still enjoying it. So how do these benefits actually all work? Well, one of the main benefits, especially if you own a business, is protecting your stuff. So let's say you're an accountant and you own a business, you've got a couple of staff, and you decide that you want to go and rent out an office space.
3:59 Speaker 00 Well, sometimes when you rent a commercial property, the owner of that will say, okay, but if you go bust and your company goes belly up, I want a personal guarantee that you are going to pay the rent. And that means that if your company gets shut down or you shut your company down, maybe because the company's gone into liquidation, well, you still have to. Pay the rent for that property. Well, if you're shutting down your business, you might be going through a pretty rough time not be able to afford that. So what would happen if you didn't put your property into a trust? Is maybe the commercial landlord could come along and force you to sell that property. So he gets paid his rent.
4:37 Speaker 00 But if you put your property into a family trust and the commercial landlord comes after you, chasing you for that personal guarantee for that rent that you owe him. Well, no, no, no, you don't own that property anymore. The trust owns the property and so they can't force you to sell it in order to get paid back. And so it's a way to say, okay, I've got some personal assets, like a holiday home or a house. And I want to separate that out from myself because I know that I own a business. I might get sued, I might give some personal guarantees to people. Because of that, maybe I'm more likely to go bankrupt, but I don't want to lose my house, so I'm going to put it into a trust.
5:15 Speaker 00 But Andrew, it's really important that you set up the trust properly because if you don't and you don't manage it properly, you could find you losing your assets anyway.
5:24 Speaker 01 Do you know, I remember going along to an insurance conference of all things, like 20 years ago. And a guy was speaking there called Jonathan Cron, who was kind of one of the, the leading minds of trusts in New Zealand. He's written a bunch of books and so has Martin Hors, really, really good books if you want to go read those. If that kind of stuff spins your wheels, these are the people that you want to listen to. And they talk about the fact that in their experiences, heaps of family trusts, I kind of think Martin Hors said 75% of them. Are so badly arranged or managed that they could be easily attacked in court. And if they're attacked in court, they're likely to be overturned. And if you manage it badly, it's like having insurance in your house for all your contents.
6:09 Speaker 01 And then going away on holiday and leaving the door open. And if someone comes in and robs it, well, tough luck kind of thing. Like there can be a lot of money with administering trusts and, and setting them up in the first place. And if they're not worth the paper they're written on, literally, then what's the point of doing it?
6:26 Speaker 00 And we'll come back to how people are actually able to break into your trust, but just. Giving you some idea around the value of them. I remember Matt Gilligan sharing a story, I think it was at a conference we were at at Eden Park. He's a very well-known property councillor to Auckland. And he was giving us an example of when he bought a property and it was a farm and he bought it really cheap off a guy down in Southland. And the reason he was able to get it cheap was it was a, effectively a mortgager sale. Now, what had happened to this farm is that the father had owned it for a while. And then he died and he passed it on to his son. But at that point, his son was in bankruptcy.
7:07 Speaker 00 So the official assignee, the person who comes along and manages your, your assets if you are bankrupt, said, "Whippy, we've got a new asset now, a farm. We're going to be able to pay back some of the creditors who the son owed money to. So let's sell that farm and then we can pay them all back." That's very good news. And Matt got in there and got a very good deal. Now, a better way to structure that would be for that when the dad died, not to put it in the will that it goes to the son, but it goes to a trust that the son is a beneficiary of. Because what would happen then? So dad pops his clogs, the farm doesn't go to son, it goes into a trust that the son's the beneficiary of. Uh-uh, the official assignee, the person managing the, the son's bankruptcy, can't touch that farm anymore because the son doesn't own it.
7:53 Speaker 00 The trust owns it instead, but the son still gets the benefit of it. So I, I get that some of these are kind of maybe quite complicated. And if you're walking your dog or running on your treadmill, you're like, you might think-
8:03 Speaker 01 What the hell are they talking about?
8:04 Speaker 00 What are they talking about? But so maybe listen back to this one because it's actually quite important when you think, oh, there are some little intricacies here, but there are some big benefits as well. Now, Andrew, this is a big topic. So how do you set the trust up so that it can't be broken into?
8:18 Speaker 01 So I think the most important thing is that you follow the rules to the T because there are kind of three ways that people break into trusts. First is sham trusts. So these are trusts where you kind of, you've set them up, but it's not really done in a legitimate way. And so often this can be around who has done each of the different roles that he was describing before.
8:38 Speaker 00 So an example of that- Might be that I decide that I'm going to put my house into a family trust. But I'm the only trustee, I'm the only beneficiary. And actually, the assets aren't really in a trust, I'm just owning it, but in a different name. In those cases, the courts might say, that's not a real trust, it's not being operated the right way. You're just trying to get some legal protection where perhaps you ought not to say, nah mate, we're going to break into that trust.
9:06 Speaker 01 And that kind of leads into the second one, which is when you've got too much control. So if, for example, you've set it up in such a way that, you know, there's some independent trustees. But really, you're the one going in there and just dipping into that account at willy nilly, just to fund your lifestyle. Those kind of trusts, I've read lots of cases of those being overturned. And probably the third one, which I've seen a wee bit, is when people just move assets in there right before they go broke. So say, for example, a builder thinks, I've built all these houses and I know they didn't do a very good job. And I know creditors are chasing me and that maybe, maybe I'm about to get sued. Well, I'll just put my house into a trust right now and gift it all away. No, no, no, that could get overturned pretty easily.
9:46 Speaker 00 And so a couple of things to do to make sure that your trust doesn't get broken into though, of course, anybody who does have a trust. You're going to go and get some legal advice about this, you're not going to listen to just the 15 minutes of this podcast. Main thing is having independent trustees, so not just you on the trust, another trustee on there. Keeping proper records about payments out to you yourself. So if you are paying some money out to you. You don't want to just move it at the bank, you want to make sure there's a trustee resolution around that, some paperwork to make sure that it's actually legitimate. And basically, don't treat it like your personal piggy bank and review it with your lawyer. Now, there are some catches with trusts, which is that they are not free and they are not simple.
10:25 Speaker 01 Yeah, there are some significant costs to setting them up. So you've got your initial setup cost where you're going to have a lawyer. It's probably a few thousand dollars. Then potentially you've got actually putting the assets into the trust. So say, for example, you move your own home, which is a very common thing. There's some conveyancing costs involved in that because you're selling your property to your trust. So there's a sale from you and there's a purchase from your trust. And often there'll be. A discharge fee from the bank and there might be some other fees from the bank side of things. Now, of course, there are some ongoing costs as well, so you've got to be aware of that. So if you are running a trust in the correct way, generally speaking, you'll have an annual meeting with your lawyer or your independent trustees, there'll be costs involved with that.
11:08 Speaker 01 And I think one of the other catches is they're not necessarily as secure as you might think. So as we've said before, there are cases where trusts get basically unwound and anyone going after the assets might actually have a claim against them, be it relationship property or a creditor. So they might not be as secure as you think. Now, one of the big catches that's come in recently is that you have to disclose to the beneficiaries how much is actually in there. Now, you might think, well, what's the problem with that? I'll tell you why. Let's say, for example, I've got a trust and I think, okay, I'm going to give some money to my kids in the future. Once I die, they can have my assets. Well, that's all good, but now I've got to disclose to them every year how much in value the assets are in there.
11:51 Speaker 01 And that could actually make for a little bit of an uncomfortable conversation because you're probably thinking, well, I don't want to spoil my kids. And I don't want them to be jumping out of a cake every birthday, hoping that they scare me enough to clear up the money as soon as possible. So I know there's been some rejigs of trusts following their change in the rules there.
12:10 Speaker 00 And then there's also higher taxes. They, it used to be that trusts had a 33% tax rate. Now it's 39% if you've got assets have a 10 grand in there. But Andrew, give us an example of someone who's had their trust broken into.
12:23 Speaker 01 Well, I did read about a case, which was Clayton versus Clayton. It was a couple that was splitting up. This is often the time where they might be challenged and the husband had a trust and he had way too much control over the trust and was running it like he owned the show. And it was basically his just own personal bank account. So rather than it being separate assets where there was a genuine divide, he was basically just running this account like it was his own and therefore it was a personal account, which was up for grabs in relationship property claims.
12:53 Speaker 00 And so they had to split it. And in that case, he lost half of the assets in the trusts. But then I saw another one, and this was quite. Quite interesting. This was Cooper versus Pini. And the husband and wife worked on a farm together. And the farm was owned by the husband's family trust. Now, the wife tried to use the case that Andrew's just talked about, Clayton versus Clayton, to say, well, my husband's got a lot of control over the trust. So he basically owns it. We're splitting up. So I want to make sure that I get fifty percent of his family farm. Now, in this case, the court actually disagreed this time. And the reason was because the husband didn't have free rein. He wasn't the only trustee. He couldn't make decisions about this farm on his own.
13:35 Speaker 00 And he was still bound by his duties as a trustee to the other beneficiaries within the trust. So it wasn't just him. But I think this does tell you, if you've got too much control over the trust, if you do treat it like your personal piggy bank. If you've got too much control, then it might not stand up. That trust might not stand up in a relationship split. And maybe this is the reason why that for the first time in a long time, the number of trusts or number of active trusts is actually going down, Andrew.
14:01 Speaker 01 Yeah, in two thousand and one, there are about one hundred and sixty five thousand trusts. Now, by two thousand and seventeen, that peaked at around two hundred and sixty four thousand. But since then, the numbers, according to the IRD, have dropped. And so by twenty twenty three, there are about thirty two thousand less trusts in New Zealand than at the peak.
14:20 Speaker 00 So let's talk about who really needs a trust in twenty twenty five. Look, I think if you've got a lot of assets that you want to protect, if you're a business owner, if you've got a lot of properties, if you've got a lot of investments, then it could be really beneficial having a trust. Or if you're in an occupation where you're likely to get sued. So maybe directors signing personal guarantees for loans, maybe even property developers. Well, having a trust can put a firewall around your assets. But then also people who've got complex families. So maybe if you're on your second marriage or you've got a blended family. So some kids with one partner, another set of kids with a different partner. This can just help you have a little bit more control over the assets that you do have. But look, if you're a typical wage earner with a family home, maybe some savings.
15:04 Speaker 00 Uh, to be honest, a trust might be a little bit more trouble than it's worth, especially because of all the costs of setting it up. And I saw a little something from Katrina Shanks, she used to be the CEO of Financial Advice NZ. She said, look, many Kiwi trusts are still worthwhile, but it really depends on if you need one, and I agree with that. And over the last 15 minutes, you've learned, do you really need a family trust in 2025? The three reasons that Kiwis still use trusts, and whether they apply to you or not, and how people can still get in and bust your trusts. Right, let's wrap it up there, but please don't forget to rate, review and subscribe to the podcast. Really does help us get the message out to more people.
15:44 Speaker 00 Thanks for listening to the Property Academy Podcast. I'm your host, Stephen Knight. And I'm Andrew Nichols. We're going to be back in tomorrow with even more daily strategies, tactics and insights to help you get the most out of your son, property marketer. Until next time.
Previous I Own 43 Properties But I Wish I Learned This Sooner⎥Ep. 2104 Next Are We Really at the Bottom of the Housing Market?⎥Ep. 2106 Page updated November 15, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated