Pod Insights The Property Academy Podcast Developers I Wouldn’t Touch (Without Naming Them)⎟Ep. 2389 About this episode Not all property developers are created equal… and when the market gets tough, some start cutting corners. In this episode, Ed and Andrew reveal the real red flags they’ve seen from developers – from misleading numbers to legal grey areas – and how investors can protect themselves when buying off the plans. You’ll learn: The 6 biggest red flags that should make you walk away from a developer The sales tactics that cross the line How to protect yourself legally and financially before signing a deal Most developers are doing the right thing… but the small number who aren’t can cost you tens (or hundreds) of thousands. Don't forget to create your free Opes+ account and Wealth Plan here. For more from Opes Partners:Sign up for the weekly Private Property newsletterInstagramTikTok
Transcript 0:08 Speaker 00 Hello and welcome along to the Property Academy Podcast by Opes Partners. I'm your host, Sebbit Knight.
0:12 Speaker 01 And I'm Junikum.
0:13 Speaker 00 And this is a show that helps Kiwis go from zero to five investment properties. So you can be financially free and sit around for the next 15 minutes because you're going to learn the six red flags that should make you walk away from a property developer, the dirty sales tactics that they use that they just cross the line and how to protect yourself when buying off the plans. Now, whenever the property market gets a bit tough, I always see that property developers' behaviour just gets worse because when their margins get squeezed, they just start saying and doing things that maybe they wouldn't do in a hotter market. Now, I want to be really clear, right? Because most property developers, very hardworking people, try to build some good houses in
0:54 Speaker 00 a pretty difficult market, but some, some are cutting corners, they're stretching the truth and they're operating in legal grey areas. And I think when that happens, the damage goes beyond just one deal because it drags down all of the good developers as well with the bad ones. But what are you seeing at the moment, Andrew?
1:16 Speaker 01 Well, I think because we've got bigger, because our podcast has got more popular, lots of people listen to the podcast now and then they send us our stories or they might say, I got into this legal spat with this developer. And so actually now it's not just about what we've experienced at Opus, it's what we get told about as well from other people. I know some of this might be hearsay, but I've read so many emails between people and developers or I've seen a disputes tribunal case between an investor and a developer. And so there is a bit of stuff that I'm like, God, that's bad.
1:51 Speaker 00 Okay, so we've got six red flags. What's red flag number one that should make you potentially walk away from a developer?
1:58 Speaker 01 Red flag number one. So what I'm seeing is a lot of developers right now who verge. Or maybe have their foot over the line of giving investment advice. But the interesting thing is you can't give investment advice unless you're authorised to do that. And so developers, they might give a cash flow forecast, they might give a yield, often yields. They'll give a return forecast and they'll say things like, this is a strong investment. This is a great investment. Now technically, you can do some of these things so long as you use a disclaimer saying, something along the lines of, we're not financial advisers, seek independent financial advice. But the obvious issue, they're developers, they're not investment specialists. They shouldn't be giving an investment advice.
2:42 Speaker 01 It'd be kind of like me, me coming along to Ed and saying, oh Ed, that mole on your chest, that looks like cancer to me, but I'm not a doctor, you should seek medical advice. Now it's thinking that I've got any grounds to be giving that kind of advice. But no, I gave a quick disclaimer and it was in tiny font at the bottom of my note to him. And I just kind of think, if you're a developer, give advice on developments. If you're not an investment advisor, don't even talk about those things.
3:13 Speaker 00 Well, I think the issue is that from my experience, when I've reviewed the claims and the cash flow projections and, and some of the things developers say, they're actually wrong. Or there are obvious errors. And I think there is a real risk on relying on medical advice from somebody who's not a doctor. And similarly, I think there's a real, real risk in relying on investment returns and topics and projections and advice from people who aren't actually that. Now, what can you do to protect yourself though?
3:46 Speaker 01 So I think the first thing is you need to check whether or not the person or the company that you're talking to is registered to give financial advice. If you're going to even consider or look at any kind of financial projections. And the way you do that is you go to the financial services providers register, F S P R. If you put that into Google, you can type in their details. And if they come up, all good, they can give you financial advice. If they don't come up, then don't listen to it.
4:17 Speaker 00 The red flag number two is when the numbers for a property only works as an Airbnb. Now, of course, properties that are on Airbnb do tend to get high cash flow compared to if you took the exact same property and rented it out as a standard long term. And that's why some developers will kind of inflate the numbers that they're giving you, which we just said they shouldn't give you, but they inflate those numbers by only looking at it as an Airbnb. Now, this can cause multiple issues, like if you are earning over 60 grand a year from your Airbnb, click, we're right into, you've got to be registered for GST. Sometimes the numbers don't include that and that can create complications.
4:59 Speaker 00 Years later, depending on how the property was structured, you might face a 13% tax bill on any increase in value you've seen on the property. For instance, if you're, if you're buying it excluding GST, which I've seen more developers advertising these days because it makes the property look cheaper, despite the fact that you might have this bigger tax bill later on. And then of course, by the time you get to those years later, the salesperson who showed you the Airbnb projections is so long gone, you're left explaining the situation to the IRD, saying that person from that development company said it was all good. Well, they're not here anymore. And I think it is quite risky, which is why you've got to check if the property stacks up as a long-term rental, not just as an Airbnb.
5:43 Speaker 00 Now, you might still Airbnb it, but you want to have that backup plan in case tourism goes through the floor or the numbers don't quite stack up as it looked. And of course, there's, there could be more regulation, you know, councils are tightening the rules and some apartment buildings are banning short-term letting altogether.
6:01 Speaker 01 I was just going to add something there. I was out for lunch with a friend of mine who's a developer in Christchurch on Saturday. And as we were walking to lunch, we were talking about exactly this issue. Now, he, plus two other big developers in Christchurch are building hotels at the moment. And he said, do you know what we're going to do pretty soon? We are going to put pressure on the council to tighten up the regulation around your BMBs because we're not going to invest all this. This money and we're not going to have international hotels come here and employ people if we don't also treat the Airbnbs as essentially hotel rooms and charge them rates accordingly and and tax accordingly. There will be a big shake up of this in New Zealand over the next few while as we become more popular for tourism again.
6:45 Speaker 00 Well, I think what you can do to protect yourself is to model an investment as a long term rental. And if you're going to do it as an Airbnb, do both. Check the numbers as an Airbnb, check the numbers as a long term rental. I'm not anti Airbnb properties at all, noting that there could be some changes coming down the line in the future. But you know, if it's working for you today, all good. But make sure you're running the numbers as a long term rental rather than buying something that's incredibly low yielding. But oh, it's on Airbnb. So the numbers seem to work. What's red flag number three, Andrew?
7:18 Speaker 01 Guaranteeing your property will increase in value when you can't do that. So I recently received an email from someone saying, what do you think about this? And a developer had marketed some properties with a guarantee that it was going to go up in value between now and settlement. Now, to be fair, you sign up for a property today in a buoyant market where you'll likely see some increase and it'll be worth more when it's finished than what it is today. Yeah, that might be a likely outcome. But there is no world in that that uplift is guarantee. At least the developer is going to write that into a contract, i.e. not an email from a salesperson. That's absolute nonsense and you're never
8:03 Speaker 01 going to see that happen. And I've also heard people on the phone say things like, if you can't settle the property, don't worry, we'll resell it and we can share in the profits. Again, like if a salesperson on a phone is telling you that, I'd be incredibly nervous about what else they're saying that might not be true. Because developers, they fall outside of the real estate authority or the financial markets authority, generally speaking, unless they're registered with those two entities, which I very much doubt it. And essentially, you're working under the same premises if you went and bought a property privately. And it's very much a case of buyer beware. And yep, there are some other laws that might protect you.
8:48 Speaker 01 But if you got into an instance where a property hadn't gone up in value, like you were promised, and you couldn't settle it, and you wanted to get out of it, and the developer said, well, no, that's we've got a contract. The contract says you need to settle it at that price that we agreed to. The way that you'd fight that, you'd have to go to court. And the developer is probably going to have more money than you are. And so that's probably not going to work out that well for you. And so in instances like this, I think what you'd need to do to protect yourself. If you're relying on a specific claim about prices rising, or a guaranteed buyback, or something like that, you need to get the specifics in writing and in the sale and purchase agreement,
9:32 Speaker 01 not an email from a staff member.
9:36 Speaker 00 Now, for the next one, red flag number four is refusing to fix issues with the property that they're actually legally on the hook for. Now, when you buy a new build property in New Zealand, you get two protections automatically, right? So you've got a 12-month defect repair period. So the builder's got to fix any defects that you tell them about within the first year. And you also get a 10-year structural warranty. Something goes wrong with the structure of the house within 10 years, builder's got to fix it. Now, most developers do honour these obligations, but not all of them. And I know that you've been involved, Andrew, in a, in a recent example where a developer has not been fixing the defects they're actually on the hook for.
10:18 Speaker 01 Yeah, I would have loved to have shared more about the specifics around this one, but the client's got a confidentiality agreement. But the listeners of the show, they bought a property from a developer that we specifically don't recommend. And there was an issue with the septic tank system. And it was within the warranty period. Now, when there's some investigations done, turned out that the septic tank system was not fit for purpose. It was not up to scratch for the number of units that were in there and the volume of waste. That they were dealing with. Now, the problem was the developer just said, no, it's fine. It was working and now it's clogged up again, or now it's broken again. And this had happened several times and they just said, oh, sorry, we're not willing to replace
11:00 Speaker 01 that. Now, fortunately, with a bit of advice from us, the owners bandied together and they got an independent engineering report and the report confirmed exactly what they suspected, i.e. this was not compliant. And eventually the developer realised this could become a squeaky well. I don't want to end up on the Property Academy podcast again, and I don't want to end up maybe in the paper because there's a court finding. And so they eventually did the right thing. But the owners had to pay for all this and have quite a bit of stress in doing this. So this is just something that we see quite a bit and is the reason why sometimes people end up on our don't recommend list.
11:38 Speaker 00 Now, in terms of what you can do to protect yourself, thankfully, the disputes tribunal actually increased their limit around the cases that they'll oversee. So the previous limit for compensation was $30,000. That's gone up to 60 grand. That happened earlier this year. And what that means is you can more easily take a developer through the justice system without it costing you a lot of money when things go wrong. So if you know your rights and aren't afraid to go to the disputes tribunal, that can be one thing you can do to protect yourself. But that's really the ambulance at the bottom of the cliff. And that's why I know that sometimes it can be very boring when we harp on about actually checking a developer out in the right ways. But it's very important
12:22 Speaker 00 because that's how you protect yourself from getting into these situations. Now, I've got two red flags left to go through. What is red flag number five? This one really floored me.
12:31 Speaker 01 Now, this was a bit of a rough one. I had the dad of a young purchaser email me and say, hey, let me just tell you a bit of a story about a developer that my daughter wanted to buy through. She looked at some of their products, thought, oh yeah, this one looks pretty good. They were asking about $800,000 for it. She thought, well, I'm going to offer a little bit less because my finance doesn't allow me to go up that high. I'm going to offer them $770,000, say. Made an offer through a sale and purchase agreement, normal process. And the developer came back and said, no, we want 800,000. And the purchaser said, that's okay. It doesn't really work at 800,000. Thanks very much. It's not for me. All in writing, a few days later, the developer's office sent a letter and it said,
13:14 Speaker 01 "Congratulations, you're now the successful purchaser, subject to DD, of this property at 770." So signed the agreement that they had originally put in. But the key thing here is that actually the offer was at an end. The purchaser had said, "You know what, that's okay." And they'd actually gone and subsequently signed up to buy something else at that stage. But the developer was trying to be sneaky and so took the original offer, even though they'd been back and forward contracts, and basically just used an old offer, which you can't do. That's just unethical.
13:51 Speaker 00 And in fact, it's illegal. So if you are working with any seller and you put in an offer and sign the sale and purchase agreement and give it to them and they counter and send you a new sale and purchase agreements and give you a counter offer, that first offer that you have put to them, that dies. So as soon as they counter it, they can't then go, "Oh, wait, wait a second. I'm going to grab that other contract, sign it, write the deals live." No, no, no, no, no. By countering, that original offer goes, it's null and void, can't be signed again for you to get on. So I suppose the red flag there was trapping you in a deal that you already walked away from. And it's just very, very bad behaviour.
14:34 Speaker 00 Unfortunately, in this case, there's not really much you can do to protect yourself other than knowing that actually that contract's void, they can't be using that, they can't sign that. But we're now on to red flag number six, our final red flag that tells you you should run away from a developer. What is it, Andrew?
14:51 Speaker 01 Sugar coating the numbers with incentives that disappear. Now, there's a lot of times that, you know, maybe you might have an incentive. Look, banks have cash backs, which, you know, you get as a one-off thing. So I kind of get the fact that sometimes in a harder market, you might want to compete for business and maybe you throw in some incentives. But you've got to be really careful as a purchaser and an investor. You're not looking at a deal based on those incentives. So they're just the icing on the cake. It's the cake that you're doing this for. So things like rental guarantees, cash back offers, furniture packages, these are all things that have benefits, but you've got to redefine print carefully. And I'll give you a really good example. Ed and I just landed in Queenstown last week for a board
15:33 Speaker 01 meeting. And when I got off the plane, I got a phone call from a developer who I, I, they're a big name developer in Auckland. And the developer said, would you like to have a look at some of these properties we've got? And I said, I looked at this three years ago. If they haven't sold, you guys need to reconsider what your deals are. And he said, no, no, no, no, these are really good deals now, really good deals now. We've got yields at like 11% or something like that. And I was like, okay, is that based on a made up hydraulic rent that you're just, you know, giving clients money back? And he said, ah, and I said, great. Send me the real numbers. That's absolute nonsense, which he didn't even know the real numbers. Like he didn't even know what the real rent would be because they're taking money that you're paying them to buy
16:18 Speaker 01 the property and giving it back to you as a rental guarantee. But then in two years' time, when that rental guarantee changes, we just drop down to a normal rent. And all of a sudden, that property that was paying for itself, felt really good at the time, is now actually just an average investment. So you've got to be really, really careful. And the way you protect yourself, ignore any numbers from a rental guarantee, ignore any yields based on the rental guarantee. Always, especially with a developer that you're dealing with directly, get your independent rental guarantee and do your numbers based on that. And if the numbers don't work on that, then it's not a good investment.
16:55 Speaker 00 And because all of these are quite hard to see in advance, that's the exact reason why we built the Opes Wealth Pathway. This is where you work with a financial advisor who builds your wealth plan and then helps you look at properties and see if they actually stack up and recommends you ones that they can stand behind. Now, if you're keen to check that out and you want to invest in new builds, go to opespartners.co.nz, click the big orange button, pick your advisor, book a time and you'll get your free wealth plan. Because over the last 15 minutes, you've learned the six red flags that should make you walk away from a property developer, the dirty sales tactics that they use that just cross the line, and how to protect yourself when buying off the plans. Right, let's wrap it up there. But please don't forget to rate, review and subscribe to the podcast. It really does help us get the message out to more people.
17:47 Speaker 00 Thanks for listening to the Property Academy Podcast. I'm your host Steve Attenborough.
17:50 Speaker 01 And I'm your host Nick.
17:51 Speaker 00 We're going to be back here tomorrow with even more daily strategies, tactics and insights to help you get the most out of your estate and property market. Until next time.
Previous A Sneaky Peek at the Property Deals We’re Recommending Right Now⎟Ep. 2388 Next Burgled. Flooded. Cancer… And They Still Built Wealth⎟Ep. 2390 Page updated November 14, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated