Pod Insights The Property Academy Podcast Confessions of Property Investors (What They Won’t Say Publicly)⎟Ep. 2387 About this episode What do property investors really think… but never say out loud? In this crossover episode, Ed and Andrew sit down with Nefe and Stevie from the new 'She Owns This' podcast to spill the tea on the uncomfortable truths, tough conversations, and behind-the-scenes realities of working with property investors. You’ll learn:The “confessions” property investors and advisers don’t usually share publiclyThe hardest conversations advisers have to have The tough truths most investors need to hear (but don’t want to)This episode pulls back the curtain on what really happens behind closed doors. It’s honest, a bit uncomfortable, and exactly the kind of conversation more investors need to hear. Make sure to subscribe to the She Owns This podcast or listen on Spotify or Apple podcasts
Transcript 0:08 Speaker 00 Hello and welcome along to the Property Academy Podcast by Opus Partners. I'm your host, Sebik Knight.
0:12 Speaker 01 And I'm Eddie McCall.
0:13 Speaker 00 And this is a show that helps Kiwis go from zero to five investment properties. So you could be financially free and stick around for the next 15 minutes because you're going to learn confessions of a property investment addict, the hardest conversations these investors have had to have, and the tough advice most property investors really need to hear. And for this episode, we're really pleased to be joined by Stevie and Niffy. And the reason we wanted to get these guys on is something that has bugged me for a long, long time is that we don't have enough women listening to the Property Academy Podcast. And for so long, I've tried to increase the number of women who listen to the show. It's at about 25%, but nothing I've done has really budged the numbers, which is why
0:56 Speaker 00 when I received an email over the Christmas break from a listener saying, hey, could we have more women hosts on the show? I thought, I know just the thing, we'll launch a new podcast. So we have just launched the She Owns This Podcast. It's hosted by Niffy Marston and Stevie Wearing. Both have been on the show and both are financial advisors for property investors from our team at Opus. Stevie and Niffy, welcome along to the show.
1:21 Speaker 02 Hiya. Thanks for having us.
1:23 Speaker 01 How are they nervous now?
1:25 Speaker 00 And the great thing is this show is about women getting smarter with money, right? Property, investing, some of the conversations that don't happen enough. So today, we want to spill the tea, hear some of their confessions as property investors, and talk about the hardest advice they've had to give other property investors as well. Stevie, we're going to start with you. How did you first start investing in property?
1:47 Speaker 02 So close to 10 years ago, my then partner and I decided that we wanted to buy a property because we were paying out the years for rent in Wellington. And so what we did, we saved up, saved up, saved up, and we also used the bank of mum and dad. And we looked at properties around Wellington and realised that if you wanted to buy a property, you're probably going to have to pay out the years for something that is... Central City, but probably Leakey. No, I say that, that's what a lot of lawyers were really scaring us about is that the quality of property in Wellington is very varied. And so what we ended up looking at is what new builds were available. Yes, we had to look a little bit outside of Wellington City, but we realised that we could buy something actually cheaper that was brand new. And so that's the route that we went down.
2:31 Speaker 01 And what about you, Nephi? I remember you're recently in the Sunday Star Times. Tell us about how you got started.
2:38 Speaker 02 Yeah, so when I first started getting into property investing, I actually bought my first home with my now husband using a 10% deposit, which was a combination of cash, KiwiSaver and the First Home Buyer's Grant at the time. And you could get more money at the time buying a new build with the grant. So we purchased the first one. We used a revolving credit facility to pay down that debt as quickly as possible. In that time, the market boom because it was post-COVID. We had some usable equity in there and then we leveraged and bought again and we've just rinsed and repeat.
3:06 Speaker 01 So you both had successful starting out and obviously both still together with your partners? Or maybe not with you, Stevie?
3:13 Speaker 02 No, not with me, but it still worked out pretty well. We did quite well on the property and it was all amicable. So we, we both walked away with a healthy little chunk that we were able to reinvest.
3:21 Speaker 01 And you might actually cover this in your show, but how did you manage owning a property together after a separation?
3:27 Speaker 02 So we decided that we wanted to keep the property. It was a good wee asset. We didn't have any plans individually to do anything else. So we went to the lawyers, we came up with a separation agreement that we were happy with. It was very similar to a contracting out agreement that's quite typical for couples, where it just put some parameters around if one of us wanted to sell, what would that look like? And that gave us confidence to be able to hold on to the property, knowing that that property isn't going to stop either one of us from moving on or doing something different.
3:56 Speaker 01 Because that's always a tough time balancing finances in a separation, plus the emotional strain of a separation. Those kind of things can put pressure on, on you and also on, on the finances. Did you come close to it all going wrong there? And/or have there ever been times while you've been investing where you've come close to the wire?
4:16 Speaker 02 So the good thing about doing this is even though I Had a property with an ex-partner and that luckily we were both quite chill about the whole thing. We only actually had to really talk once a year. So when the fixed rates came up and we were just fixing for one year at a time. And when the tenancy came up for renewal, that's kind of the only time that we chatted about it. So it was pretty low pressure. There were a couple of instances where one of us had a situation where we were thinking, oh, this might change things. We'd have a conversation and we'd say, well, you've got all of the power to say we need to sell the property. And almost having that conversation and knowing that you weren't stuck in a corner with this property and the other person holding you back. Actually ended in us saying, well, actually we'll just hold on to it.
5:00 Speaker 01 What was the trigger for when you did decide to sell? And, and how did that work in practice in terms of if you could both decide when you were going to sell? How do you actually navigate that?
5:12 Speaker 02 Yeah. So we had a really good clause in our contract that said, hey, if one person decides that we need to sell. The other person gets first right of refusal for eight weeks. So essentially that means that, let's say that Nefi and I are in a relationship and I say, I need to sell this property. Nefi has eight weeks to go talk to a mortgage advisor to see if she wants to buy the property outright. And it gives her that time to go through and say, is this what I actually want to do? Can I actually do it? Or otherwise, if I hear nothing from her, I get to put that property on market.
5:40 Speaker 01 Great way of doing it.
5:41 Speaker 00 Now I wanted to dig into some of these confessions and Nefi, I want to know, what is the part of your property investor journey? That you are least proud of and what has it taught you?
5:53 Speaker 02 Oh, okay. So when I was getting into investing in my first property. The first property I actually put under contract was an apartment, which I'm least proud of. And what, what I'm coming down to here is I was rushing into properties because I was too ambitious and I was too eager just to get on the property market at the time. It was a hot market. I could have afforded the apartment. However, looking back on that, that wouldn't have been the best property for me at my age and stage. What I needed was growth properties, things like townhouses and standalone homes. Now thankfully I was able to get out of that property and I was able to buy a Christchurch townhouse. Now in saying that, looking over the long.
6:30 Speaker 03 Long term, I'm glad I at least did something rather than doing nothing. Because at least now I can say, well, hey, maybe the property I have now in Auckland is an investment. And maybe the property in Christchurch are fine, but they could be better. At least I'm in a position where I can lift and shift in the future.
6:44 Speaker 01 It's such a balance between getting into the market and having as much time in the market as possible. And also chasing the perfect investment.
6:53 Speaker 03 Yeah.
6:53 Speaker 01 Because sometimes the perfect investment might be years away from what your borrowing ability is. But you also don't want to buy something rubbish just for the sake of having something.
7:01 Speaker 03 Yeah.
7:01 Speaker 01 That's where it becomes quite challenging, right?
7:03 Speaker 03 It is. It's just finding a balance going, at least I'm doing something. I don't want to give myself too much of a hard time, but yeah.
7:08 Speaker 00 What was it that made you not proud of that moment?
7:11 Speaker 03 Again, I think I was just a bit ambitious and a bit, I was trying to move too quickly, I think. I didn't actually stop and go, okay, is this actually the right property for me? Knowing what I know now, if I was to say to my 23 year old self, no, don't go for the apartment. Just wait a little bit longer and buy the townhouse, of course, I would have. But at the time, I just wanted to get on as quickly as possible. And I was just quite aggressive that it probably clouded my judgment for a minute there. But thankfully, I'm all right.
7:37 Speaker 00 Okay, but you guys are also financial advisors, specifically working with property investors. So I want to get into some of the confessions around working with investors. Now, Stevie, I'm going to start with you. What's the conversation you dread having with a property investor? But you know you have to have it anyway?
7:55 Speaker 02 The first investor that I think about is the investor that has been doing everything right from their perspective. Like they've been working really hard. They might be focusing on paying down their personal home and getting the kids sorted. And there is nothing wrong with either of those things. But they sit in front of me and they might be close to 60, they might be 58. And they're saying, hey, now that I've done these things, the kids are off, they're doing their own things, they're having their own children. My house is finally paid off. And I've got these big ambitions about what retirement is going to look like because I've been working so hard. And now we want to go on the cruises and we want to buy the caravan and we want to have all of this income. And I do dread that conversation of saying, hey, I understand that you've worked really, really hard.
8:35 Speaker 02 But now your goals are a little too ambitious and we're going to have to readjust that because we just don't have the time.
8:42 Speaker 01 And why is that? Why can't they afford to go on the cruises? I mean, if they've paid off their their own home, they've got no mortgage. What's the issue?
8:48 Speaker 03 So the issue is that they've got their own home that's paid off, but they can't actually eat into that. So they have to sell that property, their personal home, to get any money out of it. And so when you get older as well, your your risk tolerance tends to go down and you're very protective of your personal home. And more often than not, the idea of selling your house to get the money out and then renting potentially is not something that people want to do. So you've gained all of this wealth in your house, but you can't actually access it or live off it.
9:16 Speaker 01 You're right, though, about like, that conversation with investors is sometimes quite a tough one to have as a financial advisor, because people often want a lot, but aren't necessarily prepared to make the sacrifices to get there. And and if they've got a short runway, maybe it is just financially impossible, or just mathematically impossible. It's a pretty hard conversation to have with people.
9:37 Speaker 03 Yeah, you you're sitting there going, I'm about to absolutely burst your bubble. And it's not that we can't do anything and we can't get you into a better position, but it's really not going to be what's on the vision board for you at home on your fridge. Leave my vision board alone, Stevie.
9:53 Speaker 01 And Nefi, what about you? Have you ever watched a client make a decision that you think that's just a really bad idea, but then they've done it anyway? And and kind of, how do you, how do you deal with that?
10:05 Speaker 03 Oh, a hundred percent. I've had a client where they've made a decision that I think was bad. I recently had a client that was actually really young. They were forty, they were already mortgaged beyond their own home. They could borrow 1.5 million. They were on great incomes. And so we created a plan around, okay, let's retire you in 20 years. What I suggest we do is let's go for a property in Auckland and a standalone home in Christchurch. Therefore, you're diversified across locations and you're diversified on typology as well. And in the end, what they actually did was they got suckered into developer chat and they found a duplex, a 1.4 million dollar progressive build payment in one suburb in Christchurch with,
10:49 Speaker 03 I would probably say, optimistic rental appraisals.
10:52 Speaker 02 And the numbers, as much as I tried to say, look, this is not as shiny as you think it is, they still ended up buying that property. And what my concern was and reason why I think it was a bad decision is not only are you A, maxing yourself out on your borrowing, but you're also having all of your wealth concentrated, not only in one city, but in one suburb, rather than that diversification geographically as well. And so, yeah, that sometimes there's only so much we can do as advisors. We can give ourselves the honest opinion, we can run the numbers, but ultimately it comes down to the client who wants to make that kind of decision.
11:26 Speaker 01 Yeah, and because property, even though when we talk about investments, it should not be an emotional decision, properties are, right?
11:33 Speaker 02 Yeah.
11:34 Speaker 01 People think about Queenstown, they get back from Queenstown after being on holiday, now they want to buy a house in Queenstown. They think about something like the glamorous numbers and all of a sudden that's what they convince themselves what they want to do. But it's a real balance as advisors between telling people what they should do based on our experience, but also, you're right, you've got to give people the option to do it themselves as well, because it's their money at the end of the day. As frustrating as it can be, it sounds like you did the right thing, you did everything you could. And Stevie, the stuff that you're not supposed to say, is there a type of investor that you just can't actually help? And what do you do when someone like that does come to see you?
12:12 Speaker 02 I want to think that we can help everyone, but the reality is that if you are not willing to take advice or just take into consideration an alternative way of thinking about money, then a financial advisor really can't help you. And I think back to a client that I sat down with who is from the Czech Republic originally, living in New Zealand, has been here for about eight years now. And we had this really deep conversation because we were coming up against roadblocks and lots of issues around the fundamentals of investing in property in New Zealand. And when it came down to it, she was talking to me about growing up in a communist country and it just, her upbringing was so much different to what New Zealanders have gone through and also what the market has been like.
12:55 Speaker 02 And so her whole idea is, I need to invest in gold and nothing else and you can't convince me otherwise and oh, I saw this with property. In the Czech Republic and understanding that it's such a different way of thinking. Everyone in New Zealand thinks differently because we weren't, we didn't grow up in that, that sort of environment. And so she was so resistant to alternative advice and I actually had to tell her, hey, my role here is to look at the data, look at the investment that you're considering, which is property in New Zealand, and give you the right advice for you. And you need to decide whether you can take that or whether you can trust that. And it came down to, that was not the right time for her because she just couldn't get out of that headspace. And so if you're going to see someone, you do need to just go into it with an open mind and look through data.
13:39 Speaker 02 We can, we can take you through as much data as you may need to get comfortable, but you do have to be open to that.
13:44 Speaker 00 And if we really want to get into the juicy confessions, what I really want to know is, have you ever fired a property investor? Have you ever fired a client? And what pushed you to that point?
13:54 Speaker 02 So.
13:55 Speaker 01 Nefy, I, uh, the nefy, the nice nefy. I can't believe you're the one answering this.
14:00 Speaker 02 Watch me about to get fired. I am. So fired would be a strong word, but maybe paused, paused a client before. And generally it has been, often I find people that are highly intelligent, generally where their jobs involve scrutinizing a lot of data and information. They've been trained to do that and they've been doing it for years. So it's really difficult as an advisor to come to them with the data because they come back and they say, well, my friend said this and, you know, my plumber said that, my gardener said this. And it does get to a point where there's so much pushback. There's only so much information you can give them. If they just don't trust you yet, or they're just not ready, sometimes you have to say, listen, it doesn't sound like you're ready yet. Your risk tolerance isn't ready. Why don't we just pause this for six months? Do some study, marinate on it for a bit and then let's come back to this.
14:43 Speaker 01 You're talking about engineers, aren't you?
14:45 Speaker 02 Maybe.
14:46 Speaker 01 And Stevie, final question from me. Just talk about the show. Why does she owns this actually need to exist?
14:52 Speaker 02 We have this simple philosophy that women should own more of the country. So there was a study done that we were talking about in the first episode of this podcast, where only 33% of Gen Z women own their own home versus 53% of Gen Z men. So that's a 20 percentage point gap. And for millennials, it's 47% of women owning their own home and 66% of guys. So it's not that we want guys to own less, but we do want women to own more.
15:20 Speaker 01 And actually, because I listened to that episode, which was great, by the way, there was another point in it, and I'll butcher this, but I'm pretty sure it was something along the lines of females more than males thought that property was a good investment and more so than were actually investing. What do you think that is?
15:36 Speaker 02 That's exactly right. So the desire to own property is stronger with women and yet they own less. And so we were digging into this and thinking about the fact that generally speaking, women are a bit more risk adverse. And as well as that, we do think as two people who have read a lot of books, we've watched a lot of webinars, we have watched a lot of YouTube, there aren't many resources that are targeted to women. And I do think that women and men take in information more. And, you know, there's only so many videos of men talking about finance. Sorry.
16:05 Speaker 01 Whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa. Cut, cut, cut that part out, David.
16:10 Speaker 02 That we can take. So we wanted to create a safe space for women to talk about finance.
16:14 Speaker 00 And She Owns This is now live. So if you liked this conversation, you're going to absolutely love the full show. That's where Stevie and Niffy go deeper on the stuff that, to be honest, advisors usually keep to themselves. So we're talking about real stories, real numbers and real talk about money. You can listen to it now if you search She Owns This on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts. We'll also get producer Dave to drop those links below because in the last 15 minutes, you've learned confessions of a property investment addict, the hardest conversations these advisors have had to have, and the tough advice most property investors really need to hear. Right, let's wrap it up there. But please don't forget to rate, review and subscribe to the podcast. Really does help us get the message out to more people.
17:03 Speaker 00 Thanks for listening to the Property Academy Podcast. I'm your host, Stephen Knight.
17:06 Speaker 01 And I'm Dr Michael.
17:07 Speaker 00 We're going to be back here tomorrow with even more daily strategies, tactics and insights to help you get the most out of the new estate property market. Until next time.
Previous Which Makes You Richer – Property or Business? (It’s Not What You Think)⎟Ep. 2386 Next A Sneaky Peek at the Property Deals We’re Recommending Right Now⎟Ep. 2388 Page updated November 14, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated