Pod Insights The Property Academy Podcast 7 Signs You’re About to Buy the Wrong Property⎟Ep. 2412 About this episode One bad property decision… could cost you $750,000. In this episode, Ed and Andrew break down the 7 biggest warning signs that you’re about to buy the wrong property – including a real story of a buyer who overpaid at the peak and got stuck when the market turned. You’ll learn: The 7 red flags that signal a bad investment before you buy Why chasing a “bargain” or a booming market can backfire The costly mistakes ... like skipping due diligence or misunderstanding what you’re buying The key takeaway? Most bad property deals don’t look bad at first. They feel excited, logical, even “safe.” But if you ignore the fundamentals, one wrong purchase can set you back years. And here is the 23 Step Checklist to use before you commit to any property – whether you’re an investor buying a new build, purchasing an existing rental, or even buying your first home. If a property can’t pass these checks, walk away. For more from Opes Partners:Sign up for the weekly Private Property newsletterInstagramTikTok
Transcript 0:08 Speaker 00 Hello and welcome along to the Property Academy Podcast by Opes Partners. I'm your host, Stephen Knight. And I'm Nick the Nickel. And this is the show that helps Kiwis go from zero to five investment property so you can be financially free and stick around for the next 15 minutes because you're going to learn the seven signs that you're buying the wrong property, the property investor who lost $750,000 with nothing to show for it, and why the bargain property could actually be the one that ruins your portfolio. Now, I saw this amazing story, Andrew, on Radio New Zealand. There was this buyer called Mr. Singh. Now, Mr. Singh signs up to buy a property in Auckland at the absolute peak of the market. A few years ago. Yep, in 2021, and he agrees to pay about $1.9 million to buy a property, right? He
0:51 Speaker 00 does it at auction, right? And this was well above what the real estate agents thought that this property was worth. Now, this buyer thinks he's pretty clever. He's seen property prices go up, and so he negotiates for what's called a deferred settlement. And then for anyone new to the show, what's a deferred settlement? He's just going to pay for it later on. So he's not going to be able to move into it, but he's basically agreeing to the price $1.9 million today. I'll pay you next year. And so the couple are like, sweet, that's all good. We can still live in this for a year. And then he's like, okay, I know I'm signed up. I have to buy this property, but I'm going to sell it straight away. So I'm going to find another buyer to buy this property off me at a higher price. And then rather than me having to pay Mr. and Mrs.
1:36 Speaker 00 Smith, I'll just take the money, pass it on to them, and I'll keep the extra if I sell it at that higher price. And so he's thinking, okay, I've got these people on the hook to sell it to me. I've paid them a little bit of a margin, and they've given me this discretion to have another year. He's allowed to because now he's essentially the owner, even though he doesn't own it yet. Because he's got a contract and he's paid the deposit, he can go find another buyer. And in the event that that person will pay more money, it'll change hands on the same day, for example, and he'll just margin the difference. So he reckons he's going to make a couple of hundred thousand dollars. So as soon as he's unconditional, he puts a for sale sign out the front. Imagine if you were the people that sold to him. I think their name actually was Mr. and Mrs. Smith. Actually.
2:20 Speaker 00 So imagine this though, you've taken on that deal thinking, okay, we've got a really good price for that. And then all of a sudden you get the sign put out and that sneaky buyer is just gonna sell that property for more money. I could understand how that would feel a bit gross. Well, the sellers actually said it was okay that he could find another buyer, but they were like, no, we didn't agree to you putting a for sale sign out the front. Right. But we did agree to have viewings. Now, here's the interesting thing. They're used to viewing. Mr. Singh did get a buyer interested at two point one five million dollars. So that's about two hundred and fifty grand more that he bought this property for. Okay. He rejected it. He wanted an extra three hundred thousand dollars.
3:04 Speaker 00 He wants, he wants about two point four million dollars for this property. And then the market tanks, Auckland prices drop like a stone. He still has to buy the property for one point nine million dollars, can't find anyone to buy the property off him, can't get the money. So the current owners, they need to resell it. They end up selling it for just over one point one million dollars. And then Mr. Singh is on the hook for seven hundred and fifty thousand dollars. Because they sold it for about seven hundred and fifty K less than what, what he had signed a contract to pay. He's still on the hook for those seven hundred and fifty thousand dollars of worth of damages.
3:42 Speaker 00 I think that's something that people forget. So people think if I pay a deposit, so Mr. Singh might have thought, I'll pay my ten percent deposit, for example, or maybe even negotiate a five percent deposit. So paid a hundred grand as my deposit. And then when he can't find a buyer and defaults on the settlement, he's still responsible for the losses that they incur. It's not like you just pay the deposit and walk away. So they could potentially bankrupt him if he can't pay that money. And because properties are worth so much cash, right? And the risks are so large, that's why people need to understand these seven signs that they are buying the wrong property. So what is the, what is the first sign?
4:21 Speaker 00 Sign number one is you're chasing a booming market. So in this example, Mr. Singh ultimately was chasing a booming market and it can be like. Obviously, what he's done here is he's snatched defeat from the jaws of victory by rejecting a very, very good offer. He could have made a couple of hundred grand, see he's lost, say, almost a million dollars because he's just that little bit greedy, chasing the boom. And I think you've got to look at a market, if you're looking, particularly if you're doing a flip or something like this, or contemporary, a settlement. A market that's already kind of had that rise, you've got to be really careful in thinking, okay, well, twelve months down the track, maybe that's going to peter off or maybe it's going to pull back because if you're doing that,
5:03 Speaker 00 as soon as that starts dropping, fewer people are buying, it can erode your profits and get into the negatives really, really quickly. And I think there's a real risk of that in even today's market. So right now, if I were looking at doing a deal like this, I would say, okay, well, Auckland's undervalued. Maybe there's an opportunity there. Maybe there's a way I can make money there. Maybe a little bit less so in Christchurch, I might be able to do the same thing. But if you take somewhere like Immaculate, right? Right now, prices have been pretty hot, like they're up about nineteen percent since the trough. And the QV index shows eight point two percent annual growth last year. So it's one of the strongest regions around. And you might think, wow, Immaculate was going really well.
5:48 Speaker 00 That's an opportunity. I can get some quick gains. But here's the thing, let's say house prices in Immaculate are only going to go up forty percent this boom. And they're already up nineteen percent. So you've only got twenty one percent left, like just made up numbers. Whereas if you go to an area like Auckland again, because we haven't started to have that recovery yet, you might have forty percent that you can still gain out of this next boom. Well, I suppose if you think about one of the greatest investors in history, Warren Buffett, right? He doesn't look at Nvidia and say, oh, Nvidia's booming. I've got to get in pretty quickly. I better buy some shares. And then I'm going to sell them in a year's time. I'm going to make all this money.
6:30 Speaker 00 His whole idea is I'm going to go around looking for undervalued companies and I'm going to buy and I'm going to hold for forty years, rather than chasing whatever's booming at the moment. And I think that we apply. By that logic, and the logic's pretty clear when we're talking about shares, we don't necessarily apply the same thinking to property. I think the second sign that you're buying the wrong property is if you've only looked at the rent and the mortgage. Now, this doesn't matter whether you're a first home buyer or you're an investor. What so many people do is they go to a mortgage calculator and they say, okay, righty-o. I'm gonna buy five hundred thousand dollars to buy this property. And it's going to cost me a weekly payment of five hundred ninety-one dollars. Okay, the mortgage is five hundred ninety-one dollars.
7:12 Speaker 00 The rent is six hundred dollars a week. So sweet. It's all good. It's paying for itself. Good deal. But what they have factored in, and this is both first home buyers and investors, are things like rates and insurance and maintenance and property management. Or if you are a property investor, vacancy, because you aren't gonna have a tenant in there fifty-two weeks of the year. Sometimes the tenant's gonna give notice and is gonna move out. That'll happen roughly every two years, depending on what you've bought. So you're not always gonna have a tenant in there. And those non-mortgage costs can add up to eight to eleven thousand dollars a year. And that's even before we start thinking about the mortgage as well. And the issue that I see is that sometimes both investors and first home buyers start struggling
7:55 Speaker 00 because they face all of these costs that they weren't actually thinking about. And if you're not sure whether the property that you're looking at is gonna pass all of these seven tests, I've actually put together this checklist that you can use when you buy a property. It includes the twenty-three steps that our property team uses when they're looking for new build investment properties for our clients. And you can download it with the link below. I'll put that down in the description so you can get it all. What's sign number three? Sign number three is when you start to look for a Frankenstein property. And what I mean by that is there are properties which are higher growth and they will go up at a faster rate than other properties, but they tend not to have as good cash flow. And then there are yield properties which have better cash flow,
8:38 Speaker 00 but they typically won't go up in value as fast as high-growth properties. Now, there's just a trade-off. Like, that's just the way that it works. You can be high-growth or you can be high-yield. Not always a straight line. Most people, what I find they do is they buy the property that they're comfortable with and they kind of make the yields work. Or they, they just buy somewhere in the middle. And as a result, like they buy properties that are lemons. They're not, neither great growth or neither great yield. And again, I just think it's because people don't set their buying criteria at the start. I had, I had a podcast listener email me at the weekend, actually. And because I've got two kids now and no life, I was sitting answering emails Saturday night at like 10 o'clock.
9:19 Speaker 00 And they were looking for exactly this. They're like, we want a really good growth property with really great rental income. I was like, don't we all? And so then kind of started to tease out, well, what's your priority? Because once you figure out what your priority is, wealth later or cash flow now. Then you can start to actually analyse what's right or wrong. Now, sign number four is if you're thinking like a homeowner as opposed to an investor. Now, this one really impacts first time investors. So if you are buying that first investment property, maybe you've only ever bought a, a house for yourself to live in, right? And so the way you're used to looking at houses is just like you normally do. So you look for what sort of house would you specifically like to live in?
10:03 Speaker 00 And I always think if you already own a house and you're looking to buy a second one, you're above average income. You're not the average person anymore, right? Your incomes and your wealth will be above average. And so typically the mistakes I see first time investors do is they look for things like a pool. Or being close to shops or being in a good school zone, right? And because I now am married to a financial advisor, we talk a lot about shares at home. And we were driving in the car the other day and I said, it is exactly like my food bag. So do you remember when my food bag listed on the stock exchange, right? And I mean, there are a number of reasons why my food bag has absolutely tanked, right? When it listed, I think it opened at about a dollar seventy five a share.
10:45 Speaker 00 And now it's trading at like 20 cents a share, right? It is absolutely tanked. But I think the way that unsophisticated investors go about investing in shares is go, I like my food bag. I buy my food bag. I buy my food bag. Makes sense. I like the company. I know something about that product because I've purchased it in the past. So I've got some insider knowledge because I've used Nadia Libs sources in the past. So I'm gonna buy those shares. But actually, that doesn't mean that that dollar seventy five that it opened at, or whatever it happened to be, was a fair price for the company. It didn't mean that it was a well-run company. Ultimately, the share price has absolutely tanked.
11:27 Speaker 00 Now, I used my food bag. I thought it was a pretty good product, especially during lockdown. But just because I I'd used it in the past didn't mean that the share was a good investment. And just because you might own a home where you think the school zone's good, or it's got a pool, or this sort of house would suit me absolutely fine, it doesn't mean that it's a good investment. Because when we're thinking about investment, we've got to think about the rent and the cash flow, and how much you're paying for the property. All of these things matter as opposed to the pool, or close to shops, or all of these other things, right? So when you make investments, you can't be in that consumer mindset, right? We've got to be doing things differently, and it starts with the numbers first,
12:13 Speaker 00 as opposed to thinking about, would we live in this Deirdre? Do we really like this? To be honest, the average person listening to the show probably is not married to a person called Deirdre, because because most people are in their thirties rather than their nineties. Sorry, somebody's gonna be called Deirdre listening to this and get very offended by that. Um, that was a great example, by the way. My food bag was a, that was a moment of clarity in your Essex of my mind. So number five is when you actually don't know what you're buying. And again, that's kind of like those people I was talking about before, where, you know, they think they know what their criteria is, but they don't. You wouldn't believe how many people buy properties and they don't know exactly what it is they're buying. And I'll give you two examples. Let's use new builds because that's something we specialise in. There are two types of new builds. People just think, oh, it's new, they're all the same. It's not the case.
12:57 Speaker 00 So you can buy a turnkey new build where you go to a developer and you're buying a completed property that's yet to be built. So it's, you're gonna buy it when it's finished. You're not going to be responsible. The construction or the build overruns or any of those kind of things, you pay a deposit, you settle it at the end. At a fixed price. At a fixed price. That's what a turnkey is. Now, you can also have a build where you buy the land, you engage the builder to build the product on top, you're responsible for the landscaping, you're responsible for some of the appliances, all of those kind of things. And that's called a progressive payment build. Now, with those, they can often seem cheaper. And we did a video on this years ago, I was trying to find it at the weekend, but basically you're buying the land, it might be two hundred grand,
13:42 Speaker 00 and you might be building the house, that might be three hundred grand. You think five hundred thousand's a really good value. But then the turnkey might be, let's call it five hundred and thirty. Now, by the time you buy the land and you build the house and you make stage payments and you pay interest on the mortgage you're taking out, which is increasing over the next six months, nine months while it's being built, then you pay for all the extra stuff, all of a sudden, this one might cost more than the turnkey build, but because you didn't know the difference of what you were building, well then, you've taken on more risk because with a progressive payment build, you're responsible for those overruns and you might end up paying more money anyway, all because you got suckered into a different type of product.
14:23 Speaker 00 And specifically with that, I think the part that people really don't understand is with a turnkey, for instance, you are buying the finished product at a fixed price. If you are going down a progressive payment, you are hiring the builder to build you the house. Now, if the builder takes more time, whose problem is that? That's yours. You're the one who's got to pay more money to the bank because you got those mortgage payments, even if you've got a fixed price contract. If they have to sub out different materials or, oh, we can't get that one, we've got to do something else, all of it becomes your problem as opposed to the developer's problem. And I think that's the part that people don't realise. Like, if you, if I hire a plumber to come and do a service at my house, like, if it takes twice as long, that's my fault. I'm, or it's not my fault, but I'm the one footing. It's your responsibility.
15:08 Speaker 00 I'm the one who's responsible for for fitting the bill. Yeah, if it's something different like um. Come on, Eddie, you can do it. Buying a tap, I'm buying a product. I just go to the shop and I buy that, you know. So it's not like, oh, well, actually, that tap took us a lot longer to make. I don't care, I'm buying it, it's finished now. And look, I I did say before, you got stitched into it, making it sound like you as the buyer should should have known. Be so, and to be fair, like if you're making a big transaction, you do want to do a bit of research first. But I do know that builders can sometimes make it or developers can make it a bit misleading online. Like you see on Trade Me, ads for a property and they'll say five hundred thousand dollars. But again, they don't tell you that that's not going to actually be a finished product like, yeah, it can be a bit misleading.
15:53 Speaker 00 Okay, we've got two more. What's sign number six? Sign number six, I've been guilty of it. This is what we call the gunner property. So I'm gonna do something with it. I'm gonna develop it one day. I'm gonna put some units on the back of it. And I often talk about the example of Wilson's Road, which was my gunner property. This was a property that my parents owned. It had a large section that was suitable for development. It's like five hundred fifty square meters of developable land. And I thought, okay, here's what I'm gonna do. I'm gonna buy it. I can't develop it right now because I don't have any money. But I can renovate it, I can rent it out, we'll do that for so many years and then I'll put some units on it. And then ten years later, I'd still done nothing with it, other than just had it as a rental. It was an old house, like it was a hundred year old house.
16:37 Speaker 00 The maintenance was horrific. And had it not been for a major upswing in the market and then I could exit it and sold it to another developer that did nothing with it. I would have just been, you know, in a hole there. And and I guess like, you know, you could say, well, I still made money out of it. So what was wrong with that? Well, I did because I waited long enough. And if you wait long enough, you tend to make money out of property. But that property did hold me back because it was a property, it was done in my portfolio. That I didn't have to think about, but also it was money that was tied up in that that I couldn't exit and put into something more useful. And sign number seven is if you're skipping due diligence, right? Now, you wouldn't believe that so many people will say, I don't want to spend $500 on a building inspection because that costs money.
17:23 Speaker 00 I'll just get my brother's dog's uncle's cat to inspect the property for me. But then when they buy a car, they'll pay $200 for an A A check. Is that what happens? Yeah, a hundred percent. You see, I don't buy enough cars to be able to know. I'm not fancy like you, Andrew. Nor do I. But what you can find is that that $500 or $1,000 building inspection could save you $300,000 and maintenance costs that you could avoid by not buying a dud property, or even better, you can use it to negotiate a better price. But you know, when the average reclad, if you buy a leaky home, it might cost you $150 to $500,000 to reclad at the upper end
18:04 Speaker 00 to reclad a house because it's a leaky home, right? But if you could get a standard building inspection that costs 800 bucks, you can avoid that that entire maintenance cost and really understand it. And I just think that we should never be skipping proper due diligence, right? It doesn't matter whether it's a hot market. It doesn't matter whether the auctions in three days, get the building inspection, do your proper checks on this house because you're ultimately going to pay $800,000 for it. Like, if you were to buy a $300 dress, you would, which I just did last weekend. No, I don't, I don't, I don't. Spend more. I, no, I was gonna say buy the second hand. No, and
18:49 Speaker 00 people are gonna think that's what I actually do on my weekends. You know, you would at least try it on and see if you look good, right? And I just think that we should. I'll give you another example.
18:58 Speaker 00 Give me a better example. That was a weird one. They will cut that whole one out or it might make it. No, no, leave that. And the people need to know what Ed does on his weekends. I might be answering emails, but Ed's prancing around the house in a secondhand dress.
19:12 Speaker 00 My mother listens to this show. Yeah, she knows. She knows about your, your high heels. So I had a phone call literally today as I was driving into the office about someone who bought a property in Auckland and they've skimmed on the property file. Now they're going to sell that property and the agent came around and said, okay, cool. It's a 60 square metre house. And they said, no, no, it's not 90 square metres. I'm just making up the numbers. And they said, uh, 60 says here on the property file. Uh-oh, that extra room is not consented. Oh. And because they didn't do full due diligence, now they've got a property which has got an unconceded addition. Yes.
19:53 Speaker 00 That voids the insurance. They can't sell it until it's remedied or not unless they sell it as is. That is a real problem. Oh, that's going to cost some real money to get that all. And time and stress. Well, and that's why if you're not sure whether the property that you're looking at passes these tests, and that's where you can get that 23 step checklist that our property team actually use when they're looking for investments for our clients to just make sure that you're not buying that dud property. I'll drop that link down in the show notes where you're able to download it. And over the last 15 minutes, you've learned the seven signs that you're buying the wrong property, the property investor who lost $750,000 with nothing to show for it, and why that bargain property could actually be the one that ruins your portfolio. Right, let's wrap it up there, but please don't forget to rate,
20:36 Speaker 00 review and subscribe to the podcast. Really does help us get the message out to more people.
20:47 Speaker 00 Thanks for listening to the Property Academy Podcast. I'm your host, Seb at Night. We're going to be back here tomorrow with even more daily strategies, tactics and insights to help you get the most out of your sound property market. Until next time.
Previous They Turned Their Backyard Into $36K a Year – Here’s How⎟Ep. 2411 Next Nobody Warns You About This Bank Change⎟Ep. 2413 Page updated November 14, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated