Pod Insights The Property Academy Podcast Auckland’s Lost Decade: When Do Prices Come Back?⎟Ep. 2489 About this episode Auckland used to lead New Zealand's property market. So why has it spent the last decade falling behind?
In this episode, Ed and Andrew unpack Auckland's "lost decade", why prices have lagged behind much of the country, and when the city's property market could finally start catching up again. You'll learn:
Why Auckland has underperformed for the last decade How one small town could theoretically overtake Auckland's average house price When Auckland could finally return to its 2021 peak A decade can change a lot. But the last 10 years ... is not necessarily a good indicator of future growth.
Book a meeting https://bit.ly/3QE2XJN to start your path to financial freedom with a detailed financial plan for $0.
For more from Opes Partners:
Sign up for the weekly Private Property newsletter https://www.opespartners.co.nz/newsletter-sign-upInstagram https://www.instagram.com/opes_partners/TikTok https://www.tiktok.com/@opespartners
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 Hello and welcome along to the Property Academy Podcast by Obus Partners. I'm your host, Stephen Knight.
0:04 Speaker 01 And I'm your nickel.
0:04 Speaker 00 And this is the show that helps Kiwis go from zero to five investment property. So you could be financially free and stick around for the next 15 minutes because you're going to learn the reasons why Auckland has been New Zealand's worst performing property market for a decade. When this small town could have more expensive house prices than our largest city. And when Auckland house prices could finally start going up. Now, the reason I wanted to talk about this is because Matt, who's our listener of the show, emailed me in and he said, with you and Andrew being so bullish on Auckland's kind of medium term and in terms of house prices going up, when might we finally see some sustained capital growth in Auckland?
0:44 Speaker 00 Because it's been three false starts and counting and it's been a long time between martinis.
0:51 Speaker 01 Maybe for you, not, not, not, not us. But yeah, Matt, I agree.
0:55 Speaker 00 So what, I mean, what are your initial thoughts? Cause I've got some data, right? But what are your initial thoughts on Matt's question?
1:00 Speaker 01 I completely agree, Matt. It has been, it has felt like a bit of a grind in Auckland, like not only property prices, but also the rental market has been really tough or much tougher than it has been in the past. And a lot of my investors and myself, like when you buy a property and you're kind of, you know, you're topping up that property, it is a bit disheartening when you see the market go down or just even stay flat for a period of time. Cause you think, well, maybe the Auckland market's just screwed. Like I could understand how people would think that.
1:28 Speaker 00 Well, I think the timing on Matt's question is pretty perfect because we're actually about to hit a record that basically nobody wants. So I was on News Talk ZB the other day with Heather Duplessis Allen, who I was kind of quite scared to talk to her. Cause she's like, oh, cause when she like, when she rips into somebody and like gives them a hard time.
1:44 Speaker 01 Oh, you thought you couldn't handle yourself against her.
1:47 Speaker 00 Well, she, well, she's, she's a tough woman, right? And I was like, oh gosh, hopefully this goes well. Anyway, we're, we're great mates. We had a wonderful time having a wee chat chat. And we were talking about this specifically. And one thing that came up is that New Zealand's current housing downturn is on track to be the longest in modern history. Cause we're about four and a half years and, and I think the longest on record, if we go back to like. 1962, the longest was about five years. So depending on what happens over the next couple of months, we could even pass that. Of course, on the show previously, we've talked about how the the average downturn is around four and a half years. So, yep, we're on average. This could go a little bit longer. And she actually wanted to know the same thing. At what point could Auckland house prices start going up?
2:32 Speaker 00 Now, I think the honest starting point is that Auckland's property prices have kind of been the dog of the New Zealand market for around about a decade, right?
2:41 Speaker 01 Yeah, and we actually just released a new long term capital growth calculator, where you can actually see how fast house prices have gone up over whatever period of time you want to look at. So we normally say 10 years is a good length of time in Auckland. So look at the last 10 years with the growth in in Auckland. The average growth rate for the last 10 years in Auckland is 1.9%.
3:03 Speaker 00 So you buy a property 10 years ago.
3:05 Speaker 01 Yeah.
3:06 Speaker 00 And you hold it and it goes up on average by 1.9% per year.
3:09 Speaker 01 Compounding, right? But like, that's bugger all. And inflation could be more than that.
3:14 Speaker 00 I mean, inflation was was way more than that. And the other thing that's interesting is that there are lots of other areas that have done much better than Auckland over the last 10 years. Now, I'm just going to scroll through all 67 areas and we are going to just pick a random one, right? Here we go. I've chosen a random one. So what have I chosen? Because I'm blind, Andrew. Kaikoura.
3:34 Speaker 01 Yeah.
3:35 Speaker 00 So if we look at Kaikoura, if you bought 10 years ago, the market's up about 7.1%, 7.2%.
3:42 Speaker 01 Right. Can you imagine? Can you imagine 10 years ago, us saying, don't buy in Auckland, buy in Kaikoura, you'll get a much better return? Like, people would think we're off our heads.
3:52 Speaker 00 Well, I mean, does that, does it surprise you that Auckland's had a bit of a rough time?
3:57 Speaker 01 I mean, it doesn't, because when we think about the timing, like Auckland and Wellington have just been beaten by this like downturn. And so, you know, Auckland, you're down like 20 something percent, Wellington, you're down 30%. So now, if you're taking a 10 year view over the last, you know, three, four, five years, you've just basically been pulverized. And Auckland was a bit clunky before that anyway. So, um, so ye- yes, the number is quite low, but it does make sense when you put it into context that we are talking about averages and we've just had that downturn.
4:28 Speaker 00 And I know we were just speaking on another video about, okay, Auckland's had it rough, but it doesn't always have it rough.
4:37 Speaker 01 So if we look at, say, a 10 year view and we use a 6% growth, right? So, so we're using much higher than what it has been for the last 10 years, like three times as much. Um, 86.3% of the time, if you take a 10 year view, Auckland has achieved 6% or greater compounding for that 10 year stretch. So again, not all the time, like still 14% of the time, you didn't get that kind of result. But actually, those odds, they're pretty good.
5:07 Speaker 00 Well, I think the other thing is there is a real danger in thinking that if something is currently happening, it's just going to continue on forever, right? So some people could look at that and say, well, Auckland's 10 year average has been 1.9%. And so it's actually just going to continue to underperform forever. And it's quite interesting because if I look at like another small town that I just, I beg on constantly, right?
5:30 Speaker 01 Oh, you're not going to do it again, are you?
5:33 Speaker 00 Well, which one do you think I'm going to talk about?
5:35 Speaker 01 Twisel, because actually I was out with some mortgage brokers last week.
5:38 Speaker 00 Oh, were you?
5:39 Speaker 01 And one of them said, you need to stop begging on Twisel. I was like, no, no, no.
5:45 Speaker 00 I've been EO'd to property at Twisel.
5:46 Speaker 01 Of course he does. Yeah. And actually he's done really well. Um, and actually his, his, um, his business partner was like, nah, Twisel, Andrew's completely right about that.
5:57 Speaker 00 Well, one thing, uh, one other part of the country I beg on all the time is Kawato. Now, Kawato is a tiny little town of 6,000 people that is, oh, I'm not even going to show you the results yet, Andrew. I'm going to make you wait with anticipation. Um, a tiny little town of 6,000 people that is like completely surrounded by Fokatane district. It's in the Bay of Plenty, right? And it, it, it used to have like a paper mill that, that provided lots of jobs. Um, recently closed down or closed down a couple of years ago. Now, if we look at Kawato, over the last 10 years, property prices are up an average of 13.1%.
6:34 Speaker 01 That means again, like.
6:35 Speaker 00 Over 10 years.
6:36 Speaker 01 If you look at that and you're like, okay, that seems like a better investment than Auckland. Like you've got to be really careful with just looking at those kinds of numbers and thinking that's the opportunity.
6:46 Speaker 00 If you think that, okay, this is just going to continue on. So Auckland's going up at 1.9%. Kawato's going up at 13.1%. If we just take those numbers forward. Now, remember the median sale price in Auckland is a million, a million $10,000, like just a touch over a million bucks. Kawato's $406,000 at the moment, right? So if we run that forward, in nine years, by 2035, less than a decade, the average Kawato house will be worth more than the average Auckland house.
7:19 Speaker 01 I'd be willing to bet that that's not going to be the case.
7:22 Speaker 00 Well, it's probably not going to be the case that the small town of 6,000 people, sorry for anybody who lives in Kawato, but it's nice to know you guys.
7:28 Speaker 01 They don't have the internet there.
7:29 Speaker 00 I was just about to make that joke, Andrew. You've stolen it again. But it's nice to know they have Starlink now. But it's unlikely in my mind that we're going to see that rate continue where Kawato keeps running, running ahead and then Auckland lags behind. What's more likely to happen is that Kawato runs out of a bit of puff and Auckland speeds up again to a more normal rate of growth. And that's just all to say that effectively, the last 10 years, or whatever window you're looking at, is not necessarily a good indicator of future growth. I mean, that is effectively what people mean when they say past performance is not the best indicator of future performance. And actually, there was another point that
8:11 Speaker 00 I thought you, um, here you go. You don't usually get a compliment out of me, but there was another point that you made in your recent private property newsletter about why Auckland had done particularly bad over the last 10 years. I thought, I thought it was a reasonably well-made point for you. And the point you're effectively making is that the 10-year growth that, that any asset has depends on where you start measuring it. So if you start the clock of those 10 years at the very start of the boom and you end it at the top of a boom, you could have an amazing growth rate. Similarly, if you start it halfway through a boom and then finish it at the end of a downturn, there might be almost no growth within those 10 years. And so the, the amount of growth you look at depends on which period you look at. Is there a
8:56 Speaker 00 Similar to.
8:57 Speaker 01 That's why, that's why often when you see developers quoting numbers around your historic growth rates, they can be quite um selective around what uh duration they're gonna use.
9:09 Speaker 00 Well, there was actually a very interesting scenario as well, just as we were coming out of COVID. So a year after COVID, remember how um we went into lockdown? Lots and lots of the share market just plunged in value, right? Then it rocketed back and the FMA came out and uh gave a a warning to, or a directive, I suppose, to all um fund managers, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey. We don't want you saying that your annual returns were twenty five percent. But from March twenty twenty to March twenty twenty one, because if you started looking at April twenty twenty to April twenty twenty one, the at the the average return might be, say, seven percent.
9:55 Speaker 00 So the window you look at very much impacts what the return is. That's the whole reason we created this other calculator to say, hey, that's fine. Let's not look at one window, let's look at two hundred and eighty seven windows, right? Let's look at as many as we can and see what happens over those windows that you wanna look at, in this case, ten years. And one reason that Auckland has underperformed is that if you start the clock exactly ten years ago, from two thousand and twelve to two thousand and sixteen, Auckland went on this massive boom run, right? House prices absolutely skyrocketed after the GFC. Then the Reserve Bank came out with new LVR restrictions. They they made investors, or they said to investors, you've got to have a bigger deposit
10:37 Speaker 00 to buy an ha- uh a house in Auckland compared to buying a house anywhere else. So Auckland started petering out, all of the investors decided to buy elsewhere. And so you're starting the the ten year clock at the end of their boom and you're finishing the clock at the end of a downturn, so of course it's gonna underperform. Compare that to Christchurch where the ten year clock right now starts right before they go through this massive boom. House prices come a little bit back, but now they're reaching record highs again. And so you you the the. When you start the 10 year clock or the 15 year clock really matters, which is why Auckland's done particularly bad, but I'm not sure if that will continue. Because if we think about the next 10 years, we're not starting at the top of a boom.
11:20 Speaker 00 We're starting at the bottom of a downturn and so the return is likely to be higher than the 1.9% that you've had over the last 10 years.
11:27 Speaker 01 And I think for most investors, if you are looking at Auckland at the moment and you're thinking, oh God, what are the rates going to be in the future? Is the market just, you know, completely caught there because there's so many more properties there now? There's been all this kind of conversation around poorly built townhouses and maybe that's affected the market. Just remember that Auckland represents, what is it, 30% of the population?
11:51 Speaker 00 Yeah, about a third.
11:52 Speaker 01 Like huge, right? And I think it's forecast to get to 40%. Like as long as those forecasts are even within kooie of being correct, that's going to put a massive amount of pressure on the existing stock at the moment. And whilst it might not feel like there's a shortage today, five years from now, you'll be reading Auckland house prices rocketing, skyrocketing, housing shortage, housing prices, all those kinds of things again, and we go through the whole cycle again.
12:20 Speaker 00 I mean, how similar does this feel to previous cycles? You've probably been through two, this is probably your third market cycle, right? How similar does this feel to other market downturns that you have been through?
12:32 Speaker 01 It's funny because I was just on a podcast the other day, not our podcast, someone else's podcast, I'm talking about this and this one's been a lot more, I wouldn't say relaxing for me, but, but I kind of, I kind of go with the flow a lot more now. And because this one's been more extreme from a numbers perspective, I'm glad I've gone through that in the past because I'm just kind of, yeah, this is what happens and just stay the course. Whereas someone that hadn't gone through that, who had just lost money and never experienced a good market, probably could give up a lot easier.
13:05 Speaker 00 That's quite interesting. I was talking to a financial advisor who, who manages money for like mega, mega millionaires, right? And we were talking about market cycles and she's been in the game for, you know, 30. Thirty plus years. And she said, I'm just so bored of market cycles now. You know, people freak out and then I tell them to just stay the course. And then it's going to go up and it rockets back. Now, I mean, I appreciated her attitude around that. Of course, different people have different tolerances for risk. But I, I mean, I felt it somewhat, I found it somewhat reassuring in that like, oh, cool. You know, you're like, oh, well, we go through different market cycles.
13:38 Speaker 01 Yeah. And, and I think, um, because of, because of those, because of those negative experiences, you can actually, um, weather the storm a lot better mentally.
13:47 Speaker 00 Now, if we've come back to that, that question that Matt had, which is, but how long for house prices to recover? And we specifically look in Auckland, these are the numbers that I shared on News Talk ZB recently. So if we think about how long is it going to take for house prices to get back to where they were in about November 2021? Auckland's currently 23% below where it was way back in the day. So if you bought a property for a million bucks back then, there is a chance it could be worth $770,000 today. So for, for house prices to get back to that million bucks, we need house prices to go up by about 30%. Now I created what's called a Monte Carlo simulation. I've talked about this previously on the show
14:29 Speaker 00 to understand the percentage chance that like, if the market performs, you know, on average, like it has in the past, in terms of sometimes being up, sometimes being down, how long might it take to recover? I give it about a 33% chance that the market recovers within three years. So that's like not much of a chance, not much of a chance that it recovers in three years, but a small chance. I give it a 50% chance that it recovers within five years. Okay. So five years to get an extra 30%, that, that sounds about what it's been in the past. And I give it a 75% chance that house prices recover within 11 years. So about a, about a coin flip chance that the market recovers back to where it was in five years.
15:11 Speaker 00 A, a pretty good chance, a three in four chance that it happens within the decade, basically is what I'm saying. I mean, if we think about that, that would mean that house prices get back to the peak. If we think about that 50 50 chance by about 2031. I mean, how does that feel to you? What's your reaction to that?
15:30 Speaker 01 I'd actually be surprised if it hadn't by that stage. I really do think it would. And, and, you know, if you are an investor who has just experienced a downturn in Auckland, like that, the financially smart thing to do, now it's subject to your needing to and being comfortable with this, is dollar cost average. If you go and buy a property today while it's discounted, you hopefully get that 30% rise on another property. Now, again, that's a very general statement. I don't want anyone to go out and do that without actually talking to a financial advisor, but that's what I'd be doing.
16:02 Speaker 00 But look, I also don't want to oversell it, right? Because there is an honest caveat here in that there are some things that could mean that Auckland maybe doesn't get that big catch up that we're expecting. So, I mean, what are some of the things that would make you not buy into that Auckland catch up story?
16:20 Speaker 01 I think the, the supply conversation, like there is a lot of talk, like I said before, around oversupply of townhouses. Now, we've covered this on the show before. I don't really buy into that, that word of oversupply because really that just becomes a pricing issue. But, you know, there has been more availability than there had been in the past. And so, so that would be something that maybe people would be worried about. And then maybe just kind of issues around people's incomes. So now, now that we've got DTIs in place that limit the amount of money that you can borrow from the bank and it's kind of tied to your income. Well, incomes aren't creeping up that quickly at the moment.
16:57 Speaker 00 Now, I suppose that kind of bear case, I suppose, this, the case that Auckland continues to underperform is that Auckland sped away after the, the GFC, right? And maybe this is just everyone catching up and it's, it's just some comeuppance for the Auckland market rather than, we usually talk about the Auckland market like a coiled spring. Okay, it hasn't gone yet. It hasn't gone yet. It's underperformed for a while. Perhaps this is just, um, uh, house prices coming back to more affordable levels and then we start to see that expansion again. But maybe that, there is a case for that not to happen, right? But then on the other hand, I often think about Ireland as well. After the two, about 2006, 2007, Ireland went
17:38 Speaker 00 through one of the largest house price downturns in the history of the world. It was like down over 50%, like nudging up towards 60%. Now, if you were sitting in Ireland, you'd think, oh my gosh, house prices are never going to ever recover. But today, like not that long after, I think it was about 10 years from the downturn for, for prices to get back to their, their peak. But today, house prices are higher than they were back in the peak in 2006. Now, that was like double the downturn that we've gone through, over, over double the downturn we've been through.
18:11 Speaker 01 Double the downturn. And it was, it was brutal, like I remember. In fact, I'm working with a client right now whose parents basically lost pretty much all of their money that was in some rental properties because of that downturn and not being able to weather the storm.
18:25 Speaker 00 But I also take that as like, oh, wow. Even in one of the frothiest markets that have ever happened in terms of Irish house prices, then the downturn, it's interesting to see, okay, eventually it recovers. There are some instances where massive house price downturns haven't recovered. I remember doing a video, talking about the Japanese house price downturn, where actually house prices today have not recovered back to the point where they were in the like early to late 90s, but most of the time they do. And so that's kind of the bet that I'm willing to take. And over the last 15 minutes, you've learned the reasons why Auckland has been New Zealand's worst performing market in a decade, when this small town could have more expensive house prices than our largest city, and when Auckland house prices could finally start going up again.
19:09 Speaker 00 Right, let's wrap it up there, but please don't forget to rate, review and subscribe to the podcast. Really does help us get the message out to more people.
19:23 Speaker 00 Thanks for listening to the Property Academy Podcast. I'm your host, Stephen Dye. I'm Andrew Nickel. We're going to be back here tomorrow with even more daily strategies, tactics and insights to help you get the most of the news on the property market. Until next time.
Previous She Spent Almost Six Figures Just To Sell Her House⎟Ep. 2488 Next The Deposit Gift Mistake That Ends Up In Court⎟Ep. 2490 Page updated November 14, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated