Pod Insights The Property Academy Podcast $46,000 Landlord Victory: How It Happened⎥Ep. 2212 About this episode The Tenancy Tribunal is where landlords and tenants battle it out, and sometimes the results are jaw-dropping. In this episode, Ed and Andrew unpack the five largest Tribunal cases they could find, and what they mean for landlords and tenants alike. You’ll learn:Why one landlord had to pay $21,000 for renting out an unlawful propertyHow toxic lead paint and cockroach infestations cost other landlords dearlyThe staggering case of a tenant who racked up $49,000 in unpaid rentThese are the true stories that show just how high the stakes can be in property management. Don't forget to create your free Opes+ account here. For more from Opes Partners:Sign up for the weekly Private Property newsletterInstagramTikTok
Transcript 0:08 Speaker 00 Hello and welcome along to the Property Academy Podcast by Opes Partners. I'm your host, David Knight.
0:12 Speaker 01 And I'm Andrew Nicoll.
0:12 Speaker 00 And this is the show that helps Kiwis go from zero to five investment properties. So you can be financially free and stick around for the next 15 minutes because you're going to learn the five largest tenancy tribunal cases we could possibly find. Why one landlord had to pay over $20,000 to a tenant for emotional distress. And the shocking reason why a tenant owed their landlord almost $50,000. Now, recently, we did an episode, I was quite taken with it, about whether the tenancy tribunal is rigged against landlords. And through looking at over 1,000 tenancy tribunal cases, we have found some pretty
0:52 Speaker 00 extreme and shocking instances where both landlords and tenants have got into disputes. And Andrew, what was the fifth largest case we could find?
1:01 Speaker 01 Okay, so this one was from earlier this year. So tenants had been renting their flat in Wellington for the past six years and the paint on the outside of the unit was pretty old. So the landlord organises to get it touched up. So the painters arrive, they start stripping off the old paint. Now, the interesting thing here is that dust blew some of the paint chips into the house and it went on the furniture and on to the tenant's clothes. And somehow, the tenant thought, now this is interesting, I wonder whether or not they've tested for lead. Now, I would have never have thought this myself as a landlord. When the tenant raised this as a concern, they ended up getting the Poison Control and WorkSafe Centre in and they tested it.
1:43 Speaker 01 Turns out, there was dangerously high levels of lead contamination inside and outside the property. Now, that probably wouldn't have been an issue if you weren't disrupting the paint. But when the dust is coming in and landing on your clothes, that's a real problem. Now, what happened is the tenant took the landlord to the tenancy tribunal and the tribunal ordered that the landlord pay almost $10,000 to the tenant in compensation.
2:10 Speaker 00 And that was because the tenants had to keep cleaning, they lost their outdoor space while this was all going on, they're highly stressed. And what was really interesting is the the lead dust, Andrew, started ruining the appliances, like the dishwasher and the washing machine, started getting all in there and they had to replace them. But ten thousand dollars or just over nine grand, it was nine thousand one hundred and eighty five dollars. It's a a big chunk of change when, if you think about what the landlord's position was as well, they would have probably been paying fifteen grand, twenty grand to the painters as well.
2:41 Speaker 01 Do you find it interesting that someone would even consider to get it tested, the dust tested?
2:46 Speaker 00 Well, I never would have thought about it, but maybe the tenants were feeling sick or feeling, you know, that something was a bit off. Why? What's your read on this?
2:54 Speaker 01 I was just surprised that someone even thought to do that.
2:56 Speaker 00 Now, the fourth largest case we could possibly find out of those thousand cases was, there was this tenant who moved into a Christchurch property. Now, this was back twenty twenty three. And she expected the basics, you know, a kind of warm, safe house. But instead, after she moved in, she noticed that there was cockroaches all over the place. She even noticed that, like, she she went up to her washing machine and was like, looking at the cables and she's like, looks like something's been chewing through this. Oh, it turns out it was rats. Rats were chewing into the appliances. Some of the power points didn't work and she went for, I think it was eight months without a working stove, right? So pretty bad.
3:36 Speaker 00 Now, for nearly two years, the landlord didn't even address any of these concerns with the property and and actually the tenant was very proactive. She was constantly messaging the landlord. She issued fourteen day breach notices. That's where you say to the other party, whether the landlord to the tenant or the tenant to the landlord. Hey, you're in breach of our contract. You've got fourteen days to rectify it before I take you to the tribunal. Nothing changed for two years. Now, in total, the landlord had to pay the tenant nine thousand two hundred and sixty six dollars. And do you know what? I'm a little surprised it's not more if this was going on for a whole two years. But this is one of those cases where, you know, often landlords. Talk about tenants from hell.
4:22 Speaker 00 But actually, I think this is probably an example of a landlord from hell, you know, where they've really just done the worst possible thing and it reflects badly on all of us property investors. These are quite interesting, aren't they, going through these like tenanted landlord horror stories? What was the third largest case out of the thousand we looked at?
4:38 Speaker 01 Okay, so back in nineteen ninety five, this couple buys a property. And it's not your standard house, it's a large workshop and it had a separate office and a lunchroom. And these guys were using this to run their carpet business out of. Now, over time, they made it into a more kind of livable space. So they, they put in a toilet, they put in a shower. And then they thought, okay, we don't need this anymore, we're gonna rent it out. Now, fast forward to two thousand and eighteen. A tenant moves into that small converted office and on the surface, it looks like just kind of a quirky little place for them to live. It was affordable and they think, okay, this is great, we'll live here. But legally, there was a problem. The owner hadn't actually consented the property as a dwelling, so in the eyes of the law,
5:23 Speaker 01 it's a commercial workshop, it's not a place that someone can actually reside in.
5:27 Speaker 00 Okay, okay, that's very interesting. So what happens then? So the tenant moves in in two thousand and eighteen, but this is a, a pretty recent case, so what happened?
5:37 Speaker 01 Yeah, it's recent because the tenant actually lived there for seven years and she may do. But as time went on, there started to be these issues. So the roof was leaking, there was mould, there was moss. And obviously this is not the kind of environment you want to be living in. And I remember reading that there were these translucent roofing panels, like the kind of thing you might have on a, an old garage or an old shed. And so it would become like really, really hot in the summer and then freezing in the winter. And the problem was the landlords often blurred the lines between this being their property, because they lived nearby, so they just kept showing up and the tenant just having this safe space for themselves to be able to occupy.
6:15 Speaker 00 And that main issue as well is that there was this big workshop, right? And the, the landlords still used the big workshop as their storage space. So they're coming along, having a look at their storage space, getting stuff out, putting stuff in. And it's the converted office on the side that the tenant's living in. And so, oh, yahoo, anybody home, you know, turning up all of the time.
6:39 Speaker 01 Imagine that, you're lying in bed on a Sunday morning, flicking through TikTok and then all of a sudden your landlord bowls in because they wanna get something out of the storage unit.
6:48 Speaker 00 Now, how much did these landlords have to pay the tenant?
6:52 Speaker 01 Yeah, this is a big one. So in this case, the landlord had to pay the tenant twenty one thousand dollars. Now, the makeup of that, fifteen thousand dollars because the property couldn't actually legally be rented, six thousand dollars because it was cold, damp and leaking, and a thousand dollars worth of exemplary damages because they kept turning up and being annoying, basically.
7:14 Speaker 00 Now, I really wanna dig into the fifteen thousand dollars that the landlords had to pay because the property couldn't be legally rented. Usually, if you rent out a property that couldn't actually be legally rented because it's a commercial space, typically the landlord would have to refund all of the rent. That's usually what happens at the tenancy tribunal. But in this case, the tribunal said, look, the tenant's been living there for seven years. In that case, it would be about sixty grand worth of rent. Actually, you were pretty happy living there for all of that time, so they provided a seventy five percent discount. So rather than the landlord having to refund sixty grand, it went down to fifteen thousand dollars.
7:58 Speaker 00 And actually, I think that's a pretty fair decision from the tenancy tribunal. You do have to punish the landlord for like renting out something that can't legally be lived in. But at the same time, the tenant was living there for seven years. So I don't think it'd be fair if they said, oh, get all seven years of your rent back, because then that provides the wrong incentive to tenants to be like, great, you know, I'll just go rent something that I know legally can't be rented out and then five years later I'll get all my rent back. It's like a wonderful savings scheme. But this doesn't compare at all to the second largest case we could find. So this one happened, you know, early this year, twenty twenty five, and the police ended up raiding a suburban Auckland home
8:41 Speaker 00 and they uncovered a large-scale cannabis operation. Now, I know what you're thinking, oh, this is quite good.
8:48 Speaker 01 Great tenant.
8:50 Speaker 00 The tenant was clearly paying their rent if they've got a big, big business going on.
8:53 Speaker 01 And cash every week.
8:56 Speaker 00 Slitted it envelope into your letterbox with a little extra grass.
9:04 Speaker 00 Both parties are happy and chill. Now, the thing is.
9:07 Speaker 01 You can tell Ed's limited knowledge of the marijuana, can't you?
9:11 Speaker 00 I was gonna say, I hope people don't think that I'm like on the grass. I've never done it in my life, Ed. I've got no idea what it's like.
9:17 Speaker 01 It might quieten you down.
9:19 Speaker 00 I'll just be sitting there saying Hakuna Matata.
9:25 Speaker 00 Now, what ended up happening? This is the sad part, the sad part.
9:32 Speaker 00 So laughing at our own jokes. Well, once the police uncovered it, the tenants abandoned the property. And so they left behind broken doors and windows. I actually think they punched, so this again shows how little I know about cannabis. But they punched some holes in the walls to ventilate the whole operation. They'd ripped the kitchen apart. And these poor old landlords couldn't re-let this place for weeks and the costs started to stack up fast. So this is what the tenant had to pay the landlord. It was thirteen thousand eight hundred dollars to replace windows and doors, almost fifteen grand to repair the kitchen. Another six grand to repaint and restore the interior, two grand for rubbish removal.
10:13 Speaker 00 In total, the tenant had to pay, and this is above and beyond their bond, thirty seven and a half thousand dollars.
10:22 Speaker 01 That's insane.
10:23 Speaker 00 Hopefully that cannabis operation was very, very profitable because I hope the landlord got their money back. But I am assuming that they're probably not gonna get that money back from the tenants, which is the incredibly sad thing there, isn't it? You know, or to get drip fed back at a very small amount because like you can be ordered, and this is a very important learning about the Tennessee tribunal. You can be ordered, you know, a hundred grand, but if your tenant doesn't have a hundred grand to pay you, you're not getting the hundred grand, right? You know, and even if you take them to court, you might get it drip fed back at twenty dollars a week. And this is why it's very important to have quite robust insurance because ultimately if you don't have a good insurance policy and your tenant's not gonna pay you. You're on the hook for that money. And if you wanna rent out that. Property, which you probably do because you've got a mortgage on it.
11:08 Speaker 00 You're the one having to shell out that money. That is one of the the real risks of being a landlord, which is one of the reasons why I always say you want to have some pretty robust insurance there as well. But actually, that wasn't even the largest case we found, Andrew. What was the largest one out of the thousand we looked at?
11:24 Speaker 01 Yeah, this one's insane. So this was in Auckland and it was a fairly standard tenancy at the start, but it turned into the largest rent arrears case ever seen by the tenancy tribunal. So the tenant, there was a bit more complexity to to their situation. So they had a bit of a personal relationship with the landlord and also had some pretty serious medical challenges. Now, where it became a bit unusual is the tenant would just go silent for a few months and not make payments for their rent. And then all of a sudden, they'd get caught up, they'd make a big lump sum payment. And in one instance, the tenant paid thirty thousand dollars in one go. Like, imagine that. Imagine getting no rent for six months and then all of a sudden thirty thousand dollars, or maybe even a year. And the tenant would always fall behind and then make these payments.
12:09 Speaker 01 But in the end, the tenant was forty nine thousand dollars behind an unpaid rent.
12:16 Speaker 00 That is insane. I look at that situation, Andrew, and I know that the tenant was ordered to pay that forty nine grand to the landlord. And maybe they do have it because I don't know how the tenant got thirty grand to to all of a sudden one off transfer, unless they were saving up all of that rent. But I do look at this and say, the landlord has got some serious explaining to do.
12:38 Speaker 01 Yeah, a hundred percent. If you're not keeping on top of your tenant, you're then allowing them to get further and further in debt. That's unacceptable as well.
12:46 Speaker 00 And it wasn't really clear in this case what exactly the the personal relationship between the landlord and the tenant was. It wasn't really explained. It was kind of more hinted at. But I was just looking at this reading. The landlord could have evicted the tenant much earlier. After twenty one days of unpaid rent, they could apply to the tenancy tribunal to have a a quick resolution. But they chose for whatever reason not to do that. I imagine that the mortgage is very low on this property. If the landlord really did have a Mortgage on it and they weren't getting any rented. I imagine that they would have taken some pretty quick action there. But I think both parties have some quite serious blame in that situation. You know, it's not right for a tenant to get 50 grand
13:27 Speaker 00 behind an unpaid rent. But also, I don't think it's it's fair for the landlord to let that go that far. How do you get out of that hole? Exactly. Both parties are to blame there.
13:38 Speaker 01 Yeah, it's amazing how with all the cases that we looked at, there was, what was the average for for your kind of standard case? A kind of few thousand dollars?
13:46 Speaker 00 The average payment was $1,800 to the landlord.
13:49 Speaker 01 Yeah, so these are definitely on the extreme end of the spectrum as far as payments go. But those are crazy numbers and also some pretty bad situations like, you know, poisoning your tenants with lead and having rats chew through cords.
14:03 Speaker 00 Well, that's a very important point that you made just before, which is that these are the most extreme cases. We've pulled them out because they're very interesting stories that have lessons for us. Yeah, this is not the average case. The average case is the tenant gets a bit behind on their rent and they have to pay $1,800 to their landlord. That's kind of the average case that goes to the tenancy tribunal. And actually, about 18% of cases don't have any payment involved at all. So it might be if you're a landlord and you're trying to get a possession order for your property. So these are definitely not the standard. These are the outliers. But the outliers also have lessons for us. And over the last 15 minutes, you've learned the five largest tenancy tribunal cases we could find. Why one landlord had to pay over 20 grand to a tenant for emotional distress.
14:48 Speaker 00 And the shocking reason why a tenant owe their landlord almost 50K. Right, let's wrap it up there. But please don't forget to rate, review and subscribe to the podcast. Really does help us get the message out to more people.
15:04 Speaker 00 Thanks for listening to the Property Academy Podcast. I'm your host, Tim McKnight.
15:06 Speaker 01 I'm Andrew Heffron.
15:07 Speaker 00 We're going to be back again tomorrow with even more daily strategies, tactics, insights to help you get the most out of the estate on the property market. Until next time.
Previous Revolving Credit: The Secret Weapon to Pay Off Your Mortgage Faster⎥Ep. 2211 Next The Clue That Predicts Your Next Mortgage Rate Cut⎥Ep. 2214 Page updated November 15, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated